What neighborhood is Bainbridge Nursing & Rehabilitation Center in?

Bainbridge Nursing & Rehabilitation Center is in the The Bronx neighborhood of Bronx.

Who is the owner of Bainbridge Nursing & Rehabilitation Center?

The legal owner and operator of Bainbridge Nursing & Rehabilitation Center is Bainbridge Nursing and Rehabilitation Center, LLC (For Profit).

Is Bainbridge Nursing & Rehabilitation Center in a walkable area?

Bainbridge Nursing & Rehabilitation Center has a walk score of 85. Very walkable. Most errands can be accomplished on foot, and many essentials are within a short walk.

What is the license number of Bainbridge Nursing & Rehabilitation Center?

According to NY state health department records, Bainbridge Nursing & Rehabilitation Center's license number is 7000319N.

How many residents currently live at Bainbridge Nursing & Rehabilitation Center?

Bainbridge Nursing & Rehabilitation Center's occupancy is 192%.

How many beds does Bainbridge Nursing & Rehabilitation Center have?

Bainbridge Nursing & Rehabilitation Center has 200 beds.

Has Bainbridge Nursing & Rehabilitation Center had any recent deficiencies or citations?

Bainbridge Nursing & Rehabilitation Center has had 15 recently reported deficiencies.

Bainbridge Nursing & Rehabilitation Center | 5-Star Nursing Home in Bronx, NY

Lawsuit Summary

Total Cases

Active Cases

5 active · 1 restored

Closed

7 Disposed

Since

2015

Most Recent

2025

Next Court Date

May 06, 2026

This facility is currently involved in 6 active lawsuits.

Cases

13 cases · Click to expand details (22 from 2010 – present; older years: list only)

Court

Year

Index Number

Status

Case Type

Plaintiff / Petitioner

Plaintiff Firm

Defendant / Respondent

Defendant Firm

Appearance

Justice

Bronx Supreme Court

2025

818648/2025E

Active

Tort

PATRICE BYAM, AS PROPOSED ADMINISTRATRIX OF THE ESTATE OF CARMEN BYAM, DECEASED

KRENTSEL & GUZMAN, LLP

BAINBRIDGE NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTER

JOSEPH D. FURLONG

06/09/2026

Gouldborne, Hon. Patsy

▼

Case Info

Court

Bronx Supreme Court

Index Number

818648/2025E

Status

Active

Year Filed

2025

Case Name

PATRICE BYAM, AS PROPOSED ADMINISTRATRIX OF THE ESTATE OF CARMEN BYAM, DECEASED vs. BAINBRIDGE NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTER

Case Type

Tort-Other

Track

Standard

RJI Filed

09/16/2025

NOI Due

09/16/2026

NOI Filed

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

Gouldborne, Hon. Patsy

Next Appearance

06/09/2026

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

PATRICE BYAM, AS PROPOSED ADMINISTRATRIX OF THE ESTATE OF CARMEN BYAM, DECEASED

Attorney / FirmKRENTSEL & GUZMAN, LLP

Defendant / Respondent

BAINBRIDGE NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTER

Attorneys / FirmsJOSEPH D. FURLONG

Motions (1)

#	Date Filed	Filed By	Relief Sought	Submit Date	Answer	Status	Decision	Order Signed
1	09/16/2025		Dismiss	12/22/2025	No	Before Justice: Gouldborne, Hon. Patsy

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints (56)

Doc #	Date Filed	Document	Description	Motion #	Filing User
1	09/03/2025	SUMMONS + COMPLAINT			Jonathan Joseph Panarella
2	09/03/2025	STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING			Jonathan Joseph Panarella
3	09/08/2025	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	BAINBRIDGE NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTER, LLC / AFFIDAVIT		Jonathan Joseph Panarella
4	09/08/2025	STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING			Jonathan Joseph Panarella
5	09/12/2025	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Affirmation of Service on Bainbridge Nursing and Rehabilitation Center		Jonathan Joseph Panarella
6	09/16/2025	NOTICE OF MOTION		1	Joseph Duffy Furlong
7	09/16/2025	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION		1	Joseph Duffy Furlong
8	09/16/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Ex A - S&C.pdf	1	Joseph Duffy Furlong
9	09/16/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Ex B - Affidavit.pdf	1	Joseph Duffy Furlong
10	09/16/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Ex C - Roote.pdf	1	Joseph Duffy Furlong
11	09/16/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Ex D - Hampton.pdf	1	Joseph Duffy Furlong
12	09/16/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Ex E - Ruth.pdf	1	Joseph Duffy Furlong
13	09/16/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Ex F - Crampton.pdf	1	Joseph Duffy Furlong
14	09/16/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Ex G - Saltanovich.pdf	1	Joseph Duffy Furlong
15	09/16/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Ex H - Damon.pdf	1	Joseph Duffy Furlong
16	09/16/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Ex I - Garcia.pdf	1	Joseph Duffy Furlong
17	09/16/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Ex J - DeFonce.pdf	1	Joseph Duffy Furlong
18	09/16/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Ex K - Fortes.pdf	1	Joseph Duffy Furlong
19	09/16/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Ex L - Robertson.pdf	1	Joseph Duffy Furlong
20	09/16/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Ex M - Colon.pdf	1	Joseph Duffy Furlong
21	09/16/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Ex N - Spitzer.pdf	1	Joseph Duffy Furlong
22	09/16/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Ex O - Hasan.pdf	1	Joseph Duffy Furlong
23	09/16/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Ex P - Valukis.pdf	1	Joseph Duffy Furlong
24	09/16/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Ex Q - Sapienza.pdf	1	Joseph Duffy Furlong
25	09/16/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Ex R - Bushart.pdf	1	Joseph Duffy Furlong
26	09/16/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Ex S - Schapers.pdf	1	Joseph Duffy Furlong
27	09/16/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Ex T - Thomas.pdf	1	Joseph Duffy Furlong
28	09/16/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Ex U - Becker.pdf	1	Joseph Duffy Furlong
29	09/16/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Ex V - Burke.pdf	1	Joseph Duffy Furlong
30	09/16/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Ex W - Gaviria.pdf	1	Joseph Duffy Furlong
31	09/16/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Ex X - Ho.pdf	1	Joseph Duffy Furlong
32	09/16/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Ex Y - Machin.pdf	1	Joseph Duffy Furlong
33	09/16/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Ex Z - Gibbs.pdf	1	Joseph Duffy Furlong
34	09/16/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Ex AA - McCaffrey.pdf	1	Joseph Duffy Furlong
35	09/16/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Ex BB - Brzozowiec.pdf	1	Joseph Duffy Furlong
36	09/16/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Ex CC - Wasserman.pdf	1	Joseph Duffy Furlong
37	09/16/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Ex DD - Candella.pdf	1	Joseph Duffy Furlong
38	09/16/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Ex EE - Loggia.pdf	1	Joseph Duffy Furlong
39	09/16/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Ex FF - Caropreso.pdf	1	Joseph Duffy Furlong
40	09/16/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Ex GG - Lociero.pdf	1	Joseph Duffy Furlong
41	09/16/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Ex HH - Serebryakova.pdf	1	Joseph Duffy Furlong
42	09/16/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Ex II - Mitchell.pdf	1	Joseph Duffy Furlong
43	09/16/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Ex JJ - Lee.pdf	1	Joseph Duffy Furlong
44	09/16/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Ex KK - McDougald.pdf	1	Joseph Duffy Furlong
45	09/16/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Ex LL - Mancuso.pdf	1	Joseph Duffy Furlong
46	09/16/2025	RJI -RE: NOTICE OF MOTION		1	Joseph Duffy Furlong
47	09/16/2025	ADDENDUM - GENERAL (840A)		1	Joseph Duffy Furlong
48	10/03/2025	STIPULATION - ADJOURNMENT OF MOTION	Stipulation to Adjourn Motion Sequence 01 Returnable 10/14 to 11/19/25	1	Jonathan Joseph Panarella
49	10/03/2025	STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING		1	Jonathan Joseph Panarella
50	10/31/2025	STIPULATION - ADJOURNMENT OF MOTION	Stipulation to Adjourn Motion Sequence 01 Returnable 11/19 to 12/22/25	1	Jonathan Joseph Panarella
51	12/09/2025	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION		1	Jonathan Joseph Panarella
52	12/09/2025	AFFIRMATION	Word Count Certification	1	Jonathan Joseph Panarella
53	12/09/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	WebSurrogate Printout	1	Jonathan Joseph Panarella
54	12/09/2025	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE		1	Jonathan Joseph Panarella
55	12/15/2025	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN REPLY		1	Joseph Duffy Furlong
56	12/15/2025	STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING		1	Joseph Duffy Furlong

Bronx Supreme Court

2025

820571/2023E

Active

Medical Malpractice

OLASEUN, DEBORAH

KELLY & GROSSMAN, LLP

BAINBRIDGE NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTER, LLC

SHEELEY LLP

05/06/2026

Frishman, Hon. Michael A.

▼

Case Info

Court

Bronx Supreme Court

Index Number

820571/2023E

Status

Active

Year Filed

2025

Case Name

OLASEUN, DEBORAH vs. BAINBRIDGE NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTER, LLC

Case Type

Tort-Medical, Dental, or Podiatric Malpractice

Track

Complex

RJI Filed

02/26/2025

NOI Due

05/30/2026

NOI Filed

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

Frishman, Hon. Michael A.

Next Appearance

05/06/2026

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

OLASEUN, DEBORAH

Attorney / FirmKELLY & GROSSMAN, LLP

Defendant / Respondent

BAINBRIDGE NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTER, LLC

Attorneys / FirmsSHEELEY LLP

Motions

No motions recorded for this case.

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints (36)

Doc #	Date Filed	Document	Description	Filing User
1	12/28/2023	SUMMONS + COMPLAINT		Dennis Kelly
2	01/12/2024	NOTICE OF CHANGE OF FIRM NAME OR ADDRESS (PRE RJI)		Dennis Kelly
3	01/23/2024	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE		Dennis Kelly
4	01/23/2024	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE		Dennis Kelly
5	02/02/2024	ANSWER	Verified Answer	Jennifer Ann Levine
6	02/02/2024	DEMAND FOR:	Demand for Examination before Trial	Jennifer Ann Levine
7	02/08/2024	DEMAND FOR BILL OF PARTICULARS		Jennifer Ann Levine
8	02/08/2024	DEMAND FOR:	Combined Discovery Demands	Jennifer Ann Levine
9	02/08/2024	NOTICE OF DISCOVERY AND INSPECTION	Notice of Discovery and Inspection for Social Media	Jennifer Ann Levine
10	02/26/2025	BILL OF PARTICULARS	Verified Bill of Particulars	Dennis Kelly
11	02/26/2025	RESPONSE TO DEMAND	Plaintiff's combined responses to defendant's demands	Dennis Kelly
12	02/26/2025	NOTICE OF DISCOVERY AND INSPECTION	Policies and Procedures and medical records	Dennis Kelly
13	02/26/2025	DEMAND FOR:	Nursing Home combined demands	Dennis Kelly
14	02/26/2025	PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE REQUEST		Dennis Kelly
15	02/26/2025	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	AOS- Bill of Particulars	Dennis Kelly
16	02/26/2025	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	AOS- combined responses	Dennis Kelly
17	02/26/2025	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	AOS- D&I	Dennis Kelly
18	02/26/2025	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	AOS- PC request	Dennis Kelly
19	02/26/2025	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	AOS- RJI	Dennis Kelly
20	02/26/2025	RJI -RE: REQUEST FOR PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE		Dennis Kelly
21	04/07/2025	ORDER - PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE	Dated 3/28/2025	Shomari Dixon
22	04/23/2025	DEMAND FOR:	Demand for Authorizations	Jennifer Ann Levine
23	06/25/2025	RESPONSE TO DEMAND	Defendant's Response to Plaintiffs Notice for D&I	Nazia Zaman Reill
24	06/25/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Email Correspondence to Plt's Counsel re Discovery Document Exchange	Nazia Zaman Reill
25	06/25/2025	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service	Nazia Zaman Reill
26	06/25/2025	RESPONSE TO DEMAND	Defendant's Response to Plaintiffs Combined Discovery Demands	Nazia Zaman Reill
27	06/25/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Email Correspondence to Plt's Counsel re Discovery Document Exchange	Nazia Zaman Reill
28	06/25/2025	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service	Nazia Zaman Reill
29	07/11/2025	ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE	Dated July 2 2025	Michael Kenny
30	07/21/2025	DEMAND FOR:	Letter to Plaintiff re Authorization	Jennifer Ann Levine
31	08/05/2025	ORDER ( PROPOSED )	Proposed Order	Nazia Zaman Reill
32	08/25/2025	STIPULATION - SO ORDERED	AND ORDER DATED 8/13/2025	Jenny Leon
33	11/21/2025	DEMAND FOR:	Post-EBT Demand for Authorizations	Nazia Zaman Reill
34	12/10/2025	ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE	Dated December 1 2025	Michael Kenny
35	01/14/2026	ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE	DATED 1/8/2026	Sara Mallach
36	03/02/2026	ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE	DATED 02/11/2026	Michelle Alemany

Bronx Supreme Court

2023

814428/2023E

Disposed

Medical Malpractice

BYAM, PATRICE

Krentsel & Guzman, LLP

BAINBRIDGE NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTER

Barker Patterson Nichols, LLP

06/04/2024

Capella, Hon. Joseph E.

▼

Case Info

Court

Bronx Supreme Court

Index Number

814428/2023E

Status

Disposed

Year Filed

2023

Case Name

BYAM, PATRICE vs. BAINBRIDGE NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTER

Case Type

Tort-Medical, Dental, or Podiatric Malpractice

Track

Complex

RJI Filed

11/06/2023

NOI Due

02/06/2025

NOI Filed

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

Capella, Hon. Joseph E.

Next Appearance

06/04/2024

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

BYAM, PATRICE

Attorney / FirmKrentsel & Guzman, LLP

Defendant / Respondent

BAINBRIDGE NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTER

Attorneys / FirmsBarker Patterson Nichols, LLP

Motions (1)

#	Date Filed	Filed By	Relief Sought	Submit Date	Answer	Status	Decision	Order Signed
1	11/06/2023		Dismiss	06/04/2024	No	Decided: 03/27/2025 Granted Before Justice: Capella, Hon. Joseph E.	Short Form Order	03/27/2025

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints (73)

Doc #	Date Filed	Document	Description	Motion #	Filing User
1	09/20/2023	SUMMONS + COMPLAINT			Jonathan Joseph Panarella
2	09/20/2023	STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING			Jonathan Joseph Panarella
3	09/29/2023	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service on BAINBRIDGE NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTER		Jonathan Joseph Panarella
4	09/29/2023	STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING			Jonathan Joseph Panarella
5	10/23/2023	STIPULATION - OTHER	Stip to Ext Time to Respond to 1.17.24		Lori Michele Shapiro
6	10/23/2023	STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING			Lori Michele Shapiro
7	11/03/2023	NOTICE OF MOTION	Notice of Motion to Dismiss	1	Charles K. Faillace
8	11/03/2023	AFFIRMATION	Affirmation of Joseph D. Furlong	1	Charles K. Faillace
9	11/03/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit A - Summons & Complaint	1	Charles K. Faillace
10	11/03/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit B - Byam - Stip to Ext Time to Respond to 1.17.24	1	Charles K. Faillace
11	11/03/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit C - Decision & Order [Case for Motion]	1	Charles K. Faillace
12	11/03/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit D - Hampton v. City of New York	1	Charles K. Faillace
13	11/03/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit E - Ruth v. Elderwood at Amherst, August 5, 2021	1	Charles K. Faillace
14	11/03/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit F - Crampton v. Garnet Health - April 10_2023	1	Charles K. Faillace
15	11/03/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit G - Saltanovich v. Sea View Hospital Rehabilitation	1	Charles K. Faillace
16	11/03/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit H - Damon	1	Charles K. Faillace
17	11/03/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit I - Garcia.pdf.pdf	1	Charles K. Faillace
18	11/03/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit J - DeFonce.pdf.pdf	1	Charles K. Faillace
19	11/03/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit K - Fortes.pdf.pdf	1	Charles K. Faillace
20	11/03/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit L - Robertson v. Humboldt House Rehabilitation	1	Charles K. Faillace
21	11/03/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit M - Colon	1	Charles K. Faillace
22	11/03/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit N - Spitzer v. Sky View Rehabilitation	1	Charles K. Faillace
23	11/03/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit O - Hasan v. Terrace Acquisions, II, LLC	1	Charles K. Faillace
24	11/03/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit P - Valukis	1	Charles K. Faillace
25	11/03/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit Q - Sapienza	1	Charles K. Faillace
26	11/03/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit R - Bushart	1	Charles K. Faillace
27	11/03/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit S - Schapers v. West Lawrence Care Center, LLC	1	Charles K. Faillace
28	11/03/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit T - Linda Thomas v White Oaks Rehab	1	Charles K. Faillace
29	11/03/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit U - Becker v. Carmel Richmond Nursing Home, Inc.	1	Charles K. Faillace
30	11/03/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit V - Burke v. Sapphire	1	Charles K. Faillace
31	11/03/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit W - Gaviria v. Sapphire	1	Charles K. Faillace
32	11/03/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit X - Ho v Sapphire Center	1	Charles K. Faillace
33	11/03/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit Y - Machin v. Sapphire	1	Charles K. Faillace
34	11/03/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit Z - Gibbs v. Atlantis	1	Charles K. Faillace
35	11/03/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit AA - McCaffery v White Plains Hospital	1	Charles K. Faillace
36	11/03/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit BB - Brzozowiec v. Ellicott Center for Rehab	1	Charles K. Faillace
37	11/03/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit CC - Wasserman v. Grand South Point	1	Charles K. Faillace
38	11/03/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit DD - Candella v Eger Health Care	1	Charles K. Faillace
39	11/03/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit EE - Nadine Loggia v Carmel Richmond	1	Charles K. Faillace
40	11/03/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit FF - Daniel Caropreso v. Carmel Richmond Nursing Home	1	Charles K. Faillace
41	11/03/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit GG - Lociero v. Park Avn. Operating	1	Charles K. Faillace
42	11/03/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit HH - Serebryakova v. Shorefront Operating	1	Charles K. Faillace
43	11/03/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit II - Mitchell v Jewish Home	1	Charles K. Faillace
44	11/03/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit JJ - Lee v Sapphire Center for Rehab	1	Charles K. Faillace
45	11/03/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit KK - McDougald v. Garber	1	Charles K. Faillace
46	11/03/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit LL - Mancuso v. Rubin	1	Charles K. Faillace
47	11/03/2023	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service	1	Charles K. Faillace
48	11/03/2023	RJI -RE: NOTICE OF MOTION	RJI	1	Charles K. Faillace
49	11/17/2023	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION		1	Jonathan Joseph Panarella
50	11/17/2023	CERTIFICATION OF SIGNATURE ( ATTORNEY OR PARTY )	Word Count Certification	1	Jonathan Joseph Panarella
51	11/17/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	NYS Assembly Memorandum in Support of Legislation for a new Bill, Sponsored by Assembly Member Kim	1	Jonathan Joseph Panarella
52	11/17/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Floor Debate Transcript	1	Jonathan Joseph Panarella
53	11/17/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Affidavit of Assembly Member Ronald T. Kim in Rivera-Zayas v. Our Lady	1	Jonathan Joseph Panarella
54	11/17/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Decision/Order in Whitehead v. Pine Haven Operating	1	Jonathan Joseph Panarella
55	11/17/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Order in Robertson v. Humboldt House Rehabilitation	1	Jonathan Joseph Panarella
56	11/17/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Attorney General's Report	1	Jonathan Joseph Panarella
57	11/17/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Decision in Gonnelly v. Newburgh Operations, LLC	1	Jonathan Joseph Panarella
58	11/17/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Decision in Lara v. S&J Operational, LLC	1	Jonathan Joseph Panarella
59	11/17/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Department of Health Advisory	1	Jonathan Joseph Panarella
60	11/17/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	CMS Memo	1	Jonathan Joseph Panarella
61	11/17/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	CDC Updated Guidance	1	Jonathan Joseph Panarella
62	11/17/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Decision in Hernandez v. Clove Lakes Healthcare	1	Jonathan Joseph Panarella
63	11/17/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Decision in Pierro v. Carmel Richmond Healthcare	1	Jonathan Joseph Panarella
64	11/17/2023	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE		1	Jonathan Joseph Panarella
65	11/17/2023	STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING		1	Jonathan Joseph Panarella
66	12/06/2023	NOTICE OF CHANGE OF FIRM NAME OR ADDRESS (POST RJI)	Ltr to Court re change of firm name		Joseph Duffy Furlong
67	12/06/2023	STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING	Statement of Authorization for Electronic Filing		Joseph Duffy Furlong
68	12/06/2023	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN REPLY	Affirmation in Reply	1	Joseph Duffy Furlong
69	01/16/2024	STIPULATION - OTHER	Stip ETR to 4.16.24		Lori Michele Shapiro
70	04/15/2024	STIPULATION - OTHER	Stip ETR to 7.15.24		Lori Michele Shapiro
71	04/02/2025	DECISION + ORDER ON MOTION	SHORT FORM ORDER DATED 3/27/2025	1	Sara Mallach
72	04/02/2025	NOTICE OF ENTRY		1	Joseph Duffy Furlong
73	04/02/2025	STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING		1	Joseph Duffy Furlong

Bronx Supreme Court

2022

806579/2022E

Disposed

Comm-Contract

Bainbridge Nursing & Rehabilitation Center

SANTUCCI & CALDERONI, PLLC

Mitchnick, Judith

11/07/2025

Nicolas-Brewster, Hon. Mary Lynn

▼

Case Info

Court

Bronx Supreme Court

Index Number

806579/2022E

Status

Disposed

Year Filed

2022

Case Name

Bainbridge Nursing & Rehabilitation Center vs. Mitchnick, Judith

Case Type

Comm-Contract

Track

Standard

RJI Filed

06/07/2022

NOI Due

06/07/2023

NOI Filed

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

Nicolas-Brewster, Hon. Mary Lynn

Next Appearance

11/07/2025

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

Bainbridge Nursing & Rehabilitation Center

Attorney / FirmSANTUCCI & CALDERONI, PLLC

Defendant / Respondent

Mitchnick, Judith

Attorneys / Firms

Motions (3)

#	Date Filed	Relief Sought	Submit Date	Answer	Status	Decision	Order Signed
1	06/07/2022	Judgment - Default	09/14/2022	No	Decided: 09/14/2022 Interim Decision Before Justice: Thompson, Hon. Kenneth	Short Form Order	09/14/2022
1	06/07/2022	Judgment - Default	09/14/2022	No	Decided: 11/28/2022 Interim Decision Before Justice: Thompson, Hon. Kenneth	Memorandum	11/28/2022
1	06/07/2022	Judgment - Default	09/14/2022	No	Decided: 06/21/2023 Denied Before Justice: Hummel, Hon. Veronica G.	Short Form Order	06/21/2023

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints (19)

Doc #	Date Filed	Document	Description	Motion #	Filing User
1	04/28/2022	SUMMONS			Fred Thomas Santucci
2	04/28/2022	COMPLAINT			Fred Thomas Santucci
3	04/28/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Outstanding Invoices		Fred Thomas Santucci
4	05/04/2022	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE			Fred Thomas Santucci
5	06/07/2022	NOTICE OF MOTION		1	Fred Thomas Santucci
6	06/07/2022	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION	Affirmation of facts	1	Fred Thomas Santucci
7	06/07/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Filing Receipt	1	Fred Thomas Santucci
8	06/07/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Summons & Complaint	1	Fred Thomas Santucci
9	06/07/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Affidavit of Service for Summons & Complaint	1	Fred Thomas Santucci
10	06/07/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	3215 Notice With Affidavit of Service	1	Fred Thomas Santucci
11	06/07/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Affidavit of Miltiary Investgation	1	Fred Thomas Santucci
12	06/07/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Affidavit of Merit	1	Fred Thomas Santucci
13	06/07/2022	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service	1	Fred Thomas Santucci
14	06/07/2022	RJI -RE: NOTICE OF MOTION		1	Fred Thomas Santucci
15	06/07/2022	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Amended Affidavit of Service for Motion	1	Fred Thomas Santucci
16	09/19/2022	ORDER - INTERIM	DATED 9/14/2022	1	Tamieka J Long
17	12/06/2022	ORDER - INTERIM	Decision and Order dated 11/28/2022	1	Neil Espinal
18	06/22/2023	DECISION + ORDER ON MOTION	Dated 6/21/2023	1	Shomari Dixon
19	11/17/2025	ORDER - OTHER	Dated November 7 2025		Michael Kenny

Bronx Supreme Court

2022

810584/2021E

Active-Restored

Medical Malpractice

RODRIGUEZ, ELVIN MANUEL

RASKIN & KREMINS, L.L.P.

Bainbridge Nursing & Rehabilitation Center, LLC

VOUTE LOHRFINK MCANDREW MEISNER & ROBERTS LLP

09/15/2026

Gerez, Hon. Alicia

▼

Case Info

Court

Bronx Supreme Court

Index Number

810584/2021E

Status

Active-Restored

Year Filed

2022

Case Name

RODRIGUEZ, ELVIN MANUEL vs. Bainbridge Nursing & Rehabilitation Center, LLC

Case Type

Tort-Medical, Dental, or Podiatric Malpractice

Track

Complex

RJI Filed

10/06/2022

NOI Due

01/07/2024

NOI Filed

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

Gerez, Hon. Alicia

Next Appearance

09/15/2026

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

RODRIGUEZ, ELVIN MANUEL

Attorney / FirmRASKIN & KREMINS, L.L.P.

Defendant / Respondent

Bainbridge Nursing & Rehabilitation Center, LLC

Attorneys / FirmsVOUTE LOHRFINK MCANDREW MEISNER & ROBERTS LLP

Motions (2)

#	Date Filed	Filed By	Relief Sought	Submit Date	Answer	Status	Decision	Order Signed
2	03/01/2024		Attorney - Disqualify/Relieve/Substitute/Withdraw	05/03/2024	No	Decided: 05/03/2024 Granted Before Justice: Gerez, Hon. Alicia	Memorandum	05/03/2024
1	11/22/2023		Attorney - Disqualify/Relieve/Substitute/Withdraw	12/18/2023	No	Decided: 12/18/2023 Denied Before Justice: Capella, Hon. Joseph E.	Short Form Order	12/18/2023

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints (43)

Doc #	Date Filed	Document	Description	Motion #	Filing User
1	08/04/2021	SUMMONS + COMPLAINT			Lewis Rosenberg
2	09/03/2021	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	BAINBRIDGE NURSING & REHABILITATION CENTER LLC		Lewis Rosenberg
3	09/09/2021	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	BAINBRIDGE NURSING & REHABILITATION CENTER LLC		Lewis Rosenberg
4	10/01/2021	ANSWER			Thomas J Benvenuto
5	07/05/2022	BILL OF PARTICULARS			Lewis Rosenberg
6	10/06/2022	PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE REQUEST			Lewis Rosenberg
7	10/06/2022	RJI -RE: REQUEST FOR PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE			Lewis Rosenberg
8	11/10/2022	PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE ORDER (PROPOSED)			Lewis Rosenberg
9	11/25/2022	ORDER - PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE	DATED 11/16/2022		Michelle Alemany
10	12/27/2022	CONSENT TO CHANGE ATTORNEY (POST RJI)	Consent to Change Attorney - Bainbridge Nursing & Rehab Center		Hal Roberts
11	09/08/2023	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE			Lewis Rosenberg
12	11/22/2023	ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE ( PROPOSED )		1	Lewis Rosenberg
13	11/22/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	SUMMONS AND COMPALINT	1	Lewis Rosenberg
14	11/22/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	DEFENDANT'S ANSWER	1	Lewis Rosenberg
15	11/22/2023	AFFIRMATION		1	Lewis Rosenberg
16	11/28/2023	ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE	SIGNED ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE DATED 11/28/2023	1	Lissette Rodriguez
17	12/08/2023	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE		1	Lewis Rosenberg
18	12/11/2023	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE		1	Lewis Rosenberg
19	12/12/2023	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE		1	Lewis Rosenberg
20	12/19/2023	ORDER - WITHDRAWING AS ATTORNEY	Short Form Order dated 12/18/2023 DENIED	1	Neil Espinal
21	03/01/2024	ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE ( PROPOSED )		2	Lewis Rosenberg
22	03/01/2024	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT		2	Lewis Rosenberg
23	03/01/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Summons and Complaint	2	Lewis Rosenberg
24	03/01/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Verified Answer	2	Lewis Rosenberg
25	03/01/2024	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service and Backing	2	Lewis Rosenberg
26	03/06/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Preliminary Conference Order 11/16/2022		Lewis Rosenberg
27	03/06/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Email Chain		Lewis Rosenberg
28	03/08/2024	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Certified Mail Affidavits of Service	1	Lewis Rosenberg
29	05/09/2024	ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE	SHORT FORM ORDER & DECISION/ORDER DATED 5/3/2024.	2	Lissette Rodriguez
31	05/22/2024	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE			Lewis Rosenberg
32	07/22/2024	ORDER - OTHER	DATED 7/15/2024		Shomari Dixon
33	05/03/2024	DECISION + ORDER ON MOTION		2	Michael Kenny
34	02/04/2025	ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE	SO-ORDERED DATED 1/29/2025.		Lissette Rodriguez
35	02/07/2025	RESPONSE TO DEMAND	Response to Combined Demands		Jenna Rose Franceschini
36	03/13/2025	NOTICE OF APPEARANCE (POST RJI)			Michael F. Kremins
37	03/24/2025	NOTICE OF DISCOVERY AND INSPECTION			Michael F. Kremins
38	04/01/2025	ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE	DATED 3/25/2025		Sara Mallach
39	05/21/2025	ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE	DATED 5/19/2025		Jenny Leon
40	05/27/2025	DEMAND FOR:	Post EBT Demand for Authorizations		Jenna Rose Franceschini
41	09/18/2025	NOTICE OF APPEARANCE (POST RJI)	Notice of Appearance		Thomas Paul Valet
42	09/23/2025	ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE	DATED 9/9/2025		Sara Mallach
43	01/16/2026	ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE	Dated January 6 2026		Michael Kenny
44	04/02/2026	STIPULATION - SO ORDERED	Stipulation and Order, DATED 3/31/2026		Amanda Guzman

Bronx Supreme Court

2020

28862/2020E (0028862/2020)

Active

Medical Malpractice

HODGE, ANISSA

C/O KERNER & KERNER, P.C.

BAINBRIDGE NURSING AND

Kaufman Borgeest & Ryan LLP

06/29/2026

Capella, Hon. Joseph E.

▼

Case Info

Court

Bronx Supreme Court

Index Number

28862/2020E (0028862/2020)

Status

Active

Year Filed

2020

Case Name

HODGE, ANISSA vs. BAINBRIDGE NURSING AND

Case Type

Tort-Medical, Dental, or Podiatric Malpractice

Track

Complex

RJI Filed

09/30/2020

NOI Due

11/30/2023

NOI Filed

10/31/2023

Calendar Number

2023-02782

Jury Status

Jury At Plaintiff's Request

Justice

Capella, Hon. Joseph E.

Next Appearance

06/29/2026

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

HODGE, ANISSA

Attorney / FirmC/O KERNER & KERNER, P.C.

Defendant / Respondent

BAINBRIDGE NURSING AND

Attorneys / FirmsKaufman Borgeest & Ryan LLP

Motions (1)

#	Date Filed	Filed By	Relief Sought	Submit Date	Answer	Status	Decision	Order Signed
1	01/31/2024		Judgment - Summary	06/21/2024	No	Decided: 02/25/2025 Denied Before Justice: Gerez, Hon. Alicia	Memorandum	02/25/2025

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints (47)

Doc #	Date Filed	Document	Description	Motion #	Filing User
1	07/31/2020	SUMMONS + COMPLAINT			Kenneth Todd Kerner
2	08/28/2020	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service upon Bainbridge Nursing and Rehabilitation Center, LLC		Kenneth Todd Kerner
3	09/28/2020	ANSWER	ans.Bainbridge Nursing		Thomas J Benvenuto
4	09/30/2020	RJI -RE: REQUEST FOR PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE			Kenneth Todd Kerner
5	03/05/2021	ORDER - PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE	Dated 02/04/2021		Terrence Daly
6	05/10/2021	CONSENT TO CHANGE ATTORNEY (POST RJI)	Consent to Change Attorney		Thomas Joseph Gerspach
7	05/10/2021	STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING	Statement of Authorization for Electronic Filing		Thomas Joseph Gerspach
8	06/04/2021	ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE	DATED 5/18/2021.		Lissette Rodriguez
9	11/22/2022	NOTICE OF DEPOSITION	Notice of Non-Party Deposition - SeniorCare		Kenneth Todd Kerner
10	02/03/2023	ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE	dated 1-23-2023		Hope Maddox
11	05/02/2023	NOTICE OF CHANGE OF FIRM NAME OR ADDRESS (POST RJI)			Alexander Sikoscow
12	05/02/2023	STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING			Alexander Sikoscow
13	07/24/2023	CONSENT TO CHANGE ATTORNEY (POST RJI)	Consent to Change Attorney - Bainbridge Nursing & Rehab Center		Howard Jacobowitz
14	09/06/2023	DEMAND FOR:	Demand for Arons Authorizations		Neil Brian Ptashnik
15	10/31/2023	NOTE OF ISSUE:WITH JURY			Kenneth Todd Kerner
16	11/02/2023	STIPULATION - SO ORDERED	DATED 10/30/2023		Neil Espinal
17	11/17/2023	STIPULATION - OTHER			Anna R. Schwartz
18	01/31/2024	NOTICE OF MOTION	NOTICE OF MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT	1	Jenna Rose Franceschini
19	01/31/2024	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT	ATTORNEY AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT	1	Jenna Rose Franceschini
20	01/31/2024	STATEMENT OF MATERIAL FACTS	STATEMENT OF UNDISPUTED MATERIAL FACTS	1	Jenna Rose Franceschini
21	01/31/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	EXPERT AFFIRMATION OF DR. SALZMAN	1	Jenna Rose Franceschini
22	01/31/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	SUMMONS AND COMPLAINT	1	Jenna Rose Franceschini
23	01/31/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	ANSWER	1	Jenna Rose Franceschini
24	01/31/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	BILL OF PARTICULARS	1	Jenna Rose Franceschini
25	01/31/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	PLAINTIFF EBT TRANSCRIPT	1	Jenna Rose Franceschini
26	01/31/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	DEFENDANT EBT TRANSCRIPT	1	Jenna Rose Franceschini
27	01/31/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	EBT TRANSCRIPT OF DR. ABRAMS	1	Jenna Rose Franceschini
28	01/31/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	EBT TRANSCRIPT OF EMS WORKER JUAN MEDINA	1	Jenna Rose Franceschini
29	01/31/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	NOTE OF ISSUE	1	Jenna Rose Franceschini
30	01/31/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	STIPULATION AND EMAIL CORRESPONDENCE WITH COURT	1	Jenna Rose Franceschini
31	01/31/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	MONTEFIORE RECORDS	1	Jenna Rose Franceschini
32	01/31/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	BAINBRIDGE RECORDS	1	Jenna Rose Franceschini
33	01/31/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	STATE CHEST X RAY REPORT - BAINBRIDGE	1	Jenna Rose Franceschini
34	01/31/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	SENIOR CARE EMS RECORDS	1	Jenna Rose Franceschini
35	02/28/2024	STIPULATION - ADJOURNMENT OF MOTION		1	Kenneth Todd Kerner
36	03/26/2024	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE			Kenneth Todd Kerner
37	04/29/2024	STIPULATION - ADJOURNMENT OF MOTION		1	Kenneth Todd Kerner
38	05/27/2024	RESPONSE TO STATEMENT OF MATERIAL FACTS		1	Kenneth Todd Kerner
39	05/27/2024	MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN OPPOSITION		1	Kenneth Todd Kerner
40	05/27/2024	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION	Attorney's Affirmation in Opposition to Summary Judgment	1	Kenneth Todd Kerner
41	05/27/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Redacted Physician's Affirmation in Opposition to Summary Judgment	1	Kenneth Todd Kerner
42	05/27/2024	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE		1	Kenneth Todd Kerner
43	06/11/2024	STIPULATION - OTHER	Stipulation to Adjourn Motion Practice/Defendant's Reply Affirmation		Jenna Rose Franceschini
44	06/18/2024	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN REPLY	Reply Affirmation in Support of Summary Judgment Motion	1	Jenna Rose Franceschini
45	06/25/2024	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE	Letter to Justice Gerez requesting adjournment of conference		Kenneth Todd Kerner
46	03/03/2025	DECISION + ORDER ON MOTION	SHORT FORM ORDER DATED 2/25/2025	1	Jenny Leon
47	03/03/2025	NOTICE OF ENTRY		1	Kenneth Todd Kerner

Bronx Supreme Court

2020

34574/2019E (0034574/2019)

Disposed

Medical Malpractice

QUINONES, INES

Doolan Platt & Setareh, LLP

Bainbridge Nursing and Rehabilitation Center, LLC

Kaufman Borgeest & Ryan LLP

09/11/2024

Gerez, Hon. Alicia

▼

Case Info

Court

Bronx Supreme Court

Index Number

34574/2019E (0034574/2019)

Status

Disposed

Year Filed

2020

Case Name

QUINONES, INES vs. Bainbridge Nursing and Rehabilitation Center, LLC

Case Type

Tort-Medical, Dental, or Podiatric Malpractice

Track

Complex

RJI Filed

02/10/2020

NOI Due

07/10/2023

NOI Filed

07/10/2023

Calendar Number

2023-01722

Jury Status

Jury At Plaintiff's Request

Justice

Gerez, Hon. Alicia

Next Appearance

09/11/2024

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

QUINONES, INES

Attorney / FirmDoolan Platt & Setareh, LLP

Defendant / Respondent

Bainbridge Nursing and Rehabilitation Center, LLC

Attorneys / FirmsKaufman Borgeest & Ryan LLP

Motions (1)

#	Date Filed	Filed By	Relief Sought	Submit Date	Answer	Status	Decision	Order Signed
1	05/29/2024		Compromise	07/05/2024	No	Decided: 07/05/2024 Signed Before Justice: Gerez, Hon. Alicia	Long Form Order

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints (27)

Doc #	Date Filed	Document	Description	Filing User
1	12/10/2019	SUMMONS + COMPLAINT	Summons & Verified Complaint	Jason J. Platt
2	12/23/2019	AFFIDAVIT	Affidavit of Servic e Bainbridge	Jason J. Platt
3	02/03/2020	ANSWER	Answer Bainbridge Nursing & Rehabilitation Center LLC	Thomas J Benvenuto
4	02/10/2020	PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE REQUEST	Request for PC	Jason J. Platt
5	02/10/2020	RJI -RE: REQUEST FOR PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE		Jason J. Platt
6	02/22/2021	PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE ORDER (PROPOSED)		Mary C Mathwich
7	04/05/2021	CONSENT TO CHANGE ATTORNEY (POST RJI)	Consent to Change Attorney	Thomas Joseph Gerspach
8	04/05/2021	STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING	Statement of Authorization for Electronic Filing	Thomas Joseph Gerspach
9	04/15/2021	NOTICE OF DEPOSITION UPON ORAL EXAMINATION	EBT Notice - NPW	Thomas Joseph Gerspach
10	06/22/2021	ORDER - PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE	Dated 6/1/2021	Rosa E Matos
11	04/28/2023	NOTICE OF CHANGE OF FIRM NAME OR ADDRESS (POST RJI)		Jason J. Platt
12	05/09/2023	NOTICE OF CHANGE OF FIRM NAME OR ADDRESS (POST RJI)		Alexander Sikoscow
13	05/09/2023	STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING		Alexander Sikoscow
14	07/06/2023	BILL OF PARTICULARS	Supplemental Bill of Particulars	Jason J. Platt
15	07/10/2023	NOTE OF ISSUE:WITH JURY	Note of Issue	Jason J. Platt
16	07/21/2023	CONSENT TO CHANGE ATTORNEY (POST RJI)	Consent to Change Attorney - Bainbridge Nursing & Rehab Center	Howard Jacobowitz
17	02/27/2024	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE	Letter requesting Pre-Trial Conference adjournment	Jason J. Platt
18	05/08/2024	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE		Jason J. Platt
19	05/29/2024	COMPROMISE ORDER (CPLR 1207) (PROPOSED)	Compromise Order	Jason J. Platt
20	05/29/2024	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT	Affirmation in Support	Jason J. Platt
21	05/29/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Compromise Order	Jason J. Platt
22	05/29/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Retainer Agreement	Jason J. Platt
23	05/29/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Death Certificate	Jason J. Platt
24	05/29/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Letters of Administration	Jason J. Platt
25	05/29/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Settlement Confirmation Letter	Jason J. Platt
26	05/29/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Affidavit	Jason J. Platt
27	06/11/2024	ORDER - COMPROMISE & SETTLEMENT	dated 6/5/2024.	Lissette Rodriguez

Bronx Supreme Court

2019

20581/2019E (0020581/2019)

Active

Negligence

LIPSEY, PAUL

MARK DAVID SHIRIAN P.C.

BAINBRIDGE NURSING AND

Abrams Fensterman, LLP

04/23/2026

Perez, Hon. Bianka

▼

Case Info

Court

Bronx Supreme Court

Index Number

20581/2019E (0020581/2019)

Status

Active

Year Filed

2019

Case Name

LIPSEY, PAUL vs. BAINBRIDGE NURSING AND

Case Type

Tort-Other Negligence

Track

Standard

RJI Filed

08/06/2019

NOI Due

09/22/2023

NOI Filed

04/07/2025

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Jury At Plaintiff's Request

Justice

Perez, Hon. Bianka

Next Appearance

04/23/2026

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

LIPSEY, PAUL

Attorney / FirmMARK DAVID SHIRIAN P.C.

Defendant / Respondent

BAINBRIDGE NURSING AND

Attorneys / FirmsAbrams Fensterman, LLP

Motions (5)

#	Date Filed	Relief Sought	Submit Date	Answer	Status	Decision	Order Signed
5	06/03/2025	Judgment - Summary	04/22/2026	No	Before Justice: Perez, Hon. Bianka
4	02/07/2024	Strike Pleadings	03/06/2024	No	Decided: 10/11/2024 Granted Before Justice: Fernandez, Hon. Raymond P.	Short Form Order	10/11/2024
3	08/15/2023	Strike Pleadings	09/20/2023	No	Decided: 12/05/2023 Denied Before Justice: Fernandez, Hon. Raymond P.	Short Form Order	12/05/2023
2	04/29/2021	Strike Pleadings	03/25/2022	No	Decided: 03/25/2022 Denied Before Justice: Rodriguez, Hon. Julia I.	Short Form Order	03/25/2022
1	05/19/2020	Strike Pleadings	05/05/2022	No	Decided: 05/05/2022 Denied Before Justice: Rodriguez, Hon. Julia I.	Short Form Order	05/05/2022

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints (124)

Doc #	Date Filed	Document	Description	Motion #	Filing User	File
1	01/15/2019	SUMMONS + COMPLAINT			Mark David Shirian	pdf
2	01/17/2019	CONSENT TO EFILING			Mark David Shirian
3	01/28/2019	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE			Mark David Shirian
4	02/14/2019	ANSWER	Answer - Bainbridge Nursing and Rehabilitation Center, LLC		Thomas J Benvenuto	pdf
5	08/06/2019	RJI -RE: REQUEST FOR PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE			Mark David Shirian
6	08/08/2019	NOTICE OF PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE	08/26/2019		Jason C Wright
7	08/27/2019	ORDER - PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE	Dated 08/26/2019		Deirdre C Johnson
8	11/06/2019	DEMAND FOR:	Outstanding Discovery		Mark David Shirian
9	01/08/2020	ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE	DATED: DECEMBER 12, 2019		Sandra Riveralopez
10	03/02/2020	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE			Mark David Shirian
11	05/19/2020	NOTICE OF MOTION		001	Mark David Shirian	pdf
12	05/19/2020	AFFIRMATION OF GOOD FAITH		001	Mark David Shirian
13	05/19/2020	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT		001	Mark David Shirian
14	05/19/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Pleadings	001	Mark David Shirian
15	05/19/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Preliminary Conference Order	001	Mark David Shirian
16	05/19/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Good-Faith letter, dated November 6, 2019	001	Mark David Shirian
17	05/19/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Compliance Conference Order	001	Mark David Shirian
18	06/15/2020	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION		001	Denise Buda
19	06/15/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Response Demand BP Aff Defenses	001	Denise Buda
20	06/15/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Response Discovery Demands	001	Denise Buda
21	06/15/2020	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE		001	Denise Buda
22	09/03/2020	COURT NOTICE			Michael Habich
23	09/14/2020	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN REPLY		001	Mark David Shirian
24	09/14/2020	SUR-REPLY		001	Denise Buda
25	09/14/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Supplemental Discovery Response	001	Denise Buda
26	09/14/2020	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE		001	Denise Buda
27	01/14/2021	DEMAND FOR:	Bainbridge Demand for HIPAA Authorization		Elliot Emil Braun
28	03/22/2021	COURT NOTICE	Mediation-Consent Rules & Form		Michael Habich
29	04/29/2021	NOTICE OF MOTION		002	Mark David Shirian	pdf
30	04/29/2021	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION		002	Mark David Shirian
31	04/29/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Pleadings	002	Mark David Shirian
32	04/29/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Defendants Supplemental Response to Plaintiffs Demands	002	Mark David Shirian
33	05/14/2021	STIPULATION - ADJOURNMENT OF MOTION		002	Elliot Emil Braun
34	06/16/2021	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION		002	Elliot Emil Braun
35	06/16/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Affidavit of Jonathan Amoo	002	Elliot Emil Braun
36	06/16/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Summons and Complaint	002	Elliot Emil Braun
37	06/16/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Bainbridge Answer	002	Elliot Emil Braun
38	06/16/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Plaintiff's Combined Demands	002	Elliot Emil Braun
39	06/16/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Bainbridge Response to Plaintiff's Combined Demands	002	Elliot Emil Braun
40	06/16/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Bainbridge First Supplemental Response to Demands	002	Elliot Emil Braun
41	06/16/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Bainbridge Second Supplemental Response to Demands	002	Elliot Emil Braun
42	06/16/2021	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE		002	Elliot Emil Braun
43	06/16/2021	CONSENT TO CHANGE ATTORNEY (POST RJI)			Elliot Emil Braun
44	06/21/2021	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN REPLY		002	Mark David Shirian
45	03/29/2022	ORDER - STRIKE	SHORT FORM ORDER AND DECISION/ORDER DENIED DATED 3/25/2022	002	Attanya Douglas
46	05/10/2022	ORDER - STRIKE	DECISION/ORDER DENIED DATED 5/5/2022	001	Attanya Douglas
47	11/14/2022	ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE	DATED 11/9/2022		Neil Espinal
48	11/15/2022	NOTICE OF ENTRY		001	Denise Buda
49	11/15/2022	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE		001	Denise Buda
50	11/15/2022	NOTICE OF ENTRY		002	Denise Buda
51	11/15/2022	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE		002	Denise Buda
52	05/05/2023	DEMAND FOR:	Post-EBT Demands		Mark David Shirian
53	06/05/2023	RESPONSE TO DEMAND	Response to Post EBT Demands		Denise Buda
54	07/24/2023	RESPONSE TO DEMAND	Further Response Post EBT Demands		Denise Buda
55	08/15/2023	NOTICE OF MOTION		3	Mark David Shirian	pdf
56	08/15/2023	AFFIRMATION OF GOOD FAITH		3	Mark David Shirian
57	08/15/2023	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION		3	Mark David Shirian
58	08/15/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Pleadings	3	Mark David Shirian
59	08/15/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Compliance Conference Order	3	Mark David Shirian
60	08/15/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	EBT Transcript of Jonathan Amoo	3	Mark David Shirian
61	08/15/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Plaintiff's Post EBT Demands	3	Mark David Shirian
62	08/15/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Response to Post EBT Demands	3	Mark David Shirian
63	09/15/2023	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION		3	Denise Buda
64	09/15/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Decision and Order denying motion to strike	3	Denise Buda
65	09/18/2023	NOTICE OF REJECTION		3	Mark David Shirian
66	09/19/2023	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN REPLY		3	Mark David Shirian
67	09/20/2023	AFFIRMATION	Response to Pltf Notice of Rejection	3	Denise Buda
68	12/07/2023	ORDER - STRIKE	Short Form Order dated 12/5/2023 DENIED	3	Neil Espinal
69	01/10/2024	ORDER - CASE SCHEDULING	Compliance Conference Scheduling Order		Amina Martin
70	02/07/2024	NOTICE OF MOTION		4	Mark David Shirian	pdf
71	02/07/2024	AFFIRMATION OF GOOD FAITH		4	Mark David Shirian
72	02/07/2024	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION		4	Mark David Shirian
73	02/07/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	A	4	Mark David Shirian
74	02/07/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	B	4	Mark David Shirian
75	02/07/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	C	4	Mark David Shirian
76	02/07/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	D	4	Mark David Shirian
77	02/07/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	E	4	Mark David Shirian
78	02/07/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	F	4	Mark David Shirian
79	02/07/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	G	4	Mark David Shirian
80	02/28/2024	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION		4	Denise Buda
81	02/28/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	12.07.23 request conference	4	Denise Buda
82	03/04/2024	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN REPLY		4	Mark David Shirian
83	10/21/2024	ORDER - STRIKE	SHORT FORM ORDER DATED 10/11/2024	4	Michelle Alemany
84	10/21/2024	NOTICE OF ENTRY		4	Mark David Shirian
85	12/17/2024	RESPONSE TO DEMAND	12-17-24 Response to Post EBT Demands		David Todd Verschell
86	12/30/2024	RESPONSE TO DEMAND	Ctd Response to Post EBT Demands dated 12/6/24		David Todd Verschell
87	02/24/2025	NOTICE OF DEPOSITION/SUBPOENA			Mark David Shirian
88	03/24/2025	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE			Mark David Shirian
89	04/07/2025	NOTE OF ISSUE:WITH JURY			Mark David Shirian	pdf
90	06/03/2025	NOTICE OF MOTION		5	Melissa Stacy Goldberg	pdf
91	06/03/2025	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION		5	Melissa Stacy Goldberg
92	06/03/2025	STATEMENT OF MATERIAL FACTS		5	Melissa Stacy Goldberg	pdf
93	06/03/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	BPs/Supp BPs	5	Melissa Stacy Goldberg
94	06/03/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	plaintiff EBT	5	Melissa Stacy Goldberg
95	06/03/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	EBT (Amoo)	5	Melissa Stacy Goldberg
96	06/03/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	EBT (Goldbrenner)	5	Melissa Stacy Goldberg
97	06/03/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	EBT (Richard)	5	Melissa Stacy Goldberg
98	06/03/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Montefiore (Part 1)	5	Melissa Stacy Goldberg
99	06/03/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Montefiore (Part 2)	5	Melissa Stacy Goldberg
100	06/03/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Bainbridge (Part 1)	5	Melissa Stacy Goldberg
101	06/03/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Bainbridge (Part 2)	5	Melissa Stacy Goldberg
102	06/03/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Supplemental Response with investigation	5	Melissa Stacy Goldberg
103	06/03/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Bed Manual	5	Melissa Stacy Goldberg
104	06/03/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Amoo Affidavit	5	Melissa Stacy Goldberg
105	07/17/2025	STIPULATION - ADJOURNMENT OF MOTION		5	Mark David Shirian
106	08/15/2025	STIPULATION - ADJOURNMENT OF MOTION		5	Mark David Shirian
107	08/29/2025	NOTICE OF CROSS-MOTION		5	Mark David Shirian
108	08/29/2025	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION AND IN SUPPORT OF CROSS-MOTION		5	Mark David Shirian
109	08/29/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Verified Bill of Particulars	5	Mark David Shirian
110	08/29/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	transcript of the deposition of Paul Lipsey	5	Mark David Shirian
111	08/29/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	transcript of the deposition of Jonathan Amo0	5	Mark David Shirian
112	08/29/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	deposition of Jacob Goldbrenner	5	Mark David Shirian
113	08/29/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	deposition of Shakila Richard, RN	5	Mark David Shirian
114	08/29/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	medical records from Montefiore Medical Center (Part 1)	5	Mark David Shirian
115	08/29/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	medical records from Montefiore Medical Center (Part 2)	5	Mark David Shirian
116	08/29/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	records from Bainbridge Nursing and Rehabilitation Center	5	Mark David Shirian
117	08/29/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Bainbridge Nursing and Rehabilitation Center (Part 2)	5	Mark David Shirian
118	08/29/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	incident report	5	Mark David Shirian
119	08/29/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	manufacturer's maintenance manual for the M.C. Healthcare bed	5	Mark David Shirian
120	08/29/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	affidavit of Jonathan Amoo	5	Mark David Shirian
121	08/29/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Further Response to Post-EBT Demands dated July 24, 2023	5	Mark David Shirian
122	10/01/2025	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO CROSS-MOTION AND IN FURTHER SUPPORT OF MOTION	Affirmation in opposition and in reply	5	Melissa Stacy Goldberg
123	10/03/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Summons and Complaint, which were previously annexed by reference to NYSCEF #1	5	Melissa Stacy Goldberg
124	10/05/2025	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN FURTHER SUPPORT OF CROSS-MOTION	Reply Affirmation in Support of Cross-Motion	5	Mark David Shirian

Bronx Supreme Court

2019

23275/2017E (0023275/2017)

Disposed

Medical Malpractice

LAW, WILLIAM

FINKELSTEIN & PARTNERS

BAINBRIDGE NURSING AND

Abrams Fensterman, LLP

06/03/2025

Frishman, Hon. Michael A.

▼

Case Info

Court

Bronx Supreme Court

Index Number

23275/2017E (0023275/2017)

Status

Disposed

Year Filed

2019

Case Name

LAW, WILLIAM vs. BAINBRIDGE NURSING AND

Case Type

Tort-Medical, Dental, or Podiatric Malpractice

Track

Complex

RJI Filed

08/07/2019

NOI Due

NOI Filed

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

Frishman, Hon. Michael A.

Next Appearance

06/03/2025

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

LAW, WILLIAM

Attorney / FirmFINKELSTEIN & PARTNERS

Defendant / Respondent

BAINBRIDGE NURSING AND

Attorneys / FirmsAbrams Fensterman, LLP

Motions

No motions recorded for this case.

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints (40)

Doc #	Date Filed	Document	Description	Filing User
1	04/24/2017	SUMMONS + COMPLAINT	Summons and Complaint, verification dated 4-19-2017	Mary E Wright
2	04/24/2017	STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING	Statement of Auth for E-filing dated 4-24-2017	Mary E Wright
3	05/22/2017	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Bainbridge Nursing and Rehabilitation Center, LLC - Affidavit of Service of Summons and Complaint and Notice Regarding Availability of E-Filing	Mary E Wright
4	05/22/2017	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	East Haven Nursing and Rehabilitation Center, LLC - Affidavit of Service of Summons and Complaint and Notice Regarding Availability of E-Filing	Mary E Wright
5	06/02/2017	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Alexander Hartman - Affidavit of Service of Summons and Complaint and Notice Regarding Availability of E-Filing	Mary E Wright
6	06/29/2017	ANSWER	East Haven Nursing	Thomas J Benvenuto
7	06/30/2017	ANSWER	Bainbridge Nursing	Thomas J Benvenuto
8	06/30/2017	ANSWER	Hartman	Thomas J Benvenuto
9	10/30/2018	STIPULATION - DISCONTINUANCE ( REQUEST TO SO ORDER )	stipulation of discontinuance	Thomas J Benvenuto
10	08/07/2019	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE		Mary E Wright
11	08/07/2019	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE	Request for Preliminary Conference	Mary E Wright
12	08/07/2019	STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING		Mary E Wright
13	08/07/2019	RJI -RE: REQUEST FOR PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE		Mary E Wright
14	08/13/2019	NOTICE OF PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE	08/28/2019	Jason C Wright
15	08/14/2019	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE	cc of deft atty letter advising of Conference	Lawrence D Lissauer
16	08/14/2019	STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING		Lawrence D Lissauer
17	09/03/2019	ORDER - PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE	DATED AUGUST 28,2019	Sandra Riveralopez
18	01/20/2020	NOTICE OF APPEARANCE (POST RJI)		Quinn Noelle Cartelli
19	01/31/2020	ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE	DATED: JANUARY 21, 2020	Rosalind Carrington
20	06/07/2021	RESPONSE TO DEMAND	Bainbridge- Response to Demands for Documents & information	Elliot Emil Braun
21	06/07/2021	RESPONSE TO DEMAND	Bainbridge -Response to Notice to Produce	Elliot Emil Braun
22	06/11/2021	DEMAND FOR:	Good Faith Letter	Lawrence D Lissauer
23	06/11/2021	STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING	Our File No. 112641-02	Lawrence D Lissauer
24	06/21/2021	STIPULATION - SO ORDERED	Dated 6/8/2021	Rosa E Matos
25	06/22/2021	CONSENT TO CHANGE ATTORNEY (POST RJI)	Consent to Change Attorney-Bainbridge	Elliot Emil Braun
26	06/22/2021	CONSENT TO CHANGE ATTORNEY (POST RJI)	Consent to Change Attorney-Alexander Hartman	Elliot Emil Braun
27	07/13/2023	SUBPOENA ( REQUEST TO SO ORDER )		Lawrence D Lissauer
28	07/13/2023	SUBPOENA ( REQUEST TO SO ORDER )		Lawrence D Lissauer
29	07/13/2023	SUBPOENA ( REQUEST TO SO ORDER )		Lawrence D Lissauer
30	07/13/2023	STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING		Lawrence D Lissauer
31	07/27/2023	SUBPOENA - SO ORDERED	DATED 07/25/2023	Michelle Alemany
32	07/27/2023	SUBPOENA - SO ORDERED	DATED 07/25/2023	Michelle Alemany
33	07/27/2023	SUBPOENA - SO ORDERED	DATED 07/25/2023	Michelle Alemany
34	04/04/2024	RESPONSE TO DEMAND	Response to Demand for Policies and Procedures	Denise Buda
35	04/11/2024	ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE	Dated 4/9/2024.	Ann Colon
37	07/26/2024	ORDER ( PROPOSED )		Denise Buda
38	10/09/2024	ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE	DATED 10/2/2024.	Lissette Rodriguez
39	12/18/2024	ORDER ( PROPOSED )		Marie G Costello
40	12/26/2024	ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE	DATED 12/19/2024	Sara Mallach
41	04/21/2026	STIPULATION - OTHER - ( REQUEST TO SO ORDER )	Amend Caption / Lift stay	Melissa Stacy Goldberg

Bronx Supreme Court

2019

24610/2018E (0024610/2018)

Active

Medical Malpractice

BETTY G. PENAFIEL,

ZELENITZ, SHAPIRO & D'AGOSTINO, P.C.

BAINBRIDGE NURSING

Benvenuto & Gaujean

05/06/2026

Frishman, Hon. Michael A.

▼

Case Info

Court

Bronx Supreme Court

Index Number

24610/2018E (0024610/2018)

Status

Active

Year Filed

2019

Case Name

BETTY G. PENAFIEL, vs. BAINBRIDGE NURSING

Case Type

Tort-Medical, Dental, or Podiatric Malpractice

Track

Complex

RJI Filed

12/27/2019

NOI Due

03/29/2021

NOI Filed

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

Frishman, Hon. Michael A.

Next Appearance

05/06/2026

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

BETTY G. PENAFIEL,

Attorney / FirmZELENITZ, SHAPIRO & D'AGOSTINO, P.C.

Defendant / Respondent

BAINBRIDGE NURSING

Attorneys / FirmsBenvenuto & Gaujean

Motions (1)

#	Date Filed	Filed By	Relief Sought	Submit Date	Answer	Status	Decision	Order Signed
1	12/27/2019		Strike Pleadings	02/24/2020	No	Decided: 02/24/2020 Granted Before Justice: Capella, Hon. Joseph E.	Short Form Order	02/24/2020

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints (18)

Doc #	Date Filed	Document	Description	Motion #	Filing User
1	04/20/2018	SUMMONS + COMPLAINT			David A Shapiro
2	04/30/2018	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE			David A Shapiro
3	05/18/2018	ANSWER	Answer for Bainbridge		Thomas J Benvenuto
4	12/27/2019	NOTICE OF MOTION	Notice of Motion	001	Thomas J Benvenuto
5	12/27/2019	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service and Back	001	Thomas J Benvenuto
6	12/27/2019	AFFIRMATION	Affirmation in Support	001	Thomas J Benvenuto
7	12/27/2019	AFFIRMATION OF GOOD FAITH	Affirmation of Good Faith	001	Thomas J Benvenuto
8	12/27/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit A - Summons and Complaint	001	Thomas J Benvenuto
9	12/27/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit B - Verified Answer	001	Thomas J Benvenuto
10	12/27/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit C - Letter to Plaintiff's Counsel dated July 30, 2019	001	Thomas J Benvenuto
11	12/27/2019	RJI -RE: NOTICE OF MOTION		001	Thomas J Benvenuto
12	02/26/2020	DECISION + ORDER ON MOTION	SHORT FORM ORDER & STIPULATION SO ORDERED DATED 2/24/2020	001	Rosa E Matos
13	12/16/2020	PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE ORDER (PROPOSED)			Nicholas P. Stockton
14	01/22/2021	ORDER - PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE	DATED 1/4/2021.		Lissette Rodriguez
15	05/09/2023	NOTICE OF CHANGE OF FIRM NAME OR ADDRESS (POST RJI)			Alexander Sikoscow
16	05/09/2023	STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING			Alexander Sikoscow
17	08/02/2023	CONSENT TO CHANGE ATTORNEY (POST RJI)	Consent to Change Attorney - Bainbridge Nursing & Rehab Center		Howard Jacobowitz
18	03/10/2026	ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE	Dated March 2 2026		Michael Kenny

Bronx Supreme Court

2016

24063/2016E (0024063/2016)

Disposed

Medical Malpractice

CARDILLO, ROSARIA

Doolan Platt & Setareh, LLP

BAINBRIDGE NURSING

Heidell, Pittoni, Murphy & Bach, LLP

07/15/2022

Frishman, Hon. Michael A.

▼

Case Info

Court

Bronx Supreme Court

Index Number

24063/2016E (0024063/2016)

Status

Disposed

Year Filed

2016

Case Name

CARDILLO, ROSARIA vs. BAINBRIDGE NURSING

Case Type

Tort-Medical, Dental, or Podiatric Malpractice

Track

Complex

RJI Filed

11/17/2016

NOI Due

02/18/2018

NOI Filed

03/22/2021

Calendar Number

2021-00360

Jury Status

Jury At Plaintiff's Request

Justice

Frishman, Hon. Michael A.

Next Appearance

07/15/2022

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

CARDILLO, ROSARIA

Attorney / FirmDoolan Platt & Setareh, LLP

Defendant / Respondent

BAINBRIDGE NURSING

Attorneys / FirmsHeidell, Pittoni, Murphy & Bach, LLP

Motions (2)

#	Date Filed	Filed By	Relief Sought	Submit Date	Answer	Status	Decision	Order Signed
2	08/03/2022		Compromise	09/30/2022	No	Decided: 09/30/2022 Signed Before Justice: Frishman, Hon. Michael A.	Long Form Order	09/30/2022
1	08/27/2019		Strike Pleadings	10/09/2019	No	Decided: 10/09/2019 Decided Before Justice: Silver, Hon. George J.	Short Form Order	10/09/2019

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints (66)

Doc #	Date Filed	Document	Description	Motion #	Filing User	File
1	06/14/2016	SUMMONS + COMPLAINT	Summons & Verified Complaint		Jason J. Platt	pdf
2	10/13/2016	AFFIDAVIT	Aff of Service for service upon Bainbridge		Jason J. Platt
3	10/13/2016	AFFIDAVIT	Aff of service for service upon Montefiore		Jason J. Platt
4	11/07/2016	ANSWER	Answer- Bainbridge Nursing and Rehabilitation Center		Thomas J Benvenuto	pdf
5	11/11/2016	ANSWER	Answer for Montefiore Medical Center		Patrick Joseph Murphy	pdf
6	11/11/2016	DEMAND FOR BILL OF PARTICULARS	Demand for BP w-Initial Combined Demands and Notices for Montefiore Medical Center		Patrick Joseph Murphy
7	11/11/2016	NOTICE OF DEPOSITION	Notice of Deposition for Montefiore Medical Center		Patrick Joseph Murphy
8	11/17/2016	RJI -RE: NOTICE OF MEDICAL, DENTAL OR PODIATRIC MALPRACTICE			Jason J. Platt
9	11/17/2016	NOTICE OF MEDICAL MALPRACTICE	Notice of Medical Malpractice Action		Jason J. Platt
10	01/17/2017	ORDER - PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE	dated 1/10/2017		Rosa E Matos
11	05/16/2017	CONSENT TO CHANGE ATTORNEY (POST RJI)			Denise Buda
12	07/17/2017	ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE	dated 7/11/2017		Rosa E Matos
13	03/22/2018	ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE	DATED 2/20/2018		Wanda Delgado
14	07/27/2018	ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE	DATED 7/10/2018		Wanda Delgado
15	12/06/2018	STIPULATION - SO ORDERED	DATED 10/25/2018		Wanda Delgado
16	02/27/2019	STIPULATION - SO ORDERED	DATED:01/16/2019		Marcy K Thomas
17	03/14/2019	ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE	DATED 3/6/2019		Sandra Riveralopez
18	04/19/2019	STIPULATION - SO ORDERED	Dated 4/3/2019		Rosa E Matos
19	05/21/2019	STIPULATION - OTHER	DATED 05/15/2019		Deirdre C Johnson
20	07/25/2019	STIPULATION - SO ORDERED	Dated 07/17/2019		Deirdre C Johnson
21	08/27/2019	NOTICE OF MOTION	Notice of Motion	001	Denise Katherine Neuendorf	pdf
22	08/27/2019	AFFIRMATION OF GOOD FAITH	Affirmation of Good Faith	001	Denise Katherine Neuendorf
23	08/27/2019	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT	Affirmation In Support	001	Denise Katherine Neuendorf
24	08/27/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	Summons and Complaint	001	Denise Katherine Neuendorf
25	08/27/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	Verified Answer	001	Denise Katherine Neuendorf
26	08/27/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	Preliminary Conference Order 1.10.17	001	Denise Katherine Neuendorf
27	08/27/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	Good Faith Letters	001	Denise Katherine Neuendorf
28	08/27/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	Court Stipulation dated 7.17.19	001	Denise Katherine Neuendorf
29	08/27/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	Demand for Azs dated 12.29.17 & 7.10.19	001	Denise Katherine Neuendorf
30	08/27/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	Notice for Discovery and Inspection dated 11.16.17	001	Denise Katherine Neuendorf
31	09/17/2019	STIPULATION - SO ORDERED	Dated: 09/04/2019		Julio Grandgerard
32	12/30/2019	STIPULATION - SO ORDERED	DATED 12/4/2019		Melanie Ocasio
33	02/06/2020	STIPULATION - DISCOVERY ( REQUEST TO SO ORDER )	Proposed Stip Resolving Defts' Mtn to Dismiss/Compel Discovery		Denise Katherine Neuendorf
34	02/20/2020	ORDER - INTERIM	DATED 9/4/2019.		Lissette Rodriguez
35	10/16/2020	RESPONSE TO DEMAND			Denise Buda
36	10/16/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Shakila Richard Affidavit		Denise Buda
37	10/16/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Shakila Richard CV		Denise Buda
38	10/16/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	PRI Insurance Dec. sheet		Denise Buda
39	10/16/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Bainbridge Care Providers		Denise Buda
40	10/16/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Table of Contents		Denise Buda
41	10/16/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Policy & Procedure Pressure Ulcers		Denise Buda
42	10/16/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Job Descriptions		Denise Buda
43	10/16/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	TAR documentation wound care		Denise Buda
44	10/16/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Pressure Mattress Invoices		Denise Buda
45	10/16/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Paint Bill of Rights		Denise Buda
46	10/16/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	24 Hour Reports		Denise Buda
47	10/16/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Bainbridge itemized bill		Denise Buda
48	10/16/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Punch In Punch Out Repports		Denise Buda
49	10/16/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Staffing Sheets Dec. 2013		Denise Buda
50	10/16/2020	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE			Denise Buda
51	10/19/2020	STIPULATION - DISCONTINUANCE ( REQUEST TO SO ORDER )	Stipulation of Discontinuance with Prejudice as to Montefiore Medical Center		Eric David Gingold	pdf
53	10/23/2020	STIPULATION - SO ORDERED	Dated 10/20/2020		Terrence Daly
54	02/25/2021	ORDER - INTERIM	DATED 2/19/2021.		Lissette Rodriguez
55	03/19/2021	BILL OF PARTICULARS	Further Supplemental Verified Bill of Particulars		Jason J. Platt
57	03/22/2021	NOTE OF ISSUE:WITH JURY	Note of Issue		Jason J. Platt	pdf
58	08/03/2022	COMPROMISE ORDER (CPLR 1207) (PROPOSED)	Compromise Order		Jason J. Platt
59	08/03/2022	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT	Affirmation in Support		Jason J. Platt
60	08/03/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Compromise Order		Jason J. Platt
61	08/03/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Retainer Agreement		Jason J. Platt
62	08/03/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Death Certificate		Jason J. Platt
63	08/03/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Letters of Administration		Jason J. Platt
64	08/03/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Settlement Confirmation Letter		Jason J. Platt
65	08/03/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Decree for settlement against hospital defendant		Jason J. Platt
66	08/03/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Affidavit of plaintiff/petitioner		Jason J. Platt
67	10/05/2022	ORDER - OTHER	Compromise Order Dated 9/30/2022		Rosa E Matos
68	01/03/2023	STIPULATION - DISCONTINUANCE (POST RJI)	Stip Disc Bainbridge		Denise Buda	pdf

Bronx Supreme Court

2015

24849/2015E (0024849/2015)

Disposed

Negligence

MOBLEY, DARLENE

GALLIVAN & GALLIVAN, ATTORNEYS AT LAW

BAINBRIDGE NURSING AND

Abrams Fensterman, LLP

03/18/2026

Capella, Hon. Joseph E.

▼

Case Info

Court

Bronx Supreme Court

Index Number

24849/2015E (0024849/2015)

Status

Disposed

Year Filed

2015

Case Name

MOBLEY, DARLENE vs. BAINBRIDGE NURSING AND

Case Type

Tort-Other Negligence

Track

Complex

RJI Filed

11/17/2015

NOI Due

02/17/2017

NOI Filed

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

Capella, Hon. Joseph E.

Next Appearance

03/18/2026

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

MOBLEY, DARLENE

Attorney / FirmGALLIVAN & GALLIVAN, ATTORNEYS AT LAW

Defendant / Respondent

BAINBRIDGE NURSING AND

Attorneys / FirmsAbrams Fensterman, LLP

Motions (3)

#	Date Filed	Relief Sought	Submit Date	Answer	Status	Decision	Order Signed
3	03/04/2026	Compromise	03/18/2026	No	Decided: 03/26/2026 Granted Before Justice: Capella, Hon. Joseph E.	Short Form Order	03/26/2026
2	03/18/2019	Strike Pleadings	07/15/2019	No	Decided: 07/15/2019 Withdrawn Before Justice: Capella, Hon. Joseph E.	Short Form Order	07/15/2019
1	03/18/2019	Strike Pleadings	05/23/2019	No	Decided: 05/23/2019 Decided Before Justice: Douglas, Hon. Laura G.		05/23/2019

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints (48)

Doc #	Date Filed	Document	Description	Motion #	Filing User	File
1	09/01/2015	SUMMONS + COMPLAINT	Mobley Summons and Complaint		Thomas L. Gallivan	pdf
2	11/10/2015	ANSWER	BAINBRIDGE'S ANSWER		Thomas J Benvenuto	pdf
3	11/17/2015	RJI -RE: REQUEST FOR PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE	RJI		Thomas L. Gallivan
4	11/17/2015	PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE REQUEST	PC Request		Thomas L. Gallivan
5	11/17/2015	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Aff of Serv - RJI		Thomas L. Gallivan
6	01/20/2016	ORDER - PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE	Dated 01/14/2016		Kenneth Brewster
7	03/21/2016	NOTICE OF APPEARANCE (POST RJI)	Notice of Appearance		Denise Buda
8	03/21/2016	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service and Litigation Back		Denise Buda
9	03/31/2016	CONSENT TO CHANGE ATTORNEY (POST RJI)	Consent to Change Attorney		Denise Buda
10	09/13/2016	ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE	DATED: 09/12/16		Marcy K Thomas
11	12/12/2016	NOTICE OF CHANGE OF FIRM NAME OR ADDRESS (POST RJI)			Josie Marie Conelley
12	03/18/2019	NOTICE OF MOTION		001	Jonathan Aaron Heller	pdf
13	03/18/2019	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT		001	Jonathan Aaron Heller
14	03/18/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	Summons and Complaint	001	Jonathan Aaron Heller
15	03/18/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	Answer	001	Jonathan Aaron Heller
16	03/18/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	PC Order	001	Jonathan Aaron Heller
17	03/18/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	9-13-16 CC Order	001	Jonathan Aaron Heller
18	03/18/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	90-Day Notice	001	Jonathan Aaron Heller
19	03/18/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	EBT Confirmation	001	Jonathan Aaron Heller
20	03/18/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	11.12.2018 Statement of Record	001	Jonathan Aaron Heller
21	03/18/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	Invoices	001	Jonathan Aaron Heller
22	03/18/2019	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE		001	Jonathan Aaron Heller
23	04/22/2019	STIPULATION - ADJOURNMENT OF MOTION	Stip to Adjourn Motion	001	Thomas L. Gallivan
24	07/03/2019	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE		001	Denise Buda
25	07/16/2019	ORDER - INTERIM	DATED 5/23/2019	001	Melanie Ocasio
26	07/16/2019	DECISION + ORDER ON MOTION	SHORT FORM ORDER DATED 7/15/2019	001	Melanie Ocasio	pdf
27	12/20/2019	STIPULATION - SO ORDERED	DATED 12/2/2019		Rosa E Matos
28	03/01/2020	DEMAND FOR:	3 1 20 - designation def ebt		Thomas L. Gallivan
29	03/10/2020	STIPULATION - SO ORDERED	DATED: MARCH 2, 2020		Rosalind Carrington
30	02/08/2021	NOTICE OF DISCOVERY AND INSPECTION	NOTICE FOR D&I		Thomas L. Gallivan
31	04/23/2021	RESPONSE TO DEMAND			Elliot Emil Braun
32	07/29/2025	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE	Request for adjournment of status conference		Melissa Stacy Goldberg
33	03/04/2026	ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE ( PROPOSED )		3	Thomas L. Gallivan	pdf
34	03/04/2026	AFFIRMATION	Attorney Affirmation	3	Thomas L. Gallivan
35	03/04/2026	AFFIDAVIT	Affidavit in Support	3	Thomas L. Gallivan
36	03/04/2026	EXHIBIT(S)	Letters of Administration	3	Thomas L. Gallivan
37	03/04/2026	EXHIBIT(S)	Retainer Agreement	3	Thomas L. Gallivan
38	03/04/2026	EXHIBIT(S)	Death Certificate	3	Thomas L. Gallivan
39	03/04/2026	EXHIBIT(S)	NYC HRR/DSS Letter	3	Thomas L. Gallivan
40	03/04/2026	EXHIBIT(S)	Proposed Order	3	Thomas L. Gallivan
41	03/09/2026	ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE	Dated 3/6/2026	3	Shomari Dixon	pdf
42	03/09/2026	ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE - CONFORMED COPY			Thomas L. Gallivan	pdf
43	03/09/2026	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service of OTSC		Thomas L. Gallivan
44	03/09/2026	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service of OTSC		Thomas L. Gallivan
45	03/09/2026	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service of OTSC		Thomas L. Gallivan
46	03/27/2026	DECISION + ORDER ON MOTION	SHORT FORM ORDER & ORDER DATED 03/26/2026	3	Michelle Alemany	pdf
47	04/21/2026	STIPULATION - DISCOVERY ( REQUEST TO SO ORDER )	FULLY EXECUTED SOD with REQUEST TO SO-ORDER		Melissa Stacy Goldberg
48	04/21/2026	STIPULATION - DISCONTINUANCE (POST RJI)	FULLY EXECUTED SOD with REQUEST TO SO-ORDER		Melissa Stacy Goldberg

Bronx Supreme Court

2015

25050/2014E (0025050/2014)

Disposed

OM-Other

MURPHY, VIOLET

LAW FIRM OF LOUIS GINSBERG, P.C.

BAINBRIDGE NURSING AND

JACKSON LEWIS P.C.

11/30/2015

Gonzalez, Hon. Lizbeth

▼

Case Info

Court

Bronx Supreme Court

Index Number

25050/2014E (0025050/2014)

Status

Disposed

Year Filed

2015

Case Name

MURPHY, VIOLET vs. BAINBRIDGE NURSING AND

Case Type

OM-Other

Track

Standard

RJI Filed

01/21/2015

NOI Due

01/21/2016

NOI Filed

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

Gonzalez, Hon. Lizbeth

Next Appearance

11/30/2015

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

MURPHY, VIOLET

Attorney / FirmLAW FIRM OF LOUIS GINSBERG, P.C.

Defendant / Respondent

BAINBRIDGE NURSING AND

Attorneys / FirmsJACKSON LEWIS P.C.

Motions

No motions recorded for this case.

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints (6)

Doc #	Date Filed	Document	Description	Filing User	File
1	10/27/2014	SUMMONS + COMPLAINT		Louis Ginsberg	pdf
2	12/29/2014	ANSWER		Jason A Zoldessy	pdf
3	01/21/2015	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE		Louis Ginsberg
4	01/21/2015	RJI -RE: REQUEST FOR PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE		Louis Ginsberg
5	03/06/2015	ORDER - PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE	DATED 3/3/2015	Wanda Delgado
6	05/14/2015	STIPULATION - DISCONTINUANCE (POST RJI)		Jason A Zoldessy	pdf

Lawsuit Summary

Cases

Need Help?

Let us help you or a loved one find the perfect senior home.