Assisted Living Magazine — Lawsuit Report

Sapphire Nursing and Rehab at Goshen

📍 46 HARRIMAN DRIVE, GOSHEN, ORANGE, NY, 10924

Owner: Goshen Operations Llc

Lawsuit Summary

Total Cases
7
Active Cases
2
2 active
Closed
5
5 Disposed5 Disposed
Since
2019
Most Recent
2025
Next Court Date
Apr 29, 2026
This facility is currently involved in 2 active lawsuits.

Cases

7 cases · Click to expand details (11 from 2010 – present; older years: list only)
#CourtYearIndex Number StatusCase TypePlaintiff / PetitionerPlaintiff Firm Defendant / RespondentDefendant FirmAppearanceJustice
1 Orange Supreme Court 2025 EF007342-2024 Active Negligence NEWMAN, CORA JOHN V. JANUSAS SAPPHIRE NURSING AND REHAB AT GOSHEN et al CAITLIN ROBIN AND ASSOCIATES PLLC 04/29/2026 Vazquez-Doles, Hon. Maria S. ▼
Case Info
Court
Orange Supreme Court
Index Number
EF007342-2024
Status
Active
Year Filed
2025
Case Name
NEWMAN, CORA vs. SAPPHIRE NURSING AND REHAB AT GOSHEN et al
Case Type
Tort-Other Negligence
Track
Standard
RJI Filed
02/19/2025
NOI Due
02/19/2026
NOI Filed
Calendar Number
—
Jury Status
Justice
Vazquez-Doles, Hon. Maria S.
Next Appearance
04/29/2026
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
NEWMAN, CORA
Attorney / FirmJOHN V. JANUSAS
Defendant / Respondent
SAPPHIRE NURSING AND REHAB AT GOSHEN et al
Attorneys / FirmsCAITLIN ROBIN AND ASSOCIATES PLLC
Motions
No motions recorded for this case.
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (23)
Doc #Date FiledDocumentDescriptionMotion #Filing UserFile
109/04/2024SUMMONS + COMPLAINTJohn V. Janusaspdf
209/27/2024AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEJohn V. Janusas
309/27/2024AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEJohn V. Janusas
411/11/2024ANSWERVerified AnswerCaitlin Anne Robinpdf
511/11/2024NOTICE OF DEPOSITIONNotice of DepositionCaitlin Anne Robin
611/11/2024DEMAND FOR BILL OF PARTICULARSDemand for Verified Bill of ParticularsCaitlin Anne Robin
711/11/2024DEMAND FOR:Demand for MedicareCaitlin Anne Robin
811/11/2024DEMAND FOR:Demand for Notice for Discovery and InspectionCaitlin Anne Robin
902/19/2025RJI -RE: REQUEST FOR PRELIMINARY CONFERENCEJohn V. Janusas
1002/19/2025PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE REQUESTJohn V. Janusas
2 Orange Supreme Court 2023 EF000072-2022 Active Tort LYSSETTE SOTO, as Executor of the Estate of SOTO, ANA PARKER WAICHMAN GOSHEN OPERATIONS, LLC et al Thompson-Tinsley Law, PLLC 06/08/2026 McGovern, Hon. Kyle C. ▼
Case Info
Court
Orange Supreme Court
Index Number
EF000072-2022
Status
Active
Year Filed
2023
Case Name
LYSSETTE SOTO, as Executor of the Estate of SOTO, ANA vs. GOSHEN OPERATIONS, LLC et al
Case Type
Tort-Other
Track
Standard
RJI Filed
07/27/2023
NOI Due
07/27/2024
NOI Filed
01/14/2026
Calendar Number
—
Jury Status
Jury At Plaintiff's Request
Justice
McGovern, Hon. Kyle C.
Next Appearance
06/08/2026
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
LYSSETTE SOTO, as Executor of the Estate of SOTO, ANA
Attorney / FirmPARKER WAICHMAN
Defendant / Respondent
GOSHEN OPERATIONS, LLC et al
Attorneys / FirmsThompson-Tinsley Law, PLLC
Motions (1)
#Date FiledFiled ByRelief SoughtSubmit DateAnswerStatusDecisionOrder Signed
103/17/2026Judgment - SummaryNoBefore Justice: McGovern, Hon. Kyle C.
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (42)
Doc #Date FiledDocumentDescriptionMotion #Filing UserFile
101/03/2022SUMMONS + COMPLAINTSummons and Verified ComplaintRyan Hamilton Mcallisterpdf
202/14/2022AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICERyan Hamilton Mcallister
302/14/2022STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILINGRyan Hamilton Mcallister
402/15/2022AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICERyan Hamilton Mcallister
502/15/2022AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICERyan Hamilton Mcallister
602/15/2022AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICERyan Hamilton Mcallister
702/15/2022STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILINGRyan Hamilton Mcallister
803/31/2022ANSWERVerified AnswerCaitlin Anne Robinpdf
907/27/2023PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE REQUESTRyan Hamilton Mcallister
1007/27/2023RJI -RE: REQUEST FOR PRELIMINARY CONFERENCERyan Hamilton Mcallister
3 Orange Supreme Court 2021 EF002392-2020 Disposed Tort COLAO, ANTHONY FINKELSTEIN & PARTNERS GOSHEN OPERATIONS, LLC d/b/a SAPPHIRE NURSING AND REHAB AT GOSHEN et al CAITLIN ROBIN AND ASSOCIATES PLLC 04/24/2025 McGovern, Hon. Kyle C. ▼
Case Info
Court
Orange Supreme Court
Index Number
EF002392-2020
Status
Disposed
Year Filed
2021
Case Name
COLAO, ANTHONY vs. GOSHEN OPERATIONS, LLC d/b/a SAPPHIRE NURSING AND REHAB AT GOSHEN et al
Case Type
Tort-Other
Track
Standard
RJI Filed
11/12/2021
NOI Due
01/31/2024
NOI Filed
Calendar Number
—
Jury Status
Justice
McGovern, Hon. Kyle C.
Next Appearance
04/24/2025
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
COLAO, ANTHONY
Attorney / FirmFINKELSTEIN & PARTNERS
Defendant / Respondent
GOSHEN OPERATIONS, LLC d/b/a SAPPHIRE NURSING AND REHAB AT GOSHEN et al
Attorneys / FirmsCAITLIN ROBIN AND ASSOCIATES PLLC
Motions
No motions recorded for this case.
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (49)
Doc #Date FiledDocumentDescriptionMotion #Filing UserFile
105/26/2020SUMMONS + COMPLAINTSummons and Complaint dated 3/31/2020Lawrence D Lissauerpdf
205/26/2020EXHIBIT(S)Exhibit A-Letters of AdministrrationLawrence D Lissauer
305/26/2020STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILINGStatement of Authorization dated 5/26/2020Lawrence D Lissauer
408/12/2020AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICESapphire Nursing and Rehab at Goshen-aff of serv scLawrence D Lissauer
508/18/2020AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEGoshen Operations, LLC d/b/a Sapphire Nursing & Rehab at Goshen-aff of serv scLawrence D Lissauer
608/19/2020ANSWERVerified AnswerCaitlin Anne Robinpdf
708/24/2020PROOF OF SERVICEProof of Notification to NYSDOH pursuant to CPLR 306-cLawrence D Lissauer
809/14/2020AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEElant at Goshen, Inc. d/b/a Elant at Goshen-aff of serv scLawrence D Lissauer
902/18/2021ANSWERMarie Denise Flynnpdf
1002/18/2021BILL OF PARTICULARSMarie Denise Flynn
4 Orange Supreme Court 2021 EF002415-2020 Disposed-Court Date/Application Pending Tort SAMPSON, ROSALYN AS ADMINISTRATOR FINKELSTEIN & PARTNERS GOSHEN OPERATIONS, LLC d/b/a SAPPHIRE NURSING AND REHAB AT GOSHEN et al CAITLIN ROBIN AND ASSOCIATES PLLC 05/27/2026 Vazquez-Doles, Hon. Maria S. ▼
Case Info
Court
Orange Supreme Court
Index Number
EF002415-2020
Status
Disposed-Court Date/Application Pending
Year Filed
2021
Case Name
SAMPSON, ROSALYN AS ADMINISTRATOR vs. GOSHEN OPERATIONS, LLC d/b/a SAPPHIRE NURSING AND REHAB AT GOSHEN et al
Case Type
Tort-Other
Track
Standard
RJI Filed
08/16/2021
NOI Due
12/15/2023
NOI Filed
04/24/2024
Calendar Number
—
Jury Status
Jury At Plaintiff's Request
Justice
Vazquez-Doles, Hon. Maria S.
Next Appearance
05/27/2026
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
SAMPSON, ROSALYN AS ADMINISTRATOR
Attorney / FirmFINKELSTEIN & PARTNERS
Defendant / Respondent
GOSHEN OPERATIONS, LLC d/b/a SAPPHIRE NURSING AND REHAB AT GOSHEN et al
Attorneys / FirmsCAITLIN ROBIN AND ASSOCIATES PLLC
Motions (2)
#Date FiledFiled ByRelief SoughtSubmit DateAnswerStatusDecisionOrder Signed
212/05/2024Judgment - Summary03/25/2025NoDecided: 03/25/2025 Decided Before Justice: Vazquez-Doles, Hon. Maria S.Short Form Order03/25/2025
103/13/2023Dismiss04/11/2023NoDecided: 04/11/2023 Withdrawn Before Justice: Vazquez-Doles, Hon. Maria S.
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (91)
Doc #Date FiledDocumentDescriptionMotion #Filing UserFile
105/26/2020SUMMONS + COMPLAINTSummons and Complaint dated 5/21/2020Lawrence D Lissauerpdf
205/26/2020STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILINGStatement of Authorization dated 5/26/2020Lawrence D Lissauer
308/12/2020AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICESapphire Nursing and Rehab at Goshen-aff of serv scLawrence D Lissauer
408/18/2020AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEGoshen Operations, LLC d/b/a Sapphire Nursing and Rehab at Goshen-aff of serv scLawrence D Lissauer
508/18/2020ANSWERVerified AnswerCaitlin Anne Robinpdf
608/24/2020PROOF OF SERVICEProof of Notification to NYSDOH pursuant to CPLR 306-cLawrence D Lissauer
709/14/2020AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEElant at Goshen, Inc. d/b/a Elant at GoshenLawrence D Lissauer
809/23/2020AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEEsther Landa-aff of serv scLawrence D Lissauer
909/23/2020AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEMachla Abramczyk-aff of serv scLawrence D Lissauer
1009/23/2020AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICERichard Platschek-aff of serv scLawrence D Lissauer
5 Orange Supreme Court 2020 EF003640-2019 Disposed Negligence Florence V. VanVorst, as Administratrix of the Estate of Florence Henderson and Florence V. VanVorst, Individually New York Injury Law, LLP Goshen Operations, LLC dba Sapphire Nursing and Rehab at Goshen et al CAITLIN ROBIN AND ASSOCIATES PLLC 07/30/2025 Vazquez-Doles, Hon. Maria S. ▼
Case Info
Court
Orange Supreme Court
Index Number
EF003640-2019
Status
Disposed
Year Filed
2020
Case Name
Florence V. VanVorst, as Administratrix of the Estate of Florence Henderson and Florence V. VanVorst, Individually vs. Goshen Operations, LLC dba Sapphire Nursing and Rehab at Goshen et al
Case Type
Tort-Other Negligence
Track
Standard
RJI Filed
07/15/2020
NOI Due
07/15/2021
NOI Filed
10/20/2022
Calendar Number
—
Jury Status
Justice
Vazquez-Doles, Hon. Maria S.
Next Appearance
07/30/2025
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
Florence V. VanVorst, as Administratrix of the Estate of Florence Henderson and Florence V. VanVorst, Individually
Attorney / FirmNew York Injury Law, LLP
Defendant / Respondent
Goshen Operations, LLC dba Sapphire Nursing and Rehab at Goshen et al
Attorneys / FirmsCAITLIN ROBIN AND ASSOCIATES PLLC
Motions (1)
#Date FiledFiled ByRelief SoughtSubmit DateAnswerStatusDecisionOrder Signed
112/20/2022Judgment - Summary04/07/2023NoDecided: 06/29/2023 Decided Before Justice: Vazquez-Doles, Hon. Maria S.Short Form Order06/29/2023
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (83)
Doc #Date FiledDocumentDescriptionMotion #Filing UserFile
105/06/2019SUMMONS + COMPLAINTThomas Ritchie Davispdf
205/06/2019EXHIBIT(S)letters of administrationThomas Ritchie Davis
305/06/2019EXHIBIT(S)NYS Dept of Health reportThomas Ritchie Davis
405/14/2019AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEThomas Ritchie Davis
506/24/2019AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEThomas Ritchie Davis
606/24/2019AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEThomas Ritchie Davis
706/24/2019AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEThomas Ritchie Davis
806/24/2019AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEThomas Ritchie Davis
906/27/2019ANSWERCaitlin Anne Robinpdf
1007/15/2020RJI -RE: REQUEST FOR PRELIMINARY CONFERENCEThomas Ritchie Davis
6 Orange Supreme Court 2019 7533/2018 Disposed Comm-Contract SAPPHIRE NURSING & REHAB AT M. L. ZAGER, P.C. BETTEN, ARLENE 07/10/2019 Onofry, Hon. Robert A. ▼
Case Info
Court
Orange Supreme Court
Index Number
7533/2018
Status
Disposed
Year Filed
2019
Case Name
SAPPHIRE NURSING & REHAB AT vs. BETTEN, ARLENE
Case Type
Comm-Contract
Track
Standard
RJI Filed
01/15/2019
NOI Due
01/15/2020
NOI Filed
Calendar Number
—
Jury Status
Justice
Onofry, Hon. Robert A.
Next Appearance
07/10/2019
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
SAPPHIRE NURSING & REHAB AT
Attorney / FirmM. L. ZAGER, P.C.
Defendant / Respondent
BETTEN, ARLENE
Attorneys / Firms
Motions (2)
#Date FiledFiled ByRelief SoughtSubmit DateAnswerStatusDecisionOrder Signed
204/25/2019Contempt07/10/2019NoDecided: 07/10/2019 Settled Before Justice: Onofry, Hon. Robert A.Oral
101/15/2019DEFENDANTVacate - Decision/Order/Judgment/Award02/06/2019NoDecided: 02/19/2019 Granted Before Justice: Onofry, Hon. Robert A.Short Form Order02/19/2019
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints
No eFiled documents available for this case.
7 Orange Supreme Court 2019 EF003633-2019 Disposed Comm-Contract SAPPHIRE NURSING & REHAB AT GOSHEN M.L. ZAGER P.C. YAROSZ, FRANCES 05/24/2022 Onofry, Hon. Robert A. ▼
Case Info
Court
Orange Supreme Court
Index Number
EF003633-2019
Status
Disposed
Year Filed
2019
Case Name
SAPPHIRE NURSING & REHAB AT GOSHEN vs. YAROSZ, FRANCES
Case Type
Comm-Contract
Track
Standard
RJI Filed
11/06/2019
NOI Due
NOI Filed
Calendar Number
—
Jury Status
Justice
Onofry, Hon. Robert A.
Next Appearance
05/24/2022
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
SAPPHIRE NURSING & REHAB AT GOSHEN
Attorney / FirmM.L. ZAGER P.C.
Defendant / Respondent
YAROSZ, FRANCES
Attorneys / Firms
Motions (1)
#Date FiledFiled ByRelief SoughtSubmit DateAnswerStatusDecisionOrder Signed
111/06/2019Judgment - Summary11/27/2019NoDecided: 01/07/2020 Decided Before Justice: Onofry, Hon. Robert A.Short Form Order
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (19)
Doc #Date FiledDocumentDescriptionMotion #Filing UserFile
105/06/2019SUMMONS + COMPLAINTRobert Bruce Hunterpdf
205/22/2019AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICERobert Bruce Hunter
306/03/2019ANSWEROrange Wsuserpdf
407/30/2019JUDGMENT - CLERK DEFAULT (PROPOSED)Robert Bruce Hunterpdf
507/30/2019AFFIDAVITMILITARY SEARCHRobert Bruce Hunter
607/31/2019LETTER/CORRESPONDENCE FROM COURTOrange Wsuser
711/06/2019NOTICE OF MOTION1Robert Bruce Hunterpdf
811/06/2019AFFIDAVIT1Robert Bruce Hunter
911/06/2019EXHIBIT(S)PLEADINGS1Robert Bruce Hunter
1011/06/2019EXHIBIT(S)STATEMENT1Robert Bruce Hunter