Who is the owner of Brookside Multicare Nursing Center?

The legal owner and operator of Brookside Multicare Nursing Center is Optima Care Smithtown, LLC (For Profit).

Is Brookside Multicare Nursing Center in a walkable area?

Brookside Multicare Nursing Center has a walk score of 16. Car-dependent. Most errands require a car, with limited nearby walkable options.

What is the license number of Brookside Multicare Nursing Center?

According to NY state health department records, Brookside Multicare Nursing Center's license number is 5157318N.

What is the occupancy rate at Brookside Multicare Nursing Center?

Brookside Multicare Nursing Center's occupancy is 86%.

How many beds does Brookside Multicare Nursing Center have?

Brookside Multicare Nursing Center has 353 beds.

Has Brookside Multicare Nursing Center had any recent deficiencies or citations?

Brookside Multicare Nursing Center has had 57 recently reported deficiencies.

Are there photos of Brookside Multicare Nursing Center?

Yes — there are 16 photos of Brookside Multicare Nursing Center in the photo gallery on this page.

Brookside Multicare Nursing Center | 3-Star Nursing Home in Suffolk County, NY

Lawsuit Summary

Total Cases

Active Cases

7 active

Stayed / Paused

1 Stayed

Closed

7 Disposed

Since

2021

Most Recent

2026

Next Court Date

Apr 23, 2026

This facility is currently involved in 7 active lawsuits.

Cases

15 cases · Click to expand details (25 from 2010 – present; older years: list only)

Court

Year

Index Number

Status

Case Type

Plaintiff / Petitioner

Plaintiff Firm

Defendant / Respondent

Defendant Firm

Appearance

Justice

Suffolk Supreme Court

2026

634115/2025

Active

Negligence

WILLSEY, LUCILLE

DALLAS LAW, LLC

OPTIMA CARE SMITHTOWN, LLC d/b/a BROOKSIDE MULTICARE NURSING CENTER

WILSON, ELSER, MOSKOWITZ, EDELMAN & DICKER

05/12/2026

Suffolk Supreme, DCM-Justice

▼

Case Info

Court

Suffolk Supreme Court

Index Number

634115/2025

Status

Active

Year Filed

2026

Case Name

WILLSEY, LUCILLE vs. OPTIMA CARE SMITHTOWN, LLC d/b/a BROOKSIDE MULTICARE NURSING CENTER

Case Type

Tort-Other Negligence

Track

Standard

RJI Filed

04/14/2026

NOI Due

04/14/2027

NOI Filed

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

Suffolk Supreme, DCM-Justice

Next Appearance

05/12/2026

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

WILLSEY, LUCILLE

Attorney / FirmDALLAS LAW, LLC

Defendant / Respondent

OPTIMA CARE SMITHTOWN, LLC d/b/a BROOKSIDE MULTICARE NURSING CENTER

Attorneys / FirmsWILSON, ELSER, MOSKOWITZ, EDELMAN & DICKER

Motions

No motions recorded for this case.

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints (11)

Doc #	Date Filed	Document	Description	Filing User	File
1	12/22/2025	SUMMONS + COMPLAINT		Robert John Dallas	pdf
2	01/05/2026	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Optima Care Smithtown, LLC	Robert John Dallas
3	01/05/2026	STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING		Robert John Dallas
4	02/16/2026	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Notice pursuant to CPLR 306(c)	Robert John Dallas
5	03/03/2026	ANSWER		Lori Rosen Semlies	pdf
6	03/03/2026	DEMAND FOR BILL OF PARTICULARS		Lori Rosen Semlies
7	03/03/2026	DEMAND FOR:	Combined Demands	Lori Rosen Semlies
8	04/03/2026	RESPONSE TO DEMAND	Photograph Exchange	Robert John Dallas
9	04/03/2026	PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE REQUEST		Robert John Dallas
10	04/03/2026	RJI -RE: REQUEST FOR PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE		Robert John Dallas
11	04/15/2026	COURT NOTICE		Renee Ambrosio

Suffolk Supreme Court

2026

615825/2025

Active

Negligence

DEJESUS-PETROMELIS, JENNIFER

KENNETH J. READY & ASSOCIATES

BROOKSIDE MULTICARE NURSING CENTER

WILSON, ELSER, MOSKOWITZ, EDELMAN & DICKER

07/30/2026

Hensley, Hon. Paul M.

▼

Case Info

Court

Suffolk Supreme Court

Index Number

615825/2025

Status

Active

Year Filed

2026

Case Name

DEJESUS-PETROMELIS, JENNIFER vs. BROOKSIDE MULTICARE NURSING CENTER

Case Type

Tort-Other Negligence

Track

Standard

RJI Filed

01/21/2026

NOI Due

01/21/2027

NOI Filed

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

Hensley, Hon. Paul M.

Next Appearance

07/30/2026

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

DEJESUS-PETROMELIS, JENNIFER

Attorney / FirmKENNETH J. READY & ASSOCIATES

Defendant / Respondent

BROOKSIDE MULTICARE NURSING CENTER

Attorneys / FirmsWILSON, ELSER, MOSKOWITZ, EDELMAN & DICKER

Motions

No motions recorded for this case.

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints (11)

Doc #	Date Filed	Document	Description	Filing User	File
1	06/17/2025	SUMMONS + COMPLAINT	Summons & Verified Complaint	Kenneth John Ready	pdf
2	06/25/2025	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	BROOKSIDE MULTICARE NURSING CENTER	Kenneth John Ready
3	06/25/2025	STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING		Kenneth John Ready
4	08/29/2025	ANSWER		Lori Rosen Semlies	pdf
5	08/29/2025	DEMAND FOR BILL OF PARTICULARS		Lori Rosen Semlies
6	08/29/2025	DEMAND FOR:	Combined Demands	Lori Rosen Semlies
7	01/09/2026	PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE REQUEST		John Fitzgerald Ready
8	01/09/2026	RJI -RE: REQUEST FOR PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE		John Fitzgerald Ready
9	01/21/2026	COURT NOTICE		Renee Ambrosio
10	02/24/2026	COURT NOTICE		Patricia Leonard
11	03/02/2026	ORDER - PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE		Linnett Gordon

Queens Supreme Court

2025

718348/2024

Disposed

OM-Other

Optima Care Smithtown, LLC d/b/a Brookside Multicare Nursing Center Smithtown

SCHWARTZ SLADKUS REICH GREENBERG ATLAS LLP

Shackleford, Audley

01/06/2026

Livote, Hon. Leonard

▼

Case Info

Court

Queens Supreme Court

Index Number

718348/2024

Status

Disposed

Year Filed

2025

Case Name

Optima Care Smithtown, LLC d/b/a Brookside Multicare Nursing Center Smithtown vs. Shackleford, Audley

Case Type

OM-Other

Track

Standard

RJI Filed

11/03/2025

NOI Due

11/03/2026

NOI Filed

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

Livote, Hon. Leonard

Next Appearance

01/06/2026

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

Optima Care Smithtown, LLC d/b/a Brookside Multicare Nursing Center Smithtown

Attorney / FirmSCHWARTZ SLADKUS REICH GREENBERG ATLAS LLP

Defendant / Respondent

Shackleford, Audley

Attorneys / Firms

Motions (1)

#	Date Filed	Filed By	Relief Sought	Submit Date	Answer	Status	Decision	Order Signed
1	11/03/2025		Judgment - Default	01/06/2026	No	Decided: 03/24/2026 Denied Before Justice: Livote, Hon. Leonard	Short Form Order

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints (28)

Doc #	Date Filed	Document	Description	Motion #	Filing User	File
1	09/05/2024	SUMMONS + COMPLAINT			Shelby Elyssa Neiss	pdf
2	09/05/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Invoice		Shelby Elyssa Neiss
3	09/05/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Admission Agreement		Shelby Elyssa Neiss
4	09/05/2024	STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING			Shelby Elyssa Neiss
5	09/16/2024	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE			Shelby Elyssa Neiss
6	01/06/2025	AFFIRMATION	Non-Military Affirmation		Shelby Elyssa Neiss
7	01/06/2025	AFFIDAVIT OF FACTS	Affirmation of Facts		Shelby Elyssa Neiss
8	01/06/2025	AFFIRMATION	Additional Mailing Affirmation		Shelby Elyssa Neiss
9	01/06/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Invoice for Service of Summons and Complaint		Shelby Elyssa Neiss
10	01/06/2025	JUDGMENT - CLERK DEFAULT (PROPOSED)			Shelby Elyssa Neiss
11	01/06/2025	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE			Shelby Elyssa Neiss
12	01/06/2025	BILL OF COSTS			Shelby Elyssa Neiss
13	11/03/2025	NOTICE OF MOTION	Notice of Motion to Enter Default Judgment	001	Shelby Elyssa Neiss	pdf
14	11/03/2025	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT		001	Shelby Elyssa Neiss
15	11/03/2025	AFFIRMATION	Affirmation of Facts	001	Shelby Elyssa Neiss
16	11/03/2025	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE		001	Shelby Elyssa Neiss
17	11/03/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Summons and Verified Complaint	001	Shelby Elyssa Neiss
18	11/03/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Summons and Verified Complaint Affirmation of Service	001	Shelby Elyssa Neiss
19	11/03/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	AOS Additional Mailing	001	Shelby Elyssa Neiss
20	11/03/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Non-Military Affirmation	001	Shelby Elyssa Neiss
21	11/03/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Default Judgment Application Confirmation Notice	001	Shelby Elyssa Neiss
22	11/03/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Default Judgment Application Rejection Notice	001	Shelby Elyssa Neiss
23	11/03/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Statement of Account and Medical Assistance Budget	001	Shelby Elyssa Neiss
24	11/03/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Admission Agreement	001	Shelby Elyssa Neiss
25	11/03/2025	STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING		001	Shelby Elyssa Neiss
26	11/03/2025	RJI -RE: NOTICE OF MOTION		001	Shelby Elyssa Neiss	pdf
27	12/18/2025	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE		001	Shelby Elyssa Neiss
28	03/25/2026	DECISION + ORDER ON MOTION		001	Tongenykau Brunson	pdf

Suffolk Supreme Court

2024

626734/2023

Stayed

Negligence

DOWD, RICHARD G

DUFFY & DUFFY, PLLC

OPTIMA CARE SMITHTOWN, LLC d/b/a BROOKSIDE MULTICARE NURSING CENTER

KERLEY, WALSH, MATERA & CINQUEMANI, P.C.

10/15/2025

Pastoressa, Hon. Joseph C.

▼

Case Info

Court

Suffolk Supreme Court

Index Number

626734/2023

Status

Stayed

Year Filed

2024

Case Name

DOWD, RICHARD G vs. OPTIMA CARE SMITHTOWN, LLC d/b/a BROOKSIDE MULTICARE NURSING CENTER

Case Type

Tort-Other Negligence

Track

Standard

RJI Filed

01/18/2024

NOI Due

NOI Filed

10/10/2025

Calendar Number

202501260OT

Jury Status

Jury At Plaintiff's Request

Justice

Pastoressa, Hon. Joseph C.

Next Appearance

10/15/2025

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

DOWD, RICHARD G

Attorney / FirmDUFFY & DUFFY, PLLC

Defendant / Respondent

OPTIMA CARE SMITHTOWN, LLC d/b/a BROOKSIDE MULTICARE NURSING CENTER

Attorneys / FirmsKERLEY, WALSH, MATERA & CINQUEMANI, P.C.

Motions

No motions recorded for this case.

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints (44)

Doc #	Date Filed	Document	Description	Filing User	File
1	10/27/2023	SUMMONS + COMPLAINT	SUMMONS AND COMPLAINT W/VERIFICATION PAGE	Damien Smith	pdf
2	11/10/2023	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	BROOKSIDE MULTICARE NURSING CENTER	Damien Smith
3	11/10/2023	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	OPTIMA CARE SMITHTOWN, LLC	Damien Smith
4	11/10/2023	STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING		Damien Smith
5	11/24/2023	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	OPTIMA CARE SMITHTOWN, LLC	Damien Smith
6	12/07/2023	STIPULATION - TIME TO ANSWER		Lori Rosen Semlies	pdf
7	12/13/2023	CONSENT TO CHANGE ATTORNEY (PRE RJI)		Michael Richard Janes
8	12/13/2023	STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING		Michael Richard Janes
9	01/10/2024	ANSWER	Verified Answer, Demand for BP & Notice for EBT	Michael Richard Janes	pdf
10	01/10/2024	DEMAND FOR:	Combined Discovery Demands	Michael Richard Janes
11	01/11/2024	DEMAND FOR:	LITIGATION HOLD NOTICE	Damien Smith
12	01/11/2024	DEMAND FOR:	COMBINED DEMANDS	Damien Smith
13	01/11/2024	DEMAND FOR BILL OF PARTICULARS	DEMAND FOR BILL OF PARTICULARS AS TO AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSES	Damien Smith
14	01/11/2024	NOTICE OF DISCOVERY AND INSPECTION	NOTICE FOR DISCOVERY AND INSPECTION - EMR RECORDS	Damien Smith
15	01/17/2024	RESPONSE TO DEMAND	Response to Combined Demands	Damien Smith
16	01/18/2024	PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE REQUEST	PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE REQUEST	Damien Smith
17	01/18/2024	AFFIDAVIT	AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Damien Smith
18	01/18/2024	RJI -RE: REQUEST FOR PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE		Damien Smith
19	01/18/2024	ADDENDUM - GENERAL (840A)		Damien Smith
20	01/18/2024	PROOF OF SERVICE	Affirmation of Service - Notice of Commencement	Damien Smith
21	01/18/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Notice of Commencement/Summons and Complaint and Affidavit of Service	Damien Smith
22	01/26/2024	COURT NOTICE		Janet Dantuono
23	02/27/2024	BILL OF PARTICULARS		Thomas L. Gallivan
24	02/27/2024	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE		Thomas L. Gallivan
25	02/28/2024	PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE ORDER (PROPOSED)		Thomas L. Gallivan
26	03/01/2024	ORDER - PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE		Pamela Oconnor
27	04/18/2024	DEMAND FOR:	Letter to Kerley Walsh requesting records	Damien Smith
28	04/29/2024	DEMAND FOR:	demand for deposition date for witness	Damien Smith
29	05/02/2024	DEMAND FOR:	Deposition date for plaintiff	Michael Richard Janes
30	08/15/2024	ORDER ( PROPOSED )	DISCOVERY	Damien Smith
31	08/20/2024	ORDER - OTHER	DISCOVERY	Christina Altomare
32	09/27/2024	DEMAND FOR:		Damien Smith
33	11/04/2024	DEMAND FOR:	demand for deposition dates for witnesses	Damien Smith
34	11/06/2024	DEMAND FOR:	Deposition date for witnesses	Michael Richard Janes
35	11/13/2024	ORDER ( PROPOSED )	Proposed Compliance Conference Order	Damien Smith
36	11/22/2024	ORDER - OTHER	DISCOVERY	Christina Altomare
37	02/04/2025	DEMAND FOR:	demand for deposition dates for witnesses	Damien Smith
38	02/26/2025	ORDER ( PROPOSED )		Damien Smith
39	02/26/2025	BILL OF PARTICULARS	Supplemental Verified Bill of Particulars	Damien Smith
40	03/05/2025	ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE	FILE NOTE OF ISSUE BY 10/15/25	Christina Altomare
41	04/04/2025	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE	Designation of physicians	Michael Richard Janes
42	05/20/2025	RESPONSE TO DEMAND	Notice of Insurance	Michael Richard Janes
43	10/10/2025	NOTE OF ISSUE:WITH JURY	Note of Issue	Damien Smith	pdf
44	01/08/2026	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE	Letter to advise of death of plaintiff	Damien Smith

Queens Supreme Court

2023

705842/2023

Active

Negligence

as administrator of the Estate of ROBERT SOTO DECEASED, SYLVIA SOTO

Frekhtman & Associates Attorneys at Law

BROOKSIDE MULTICARE NURSING CENTER et al

SHEELEY, LLP

05/15/2026

Compliance Conf Judge,

▼

Case Info

Court

Queens Supreme Court

Index Number

705842/2023

Status

Active

Year Filed

2023

Case Name

as administrator of the Estate of ROBERT SOTO DECEASED, SYLVIA SOTO vs. BROOKSIDE MULTICARE NURSING CENTER et al

Case Type

Tort-Other Negligence

Track

Standard

RJI Filed

07/14/2023

NOI Due

07/13/2024

NOI Filed

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

Compliance Conf Judge,

Next Appearance

05/15/2026

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

as administrator of the Estate of ROBERT SOTO DECEASED, SYLVIA SOTO

Attorney / FirmFrekhtman & Associates Attorneys at Law

Defendant / Respondent

BROOKSIDE MULTICARE NURSING CENTER et al

Attorneys / FirmsSHEELEY, LLP

Motions

No motions recorded for this case.

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints (22)

Doc #	Date Filed	Document	Description	Filing User	File
1	03/17/2023	SUMMONS + COMPLAINT	SUMMONS & COMPLAINT	Arkady Frekhtman	pdf
2	04/26/2023	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE		Arkady Frekhtman
3	04/26/2023	STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING		Arkady Frekhtman
4	06/19/2023	ANSWER		David H Sculnick	pdf
5	06/19/2023	DEMAND FOR BILL OF PARTICULARS		David H Sculnick
6	06/19/2023	NOTICE OF DISCOVERY AND INSPECTION		David H Sculnick
7	06/19/2023	NOTICE OF DISCOVERY AND INSPECTION		David H Sculnick
8	07/14/2023	PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE REQUEST		Arkady Frekhtman
9	07/14/2023	RJI -RE: REQUEST FOR PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE		Arkady Frekhtman
10	07/14/2023	ADDENDUM - GENERAL (840A)		Arkady Frekhtman
11	08/16/2023	ORDER - PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE		Louisa Ammirati
12	11/14/2023	BILL OF PARTICULARS	Verified Bill of Particulars	Arkady Frekhtman
13	11/14/2023	BILL OF PARTICULARS	Amended Bill of Particulars	Arkady Frekhtman
14	11/16/2023	ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE		Kathleen Batyr
15	04/11/2024	DEMAND FOR:	Demand for Authorizations 4.09.24	Janae Newmark
16	11/18/2024	DEMAND FOR:	Demand for Authorizations	Jennifer Ann Levine
17	11/18/2024	PROOF OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service	Jennifer Ann Levine
18	03/07/2025	STIPULATION - DISCOVERY		Jennifer Ann Levine
19	04/11/2025	RESPONSE TO DEMAND	Response to Demand for Production of Insurance Coverage Information	Jennifer Ann Levine
20	09/11/2025	STIPULATION - SO ORDERED		Kathleen Batyr
21	10/10/2025	DEMAND FOR:	Demand for Authorizations	Jennifer Ann Levine
22	04/03/2026	STIPULATION - SO ORDERED		Meriam J Marica

Suffolk Supreme Court

2023

616367/2023

Active

Negligence

Morales, Rosita

Alonso Krangle LLP

Optima Care Smithtown, LLC d/b/a Brookside Multicare Nursing Center

SHEELEY, LLP

04/23/2026

CCP-Justice,

▼

Case Info

Court

Suffolk Supreme Court

Index Number

616367/2023

Status

Active

Year Filed

2023

Case Name

Morales, Rosita vs. Optima Care Smithtown, LLC d/b/a Brookside Multicare Nursing Center

Case Type

Tort-Other Negligence

Track

Standard

RJI Filed

09/28/2023

NOI Due

09/27/2024

NOI Filed

07/22/2025

Calendar Number

202500920OT

Jury Status

Jury At Plaintiff's Request

Justice

CCP-Justice,

Next Appearance

04/23/2026

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

Morales, Rosita

Attorney / FirmAlonso Krangle LLP

Defendant / Respondent

Optima Care Smithtown, LLC d/b/a Brookside Multicare Nursing Center

Attorneys / FirmsSHEELEY, LLP

Motions

No motions recorded for this case.

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints (18)

Doc #	Date Filed	Document	Description	Filing User	File
1	07/05/2023	SUMMONS + COMPLAINT		David Bruce Krangle	pdf
2	07/20/2023	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE		David Bruce Krangle
3	07/20/2023	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE		David Bruce Krangle
4	08/21/2023	ANSWER	Verified Answer	Eleanor Bliss Ferry	pdf
5	08/21/2023	DEMAND FOR BILL OF PARTICULARS	Demand for Bill of Particulars	Eleanor Bliss Ferry
6	08/21/2023	DEMAND FOR:	Combined Demands	Eleanor Bliss Ferry
7	08/21/2023	DEMAND FOR:	Notice of Discovery and Inspection for Social Media	Eleanor Bliss Ferry
8	09/21/2023	PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE REQUEST		David Bruce Krangle
9	09/21/2023	RJI -RE: REQUEST FOR PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE		David Bruce Krangle
10	09/21/2023	ADDENDUM - GENERAL (840A)		David Bruce Krangle
11	11/13/2023	COURT NOTICE		Patricia Leonard
12	11/16/2023	PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE ORDER (PROPOSED)		David Bruce Krangle
13	11/20/2023	ORDER - PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE		Erin C Fulciniti
14	04/23/2024	COURT NOTICE		Donna Bodenmiller
15	05/07/2025	ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE	NOI - O/O/B 6/11/2025 With side Stipulation	Christine Randazzo
16	06/18/2025	ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE	AMENDED - NOI - O/O/B 7/23/2025	Christine Randazzo
17	07/22/2025	NOTE OF ISSUE:WITH JURY		David Bruce Krangle	pdf
18	12/10/2025	NOTIFICATION FROM COURT	PRE-TRIAL RESERVE CONFERENCE	Susan Engler

Suffolk Supreme Court

2023

205553/2022

Disposed

Negligence

RUTH KRAUT, as Proposed Administratrix of the Estate of ROBERT KRAUT, Deceased

Krentsel & Guzman, LLP

OPTlMA CARE SMITHTOWN, LLC D/B/A BROOKSIDE MULTICARE NURSING CENTER

Wilson Elser Moskowitz Edelman & Dicker LLP

03/02/2023

Nolan, Hon. George M.

▼

Case Info

Court

Suffolk Supreme Court

Index Number

205553/2022

Status

Disposed

Year Filed

2023

Case Name

RUTH KRAUT, as Proposed Administratrix of the Estate of ROBERT KRAUT, Deceased vs. OPTlMA CARE SMITHTOWN, LLC D/B/A BROOKSIDE MULTICARE NURSING CENTER

Case Type

Tort-Other Negligence

Track

Standard

RJI Filed

02/01/2023

NOI Due

02/01/2024

NOI Filed

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

Nolan, Hon. George M.

Next Appearance

03/02/2023

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

RUTH KRAUT, as Proposed Administratrix of the Estate of ROBERT KRAUT, Deceased

Attorney / FirmKrentsel & Guzman, LLP

Defendant / Respondent

OPTlMA CARE SMITHTOWN, LLC D/B/A BROOKSIDE MULTICARE NURSING CENTER

Attorneys / FirmsWilson Elser Moskowitz Edelman & Dicker LLP

Motions (1)

#	Date Filed	Filed By	Relief Sought	Submit Date	Answer	Status	Decision	Order Signed
1	02/03/2023		Dismiss	03/02/2023	No	Decided: 09/28/2023 Granted Before Justice: Nolan, Hon. George M.	Short Form Order	09/28/2023

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints (23)

Doc #	Date Filed	Document	Description	Motion #	Filing User	File
1	11/09/2022	SUMMONS + COMPLAINT			Jonathan Joseph Panarella	pdf
2	11/09/2022	STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING			Jonathan Joseph Panarella
3	11/17/2022	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	OPTIMA CARE SMITHTOWN, LLC / AFFIDAVIT		Jonathan Joseph Panarella
4	11/17/2022	STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING			Jonathan Joseph Panarella
5	11/30/2022	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service on Optima Care Smithtown, LLC		Jonathan Joseph Panarella
6	12/20/2022	STIPULATION - TIME TO ANSWER			Lori Rosen Semlies	pdf
7	01/19/2023	DEMAND FOR:	Notice Requesting Coordination		Jonathan Joseph Panarella
8	01/19/2023	STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING			Jonathan Joseph Panarella
9	01/19/2023	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE			Jonathan Joseph Panarella
10	02/01/2023	NOTICE OF MOTION		001	Kathryn Mary Lang	pdf
11	02/01/2023	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION		001	Kathryn Mary Lang
12	02/01/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Summons and Complaint	001	Kathryn Mary Lang
13	02/01/2023	RJI -RE: NOTICE OF MOTION		001	Kathryn Mary Lang	pdf
14	02/01/2023	ADDENDUM - GENERAL (840A)		001	Kathryn Mary Lang
15	02/01/2023	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION		001	Jonathan Joseph Panarella
16	02/01/2023	CERTIFICATION OF SIGNATURE ( ATTORNEY OR PARTY )	Certificate of Compliance for Affirmation in Opposition	001	Jonathan Joseph Panarella
17	02/01/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Final Order of Coordination	001	Jonathan Joseph Panarella
18	02/01/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Notice Requesting Coordination	001	Jonathan Joseph Panarella
19	02/01/2023	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE		001	Jonathan Joseph Panarella
20	02/08/2023	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE			Lori Rosen Semlies
21	02/27/2023	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN REPLY		001	Kathryn Mary Lang
22	09/29/2023	ORDER - MOTION- SHORT FORM		001	Evan M Kandel
23	09/29/2023	NOTICE OF ENTRY		001	Lori Rosen Semlies

Suffolk Supreme Court

2022

617414/2022

Active

Medical Malpractice

Winterfield, Lisa

Sacco & Fillas, LLP

BROOKSIDE MULTICARE NURSING CENTER et al

Wilson Elser Moskowitz Edelman & Dicker LLP

05/26/2026

Gajdos Jr., Hon. Michael A.

▼

Case Info

Court

Suffolk Supreme Court

Index Number

617414/2022

Status

Active

Year Filed

2022

Case Name

Winterfield, Lisa vs. BROOKSIDE MULTICARE NURSING CENTER et al

Case Type

Tort-Medical, Dental, or Podiatric Malpractice

Track

Complex

RJI Filed

12/07/2022

NOI Due

03/09/2024

NOI Filed

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

Gajdos Jr., Hon. Michael A.

Next Appearance

05/26/2026

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

Winterfield, Lisa

Attorney / FirmSacco & Fillas, LLP

Defendant / Respondent

BROOKSIDE MULTICARE NURSING CENTER et al

Attorneys / FirmsWilson Elser Moskowitz Edelman & Dicker LLP

Motions (1)

#	Date Filed	Filed By	Relief Sought	Submit Date	Answer	Status	Decision	Order Signed
1	01/08/2024		Amend Caption/Pleadings	02/08/2024	No	Decided: 02/14/2024 Granted Before Justice: Santorelli, Hon. Joseph A.	Short Form Order	02/14/2024

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints (73)

Doc #	Date Filed	Document	Description	Motion #	Filing User	File
1	08/31/2022	SUMMONS + COMPLAINT			Elliot Lon Lewis	pdf
2	08/31/2022	STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING			Elliot Lon Lewis
3	09/13/2022	PROOF OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service On Defendant Brookside Multicare Nursing Center		Elliot Lon Lewis
4	09/13/2022	STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING			Elliot Lon Lewis
5	09/22/2022	PROOF OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service On Defendant Good Samaritan Hospital Medical Center		Elliot Lon Lewis
6	09/23/2022	ANSWER	Verified Answer, Demand for Verified Bill of Particulars and Various Other Discovery Demands obo Good Samaritan Hospital Medical Center		Jordan Scott Palatiello	pdf
7	10/05/2022	ANSWER			Lori Rosen Semlies	pdf
8	10/05/2022	DEMAND FOR BILL OF PARTICULARS	with various combined demands		Lori Rosen Semlies
9	11/16/2022	NOTICE OF MEDICAL MALPRACTICE			Elliot Lon Lewis
10	11/16/2022	PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE REQUEST			Elliot Lon Lewis
11	11/16/2022	RJI -RE: REQUEST FOR PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE			Elliot Lon Lewis
12	12/19/2022	DEMAND FOR:	Demand for Authorizations		Jordan Scott Palatiello
13	12/19/2022	DEMAND FOR:	Demand for Arons Authorizations		Jordan Scott Palatiello
14	12/19/2022	DEMAND FOR:	Demand for Arons Authorization		Jordan Scott Palatiello
15	12/23/2022	RESPONSE TO DEMAND	PLAINTIFFS RESPONSE TO DEFENDANTS DEMANDS FOR AUTHORIZATIONS dated December 5, 2022, and December 6, 2022		Elliot Lon Lewis
16	01/06/2023	COURT NOTICE			Patricia Leonard
17	01/19/2023	COURT NOTICE			Patricia Leonard
18	02/06/2023	COURT NOTICE			Patricia Leonard
19	03/24/2023	RESPONSE TO DEMAND	Response to Plaintiffs' First Notice for Discovery and Inspection		Jordan Scott Palatiello
20	03/24/2023	RESPONSE TO DEMAND	Response to Plaintiffs' Demand for Medical Records		Jordan Scott Palatiello
21	03/24/2023	RESPONSE TO DEMAND	Response to Plaintiff's Demand for Meta Data and Audit Tracking Data of the Defendant's Electronic Records System		Jordan Scott Palatiello
22	03/24/2023	RESPONSE TO DEMAND	Response to Plaintiff's Demand for Electronic Stored Records		Jordan Scott Palatiello
23	03/24/2023	RESPONSE TO DEMAND	Response to Plts Dmd for Document Retention Policy		Jordan Scott Palatiello
24	03/24/2023	RESPONSE TO DEMAND	Response to Plts Demand for Radiology Studies		Jordan Scott Palatiello
25	03/24/2023	RESPONSE TO DEMAND	Response to Plaintiffs' Demand for Insurance Agreements		Jordan Scott Palatiello
26	03/24/2023	RESPONSE TO DEMAND	Response to Plaintiffs' Demand for Incident Reports		Jordan Scott Palatiello
27	03/24/2023	RESPONSE TO DEMAND	Response to Plaintiffs' Demand for Statements		Jordan Scott Palatiello
28	03/24/2023	RESPONSE TO DEMAND	Response to Plaintiffs' Demand for Witnesses		Jordan Scott Palatiello
29	03/28/2023	DEMAND FOR:	Demand for Authorizations		Jordan Scott Palatiello
30	04/04/2023	COURT NOTICE			Patricia Leonard
31	05/01/2023	COURT NOTICE			Patricia Leonard
32	05/22/2023	ORDER - PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE			Emily Faux
33	11/13/2023	COURT NOTICE			Donna Bodenmiller
34	12/14/2023	DEMAND FOR:	Demand for Authorizations		Christine M. Cawley
35	12/28/2023	NOTICE OF MOTION		001	Elliot Lon Lewis	pdf
36	12/28/2023	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION		001	Elliot Lon Lewis
37	12/28/2023	AFFIRMATION		001	Elliot Lon Lewis
38	12/28/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Plaintiffs' Original Summons and Verified Complaint	001	Elliot Lon Lewis
39	12/28/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Affidavits of Service	001	Elliot Lon Lewis
40	12/28/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Defendant - BROOKSIDE MULTICARE NURSING CENTER's - Answer	001	Elliot Lon Lewis
41	12/28/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Defendant - GOOD SAMARITAN HOSPITAL MEDICAL CENTER's - Answer	001	Elliot Lon Lewis
42	12/28/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Plaintiffs Pre-Action Discovery Petition	001	Elliot Lon Lewis
43	12/28/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Plaintiffs' Proposed First Amended Verified Complaint and Certificate of Merit	001	Elliot Lon Lewis
44	01/23/2024	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION	Affirmation in Opposition	001	Jordan Scott Palatiello
45	01/23/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Exh A - Summons and Complaint	001	Jordan Scott Palatiello
46	01/23/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Exh B - Verified Answer obo Good Samaritan Hospital Medical Center	001	Jordan Scott Palatiello
47	01/23/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Exh C - 11.17.22 correspondence to plaintiff	001	Jordan Scott Palatiello
48	01/25/2024	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN REPLY	Reply Affirmation	001	Elliot Lon Lewis
49	01/25/2024	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE		001	Elliot Lon Lewis
50	01/25/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	May 31, 2023, defendant letter	001	Elliot Lon Lewis
51	01/30/2024	SUR-REPLY	Sur-Reply	001	Jordan Scott Palatiello
52	01/30/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Exh A - 11.28.22 email	001	Jordan Scott Palatiello
53	01/30/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Exh B - NYSCEF service address for plaintiff	001	Jordan Scott Palatiello
54	02/01/2024	DEMAND FOR:	Demand for Execution Page- Plaintiff		Christine M. Cawley
55	02/08/2024	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE	Ltr to Judge Santorelli regarding re-filing of Aff in Opp	001	Robert J Cristiano
56	02/08/2024	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION		001	Robert J Cristiano
57	02/08/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit A - Order to Show Cause	001	Robert J Cristiano
58	02/08/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit B - Correspondence Withdrawing Order to Show Cause.	001	Robert J Cristiano
59	02/08/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit C - Summons & Complaint	001	Robert J Cristiano
60	02/08/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit D - Answer	001	Robert J Cristiano
61	02/15/2024	ORDER - AMENDING CAPTION		001	Lizette Shapiro
62	02/15/2024	NOTICE OF ENTRY		001	Elliot Lon Lewis
63	03/05/2024	ANSWER	Verified Answer to First Amended Complaint obo Good Sam		Jordan Scott Palatiello	pdf
64	04/03/2024	RESPONSE TO DEMAND	Letter to Defense Counsels Designating Witnesses for Deposition		Elliot Lon Lewis
65	04/03/2024	STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING			Elliot Lon Lewis
66	04/11/2024	ANSWER (AMENDED)			Robert J Cristiano	pdf
67	05/23/2024	NOTICE OF DISCOVERY AND INSPECTION	Post Deposition Notice of Discovery and Inspection		Jordan Scott Palatiello
68	05/30/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Notice of Commencement of Action Pursuant to CPLR 306-C		John P Margand
69	05/30/2024	STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING			John P Margand
70	08/26/2025	DEMAND FOR:	Demand for Insurance Information-Brookside Multicare Nursing Center		Jordan Scott Palatiello
71	04/08/2026	NOTICE TO TAKE DEPOSITION	Notice to Take Deposition Dr. Joseph George Chandrankunnel		John P Margand
72	04/08/2026	STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING			John P Margand
73	04/13/2026	NOTICE OF DEPOSITION	Letter to defendants re EBTs		Jeffrey T. Hellerman

Suffolk Supreme Court

2022

613311/2022

Disposed

Negligence

KAZAN, EILEEN

DUFFY & DUFFY, PLLC

OPTIMA CARE SMITHTOWN, LLC d/b/a BROOKSIDE MULTICARE NURSING CENTER

KERLEY, WALSH, MATERA & CINQUEMANI PC

08/06/2024

Kevins, Hon. Linda J.

▼

Case Info

Court

Suffolk Supreme Court

Index Number

613311/2022

Status

Disposed

Year Filed

2022

Case Name

KAZAN, EILEEN vs. OPTIMA CARE SMITHTOWN, LLC d/b/a BROOKSIDE MULTICARE NURSING CENTER

Case Type

Tort-Other Negligence

Track

Standard

RJI Filed

11/18/2022

NOI Due

11/15/2023

NOI Filed

11/09/2023

Calendar Number

202301728OT

Jury Status

Jury At Plaintiff's Request

Justice

Kevins, Hon. Linda J.

Next Appearance

08/06/2024

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

KAZAN, EILEEN

Attorney / FirmDUFFY & DUFFY, PLLC

Defendant / Respondent

OPTIMA CARE SMITHTOWN, LLC d/b/a BROOKSIDE MULTICARE NURSING CENTER

Attorneys / FirmsKERLEY, WALSH, MATERA & CINQUEMANI PC

Motions (1)

#	Date Filed	Filed By	Relief Sought	Submit Date	Answer	Status	Decision	Order Signed
1	03/07/2024		Judgment - Summary	08/05/2024	No	Decided: 08/05/2024 Closed Before Justice: Kevins, Hon. Linda J.	Oral

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints (56)

Doc #	Date Filed	Document	Description	Motion #	Filing User	File
1	07/13/2022	SUMMONS + COMPLAINT	SUMMONS AND COMPLAINT W/VERIFICATION PAGE		Damien Smith	pdf
2	08/02/2022	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	OPTIMA CARE SMITHTOWN, LLC		Damien Smith
3	08/02/2022	STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING			Damien Smith
4	08/09/2022	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	OPTIMA CARE SMITHTOWN, LLC		Damien Smith
5	08/09/2022	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	BROOKSIDE MULTICARE NURSING CENTER		Damien Smith
6	08/09/2022	STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING			Damien Smith
7	09/16/2022	STIPULATION - TIME TO ANSWER			Michael Richard Janes	pdf
8	09/16/2022	STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING			Michael Richard Janes
9	10/07/2022	ANSWER			Michael Richard Janes	pdf
10	10/07/2022	DEMAND FOR BILL OF PARTICULARS			Michael Richard Janes
11	10/07/2022	NOTICE OF DEPOSITION			Michael Richard Janes
12	10/07/2022	DEMAND FOR:			Michael Richard Janes
13	10/10/2022	DEMAND FOR:	LITIGATION HOLD NOTICE		Damien Smith
14	10/10/2022	DEMAND FOR:	PLAINTIFF'S COMBINED DEMANDS		Damien Smith
15	10/10/2022	NOTICE OF DISCOVERY AND INSPECTION	NOTICE FOR D&I EMR		Damien Smith
16	10/10/2022	DEMAND FOR BILL OF PARTICULARS	DEMAND FOR BP AS TO AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSES		Damien Smith
17	10/10/2022	RESPONSE TO DEMAND	RESPONSE TO RUBIN PATERNITI ET.AL COMBINED DEMANDS		Damien Smith
18	10/10/2022	DEMAND FOR:	DEMAND FOR PHOTOGRAPHS		Damien Smith
19	10/10/2022	PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE REQUEST			Damien Smith
20	10/10/2022	PROOF OF SERVICE			Damien Smith
21	10/10/2022	RJI -RE: REQUEST FOR PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE			Damien Smith
22	10/10/2022	ADDENDUM - GENERAL (840A)			Damien Smith
23	11/02/2022	PROOF OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service - Notice of Commencement		Damien Smith
24	11/02/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Notice of Commencement/Summons and Complaint and Affidavit of Service		Damien Smith
25	12/19/2022	COURT NOTICE			Patricia Leonard
26	12/27/2022	BILL OF PARTICULARS			Damien Smith
27	12/27/2022	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE			Damien Smith
28	12/27/2022	PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE ORDER (PROPOSED)			Damien Smith
29	01/03/2023	ORDER - PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE			Emily Faux
30	03/23/2023	CONSENT TO CHANGE ATTORNEY (POST RJI)			Michael Richard Janes
31	03/23/2023	STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING			Michael Richard Janes
32	05/04/2023	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE			Michael Richard Janes
33	08/09/2023	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE			Michael Richard Janes
34	10/30/2023	ORDER ( PROPOSED )	Certification Order		Damien Smith
35	11/01/2023	ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE			Darlene M Curaba
36	11/09/2023	NOTE OF ISSUE:WITH JURY	NOTE OF ISSUE		Damien Smith	pdf
37	12/12/2023	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE			Michael Richard Janes
38	03/07/2024	NOTICE OF MOTION	Notice of Motion	001	Joy Woda Schneider	pdf
39	03/07/2024	ORDER ( PROPOSED )	Proposed Order	001	Joy Woda Schneider
40	03/07/2024	STATEMENT OF MATERIAL FACTS	Defendats' Statement of Undisputed Material Facts	001	Joy Woda Schneider	pdf
41	03/07/2024	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT	Affirmation in Support	001	Joy Woda Schneider
42	03/07/2024	MEMORANDUM OF LAW	Memo of Law	001	Joy Woda Schneider
43	03/07/2024	CERTIFICATION OF SIGNATURE ( ATTORNEY OR PARTY )	Certification Pursuant to Uniform Rule 202.8-b	001	Joy Woda Schneider
44	03/07/2024	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service	001	Joy Woda Schneider
45	03/07/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Expert Affirmation of Dr. Lawrence Diamond	001	Joy Woda Schneider
46	03/07/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	EBT of Plaintiff-Eileen Kazan	001	Joy Woda Schneider
47	03/07/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Correspondence for executed transcript of Eileen Kazan	001	Joy Woda Schneider
48	03/07/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	NPW EBT of RN Ricciardo on behalf of Defendant-Brookside	001	Joy Woda Schneider
49	03/07/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Defendant Brookside Chart-REDACTED	001	Joy Woda Schneider
50	03/07/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Stony Brook University Hospital Chart-Part 1-REDACTED	001	Joy Woda Schneider
51	03/07/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Stony Brook University Hospital Chart-Part 2-REDACTED	001	Joy Woda Schneider
52	03/07/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Death Certificate-REDACTED	001	Joy Woda Schneider
53	03/07/2024	STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING	Statement of Authorization for Electronic Filing-KWMC	001	Joy Woda Schneider
54	03/21/2024	STIPULATION - ADJOURNMENT OF MOTION		001	Damien Smith
55	06/04/2024	STIPULATION - ADJOURNMENT OF MOTION		001	Damien Smith
56	08/05/2024	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE	Letter to advise of settlement		Damien Smith

Suffolk Supreme Court

2022

608621/2022

Active

Negligence

MELGARDEPORTAN, LUCILA

ALAN RIPKA & ASSOCIATES, LLP

BROOKSIDE MULTICARE NURSING CENTER et al

Lewis Johs Avallone Aviles, LLP

05/21/2026

Nolan, Hon. George M.

▼

Case Info

Court

Suffolk Supreme Court

Index Number

608621/2022

Status

Active

Year Filed

2022

Case Name

MELGARDEPORTAN, LUCILA vs. BROOKSIDE MULTICARE NURSING CENTER et al

Case Type

Tort-Other Negligence

Track

Standard

RJI Filed

09/02/2022

NOI Due

09/02/2023

NOI Filed

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

Nolan, Hon. George M.

Next Appearance

05/21/2026

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

MELGARDEPORTAN, LUCILA

Attorney / FirmALAN RIPKA & ASSOCIATES, LLP

Defendant / Respondent

BROOKSIDE MULTICARE NURSING CENTER et al

Attorneys / FirmsLewis Johs Avallone Aviles, LLP

Motions (2)

#	Date Filed	Filed By	Relief Sought	Submit Date	Answer	Status	Decision	Order Signed
2	04/22/2026		Dismiss		No	Before Justice: Nolan, Hon. George M.
1	06/06/2025		Injunction/Restraining Order	06/26/2025	No	Decided: 08/14/2025 Granted Before Justice: Nolan, Hon. George M.	Short Form Order	08/14/2025

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints (52)

Doc #	Date Filed	Document	Description	Motion #	Filing User	File
1	05/04/2022	SUMMONS + COMPLAINT			Andrey Demidov	pdf
2	05/13/2022	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Affiavit of Service - Brookside Multicare Nursing Center		Andrey Demidov
3	05/13/2022	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service - Avalon Gardens Rehabilitation & Health Care Center, LLC d/b/a Brookside Multicare Nursing Center (Secretary of State)		Andrey Demidov
4	05/25/2022	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service - Avalon Gardens Rehabilitation & Health CareCenter, LLC d/b/a Brookside Multicare Nursing Center		Andrey Demidov
5	06/09/2022	STIPULATION - TIME TO ANSWER	Stipulation Extending Time to Serve Answers to Complaint		Kenneth Steven Oliver	pdf
6	06/13/2022	STIPULATION - TIME TO ANSWER	Avalon Gardens Stip to Extend Time to Answer		Greg Michael Mondelli	pdf
7	07/08/2022	ANSWER	Verified Answer		Kenneth Steven Oliver	pdf
8	07/08/2022	DEMAND FOR BILL OF PARTICULARS	Demand for BP		Kenneth Steven Oliver
9	07/08/2022	NOTICE OF DEPOSITION/SUBPOENA	Notice of Deposition		Kenneth Steven Oliver
10	07/11/2022	ANSWER	Avalon Gardens Rehabilitation & Health Care Center, LLC Verified Answer, Demand for BP, Notice of EBT and various discovery demands		Greg Michael Mondelli	pdf
11	07/12/2022	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service		Kenneth Steven Oliver
12	07/12/2022	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service		Kenneth Steven Oliver
13	07/12/2022	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service		Kenneth Steven Oliver
14	07/22/2022	NOTICE TO ADMIT			Andrey Demidov
15	08/15/2022	RESPONSE TO DEMAND	Response to Notice to Admit		Kenneth Steven Oliver
16	08/16/2022	DEMAND FOR:	Combined Demands on behalf of Optima Care Smithtown, LLC d/b/a Brookside Multicare Nursing Center		Jill W Laurence
17	08/16/2022	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service of Combined Demands		Jill W Laurence
18	08/17/2022	STIPULATION - DISCONTINUANCE (PRE RJI)	Stipulation of Discontinuance-Avalon Gardens only		Greg Michael Mondelli	pdf
19	08/18/2022	PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE REQUEST			Andrey Demidov
20	08/18/2022	RJI -RE: REQUEST FOR PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE			Andrey Demidov
21	08/18/2022	ADDENDUM - GENERAL (840A)			Andrey Demidov
22	08/22/2022	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service of Response to Notice to Admit		Kenneth Steven Oliver
23	10/21/2022	COURT NOTICE			Patricia Leonard
24	10/31/2022	COURT NOTICE			Patricia Leonard
25	11/22/2022	STIPULATION - OTHER	Stipulation Extending Time to Conduct Preliminary Conference		Alan Seth Ripka
26	11/22/2022	COURT NOTICE			Patricia Leonard
27	01/20/2023	DEMAND FOR:	Plaintiff's Combined Demands to Optima Care Smithtown LLC d/b/a Brookside Multicare Nursing Center		Alan Seth Ripka
28	01/23/2023	ANSWER (AMENDED)	Verified Amended Answer for Optima Care Smithtown LLC d/b/a Brookside		Kenneth Steven Oliver	pdf
29	01/27/2023	COURT NOTICE			Patricia Leonard
30	01/30/2023	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service of Amended Verified Answer		Kenneth Steven Oliver
31	02/06/2023	RESPONSE TO DEMAND	Response to Combined Demands		Christiana Mary Fraser
32	02/06/2023	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service		Christiana Mary Fraser
33	02/06/2023	RESPONSE TO DEMAND	Response to Demand for Bill of Particulars		Christiana Mary Fraser
34	02/06/2023	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service		Christiana Mary Fraser
35	03/03/2023	ORDER ( PROPOSED )			Alan Seth Ripka
36	03/06/2023	ORDER - PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE			Erin C Fulciniti
37	02/02/2024	NOTICE OF APPEARANCE (POST RJI)			Sarah Jane Green
38	06/06/2025	ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE ( PROPOSED )			Solomon Lawrence Kushner	pdf
39	06/06/2025	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT	Affirmation In Support		Solomon Lawrence Kushner
40	06/06/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Summons And Complaint		Solomon Lawrence Kushner
41	06/06/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Verified Answer		Solomon Lawrence Kushner
42	06/06/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Stipulation		Solomon Lawrence Kushner
43	06/06/2025	AFFIRMATION	Affirmation of Compliance with UCR 202.7(f)		Solomon Lawrence Kushner
44	06/06/2025	ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE-SIGNED		001	Anita Massey	pdf
45	06/10/2025	ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE - CONFORMED COPY	Order to Show Cause with Supporting Docs		Kenneth Steven Oliver	pdf
46	06/10/2025	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service		Kenneth Steven Oliver
47	08/19/2025	ORDER - DISCHARGE ATTORNEY	DISCHARGES DORF, NELSON & ZAUDERER LLP.	001	Evan M Kandel
48	08/26/2025	NOTICE OF ENTRY	Order with Notice of Entry		Kenneth Steven Oliver
49	08/26/2025	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service		Kenneth Steven Oliver
50	09/15/2025	NOTICE OF APPEARANCE (POST RJI)			Andrew Thomas Sheeley
51	04/22/2026	NOTICE OF MOTION	Defendant's Notice of Motion-Motion to Dismiss 04.22.26	002	Mairead Claire Maguire
52	04/22/2026	AFFIRMATION	Defendant's Affirmation in Support 04.22.26	002	Mairead Claire Maguire

Suffolk Supreme Court

2022

605674/2022

Active

Tort

THERESA HERNANDEZ, AS PROPOSED ADMINISTRATOR OF ESTATE OF FREDERICK L. OSONITSCH

GEORGAKLIS & MALLAS PLLC

OPTIMA CARE SMITHTOWN LLC d/b/a BROOKSIDE MULTICARE NURSING CENTER

Wilson Elser Moskowitz Edelman & Dicker LLP

05/07/2026

McGreevy, Hon. Peter R.

▼

Case Info

Court

Suffolk Supreme Court

Index Number

605674/2022

Status

Active

Year Filed

2022

Case Name

THERESA HERNANDEZ, AS PROPOSED ADMINISTRATOR OF ESTATE OF FREDERICK L. OSONITSCH vs. OPTIMA CARE SMITHTOWN LLC d/b/a BROOKSIDE MULTICARE NURSING CENTER

Case Type

Tort-Other

Track

Standard

RJI Filed

07/15/2022

NOI Due

07/15/2023

NOI Filed

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

McGreevy, Hon. Peter R.

Next Appearance

05/07/2026

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

THERESA HERNANDEZ, AS PROPOSED ADMINISTRATOR OF ESTATE OF FREDERICK L. OSONITSCH

Attorney / FirmGEORGAKLIS & MALLAS PLLC

Defendant / Respondent

OPTIMA CARE SMITHTOWN LLC d/b/a BROOKSIDE MULTICARE NURSING CENTER

Attorneys / FirmsWilson Elser Moskowitz Edelman & Dicker LLP

Motions (2)

#	Date Filed	Filed By	Relief Sought	Submit Date	Answer	Status	Decision	Order Signed
2	01/09/2023		Amend Caption/Pleadings	01/12/2023	No	Decided: 04/06/2023 Granted Before Justice: Baisley, Hon. Paul J.	Short Form Order	04/06/2023
1	07/15/2022		Dismiss	01/12/2023	No	Decided: 04/06/2023 Denied Before Justice: Baisley, Hon. Paul J.	Short Form Order	04/06/2023

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints (33)

Doc #	Date Filed	Document	Description	Motion #	Filing User	File
1	03/28/2022	SUMMONS	Summons		Kostantinos Mallas	pdf
2	03/28/2022	COMPLAINT	Complaint		Kostantinos Mallas	pdf
3	04/11/2022	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	AOS- Brookside Multicare Nursing Center		Kostantinos Mallas
4	07/15/2022	NOTICE OF MOTION		001	Joseph Matthew Caldarera	pdf
5	07/15/2022	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT		001	Joseph Matthew Caldarera
6	07/15/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Summons & Complaint dated 3-28-22	001	Joseph Matthew Caldarera
7	07/15/2022	RJI -RE: NOTICE OF MOTION		001	Joseph Matthew Caldarera	pdf
8	08/17/2022	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE	Correspondence to Judge requesting adjournment of motion	001	Kostantinos Mallas
9	09/26/2022	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE	Correspondence to Judge requesting adjournment of motion	001	Kostantinos Mallas
10	10/24/2022	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE	Correspondence to Judge	001	Kostantinos Mallas
11	11/30/2022	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE	Correspondence to Judge requesting adjournment of motion	001	Kostantinos Mallas
12	01/05/2023	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION	Affirmation in Opposition	001	Kostantinos Mallas
13	01/05/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Limited Letters of Administration	001	Kostantinos Mallas
14	01/05/2023	NOTICE OF CROSS-MOTION	Notice of Cross Motion to Amend	002	Kostantinos Mallas
15	01/05/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Summons and Complaint	002	Kostantinos Mallas
16	01/05/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Limited Letters of Administration	002	Kostantinos Mallas
17	01/05/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Supplemental Summons and Amended Verified Complaint	002	Kostantinos Mallas
18	01/09/2023	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT	Affirmation of Support	002	Kostantinos Mallas
19	04/07/2023	DECISION + ORDER ON MOTION	and Motion 002	001	Susan Engler	pdf
20	04/26/2023	STIPULATION - TIME TO ANSWER			Stephen Peter Bona	pdf
21	05/15/2023	ANSWER	Answer to Amended Complaint		Katherine L Mccrink	pdf
22	06/08/2023	PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE ORDER (PROPOSED)	Proposed PC Order		Kostantinos Mallas
23	06/13/2023	ORDER - PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE			Susan Engler
24	11/15/2023	BILL OF PARTICULARS	BILL OF PARTICULARS		Kostantinos Mallas
25	11/15/2023	NOTICE OF DEPOSITION	NOTICE OF DEPOSITION		Kostantinos Mallas
26	11/15/2023	DEMAND FOR BILL OF PARTICULARS	DEMAND FOR BILL OF PARTICULARS		Kostantinos Mallas
27	11/15/2023	RESPONSE TO DEMAND	RESPONSE TO COMBINED DEMANDS		Kostantinos Mallas
28	11/15/2023	RESPONSE TO DEMAND	NOTICE OF MEDICAL EXCHANGE		Kostantinos Mallas
29	11/15/2023	DEMAND FOR:	COMBINED DEMANDS		Kostantinos Mallas
30	11/15/2023	RESPONSE TO DEMAND	NOTICE OF AVAILABILITY		Kostantinos Mallas
31	04/02/2025	DEMAND FOR:	Good Faith Letter for BP and Response to Combined Demands		Kostantinos Mallas
32	05/12/2025	RESPONSE TO DEMAND	Supplemental Response to Demand for Insurance		Lori Rosen Semlies
33	02/24/2026	STIPULATION - SO ORDERED			Shannon Stark

Suffolk Supreme Court

2022

600623/2022

Disposed

Medical Malpractice

Lisa Winterfield,

Sacco & Fillas, LLP

Brookside Multicare Nursing Center

03/17/2022

Nolan, Hon. George M.

▼

Case Info

Court

Suffolk Supreme Court

Index Number

600623/2022

Status

Disposed

Year Filed

2022

Case Name

Lisa Winterfield, vs. Brookside Multicare Nursing Center

Case Type

Tort-Medical, Dental, or Podiatric Malpractice

Track

Complex

RJI Filed

01/11/2022

NOI Due

04/14/2023

NOI Filed

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

Nolan, Hon. George M.

Next Appearance

03/17/2022

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

Lisa Winterfield,

Attorney / FirmSacco & Fillas, LLP

Defendant / Respondent

Brookside Multicare Nursing Center

Attorneys / FirmsBrookside Multicare Nursing Center

Motions (1)

#	Date Filed	Filed By	Relief Sought	Submit Date	Answer	Status	Decision	Order Signed
1	01/11/2022		Discovery - Pre-Action	03/17/2022	No	Decided: 05/26/2022 Granted Before Justice: Nolan, Hon. George M.	Short Form Order	05/26/2022

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints (16)

Doc #	Date Filed	Document	Description	Motion #	Filing User	File
1	01/11/2022	PETITION	Notice of Petition		David Ethan Silverman
2	01/11/2022	ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE ( PROPOSED )	Order to Show Cause		David Ethan Silverman	pdf
3	01/11/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Request sent to obtain medical records		David Ethan Silverman
4	01/11/2022	RJI -RE: ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE			David Ethan Silverman	pdf
5	01/18/2022	ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE-SIGNED		001	Victoria Figueroa	pdf
6	01/24/2022	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE			David Ethan Silverman
7	01/24/2022	STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING			David Ethan Silverman
8	01/28/2022	STIPULATION - ADJOURNMENT OF MOTION		001	Robert J Cristiano
9	05/26/2022	DECISION + ORDER ON MOTION		001	Edward Haag	pdf
10	07/21/2022	NOTICE OF ENTRY			Elliot Lon Lewis
11	07/21/2022	STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING			Elliot Lon Lewis
12	01/24/2024	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION		001	Robert J Cristiano
13	01/24/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Order to Show Cause	001	Robert J Cristiano
14	01/24/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Correspondence withdrawing Order to Show Cause	001	Robert J Cristiano
15	01/24/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Summons and Complaint	001	Robert J Cristiano
16	01/24/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Answer	001	Robert J Cristiano

Kings Supreme Court

2022

513831/2021

Disposed

Negligence

KHALID, HAMZA

Sacco & Fillas, LLP

BROOKSIDE MULTICARE NURSING CENTER

Wilson Elser Moskowitz Edelman & Dicker LLP

03/11/2026

Swern, Hon. Anne J.

▼

Case Info

Court

Kings Supreme Court

Index Number

513831/2021

Status

Disposed

Year Filed

2022

Case Name

KHALID, HAMZA vs. BROOKSIDE MULTICARE NURSING CENTER

Case Type

Tort-Other Negligence

Track

Complex

RJI Filed

01/06/2022

NOI Due

12/27/2024

NOI Filed

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

Swern, Hon. Anne J.

Next Appearance

03/11/2026

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

KHALID, HAMZA

Attorney / FirmSacco & Fillas, LLP

Defendant / Respondent

BROOKSIDE MULTICARE NURSING CENTER

Attorneys / FirmsWilson Elser Moskowitz Edelman & Dicker LLP

Motions (3)

#	Date Filed	Filed By	Relief Sought	Submit Date	Answer	Status	Decision	Order Signed
3	02/05/2026	DEFENDANT	Dismiss	03/11/2026	Yes	Decided: 03/11/2026 Denied Before Justice: Gotlieb, Hon. Brian L.	Short Form Order	03/11/2026
2	10/16/2023		Dismiss	11/21/2023	Yes	Decided: 11/21/2023 Granted to the Extent of the Order Before Justice: Ruchelsman, Hon. Leon	Short Form Order	11/21/2023
1	09/06/2022		Attorney - Disqualify/Relieve/Substitute/Withdraw	10/05/2022	No	Decided: 10/05/2022 Granted Before Justice: Velasquez, Hon. Richard	Short Form Order	10/05/2022

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints (47)

Doc #	Date Filed	Document	Description	Motion #	Filing User	File
1	06/09/2021	SUMMONS + COMPLAINT			David Ethan Silverman	pdf
2	06/09/2021	CERTIFICATE OF MERIT			David Ethan Silverman
3	06/21/2021	PROOF OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service for Defendant Brookside Multicare Nursing Center		David Ethan Silverman
4	06/21/2021	STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING			David Ethan Silverman
5	11/08/2021	ANSWER			Lori Rosen Semlies	pdf
6	11/08/2021	DEMAND FOR BILL OF PARTICULARS			Lori Rosen Semlies
7	11/08/2021	DEMAND FOR:	Combined Discovery Demands		Lori Rosen Semlies
8	01/06/2022	NOTICE OF MEDICAL MALPRACTICE	Notice OF Medical Malpractice		David Ethan Silverman
9	01/06/2022	RJI -RE: REQUEST FOR PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE			David Ethan Silverman
10	01/27/2022	NOTICE OF DISCOVERY AND INSPECTION	Plaintiff's Notice for Discovery and Inspection- Adult Care and Nursing Home		David Ethan Silverman
11	02/15/2022	ORDER - PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE			Robert Lynch
12	07/26/2022	ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE ( PROPOSED )			Albert Robert Matuza	pdf
13	07/26/2022	AFFIRMATION	Affirmation in Support		Albert Robert Matuza
14	07/26/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Filed Summons and Complaint		Albert Robert Matuza
15	07/26/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Defendant's Verified Answer		Albert Robert Matuza
16	07/26/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	PCO		Albert Robert Matuza
17	09/06/2022	ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE-SIGNED	SIGNED OSC	1	Daniel Lask	pdf
18	09/12/2022	PROOF OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service re plaintiff Hamza Khalid		Albert Robert Matuza
19	09/12/2022	PROOF OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service re plaintiff Sajida Mehmood		Albert Robert Matuza
20	09/12/2022	PROOF OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service re defense counsel		Albert Robert Matuza
21	09/12/2022	STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING			Albert Robert Matuza
22	10/07/2022	ORDER - OTHER		1	Michelle Shamell
23	10/14/2022	NOTICE OF ENTRY			Albert Robert Matuza
24	10/14/2022	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE			Albert Robert Matuza
25	10/14/2022	STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING			Albert Robert Matuza
26	11/09/2022	ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE	dtd 11/3/22		Timothy Oreilly
27	10/16/2023	NOTICE OF MOTION		2	Olivia Taylor Knott	pdf
28	10/16/2023	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT		2	Olivia Taylor Knott
29	10/16/2023	AFFIRMATION OF GOOD FAITH		2	Olivia Taylor Knott
30	10/16/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Discovery Demands	2	Olivia Taylor Knott
31	10/16/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	S_C	2	Olivia Taylor Knott
32	10/16/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Answer	2	Olivia Taylor Knott
33	10/16/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Notice of Med Mal	2	Olivia Taylor Knott
34	10/16/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	PC Order	2	Olivia Taylor Knott
35	10/16/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Order Staying Case	2	Olivia Taylor Knott
36	10/16/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	CC Order	2	Olivia Taylor Knott
37	10/16/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	GF letters	2	Olivia Taylor Knott
38	10/16/2023	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE		2	Olivia Taylor Knott
39	11/30/2023	DECISION + ORDER ON MOTION		2	Craig Schatzman	pdf
40	12/18/2023	NOTICE OF ENTRY/COPY OF ENTERED ORDER/PROOF OF SERVICE		2	Olivia Taylor Knott
41	12/20/2023	NOTICE OF ENTRY/COPY OF ENTERED ORDER/PROOF OF SERVICE		2	Olivia Taylor Knott
42	02/04/2026	NOTICE OF MOTION		3	Jillian Fallon Oliff	pdf
43	02/04/2026	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT		3	Jillian Fallon Oliff
44	02/04/2026	EXHIBIT(S)	eCourts Appearance Chart	3	Jillian Fallon Oliff
45	02/04/2026	AFFIRMATION OF GOOD FAITH		3	Jillian Fallon Oliff
46	02/04/2026	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	DECLARATION OF SERVICE.	3	Jillian Fallon Oliff
47	03/23/2026	ORDER - OTHER	Dated March 11th, 2026	3	Kaycee Jarrard

Suffolk Supreme Court

2022

619697/2020

Disposed

Tort

Optima Care, LLC, d/b/a Brookside Multicare Nursing Center

SCHWARTZ SLADKUS REICH GREENBERG ATLAS LLP

Sastrowardoyo, Rahajyan

Castiglia Rubinstein & Associates, Attorney at Law

11/16/2023

Suffolk Supreme, DCM-Justice

▼

Case Info

Court

Suffolk Supreme Court

Index Number

619697/2020

Status

Disposed

Year Filed

2022

Case Name

Optima Care, LLC, d/b/a Brookside Multicare Nursing Center vs. Sastrowardoyo, Rahajyan

Case Type

Tort-Other

Track

Standard

RJI Filed

09/30/2022

NOI Due

09/30/2023

NOI Filed

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

Suffolk Supreme, DCM-Justice

Next Appearance

11/16/2023

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

Optima Care, LLC, d/b/a Brookside Multicare Nursing Center

Attorney / FirmSCHWARTZ SLADKUS REICH GREENBERG ATLAS LLP

Defendant / Respondent

Sastrowardoyo, Rahajyan

Attorneys / FirmsCastiglia Rubinstein & Associates, Attorney at Law

Motions (2)

#	Date Filed	Filed By	Relief Sought	Submit Date	Answer	Status	Decision	Order Signed
2	05/23/2023		Discovery	06/06/2023	No	Decided: 08/03/2023 Denied Before Justice: Suffolk Supreme, DCM-Justice	Short Form Order	08/03/2023
1	09/23/2022		Amend Caption/Pleadings	10/20/2022	No	Decided: 01/10/2023 Denied Before Justice: Suffolk Supreme, DCM-Justice	Short Form Order	01/10/2023

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints (43)

Doc #	Date Filed	Document	Description	Motion #	Filing User	File
1	12/17/2020	SUMMONS + COMPLAINT			Lester Edward Ozimkowski	pdf
2	01/06/2021	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE			Lester Edward Ozimkowski
3	05/05/2021	ANSWER			Christine Thea Rubinstein	pdf
4	02/18/2022	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE			Lester Edward Ozimkowski
5	09/23/2022	NOTICE OF APPEARANCE (PRE RJI)			Shanaz Gannie-Ali
6	09/23/2022	NOTICE OF MOTION		001	Shanaz Gannie-Ali	pdf
7	09/23/2022	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION	Affirmation in Support of Motion to Amend Caption	001	Shanaz Gannie-Ali
8	09/23/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit A - Verified Answer and Verification	001	Shanaz Gannie-Ali
9	09/23/2022	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Service of Notice of Motion, Affirmation of Motion and Exhibit on Christine Rubenstein Esq	001	Shanaz Gannie-Ali
10	09/23/2022	STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING		001	Shanaz Gannie-Ali
11	09/23/2022	RJI -RE: NOTICE OF MOTION		001	Shanaz Gannie-Ali	pdf
12	01/12/2023	ORDER - MOTION- SHORT FORM		001	Patricia Leonard
13	01/19/2023	COURT NOTICE			Patricia Leonard
14	01/31/2023	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE	Letter to Clerk		Christine Thea Rubinstein
15	01/31/2023	COURT NOTICE			Patricia Leonard
16	03/21/2023	COURT NOTICE			Patricia Leonard
17	04/04/2023	COURT NOTICE			Patricia Leonard
18	05/15/2023	COURT NOTICE			Patricia Leonard
19	05/23/2023	NOTICE OF MOTION		002	Shanaz Gannie-Ali	pdf
20	05/23/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit A - Summons and Verified Complaint	002	Shanaz Gannie-Ali
21	05/23/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit B- Verified Answer	002	Shanaz Gannie-Ali
22	05/23/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit C - Notice of Motion to Amend Caption	002	Shanaz Gannie-Ali
23	05/23/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit D - Correspondence from Counsel for Defendant	002	Shanaz Gannie-Ali
24	05/23/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit E- Amended Summons and Complaint	002	Shanaz Gannie-Ali
25	05/25/2023	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Affidavit of service for Notice of Motion	002	Shanaz Gannie-Ali
26	06/26/2023	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	AOS for Notice of Motion and supporting documents to Christine Rubenstein Esq	002	Shanaz Gannie-Ali
27	08/04/2023	DECISION + ORDER ON MOTION		002	Patricia Leonard	pdf
28	08/04/2023	COURT NOTICE			Patricia Leonard
29	08/31/2023	COURT NOTICE			Patricia Leonard
30	08/31/2023	STIPULATION - AMENDING CAPTION			Shanaz Gannie-Ali
31	08/31/2023	STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING			Shanaz Gannie-Ali
32	09/18/2023	COURT NOTICE			Rachel Kulesa
33	10/16/2023	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE	Letter to Request Adjournment		Shanaz Gannie-Ali
34	10/16/2023	COURT NOTICE			Rachel Kulesa
35	11/08/2023	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE	Letter Requesting Inquest on Submission		Shanaz Gannie-Ali
36	11/16/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit sheet and proof of pickup 11/16/23 Inquest		Susan Engler
37	12/06/2023	TRANSCRIPT - SO ORDERED	For proceedings held on 11/16/23.		Bernadette V Meuschke
38	12/07/2023	JUDGMENT -TO COUNTY CLERK (PROPOSED)			Andrea Marie Trochez	pdf
39	12/07/2023	STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING			Andrea Marie Trochez
40	12/07/2023	BILL OF COSTS			Andrea Marie Trochez
41	12/07/2023	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE			Andrea Marie Trochez
42	12/07/2023	NOTICE OF ENTRY			Andrea Marie Trochez
43	12/11/2023	JUDGMENT			Laura B Wagner	pdf

Nassau Supreme Court

2021

608881/2021

Disposed

Negligence

PERSICHILLI, ADELE et al

DUFFY & DUFFY, PLLC

OPTIMA CARE SMITHTOWN, LLC d/b/a BROOKSIDE MULTICARE NURSING CENTER

Kaufman Borgeest & Ryan LLP

02/18/2025

▼

Case Info

Court

Nassau Supreme Court

Index Number

608881/2021

Status

Disposed

Year Filed

2021

Case Name

PERSICHILLI, ADELE et al vs. OPTIMA CARE SMITHTOWN, LLC d/b/a BROOKSIDE MULTICARE NURSING CENTER

Case Type

Tort-Other Negligence

Track

Standard

RJI Filed

09/15/2021

NOI Due

12/20/2022

NOI Filed

12/02/2022

Calendar Number

2022H2191

Jury Status

Jury At Plaintiff's Request

Justice

Next Appearance

02/18/2025

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

PERSICHILLI, ADELE et al

Attorney / FirmDUFFY & DUFFY, PLLC

Defendant / Respondent

OPTIMA CARE SMITHTOWN, LLC d/b/a BROOKSIDE MULTICARE NURSING CENTER

Attorneys / FirmsKaufman Borgeest & Ryan LLP

Motions (2)

#	Date Filed	Filed By	Relief Sought	Submit Date	Answer	Status	Decision	Order Signed
2	04/08/2024		Attorney - Disqualify/Relieve/Substitute/Withdraw	05/06/2024	No	Decided: 07/23/2024 Granted Before Justice: Sher, Hon. Denise L.	Short Form Order	07/23/2024
1	02/01/2023		Judgment - Summary	06/21/2023	Yes	Decided: 10/13/2023 Denied Before Justice: Sher, Hon. Denise L.	Short Form Order	10/13/2023

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints (96)

Doc #	Date Filed	Document	Description	Motion #	Filing User	File
1	07/27/2020	SUMMONS + COMPLAINT	SUMMONS AND COMPLAINT AND VERIFICATION PAGE		Damien Smith	pdf
2	08/19/2020	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	OPTIMA CARE SMITHTOWN, LLC		Michael E Duffy
3	08/19/2020	STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING			Michael E Duffy
4	09/18/2020	STIPULATION - TIME TO ANSWER	Stipulation Extending Time to Answer		Michael Richard Janes	pdf
5	10/13/2020	DEMAND FOR:	Demand to Change Venue		Michael Richard Janes
6	10/13/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Admission Agreement		Michael Richard Janes
7	10/13/2020	NOTICE OF DEPOSITION UPON ORAL EXAMINATION	Notice to take Deposition upon Oral Examination		Michael Richard Janes
8	10/13/2020	ANSWER	Verified Answer		Michael Richard Janes	pdf
9	10/13/2020	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service		Michael Richard Janes
10	10/27/2020	STIPULATION - VENUE	Stipulation to transfer venue		Lauren Michele Lundquist
11	10/27/2020	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	OPTIMA CARE SMITHTOWN, LLC		Michael E Duffy
12	10/27/2020	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	BROOKSIDE MULTICARE NURSING CENTER		Michael E Duffy
13	02/10/2021	DEMAND FOR:	LITIGATION HOLD NOTICE		Damien Smith
14	02/10/2021	DEMAND FOR BILL OF PARTICULARS	DEMAND FOR BILL OF PARTICULARS AS TO AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSES		Damien Smith
15	02/16/2021	STIPULATION - VENUE ( REQUEST TO SO ORDER )	Stipulation to change Venue- so order		Lauren Michele Lundquist
16	02/16/2021	RJI FROM PRIOR COUNTY (COPY)	stipulation to transfer venue; Original document type was RJI -RE: OTHER		Lauren Michele Lundquist
17	02/16/2021	ADDENDUM - GENERAL (840A)			Lauren Michele Lundquist
18	02/24/2021	DEMAND FOR:	PLAINTIFF'S COMBINED DEMANDS		Damien Smith
19	02/24/2021	NOTICE OF DISCOVERY AND INSPECTION	NOTICE FOR D&I - EMR RECORDS		Damien Smith
20	05/18/2021	ORDER - TRANSFER - CHANGE OF VENUE	S/O STIP TO TRANSFER VENUE		Joanne E Downs
21	05/19/2021	NOTICE OF ENTRY			Damien Smith
22	05/19/2021	PROOF OF SERVICE	AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE		Damien Smith
23	05/19/2021	NOTICE TO COUNTY CLERK CPLR 8019(C)	NOTICE TO COUNTY CLERK CPLR 8019 (C) & STIPULATION		Damien Smith
24	05/19/2021	STIPULATION - OTHER	SO-ORDER STIPULATION AND ORDER TO CHANGE VENUE		Damien Smith
25	07/15/2021	COURT NOTICE			Theresa L Daniel
26	08/11/2021	PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE REQUEST	PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE REQUEST		Robert J Cristiano
27	08/11/2021	PROOF OF SERVICE	AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE		Robert J Cristiano
28	08/11/2021	RJI -RE: REQUEST FOR PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE			Robert J Cristiano
29	08/11/2021	ADDENDUM - GENERAL (840A)			Robert J Cristiano
30	09/15/2021	COURT NOTICE			Karen Ingoglia
31	09/27/2021	BILL OF PARTICULARS			Damien Smith
32	09/27/2021	DEMAND FOR:	RESPONSE REGARDING LETTER TO DESIGNATE		Damien Smith
33	10/12/2021	PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE ORDER (PROPOSED)			Damien Smith
34	10/18/2021	ORDER - PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE			Arlene A Tiercy
35	10/19/2021	COURT NOTICE	Filing on Behalf of - Hon. Denise L. Sher		Lisa Carlisi
36	12/07/2021	RESPONSE TO DEMAND	RESPONSE TO PC ORDER		Damien Smith
37	01/18/2022	COURT NOTICE	Filing on Behalf of - Hon. Denise L. Sher		Lisa Carlisi
38	03/02/2022	NOTICE OF DISCOVERY AND INSPECTION	NOTICE FOR D&I - INCIDENT REPORTS		Damien Smith
39	04/07/2022	COURT NOTICE	Filing on Behalf of - Hon. Denise L. Sher		Lisa Carlisi
40	05/17/2022	NOTICE OF DEPOSITION UPON ORAL EXAMINATION	Kedma Fermine		Damien Smith
41	05/17/2022	NOTICE OF DEPOSITION UPON ORAL EXAMINATION	Diane Morris		Damien Smith
42	05/17/2022	NOTICE OF DEPOSITION UPON ORAL EXAMINATION	Kedma Fermine		Damien Smith
43	05/17/2022	NOTICE OF DEPOSITION UPON ORAL EXAMINATION	Diane Morris		Damien Smith
44	06/13/2022	COURT NOTICE	Filing on Behalf of - Hon. Denise L. Sher		Lisa Carlisi
45	08/11/2022	COURT NOTICE	Filing on Behalf of - Hon. Denise L. Sher		Lisa Carlisi
46	09/30/2022	ORDER - CERTIFICATION			Bernadette Sarro
47	12/02/2022	NOTE OF ISSUE:WITH JURY	NOTE OF ISSUE		Damien Smith	pdf
48	12/05/2022	COURT NOTICE			Carmine Ambroselli
50	01/31/2023	STATEMENT OF MATERIAL FACTS	STATEMENT OF MATERIAL FACTS	001	Lauren Michele Lundquist	pdf
51	01/31/2023	AFFIRMATION	EXPERT AFFIRMATION OF DR. DIAMOND	001	Lauren Michele Lundquist
52	01/31/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	SUMMONS & COMPLAINT	001	Lauren Michele Lundquist
53	01/31/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	ANSWER	001	Lauren Michele Lundquist
54	01/31/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	BILL OF PARTICULARS	001	Lauren Michele Lundquist
55	01/31/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	BROOKSIDE MULTICARE NURSING HOME RECORDS	001	Lauren Michele Lundquist
56	01/31/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	ACCIDENT/INCIDENT REPORT	001	Lauren Michele Lundquist
57	01/31/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	DEATH CERTIFICATE	001	Lauren Michele Lundquist
58	01/31/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	EBT OF ADELE PERSICHILLI	001	Lauren Michele Lundquist
59	01/31/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	EBT OF KEDMA FERMINE	001	Lauren Michele Lundquist
60	01/31/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	WILLIAMS V RUBY	001	Lauren Michele Lundquist
61	01/31/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	PASSET V MENORAH	001	Lauren Michele Lundquist
62	01/31/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	RAGIEL V PARK	001	Lauren Michele Lundquist
63	01/31/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	HELD V WOODMERE	001	Lauren Michele Lundquist
64	01/31/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	HOLDER V MENORAH	001	Lauren Michele Lundquist
65	01/31/2023	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE		001	Lauren Michele Lundquist
66	01/31/2023	NOTICE OF MOTION	NOTICE OF MOTION	001	Lauren Michele Lundquist	pdf
67	02/01/2023	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT	AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT	001	Lauren Michele Lundquist
68	03/06/2023	STIPULATION - ADJOURNMENT OF MOTION		001	Damien Smith
69	05/01/2023	STIPULATION - ADJOURNMENT OF MOTION		001	Damien Smith
70	05/01/2023	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION	AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION	001	Damien Smith
71	05/01/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	EXHIBIT 1 - EXPERT AFFIRMATION	001	Damien Smith
72	05/01/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit 2 - St. Catherine of Sienna Medical records 6-13-19 - 6-21-19	001	Damien Smith
73	05/01/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	EXHIBIT 3 - PHL 2801-d(2).pdf	001	Damien Smith
74	05/01/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit 4 - Morrisette v. Terence Cardinal Cooke Health Care Center	001	Damien Smith
75	05/01/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit - 5 - decisions	001	Damien Smith
76	05/01/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit 6 - PHL 12-b	001	Damien Smith
77	05/01/2023	AFFIDAVIT	RULE 202.8-B CERTIFICATION	001	Damien Smith
78	05/01/2023	PROOF OF SERVICE	AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	001	Damien Smith
79	05/18/2023	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN REPLY	REPLY AFFIRMATION	001	Lauren Michele Lundquist
80	05/18/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	IACOVONE	001	Lauren Michele Lundquist
81	10/17/2023	DECISION + ORDER ON MOTION		001	Bernadette Sarro	pdf
82	10/23/2023	NOTICE OF ENTRY	ORDER WITH NOTICE OF ENTRY	001	Damien Smith
83	10/23/2023	PROOF OF SERVICE	AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	001	Damien Smith
84	11/15/2023	NOTICE			Carmine Ambroselli
85	04/05/2024	ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE ( PROPOSED )	OTSC	2	Lauren Michele Lundquist	pdf
86	04/05/2024	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT		2	Lauren Michele Lundquist
87	04/05/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	SUMMONS & COMPLAINT	2	Lauren Michele Lundquist
88	04/05/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	VERIFIED ANSWER	2	Lauren Michele Lundquist
89	04/08/2024	ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE		2	Bernadette Sarro	pdf
90	04/26/2024	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE	AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION	2	Damien Smith	pdf
91	04/26/2024	AFFIDAVIT	RULE 202.8-B CERTICATION	2	Damien Smith
92	04/26/2024	PROOF OF SERVICE		2	Damien Smith
93	07/24/2024	DECISION + ORDER ON MOTION		2	Bernadette Sarro	pdf
94	07/24/2024	NOTICE OF ENTRY	ORDER W/NOE		Lauren Michele Lundquist
95	07/24/2024	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE			Lauren Michele Lundquist
96	08/07/2024	COURT NOTICE	Filing on Behalf of - Hon. Denise L. Sher		Diana Pariselli
97	08/27/2024	NOTICE OF APPEARANCE (POST RJI)			Lori Rosen Semlies

Lawsuit Summary

Cases

Need Help?

Let us help you or a loved one find the perfect senior home.