Is Brookhaven Care Center in a walkable area?

Brookhaven Care Center has a walk score of 5. Car-dependent. Most errands require a car, with limited nearby walkable options.

What is the license number of Brookhaven Care Center?

According to NY state health department records, Brookhaven Care Center's license number is 700-F-290.

What is the occupancy rate at Brookhaven Care Center?

Brookhaven Care Center's occupancy is 95.7%.

Are pets allowed at Brookhaven Care Center?

No, Brookhaven Care Center has a no-pet policy.

Does Brookhaven Care Center operate as a for-profit or non-profit?

Brookhaven Care Center is registered as a for-profit in NY.

What is the overall rating for Brookhaven Care Center?

Brookhaven Care Center received a 2-star overall rating from the CMS (Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services). This score combines results from staffing levels, quality measures, and health inspections.

How many beds does Brookhaven Care Center have?

Brookhaven Care Center has 182 beds.

Brookhaven Care Center | 2-Star Nursing Home in Brookhaven, NY

Lawsuit Summary

Total Cases

Active Cases

6 active

Stayed / Paused

1 Stayed

Closed

25 Disposed

Since

2012

Most Recent

2026

Last Scheduled Court Date

Aug 04, 2026

This facility is currently involved in 6 active lawsuits.

Cases

32 cases · Click to expand details

Court

Year

Index Number

Status

Case Type

Plaintiff / Petitioner

Plaintiff Firm

Defendant / Respondent

Defendant Firm

Appearance

Justice

Nassau Supreme Court

2026

603115/2026

Active

Tort

GEE, RICKEY

FINKELSTEIN & PARTNERS

BROOKHAVEN REHABILITATION & HEALTH CARE CENTER et al

AARONSON RAPPAPORT FEINSTEIN & DEUTSCH

09/14/2026

Prager, Hon. Erica L.

▼

Case Info

Court

Nassau Supreme Court

Index Number

603115/2026

Status

Active

Year Filed

2026

Case Name

GEE, RICKEY vs. BROOKHAVEN REHABILITATION & HEALTH CARE CENTER et al

Case Type

Tort-Other

Track

Standard

RJI Filed

03/23/2026

NOI Due

03/23/2027

NOI Filed

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

Prager, Hon. Erica L.

Next Appearance

09/14/2026

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

GEE, RICKEY

Attorney / FirmFINKELSTEIN & PARTNERS

Defendant / Respondent

BROOKHAVEN REHABILITATION & HEALTH CARE CENTER et al

Attorneys / FirmsAARONSON RAPPAPORT FEINSTEIN & DEUTSCH

Motions

No motions recorded for this case.

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints (40)

Doc #	Date Filed	Document	Description	Motion #	Filing User
1	06/25/2024	SUMMONS + COMPLAINT	Summons and Verified Complaint dated 6-24-2024		Lawrence D Lissauer
2	06/25/2024	STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING	Statement of Authorization for efiling dated 6-25-2024		Lawrence D Lissauer
3	07/08/2024	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Affidavit of service dated 6-25-24 and NYS dos receipt dated 6-25-24 for Brookhaven Rehabilitation and Health Care Center, LLC dba Brookhaven Rehabilitation & Health Care Center		Lawrence D Lissauer
4	07/08/2024	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Affidavit of service dated 6-25-24 and NYS dos receipt dated 6-25-24 for West Lawrence Care Center, LLC dba West Lawrence Care Center		Lawrence D Lissauer
5	07/16/2024	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Affidavit of service dated 7-15-2024 for Brookhaven Rehabilitation & Healthcare Center		Lawrence D Lissauer
6	07/16/2024	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Affidavit of service dated 7-15-2024 for West Lawrence Care Center		Lawrence D Lissauer
7	07/22/2024	PROOF OF SERVICE	Proof of Notification to NYS DOH dated 7-9-2024		Lawrence D Lissauer
8	08/09/2024	ANSWER	Verified Answer - Brookhaven Rehabilitation and Health Care Center		Patrick Philippe Mevs
9	08/09/2024	DEMAND FOR BILL OF PARTICULARS	Demand for a Bill of Particulars - Brookhaven Rehabilitation and Health Care Center		Patrick Philippe Mevs
10	08/09/2024	NOTICE OF DEPOSITION	Notice of Deposition - Brookhaven Rehabilitation and Health Care Center		Patrick Philippe Mevs
11	08/09/2024	DEMAND FOR:	Combined Demands - Brookhaven Rehabilitation and Health Care Center		Patrick Philippe Mevs
12	08/09/2024	NOTICE OF MOTION		001	Benjamin Daniel Rosenfield
13	08/09/2024	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION	Attorney Affirmation	001	Benjamin Daniel Rosenfield
14	08/09/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Admissions Agreement	001	Benjamin Daniel Rosenfield
15	08/09/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Summons and Complaint	001	Benjamin Daniel Rosenfield
16	08/09/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Answer	001	Benjamin Daniel Rosenfield
17	08/09/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Affidavit of Robert Rosenberg	001	Benjamin Daniel Rosenfield
18	08/09/2024	RJI FROM PRIOR COUNTY (COPY)	Original document type was RJI -RE: NOTICE OF MOTION	001	Benjamin Daniel Rosenfield
19	08/09/2024	ADDENDUM - GENERAL (840A)		001	Benjamin Daniel Rosenfield
20	09/20/2024	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION		001	Ann R. Johnson
21	09/20/2024	CERTIFICATION OF SIGNATURE ( ATTORNEY OR PARTY )	CERTIFICATION PURSUANT TO 22 NYCRR 202.8-b(c)	001	Ann R. Johnson
22	09/30/2024	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN REPLY		001	Benjamin Daniel Rosenfield
23	10/03/2024	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Affirmation of Service dated 10-2-2024 for David Cytryn		Lawrence D Lissauer
24	10/07/2024	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Affidavit of service dated 9-30-2024 and Affidavit of Mailing dated 10-1-2024 for David Cytryn		Lawrence D Lissauer
25	10/07/2024	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Affirmation of service dated 10-2-2024 for David Cytryn		Lawrence D Lissauer
26	10/24/2024	ANSWER	Verified Answer		Caitlin Anne Robin
27	10/24/2024	DEMAND FOR:	Demand for Medicare / Medicaid		Caitlin Anne Robin
28	10/24/2024	DEMAND FOR:	Demand for Notice of Discovery and Combined Demands		Caitlin Anne Robin
29	10/24/2024	DEMAND FOR:	Demand for a Verified Bill of Particulars		Caitlin Anne Robin
30	10/24/2024	DEMAND FOR:	Demand for a Verified Bill of Particulars - David Cytryn		Caitlin Anne Robin
31	10/24/2024	NOTICE OF DEPOSITION			Caitlin Anne Robin
32	11/24/2025	ORDER - TRANSFER - CHANGE OF VENUE	Change Venue - Nassau County	001	Jerome D White
33	11/24/2025	NOTICE OF ENTRY	Notice of Entry	001	Patrick Philippe Mevs
34	02/07/2026	NOTICE TO COUNTY CLERK CPLR 8019(C)			Benjamin Daniel Rosenfield
35	02/10/2026	COUNTY CLERK CERTIFICATION OF MINUTES	QUEENS E-FILE INDEX # 713259/2024		Christine Cheng
36	02/10/2026	COURT NOTICE			Lauren L Websdell
37	08/09/2024	RJI -RE: REQUEST FOR PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE			Benjamin Daniel Rosenfield
38	03/10/2026	ADDENDUM - GENERAL (840A)			Benjamin Daniel Rosenfield
39	03/23/2026	COURT NOTICE			Ellen Libassi
40	04/28/2026	ORDER - PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE			Doris S Brown

Queens Supreme Court

2024

713259/2024

Disposed

Tort

GEE, RICKEY

FINKELSTEIN & PARTNERS

BROOKHAVEN REHABILITATION & HEALTH CARE CENTER et al

Aaronson Rappaport Feinstein & Deutsch LLP

12/08/2025

Kelly, Hon. Peter Joseph

▼

Case Info

Court

Queens Supreme Court

Index Number

713259/2024

Status

Disposed

Year Filed

2024

Case Name

GEE, RICKEY vs. BROOKHAVEN REHABILITATION & HEALTH CARE CENTER et al

Case Type

Tort-Other

Track

Standard

RJI Filed

08/09/2024

NOI Due

08/09/2025

NOI Filed

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

Kelly, Hon. Peter Joseph

Next Appearance

12/08/2025

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

GEE, RICKEY

Attorney / FirmFINKELSTEIN & PARTNERS

Defendant / Respondent

BROOKHAVEN REHABILITATION & HEALTH CARE CENTER et al

Attorneys / FirmsAaronson Rappaport Feinstein & Deutsch LLP

Motions (1)

#	Date Filed	Filed By	Relief Sought	Submit Date	Answer	Status	Decision	Order Signed
1	08/09/2024		Change Venue	11/20/2024	No	Decided: 11/21/2025 Granted Before Justice: Kelly, Hon. Peter Joseph	Short Form Order

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints (40)

Doc #	Date Filed	Document	Description	Motion #	Filing User
1	06/25/2024	SUMMONS + COMPLAINT	Summons and Verified Complaint dated 6-24-2024		Lawrence D Lissauer
2	06/25/2024	STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING	Statement of Authorization for efiling dated 6-25-2024		Lawrence D Lissauer
3	07/08/2024	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Affidavit of service dated 6-25-24 and NYS dos receipt dated 6-25-24 for Brookhaven Rehabilitation and Health Care Center, LLC dba Brookhaven Rehabilitation & Health Care Center		Lawrence D Lissauer
4	07/08/2024	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Affidavit of service dated 6-25-24 and NYS dos receipt dated 6-25-24 for West Lawrence Care Center, LLC dba West Lawrence Care Center		Lawrence D Lissauer
5	07/16/2024	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Affidavit of service dated 7-15-2024 for Brookhaven Rehabilitation & Healthcare Center		Lawrence D Lissauer
6	07/16/2024	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Affidavit of service dated 7-15-2024 for West Lawrence Care Center		Lawrence D Lissauer
7	07/22/2024	PROOF OF SERVICE	Proof of Notification to NYS DOH dated 7-9-2024		Lawrence D Lissauer
8	08/09/2024	ANSWER	Verified Answer - Brookhaven Rehabilitation and Health Care Center		Patrick Philippe Mevs
9	08/09/2024	DEMAND FOR BILL OF PARTICULARS	Demand for a Bill of Particulars - Brookhaven Rehabilitation and Health Care Center		Patrick Philippe Mevs
10	08/09/2024	NOTICE OF DEPOSITION	Notice of Deposition - Brookhaven Rehabilitation and Health Care Center		Patrick Philippe Mevs
11	08/09/2024	DEMAND FOR:	Combined Demands - Brookhaven Rehabilitation and Health Care Center		Patrick Philippe Mevs
12	08/09/2024	NOTICE OF MOTION		001	Benjamin Daniel Rosenfield
13	08/09/2024	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION	Attorney Affirmation	001	Benjamin Daniel Rosenfield
14	08/09/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Admissions Agreement	001	Benjamin Daniel Rosenfield
15	08/09/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Summons and Complaint	001	Benjamin Daniel Rosenfield
16	08/09/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Answer	001	Benjamin Daniel Rosenfield
17	08/09/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Affidavit of Robert Rosenberg	001	Benjamin Daniel Rosenfield
18	08/09/2024	RJI FROM PRIOR COUNTY (COPY)	Original document type was RJI -RE: NOTICE OF MOTION	001	Benjamin Daniel Rosenfield
19	08/09/2024	ADDENDUM - GENERAL (840A)		001	Benjamin Daniel Rosenfield
20	09/20/2024	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION		001	Ann R. Johnson
21	09/20/2024	CERTIFICATION OF SIGNATURE ( ATTORNEY OR PARTY )	CERTIFICATION PURSUANT TO 22 NYCRR 202.8-b(c)	001	Ann R. Johnson
22	09/30/2024	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN REPLY		001	Benjamin Daniel Rosenfield
23	10/03/2024	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Affirmation of Service dated 10-2-2024 for David Cytryn		Lawrence D Lissauer
24	10/07/2024	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Affidavit of service dated 9-30-2024 and Affidavit of Mailing dated 10-1-2024 for David Cytryn		Lawrence D Lissauer
25	10/07/2024	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Affirmation of service dated 10-2-2024 for David Cytryn		Lawrence D Lissauer
26	10/24/2024	ANSWER	Verified Answer		Caitlin Anne Robin
27	10/24/2024	DEMAND FOR:	Demand for Medicare / Medicaid		Caitlin Anne Robin
28	10/24/2024	DEMAND FOR:	Demand for Notice of Discovery and Combined Demands		Caitlin Anne Robin
29	10/24/2024	DEMAND FOR:	Demand for a Verified Bill of Particulars		Caitlin Anne Robin
30	10/24/2024	DEMAND FOR:	Demand for a Verified Bill of Particulars - David Cytryn		Caitlin Anne Robin
31	10/24/2024	NOTICE OF DEPOSITION			Caitlin Anne Robin
32	11/24/2025	ORDER - TRANSFER - CHANGE OF VENUE	Change Venue - Nassau County	001	Jerome D White
33	11/24/2025	NOTICE OF ENTRY	Notice of Entry	001	Patrick Philippe Mevs
34	02/07/2026	NOTICE TO COUNTY CLERK CPLR 8019(C)			Benjamin Daniel Rosenfield
35	02/10/2026	COUNTY CLERK CERTIFICATION OF MINUTES	QUEENS E-FILE INDEX # 713259/2024		Christine Cheng
36	02/10/2026	COURT NOTICE			Lauren L Websdell
37	08/09/2024	RJI -RE: REQUEST FOR PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE			Benjamin Daniel Rosenfield
38	03/10/2026	ADDENDUM - GENERAL (840A)			Benjamin Daniel Rosenfield
39	03/23/2026	COURT NOTICE			Ellen Libassi
40	04/28/2026	ORDER - PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE			Doris S Brown

Queens Supreme Court

2024

702340/2024

Active

Tort

BROOKHAVEN REHABILITATION AND HEALTH CARE CENTER, LLC

GARRETT I. ELIAS ATTORNEY AT LAW

RACIOPPO, RALPH

07/14/2026

Johnson, Hon. Denise N.

▼

Case Info

Court

Queens Supreme Court

Index Number

702340/2024

Status

Active

Year Filed

2024

Case Name

BROOKHAVEN REHABILITATION AND HEALTH CARE CENTER, LLC vs. RACIOPPO, RALPH

Case Type

Tort-Other

Track

Standard

RJI Filed

12/31/2024

NOI Due

12/31/2025

NOI Filed

10/03/2025

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

Johnson, Hon. Denise N.

Next Appearance

07/14/2026

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

BROOKHAVEN REHABILITATION AND HEALTH CARE CENTER, LLC

Attorney / FirmGARRETT I. ELIAS ATTORNEY AT LAW

Defendant / Respondent

RACIOPPO, RALPH

Attorneys / Firms

Motions (2)

#	Date Filed	Filed By	Relief Sought	Submit Date	Answer	Status	Decision	Order Signed
2	05/02/2025		Judgment - Default	06/24/2025	Yes	Decided: 10/01/2025 Granted Before Justice: Johnson, Hon. Denise N.	Short Form Order
1	12/31/2024		Injunction/Restraining Order	01/28/2025	No	Decided: 03/18/2025 Denied Before Justice: Johnson, Hon. Denise N.	Short Form Order

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints (38)

Doc #	Date Filed	Document	Description	Motion #	Filing User
1	01/31/2024	SUMMONS + COMPLAINT			Garrett I Elias
2	04/29/2024	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	RALPH RACIOPPO A/K/A RALPH R. RACIOPPO		Garrett I Elias
3	04/29/2024	STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING			Garrett I Elias
4	12/31/2024	ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE ( PROPOSED )		001	Garrett I Elias
5	12/31/2024	AFFIRMATION	Affirmation of Emergency Relief	001	Garrett I Elias
6	12/31/2024	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF PROPOSED OSC/EXPARTE APP	Attorney Affirmation	001	Garrett I Elias
7	12/31/2024	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF PROPOSED OSC/EXPARTE APP	Menahemov Affirmation	001	Garrett I Elias
8	12/31/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Brookhaven Invoice	001	Garrett I Elias
9	12/31/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Medicaid Budget	001	Garrett I Elias
10	12/31/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	JP Morgan Chase Bank statements	001	Garrett I Elias
11	12/31/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Summons and Verified Complaint	001	Garrett I Elias
12	12/31/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	TRO Notice	001	Garrett I Elias
13	12/31/2024	RJI -RE: ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE		001	Garrett I Elias
14	01/07/2025	ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE		001	Jerome D White
15	01/21/2025	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	RALPH RACIOPPO A/K/A RALPH R. RACIOPPO	001	Garrett I Elias
16	01/21/2025	STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING		001	Garrett I Elias
17	01/21/2025	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE		001	Garrett I Elias
18	03/14/2025	OTHER COURT FILED DOCUMENT	SUPPORTING PAPERS FOR DOCUMENT NUMBER 14		Brenda Sutton Jeffers
19	03/20/2025	ORDER - MOTION- SHORT FORM		001	Aimee Lopez
20	05/02/2025	ORDER - PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE			Erica Nieves
21	05/02/2025	NOTICE OF MOTION		002	Garrett I Elias
22	05/02/2025	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION	Attorney Affirmation	002	Garrett I Elias
23	05/02/2025	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION	Menahemov Affirmation	002	Garrett I Elias
24	05/02/2025	AFFIRMATION	Affirmation of Non-Military Investigation	002	Garrett I Elias
25	05/02/2025	NOTICE OF COMPLIANCE		002	Garrett I Elias
26	05/02/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Brookhaven Invoice	002	Garrett I Elias
27	05/02/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Medicaid Budget	002	Garrett I Elias
28	05/02/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Summons and Verified Complaint	002	Garrett I Elias
29	05/02/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Affidavit of Service	002	Garrett I Elias
30	05/02/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	3215(g) Default Notice	002	Garrett I Elias
31	05/02/2025	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE		002	Garrett I Elias
32	06/11/2025	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE		002	Garrett I Elias
33	07/29/2025	ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE			Erica Nieves
34	10/02/2025	ORDER - MOTION- SHORT FORM		002	Tulun Ahmed
35	10/03/2025	NOTICE OF ENTRY			Garrett I Elias
36	10/03/2025	NOTE OF ISSUE:WITHOUT JURY			Garrett I Elias
37	10/03/2025	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Note of Issue		Garrett I Elias
38	03/31/2026	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE	Copy of Notice to Defendant re: Inquest		Steven P Bann

Queens Supreme Court

2024

720114/2023

Disposed

Tort

BROOKHAVEN REHABILITATION AND HEALTH CARE CENTER, LLC

Abrams Fensterman, LLP

SANCHEZ, VINCENTE et al

09/12/2024

Lin, Hon. Karen

▼

Case Info

Court

Queens Supreme Court

Index Number

720114/2023

Status

Disposed

Year Filed

2024

Case Name

BROOKHAVEN REHABILITATION AND HEALTH CARE CENTER, LLC vs. SANCHEZ, VINCENTE et al

Case Type

Tort-Other

Track

Standard

RJI Filed

NOI Due

NOI Filed

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

Lin, Hon. Karen

Next Appearance

09/12/2024

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

BROOKHAVEN REHABILITATION AND HEALTH CARE CENTER, LLC

Attorney / FirmAbrams Fensterman, LLP

Defendant / Respondent

SANCHEZ, VINCENTE et al

Attorneys / Firms

Motions (1)

#	Date Filed	Filed By	Relief Sought	Submit Date	Answer	Status	Decision	Order Signed
1	07/17/2024		Vacate - Decision/Order/Judgment/Award	09/12/2024	No	Decided: 09/27/2024 Signed Before Justice: Lin, Hon. Karen	Long Form Order	09/27/2024

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints (31)

Doc #	Date Filed	Document	Description	Motion #	Filing User
1	09/28/2023	SUMMONS + COMPLAINT			Steven P Bann
2	10/13/2023	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	VINCENTE SANCHEZ		Steven P Bann
3	10/13/2023	STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING			Steven P Bann
4	12/05/2023	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	NELSON CRUZ		Nicholas Corona
5	12/05/2023	STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING			Nicholas Corona
6	06/06/2024	JUDGMENT - CLERK DEFAULT (PROPOSED)			Garrett I Elias
7	06/06/2024	AFFIRMATION	Affirmation of Non-Expiration of Statute of Limitations		Garrett I Elias
8	06/06/2024	AFFIRMATION	Affirmation of Mailing		Garrett I Elias
9	06/06/2024	AFFIRMATION	Affirmation of Non-Military Investigation - Vincente Sanchez		Garrett I Elias
10	06/06/2024	AFFIRMATION	Affirmation of Non-Military Investigation - Nelson Cruz		Garrett I Elias
11	06/06/2024	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE			Garrett I Elias
12	06/21/2024	JUDGMENT	Default Money Judgment		Keelin M Reilly
13	06/21/2024	NOTICE OF ENTRY			Nicholas Corona
14	06/21/2024	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE			Nicholas Corona
15	07/17/2024	ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE ( PROPOSED )		001	Alejandro Roca
16	07/17/2024	RJI -RE: ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE		001	Alejandro Roca
17	07/17/2024	ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE		001	Christine Cheng
18	07/18/2024	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE			Alejandro Roca
19	09/05/2024	NOTICE OF CROSS-MOTION		001	Garrett I Elias
20	09/05/2024	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE	Attorney Affirmation in Opposition of Deft's Order to Show Cause and in Support of Cross-Motion	001	Garrett I Elias
21	09/05/2024	NOTICE OF COMPLIANCE		001	Garrett I Elias
22	09/05/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Brookhaven Invoice	001	Garrett I Elias
23	09/05/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Summons and Verified Complaint	001	Garrett I Elias
24	09/05/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Affidavit of Service	001	Garrett I Elias
25	09/05/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Admission Agreement	001	Garrett I Elias
26	09/05/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Judgment	001	Garrett I Elias
27	09/05/2024	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE		001	Garrett I Elias
28	09/30/2024	ORDER - 325(d)			Christine Cheng
29	11/06/2024	NOTICE OF DISCONTINUANCE (POST RJI)			Garrett I Elias
30	11/06/2024	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Notice of Discontinuance		Garrett I Elias
31	11/06/2024	STIPULATION - DISCONTINUANCE (POST RJI)			Garrett I Elias

Queens Supreme Court

2023

715892/2023

Active

Tort

BROOKHAVEN REHABILITATION AND HEALTH CARE CENTER, LLC

Abrams Fensterman, LLP

BANK OF AMERICA, N.A.

10/18/2023

Perez, Hon. Sandra

▼

Case Info

Court

Queens Supreme Court

Index Number

715892/2023

Status

Active

Year Filed

2023

Case Name

BROOKHAVEN REHABILITATION AND HEALTH CARE CENTER, LLC vs. BANK OF AMERICA, N.A.

Case Type

Tort-Other

Track

Standard

RJI Filed

08/02/2023

NOI Due

08/01/2024

NOI Filed

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

Perez, Hon. Sandra

Next Appearance

10/18/2023

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

BROOKHAVEN REHABILITATION AND HEALTH CARE CENTER, LLC

Attorney / FirmAbrams Fensterman, LLP

Defendant / Respondent

BANK OF AMERICA, N.A.

Attorneys / FirmsBANK OF AMERICA, N.A.

Motions (1)

#	Date Filed	Filed By	Relief Sought	Submit Date	Answer	Status	Decision	Order Signed
1	08/02/2023		Subpoena	01/12/2024	No	Decided: 01/12/2024 Withdrawn Before Justice: Leverett, Hon. Ulysses B.

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints (14)

Doc #	Date Filed	Document	Description	Motion #	Filing User
1	08/02/2023	PETITION			Nicholas Corona
2	08/02/2023	ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE ( PROPOSED )		001	Nicholas Corona
3	08/02/2023	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF PROPOSED OSC/EXPARTE APP	Attorney Affirmation	001	Nicholas Corona
4	08/02/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Brookhaven Invoice	001	Nicholas Corona
5	08/02/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Estate Search	001	Nicholas Corona
6	08/02/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Proposed Judicial Subpoena Duces Tecum	001	Nicholas Corona
7	08/02/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Bank Search	001	Nicholas Corona
8	08/02/2023	RJI -RE: ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE			Nicholas Corona
9	08/08/2023	ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE		001	Christine Cheng
10	08/08/2023	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service - Bank of America, N.A. Legal Order Processing	001	Nicholas Corona
11	08/17/2023	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	BANK OF AMERICA, N.A.	001	Nicholas Corona
12	08/17/2023	STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING		001	Nicholas Corona
14	01/11/2024	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE	Letter Withdrawing Plaintiff's Order to Show Cause	001	Nicholas Corona
15	01/11/2024	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE	Corrected Letter Withdrawing Plaintiff's Order to Show Cause	001	Nicholas Corona

Queens Supreme Court

2023

702306/2023

Active

Medical Malpractice

Sgagias, The Estate of Kathren

Napoli Shkolnik, PLLC

Brookhaven Rehabilitation & Health Care Center LLC et al

ABC Corporation

08/04/2026

Compliance Conf Judge,

▼

Case Info

Court

Queens Supreme Court

Index Number

702306/2023

Status

Active

Year Filed

2023

Case Name

Sgagias, The Estate of Kathren vs. Brookhaven Rehabilitation & Health Care Center LLC et al

Case Type

Tort-Other Professional Malpractice

Track

Standard

RJI Filed

03/14/2023

NOI Due

03/13/2024

NOI Filed

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

Compliance Conf Judge,

Next Appearance

08/04/2026

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

Sgagias, The Estate of Kathren

Attorney / FirmNapoli Shkolnik, PLLC

Defendant / Respondent

Brookhaven Rehabilitation & Health Care Center LLC et al

Attorneys / FirmsABC Corporation

Motions (6)

#	Date Filed	Relief Sought	Submit Date	Answer	Status	Decision
5	07/02/2026	Renew/Reargue/Resettle/Reconsider		Yes	Before Justice: McKetney-Butler, Hon. Laurentina S.
4	04/24/2026	Renew/Reargue/Resettle/Reconsider	07/14/2026	Yes	Decided: 07/14/2026 Withdrawn Before Justice: McKetney-Butler, Hon. Laurentina S.
3	12/15/2024	Renew/Reargue/Resettle/Reconsider	02/25/2025	Yes	Decided: 03/16/2026 Granted to the Extent of the Order Before Justice: McKetney-Butler, Hon. Laurentina S.	Short Form Order
3	12/15/2024	Renew/Reargue/Resettle/Reconsider	02/25/2025	Yes	Decided: 05/22/2026 Granted to the Extent of the Order Before Justice: McKetney-Butler, Hon. Laurentina S.	Short Form Order
2	11/06/2023	Dismiss	02/20/2024	Yes	Decided: 09/18/2024 Denied Before Justice: McKetney-Butler, Hon. Laurentina S.	Short Form Order
1	03/14/2023	Dismiss	04/25/2023	No	Decided: 04/25/2023 Withdrawn Before Justice: McKetney-Butler, Hon. Laurentina S.	Oral

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints (212)

Doc #	Date Filed	Document	Description	Motion #	Filing User
1	02/01/2023	SUMMONS + COMPLAINT			Joseph Leonard Ciaccio
2	03/07/2023	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE			Joseph Leonard Ciaccio
3	03/07/2023	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE			Joseph Leonard Ciaccio
4	03/07/2023	STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING			Joseph Leonard Ciaccio
5	03/14/2023	NOTICE OF MOTION		001	Emeka K Thomas
6	03/14/2023	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION		001	Emeka K Thomas
7	03/14/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	S&C	001	Emeka K Thomas
8	03/14/2023	RJI -RE: NOTICE OF MOTION		001	Emeka K Thomas
9	04/25/2023	STIPULATION - WITHDRAWING MOTION/ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE		001	Joseph Leonard Ciaccio
10	05/05/2023	SUMMONS (POST RJI) (AMENDED)			Joseph Leonard Ciaccio
11	05/05/2023	COMPLAINT (AMENDED)			Joseph Leonard Ciaccio
12	06/28/2023	ORDER - PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE			Louisa Ammirati
13	08/31/2023	STIPULATION - TIME TO ANSWER			Lori Rosen Semlies
14	09/27/2023	ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE			David Pierrelouis
15	09/29/2023	STIPULATION - TIME TO ANSWER			Lori Rosen Semlies
16	10/27/2023	STIPULATION - TIME TO ANSWER			Lori Rosen Semlies
17	10/27/2023	NOTICE OF MOTION		002	Steven Vincent Debraccio
18	10/27/2023	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION		002	Steven Vincent Debraccio
19	10/27/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	85 Fed Reg 15198	002	Steven Vincent Debraccio
20	10/27/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Affidavit of Arleen Comrie	002	Steven Vincent Debraccio
21	10/27/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Pre-COVID-19 Infection Control Policies	002	Steven Vincent Debraccio
22	10/27/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	COVID-19 Policies and Procedures	002	Steven Vincent Debraccio
23	10/27/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	3/16/2020 NYS DOH Guidance	002	Steven Vincent Debraccio
24	10/27/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	3/21/2020 NYS DOH Guidance	002	Steven Vincent Debraccio
25	10/27/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	NYS DOH Guidance on Nursing Home Admission	002	Steven Vincent Debraccio
26	10/27/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	NYS DOH April 2_ 2020 Advisory	002	Steven Vincent Debraccio
27	10/27/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	NYS DOH April 8_ 2020 Advisory	002	Steven Vincent Debraccio
28	10/27/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Brookhaven Redacted Progress Notes Part 1 of 3	002	Steven Vincent Debraccio
29	10/27/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Brookhaven Redacted Progress Notes Part 2 of 3	002	Steven Vincent Debraccio
30	10/27/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Brookhaven Redacted Progress Notes Part 3 of 3	002	Steven Vincent Debraccio
31	10/27/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Decedent's Redacted Physician's Notes -PART 1 of 8	002	Steven Vincent Debraccio
32	10/27/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Decedent's Redacted Physician's Notes -PART 2 of 8	002	Steven Vincent Debraccio
33	10/27/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Decedent's Redacted Physician's Notes -PART 3 of 8	002	Steven Vincent Debraccio
34	10/27/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Decedent's Redacted Physician's Notes -PART 4 of 8	002	Steven Vincent Debraccio
35	10/27/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Decedent's Redacted Physician's Notes -PART 5 of 8	002	Steven Vincent Debraccio
36	10/27/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Decedent's Redacted Physician's Notes -PART 6 of 8	002	Steven Vincent Debraccio
37	10/27/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Decedent's Redacted Physician's Notes -PART 7 of 8	002	Steven Vincent Debraccio
38	10/27/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Decedent's Redacted Physician's Notes -PART 8 of 8	002	Steven Vincent Debraccio
39	10/27/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Decedent's Redacted Care Plans	002	Steven Vincent Debraccio
40	10/27/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Decedent's Redacted Lab Test Results	002	Steven Vincent Debraccio
41	10/27/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	S&C	002	Steven Vincent Debraccio
42	10/27/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Amended Complaint	002	Steven Vincent Debraccio
43	10/27/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Stip Extending Time to Answer	002	Steven Vincent Debraccio
44	10/27/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Unreported decisions	002	Steven Vincent Debraccio
45	10/27/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Multiple S&Cs	002	Steven Vincent Debraccio
46	10/27/2023	MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN SUPPORT		002	Steven Vincent Debraccio
47	01/03/2024	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION		002	Wilbert Mendez Marrero
48	01/03/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	WHO Situation Report 3	002	Wilbert Mendez Marrero
49	01/03/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	CMS Information for Healthcare Facilities Concerning 2019 Novel Coronavirus Illness (2019-nCoV)	002	Wilbert Mendez Marrero
50	01/03/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	NYDOH Report 2020-S-55 dated March 2022: Use, Collection, and Reporting of Infection Control Data	002	Wilbert Mendez Marrero
51	01/03/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Guidance for Resident and Family Communication in Adult Care Facilities and Nursing Homes	002	Wilbert Mendez Marrero
52	01/03/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	CMS Interim Final Rule Updating Requirements for Notification of Confirmed and Suspected COVID-19 Cases Among Residents and Staff in Nursing Homes	002	Wilbert Mendez Marrero
53	01/03/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Affirmation from Vicky Sgagias	002	Wilbert Mendez Marrero
54	01/04/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Medicare Data	002	Wilbert Mendez Marrero
55	01/04/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Nursing Home Response to COVID-19 Pandemic Report by the New York State Office of the Attorney General Letitia James	002	Wilbert Mendez Marrero
56	01/04/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	New York Senate Bill S5177 and Assembly Bill 10840/S08835	002	Wilbert Mendez Marrero
57	01/04/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Emergency Preparedness Requirements for Medicare and Medicaid Participating Providers and Suppliers	002	Wilbert Mendez Marrero
58	01/04/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Assemblyman Ronald T. Kim Affidavit	002	Wilbert Mendez Marrero
59	01/04/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Cacace v. Grandell	002	Wilbert Mendez Marrero
60	01/04/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Lara v SJ Operational	002	Wilbert Mendez Marrero
61	01/04/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Gonnelly v Newburgh Operations	002	Wilbert Mendez Marrero
62	01/04/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Byington v North Sea Associates	002	Wilbert Mendez Marrero
63	01/04/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Matos v Chiong Order - Expert Affidavit	002	Wilbert Mendez Marrero
64	01/04/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Townsend v Penus	002	Wilbert Mendez Marrero
65	01/04/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Pena v Gupta	002	Wilbert Mendez Marrero
66	01/04/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Hernandez v. Clove Lakes	002	Wilbert Mendez Marrero
67	01/04/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Quattlebaum v. Dragomir	002	Wilbert Mendez Marrero
68	01/04/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Robertson v Humbdolt	002	Wilbert Mendez Marrero
69	01/04/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Costiera v MMR	002	Wilbert Mendez Marrero
70	01/04/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Espinal v Jackson Heights	002	Wilbert Mendez Marrero
71	01/04/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Messina v Clove Lakes	002	Wilbert Mendez Marrero
72	01/04/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Rago v Sky View	002	Wilbert Mendez Marrero
73	01/04/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Dinunzio v Cobble Hill	002	Wilbert Mendez Marrero
74	01/04/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Vogl v Fulton Commons	002	Wilbert Mendez Marrero
75	01/04/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Boedewig v. Grand Great Neck LLC	002	Wilbert Mendez Marrero
76	01/04/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Massimo v. Dubey	002	Wilbert Mendez Marrero
77	01/04/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Adler v. Troy	002	Wilbert Mendez Marrero
78	01/04/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Est. of Pierro v Brookhaven Richmond	002	Wilbert Mendez Marrero
79	01/04/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Est. of Thomas v Clove Lakes	002	Wilbert Mendez Marrero
80	01/04/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Kluska v. Montefiore St Lukes Hospital	002	Wilbert Mendez Marrero
81	01/04/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Arbor Mgmt. Servs LLC v. Hendrix	002	Wilbert Mendez Marrero
82	01/04/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Hansen v. Brandywine	002	Wilbert Mendez Marrero
83	01/04/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Maglioli v. Alliance Holdings LLC	002	Wilbert Mendez Marrero
84	01/04/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Saldana v. Glenhaven Healthcare LLC	002	Wilbert Mendez Marrero
85	01/04/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Solomon v. St. Joseph Hospital et al	002	Wilbert Mendez Marrero
86	01/04/2024	MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN OPPOSITION		002	Wilbert Mendez Marrero
87	01/12/2024	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN REPLY		002	Steven Vincent Debraccio
88	01/12/2024	MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN REPLY		002	Steven Vincent Debraccio
89	01/12/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	NYS DOH Advisory Mar. 13, 2020	002	Steven Vincent Debraccio
90	01/12/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Affidavit of Arleen Comrie (corrected)	002	Steven Vincent Debraccio
91	01/12/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Executive Order 202.10	002	Steven Vincent Debraccio
92	01/12/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Nursing Affidavit in Crampton case	002	Steven Vincent Debraccio
93	01/12/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Excerpted NYS DOH Profile of Defendant from NYS DOH Website	002	Steven Vincent Debraccio
94	01/12/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Additional PREP Act Decisions	002	Steven Vincent Debraccio
95	04/03/2024	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE	Ltr enclosing supplemental authority (Hasan)	002	Steven Vincent Debraccio
96	07/20/2024	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE		002	Wilbert Mendez Marrero
97	07/20/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Holder v Jacob (First Dept - July 18, 2024)	002	Wilbert Mendez Marrero
98	07/20/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Damon v Clove Lakes (2nd Dept - June 5, 2024)	002	Wilbert Mendez Marrero
99	07/20/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Kluska v Montefiore (2nd Dept. - May 1, 2024)	002	Wilbert Mendez Marrero
100	07/23/2024	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE		002	Steven Vincent Debraccio
101	10/09/2024	ORDER - MOTION- SHORT FORM		002	Brenda Sutton Jeffers
102	12/15/2024	NOTICE OF MOTION		003	Steven Vincent Debraccio
103	12/15/2024	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION		003	Steven Vincent Debraccio
104	12/15/2024	MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN SUPPORT		003	Steven Vincent Debraccio
105	12/15/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Fed Reg re PREP Act	003	Steven Vincent Debraccio
106	12/15/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Affidavit of Arleen Comrie	003	Steven Vincent Debraccio
107	12/15/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	pre-COVID Infection Control Policies	003	Steven Vincent Debraccio
108	12/15/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	COVID-19 Policies and Procedures	003	Steven Vincent Debraccio
109	12/15/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	NYS DOH Advisory Mar. 16, 2020	003	Steven Vincent Debraccio
110	12/15/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	NYS DOH Advisory Mar. 21, 2020	003	Steven Vincent Debraccio
111	12/15/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	NYS DOH Advisory Mar. 25, 2020	003	Steven Vincent Debraccio
112	12/15/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	NYS DOH Advisory Apr. 2, 2020	003	Steven Vincent Debraccio
113	12/15/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	NYS DOH Advisory Apr. 8, 2020	003	Steven Vincent Debraccio
114	12/15/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Decedent's Redacted Progress Notes	003	Steven Vincent Debraccio
115	12/15/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Decedent's Redacted Physician's Notes	003	Steven Vincent Debraccio
116	12/15/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Decedent's Redacted Care Plans	003	Steven Vincent Debraccio
117	12/15/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Decedent's Redacted Lab Results	003	Steven Vincent Debraccio
118	12/15/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Summons and Verified Complaint	003	Steven Vincent Debraccio
119	12/15/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Verified Amended Complaint	003	Steven Vincent Debraccio
120	12/15/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Stipulation to Extend Time to Appear	003	Steven Vincent Debraccio
121	12/15/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Filed Prior NOM for MTD	003	Steven Vincent Debraccio
122	12/15/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Decision and Order on Prior MTD	003	Steven Vincent Debraccio
123	12/15/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Unreported Cases	003	Steven Vincent Debraccio
124	12/15/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Multiple Summonses and Verified Complaints	003	Steven Vincent Debraccio
125	12/15/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Executive Order 202.10	003	Steven Vincent Debraccio
126	12/15/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Lattrell Affidavit for MTD in Whitehead case	003	Steven Vincent Debraccio
127	12/15/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Slater Affidavit for MTD in Hasan case	003	Steven Vincent Debraccio
128	12/15/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Attorney Affirmation for Mera MTD	003	Steven Vincent Debraccio
129	12/15/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Physician Affirmation in Mera MTD	003	Steven Vincent Debraccio
130	12/15/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Table of Contents for Martinez ROA	003	Steven Vincent Debraccio
131	12/15/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Physician Affirmation for Martinez MTD	003	Steven Vincent Debraccio
132	12/15/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Summons and Verified Complaint in Whitehead	003	Steven Vincent Debraccio
133	12/15/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Summons and Verified Complaint in Hasan	003	Steven Vincent Debraccio
134	12/15/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Reply Brief in Hasan	003	Steven Vincent Debraccio
135	12/15/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Advisory Opinion 20-01	003	Steven Vincent Debraccio
136	12/15/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Advisory Opinion 20-04	003	Steven Vincent Debraccio
137	12/15/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Advisory Opinion 21-01	003	Steven Vincent Debraccio
138	12/15/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Response Letter	003	Steven Vincent Debraccio
139	12/15/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	85 Fed Reg 110	003	Steven Vincent Debraccio
140	12/15/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	82 Fed Reg 243	003	Steven Vincent Debraccio
141	12/15/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	85 Fed Reg 52	003	Steven Vincent Debraccio
142	12/15/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	85 Fed Reg 237	003	Steven Vincent Debraccio
143	12/15/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Summons and Verified Complaint in Kluska	003	Steven Vincent Debraccio
144	02/16/2025	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION		003	Wilbert Mendez Marrero
145	02/16/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	WHO Situation Report 3	003	Wilbert Mendez Marrero
146	02/16/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	CMS Information for Healthcare Facilities Concerning 2019 Novel Coronavirus Illness (2019-nCoV)	003	Wilbert Mendez Marrero
147	02/16/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	NYDOH Report 2020-S-55 dated March 2022: Use, Collection, and Reporting of Infection Control Data	003	Wilbert Mendez Marrero
148	02/16/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Guidance for Resident and Family Communication in Adult Care Facilities and Nursing Homes	003	Wilbert Mendez Marrero
149	02/16/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Final Rule Updating Requirements for Notification of Confirmed and Suspected COVID-19 Cases Among Residents and Staff in Nursing Homes	003	Wilbert Mendez Marrero
150	02/16/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Affirmation from Vicky Sgagias	003	Wilbert Mendez Marrero
151	02/16/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Medicare Brookhaven Staffing Data	003	Wilbert Mendez Marrero
152	02/16/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Emergency Preparedness Requirements for Medicare and Medicaid Participating Providers and Suppliers	003	Wilbert Mendez Marrero
153	02/16/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Excerpt from Transcript of NYS Assembly Session - July 23, 2020	003	Wilbert Mendez Marrero
154	02/16/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Labianca v. Waterview Acquisition I LLC et al	003	Wilbert Mendez Marrero
155	02/16/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	The Estate of Linda Nixon v. Pharney Group LLC	003	Wilbert Mendez Marrero
156	02/16/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Est. of Roote v. Elcor Operating Company LLC	003	Wilbert Mendez Marrero
157	02/16/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Multiple Trial Court Decisions	003	Wilbert Mendez Marrero
158	02/16/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Glixon v. Highland Care Center Inc	003	Wilbert Mendez Marrero
159	02/16/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	The Estate of Dorothy Hill v. West Lawerence Care Center LLC	003	Wilbert Mendez Marrero
160	02/16/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Murray v. Staten Island Care Ctr.	003	Wilbert Mendez Marrero
161	02/24/2025	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN REPLY		003	Steven Vincent Debraccio
162	02/24/2025	MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN REPLY		003	Steven Vincent Debraccio
163	02/24/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Other Affirmations in EDTPA MTDs	003	Steven Vincent Debraccio
164	02/24/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Other Unreported Decisions	003	Steven Vincent Debraccio
165	02/24/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Table of Contents for Holder Record on Appeal	003	Steven Vincent Debraccio
166	02/24/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Table of Contents for Whitehead Record on Appeal	003	Steven Vincent Debraccio
167	02/24/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Table of Contents for Damon Record on Appeal and Attorney Affirmation for MTD	003	Steven Vincent Debraccio
168	08/23/2025	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE	Ltr enclosing supplemental authority (Lara, Hyman, and Estate of Pierro)	003	Steven Vincent Debraccio
169	09/24/2025	STIPULATION - SO ORDERED			Erica Nieves
170	01/16/2026	STIPULATION - SO ORDERED			Erica Nieves
171	01/16/2026	STIPULATION - SO ORDERED	TO EXTEND DEADLINE FOR NOTE OF ISSUE		Kathleen Batyr
172	03/23/2026	ORDER - MOTION- SHORT FORM		003	Tulun Ahmed
173	03/24/2026	NOTICE OF ENTRY		003	Mary Ann Candelario
174	03/24/2026	NOTICE OF APPEAL/INFORMATIONAL STATEMENT/COPY OF ORDER/PROOF OF SERVICE		003	Steven Vincent Debraccio
175	04/03/2026	ANSWER			Steven Vincent Debraccio
176	04/23/2026	NOTICE OF MOTION		004	Steven Vincent Debraccio
177	04/23/2026	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION		004	Steven Vincent Debraccio
178	04/23/2026	MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN SUPPORT		004	Steven Vincent Debraccio
179	04/23/2026	EXHIBIT(S)	Notice of Entry of Prior Decision and Order	004	Steven Vincent Debraccio
180	04/23/2026	EXHIBIT(S)	Carey Decision and Order on Motion to Renew	004	Steven Vincent Debraccio
181	04/23/2026	EXHIBIT(S)	Summons and Verified Complaint in Estate of Pierro	004	Steven Vincent Debraccio
182	04/23/2026	EXHIBIT(S)	Summons and Verified Complaint in Byington	004	Steven Vincent Debraccio
183	04/23/2026	EXHIBIT(S)	Summons and Verified Complaint in Costiera	004	Steven Vincent Debraccio
184	04/23/2026	EXHIBIT(S)	Summons and Verified Complaint in Estate of Middleton	004	Steven Vincent Debraccio
185	04/23/2026	EXHIBIT(S)	Summons and Verified Complaint in Lara	004	Steven Vincent Debraccio
186	04/23/2026	EXHIBIT(S)	TOC for ROA in Estate of Pierro and Affidavits in Support of MTD	004	Steven Vincent Debraccio
187	04/23/2026	EXHIBIT(S)	TOC for ROA in Byington and Affidavit in Support of MTD	004	Steven Vincent Debraccio
188	04/23/2026	EXHIBIT(S)	TOC for ROA in Costiera and Affidavit and Affirmation in Support of MTD	004	Steven Vincent Debraccio
189	04/23/2026	EXHIBIT(S)	TOC for ROA in Estate of Middleton and Affirmation in Support of MTD	004	Steven Vincent Debraccio
190	05/20/2026	DEMAND FOR:	Combined Demands		Mary Ann Candelario
191	05/20/2026	NOTICE OF DISCOVERY AND INSPECTION			Mary Ann Candelario
192	06/01/2026	ORDER - MOTION- SHORT FORM		003	Tulun Ahmed
193	06/01/2026	NOTICE OF ENTRY		003	Mary Ann Candelario
194	06/05/2026	NOTICE TO TAKE DEPOSITION			Mary Ann Candelario
195 PENDING	06/24/2026	NOTICE OF APPEAL/INFORMATIONAL STATEMENT/COPY OF ORDER/PROOF OF SERVICE		003	Steven Vincent Debraccio
196	07/01/2026	NOTICE OF MOTION		005	Steven Vincent Debraccio
197	07/01/2026	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION		005	Steven Vincent Debraccio
198	07/01/2026	MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN SUPPORT		005	Steven Vincent Debraccio
199	07/01/2026	EXHIBIT(S)	Notice of Entry of Prior Decision and Order	005	Steven Vincent Debraccio
200	07/01/2026	EXHIBIT(S)	Notice of Entry of Corrected Decision and Order	005	Steven Vincent Debraccio
201	07/01/2026	EXHIBIT(S)	Carey decision and order	005	Steven Vincent Debraccio
202	07/01/2026	EXHIBIT(S)	Estate of Pierro Complaint	005	Steven Vincent Debraccio
203	07/01/2026	EXHIBIT(S)	Byington Complaint	005	Steven Vincent Debraccio
204	07/01/2026	EXHIBIT(S)	Costiera Complaint	005	Steven Vincent Debraccio
205	07/01/2026	EXHIBIT(S)	Estate of Middleton Complaint	005	Steven Vincent Debraccio
206	07/01/2026	EXHIBIT(S)	Lara Summons and Complaint	005	Steven Vincent Debraccio
207	07/01/2026	EXHIBIT(S)	Estate of Pierro TOC for ROA and Affidavits-Affirmations	005	Steven Vincent Debraccio
208	07/01/2026	EXHIBIT(S)	Byington TOC for ROA and Nursing Aff for MTD	005	Steven Vincent Debraccio
209	07/01/2026	EXHIBIT(S)	Costiera TOC for ROA and Affirmations	005	Steven Vincent Debraccio
210	07/01/2026	EXHIBIT(S)	Estate of Middleton TOC for ROA and Affirmation	005	Steven Vincent Debraccio
211	07/01/2026	EXHIBIT(S)	Agams TOC for ROA and Complaint	005	Steven Vincent Debraccio
212	07/13/2026	NOTICE OF WITHDRAWAL OF MOTION / ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE	Ltr withdrawing prior motion to reargue and renew from prior (not corrected) decision and order and request to cancel in-person argument for 7-14-26 on prior (withdrawn) notice of motion to reargue and renew	004	Steven Vincent Debraccio

Nassau Supreme Court

2023

614848/2022

Active

Medical Malpractice

HARTLEY, JASON S. as the ADMINISTRATOR OF THE ESTATE of CLAUDETTE HARTLEY

Sacco & Fillas, LLP

EAST NECK NURSING HOME AND REHABILITATION CENTER et al

Lewis Johs Avallone Aviles, LLP

08/04/2026

Daly-Sapraicone, Hon. Eileen C.

▼

Case Info

Court

Nassau Supreme Court

Index Number

614848/2022

Status

Active

Year Filed

2023

Case Name

HARTLEY, JASON S. as the ADMINISTRATOR OF THE ESTATE of CLAUDETTE HARTLEY vs. EAST NECK NURSING HOME AND REHABILITATION CENTER et al

Case Type

Tort-Medical, Dental, or Podiatric Malpractice

Track

Complex

RJI Filed

03/03/2023

NOI Due

08/04/2026

NOI Filed

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

Daly-Sapraicone, Hon. Eileen C.

Next Appearance

08/04/2026

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

HARTLEY, JASON S. as the ADMINISTRATOR OF THE ESTATE of CLAUDETTE HARTLEY

Attorney / FirmSacco & Fillas, LLP

Defendant / Respondent

EAST NECK NURSING HOME AND REHABILITATION CENTER et al

Attorneys / FirmsLewis Johs Avallone Aviles, LLP

Motions

No motions recorded for this case.

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints (67)

Doc #	Date Filed	Document	Description	Filing User
1	10/27/2022	SUMMONS + COMPLAINT		Elliot Lon Lewis
2	10/27/2022	CERTIFICATE OF MERIT		Elliot Lon Lewis
3	10/27/2022	STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING		Elliot Lon Lewis
4	11/09/2022	PROOF OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service On Defendant East Neck Nursing Center, Inc.	Elliot Lon Lewis
5	11/09/2022	STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING		Elliot Lon Lewis
6	11/09/2022	PROOF OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service On Defendant Paljr, LLC d/b/a East Neck Nursing & Rehabilitation Center	Elliot Lon Lewis
7	11/09/2022	PROOF OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service On Defendant Long Island Community Hospital At NYU Langone Health	Elliot Lon Lewis
8	11/11/2022	PROOF OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service On Defendant Long Island Community Hospital At NYU Langone Health	Elliot Lon Lewis
9	11/11/2022	PROOF OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service On Defendant East Neck Nursing Home and Rehabilitation Center	Elliot Lon Lewis
10	11/11/2022	PROOF OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service On Defendant East Neck Nursing Center Inc.	Elliot Lon Lewis
11	11/11/2022	PROOF OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service On Defendant Paljr, LLC d/b/a East Neck Nursing & Rehabilitation Center	Elliot Lon Lewis
12	11/11/2022	PROOF OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service On Defendant Paljr, LLC d/b/a East Neck Nursing & Rehabilitation Center	Elliot Lon Lewis
13	11/21/2022	NOTICE OF COMPLIANCE	NOTICE OF COMMENCEMENT OF ACTIONS FOR PERSONAL INJURIES UNDER CPLR 306-C	Elliot Lon Lewis
14	11/28/2022	ANSWER	Verified Answer	Lisa Marie Fresolone
15	11/28/2022	DEMAND FOR BILL OF PARTICULARS	Demand for Verified Bill of Particulars	Lisa Marie Fresolone
16	11/28/2022	NOTICE OF DEPOSITION UPON ORAL EXAMINATION	Notice of Deposition Upon Oral Examination	Lisa Marie Fresolone
17	11/28/2022	DEMAND FOR:	Various Combined Discovery Demands	Lisa Marie Fresolone
18	01/06/2023	ANSWER (AMENDED)	Amended Answer	Lisa Marie Fresolone
19	01/09/2023	ANSWER	Answer re: Deft. East Neck Nursing Center, Inc.	Lisa Marie Fresolone
20	01/09/2023	DEMAND FOR BILL OF PARTICULARS	Demand for Verified Bill of Particulars	Lisa Marie Fresolone
21	01/09/2023	NOTICE OF DEPOSITION UPON ORAL EXAMINATION	Notice of Deposition Upon Oral Examination	Lisa Marie Fresolone
22	01/09/2023	DEMAND FOR:	Various Combined Discovery Demands	Lisa Marie Fresolone
23	01/17/2023	ANSWER	Answer, BP Demand and Notice of EBT	Stephen Erich Rach
24	01/17/2023	DEMAND FOR:	Combined Discovery Demands	Stephen Erich Rach
25	01/17/2023	STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING		Stephen Erich Rach
26	01/23/2023	PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE REQUEST		Elliot Lon Lewis
27	01/23/2023	NOTICE OF MEDICAL MALPRACTICE		Elliot Lon Lewis
28	01/23/2023	RJI -RE: REQUEST FOR PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE		Elliot Lon Lewis
29	03/03/2023	COURT NOTICE		Liana M Barnes
30	03/30/2023	COURT NOTICE		Joan Catterson
31	04/05/2023	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE	Plaintiff's Letter to Judge dated April 5, 2023	Elliot Lon Lewis
32	08/04/2023	COURT NOTICE	Filing on Behalf of - Hon. Rhonda E. Fischer	Lisa Carlisi
33	01/08/2024	COURT NOTICE	Filing on Behalf of - Hon. Rhonda E. Fischer	Lisa Carlisi
34	02/26/2024	COURT NOTICE	Filing on Behalf of - Hon. Rhonda E. Fischer	Lisa Carlisi
35	02/27/2024	COURT NOTICE	Filing on Behalf of - Hon. Rhonda E. Fischer	Lisa Carlisi
36	04/01/2024	COURT NOTICE	Filing on Behalf of - Hon. Rhonda E. Fischer	Lisa Carlisi
37	05/22/2024	COURT NOTICE	Filing on Behalf of - Hon. Rhonda E. Fischer	Lisa Carlisi
38	05/22/2024	COURT NOTICE		Joan Catterson
39	06/21/2024	ADJOURNMENT OF CONFERENCE -REQUEST	Redacted Death Certificate	John P Margand
40	06/25/2024	COURT NOTICE		Joan Catterson
41	08/29/2024	COURT NOTICE	Filing on Behalf of - Hon. Rhonda E. Fischer	Lisa Carlisi
42	10/21/2024	COURT NOTICE	Filing on Behalf of - Hon. Rhonda E. Fischer	Lisa Carlisi
43	11/06/2024	COURT NOTICE	Filing on Behalf of - Hon. Rhonda E. Fischer	Lisa Carlisi
44	11/08/2024	ORDER - AMENDING CAPTION		Michael J Campisi
45	11/07/2024	DEPOSITION SCHEDULE RIDER		Michael J Campisi
46	02/05/2025	COURT NOTICE	Filing on Behalf of - Hon. Rhonda E. Fischer	Lisa Carlisi
47	02/28/2025	COURT NOTICE	Filing on Behalf of - Hon. Rhonda E. Fischer	Lisa Carlisi
48	03/05/2025	STIPULATION - SO ORDERED		Michael J Campisi
49	03/26/2025	COURT NOTICE	Filing on Behalf of - Hon. Rhonda E. Fischer	Lisa Carlisi
50	03/28/2025	DEMAND FOR:	Plaintiff's Designation of Facility Witnesses dated 03-28-2025	Jennifer Anne Fleming
51	04/21/2025	STIPULATION - SO ORDERED		Michael J Campisi
52	05/14/2025	COURT NOTICE	Filing on Behalf of - Hon. Rhonda E. Fischer	Lisa Carlisi
53	06/09/2025	STIPULATION - SO ORDERED		Michael J Campisi
54	06/23/2025	COURT NOTICE	Filing on Behalf of - Hon. Rhonda E. Fischer	Lisa Carlisi
55	07/03/2025	NOTICE TO COUNTY CLERK - AMENDMENT OF CAPTION	Notice To County Clerk	Jennifer Anne Fleming
56	07/03/2025	STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING	STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING	Jennifer Anne Fleming
57	07/22/2025	COURT NOTICE	Filing on Behalf of - Hon. Rhonda E. Fischer	Lisa Carlisi
58	07/28/2025	STIPULATION - SO ORDERED		Michael J Campisi
59	09/24/2025	COURT NOTICE	Filing on Behalf of - Hon. Rhonda E. Fischer	Lisa Carlisi
60	10/15/2025	STIPULATION - SO ORDERED		Michael J Campisi
61	10/07/2025	COURT NOTICE	Filing on Behalf of - Hon. Rhonda E. Fischer	Lisa Carlisi
62	10/30/2025	STIPULATION - SO ORDERED		Michael J Campisi
63	11/03/2025	COURT NOTICE	Filing on Behalf of - Hon. Rhonda E. Fischer	Lisa Carlisi
64	01/15/2026	COURT NOTICE	Filing on Behalf of - Hon. Rhonda E. Fischer	Lisa Carlisi
65	02/02/2026	COURT NOTICE	Filing on Behalf of - Hon. Eileen C. Daly-Sapraicone, JSC	George Froehlich
66	02/17/2026	ORDER - CERTIFICATION		George Froehlich
67	05/12/2026	ORDER - OTHER	Order Extending Date to File NOI	George Froehlich

Suffolk Supreme Court

2023

203848/2022

Stayed

Negligence

Cronin by Cori Kathleen Cronin Executrix, Estate of Audrey Cronin aka Audrey Elizabeth

PATRICIA BYRNE BLAIR, ESQ.

Brookhaven Rehabilitation and Health Care Center LLC dba Brookhaven Rehabilitation and Health Care Facility

Hall Booth Smith, P.C.

08/17/2023

Nolan, Hon. George M.

▼

Case Info

Court

Suffolk Supreme Court

Index Number

203848/2022

Status

Stayed

Year Filed

2023

Case Name

Cronin by Cori Kathleen Cronin Executrix, Estate of Audrey Cronin aka Audrey Elizabeth vs. Brookhaven Rehabilitation and Health Care Center LLC dba Brookhaven Rehabilitation and Health Care Facility

Case Type

Tort-Other Negligence

Track

Standard

RJI Filed

06/30/2023

NOI Due

06/29/2024

NOI Filed

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

Nolan, Hon. George M.

Next Appearance

08/17/2023

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

Cronin by Cori Kathleen Cronin Executrix, Estate of Audrey Cronin aka Audrey Elizabeth

Attorney / FirmPATRICIA BYRNE BLAIR, ESQ.

Defendant / Respondent

Brookhaven Rehabilitation and Health Care Center LLC dba Brookhaven Rehabilitation and Health Care Facility

Attorneys / FirmsHall Booth Smith, P.C.

Motions (1)

#	Date Filed	Filed By	Relief Sought	Submit Date	Answer	Status	Decision	Order Signed
1	06/30/2023		Compel Arbitration	08/17/2023	No	Decided: 12/18/2023 Granted Before Justice: Nolan, Hon. George M.	Short Form Order	12/18/2023

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints (14)

Doc #	Date Filed	Document	Description	Motion #	Filing User
1	10/24/2022	SUMMONS + COMPLAINT	Summons and Complaint		Patricia Byrne Blair
2	06/30/2023	NOTICE OF MOTION		001	David Tawei Pan
3	06/30/2023	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT		001	David Tawei Pan
4	06/30/2023	MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN SUPPORT		001	David Tawei Pan
5	06/30/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Summons and Complaint	001	David Tawei Pan
6	06/30/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Arbitration Agreement	001	David Tawei Pan
7	06/30/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Affidavit of Connie Cortes	001	David Tawei Pan
8	06/30/2023	RJI -RE: NOTICE OF MOTION		001	David Tawei Pan
9	06/30/2023	ADDENDUM - GENERAL (840A)		001	David Tawei Pan
10	07/22/2023	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION	Attorney Affirmation in Partial Opposition	001	Patricia Byrne Blair
11	12/18/2023	ORDER - MOTION- SHORT FORM	Action stayed pending arbitration	001	Evan M Kandel
12	08/18/2025	NOTICE OF DISCOVERY AND INSPECTION	Plaintiff's Combined Demands to Defendant		Patricia Byrne Blair
13	08/18/2025	NOTICE OF DISCOVERY AND INSPECTION	Plaintiff's Notice of Discovery and Inspection to Defendant		Patricia Byrne Blair
14	08/18/2025	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service of Plaintiff's Combined Demands and Notice for Discovery and Inspection on Defendant		Patricia Byrne Blair

Suffolk Supreme Court

2023

610166/2021

Active

Medical Malpractice

Masi, Lisa

CAMACHO MAURO, LLP

Brookhaven Rehabilitation and Health Care Center

Gallardo, Levin, Reiter & Rogers, LLP

07/14/2026

Tinari, Hon. Frank A.

▼

Case Info

Court

Suffolk Supreme Court

Index Number

610166/2021

Status

Active

Year Filed

2023

Case Name

Masi, Lisa vs. Brookhaven Rehabilitation and Health Care Center

Case Type

Tort-Other Professional Malpractice

Track

Standard

RJI Filed

04/27/2023

NOI Due

06/25/2026

NOI Filed

07/01/2026

Calendar Number

202600755OT

Jury Status

Jury At Plaintiff's Request

Justice

Tinari, Hon. Frank A.

Next Appearance

07/14/2026

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

Masi, Lisa

Attorney / FirmCAMACHO MAURO, LLP

Defendant / Respondent

Brookhaven Rehabilitation and Health Care Center

Attorneys / FirmsGallardo, Levin, Reiter & Rogers, LLP

Motions (3)

#	Date Filed	Relief Sought	Submit Date	Answer	Status	Decision	Order Signed
3	10/23/2024	Protective Order	12/18/2024	No	Decided: 06/09/2025 Decided Before Justice: Tinari, Hon. Frank A.	Short Form Order	06/09/2025
2	08/18/2023	Consolidate	11/14/2023	No	Decided: 02/22/2024 Denied Before Justice: Tinari, Hon. Frank A.	Short Form Order	02/22/2024
1	04/27/2023	Discovery	05/19/2023	No	Decided: 07/21/2023 Decided Before Justice: Suffolk Supreme, DCM-Justice	Short Form Order	07/21/2023

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints (102)

Doc #	Date Filed	Document	Description	Motion #	Filing User
1	05/28/2021	SUMMONS + COMPLAINT	Summons & Complaint		Andrea S Camacho
2	08/12/2021	ANSWER	Verified Answer on behalf of Brookhaven Health Care Facility LLC i/s/a Brookhaven Rehabilitation & Health Care Center		Christopher T Rogers
3	08/12/2021	DEMAND FOR BILL OF PARTICULARS	on behalf of Brookhaven Health Care Facility, LLC i/s/a Brookhaven Rehabilitation & Health Care Center		Christopher T Rogers
4	08/12/2021	NOTICE OF DISCOVERY AND INSPECTION			Christopher T Rogers
5	08/12/2021	DEMAND FOR:	Demand for Electronic Communications Data		Christopher T Rogers
6	08/12/2021	DEMAND FOR:	Demand for Expert Witness Information		Christopher T Rogers
7	08/12/2021	NOTICE OF DEPOSITION UPON ORAL EXAMINATION			Christopher T Rogers
8	08/12/2021	DEMAND FOR:	Demand for Disclosure as to Medicare/Medicaid/Private Liens		Christopher T Rogers
9	08/12/2021	DEMAND FOR:	Supplemental Demand		Christopher T Rogers
10	11/09/2021	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service		Andrea S Camacho
11	01/18/2023	DEMAND FOR BILL OF PARTICULARS	Demand for Bill of Particulars as to Affirmative Defenses		Andrea S Camacho
12	01/18/2023	DEMAND FOR:	Combined Demands		Andrea S Camacho
13	01/18/2023	DEMAND FOR:	Combined Demands and Notice for Discovery & Inspection		Andrea S Camacho
14	01/18/2023	BILL OF PARTICULARS	Plaintiff's Bill of Particulars		Andrea S Camacho
15	01/18/2023	RESPONSE TO DEMAND	Response to Notice for Discovery & Inspection		Andrea S Camacho
16	01/18/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Ex A - Authorizations		Andrea S Camacho
17	01/18/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Ex B - Certificate of Appointment of Administrator		Andrea S Camacho
18	01/18/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Ex C -- Summons & Complaint		Andrea S Camacho
19	01/18/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Ex D - Affidavit of Service		Andrea S Camacho
20	01/18/2023	RESPONSE TO DEMAND	Response to Demand for Expert Witness Information		Andrea S Camacho
21	01/18/2023	RESPONSE TO DEMAND	Response to Demand for Authorizations		Andrea S Camacho
22	01/18/2023	RESPONSE TO DEMAND	Response to Demand for Electronic Communications Datat		Andrea S Camacho
23	01/18/2023	RESPONSE TO DEMAND	Response to Demand for Medicare-Medicaid Lien Disclosure		Andrea S Camacho
24	01/18/2023	RESPONSE TO DEMAND	Response to Supplemental Demand		Andrea S Camacho
25	04/27/2023	NOTICE OF MOTION		001	Kayla Marie Schmidt
26	04/27/2023	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION		001	Kayla Marie Schmidt
27	04/27/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	S&C	001	Kayla Marie Schmidt
28	04/27/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Answer	001	Kayla Marie Schmidt
29	04/27/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Initial Demands	001	Kayla Marie Schmidt
30	04/27/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Demands	001	Kayla Marie Schmidt
31	04/27/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	GF Ltrs	001	Kayla Marie Schmidt
32	04/27/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Plaintiff's BP	001	Kayla Marie Schmidt
33	04/27/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Plaintiff's AZ's	001	Kayla Marie Schmidt
34	04/27/2023	AFFIRMATION OF GOOD FAITH		001	Kayla Marie Schmidt
35	04/27/2023	RJI -RE: NOTICE OF MOTION		001	Kayla Marie Schmidt
36	05/18/2023	STIPULATION - OTHER	Stipulation Adjourning Adjourn Motion		Andrea S Camacho
37	07/21/2023	DECISION + ORDER ON MOTION		001	Patricia Leonard
38	07/21/2023	COURT NOTICE			Patricia Leonard
39	07/24/2023	DEMAND FOR:	Security for Costs		Richard Mark Fedrow
40	08/09/2023	PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE ORDER (PROPOSED)	Proposed PC Order and Stip		Richard Mark Fedrow
41	08/10/2023	ORDER - PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE			Pamela Oconnor
42	08/18/2023	NOTICE OF MOTION	Notice of Motion	002	Richard Mark Fedrow
43	08/18/2023	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION	Affirmation in Support	002	Richard Mark Fedrow
44	08/18/2023	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service	002	Richard Mark Fedrow
45	08/22/2023	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION		002	Sooin Lee
46	08/22/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	redacted BP as to Medford	002	Sooin Lee
47	08/22/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	redacted BP as to Brookhaven HCF	002	Sooin Lee
48	08/22/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	redacted BP as to Hamlet	002	Sooin Lee
49	08/29/2023	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT	Affirmation in Support of Motion to Consolidate	002	Tammy Anne Trees
50	08/29/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit A - Amended Summons & Complaint - 5-3-2021	002	Tammy Anne Trees
51	08/29/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit B - Verified Answer to Amended Summons & Complaint - 11-24-2021	002	Tammy Anne Trees
52	08/29/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit C - Bill of Particulars in Action #1	002	Tammy Anne Trees
53	08/29/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit D - Bill of Particulars in Action #2	002	Tammy Anne Trees
54	08/29/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit E - Bill of Particulars in Action #3	002	Tammy Anne Trees
55	08/29/2023	STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING		002	Tammy Anne Trees
56	10/17/2023	STIPULATION - ADJOURNMENT OF MOTION		002	Andrea Sacco Camacho
57	11/02/2023	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION	Affirmation in Opposition to Motion to Consolidate	002	Andrea S Camacho
58	11/02/2023	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service	002	Andrea S Camacho
59	11/08/2023	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN REPLY	Reply Affirmation in Further Support of Motion to Consolidate Three Actions	002	Tammy Anne Trees
60	11/09/2023	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN REPLY	Reply in Further Support of Motion to Consolidate	002	Sooin Lee
61	11/10/2023	RESPONSE TO DEMAND	Response to Demands for Authorizations with Affidavit of Service (4552)		Andrea S Camacho
62	11/10/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit A_Authorizations (Redacted)		Andrea S Camacho
63	11/13/2023	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN REPLY	Affirmation in Reply	002	Richard Mark Fedrow
64	11/15/2023	COURT NOTICE			Angelina Daily
65	01/16/2024	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE	Ltr. to Judge		Richard Mark Fedrow
66	02/23/2024	DECISION + ORDER ON MOTION		002	Joyce Lopez
67	07/30/2024	BILL OF PARTICULARS	Plaintiff's Supplemental Bill of Particulars		Andrea S Camacho
68	07/30/2024	RESPONSE TO DEMAND	Plaintiff's Supplemental Response to Demand for Discovery		Andrea S Camacho
70	10/22/2024	NOTICE OF DISCOVERY AND INSPECTION			Richard Mark Fedrow
71	10/23/2024	DEMAND FOR:	Demand for Authorizations		Richard Mark Fedrow
72	10/23/2024	NOTICE OF MOTION		003	Richard Mark Fedrow
73	10/23/2024	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT		003	Richard Mark Fedrow
74	10/23/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Summons and Complaint	003	Richard Mark Fedrow
75	10/23/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Defendants Verified Answer filed on August 12, 2021	003	Richard Mark Fedrow
76	10/23/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Plaintiffs Bill of Particulars dated January 18, 2023	003	Richard Mark Fedrow
77	10/23/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Plaintiffs Supplemental Bill of Particulars dated July 30, 2024	003	Richard Mark Fedrow
79	10/23/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Affidavit of Kim Purcell	003	Richard Mark Fedrow
80	11/18/2024	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION	Affirmation in Opposition	003	Andrea S Camacho
81	11/18/2024	STIPULATION - ADJOURNMENT OF MOTION		003	Richard Mark Fedrow
82	12/02/2024	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN REPLY		003	Richard Mark Fedrow
84	05/19/2025	NOTICE OF CHANGE OF FIRM NAME OR ADDRESS (POST RJI)	Notice of Change of Firm Name		Christopher T Rogers
85	06/09/2025	DECISION + ORDER ON MOTION		003	Lizette Shapiro
86	07/09/2025	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE	Letter to Judge Tinari with Court Order		Richard Mark Fedrow
87	07/09/2025	NOTIFICATION FOR SEALING	Notification of Sealing with Order (NYSCEF Doc. No. 85)		Richard Mark Fedrow
89	11/21/2025	DEMAND FOR:	Demand for Authorizations		Richard Mark Fedrow
90	01/29/2026	NOTICE OF CHANGE OF FIRM NAME OR ADDRESS (POST RJI)	Notice of Change of Firm Address		Christopher T Rogers
91	02/26/2026	RESPONSE TO DEMAND	Response for Insurance Disclosure		Richard Mark Fedrow
92	03/04/2026	DEMAND FOR:	Notice to Execute - Patricia O'Brien		Andrea Sacco Camacho
93	03/04/2026	EXHIBIT(S)	EBT of Patricia O'Brien RN 2-12-26		Andrea Sacco Camacho
94	04/07/2026	DEMAND FOR:	Post EBT Demands		Andrea Sacco Camacho
95	04/07/2026	SUBPOENA ( REQUEST TO SO ORDER )	Subpoena - Mobile Digital Imaging		Andrea Sacco Camacho
96	04/07/2026	SUBPOENA ( REQUEST TO SO ORDER )	Subpoena - Eastern Portable X-Ray Corp		Andrea Sacco Camacho
97	04/08/2026	SUBPOENA - SO ORDERED	EASTERN PORTABLE X-RAY CORP - FILM RECORDS		Andrew R Meyer
98	04/08/2026	SUBPOENA - SO ORDERED	MOBILE DIGITAL IMAGING, INC. - FILM RECORDS		Andrew R Meyer
99	04/24/2026	NOTICE OF DEPOSITION	Notice of EBT - Kim Purcell		Andrea Sacco Camacho
100	04/28/2026	NOTICE OF REJECTION	Rejection of Deposition Notice		Richard Mark Fedrow
101	05/20/2026	RESPONSE TO DEMAND	Response to Post EBT Demand		Richard Mark Fedrow
102	05/20/2026	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit A - Facility Floor Plan		Richard Mark Fedrow
103	05/20/2026	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit B - Facility Resident Rights		Richard Mark Fedrow
104	05/20/2026	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit C - Fall Prevention Poster		Richard Mark Fedrow
105	05/28/2026	ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE			Robert Macdowell
106	06/30/2026	NOTE OF ISSUE:WITH JURY	Note of Issue with Certificate of Readiness, Affirmation of Compliance with Jury Demand		Andrea Sacco Camacho

Nassau Supreme Court

2022

603888/2022

Disposed

Negligence

Crosby, Christopher

JONATHAN D'AGOSTINO & ASSOCIATES, P.C.

Brookhaven Rehabilitation and Health Care Center et al

Lewis Johs Avallone Aviles, LLP

09/28/2022

McCormack, Hon. James P.

▼

Case Info

Court

Nassau Supreme Court

Index Number

603888/2022

Status

Disposed

Year Filed

2022

Case Name

Crosby, Christopher vs. Brookhaven Rehabilitation and Health Care Center et al

Case Type

Tort-Other Negligence

Track

Standard

RJI Filed

04/19/2022

NOI Due

04/19/2023

NOI Filed

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

McCormack, Hon. James P.

Next Appearance

09/28/2022

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

Crosby, Christopher

Attorney / FirmJONATHAN D'AGOSTINO & ASSOCIATES, P.C.

Defendant / Respondent

Brookhaven Rehabilitation and Health Care Center et al

Attorneys / FirmsLewis Johs Avallone Aviles, LLP

Motions

No motions recorded for this case.

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints (35)

Doc #	Date Filed	Document	Description	Motion #	Filing User
1	05/27/2020	SUMMONS + COMPLAINT			Glen Devora
2	06/15/2020	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE			Glen Devora
3	06/15/2020	STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING			Glen Devora
4	06/24/2020	ANSWER	Verified Answer		James Patrick Connors
5	06/24/2020	NOTICE OF DEPOSITION			James Patrick Connors
6	06/24/2020	DEMAND FOR BILL OF PARTICULARS			James Patrick Connors
7	06/24/2020	DEMAND FOR:	Various Discovery Demands		James Patrick Connors
8	06/26/2020	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE			Glen Devora
9	09/02/2020	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE			Glen Devora
10	09/02/2020	STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING			Glen Devora
11	11/05/2020	RJI FROM PRIOR COUNTY (COPY)	Notice of Motion to Change Venue; Original document type was RJI -RE: NOTICE OF MOTION		Timothy Dey Cameron
12	11/05/2020	NOTICE OF MOTION	Notice of Motion to Change Venue on behalf of Defendants. Ret: 12/7/20	1	Timothy Dey Cameron
13	11/05/2020	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT	Affirmation in Support of Defendants' Motion to Change Venue by Timothy Cameron, Esq.	1	Timothy Dey Cameron
14	11/05/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit A - Summons & Complaint and Answer	1	Timothy Dey Cameron
15	11/05/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit B - Brookhaven Admission	1	Timothy Dey Cameron
16	11/05/2020	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE		1	Timothy Dey Cameron
17	11/28/2020	PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE REQUEST	Crosby Christopher-Preliminary Conference Request		Glen Devora
18	11/28/2020	AFFIDAVIT	Crosby Christopher-Affidavit of service		Glen Devora
19	12/04/2020	STIPULATION - ADJOURNMENT OF MOTION		1	Glen Devora
20	12/11/2020	NOTIFICATION FROM COURT	Re: Kings County Supreme Civil Court Mediation Program		Michael Habich
21	03/17/2021	ORDER - PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE			Maura Alliano
22	04/21/2021	NOTICE	MOTION PART 83 RULES		Tishawna Woodson
23	04/30/2021	ORDER - TRANSFER - CHANGE OF VENUE		1	Tishawna Woodson
24	05/24/2021	NOTICE OF DISCOVERY AND INSPECTION	Def Brookhaven - NDI for Pltf's SS Records		Timothy Dey Cameron
25	05/24/2021	NOTICE OF DISCOVERY AND INSPECTION	Def Brookhaven - NDI for Pltf's Tax Returns		Timothy Dey Cameron
26	03/25/2022	NOTICE OF ENTRY		1	Timothy Dey Cameron
27	03/25/2022	NOTICE TO COUNTY CLERK CPLR 8019(C)		1	Timothy Dey Cameron
28	03/25/2022	COUNTY CLERK CERTIFICATION OF MINUTES			Craig Schatzman
29	11/05/2020	RJI -RE: REQUEST FOR PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE			Timothy Dey Cameron
30	03/31/2022	PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE REQUEST			Timothy Dey Cameron
31	04/19/2022	COURT NOTICE			Deirdre A Smith
32	05/18/2022	PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE ORDER (PROPOSED)			Glen Devora
33	05/19/2022	COURT NOTICE			Joan Catterson
34	06/13/2022	ORDER - PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE			Eric Justvig
35	09/21/2022	STIPULATION - DISCONTINUANCE (POST RJI)			Timothy Dey Cameron

Nassau Supreme Court

2021

604950/2020

Disposed

OM-Other

BROOKHAVEN REHABILITATION

Abrams Fensterman, LLP

ENILE, BEATRICE

03/19/2021

Sullivan, Hon. David P.

▼

Case Info

Court

Nassau Supreme Court

Index Number

604950/2020

Status

Disposed

Year Filed

2021

Case Name

BROOKHAVEN REHABILITATION vs. ENILE, BEATRICE

Case Type

OM-Other

Track

Standard

RJI Filed

01/15/2021

NOI Due

01/15/2022

NOI Filed

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

Sullivan, Hon. David P.

Next Appearance

03/19/2021

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

BROOKHAVEN REHABILITATION

Attorney / FirmAbrams Fensterman, LLP

Defendant / Respondent

ENILE, BEATRICE

Attorneys / Firms

Motions (1)

#	Date Filed	Filed By	Relief Sought	Submit Date	Answer	Status	Decision	Order Signed
1	01/19/2021		Judgment - Default	03/19/2021	Yes	Decided: 03/19/2021 Closed Before Justice: Sullivan, Hon. David P.	Short Form Order	03/19/2021

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints (25)

Doc #	Date Filed	Document	Description	Motion #	Filing User
1	05/28/2020	SUMMONS + COMPLAINT			Jeffrey Robert Neuman
2	06/30/2020	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE			Jeffrey Robert Neuman
3	06/30/2020	STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING			Jeffrey Robert Neuman
4	01/15/2021	NOTICE OF MOTION		001	Andrew St. Patrick Ferguson
5	01/15/2021	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION	Attorney Affirmation	001	Andrew St. Patrick Ferguson
6	01/15/2021	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION	Mason Affidavit	001	Andrew St. Patrick Ferguson
7	01/15/2021	AFFIRMATION	Affirmation of Non-Military Investigation	001	Andrew St. Patrick Ferguson
8	01/15/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Brookhaven Invoice	001	Andrew St. Patrick Ferguson
9	01/15/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Medicaid Budget	001	Andrew St. Patrick Ferguson
10	01/15/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	No Estate	001	Andrew St. Patrick Ferguson
11	01/15/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Last Owner Search - 502 Willow Lane, Valley Stream	001	Andrew St. Patrick Ferguson
12	01/15/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Summons and Verified Complaint	001	Andrew St. Patrick Ferguson
13	01/15/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Affidavit of Service	001	Andrew St. Patrick Ferguson
14	01/15/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	CPLR 3215(g) Default Notice	001	Andrew St. Patrick Ferguson
15	01/15/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Sale of Jointly Owned Property	001	Andrew St. Patrick Ferguson
16	01/15/2021	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE		001	Andrew St. Patrick Ferguson
17	01/15/2021	RJI -RE: NOTICE OF MOTION		001	Andrew St. Patrick Ferguson
18	03/23/2021	ORDER - OTHER		001	Arlene A Tiercy
19	03/22/2021	NOTICE OF ENTRY			Andrew St. Patrick Ferguson
20	03/22/2021	JUDGMENT -TO COURT (PROPOSED)			Andrew St. Patrick Ferguson
21	03/22/2021	BILL OF COSTS			Andrew St. Patrick Ferguson
22	03/22/2021	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE			Andrew St. Patrick Ferguson
23	05/04/2021	JUDGMENT			Venkata Penugonda
24	05/12/2021	NOTICE OF ENTRY			Andrew St. Patrick Ferguson
25	05/12/2021	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Notice of Entry		Andrew St. Patrick Ferguson

Kings Supreme Court

2021

526687/2019

Disposed

Medical Malpractice

Paul, Marie

Burdo, Rubin & Sachs, Esqs.

Brookhaven Rehabilitation and Health Care Center, LLC

Lewis Johs Avallone Aviles, LLP

02/28/2024

Spodek, Hon. Ellen M.

▼

Case Info

Court

Kings Supreme Court

Index Number

526687/2019

Status

Disposed

Year Filed

2021

Case Name

Paul, Marie vs. Brookhaven Rehabilitation and Health Care Center, LLC

Case Type

Tort-Medical, Dental, or Podiatric Malpractice

Track

Complex

RJI Filed

03/31/2021

NOI Due

04/12/2024

NOI Filed

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

Spodek, Hon. Ellen M.

Next Appearance

02/28/2024

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

Paul, Marie

Attorney / FirmBurdo, Rubin & Sachs, Esqs.

Defendant / Respondent

Brookhaven Rehabilitation and Health Care Center, LLC

Attorneys / FirmsLewis Johs Avallone Aviles, LLP

Motions (1)

#	Date Filed	Filed By	Relief Sought	Submit Date	Answer	Status	Decision	Order Signed
1	04/01/2021		Leave to File	05/07/2021	No	Decided: 05/07/2021 Granted Before Justice: Spodek, Hon. Ellen M.	Oral

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints (18)

Doc #	Date Filed	Document	Description	Motion #	Filing User
1	12/09/2019	SUMMONS + COMPLAINT			Michael Bruce Grossman
2	12/30/2019	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE			Michael Bruce Grossman
3	03/05/2020	ANSWER			James Patrick Connors
4	03/05/2020	NOTICE OF DEPOSITION			James Patrick Connors
5	03/05/2020	DEMAND FOR BILL OF PARTICULARS			James Patrick Connors
6	03/05/2020	DEMAND FOR:	Various Demands		James Patrick Connors
7	03/31/2021	NOTICE OF MOTION		1	Michael Bruce Grossman
8	03/31/2021	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION		1	Michael Bruce Grossman
9	03/31/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Notice of Medical Malpractice	1	Michael Bruce Grossman
10	03/31/2021	RJI -RE: NOTICE OF MEDICAL, DENTAL OR PODIATRIC MALPRACTICE		1	Michael Bruce Grossman
11	05/25/2021	ORDER - PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE			Maura Alliano
12	11/19/2021	ORDER ( PROPOSED )	Proposed Compliance Conference Order		Lisa Marie Fresolone
13	11/23/2021	ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE	Dated: 11/19/2021		Jazmin Sutherland
14	08/24/2022	ORDER ( PROPOSED )			Michael Bruce Grossman
15	08/31/2022	ORDER - FINAL	Dated: 08/26/2022		Jazmin Sutherland
16	03/13/2023	ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE			Michelle Shamell
17	02/26/2024	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE			Steven Lance Sachs
18	11/08/2024	STIPULATION - DISCONTINUANCE (POST RJI)	Stipulation of Discontinuance		Lisa Marie Fresolone

Queens Supreme Court

2020

724183/2020

Disposed

Tort

STANISZIEWSKI, RONALD

CELESTIN, DANIEL ETAL

MULTIVIZ HEALTH MANAGEMENT CORP.

02/28/2021

Golia, Hon. Donna Marie

▼

Case Info

Court

Queens Supreme Court

Index Number

724183/2020

Status

Disposed

Year Filed

2020

Case Name

STANISZIEWSKI, RONALD vs. CELESTIN, DANIEL ETAL

Case Type

Tort-Motor Vehicle

Track

Complex

RJI Filed

12/14/2020

NOI Due

03/17/2022

NOI Filed

07/25/2016

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Jury At Plaintiff's Request

Justice

Golia, Hon. Donna Marie

Next Appearance

02/28/2021

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

STANISZIEWSKI, RONALD

Attorney / Firm

Defendant / Respondent

CELESTIN, DANIEL ETAL

Attorneys / FirmsMULTIVIZ HEALTH MANAGEMENT CORP.

Motions (8)

#	Date Filed	Filed By	Relief Sought	Submit Date	Answer	Status	Decision	Order Signed
8	02/02/2021	DEFENDANT	Restore	02/22/2021	No	Decided: 02/28/2021 Closed Before Justice: Golia, Hon. Donna Marie	Short Form Order	02/28/2021
7	01/27/2021	DEFENDANT	Restore	01/29/2021	No	Decided: 01/29/2021 Declined to Sign Before Justice: Golia, Hon. Donna Marie	Oral	01/29/2021
6	10/02/2020	DEFENDANT	Dismiss	12/03/2020	Yes	Decided: 06/10/2021 Granted Before Justice: Hom, Hon. Phillip	Short Form Order
5	08/15/2016	DEFENDANT	Discovery	11/16/2016	Yes	Decided: 12/14/2016 Withdrawn Before Justice: Pineda-Kirwan, Hon. Diccia T.	Oral	12/14/2016
4	06/24/2016	PLAINTIFF	Renew/Reargue/Resettle/Reconsider	07/20/2016	No	Decided: 08/04/2016 Granted Before Justice: Pineda-Kirwan, Hon. Diccia T.	Short Form Order	08/04/2016
3	05/16/2016	PLAINTIFF	Attorney - Disqualify/Relieve/Substitute/Withdraw	05/19/2016	No	Decided: 05/19/2016 Declined to Sign Before Justice: Pineda-Kirwan, Hon. Diccia T.	Oral	05/19/2016
2	04/07/2016	PLAINTIFF	Attorney - Disqualify/Relieve/Substitute/Withdraw	04/14/2016	No	Decided: 04/14/2016 Declined to Sign Before Justice: Pineda-Kirwan, Hon. Diccia T.	Oral	04/14/2016
1	10/23/2015	PLAINTIFF	Extend - Time	11/16/2015	Yes	Decided: 01/13/2016 Withdrawn Before Justice: Pineda-Kirwan, Hon. Diccia T.	Oral	01/13/2016

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints (40)

Doc #	Date Filed	Document	Description	Motion #	Filing User
1	12/14/2020	COUNTY CLERK MINUTES -PRIOR TO CONVERSION			Jerome D White
2	12/14/2020	RJI -RE: REQUEST FOR PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE			Jerome D White
3	12/14/2020	CONSENT TO EFILING	LETTER APPLICATION SIGNED		Jerome D White
4	01/19/2021	ACKNOWLEDGEMENT OF SERVICE	Approval and Notice of Conversion to E-File with proof of service and cover letter		Colin Rathje
5	01/21/2021	ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE ( PROPOSED )	To So Order Stipulation of Discontinuance	007	Colin Rathje
6	01/21/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Stipulation of Discontinuance	007	Colin Rathje
7	01/21/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Summons and Complaint	007	Colin Rathje
8	01/21/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Moving Defendants' Answers	007	Colin Rathje
9	01/21/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Other Defendants' Answers	007	Colin Rathje
10	01/21/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Note of Issue	007	Colin Rathje
11	01/21/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Order Relieving Plaintiff's Counsel	007	Colin Rathje
12	01/21/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Defendant Brookhaven Communication	007	Colin Rathje
13	01/29/2021	ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE	DECLINED.	007	Francis Rus
14	01/21/2021	ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE ( PROPOSED )		008	Colin Rathje
15	01/31/2021	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION	Updated to include information requested by the Court on the prior application	008	Colin Rathje
16	01/31/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Stipulation of Discontinuance	008	Colin Rathje
17	01/31/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Summons and Complaint	008	Colin Rathje
18	01/31/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Moving Defendants' Answers	008	Colin Rathje
19	01/31/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Defendants' Answers	008	Colin Rathje
20	01/31/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Note of Issue	008	Colin Rathje
21	01/31/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Order with Notice of Entry relieving plaintiff's counsel and imposing a stay	008	Colin Rathje
22	01/31/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Defendant Brookhaven Communication	008	Colin Rathje
23	02/04/2021	ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE	seq # 8	008	Frank Giovinco
24	02/10/2021	ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE - CONFORMED COPY	signed order to show cause to lift stay and so order discontinuance.pdf	008	Colin Rathje
25	02/10/2021	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT	Updated Affirmation In Support.pdf	008	Colin Rathje
26	02/10/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit A - Stip of Disc.pdf	008	Colin Rathje
27	02/10/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit B -summons and complaint	008	Colin Rathje
28	02/10/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit C Moving Defendants Answers.pdf	008	Colin Rathje
29	02/10/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit D Defendants Answers.pdf	008	Colin Rathje
30	02/10/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit E Note of Issue.pdf	008	Colin Rathje
31	02/10/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit F - Order with Notice of Entry	008	Colin Rathje
32	02/10/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit G Defendant Brookhaven Communication.pdf	008	Colin Rathje
33	02/10/2021	AFFIDAVIT	affidavit of service - certified mail receipt	008	Colin Rathje
34	02/10/2021	AFFIDAVIT	Second Affidavit of Service	008	Colin Rathje
35	03/01/2021	DECISION + ORDER ON MOTION	SO-ORDERED STIPULATION OF DISCONTINUANCE ATTACHED	008	Hellen Williams
36	03/01/2021	NOTICE OF ENTRY	Lifting Stay and Granting Discontinuance to Defendants Barnard, Khanina and Multiviz	008	Colin Rathje
37	06/10/2021	ORDER - MOTION- SHORT FORM		007	Aimee Lopez
38	06/10/2021	ORDER - MOTION- SHORT FORM		008	Aimee Lopez
39	06/11/2021	NOTICE OF ENTRY			Pamela M. Gleit
40	07/02/2021	STIPULATION - DISCONTINUANCE (POST RJI)	Stipulation of Discontinuance with Prejudice		Ruth Corcoran

Queens Supreme Court

2020

700169/2020

Disposed

Tort

BROOKHAVEN REHABILITATION

Abrams Fensterman, LLP

HUBBARD, MICHELLE

02/10/2021

Weiss, Hon. Allan B.

▼

Case Info

Court

Queens Supreme Court

Index Number

700169/2020

Status

Disposed

Year Filed

2020

Case Name

BROOKHAVEN REHABILITATION vs. HUBBARD, MICHELLE

Case Type

Tort-Other

Track

Standard

RJI Filed

11/17/2020

NOI Due

11/17/2021

NOI Filed

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

Weiss, Hon. Allan B.

Next Appearance

02/10/2021

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

BROOKHAVEN REHABILITATION

Attorney / FirmAbrams Fensterman, LLP

Defendant / Respondent

HUBBARD, MICHELLE

Attorneys / Firms

Motions (1)

#	Date Filed	Filed By	Relief Sought	Submit Date	Answer	Status	Decision	Order Signed
1	11/18/2020		Judgment - Default	01/20/2021	Yes	Decided: 02/10/2021 Granted Before Justice: Weiss, Hon. Allan B.	Short Form Order	02/10/2021

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints (27)

Doc #	Date Filed	Document	Description	Motion #	Filing User
1	01/06/2020	SUMMONS + COMPLAINT			Jeffrey Robert Neuman
2	02/12/2020	AFFIDAVIT			Jeffrey Robert Neuman
3	02/12/2020	STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING			Jeffrey Robert Neuman
4	04/01/2020	PROOF OF SERVICE			Jeffrey Robert Neuman
5	06/15/2020	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE			Jeffrey Robert Neuman
6	06/15/2020	STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING			Jeffrey Robert Neuman
7	11/17/2020	NOTICE OF MOTION		001	Jeffrey Robert Neuman
8	11/17/2020	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION	Affirmation in Support	001	Jeffrey Robert Neuman
9	11/17/2020	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION	Affidavit in Support	001	Jeffrey Robert Neuman
10	11/17/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Invoice	001	Jeffrey Robert Neuman
11	11/17/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Medicaid Budget	001	Jeffrey Robert Neuman
12	11/17/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Summons & Verified Complaint	001	Jeffrey Robert Neuman
13	11/17/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Affidavit of Service (filed on February 12, 2020)	001	Jeffrey Robert Neuman
14	11/17/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Affidavit of Service (filed on June 15, 2020)	001	Jeffrey Robert Neuman
15	11/17/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Notice	001	Jeffrey Robert Neuman
16	11/17/2020	AFFIRMATION	Affirmation of Non-Military Investigation	001	Jeffrey Robert Neuman
17	11/17/2020	AFFIDAVIT		001	Jeffrey Robert Neuman
18	11/17/2020	RJI -RE: NOTICE OF MOTION		001	Jeffrey Robert Neuman
19	12/09/2020	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE	Copy of Letter to Defendant re: Return Date	001	Jeffrey Robert Neuman
20	02/10/2021	ORDER - MOTION- SHORT FORM		001	Ronald Grayson
21	02/15/2021	NOTICE OF ENTRY		001	Jeffrey Robert Neuman
22	02/15/2021	JUDGMENT - CLERK DEFAULT (PROPOSED)			Jeffrey Robert Neuman
23	02/15/2021	BILL OF COSTS			Jeffrey Robert Neuman
24	02/15/2021	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service		Jeffrey Robert Neuman
25	02/19/2021	JUDGMENT -TO COUNTY CLERK (PROPOSED)			Jeffrey Robert Neuman
26	02/22/2021	JUDGMENT	Money Judgment		Keelin M Reilly
27	02/24/2021	NOTICE OF ENTRY		001	Jeffrey Robert Neuman

Nassau Supreme Court

2020

608855/2020

Disposed

OM-Other

BROOKHAVEN REHABILITATION

Abrams Fensterman, LLP

JP MORGAN CHASE BANK, N.A.

Stagg Wabnik Law Group, LLP

10/16/2020

Mahon, Hon. Roy S.

▼

Case Info

Court

Nassau Supreme Court

Index Number

608855/2020

Status

Disposed

Year Filed

2020

Case Name

BROOKHAVEN REHABILITATION vs. JP MORGAN CHASE BANK, N.A.

Case Type

OM-Other

Track

Complex

RJI Filed

08/24/2020

NOI Due

11/25/2021

NOI Filed

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

Mahon, Hon. Roy S.

Next Appearance

10/16/2020

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

BROOKHAVEN REHABILITATION

Attorney / FirmAbrams Fensterman, LLP

Defendant / Respondent

JP MORGAN CHASE BANK, N.A.

Attorneys / FirmsStagg Wabnik Law Group, LLP

Motions (1)

#	Date Filed	Filed By	Relief Sought	Submit Date	Answer	Status	Decision	Order Signed
1	08/26/2020		Other	10/16/2020	No	Decided: 01/05/2021 Closed Before Justice: Mahon, Hon. Roy S.	Short Form Order	01/05/2021

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints (17)

Doc #	Date Filed	Document	Description	Motion #	Filing User
1	08/24/2020	PETITION			Andrew St. Patrick Ferguson
2	08/24/2020	ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE ( PROPOSED )		1	Andrew St. Patrick Ferguson
3	08/24/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Brookhaven Invoice		Andrew St. Patrick Ferguson
4	08/24/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	New York State Department of Health Medicaid Summary		Andrew St. Patrick Ferguson
5	08/24/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Medicaid Budget		Andrew St. Patrick Ferguson
6	08/24/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Check to Brookhaven from Lucille Chisolm		Andrew St. Patrick Ferguson
7	08/24/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Obituary - Lucille Chisolm		Andrew St. Patrick Ferguson
8	08/24/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	No Estate		Andrew St. Patrick Ferguson
9	08/24/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Proposed Judicial Subpoena Duces Tecum		Andrew St. Patrick Ferguson
10	08/24/2020	RJI -RE: ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE			Andrew St. Patrick Ferguson
11	09/15/2020	ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE		1	Joann Shea
12	09/15/2020	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE		1	Andrew St. Patrick Ferguson
13	10/15/2020	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE		1	Michelle E Tarson
14	10/15/2020	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE		1	Michelle E Tarson
15	01/15/2021	ORDER - OTHER		1	Arlene A Tiercy
16	01/07/2021	NOTICE OF ENTRY			Andrew St. Patrick Ferguson
17	01/15/2021	NOTICE OF ENTRY	Amended		Andrew St. Patrick Ferguson

Kings Supreme Court

2020

508039/2020

Disposed

Negligence

CROSBY, CHRISTOPHER

JONATHAN D'AGOSTINO & ASSOCIATES, P.C.

BROOKHAVEN REHABILITATION

Lewis Johs Avallone Aviles, LLP

08/03/2021

Joseph, Hon. Ingrid

▼

Case Info

Court

Kings Supreme Court

Index Number

508039/2020

Status

Disposed

Year Filed

2020

Case Name

CROSBY, CHRISTOPHER vs. BROOKHAVEN REHABILITATION

Case Type

Tort-Other Negligence

Track

Standard

RJI Filed

11/05/2020

NOI Due

11/23/2021

NOI Filed

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

Joseph, Hon. Ingrid

Next Appearance

08/03/2021

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

CROSBY, CHRISTOPHER

Attorney / FirmJONATHAN D'AGOSTINO & ASSOCIATES, P.C.

Defendant / Respondent

BROOKHAVEN REHABILITATION

Attorneys / FirmsLewis Johs Avallone Aviles, LLP

Motions (1)

#	Date Filed	Filed By	Relief Sought	Submit Date	Answer	Status	Decision	Order Signed
1	11/06/2020		Change Venue	04/28/2021	Yes	Decided: 04/28/2021 Granted Before Justice: Joseph, Hon. Ingrid	Short Form Order	04/28/2021

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints (35)

Doc #	Date Filed	Document	Description	Motion #	Filing User
1	05/27/2020	SUMMONS + COMPLAINT			Glen Devora
2	06/15/2020	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE			Glen Devora
3	06/15/2020	STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING			Glen Devora
4	06/24/2020	ANSWER	Verified Answer		James Patrick Connors
5	06/24/2020	NOTICE OF DEPOSITION			James Patrick Connors
6	06/24/2020	DEMAND FOR BILL OF PARTICULARS			James Patrick Connors
7	06/24/2020	DEMAND FOR:	Various Discovery Demands		James Patrick Connors
8	06/26/2020	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE			Glen Devora
9	09/02/2020	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE			Glen Devora
10	09/02/2020	STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING			Glen Devora
11	11/05/2020	RJI FROM PRIOR COUNTY (COPY)	Notice of Motion to Change Venue; Original document type was RJI -RE: NOTICE OF MOTION		Timothy Dey Cameron
12	11/05/2020	NOTICE OF MOTION	Notice of Motion to Change Venue on behalf of Defendants. Ret: 12/7/20	1	Timothy Dey Cameron
13	11/05/2020	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT	Affirmation in Support of Defendants' Motion to Change Venue by Timothy Cameron, Esq.	1	Timothy Dey Cameron
14	11/05/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit A - Summons & Complaint and Answer	1	Timothy Dey Cameron
15	11/05/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit B - Brookhaven Admission	1	Timothy Dey Cameron
16	11/05/2020	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE		1	Timothy Dey Cameron
17	11/28/2020	PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE REQUEST	Crosby Christopher-Preliminary Conference Request		Glen Devora
18	11/28/2020	AFFIDAVIT	Crosby Christopher-Affidavit of service		Glen Devora
19	12/04/2020	STIPULATION - ADJOURNMENT OF MOTION		1	Glen Devora
20	12/11/2020	NOTIFICATION FROM COURT	Re: Kings County Supreme Civil Court Mediation Program		Michael Habich
21	03/17/2021	ORDER - PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE			Maura Alliano
22	04/21/2021	NOTICE	MOTION PART 83 RULES		Tishawna Woodson
23	04/30/2021	ORDER - TRANSFER - CHANGE OF VENUE		1	Tishawna Woodson
24	05/24/2021	NOTICE OF DISCOVERY AND INSPECTION	Def Brookhaven - NDI for Pltf's SS Records		Timothy Dey Cameron
25	05/24/2021	NOTICE OF DISCOVERY AND INSPECTION	Def Brookhaven - NDI for Pltf's Tax Returns		Timothy Dey Cameron
26	03/25/2022	NOTICE OF ENTRY		1	Timothy Dey Cameron
27	03/25/2022	NOTICE TO COUNTY CLERK CPLR 8019(C)		1	Timothy Dey Cameron
28	03/25/2022	COUNTY CLERK CERTIFICATION OF MINUTES			Craig Schatzman
29	11/05/2020	RJI -RE: REQUEST FOR PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE			Timothy Dey Cameron
30	03/31/2022	PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE REQUEST			Timothy Dey Cameron
31	04/19/2022	COURT NOTICE			Deirdre A Smith
32	05/18/2022	PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE ORDER (PROPOSED)			Glen Devora
33	05/19/2022	COURT NOTICE			Joan Catterson
34	06/13/2022	ORDER - PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE			Eric Justvig
35	09/21/2022	STIPULATION - DISCONTINUANCE (POST RJI)			Timothy Dey Cameron

Queens Supreme Court

2019

718613/2019

Disposed

Comm-Other

ORISKA CORPORATION

FRANK POLICELLI

BROOKHAVEN REHABILITATION ETAL

Cullen and Dykman LLP

12/16/2019

Elliot, Hon. David

▼

Case Info

Court

Queens Supreme Court

Index Number

718613/2019

Status

Disposed

Year Filed

2019

Case Name

ORISKA CORPORATION vs. BROOKHAVEN REHABILITATION ETAL

Case Type

Comm-Other

Track

Standard

RJI Filed

11/08/2019

NOI Due

03/27/2021

NOI Filed

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

Elliot, Hon. David

Next Appearance

12/16/2019

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

ORISKA CORPORATION

Attorney / FirmFRANK POLICELLI

Defendant / Respondent

BROOKHAVEN REHABILITATION ETAL

Attorneys / FirmsCullen and Dykman LLP

Motions (1)

#	Date Filed	Filed By	Relief Sought	Submit Date	Answer	Status	Decision	Order Signed
1	12/16/2019		Alternate Service	12/16/2019	No	Decided: 12/16/2019 Marked Off Before Justice: Latin, Hon. Richard G.	Oral	12/16/2019

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints (30)

Doc #	Date Filed	Document	Description	Motion #	Filing User	File
1	11/01/2019	SUMMONS + COMPLAINT			Frank Policelli	pdf
2	11/08/2019	EXPARTE ORDER (PROPOSED)		111	Frank Policelli
3	11/08/2019	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF PROPOSED OSC/EXPARTE APP		111	Frank Policelli
4	11/08/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	Addresses	111	Frank Policelli
5	11/08/2019	RJI FROM PRIOR COUNTY (COPY)	Original document type was RJI -RE: OTHER EX PARTE APPLICATION	111	Frank Policelli
6	11/20/2019	REQUEST FOR RESTRICTED STATUS			Frank Policelli
7	11/22/2019	NOTICE OF DISCONTINUANCE (POST RJI)			Frank Policelli
8	12/11/2019	NOTICE OF APPEARANCE (POST RJI)			James Matthew Kernan
9	12/11/2019	ANSWER			Jessica Leigh Sprague	pdf
10	12/16/2019	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE			Christopher Edward Buckey
11	12/16/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	Coordination Briefing Schedule and Stay		Christopher Edward Buckey
12	12/16/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	Motion to Coordinate		Christopher Edward Buckey
13	12/16/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	Submissions to Coordinating Panel		Christopher Edward Buckey
14	12/20/2019	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE			Frank Policelli
15	12/20/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	Affirmation in Support of Coordination		Frank Policelli
16	12/20/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	EP Chart and TOC to Panel Application		Frank Policelli
17	12/20/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	Proposed Complaint in Intervention		Frank Policelli
18	12/20/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	Affidavit		Frank Policelli
19	12/20/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	Order to Show Cause		Frank Policelli
20	05/04/2020	NOTICE OF ENTRY	Notice of Entry of Order to Coordinate in Oneida County dated April 30, 2020		Christopher Edward Buckey
21	01/27/2021	COMPLAINT (AMENDED)			Frank Policelli	pdf
22	01/27/2021	SUMMONS-SUPPLEMENTAL (POST RJI)			Frank Policelli	pdf
23	01/27/2021	NOTICE OF APPEARANCE (POST RJI)			James Matthew Kernan
24	01/27/2021	ACKNOWLEDGEMENT OF SERVICE			James Matthew Kernan
25	02/12/2021	NOTICE OF REMOVAL / REMAND (POST RJI)			James Matthew Kernan
26	09/20/2021	ORDER - ADMINISTRATIVE	TRANSFER ORDER		Jerome D White
27	09/20/2021	APPELLATE TERM ORDER (COPY)			Jerome D White
28	09/20/2021	COUNTY CLERK CERTIFICATION OF MINUTES			Jerome D White
29	09/21/2021	COURT NOTICE			Maureen Arditi
30	09/22/2021	COURT NOTICE	Filing on Behalf of - County Clerk and Supreme Court		Veronica Schmachtenberg

Queens Supreme Court

2019

704814/2019

Disposed

Negligence

GONZALEZ, JUNE

LAW OFFICES OF JONATHAN D. MANDELL

BROOKHAVEN REHABILITATION

Wilson Elser Moskowitz Edelman & Dicker LLP

03/19/2021

Compliance Conf Judge,

▼

Case Info

Court

Queens Supreme Court

Index Number

704814/2019

Status

Disposed

Year Filed

2019

Case Name

GONZALEZ, JUNE vs. BROOKHAVEN REHABILITATION

Case Type

Tort-Other Negligence

Track

Standard

RJI Filed

06/20/2019

NOI Due

06/19/2020

NOI Filed

03/18/2021

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Jury At Plaintiff's Request

Justice

Compliance Conf Judge,

Next Appearance

03/19/2021

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

GONZALEZ, JUNE

Attorney / FirmLAW OFFICES OF JONATHAN D. MANDELL

Defendant / Respondent

BROOKHAVEN REHABILITATION

Attorneys / FirmsWilson Elser Moskowitz Edelman & Dicker LLP

Motions

No motions recorded for this case.

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints (16)

Doc #	Date Filed	Document	Description	Filing User	File
1	03/20/2019	SUMMONS + COMPLAINT		Jonathan D Mandell	pdf
2	05/08/2019	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Brookhaven Rehabilitation and Health Care Center, LLC	Jonathan D Mandell
3	05/13/2019	STIPULATION - TIME TO ANSWER		Daniel E Kirshblum	pdf
4	06/03/2019	ANSWER		Daniel E Kirshblum	pdf
5	06/03/2019	DEMAND FOR:	COMBINED	Daniel E Kirshblum
6	06/20/2019	PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE REQUEST		Jonathan D Mandell
7	06/20/2019	BILL OF PARTICULARS		Jonathan D Mandell
8	06/20/2019	RJI -RE: REQUEST FOR PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE		Jonathan D Mandell
9	08/15/2019	ORDER - PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE		Caroline M Enz
10	02/27/2020	ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE		Caroline M Enz
11	03/18/2021	NOTE OF ISSUE:WITH JURY		Jonathan D Mandell	pdf
12	03/24/2021	NOTICE OF DISCOVERY AND INSPECTION		Jonathan D Mandell
13	04/02/2021	STIPULATION - DISCOVERY ( REQUEST TO SO ORDER )		Michael Alan Guttman
14	04/05/2021	STIPULATION - SO ORDERED		Ronald Grayson
15	08/03/2021	STIPULATION - SO ORDERED		Mandradeo Andrade Okeeffe
16	08/31/2021	STIPULATION - DISCONTINUANCE (POST RJI)	Stip. of Discontinuance	Michael Alan Guttman	pdf

New York Supreme Court

2018

152187/2016

Disposed

Tort

DAVIS, EVELYN

FINKELSTEIN & PARTNERS

BROOKHAVEN REHABILITATION

Kaufman Borgeest & Ryan LLP

09/09/2024

Latin, Hon. Richard G.

▼

Case Info

Court

New York Supreme Court

Index Number

152187/2016

Status

Disposed

Year Filed

2018

Case Name

DAVIS, EVELYN vs. BROOKHAVEN REHABILITATION

Case Type

Tort-Other

Track

Standard

RJI Filed

05/31/2018

NOI Due

05/31/2019

NOI Filed

12/18/2020

Calendar Number

2020L-02286

Jury Status

Jury At Plaintiff's Request

Justice

Latin, Hon. Richard G.

Next Appearance

09/09/2024

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

DAVIS, EVELYN

Attorney / FirmFINKELSTEIN & PARTNERS

Defendant / Respondent

BROOKHAVEN REHABILITATION

Attorneys / FirmsKaufman Borgeest & Ryan LLP

Motions (1)

#	Date Filed	Filed By	Relief Sought	Submit Date	Answer	Status	Decision	Order Signed
1	12/19/2019		Compel Disclosure	02/26/2020	Yes	Decided: 02/26/2020 Decided Before Justice: Tisch, Hon. Alexander M.	Short Form Order	02/26/2020

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints (71)

Doc #	Date Filed	Document	Description	Motion #	Filing User	File
1	03/14/2016	SUMMONS + COMPLAINT	Summons and Complaint, verification dated 3-2-2016		Mary E Wright	pdf
2	03/14/2016	STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING	Statement of Auth for E-filing dated 3-14-16		Mary E Wright
3	04/04/2016	PROOF OF SERVICE	Proof of Notification to NYS Dept. of Health, pursuant to CPLR 306-c		Mary E Wright
4	04/14/2016	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service of Summons and Complaint and Notice of Commencement of Action Subject to Mandatory E-Filing for BROOKHAVEN REHABILITATION AND HEALTH CARE CENTER, LLC		Mary E Wright
5	04/14/2016	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service of Summons and Complaint and Notice of Commencement of Action Subject to Mandatory E-Filing for SENTOSACARE, LLC		Mary E Wright
6	06/08/2016	ANSWER			Sandra Brown Langolf	pdf
7	06/08/2016	ANSWER			Sandra Brown Langolf	pdf
8	06/08/2016	BILL OF PARTICULARS			Sandra Brown Langolf
9	06/08/2016	BILL OF PARTICULARS			Sandra Brown Langolf
10	06/08/2016	NOTICE OF DEPOSITION UPON ORAL EXAMINATION			Sandra Brown Langolf
11	06/08/2016	NOTICE OF DEPOSITION UPON ORAL EXAMINATION			Sandra Brown Langolf
12	03/15/2017	ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE			Kathy Quammie
13	05/31/2018	RJI -RE: REQUEST FOR PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE			Mary E Wright
14	11/21/2018	ORDER - PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE			Maria Abreu
15	03/28/2019	COURT NOTICE			Jack Wong
16	04/04/2019	ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE			Jack Wong
17	06/13/2019	ORDER - STATUS CONFERENCE			Jack Wong
18	07/15/2019	BILL OF PARTICULARS	Defendants' Verified Bill of Particulars as to Affirmative Defenses		Shevonne Shanai Greene
19	08/15/2019	ORDER - STATUS CONFERENCE			Michelle A Cruz
20	11/07/2019	ORDER - STATUS CONFERENCE			Michelle A Cruz
21	12/19/2019	NOTICE OF MOTION		001	Lawrence D Lissauer	pdf
22	12/19/2019	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION		001	Lawrence D Lissauer
23	12/19/2019	AFFIRMATION OF GOOD FAITH		001	Lawrence D Lissauer
24	12/19/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	summons and complaint	001	Lawrence D Lissauer
25	12/19/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	answer	001	Lawrence D Lissauer
26	12/19/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	bill of particulars	001	Lawrence D Lissauer
27	12/19/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	Supplemental bill of particulars	001	Lawrence D Lissauer
28	12/19/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	Deposition Notice	001	Lawrence D Lissauer
29	12/19/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	PC order	001	Lawrence D Lissauer
30	12/19/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	stipulations	001	Lawrence D Lissauer
31	12/19/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	Agpalo deposition transcript 6/14/19	001	Lawrence D Lissauer
32	12/19/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	Agpalo deposition transcript 10/30/19	001	Lawrence D Lissauer
33	12/19/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	Post EBT Demand	001	Lawrence D Lissauer
34	12/19/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	response	001	Lawrence D Lissauer
35	12/19/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	stipulation	001	Lawrence D Lissauer
36	12/19/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	occurrance report	001	Lawrence D Lissauer
37	12/19/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	care plan	001	Lawrence D Lissauer
38	12/19/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	pressure sore investigation report	001	Lawrence D Lissauer
39	12/19/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	occurrance report	001	Lawrence D Lissauer
40	12/19/2019	STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING		001	Lawrence D Lissauer
41	12/26/2019	STIPULATION - ADJOURNMENT OF CONFERENCE	Please disregard this filing. It was filed in error. Please refer to document # 43.		Shevonne Shanai Greene
42	12/26/2019	STIPULATION - OTHER	Please disregard this filing. It was filed in error. Please refer to document # 43.		Shevonne Shanai Greene
43	12/26/2019	STIPULATION - ADJOURNMENT OF MOTION -IN SUBMISSIONS PART -RM 130	Def's Stipulation Adjourning Plaintiff's Motion 12.26.19		Shevonne Shanai Greene
44	02/04/2020	ORDER - STATUS CONFERENCE			Fernando Diaz
45	02/06/2020	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION	Please disregard this filing. It was filed in error. Please refer to document # 49.	001	Shevonne Shanai Greene
46	02/06/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Defs' Supplemental Response to Plaintiff's Post-EBT Demands 2.5.20	001	Shevonne Shanai Greene
47	02/06/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Defs' Nosocomial Pressure Sore Investigation Reports	001	Shevonne Shanai Greene
48	02/06/2020	AFFIDAVIT	Defs' Affidavit of Service with Blueback to Defs' Affirmation in Opposition to Plaintiff's Motion to Compel 2.6.20	001	Shevonne Shanai Greene
49	02/06/2020	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION	Defs' Affirmation in Opposition to Plaintiff's Motion to Compel 2.6.20	001	Shevonne Shanai Greene
50	02/06/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Defs' Supplemental Response to Plaintiff's Post-EBT Demands 2.5.20	001	Shevonne Shanai Greene
51	02/06/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Defs' Nosocomial Pressure Sore Investigation Reports	001	Shevonne Shanai Greene
52	02/06/2020	AFFIDAVIT	Defs' Affidavit of Service with Blueback to Defs' Affirmation in Opposition to Plaintiff's Motion to Compel 2.6.20	001	Shevonne Shanai Greene
53	02/18/2020	COURT NOTICE			Michelle A Cruz
54	02/26/2020	DECISION + ORDER ON MOTION		001	Roberta Sumpter	pdf
55	02/28/2020	ORDER - STATUS CONFERENCE			Fernando Diaz
56	03/19/2020	URGENT - COURT APPEARANCE UPDATE			Michael Habich
57	05/04/2020	COURT NOTICE			Michelle A Cruz
58	05/21/2020	STIPULATION - DISCOVERY	Stipulation		Sandra Brown Langolf
59	08/03/2020	STIPULATION - SO ORDERED			Daniel Genossar
60	10/05/2020	STIPULATION - SO ORDERED			Michelle A Cruz
61	11/24/2020	STIPULATION - SO ORDERED			Michelle A Cruz
62	12/18/2020	NOTE OF ISSUE:WITH JURY	Note of Issue, Certificate of Readiness, Affirmation in Compliance, Stipulation		Lawrence D Lissauer	pdf
63	12/18/2020	STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING	Authorizing Lauren M. Scharfenberg		Lawrence D Lissauer
64	09/19/2022	NOTIFICATION FROM COURT			Jack Wong
65	10/12/2022	CONSENT TO CHANGE ATTORNEY (POST RJI)			Jeffrey Robert Nichols
66	10/12/2022	STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING			Jeffrey Robert Nichols
67	01/04/2023	CONSENT TO CHANGE ATTORNEY (POST RJI)			Gerasimia Stathatos
68	01/04/2023	STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING			Gerasimia Stathatos
69	01/19/2024	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE			Lawrence D Lissauer
70	01/19/2024	STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING			Lawrence D Lissauer
71 PENDING	05/08/2024	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE			Lawrence D Lissauer

Oneida Supreme Court

2018

EFCA2018-001378 (1701378/2018)

Disposed

Comm-Contract

ORISKA INSURANCE COMPANY

DAVID A BAGLEY ATTORNEY AND COUNSELOR AT LAW

BROOKHAVEN REHABILITATION AND HEALTH

LIPSIUS-BENHAIM LAW, LLP

12/17/2019

MacRae, Hon. Patrick F.

▼

Case Info

Court

Oneida Supreme Court

Index Number

EFCA2018-001378 (1701378/2018)

Status

Disposed

Year Filed

2018

Case Name

ORISKA INSURANCE COMPANY vs. BROOKHAVEN REHABILITATION AND HEALTH

Case Type

Comm-Contract

Track

Standard

RJI Filed

07/02/2018

NOI Due

07/02/2019

NOI Filed

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

MacRae, Hon. Patrick F.

Next Appearance

12/17/2019

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

ORISKA INSURANCE COMPANY

Attorney / FirmDAVID A BAGLEY ATTORNEY AND COUNSELOR AT LAW

Defendant / Respondent

BROOKHAVEN REHABILITATION AND HEALTH

Attorneys / FirmsLIPSIUS-BENHAIM LAW, LLP

Motions (7)

#	Date Filed	Relief Sought	Submit Date	Answer	Status	Order Signed
7	10/18/2019	Other	12/17/2019	No	Decided: 12/17/2019 Decided Before Justice: MacRae, Hon. Patrick F.	12/17/2019
6	06/03/2019	Other	06/05/2019	No	Decided: 06/05/2019 Decided Before Justice: MacRae, Hon. Patrick F.	06/05/2019
5	05/31/2019	Other	06/05/2019	No	Decided: 06/05/2019 Decided Before Justice: MacRae, Hon. Patrick F.	06/05/2019
4	05/29/2019	Other	06/05/2019	No	Decided: 06/05/2019 Decided Before Justice: MacRae, Hon. Patrick F.	06/05/2019
3	11/05/2018	Other	02/07/2019	No	Decided: 02/07/2019 Decided Before Justice: MacRae, Hon. Patrick F.	02/07/2019
2	08/08/2018	Other	05/02/2019	No	Decided: 05/02/2019 Decided Before Justice: MacRae, Hon. Patrick F.	05/02/2019
1	07/03/2018	Other	05/02/2019	No	Decided: 05/02/2019 Decided Before Justice: MacRae, Hon. Patrick F.	05/02/2019

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints (58)

Doc #	Date Filed	Document	Description	Motion #	Filing User	File
1	05/09/2018	SUMMONS + COMPLAINT			David Arthur Bagley	pdf
2	07/02/2018	NOTICE OF MOTION		01	Ira S Lipsius	pdf
3	07/02/2018	MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN SUPPORT		01	Ira S Lipsius
4	07/02/2018	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION	Sperber Affirmation	01	Ira S Lipsius
5	07/02/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Combined Complaints	01	Ira S Lipsius
6	07/02/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	2013 DFS Order	01	Ira S Lipsius
7	07/02/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Justice Hester Order Staying DFS Order	01	Ira S Lipsius
8	07/02/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Justice Hester Order Vacating Stay	01	Ira S Lipsius
9	07/02/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	2016 Justice Hester Decision	01	Ira S Lipsius
10	07/02/2018	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION		01	Ira S Lipsius
11	07/02/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	March 28 Email	01	Ira S Lipsius
12	07/02/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	March 29 Email	01	Ira S Lipsius
13	07/02/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	March 29 Email	01	Ira S Lipsius
14	07/02/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	April 10 Email	01	Ira S Lipsius
15	07/02/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	April 30 Email	01	Ira S Lipsius
16	07/02/2018	RJI -RE: NOTICE OF MOTION		01	Ira S Lipsius	pdf
17	08/07/2018	NOTICE OF CROSS-MOTION		02	David Arthur Bagley
18	08/07/2018	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION AND IN SUPPORT OF CROSS-MOTION		02	David Arthur Bagley
19	08/07/2018	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION AND IN SUPPORT OF CROSS-MOTION		02	David Arthur Bagley
20	08/07/2018	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION AND IN SUPPORT OF CROSS-MOTION		02	David Arthur Bagley
21	08/07/2018	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION AND IN SUPPORT OF CROSS-MOTION		02	David Arthur Bagley
22	08/07/2018	MEMORANDUM IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION AND IN SUPPORT OF CROSS-MOTION		02	David Arthur Bagley
23	09/12/2018	LETTER/CORRESPONDENCE FROM COURT		01	Lisa H Johnson
24	09/20/2018	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE			Ira S Lipsius
25	09/20/2018	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE			Ira S Lipsius
26	10/15/2018	MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN REPLY		01	Ira S Lipsius
27	10/15/2018	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION	Schlesinger Affirmation	01	Ira S Lipsius
28	10/18/2018	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN REPLY		01	David Arthur Bagley
29	10/18/2018	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN REPLY		01	David Arthur Bagley
30	10/18/2018	MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN REPLY		01	David Arthur Bagley
31	10/18/2018	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE		01	Christopher Edward Buckey
32	10/19/2018	LETTER/CORRESPONDENCE - SO ORDERED		01	Lisa H Johnson
33	11/05/2018	NOTICE OF MOTION		03	Ira S Lipsius	pdf
34	11/05/2018	MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN SUPPORT		03	Ira S Lipsius
35	11/05/2018	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION		03	Ira S Lipsius
36	11/05/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Additional Information: DFS Report and Recommendation	03	Ira S Lipsius
37	11/05/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Additional Information: DFS Final Order re Kernan	03	Ira S Lipsius
38	11/05/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Additional Information: Order re Kernan Disqualification	03	Ira S Lipsius
39	11/05/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Additional Information: NDNY Docket	03	Ira S Lipsius
40	11/15/2018	MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN OPPOSITION		03	David Arthur Bagley
41	11/15/2018	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION		03	David Arthur Bagley
42	03/15/2019	ORDER - OTHER			Lisa H Johnson
43	04/29/2019	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT		01	Ira S Lipsius
44	05/13/2019	NOTICE OF CHANGE OF FIRM NAME OR ADDRESS (POST RJI)	Notice of Change of Firm Address and Fax Number		Christopher Edward Buckey
45	05/29/2019	NOTICE OF APPEARANCE (POST RJI)			Frank Policelli
46	05/29/2019	NOTICE OF MOTION		04	Frank Policelli	pdf
47	05/31/2019	LETTER/CORRESPONDENCE FROM COURT			Senta B Siuda
48	06/03/2019	ORDER - OTHER			Lisa H Johnson
49	06/03/2019	NOTICE OF APPEARANCE (POST RJI)			Jessica Leigh Sprague
50	06/03/2019	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE			Christopher Edward Buckey
51	06/03/2019	ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE ( PROPOSED )		06	Frank Policelli	pdf
52	06/03/2019	AFFIDAVIT		06	Frank Policelli
53	06/03/2019	MEMORANDUM OF LAW		06	Frank Policelli
54	06/04/2019	MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN OPPOSITION	Memorandum of Law in Opposition to Order to Show Cause	06	Christopher Edward Buckey
55	06/04/2019	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE	C. Buckey Affirmation	06	Christopher Edward Buckey	pdf
56	06/05/2019	ORDER ( PROPOSED )			Christopher Edward Buckey
57	06/07/2019	ORDER - OTHER			Lisa H Johnson
58	10/10/2019	NOTICE OF APPEAL			Jessica Leigh Sprague	pdf

Queens Supreme Court

2017

709872/2017

Disposed

Medical Malpractice

ZOBA, GREGG

Bergman, Bergman, Fields & Lamonsoff, LLP

BROOKHAVEN ETAL

Perry, Van Etten, Rainis & Kutner, LLP

11/19/2019

O'Donoghue, Hon. Peter

▼

Case Info

Court

Queens Supreme Court

Index Number

709872/2017

Status

Disposed

Year Filed

2017

Case Name

ZOBA, GREGG vs. BROOKHAVEN ETAL

Case Type

Tort-Medical, Dental, or Podiatric Malpractice

Track

Complex

RJI Filed

03/21/2017

NOI Due

06/22/2018

NOI Filed

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

O'Donoghue, Hon. Peter

Next Appearance

11/19/2019

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

ZOBA, GREGG

Attorney / FirmBergman, Bergman, Fields & Lamonsoff, LLP

Defendant / Respondent

BROOKHAVEN ETAL

Attorneys / FirmsPerry, Van Etten, Rainis & Kutner, LLP

Motions (7)

#	Date Filed	Relief Sought	Submit Date	Answer	Status	Decision	Order Signed
7	10/15/2018	Dismiss	10/31/2018	No	Decided: 11/18/2019 Closed Before Justice: O'Donoghue, Hon. Peter	Short Form Order	11/18/2019
6	10/10/2018	Attorney - Disqualify/Relieve/Substitute/Withdraw	10/31/2018	Yes	Decided: 11/18/2019 Denied Before Justice: O'Donoghue, Hon. Peter	Short Form Order	11/18/2019
5	05/22/2018	Attorney - Disqualify/Relieve/Substitute/Withdraw	05/24/2018	No	Decided: 05/24/2018 Declined to Sign Before Justice: O'Donoghue, Hon. Peter	Oral	05/24/2018
4	12/20/2017	Renew/Reargue/Resettle/Reconsider	05/02/2018	Yes	Decided: 11/14/2019 Denied Before Justice: O'Donoghue, Hon. Peter	Short Form Order	11/14/2019
3	12/15/2017	Renew/Reargue/Resettle/Reconsider	05/02/2018	No	Decided: 10/04/2018 Denied Before Justice: O'Donoghue, Hon. Peter	Short Form Order	10/04/2018
2	10/11/2017	Sever	11/01/2017	Yes	Decided: 11/08/2017 Decided Before Justice: O'Donoghue, Hon. Peter	Short Form Order	11/08/2017
1	08/10/2017	Consolidate	08/23/2017	Yes	Decided: 08/24/2017 Granted Before Justice: O'Donoghue, Hon. Peter	Short Form Order	08/24/2017

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints (175)

Doc #	Date Filed	Document	Description	Motion #	Filing User	File
1	01/16/2017	SUMMONS + COMPLAINT	S&C		David Merrill Freeman	pdf
2	02/07/2017	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE			Philip John Rizzuto
3	02/07/2017	STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING			Philip John Rizzuto
4	02/24/2017	ANSWER			Matthew Rainis	pdf
5	02/24/2017	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE			Matthew Rainis
6	02/27/2017	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE	Correspondence to Court Clerk		Seth D Cohen
7	02/28/2017	CERTIFICATE OF MERIT	Certificate of Merit		David Merrill Freeman
8	03/21/2017	BILL OF PARTICULARS	Verified Bill of Particulars		Alicia M Bartkowski
9	03/21/2017	DEMAND FOR BILL OF PARTICULARS	Demand for a Verified BP as to Affirmative Defenses		Alicia M Bartkowski
10	03/21/2017	NOTICE OF DISCOVERY AND INSPECTION	Notice of Discovery and Inspection & Combined Demands		Alicia M Bartkowski
11	03/21/2017	NOTICE OF MEDICAL MALPRACTICE	Notice of Medical Malpractice Action		Alicia M Bartkowski
12	03/21/2017	RJI FROM PRIOR COUNTY (COPY)	Original document type was RJI -RE: NOTICE OF MEDICAL, DENTAL OR PODIATRIC MALPRACTICE		Alicia M Bartkowski
13	05/03/2017	ADJOURNMENT OF CONFERENCE -REQUEST	PC to be adjourned to June 8, 2017		David Merrill Freeman
14	06/06/2017	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE	Confirmation of fax to adjourn PC to July 20, 2017		Alicia M Bartkowski
15	07/05/2017	STIPULATION - VENUE ( REQUEST TO SO ORDER )	Stip to Change Venue & Transfer File - to be So-Ordered		David Merrill Freeman
16	07/17/2017	ORDER - OTHER			Nicole Roberts
17	07/17/2017	NOTICE OF ENTRY	Notice of Entry		Alicia M Bartkowski
18	07/19/2017	NOTICE TO COUNTY CLERK CPLR 8019(C)			David Merrill Freeman
19	07/20/2017	COUNTY CLERK CERTIFICATION OF MINUTES	Change of venue: Queens County		Janaud Miller
20	07/21/2017	COURT NOTICE			Erlon Hodge
21	03/21/2017	RJI -RE: OTHER	Corrected RJI---Assignment of Judge		David Merrill Freeman
22	08/09/2017	NOTICE OF MOTION		001	David Merrill Freeman	pdf
23	08/09/2017	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION		001	David Merrill Freeman
24	08/09/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Plaintiff's Summons and Verified Complaint	001	David Merrill Freeman
25	08/09/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Defendant, Brookhaven Rehabilitation and Health Care Center LLC's Answer	001	David Merrill Freeman
26	08/09/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Defendant, Harmandeep Singh, M.D.'s Answer	001	David Merrill Freeman
27	08/09/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Defendant, Polina Khaninia, M.D.'s Answer	001	David Merrill Freeman
28	08/09/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Plaintiff's Verified Bill of Particulars as to Brookhaven Rehabilitation and Health Care Center, LLC	001	David Merrill Freeman
29	08/09/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Plaintiff's Verified Bill of Particulars as to Harmandeep Singh, M.D.	001	David Merrill Freeman
30	08/09/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Plaintiff's Verified Bill of Particulars as to Polina Khanina, M.D.	001	David Merrill Freeman
31	08/09/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	PC Order dated August 9, 2016 signed by Hon. Peter J. O'Donoghue	001	David Merrill Freeman
32	08/09/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Motion Order dated June 8, 2017 signed by Hon. Peter J. O'Donoghue	001	David Merrill Freeman
33	08/09/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Order dated July 13, 2017 signed by Hon. Joan A. Madden	001	David Merrill Freeman
34	08/09/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Plaintiff's Summons and Verified Complaint	001	David Merrill Freeman
35	08/09/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Defendant, Magdi Bebawi, M.D.'s Answer	001	David Merrill Freeman
36	08/09/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Plaintiff's Verified Bill of Particulars as to Magdi Bebawi	001	David Merrill Freeman
37	08/09/2017	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE		001	David Merrill Freeman
38	08/09/2017	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE		001	David Merrill Freeman
39	09/07/2017	ORDER - MOTION- SHORT FORM		001	Louisa Ammirati
40	09/07/2017	STIPULATION - SO ORDERED			Louisa Ammirati
41	09/25/2017	ORDER - PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE			Caroline M Enz
42	09/26/2017	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE			Matthew Rainis
43	09/26/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Order commencing liquidation proceedings		Matthew Rainis
44	10/06/2017	NOTICE OF MOTION		002	David Merrill Freeman	pdf
45	10/06/2017	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION		002	David Merrill Freeman
46	10/06/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Plaintiffs Summons and Verified Complaint, December 28, 2015	002	David Merrill Freeman
47	10/06/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Plaintiffs Supplemental Summons and Amended Verified Complaint	002	David Merrill Freeman
48	10/06/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Verified Answer of Defendant BROOKHAVEN REHABILITATION AND HEALTH CARE CENTER, LLC	002	David Merrill Freeman
49	10/06/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Verified Answer of Defendant HARMANDEEP SINGH, M.D.	002	David Merrill Freeman
50	10/06/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Verified Answer of Defendant POLINA KHANINA, M.D.	002	David Merrill Freeman
51	10/06/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Plaintiffs Summons and Verified Complaint, January 16, 2017	002	David Merrill Freeman
52	10/06/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Verified Answer of Defendant MAGDI BEBAWI, M.D.	002	David Merrill Freeman
53	10/06/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Verified Bill of Particulars as to Defendant BROOKHAVEN REHABILITATION AND HEALTH CARE CENTER, LLC	002	David Merrill Freeman
54	10/06/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Verified Bill of Particulars as to Defendant HARMANDEEP SINGH, M.D.	002	David Merrill Freeman
55	10/06/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Verified Bill of Particulars as to Defendant POLINA KHANINA, M.D.	002	David Merrill Freeman
56	10/06/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Verified Bill of Particulars as to Defendant MAGDI BEBAWI, M.D.	002	David Merrill Freeman
57	10/06/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Stipulation So Ordered by Honorable Peter J. ODonoghue, August 17, 2017	002	David Merrill Freeman
58	10/06/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Summons and Petition for Order Commencing Liquidation Proceedings	002	David Merrill Freeman
59	10/06/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Order Commencing Liquidation Proceedings & Granting an Injunction & Automatic Stay of Proceedings	002	David Merrill Freeman
60	10/06/2017	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE		002	David Merrill Freeman
61	10/30/2017	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION	Affirmation in Partial Opposition on behalf of Defendant Hermandeep Singh, MD	002	Seth D Cohen
62	11/07/2017	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE			Christine M. Nash
63	11/07/2017	NOTICE OF ENTRY		001	David Merrill Freeman
64	11/10/2017	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION	Affirmation in Opposition	002	Eldar Mayouhas
65	11/10/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Freeman Affirmation in Support	002	Eldar Mayouhas
66	11/10/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Papers Numbered	002	Eldar Mayouhas
67	11/10/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Notice of Entry	002	Eldar Mayouhas
68	11/10/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Freeman Affirmation in Support	002	Eldar Mayouhas
69	11/10/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	NYS Courts Electronic Filing (NYSCEF)	002	Eldar Mayouhas
70	11/10/2017	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Affirmation of Services	002	Eldar Mayouhas
71	11/15/2017	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION		002	Kara Barbara Suddock
72	11/15/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Summons and Complaint	002	Kara Barbara Suddock
73	11/15/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Dr. Khanina Answer	002	Kara Barbara Suddock
74	11/15/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Summons and Complaint - Dr Bebawi Action	002	Kara Barbara Suddock
75	11/15/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Pla Aff in Support of Motion to Consolidate	002	Kara Barbara Suddock
76	11/15/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	8-24-17 Order	002	Kara Barbara Suddock
77	11/15/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Plaintiff's Motion	002	Kara Barbara Suddock
78	11/15/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Webpage	002	Kara Barbara Suddock
79	11/15/2017	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE		002	Kara Barbara Suddock
80	11/17/2017	DECISION + ORDER ON MOTION		002	Edwin Ruiz	pdf
81	11/17/2017	NOTICE OF ENTRY	Order with Notice of Entry	002	David Merrill Freeman
82	11/21/2017	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE	Letter to County Clerk re e-filing 11-7-17		David Blair Desiver
83	11/29/2017	NOTICE OF ENTRY	ORDER NOTICE OF ENTRY 11.29.17	002	Kara Barbara Suddock
84	11/29/2017	AFFIDAVIT	AOS ORDER NOE	002	Kara Barbara Suddock
85	11/29/2017	NOTICE OF APPEAL/RADI/COPY OF ORDER/PROOF OF SERVICE	CORRECTED RADI, NOTICE OF APPEAL PROOF OF SERVICE	002	Kara Barbara Suddock	pdf
86	11/29/2017	AFFIDAVIT	AOS NOTICE OF APPEAL	002	Kara Barbara Suddock
87	12/12/2017	NOTICE OF APPEAL/RADI/COPY OF ORDER/PROOF OF SERVICE		002	Eldar Mayouhas	pdf
88	12/12/2017	RADI (REQUEST FOR APP DIV INTERVENTION)		002	Eldar Mayouhas
89	12/15/2017	NOTICE OF MOTION		003	Christine M. Nash	pdf
90	12/15/2017	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT		003	Christine M. Nash
91	12/15/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Summons and Complaint	003	Christine M. Nash
92	12/15/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Supplemental Summons and Complaint	003	Christine M. Nash
93	12/15/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Verified Answer	003	Christine M. Nash
94	12/15/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Summons and Complaint	003	Christine M. Nash
95	12/15/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Affirmation In Support	003	Christine M. Nash
96	12/15/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Order	003	Christine M. Nash
97	12/15/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Stipulation	003	Christine M. Nash
98	12/15/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Affirmation in Support	003	Christine M. Nash
99	12/15/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Order	003	Christine M. Nash
100	12/15/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Affidavit	003	Christine M. Nash
101	12/15/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Confirmation Notice	003	Christine M. Nash
102	12/15/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Correspondence to Queens County Clerk	003	Christine M. Nash
103	12/15/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Affirmation In Opposition	003	Christine M. Nash
104	12/15/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Order	003	Christine M. Nash
105	12/15/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Notice of Entry	003	Christine M. Nash
106	12/19/2017	NOTICE OF MOTION	MOTION TO RENEW	004	Kenneth Tod Bierman	pdf
107	12/19/2017	AFFIRMATION	AFFIRMAITON IN SUPPORT OF MOTION TO RENEW	004	Kenneth Tod Bierman
108	12/19/2017	AFFIDAVIT	AOS ECF & REGULAR MAIL	004	Kenneth Tod Bierman
109	12/19/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	SUMMONS & COMPLAINT	004	Kenneth Tod Bierman
110	12/19/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	ANSWER&DEMANDS	004	Kenneth Tod Bierman
111	12/19/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	BEBAWI S&C	004	Kenneth Tod Bierman
112	12/19/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Pla-Aff in Support	004	Kenneth Tod Bierman
113	12/19/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	8.24.17 ORDER	004	Kenneth Tod Bierman
114	12/19/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Plaintiff's Motion to Sever	004	Kenneth Tod Bierman
115	12/19/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	CONFIRMATION NOTICE	004	Kenneth Tod Bierman
116	12/19/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Dr. Khanina Aff in Opp	004	Kenneth Tod Bierman
117	12/19/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	11.18.17 ORDER	004	Kenneth Tod Bierman
118	12/19/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	BROOKHAVEN AFF IN OPP	004	Kenneth Tod Bierman
119	12/19/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	BROOKHAVEN REARGUE	004	Kenneth Tod Bierman
120	01/05/2018	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE			David Merrill Freeman
121	05/17/2018	ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE ( PROPOSED )	Proposed Order to Show Cause to be Relieved as Counsel	005	Matthew Rainis	pdf
122	05/17/2018	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF PROPOSED OSC/EXPARTE APP		005	Matthew Rainis
123	05/17/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Proposed Order	005	Matthew Rainis
124	05/17/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	South Carolina Common Pleas Court Injunction and Automatic Stay Order	005	Matthew Rainis
125	05/17/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Letter to Dr. Bebawi dated 9.25.17	005	Matthew Rainis
126	05/17/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Letter to Dr. Bebawi dated 2.9.18	005	Matthew Rainis
127	05/17/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Letter to Dr. Bebawi dated 5.3.18	005	Matthew Rainis
128	05/17/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Letter to Dr. Bebawi dated 5.15.18	005	Matthew Rainis
129	05/17/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Email notification to all parties pursuant to 22 NYCRR 202.7(f)	005	Matthew Rainis
130	06/04/2018	ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE	DENIED	005	Frank Giovinco	pdf
131	10/08/2018	NOTICE OF MOTION		006	David Merrill Freeman	pdf
132	10/08/2018	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION		006	David Merrill Freeman
133	10/08/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit A - Plaintiff's Summons and Verified Complaint, December 28, 2015	006	David Merrill Freeman
134	10/08/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit B - Plaintiff's Supplemental Summons and Amended Verified Complaint	006	David Merrill Freeman
135	10/08/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit C - Verified Answer of Defendant Brookhaven Rehabilitation and Health Care Center, LLC	006	David Merrill Freeman
136	10/08/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit D - Verified Answer of Defendant Harmandeep Singh, M.D.	006	David Merrill Freeman
137	10/08/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit E Verified Answer of Defendant Polina Khanina, M.D.	006	David Merrill Freeman
138	10/08/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit F - Plainitff's Summons and Verified Complaint, January 16, 2017	006	David Merrill Freeman
139	10/08/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit G - Verified Answer of Defendant Magdi Bebawi, M.D.	006	David Merrill Freeman
140	10/08/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit H - Verified Bill of Particulars as to Defendant Brookhaven Rehabilitation and Health Care Center, LLC	006	David Merrill Freeman
141	10/08/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit I - Verified Bill of Particulars as to Defendant Harmandeep Singh, M.D.	006	David Merrill Freeman
142	10/08/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit J - Verified Bill of Particulars as to Defendant Polina Khanina, M.D.	006	David Merrill Freeman
143	10/08/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit K - Verified Bill of Particulars as to Defendant Magdi Bebawi, M.D.	006	David Merrill Freeman
144	10/08/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit L - Stipulation So Ordered by Honorable Peter J. O'Donoghue, August 17, 2017	006	David Merrill Freeman
145	10/08/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit M - Summons and Petition for Order Commencing Liquidation Proceedings	006	David Merrill Freeman
146	10/08/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit N - Order Commending Liquidation Proceedings & Granting an Injunction & Automatic Stay of Proceedings	006	David Merrill Freeman
147	10/08/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit O - Letter to the court, January 5, 2018	006	David Merrill Freeman
148	10/08/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit P - Letter to Agnes Zoba and Bill Zoba, October 5, 2018	006	David Merrill Freeman
149	10/08/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit Q - Disbursements	006	David Merrill Freeman
150	10/08/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit R - Retainer Statement	006	David Merrill Freeman
151	10/08/2018	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE		006	David Merrill Freeman
152	10/15/2018	ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE ( PROPOSED )	Order to Show Cause 10/12/18	007	Seth D Cohen	pdf
153	10/15/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Summons & Complaint and Amended Summons & Complaint	007	Seth D Cohen
154	10/15/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Verified Answer to Amended Complaint	007	Seth D Cohen
155	10/15/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Death Certificate (Redacted)	007	Seth D Cohen
156	10/15/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Internet Search	007	Seth D Cohen
157	10/15/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Plaintiff's Notice of Motion to Withdraw as Counsel	007	Seth D Cohen
158	10/16/2018	DECISION + ORDER ON MOTION		003	Kianna Vanputten	pdf
159	10/17/2018	ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE		007	Jerome D White	pdf
160	10/18/2018	AFFIDAVIT	Affidavit of Service for Order to Show Cause	007	Seth D Cohen
161	10/23/2018	AFFIRMATION	Affirmation in Partial Opposition	006	Sandra Brown Langolf
162	10/24/2018	AFFIRMATION	AFFIRMATION IN PARTIAL OPP TO PLTF'S MOT WITHDRAW AS COUNSEL & AOS	006	Kara Barbara Suddock
163	10/30/2018	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE		007	David Merrill Freeman	pdf
164	07/10/2019	NOTICE OF CHANGE OF FIRM NAME OR ADDRESS (POST RJI)			Matthew Rainis
165	11/21/2019	ORDER - MOTION- SHORT FORM		003	Frank Giovinco
166	11/21/2019	ORDER - MOTION- SHORT FORM		004	Frank Giovinco
167	11/25/2019	ORDER - MOTION- SHORT FORM		006	Jerome D White
168	11/25/2019	ORDER - MOTION- SHORT FORM		007	Jerome D White
169	11/25/2019	NOTICE OF ENTRY		006	Matthew Rainis
170	11/25/2019	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE		006	Matthew Rainis
171	12/02/2019	NOTICE OF ENTRY	ORDER WITH NOTICE OF ENTRY		Kara Barbara Suddock
172	12/03/2019	NOTICE OF ENTRY		006	Christine M. Nash
173	12/03/2019	NOTICE OF ENTRY	Notice of Entry 12-3-19		David Blair Desiver
174	12/04/2019	NOTICE OF ENTRY	Notice of Entry with Decision & Order Dismissing Action		David Blair Desiver
176	03/17/2020	CONSENT TO CHANGE ATTORNEY (POST RJI)	Consent to Change Attorney		David Blair Desiver

Queens Supreme Court

2017

706690/2017

Disposed

Tort

BROOKHAVEN REHABILITATION

Abrams Fensterman, LLP

BENJAMIN, ALBERT

PENA & KAHN, PLLC

10/16/2019

Scheduling Judge, Trial

▼

Case Info

Court

Queens Supreme Court

Index Number

706690/2017

Status

Disposed

Year Filed

2017

Case Name

BROOKHAVEN REHABILITATION vs. BENJAMIN, ALBERT

Case Type

Tort-Other

Track

Complex

RJI Filed

08/25/2017

NOI Due

11/26/2018

NOI Filed

11/20/2018

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

Scheduling Judge, Trial

Next Appearance

10/16/2019

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

BROOKHAVEN REHABILITATION

Attorney / FirmAbrams Fensterman, LLP

Defendant / Respondent

BENJAMIN, ALBERT

Attorneys / FirmsPENA & KAHN, PLLC

Motions (3)

#	Date Filed	Relief Sought	Submit Date	Answer	Status	Decision	Order Signed
3	06/26/2019	Judgment - Summary	08/08/2019	Yes	Decided: 08/08/2019 Closed Before Justice: Caloras, Hon. Robert I.	Short Form Order	08/08/2019
2	12/11/2018	Vacate/Strike - Note of Issue/Jury Demand/From Trial Calendar	01/17/2019	Yes	Decided: 01/17/2019 Withdrawn Before Justice: Caloras, Hon. Robert I.	Oral	01/17/2019
1	07/10/2018	Bill of Particulars	10/25/2018	Yes	Decided: 12/17/2018 Denied Before Justice: Caloras, Hon. Robert I.	Short Form Order	12/17/2018

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints (104)

Doc #	Date Filed	Document	Description	Motion #	Filing User	File
1	05/16/2017	SUMMONS + COMPLAINT			Jeffrey Robert Neuman	pdf
2	06/07/2017	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE			Jeffrey Robert Neuman
3	06/07/2017	STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING			Jeffrey Robert Neuman
4	08/25/2017	PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE REQUEST			Jeffrey Robert Neuman
5	08/25/2017	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE			Jeffrey Robert Neuman
6	08/25/2017	RJI -RE: REQUEST FOR PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE			Jeffrey Robert Neuman
7	10/30/2017	ORDER - PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE			Caroline M Enz
8	05/11/2018	ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE			Caroline M Enz
9	07/06/2018	NOTICE OF MOTION		001	Jeffrey Robert Neuman	pdf
10	07/06/2018	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT	Attorney Affirmation	001	Jeffrey Robert Neuman
11	07/06/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Brookhaven's Invoice	001	Jeffrey Robert Neuman
12	07/06/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Summons and Verified Complaint	001	Jeffrey Robert Neuman
13	07/06/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Affidavit of Service	001	Jeffrey Robert Neuman
14	07/06/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Answer	001	Jeffrey Robert Neuman
15	07/06/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Preliminary Conference Order	001	Jeffrey Robert Neuman
16	07/06/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Plaintiff's Discovery Demands	001	Jeffrey Robert Neuman
17	07/06/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Compliance Conference Order	001	Jeffrey Robert Neuman
18	07/06/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Good Faith Letter	001	Jeffrey Robert Neuman
19	07/06/2018	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE		001	Jeffrey Robert Neuman
20	08/15/2018	STIPULATION - ADJOURNMENT OF MOTION		001	Matthew J Ross
21	09/19/2018	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO CROSS-MOTION		001	Matthew J Ross
22	09/19/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Bill of Particulars	001	Matthew J Ross
23	09/19/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	LETTER TO DEFENDANT	001	Matthew J Ross
24	09/19/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	50h hearing	001	Matthew J Ross
25	09/19/2018	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE		001	Matthew J Ross
26	09/26/2018	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN REPLY		001	Jeffrey Robert Neuman
27	10/12/2018	AFFIRMATION	Sur-Reply in Further Opposition		Matthew J Ross
28	10/12/2018	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE			Matthew J Ross
29	10/24/2018	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION		001	Matthew J Ross
30	10/24/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit 1	001	Matthew J Ross
31	10/24/2018	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE		001	Matthew J Ross
32	10/24/2018	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN REPLY	Sur-Sur-Reply Affirmation	001	Jeffrey Robert Neuman
33	10/24/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Defendant's Response to Plaintiff's First Set of Interrogatories	001	Jeffrey Robert Neuman
34	10/24/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Plaintiff's Letter to Defense Counsel re Deficieny of Interrogatory Response	001	Jeffrey Robert Neuman
35	10/24/2018	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE		001	Jeffrey Robert Neuman
36	11/20/2018	NOTICE OF ENTRY			Jeffrey Robert Neuman
37	11/20/2018	NOTE OF ISSUE:WITHOUT JURY			Jeffrey Robert Neuman
38	12/07/2018	NOTICE OF MOTION		002	Jeffrey Robert Neuman	pdf
39	12/07/2018	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION	Attorney Affirmation	002	Jeffrey Robert Neuman
40	12/07/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Summons and Verified Complaint	002	Jeffrey Robert Neuman
41	12/07/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Affidavit of Service	002	Jeffrey Robert Neuman
42	12/07/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Answer	002	Jeffrey Robert Neuman
43	12/07/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Preliminary Conference Order	002	Jeffrey Robert Neuman
44	12/07/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Plaintiff's Discovery Demands	002	Jeffrey Robert Neuman
45	12/07/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Compliance Conference Order	002	Jeffrey Robert Neuman
46	12/07/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Good Faith Letter	002	Jeffrey Robert Neuman
47	12/07/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Plaintiff's Motion to Compel	002	Jeffrey Robert Neuman
48	12/07/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Defendant's Affirmation in Opposition	002	Jeffrey Robert Neuman
49	12/07/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Plaintiff's Reply Affirmation	002	Jeffrey Robert Neuman
50	12/07/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Defendant's Sur-Reply	002	Jeffrey Robert Neuman
51	12/07/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Defendant's Responses to Plaintiff's Interrogatories	002	Jeffrey Robert Neuman
52	12/07/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Defendant's Corrected Affirmation in Opposition	002	Jeffrey Robert Neuman
53	12/07/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Plaintiff's Sur-Sur-Reply	002	Jeffrey Robert Neuman
54	12/07/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Plaintiff's October 24, 2018 Letter to Defendant's Counsel	002	Jeffrey Robert Neuman
55	12/07/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Note of Issue	002	Jeffrey Robert Neuman
56	12/07/2018	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE		002	Jeffrey Robert Neuman
57	12/10/2018	NOTICE OF CROSS-MOTION	Notice of Cross-Motion	002	Matthew J Ross
58	12/10/2018	AFFIRMATION OF GOOD FAITH	Affirmation of Good Faith	002	Matthew J Ross
59	12/10/2018	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF CROSS-MOTION	Affirmation in Support of Cross-Motion	002	Matthew J Ross
60	01/02/2019	ORDER - MOTION- SHORT FORM		001	Jerome D White
61	01/15/2019	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO CROSS-MOTION		002	Jeffrey Robert Neuman
62	01/15/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	Notice of Motion Affirmation in Support	002	Jeffrey Robert Neuman
63	01/15/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	Plaintiff's Discovery Deficiency Letter	002	Jeffrey Robert Neuman
64	01/15/2019	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE		002	Jeffrey Robert Neuman
65	02/01/2019	STIPULATION - SO ORDERED			Louisa Ammirati
66	04/29/2019	STIPULATION - SO ORDERED			Louisa Ammirati
67	06/24/2019	NOTICE OF MOTION		003	Alyssa L Kelliher	pdf
68	06/24/2019	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION	Attorney Affirmation	003	Alyssa L Kelliher
69	06/24/2019	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION	Pollak Affidavit	003	Alyssa L Kelliher
70	06/24/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	Brookhaven Invoice	003	Alyssa L Kelliher
71	06/24/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	Summons and Verified Complaint	003	Alyssa L Kelliher
72	06/24/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	Affidavit of Service	003	Alyssa L Kelliher
73	06/24/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	Verified Answer	003	Alyssa L Kelliher
74	06/24/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	Plaintiff's Discovery Demands	003	Alyssa L Kelliher
75	06/24/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	Preliminary Conference Order	003	Alyssa L Kelliher
76	06/24/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	Compliance Conference Order	003	Alyssa L Kelliher
77	06/24/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	Good Faith Letter	003	Alyssa L Kelliher
78	06/24/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	Plaintiff's Motion to Compel & Strike	003	Alyssa L Kelliher
79	06/24/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	Defendant's Motion to Consolidate, Affirmation in Support and Summons & Complaint in Personal Injury Action	003	Alyssa L Kelliher
80	06/24/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	Opposition to Motion to Consolidate filed by Brookhaven's Counsel in Personal Injury Action	003	Alyssa L Kelliher
81	06/24/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	Opposition to Motion to Consolidate file by Brookhaven's Counsel in the Within Action	003	Alyssa L Kelliher
82	06/24/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	Defendant's Reply in Further Support of Motion to Consolidate	003	Alyssa L Kelliher
83	06/24/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	Court Order dated October 29, 2018 Denying Motion to Consolidate	003	Alyssa L Kelliher
84	06/24/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	Defendant's Opposition to Motion to Compel & Strike	003	Alyssa L Kelliher
85	06/24/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	Transcript from Defendant's Examination Before Trial in Personal Injury Action	003	Alyssa L Kelliher
86	06/24/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	Plaintiff's Reply In Futher Support of Motion to Compel & Strike	003	Alyssa L Kelliher
87	06/24/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	Defendant's Sur-Reply in Further Opposition of Motion to Compel & Strike	003	Alyssa L Kelliher
88	06/24/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	Defendant's Response to Plaintiff's First Set of Interrogatories	003	Alyssa L Kelliher
89	06/24/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	Letter to Defendant regarding Insufficient and Incomplete Discovery Responses	003	Alyssa L Kelliher
90	06/24/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	Note of Issue	003	Alyssa L Kelliher
91	06/24/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	Plaintiff's Motion to Vacate Note of Issue	003	Alyssa L Kelliher
92	06/24/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	Defendant's Cross-Motion to Strike & Extend Time to File Dispositive Motion	003	Alyssa L Kelliher
93	06/24/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	Plaintiff's Opposition to Defendant's Cross-Motion to Strike Pleadings	003	Alyssa L Kelliher
94	06/24/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	Defendant's Response to Plaintiff's Notice for Discovery and Inspection	003	Alyssa L Kelliher
95	06/24/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	Court Order dated December 17, 2018 Denying Plaintiff's Motion to Compel & Strike	003	Alyssa L Kelliher
96	06/24/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	Discovery Stipulation dated January 17, 2019	003	Alyssa L Kelliher
97	06/24/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	Defendant's Final Response to Plaintiff's Notice for Discovery and Inspection	003	Alyssa L Kelliher
98	06/24/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	Discovery Stipulation dated April 17, 2019	003	Alyssa L Kelliher
99	06/24/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	Average New York State Nursing Home Private Rates	003	Alyssa L Kelliher
100	06/24/2019	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE		003	Alyssa L Kelliher
101	08/01/2019	NOTICE OF MOTION (AMENDED)		003	Jeffrey Robert Neuman	pdf
102	08/01/2019	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE		003	Jeffrey Robert Neuman
103	08/21/2019	ORDER - MOTION- SHORT FORM		003	Frank Giovinco
104	12/03/2019	STIPULATION - DISCONTINUANCE (POST RJI)			Alyssa L Kelliher	pdf

Queens Supreme Court

2017

713652/2016

Disposed

Medical Malpractice

BENJAMIN, ALBERT

PENA & KAHN, PLLC

BROOKHAVEN REHABILITATION ANO

Kaufman Borgeest & Ryan LLP

09/12/2019

O'Donoghue, Hon. Peter

▼

Case Info

Court

Queens Supreme Court

Index Number

713652/2016

Status

Disposed

Year Filed

2017

Case Name

BENJAMIN, ALBERT vs. BROOKHAVEN REHABILITATION ANO

Case Type

Tort-Medical, Dental, or Podiatric Malpractice

Track

Complex

RJI Filed

03/28/2017

NOI Due

06/29/2018

NOI Filed

06/22/2018

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Jury At Plaintiff's Request

Justice

O'Donoghue, Hon. Peter

Next Appearance

09/12/2019

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

BENJAMIN, ALBERT

Attorney / FirmPENA & KAHN, PLLC

Defendant / Respondent

BROOKHAVEN REHABILITATION ANO

Attorneys / FirmsKaufman Borgeest & Ryan LLP

Motions (1)

#	Date Filed	Filed By	Relief Sought	Submit Date	Answer	Status	Decision	Order Signed
1	08/22/2018		Consolidate	10/03/2018	Yes	Decided: 10/29/2018 Denied Before Justice: O'Donoghue, Hon. Peter	Short Form Order	10/29/2018

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints (31)

Doc #	Date Filed	Document	Description	Motion #	Filing User	File
1	11/11/2016	SUMMONS			Matthew J Ross	pdf
2	11/11/2016	COMPLAINT			Matthew J Ross	pdf
3	01/13/2017	AFFIDAVIT			Matthew J Ross
4	01/13/2017	STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING			Matthew J Ross
5	03/08/2017	ANSWER	Verified Answer		Keith Lawrence Kaplan	pdf
6	03/08/2017	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	AOS for Answer		Keith Lawrence Kaplan
7	03/28/2017	RJI -RE: REQUEST FOR PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE			Matthew J Ross
8	03/28/2017	PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE REQUEST			Matthew J Ross
9	05/08/2017	ORDER - PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE			Caroline M Enz
10	11/28/2017	ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE			Caroline M Enz
11	06/22/2018	NOTE OF ISSUE:WITH JURY	Note of Issue with Jury		Matthew J Ross	pdf
12	06/22/2018	AFFIRMATION	Affirmation of Compliance		Matthew J Ross
13	06/22/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Compliance Conference Order		Matthew J Ross
14	06/22/2018	AFFIDAVIT	Affidavit of Service by Mail		Matthew J Ross
15	08/15/2018	NOTICE OF MOTION		001	Matthew J Ross	pdf
16	08/15/2018	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION		001	Matthew J Ross
17	08/15/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Pleadings for Action 1	001	Matthew J Ross
18	08/15/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Pleadings for Action 2	001	Matthew J Ross
19	08/15/2018	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE		001	Matthew J Ross
20	09/12/2018	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION	Affirmation in Opposition	001	Lauren Michele Lundquist
21	09/12/2018	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service	001	Lauren Michele Lundquist
22	09/17/2018	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION		001	Jeffrey Robert Neuman
23	09/27/2018	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN REPLY		001	Matthew J Ross
24	09/27/2018	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE		001	Matthew J Ross
25	11/27/2018	ORDER - MOTION- SHORT FORM		001	Kianna Vanputten
26	11/28/2018	NOTICE OF ENTRY	Notice of Entry		Lauren Michele Lundquist
27	11/28/2018	ORDER - (PROPOSED) "SUBMIT ORDER" PER JUDGES DECISION	Order		Lauren Michele Lundquist
28	11/28/2018	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service		Lauren Michele Lundquist
29	03/14/2019	STIPULATION - SO ORDERED			Louisa Ammirati
30	06/07/2019	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE	Letter to Judge O'Donoghue re: Mediation		Lauren Michele Lundquist
31	11/25/2019	STIPULATION - DISCONTINUANCE (POST RJI)	Stipulation of Discontinuance with Prejudice		Lauren Michele Lundquist	pdf

Queens Supreme Court

2017

712363/2016

Disposed

Medical Malpractice

RAMONA ESPINAL-BASTIEN

DUFFY & DUFFY, PLLC

BROOKHAVEN REHABILITATION

Kaufman Borgeest & Ryan LLP

08/05/2019

O'Donoghue, Hon. Peter

▼

Case Info

Court

Queens Supreme Court

Index Number

712363/2016

Status

Disposed

Year Filed

2017

Case Name

RAMONA ESPINAL-BASTIEN vs. BROOKHAVEN REHABILITATION

Case Type

Tort-Medical, Dental, or Podiatric Malpractice

Track

Complex

RJI Filed

02/24/2017

NOI Due

05/28/2018

NOI Filed

05/21/2018

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Jury At Plaintiff's Request

Justice

O'Donoghue, Hon. Peter

Next Appearance

08/05/2019

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

RAMONA ESPINAL-BASTIEN

Attorney / FirmDUFFY & DUFFY, PLLC

Defendant / Respondent

BROOKHAVEN REHABILITATION

Attorneys / FirmsKaufman Borgeest & Ryan LLP

Motions (2)

#	Date Filed	Filed By	Relief Sought	Submit Date	Answer	Status	Decision	Order Signed
2	09/27/2018		Judgment - Summary	11/21/2018	Yes	Decided: 03/26/2019 Decided Before Justice: O'Donoghue, Hon. Peter	Short Form Order	03/26/2019
1	02/28/2017		Dismiss	03/29/2017	Yes	Decided: 05/04/2017 Withdrawn Before Justice: O'Donoghue, Hon. Peter	Short Form Order	05/04/2017

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints (72)

Doc #	Date Filed	Document	Description	Motion #	Filing User	File
1	10/17/2016	SUMMONS			Damien Smith	pdf
2	10/17/2016	COMPLAINT			Damien Smith	pdf
3	10/17/2016	CERTIFICATE OF MERIT			Damien Smith
4	02/14/2017	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE			Michael E Duffy
5	02/14/2017	STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING			Michael E Duffy
6	02/24/2017	NOTICE OF MOTION	Notice of Motion	001	Keith Lawrence Kaplan	pdf
7	02/24/2017	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT	Affirmation in Support	001	Keith Lawrence Kaplan
8	02/24/2017	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service for Motion	001	Keith Lawrence Kaplan
9	02/24/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	S&C	001	Keith Lawrence Kaplan
10	02/24/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	AOS for S&C	001	Keith Lawrence Kaplan
11	02/24/2017	RJI -RE: NOTICE OF MOTION		001	Keith Lawrence Kaplan	pdf
12	02/25/2017	AFFIDAVIT			Michael E Duffy
13	02/25/2017	STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING			Michael E Duffy
14	03/07/2017	STIPULATION - ADJOURNMENT OF MOTION		001	Damien Smith
15	03/17/2017	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION		001	Elyssa Shifren
16	03/17/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Letter to Surrogate Court	001	Elyssa Shifren
17	03/17/2017	AFFIDAVIT	Affidavit of Service	001	Elyssa Shifren
18	03/23/2017	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN REPLY	Reply Affirmation	001	Sade Aiyanna Forte
19	03/23/2017	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Affidavit of service	001	Sade Aiyanna Forte
20	04/18/2017	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE		001	Damien Smith
21	04/19/2017	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE	Letter withdrawing Motion to Dismiss	001	Keith Lawrence Kaplan
22	05/11/2017	DECISION + ORDER ON MOTION		001	Edwin Ruiz	pdf
23	05/11/2017	ORDER - OTHER			Edwin Ruiz
24	05/11/2017	NOTICE OF ENTRY		001	Damien Smith
25	05/11/2017	AFFIDAVIT	Affidavit of Service	001	Damien Smith
26	05/16/2017	ANSWER	Verified Answer		Keith Lawrence Kaplan	pdf
27	05/16/2017	DEMAND FOR BILL OF PARTICULARS	Demand for a BP		Keith Lawrence Kaplan
28	05/16/2017	DEMAND FOR:	Combined Demand		Keith Lawrence Kaplan
29	05/16/2017	NOTICE OF DEPOSITION UPON ORAL EXAMINATION	Notice to take Deposition upon Oral Examination		Keith Lawrence Kaplan
30	05/16/2017	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service for Answer and Demands		Keith Lawrence Kaplan
31	06/30/2017	ORDER - PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE			Caroline M Enz
32	01/25/2018	ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE			Caroline M Enz
33	05/21/2018	NOTE OF ISSUE:WITH JURY			Damien Smith	pdf
34	09/25/2018	NOTICE OF MOTION	NOTICE OF MOTION	002	Lauren Michele Lundquist	pdf
35	09/25/2018	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT	Affirmation of Support	002	Lauren Michele Lundquist
36	09/25/2018	AFFIRMATION	Expert Affirmation	002	Lauren Michele Lundquist
37	09/25/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Summons and Complaint	002	Lauren Michele Lundquist
38	09/25/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Verified Answer	002	Lauren Michele Lundquist
39	09/25/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Verified Bill of Particulars	002	Lauren Michele Lundquist
40	09/25/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Plaintiffs Deposition Transcript	002	Lauren Michele Lundquist
41	09/25/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Transcript of Lorna Gordon	002	Lauren Michele Lundquist
42	09/25/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Brookhaven Records	002	Lauren Michele Lundquist
43	09/25/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Records from Richmond County EMS	002	Lauren Michele Lundquist
44	09/25/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Records from FDNY Emergency Services	002	Lauren Michele Lundquist
45	09/25/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Records from St. Johns Episcopal Hospital	002	Lauren Michele Lundquist
46	09/25/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Accident/Incident Report from Brookhaven Hospital	002	Lauren Michele Lundquist
47	09/25/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Death Certificate	002	Lauren Michele Lundquist
48	09/25/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Records from Office of the Chief Medical Officer Autopsy Report	002	Lauren Michele Lundquist
49	09/25/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Burns v. Rockville Center	002	Lauren Michele Lundquist
50	09/25/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Williams v. Ruby	002	Lauren Michele Lundquist
51	09/25/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Passett v. Menorah Nursing Home	002	Lauren Michele Lundquist
52	09/25/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Ragiel v. Park Avenue Extended Care	002	Lauren Michele Lundquist
53	09/25/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Held v. Woodmere Rehab & Health Center	002	Lauren Michele Lundquist
54	09/25/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Holder v. Menorah Home & Hospital	002	Lauren Michele Lundquist
55	09/25/2018	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service	002	Lauren Michele Lundquist
56	10/17/2018	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION		002	Damien Smith
57	10/17/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Physician Affirmation	002	Damien Smith
58	10/17/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Choking Aspiration Risk/Unsupervised Eating Assessment	002	Damien Smith
59	10/17/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Nurses' notes	002	Damien Smith
60	10/17/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	accident/incident materials	002	Damien Smith
61	10/17/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Autopsy Report	002	Damien Smith
62	10/17/2018	PROOF OF SERVICE		002	Damien Smith
63	11/20/2018	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN REPLY	Reply Affirmation	002	Lauren Michele Lundquist
64	11/20/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Slobin v. Boasiako Court Case	002	Lauren Michele Lundquist
65	11/20/2018	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service	002	Lauren Michele Lundquist
66	04/10/2019	ORDER - MOTION- SHORT FORM		002	Frank Giovinco
67	04/15/2019	NOTICE OF ENTRY	Order with Notice of Entry	002	Damien Smith
68	04/15/2019	PROOF OF SERVICE		002	Damien Smith
69	06/05/2019	STIPULATION - SO ORDERED			Jerome D White
70	07/11/2019	PRE-TRIAL DOCUMENT(S)	EXPERT DISCLOSURE STATEMENT PURSUANT TO CPLR 3101(d)		Damien Smith
71	07/11/2019	PROOF OF SERVICE			Damien Smith
72	08/29/2022	STIPULATION - DISCONTINUANCE (POST RJI)			Keith Lawrence Kaplan	pdf

Oneida Supreme Court

2017

EFCA2017-002204 (1702204/2017)

Disposed

Comm-Contract

ORISKA INSURANCE COMPANY

JAMES M KERNAN

BROOKHAVEN REHABILITATION AND HEALTH

Cullen and Dykman LLP

07/29/2020

MacRae, Hon. Patrick F.

▼

Case Info

Court

Oneida Supreme Court

Index Number

EFCA2017-002204 (1702204/2017)

Status

Disposed

Year Filed

2017

Case Name

ORISKA INSURANCE COMPANY vs. BROOKHAVEN REHABILITATION AND HEALTH

Case Type

Comm-Contract

Track

Standard

RJI Filed

10/20/2017

NOI Due

10/20/2018

NOI Filed

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

MacRae, Hon. Patrick F.

Next Appearance

07/29/2020

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

ORISKA INSURANCE COMPANY

Attorney / FirmJAMES M KERNAN

Defendant / Respondent

BROOKHAVEN REHABILITATION AND HEALTH

Attorneys / FirmsCullen and Dykman LLP

Motions (13)

#	Date Filed	Relief Sought	Submit Date	Answer	Status	Order Signed
13	02/24/2020	Other	07/29/2020	No	Decided: 07/29/2020 Decided Before Justice: MacRae, Hon. Patrick F.	07/29/2020
12	10/10/2019	Other	12/17/2019	No	Decided: 12/17/2019 Decided Before Justice: MacRae, Hon. Patrick F.	12/17/2019
11	09/06/2019	Other	12/17/2019	No	Decided: 12/17/2019 Decided Before Justice: MacRae, Hon. Patrick F.	12/17/2019
10	05/31/2019	Other	06/05/2019	No	Decided: 06/05/2019 Decided Before Justice: MacRae, Hon. Patrick F.	06/05/2019
9	05/29/2019	Other	06/05/2019	No	Decided: 06/05/2019 Decided Before Justice: MacRae, Hon. Patrick F.	06/05/2019
8	04/16/2019	Other	04/24/2019	No	Decided: 04/24/2019 Decided Before Justice: MacRae, Hon. Patrick F.	04/24/2019
7	04/08/2019	Other	04/24/2019	No	Decided: 04/24/2019 Decided Before Justice: MacRae, Hon. Patrick F.	04/24/2019
6	02/04/2019	Other	04/24/2019	No	Decided: 04/24/2019 Decided Before Justice: MacRae, Hon. Patrick F.	04/24/2019
5	01/31/2019	Other	04/24/2019	No	Decided: 04/24/2019 Decided Before Justice: MacRae, Hon. Patrick F.	04/24/2019
4	11/07/2018	Other	02/07/2019	No	Decided: 02/07/2019 Decided Before Justice: MacRae, Hon. Patrick F.	02/07/2019
3	08/29/2018	Other	06/14/2019	No	Decided: 06/14/2019 Decided Before Justice: MacRae, Hon. Patrick F.	06/14/2019
2	01/22/2018	Other	03/21/2018	No	Decided: 03/21/2018 Decided Before Justice: MacRae, Hon. Patrick F.	03/21/2018
1	10/30/2017	Other	10/30/2017	No	Decided: 10/30/2017 Decided Before Justice: MacRae, Hon. Patrick F.	10/30/2017

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints (106)

Doc #	Date Filed	Document	Description	Motion #	Filing User	File
1	10/20/2017	SUMMONS + COMPLAINT			James Matthew Kernan	pdf
2	10/20/2017	ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE - ACCOMPANYING COMMENCEMENT DOC(S) (PROPOSED)		01	James Matthew Kernan	pdf
3	10/20/2017	AFFIDAVIT			James Matthew Kernan
4	10/20/2017	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT			James Matthew Kernan
5	10/20/2017	COPY OF SUBPOENA			James Matthew Kernan
6	10/20/2017	RJI -RE: ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE			James Matthew Kernan	pdf
7	10/20/2017	ADDENDUM - GENERAL (840A)			James Matthew Kernan
8	11/03/2017	NOTICE OF WITHDRAWAL OF MOTION / ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE		01	James Matthew Kernan	pdf
9	01/20/2018	AFFIDAVIT		01	James Matthew Kernan
10	01/20/2018	NOTICE OF MOTION		02	James Matthew Kernan	pdf
11	01/22/2018	ANSWER WITH COUNTER-CLAIM(S)	verified		Christopher Edward Buckey	pdf
12	01/22/2018	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE			Christopher Edward Buckey
13	01/25/2018	NOTICE OF APPEARANCE (PRE RJI)	Roxanne L. Tashjian		Roxanne Lorig Tashjian
14	01/25/2018	NOTICE OF REJECTION		01	James Matthew Kernan
15	01/26/2018	NOTICE OF APPEARANCE (POST RJI)			Ira S Lipsius
16	03/01/2018	ORDER - PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE			Lisa H Johnson
17	03/09/2018	ORDER ( PROPOSED )			Ariel E Ronneburger
18	03/13/2018	ORDER - OTHER			Lisa H Johnson
19	03/20/2018	NOTICE OF WITHDRAWAL OF MOTION / ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE		02	David Arthur Bagley	pdf
20	03/23/2018	NOTICE OF ENTRY	with Order - Brookhaven		Roxanne Lorig Tashjian
21	03/28/2018	DEMAND FOR BILL OF PARTICULARS			David Arthur Bagley
22	04/02/2018	STIPULATION - DISCOVERY ( REQUEST TO SO ORDER )			Ira S Lipsius
23	04/02/2018	REPLY TO COUNTERCLAIM(S)			David Arthur Bagley
24	04/12/2018	STIPULATION - DISCOVERY			Lisa H Johnson
25	05/23/2018	NOTICE OF DISCOVERY AND INSPECTION			David Arthur Bagley
26	08/29/2018	NOTICE OF MOTION	NOTICE OF MOTION TO AMEND	03	Ryan Matthew Soebke	pdf
27	08/29/2018	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT	AFFIRMATION	03	Ryan Matthew Soebke
28	08/29/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	EXHIBIT A - COMPLAINT	03	Ryan Matthew Soebke
29	08/29/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	EXHIBIT B - ANSWERS	03	Ryan Matthew Soebke
30	08/29/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	EXHIBIT C - FEBRURAY 2013 DFS ORDER	03	Ryan Matthew Soebke
31	08/29/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	EXHIBIT D - ORDER DENYING DFS ORDER	03	Ryan Matthew Soebke
32	08/29/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	EXHIBIT E - ORDER UPHOLDING DSF	03	Ryan Matthew Soebke
33	08/29/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	EXHIBIT F - ORDER VACATING STAY	03	Ryan Matthew Soebke
34	08/29/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	EXHIBIT G - AMENDED ANSWER	03	Ryan Matthew Soebke
35	08/29/2018	MEMORANDUM OF LAW	MEMORANDUM OF LAW	03	Ryan Matthew Soebke
36	09/12/2018	LETTER/CORRESPONDENCE FROM COURT		03	Lisa H Johnson
37	09/20/2018	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE			Ira S Lipsius
38	09/20/2018	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE			Ira S Lipsius
39	09/24/2018	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION		03	David Arthur Bagley
40	09/24/2018	MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN OPPOSITION		03	David Arthur Bagley
41	10/17/2018	MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN REPLY		03	Ira S Lipsius
42	10/19/2018	LETTER/CORRESPONDENCE - SO ORDERED		03	Lisa H Johnson
43	11/05/2018	NOTICE OF MOTION		04	Ira S Lipsius	pdf
44	11/05/2018	MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN SUPPORT		04	Ira S Lipsius
45	11/05/2018	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION		04	Ira S Lipsius
46	11/05/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	DFS Report and Recommendation	04	Ira S Lipsius
47	11/05/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	DFS Final Order re Kernan	04	Ira S Lipsius
48	11/05/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Order re Kernan Disqualification	04	Ira S Lipsius
49	11/05/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	NDNY Docket	04	Ira S Lipsius
50	11/15/2018	MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN OPPOSITION		04	David Arthur Bagley
51	11/15/2018	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION		04	David Arthur Bagley
52	11/28/2018	LETTER/CORRESPONDENCE FROM COURT			Lisa H Johnson
53	01/30/2019	NOTICE OF MOTION		05	Ira S Lipsius	pdf
54	01/30/2019	MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN SUPPORT		05	Ira S Lipsius
55	01/30/2019	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION		05	Ira S Lipsius
56	02/04/2019	NOTICE OF CROSS-MOTION		06	David Arthur Bagley
57	02/04/2019	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF CROSS-MOTION		06	David Arthur Bagley
58	02/04/2019	MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN SUPPORT		06	David Arthur Bagley
59	02/06/2019	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO CROSS-MOTION		06	Ira S Lipsius
60	02/08/2019	LETTER/CORRESPONDENCE FROM COURT			Senta B Siuda
61	02/13/2019	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE			Ira S Lipsius
62	02/14/2019	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE			David Arthur Bagley
63	02/14/2019	LETTER/CORRESPONDENCE FROM COURT			Senta B Siuda
64	02/25/2019	ORDER ( PROPOSED )		05	Ira S Lipsius
65	02/28/2019	ORDER ( PROPOSED )		04	Ira S Lipsius
66	03/15/2019	ORDER - OTHER			Lisa H Johnson
67	03/15/2019	ORDER - OTHER			Lisa H Johnson
68	03/15/2019	ORDER - OTHER			Lisa H Johnson
69	03/20/2019	ANSWERS TO INTERROGATORIES			David Arthur Bagley	pdf
70	03/22/2019	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE	3/22 - Justice MacRae Correspondence Re: Status Report		Christopher Edward Buckey
71	04/04/2019	LETTER/CORRESPONDENCE FROM COURT			Lisa H Johnson
72	04/05/2019	NOTICE OF MOTION		07	Ariel E Ronneburger	pdf
73	04/05/2019	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT		07	Ariel E Ronneburger
74	04/05/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	Subpoena	07	Ariel E Ronneburger
75	04/05/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	3/21/19 Letter to James Kernan	07	Ariel E Ronneburger
76	04/05/2019	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT		07	Ariel E Ronneburger
77	04/05/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	12/18/17 E-Mail	07	Ariel E Ronneburger
78	04/05/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	7/10/17 E-Mail	07	Ariel E Ronneburger
79	04/05/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	1/3/18 E-Mail	07	Ariel E Ronneburger
80	04/05/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	4/29/15 E-Mail	07	Ariel E Ronneburger
81	04/05/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	12/2013 E-Mail	07	Ariel E Ronneburger
82	04/05/2019	MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN SUPPORT		07	Ariel E Ronneburger
83	04/08/2019	NOTICE OF APPEARANCE (POST RJI)			Frank Policelli
84	04/16/2019	NOTICE OF CROSS-MOTION		08	Frank Policelli
85	04/16/2019	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION AND IN SUPPORT OF CROSS-MOTION			Frank Policelli
86	04/16/2019	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION AND IN SUPPORT OF CROSS-MOTION			Frank Policelli
87	04/16/2019	MEMORANDUM OF LAW			Frank Policelli
88	04/16/2019	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE	04.16.19 Supplemental Status Report		Christopher Edward Buckey
89	04/16/2019	ORDER ( PROPOSED )	Stipulation and Order for the Production and Exchange of Confidential Information		Christopher Edward Buckey
90	04/23/2019	MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN OPPOSITION TO CROSS-MOTION AND IN FURTHER SUPPORT OF MOTION		08	Christopher Edward Buckey
91	04/23/2019	AFFIDAVIT		08	Christopher Edward Buckey
92	04/24/2019	STIPULATION - SO ORDERED			Lisa H Johnson
93	05/01/2019	ORDER ( PROPOSED )	Contempt Order		Christopher Edward Buckey
94	05/01/2019	ORDER ( PROPOSED )	Joinder Order		Christopher Edward Buckey
95	05/02/2019	ORDER ( PROPOSED )	Discovery Order		Christopher Edward Buckey
96	05/03/2019	ORDER - OTHER			Lisa H Johnson
97	05/22/2019	NOTICE OF APPEAL			Frank Policelli	pdf
98	05/28/2019	NOTICE OF MOTION		09	Frank Policelli	pdf
99	05/30/2019	NOTICE OF CHANGE OF FIRM NAME OR ADDRESS (POST RJI)	Notice of Change of Firm Address and Fax Number		Christopher Edward Buckey
100	09/19/2019	ANSWER (AMENDED)			Christopher Edward Buckey	pdf
101	10/08/2019	REPLY TO COUNTERCLAIM(S)			Jessica Leigh Sprague
102	10/10/2019	NOTICE OF APPEAL			Jessica Leigh Sprague	pdf
103	06/10/2020	NOTICE OF MOTION			Andrew S. Fisher
104	06/10/2020	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION			Andrew S. Fisher
105	07/31/2020	NOTICE OF ENTRY	Notice of Entry with Decision		Ira S Lipsius
106	03/16/2022	NOTICE OF ENTRY			Ira S Lipsius

Queens Supreme Court

2016

713325/2015

Disposed

Medical Malpractice

ZOBA, GREGG

Bergman, Bergman, Fields & Lamonsoff, LLP

BROOKHAVEN REHABILITATION ETAL

WAGNER, DOMAN, LETO & DI LEO, P.C.

02/06/2018

O'Donoghue, Hon. Peter

▼

Case Info

Court

Queens Supreme Court

Index Number

713325/2015

Status

Disposed

Year Filed

2016

Case Name

ZOBA, GREGG vs. BROOKHAVEN REHABILITATION ETAL

Case Type

Tort-Medical, Dental, or Podiatric Malpractice

Track

Standard

RJI Filed

06/17/2016

NOI Due

06/17/2017

NOI Filed

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

O'Donoghue, Hon. Peter

Next Appearance

02/06/2018

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

ZOBA, GREGG

Attorney / FirmBergman, Bergman, Fields & Lamonsoff, LLP

Defendant / Respondent

BROOKHAVEN REHABILITATION ETAL

Attorneys / FirmsWAGNER, DOMAN, LETO & DI LEO, P.C.

Motions (3)

#	Date Filed	Relief Sought	Submit Date	Answer	Status	Decision	Order Signed
3	08/04/2017	Discovery	08/30/2017	Yes	Decided: 08/30/2017 Withdrawn Before Justice: O'Donoghue, Hon. Peter	Oral	08/30/2017
2	05/08/2017	Consolidate	05/24/2017	Yes	Decided: 06/08/2017 Denied Before Justice: O'Donoghue, Hon. Peter	Short Form Order	06/08/2017
1	06/21/2016	Extend - Time	07/27/2016	Yes	Decided: 07/27/2016 Withdrawn Before Justice: O'Donoghue, Hon. Peter	Oral	07/27/2016

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints (87)

Doc #	Date Filed	Document	Description	Motion #	Filing User	File
1	12/28/2015	SUMMONS + COMPLAINT			David Merrill Freeman	pdf
2	01/07/2016	SUMMONS - SUPPLEMENTAL (PRE RJI)			David Merrill Freeman	pdf
3	01/07/2016	COMPLAINT (AMENDED)			David Merrill Freeman	pdf
4	01/11/2016	STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING			Philip John Rizzuto
5	01/11/2016	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE			Philip John Rizzuto
6	01/15/2016	STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING			Philip John Rizzuto
7	01/15/2016	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE			Philip John Rizzuto
8	02/01/2016	ANSWER			David Blair Desiver	pdf
9	02/04/2016	ANSWER	DR. KHANINA'S ANSWER		Thomas J Benvenuto	pdf
10	02/05/2016	STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING			Philip John Rizzuto
11	02/05/2016	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE			Philip John Rizzuto
12	02/12/2016	STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING			Philip John Rizzuto
13	02/12/2016	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE			Philip John Rizzuto
14	03/18/2016	ANSWER			Daniel Joseph Wityk	pdf
15	03/18/2016	NOTICE OF DEPOSITION UPON ORAL EXAMINATION			Daniel Joseph Wityk
16	03/18/2016	DEMAND FOR:	Demand to Preserve Social Media Accounts		Daniel Joseph Wityk
17	03/18/2016	DEMAND FOR:	Demand for Expert Disclosure		Daniel Joseph Wityk
18	03/18/2016	DEMAND FOR:	Demand for Disclosure of Medicare and Medicaid Benefits		Daniel Joseph Wityk
19	03/18/2016	DEMAND FOR BILL OF PARTICULARS			Daniel Joseph Wityk
20	03/18/2016	DEMAND FOR:	Combined Demands		Daniel Joseph Wityk
21	03/18/2016	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE			Daniel Joseph Wityk
22	05/12/2016	ANSWER	Verified Answer to Amended Complaint		David Blair Desiver	pdf
23	06/17/2016	NOTICE OF MOTION	Notice of Motion & Affirmation to Compel Discovery	001	Seth D Cohen	pdf
24	06/17/2016	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit A-Summons & Complaint	001	Seth D Cohen
25	06/17/2016	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit B-Verified Answer with Discovery Demands	001	Seth D Cohen
26	06/17/2016	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit C-Amended Verified Complaint	001	Seth D Cohen
27	06/17/2016	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit D-Verified Answer to Amended Complaint	001	Seth D Cohen
28	06/17/2016	EXHIBIT(S)	Co-Defendants' Verified Answers	001	Seth D Cohen
29	06/17/2016	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit F-Discovery Letters to Plaintiff	001	Seth D Cohen
30	06/17/2016	RJI -RE: NOTICE OF MOTION		001	Seth D Cohen	pdf
31	06/27/2016	CERTIFICATE OF MERIT	Certificate of Merit		Alicia M Bartkowski
32	07/08/2016	NOTICE OF CHANGE OF FIRM NAME OR ADDRESS (POST RJI)	Notice of Change of Address		Alicia M Bartkowski
33	07/08/2016	DEMAND FOR BILL OF PARTICULARS	Demand for Verified BP - Singh, M.D.		Alicia M Bartkowski
34	07/08/2016	DEMAND FOR BILL OF PARTICULARS	Demand for Verified BP - Khanina, M.D.		Alicia M Bartkowski
35	07/08/2016	DEMAND FOR BILL OF PARTICULARS	Demand for Verified BP - Brookhaven Rehab		Alicia M Bartkowski
36	07/08/2016	BILL OF PARTICULARS	Verified BP - Brookhaven Rehab		Alicia M Bartkowski
37	07/08/2016	BILL OF PARTICULARS	Verified BP - Singh, M.D.		Alicia M Bartkowski
38	07/08/2016	BILL OF PARTICULARS	Verified BP - Khanina, M.D.		Alicia M Bartkowski
39	07/08/2016	DEMAND FOR:	Notice to Produce Nursing Home Chart		Alicia M Bartkowski
40	07/08/2016	NOTICE OF DISCOVERY AND INSPECTION	Notice of Discovery and Inspection and Combined Demands		Alicia M Bartkowski
41	07/08/2016	RESPONSE TO DEMAND	Plaintiff's Response to Defendants' Combined Demands		Alicia M Bartkowski
42	07/08/2016	NOTICE OF MEDICAL MALPRACTICE	Notice of MedMal Action		Alicia M Bartkowski
43	07/14/2016	PROOF OF SERVICE	Proof of Service - Notice of Commencement and Request for Lien		Alicia M Bartkowski
44	07/22/2016	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION	Plaintiff's Affirmation in Opposition	001	Alicia M Bartkowski
45	07/22/2016	EXHIBIT(S)	Exh A - Certificate of Merit	001	Alicia M Bartkowski
46	07/22/2016	EXHIBIT(S)	Exh B - Notice of MedMal	001	Alicia M Bartkowski
47	07/22/2016	EXHIBIT(S)	Exh C - Responses to Demands	001	Alicia M Bartkowski
48	07/22/2016	PROOF OF SERVICE	Proof of Service	001	Alicia M Bartkowski
49	07/25/2016	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN REPLY	Reply Affirmation regarding Motion to Compel	001	Seth D Cohen
50	07/25/2016	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit A-Verified Bill of Particulars as to Dr. Harmandeep Singh	001	Seth D Cohen
51	08/02/2016	STIPULATION - SO ORDERED			Jerome D White
52	08/23/2016	ORDER - PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE			Jerome D White
53	10/03/2016	CONSENT TO EFILING			Stuart Bernstein
54	12/12/2016	SUBSTITUTION OF ATTORNEY (POST RJI)	Notice of Substitution and Consent to Change Attorney.		Stuart Bernstein
55	02/22/2017	ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE			Jerome D White
56	04/26/2017	NOTICE OF CHANGE OF FIRM NAME OR ADDRESS (POST RJI)			David Blair Desiver
57	05/04/2017	NOTICE OF MOTION		002	Alicia M Bartkowski	pdf
58	05/04/2017	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT		002	Alicia M Bartkowski
59	05/04/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Plaintiff's Summons and Complaint	002	Alicia M Bartkowski
60	05/04/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Defendant Brookhaven Rehab Answer	002	Alicia M Bartkowski
61	05/04/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Defendant Singh Answer	002	Alicia M Bartkowski
62	05/04/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Defendant Khanina Answer	002	Alicia M Bartkowski
63	05/04/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	BP Brookhaven	002	Alicia M Bartkowski
64	05/04/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	BP Singh	002	Alicia M Bartkowski
65	05/04/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	BP Khanina	002	Alicia M Bartkowski
66	05/04/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	PC Order	002	Alicia M Bartkowski
67	05/04/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Action 2 Summons and Complaint	002	Alicia M Bartkowski
68	05/04/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Defendant Bebawi Answer	002	Alicia M Bartkowski
69	05/04/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	BP Bebawi	002	Alicia M Bartkowski
70	05/04/2017	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE		002	Alicia M Bartkowski
71	06/22/2017	DECISION + ORDER ON MOTION		002	Edwin Ruiz	pdf
72	08/02/2017	NOTICE OF MOTION	MOTION TO PRECLUDE	003	Alexander Joseph Papa	pdf
73	08/02/2017	AFFIRMATION OF GOOD FAITH	AFFIRMATION IN GOOD FAITH	003	Alexander Joseph Papa
74	08/02/2017	AFFIRMATION	AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT	003	Alexander Joseph Papa
75	08/02/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	SUMMONS & COMPLAINT	003	Alexander Joseph Papa
76	08/02/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	ANSWER KHANINA	003	Alexander Joseph Papa
77	08/02/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	BILL OF PARTICULARS	003	Alexander Joseph Papa
78	08/02/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	DAZ 11.10.16	003	Alexander Joseph Papa
79	08/02/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	NOTICE TO PRODUCE 12.1.16	003	Alexander Joseph Papa
80	08/02/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	CCO 2.14.17	003	Alexander Joseph Papa
81	08/02/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	DAZ 5.1.17	003	Alexander Joseph Papa
82	08/02/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	GOOD FAITH LETTERS	003	Alexander Joseph Papa
83	08/02/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	DAZ 6.20.17	003	Alexander Joseph Papa
84	08/02/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	GOOD FAITH 7.14.17	003	Alexander Joseph Papa
85	08/02/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	DAZ 7.26.17	003	Alexander Joseph Papa
86	08/02/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	GOOD FAITH 7.28.17	003	Alexander Joseph Papa
87	08/02/2017	AFFIDAVIT	AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE ECF	003	Alexander Joseph Papa

Kings Supreme Court

2016

509979/2015

Disposed

Negligence

RAGUNANDAN, SHARON

DUFFY & DUFFY, PLLC

BROOKHAVEN REHABILITATION

Caitlin Robin & Associates PLLC

05/23/2019

Jimenez, Hon. Dawn

▼

Case Info

Court

Kings Supreme Court

Index Number

509979/2015

Status

Disposed

Year Filed

2016

Case Name

RAGUNANDAN, SHARON vs. BROOKHAVEN REHABILITATION

Case Type

Tort-Other Negligence

Track

Complex

RJI Filed

01/28/2016

NOI Due

04/30/2017

NOI Filed

08/29/2017

Calendar Number

2017-002353T

Jury Status

Jury At Plaintiff's Request

Justice

Jimenez, Hon. Dawn

Next Appearance

05/23/2019

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

RAGUNANDAN, SHARON

Attorney / FirmDUFFY & DUFFY, PLLC

Defendant / Respondent

BROOKHAVEN REHABILITATION

Attorneys / FirmsCaitlin Robin & Associates PLLC

Motions

No motions recorded for this case.

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints (29)

Doc #	Date Filed	Document	Description	Filing User	File
1	08/13/2015	SUMMONS + COMPLAINT		Frank Torres	pdf
2	08/28/2015	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE		Damien Smith
3	12/04/2015	ANSWER	Answer	Caitlin A Robin	pdf
4	12/04/2015	ACKNOWLEDGEMENT OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service	Caitlin A Robin
5	01/28/2016	PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE REQUEST	PC Request and Affirmation in Good Faith	Damien Smith
6	01/28/2016	AFFIDAVIT	Affidavit of Service Request for PC and RJI	Damien Smith
7	01/28/2016	RJI -RE: REQUEST FOR PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE		Damien Smith
8	04/19/2016	ORDER - PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE	dated 3/01/16 Filed CC 3/24/16	Regina Fitzgerald
9	10/18/2016	ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE	dated 10/13/16	Maureen Lawton
10	02/15/2017	CONSENT TO CHANGE ATTORNEY (POST RJI)	Consent to Change Attorney	Mario Christopher Giannettino
11	04/21/2017	STIPULATION - OTHER		Damien Smith
12	04/25/2017	STIPULATION - SO ORDERED		Milagros Ruiz
13	06/16/2017	STIPULATION - OTHER - ( REQUEST TO SO ORDER )	Stipulation to Extent time to File Note of Issue	Damien Smith
14	06/16/2017	AFFIRMATION	Affirmation in Compliance	Damien Smith
15	07/28/2017	STIPULATION - SO ORDERED	note of issue due 08/29/17. (final)	Milagros Ruiz
16	08/29/2017	NOTE OF ISSUE:WITH JURY		Damien Smith	pdf
17	08/29/2017	AFFIRMATION	Affirmation in Compliance	Damien Smith
18	05/31/2018	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE		Philip J. Artusa
19	05/31/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Complaint with Cert. of Merit	Philip J. Artusa
20	06/04/2018	ORDER - OTHER	dtd 6/1/2018	Talik Rhett
21	01/25/2019	TRIAL DOCUMENTS	Letter to KBR w/NPW Subpoenas	Damien Smith	pdf
22	01/31/2019	PRE-TRIAL DOCUMENT(S)	EXPERT DISCLOSURE STATEMENT PURSUANT TO CPLR 3101(d)	Damien Smith
23	02/04/2019	PRE-TRIAL DOCUMENT(S)	Expert Disclosure Statement Pursuant to CPLR 3101(d)	Philip J. Artusa
24	02/06/2019	PRE-TRIAL DOCUMENT(S)	RESPONSE TO NOTICE TO ADMIT	Damien Smith
25	04/04/2019	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE		Damien Smith
26	12/12/2019	NOTICE OF SETTLEMENT W/PROPOSED JDGMT/COUNTER JDGMT	Judgment with Notice of Settlement	Damien Smith	pdf
27	12/12/2019	PROOF OF SERVICE		Damien Smith
28	02/18/2020	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE	Letter to Judge - we hereby withdraw our Judgment with Notice of Settlement	Damien Smith
29	03/31/2021	STIPULATION - DISCONTINUANCE (POST RJI)		Philip J. Artusa	pdf

Queens Supreme Court

2015

706565/2014

Disposed

Medical Malpractice

HEBRANKO, MADELAINE ANO

Trolman Glaser Corley & Lichtman, P.C.

BEBAWI, MAGDI ANO

Benvenuto & Gaujean

08/06/2024

Catapano-Fox, Hon. Tracy A.

▼

Case Info

Court

Queens Supreme Court

Index Number

706565/2014

Status

Disposed

Year Filed

2015

Case Name

HEBRANKO, MADELAINE ANO vs. BEBAWI, MAGDI ANO

Case Type

Tort-Medical, Dental, or Podiatric Malpractice

Track

Complex

RJI Filed

06/16/2015

NOI Due

09/16/2016

NOI Filed

09/09/2016

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Jury At Plaintiff's Request

Justice

Catapano-Fox, Hon. Tracy A.

Next Appearance

08/06/2024

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

HEBRANKO, MADELAINE ANO

Attorney / FirmTrolman Glaser Corley & Lichtman, P.C.

Defendant / Respondent

BEBAWI, MAGDI ANO

Attorneys / FirmsBenvenuto & Gaujean

Motions (10)

#	Date Filed	Filed By	Relief Sought	Submit Date	Answer	Status	Decision	Order Signed
10	07/05/2024	PLAINTIFF	Contempt	07/17/2024	No	Decided: 08/08/2024 Denied Before Justice: Catapano-Fox, Hon. Tracy A.	Short Form Order
9	06/27/2024	DEFENDANT	Attorney - Disqualify/Relieve/Substitute/Withdraw	07/31/2024	No	Decided: 07/31/2024 Withdrawn Before Justice: Catapano-Fox, Hon. Tracy A.	Oral
8	12/12/2019		Attorney - Disqualify/Relieve/Substitute/Withdraw	02/26/2020	No	Decided: 02/27/2020 Granted Before Justice: O'Donoghue, Hon. Peter	Short Form Order	02/27/2020
7	03/10/2017		Dismiss	04/26/2017	Yes	Decided: 08/23/2017 Decided Before Justice: O'Donoghue, Hon. Peter	Short Form Order	08/23/2017
6	03/10/2017		Dismiss	04/26/2017	Yes	Decided: 08/23/2017 Decided Before Justice: O'Donoghue, Hon. Peter	Short Form Order	08/23/2017
5	03/10/2017		Dismiss	04/26/2017	No	Decided: 08/23/2017 Decided Before Justice: O'Donoghue, Hon. Peter	Short Form Order	08/23/2017
4	10/03/2016		Vacate/Strike - Note of Issue/Jury Demand/From Trial Calendar	04/05/2017	Yes	Decided: 04/05/2017 Withdrawn Before Justice: O'Donoghue, Hon. Peter	Oral	04/05/2017
3	09/30/2016		Vacate/Strike - Note of Issue/Jury Demand/From Trial Calendar	04/05/2017	Yes	Decided: 04/05/2017 Withdrawn Before Justice: O'Donoghue, Hon. Peter	Oral	04/05/2017
2	09/21/2015		Extend - Time	10/14/2015	Yes	Decided: 10/15/2015 Granted Before Justice: O'Donoghue, Hon. Peter	Short Form Order	10/15/2015
1	06/19/2015		Dismiss	07/29/2015	Yes	Decided: 07/29/2015 Withdrawn Before Justice: O'Donoghue, Hon. Peter	Oral	07/29/2015

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints (211)

Doc #	Date Filed	Document	Description	Motion #	Filing User	File
1	09/15/2014	SUMMONS + COMPLAINT			Jeffrey A. Lichtman	pdf
2	09/30/2014	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	UPON KHANINA		Jeffrey A. Lichtman
3	09/30/2014	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	UPON BROOKHAVEN REHABILITATION		Jeffrey A. Lichtman
4	10/30/2014	ANSWER	answer-Khanina		Thomas J Benvenuto	pdf
5	11/06/2014	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE UPON MAGDI BEBAWI, M.D.		Jeffrey A. Lichtman
6	11/07/2014	ANSWER	Answer MAGDI BEBAWI, M.D.		Larry David Bloomstein	pdf
7	11/07/2014	DEMAND FOR BILL OF PARTICULARS	Demand for Bill of Particulars DR. BEBAWI		Larry David Bloomstein
8	11/07/2014	DEMAND FOR:	Various Discovery Demands DR. BEBAWI		Larry David Bloomstein
9	11/24/2014	ANSWER	Verified Answer		Albert Buznik	pdf
10	11/24/2014	AFFIDAVIT	Affidavit of Service		Albert Buznik
11	11/24/2014	STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING			Albert Buznik
12	06/01/2015	CONSENT TO CHANGE ATTORNEY (POST RJI)			Frank Giovinco
13	06/16/2015	RJI -RE: NOTICE OF MOTION	RJI to accompany Notice of Motion		Rupa Banik	pdf
14	06/16/2015	NOTICE OF MOTION	Notice of Motion, Affirmation of Good Faith and Attorney Affirmation	001	Rupa Banik	pdf
15	06/16/2015	EXHIBIT(S)	Summons and Complaint	001	Rupa Banik
16	06/16/2015	EXHIBIT(S)	ANSWER	001	Rupa Banik
17	06/16/2015	EXHIBIT(S)	Demand for Bill of Particulars and initial discovery demands/notices	001	Rupa Banik
18	06/16/2015	EXHIBIT(S)	Demand for Authorizations	001	Rupa Banik
19	06/16/2015	EXHIBIT(S)	Good faith letters	001	Rupa Banik
20	06/25/2015	NOTICE OF CROSS-MOTION	Notice of Cross Motion	001	Thomas J Benvenuto
21	06/25/2015	EXHIBIT(S)	Summons	001	Thomas J Benvenuto
22	06/25/2015	EXHIBIT(S)	Verified Answer	001	Thomas J Benvenuto
23	06/25/2015	EXHIBIT(S)	Good Faith Letter	001	Thomas J Benvenuto
24	07/14/2015	STIPULATION - ADJOURNMENT OF MOTION		001	Jeffrey A. Lichtman
25	07/28/2015	STIPULATION - WITHDRAWING MOTION/ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE		001	Jeffrey A. Lichtman	pdf
26	09/18/2015	NOTICE OF MOTION		002	Jeffrey A. Lichtman	pdf
27	09/18/2015	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION		002	Jeffrey A. Lichtman
28	09/18/2015	EXHIBIT(S)	Summons and Complaint and Answers	002	Jeffrey A. Lichtman
29	09/18/2015	EXHIBIT(S)	Notice of Medical Malpractice Action	002	Jeffrey A. Lichtman
30	09/23/2015	ORDER - PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE			Jerome D White
31	10/20/2015	CONSENT TO EFILING			Stuart Bernstein
32	10/27/2015	DECISION + ORDER ON MOTION		002	Frank Giovinco	pdf
33	10/30/2015	NOTICE OF ENTRY		002	Jeffrey A. Lichtman
34	02/03/2016	CONSENT TO CHANGE ATTORNEY (POST RJI)			Stuart Bernstein
35	04/07/2016	ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE			Julio Mieses
36	09/09/2016	NOTE OF ISSUE:WITH JURY			Jeffrey A. Lichtman	pdf
37	09/28/2016	NOTICE OF MOTION	Motion to strike Note of Issue	003	Vincent Dennis Finnegan	pdf
38	09/28/2016	EXHIBIT(S)	Note of Issue	003	Vincent Dennis Finnegan
39	09/28/2016	EXHIBIT(S)	Discovery demands	003	Vincent Dennis Finnegan
40	09/28/2016	EXHIBIT(S)	Order dated March 22, 2016	003	Vincent Dennis Finnegan
41	09/29/2016	NOTICE OF MOTION	Notice of Motion	004	Jordan Courtney Conger	pdf
42	09/29/2016	AFFIRMATION OF GOOD FAITH	Affirmation of Good Faith	004	Jordan Courtney Conger
43	09/29/2016	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT	Affirmation in Support	004	Jordan Courtney Conger
44	09/29/2016	EXHIBIT(S)	Summons and Complaint	004	Jordan Courtney Conger
45	09/29/2016	EXHIBIT(S)	Codefendant Khanina's Answer	004	Jordan Courtney Conger
46	09/29/2016	EXHIBIT(S)	Our Answer with Various Demands	004	Jordan Courtney Conger
47	09/29/2016	EXHIBIT(S)	CoDefendant Brookhaven Answer	004	Jordan Courtney Conger
48	09/29/2016	EXHIBIT(S)	Verified Bills of Particulars as to all Defendants	004	Jordan Courtney Conger
49	09/29/2016	EXHIBIT(S)	Stip to Withdraw Motions	004	Jordan Courtney Conger
50	09/29/2016	EXHIBIT(S)	Plaintiff's Motion to File Notice of Med Mal Late	004	Jordan Courtney Conger
51	09/29/2016	EXHIBIT(S)	PC Order	004	Jordan Courtney Conger
52	09/29/2016	EXHIBIT(S)	CC Order	004	Jordan Courtney Conger
53	09/29/2016	EXHIBIT(S)	Post EBT Demands	004	Jordan Courtney Conger
54	09/29/2016	EXHIBIT(S)	Note of Issue	004	Jordan Courtney Conger
55	09/29/2016	EXHIBIT(S)	Good Faith Letter	004	Jordan Courtney Conger
56	10/18/2016	NOTICE OF CROSS-MOTION		003	Seth Jeremy Rutman
57	10/18/2016	AFFIRMATION OF GOOD FAITH		003	Seth Jeremy Rutman
58	10/18/2016	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF CROSS-MOTION		003	Seth Jeremy Rutman
59	10/18/2016	EXHIBIT(S)	Note of Issue	003	Seth Jeremy Rutman
60	10/18/2016	EXHIBIT(S)	Demand for Authorizations	003	Seth Jeremy Rutman
61	10/18/2016	EXHIBIT(S)	Compliance Conference Order	003	Seth Jeremy Rutman
62	10/20/2016	STIPULATION - ADJOURNMENT OF MOTION		004	Jeffrey A. Lichtman
63	12/19/2016	STIPULATION - SO ORDERED			Lee Goldberg
64	02/14/2017	CONSENT TO CHANGE ATTORNEY (POST RJI)	Consent to Change Attorney		Mario Christopher Giannettino
65	02/27/2017	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION		004	Jeffrey A. Lichtman
66	02/27/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Letter enclosing authorizations	004	Jeffrey A. Lichtman
67	02/27/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Ltrs enclosing Medicaid/Medicare Lien Information	004	Jeffrey A. Lichtman
68	02/28/2017	AFFIRMATION	Reply Affirmation		Rupa Banik
69	02/28/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Stipulation 11.30.16		Rupa Banik
70	03/02/2017	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN REPLY		004	Vincent Dennis Finnegan
71	03/02/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	so ordered stipulation dated November 30, 2016	004	Vincent Dennis Finnegan
72	03/06/2017	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE		004	Mario Christopher Giannettino
73	03/08/2017	NOTICE OF MOTION	Notice of Motion for Summary Judgment	005	Rupa Banik	pdf
74	03/08/2017	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION	Affirmation in Support of summary judgment motion	005	Rupa Banik
75	03/08/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Summons and Complaint	005	Rupa Banik
76	03/08/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Verified Answer of defendant Magdi Bebawi, M.D.	005	Rupa Banik
77	03/08/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Bill of Particulars	005	Rupa Banik
78	03/08/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Note of Issue	005	Rupa Banik
79	03/08/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Order dated 11/30/16	005	Rupa Banik
80	03/08/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Consent to Change Attorney	005	Rupa Banik
81	03/08/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Transcript of plaintiff's deposition	005	Rupa Banik
82	03/08/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Transcript of Dr. Bebawi's deposition	005	Rupa Banik
83	03/08/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Transcript of Dr. Khanina's deposition	005	Rupa Banik
84	03/08/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Brookhaven Records	005	Rupa Banik
85	03/08/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Dr. Bebawi's Progress Notes	005	Rupa Banik
86	03/08/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	St. Luke's-Roosevelt Hospital Records	005	Rupa Banik
87	03/08/2017	AFFIRMATION	Physician's Affirmation in support of Summary Judgment Motion	005	Rupa Banik
88	03/08/2017	NOTICE OF MOTION		006	Vincent Dennis Finnegan	pdf
89	03/08/2017	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION	Motion for Summary Judgment	006	Vincent Dennis Finnegan
90	03/08/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Summons	006	Vincent Dennis Finnegan
91	03/08/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Verified Answer	006	Vincent Dennis Finnegan
92	03/08/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Consent to Change Attorney	006	Vincent Dennis Finnegan
93	03/08/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Verified Bill of Particulars	006	Vincent Dennis Finnegan
94	03/08/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Note of Issue	006	Vincent Dennis Finnegan
95	03/08/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Stipulation	006	Vincent Dennis Finnegan
96	03/08/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Plaintiff's Deposition	006	Vincent Dennis Finnegan
97	03/08/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Continued Plaintiff's Deposition	006	Vincent Dennis Finnegan
98	03/08/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Continued Plaintiff's Deposition	006	Vincent Dennis Finnegan
99	03/08/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Continued Plaintiff's Deposition	006	Vincent Dennis Finnegan
100	03/08/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Deposition of Dr. M. Bebawi	006	Vincent Dennis Finnegan
101	03/08/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Deposition of Dr. P. Khanina	006	Vincent Dennis Finnegan
102	03/08/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Expert Affirmation of Poonam Alaigh, M.D.	006	Vincent Dennis Finnegan
103	03/08/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Report of Consultation	006	Vincent Dennis Finnegan
104	03/08/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Brookhaven Nursing Admission Assessment	006	Vincent Dennis Finnegan
105	03/08/2017	NOTICE OF MOTION		007	Mario Christopher Giannettino	pdf
106	03/08/2017	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION		007	Mario Christopher Giannettino
107	03/08/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Summons and Complaint	007	Mario Christopher Giannettino
108	03/08/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Answer	007	Mario Christopher Giannettino
109	03/08/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Bill of Particulars	007	Mario Christopher Giannettino
110	03/17/2017	STIPULATION - SO ORDERED			Jerome D White
111	04/06/2017	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION		005	Jeffrey A. Lichtman
112	04/06/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Physician's Affirmation	005	Jeffrey A. Lichtman
113	04/06/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Letter from Jeanine B. Albu, M.D.	005	Jeffrey A. Lichtman
114	04/06/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Portion of Madelaine Hebranko's EBT Transcript	005	Jeffrey A. Lichtman
115	04/06/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Portion of Polina Khanina's EBT Transcript	005	Jeffrey A. Lichtman
116	04/06/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Portion of Magdi Bebawi's EBT Transcript	005	Jeffrey A. Lichtman
117	04/06/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	4/12/12 progress note	005	Jeffrey A. Lichtman
118	04/06/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Letter from the Commissioner of Health	005	Jeffrey A. Lichtman
119	04/06/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Excerpts of the St. Lukes-Roosevelt Hospital record	005	Jeffrey A. Lichtman
120	04/06/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Plaintiff's Bills of Particulars and Notice of D&I	005	Jeffrey A. Lichtman
121	04/06/2017	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION		006	Jeffrey A. Lichtman
122	04/06/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Physician's Affirmation	006	Jeffrey A. Lichtman
123	04/06/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Letter from Jeanine B. Albu, M.D.	006	Jeffrey A. Lichtman
124	04/06/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Portion of Madelaine Hebranko's EBT Transcript	006	Jeffrey A. Lichtman
125	04/06/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Portion of Polina Khanina's EBT Transcript	006	Jeffrey A. Lichtman
126	04/06/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Portion of Magdi Bebawi's EBT Transcript	006	Jeffrey A. Lichtman
127	04/06/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	4/12/12 progress note	006	Jeffrey A. Lichtman
128	04/06/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Letter from the Commissioner of Health	006	Jeffrey A. Lichtman
129	04/06/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Excerpts of the St. Lukes-Roosevelt Hospital record	006	Jeffrey A. Lichtman
130	04/06/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Plaintiff's Bills of Particulars	006	Jeffrey A. Lichtman
131	04/06/2017	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION		007	Jeffrey A. Lichtman
132	04/06/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Physician's Affirmation	007	Jeffrey A. Lichtman
133	04/06/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Letter from Jeanine B. Albu, M.D.	007	Jeffrey A. Lichtman
134	04/06/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Portion of Madelaine Hebranko's EBT Transcript	007	Jeffrey A. Lichtman
135	04/06/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Portion of Polina Khanina's EBT Transcript	007	Jeffrey A. Lichtman
136	04/06/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Portion of Magdi Bebawi's EBT Transcript	007	Jeffrey A. Lichtman
137	04/06/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	4/12/12 progress note	007	Jeffrey A. Lichtman
138	04/06/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Letter from the Commissioner of Health	007	Jeffrey A. Lichtman
139	04/06/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Excerpts of the St. Lukes-Roosevelt Hospital record	007	Jeffrey A. Lichtman
140	04/06/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Plaintiff's Bills of Particulars	007	Jeffrey A. Lichtman
141	04/25/2017	AFFIRMATION	Reply Affirmation	007	Mario Christopher Giannettino
142	04/25/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Response to Notice for Discovery & Inspection	007	Mario Christopher Giannettino
143	04/25/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Further Response to Notice for Discovery & Inspection	007	Mario Christopher Giannettino
144	04/25/2017	STIPULATION - SO ORDERED			Lee Goldberg
145	04/26/2017	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN REPLY		005	Rupa Banik
146	09/01/2017	STIPULATION - SO ORDERED			Jerome D White
147	09/07/2017	ORDER - MOTION- SHORT FORM		005	Louisa Ammirati
148	09/08/2017	NOTICE OF ENTRY	Notice of Entry		Jacqueline Mandell
149	09/11/2017	NOTICE OF APPEAL/RADI/COPY OF ORDER/PROOF OF SERVICE	Notice of Appeal		Jacqueline Mandell	pdf
150	09/14/2017	NOTICE OF ENTRY	Order with Notic of Entry		Rupa Banik
151	09/14/2017	NOTICE OF APPEAL/RADI/COPY OF ORDER/PROOF OF SERVICE	Notice of Appeal, Request for Appellate Div. Intervention, and Order with Notice of Entry and e-filing confirmation		Rupa Banik	pdf
152	09/18/2017	NOTICE OF ENTRY		006	Vincent Dennis Finnegan
153	09/25/2017	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service		Ruth Corcoran
154	09/25/2017	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service		Ruth Corcoran
155	02/02/2018	NOTICE OF BANKRUPTCY (POST RJI)	Order Commencing Liquidation Proceedings & Granting an Injunction & Automatic Stay of Proceedings		Larry David Bloomstein
156	10/28/2019	LETTER/CORRESPONDENCE - SO ORDERED			Edwin Ruiz
157	10/30/2019	STIPULATION - SO ORDERED			Louisa Ammirati
158	12/09/2019	ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE ( PROPOSED )		008	Larry David Bloomstein	pdf
159	12/09/2019	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF PROPOSED OSC/EXPARTE APP		008	Larry David Bloomstein
160	12/09/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	SUMMONS AND COMPLAINT	008	Larry David Bloomstein
161	12/09/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	ANSWER DEFENDANT BEBAWI	008	Larry David Bloomstein
162	12/09/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	LIQUIDATION ORDER	008	Larry David Bloomstein
163	12/09/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	HALA DECISION	008	Larry David Bloomstein
164	12/09/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	LETTER FROM OCEANUS INSURANCE CO.	008	Larry David Bloomstein
165	12/09/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	LETTER TO DEFENDANT BEBAWI	008	Larry David Bloomstein
166	12/18/2019	ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE		008	Jerome D White	pdf
167	12/18/2019	ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE - CONFORMED COPY		008	Larry David Bloomstein	pdf
168	12/18/2019	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE CONFORMED ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE	008	Larry David Bloomstein
169	12/23/2019	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE		008	Jeffrey A. Lichtman	pdf
170	01/10/2020	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service		Julie A Mickiewicz
171	03/10/2020	DECISION + ORDER ON MOTION		008	Edwin Ruiz	pdf
172	06/11/2020	NOTICE OF APPEARANCE (POST RJI)			Michael Aron Ellenberg
173	06/21/2021	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE			Ingrid Hoffmann Heide
174	07/19/2021	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service to Order Filed on March 10, 2020		Noelle Marie Harvey
175	07/19/2021	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE	Letter to Michael Ellenberg, Esq. confirming he will act as counsel for Dr. Bebawi		Rupa Banik
176	07/29/2021	CONSENT TO CHANGE ATTORNEY (POST RJI)			Michael Aron Ellenberg
177	07/29/2021	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE			Michael Aron Ellenberg
178	03/06/2024	JUDGMENT -TO COURT (PROPOSED)			Jeffrey A. Lichtman	pdf
179	03/06/2024	AFFIRMATION			Jeffrey A. Lichtman
180	03/06/2024	BILL OF COSTS			Jeffrey A. Lichtman
181	03/06/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	summons and complaint		Jeffrey A. Lichtman
182	03/06/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	settlement documents		Jeffrey A. Lichtman
184	03/26/2024	JUDGMENT -TO COUNTY CLERK (PROPOSED)	Hebranko Judgment and Subpoena Affirmation		Jeffrey A. Lichtman	pdf
185	03/26/2024	AFFIRMATION			Jeffrey A. Lichtman
186	03/26/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	SUMMONS AND COMPLAINT		Jeffrey A. Lichtman
187	03/26/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	SETTLEMENT DOCUMENTS		Jeffrey A. Lichtman
188	03/26/2024	BILL OF COSTS			Jeffrey A. Lichtman
189	04/17/2024	JUDGMENT	COSTS OF PLAINTIFF		Hellen Williams	pdf
190	06/21/2024	ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE ( PROPOSED )	OSC to Withdraw as Counsel	009	Julie A Mickiewicz	pdf
191	06/21/2024	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION	Affirmation in Support of OSC to Withdraw as Counsel	009	Julie A Mickiewicz
192	06/21/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Summons and Complaint	009	Julie A Mickiewicz
193	06/21/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Answer	009	Julie A Mickiewicz
194	06/21/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Judgment	009	Julie A Mickiewicz
195	06/24/2024	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE		009	Ingrid Hoffmann Heide
196	06/28/2024	ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE	SIGNED	009	Ada I Cruz	pdf
197	07/02/2024	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	AOS	009	Julie A Mickiewicz
198	07/03/2024	ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE ( PROPOSED )		010	Jeffrey A. Lichtman	pdf
199	07/03/2024	AFFIRMATION		010	Jeffrey A. Lichtman
200	07/03/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Judgment	010	Jeffrey A. Lichtman
201	07/03/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Subpoena	010	Jeffrey A. Lichtman
202	07/03/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	transcript	010	Jeffrey A. Lichtman
203	07/08/2024	ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE		010	Christine Cheng	pdf
204	07/10/2024	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE		010	Jeffrey A. Lichtman
205	07/12/2024	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION	Affirmation in Opposition to Contempt Motion	010	Julie A Mickiewicz
206	07/12/2024	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service	010	Julie A Mickiewicz
207	07/22/2024	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE		009	Jeffrey A. Lichtman	pdf
208	07/22/2024	ORDER - MOTION - LONG FORM		010	Tulun Ahmed
209	07/22/2024	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE		009	Jeffrey A. Lichtman
210	07/30/2024	STIPULATION - WITHDRAWING MOTION/ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE	Stip wd motions	009	Julie A Mickiewicz	pdf
211	08/05/2024	SATISFACTION OF JUDGMENT	signed Satisfaction of Judgment		Julie A Mickiewicz	pdf
212	08/09/2024	ORDER - MOTION- SHORT FORM		010	Tulun Ahmed

Kings Supreme Court

2014

509390/2014

Disposed

Medical Malpractice

FARMER, KEVIN

William Schwitzer & Associates, P.C.

BROOKHAVEN REHABILITATION

Gallardo, Levin, Reiter & Rogers, LLP

03/10/2015

Jacobson, Hon. Laura Lee

▼

Case Info

Court

Kings Supreme Court

Index Number

509390/2014

Status

Disposed

Year Filed

2014

Case Name

FARMER, KEVIN vs. BROOKHAVEN REHABILITATION

Case Type

Tort-Medical, Dental, or Podiatric Malpractice

Track

Complex

RJI Filed

12/03/2014

NOI Due

03/05/2016

NOI Filed

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

Jacobson, Hon. Laura Lee

Next Appearance

03/10/2015

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

FARMER, KEVIN

Attorney / FirmWilliam Schwitzer & Associates, P.C.

Defendant / Respondent

BROOKHAVEN REHABILITATION

Attorneys / FirmsGallardo, Levin, Reiter & Rogers, LLP

Motions (2)

#	Date Filed	Filed By	Relief Sought	Submit Date	Answer	Status	Decision	Order Signed
2	02/13/2015		Dismiss	03/10/2015	Yes	Decided: 03/10/2015 Closed Before Justice: Jacobson, Hon. Laura Lee	Short Form Order	03/10/2015
1	01/02/2015		Dismiss	02/10/2015	Yes	Decided: 02/10/2015 Granted Before Justice: Jacobson, Hon. Laura Lee	Oral	02/10/2015

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints (40)

Doc #	Date Filed	Document	Description	Motion #	Filing User	File
1	10/13/2014	SUMMONS + COMPLAINT			Steven Hoffman	pdf
2	10/28/2014	STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING			Arkady Frekhtman
3	10/28/2014	PROOF OF SERVICE			Arkady Frekhtman
4	10/28/2014	PROOF OF SERVICE			Arkady Frekhtman
5	11/13/2014	ANSWER	Verified Answer		Christopher T Rogers	pdf
6	11/13/2014	DEMAND FOR BILL OF PARTICULARS	Demand for a Verified Bill of Particulars		Christopher T Rogers
7	11/13/2014	DEMAND FOR:	Demand for Expert Witness Information		Christopher T Rogers
8	11/13/2014	DEMAND FOR:	Demand for Disclosure as to Medicare/Medicaid & Private Liens		Christopher T Rogers
9	11/13/2014	NOTICE OF DISCOVERY AND INSPECTION	Notice of Discovery & Inspection of Electronically Stored Information and Litigation Hold		Christopher T Rogers
10	11/13/2014	NOTICE OF DISCOVERY AND INSPECTION	Notice for Discovery and Inspection		Christopher T Rogers
11	11/13/2014	DEMAND FOR:	Supplemental Demand		Christopher T Rogers
12	11/13/2014	NOTICE TO TAKE DEPOSITION	Notice to Take Deposition Upon Oral Examination		Christopher T Rogers
13	12/03/2014	STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING			Arkady Frekhtman
14	12/03/2014	PROOF OF SERVICE			Arkady Frekhtman
15	12/03/2014	NOTICE OF MOTION	Notice of Motion to Dismiss	1	Caitlin A Robin	pdf
16	12/03/2014	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT	Affirmation in Support	1	Caitlin A Robin
17	12/03/2014	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibt A Summons and Complaint	1	Caitlin A Robin
18	12/03/2014	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service	1	Caitlin A Robin
19	12/03/2014	RJI -RE: NOTICE OF MOTION	Request for Judicial Interventio	1	Caitlin A Robin	pdf
20	12/03/2014	STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING		1	Caitlin A Robin
21	12/16/2014	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT	Affirmation in Support	1	Jessica Lynn Smith
22	12/16/2014	EXHIBIT(S)	A-Summons and Complaint	1	Jessica Lynn Smith
23	02/10/2015	NOTICE OF MOTION	Notice of Motion	2	Caitlin A Robin	pdf
24	02/10/2015	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT	Affirmation in Support	2	Caitlin A Robin
25	02/10/2015	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit A	2	Caitlin A Robin
26	02/10/2015	AFFIDAVIT	Affidavit of Service	2	Caitlin A Robin
27	02/10/2015	STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING	Authorization	2	Caitlin A Robin
28	02/11/2015	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT		1	Jessica Lynn Smith
29	02/11/2015	EXHIBIT(S)	Summons & Complaint	1	Jessica Lynn Smith
30	02/24/2015	ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE ( PROPOSED )			Arkady Frekhtman	pdf
31	04/02/2015	DECISION + ORDER ON MOTION	dated 3/10/15 filed CC 3/17/15	2	Maureen Lawton	pdf
32	04/02/2015	NOTICE OF ENTRY	Order with Notice of Entry		Christopher T Rogers
33	04/09/2015	NOTICE OF ENTRY	Notice of Entry		Caitlin A Robin
34	04/09/2015	AFFIDAVIT	Affidavit of Service		Caitlin A Robin
35	05/13/2015	CONSENT TO CHANGE ATTORNEY (POST RJI)	Consent to Change Attorney		Caitlin A Robin
36	02/15/2017	CONSENT TO CHANGE ATTORNEY (POST RJI)	Consent to Change Attorney		Mario Christopher Giannettino
37	05/10/2017	JUDGMENT -TO COUNTY CLERK (PROPOSED)	Notice of Settlement		Jacqueline Mandell
38	05/11/2017	JUDGMENT -TO COUNTY CLERK (PROPOSED)	Notice of Settlement		Rebecca Anne Barrett	pdf
39	05/31/2017	JUDGMENT			Charles Yodice	pdf
40	05/31/2017	NOTICE OF ENTRY	Judgment with Notice of Entry		Rebecca Anne Barrett

Westchester Supreme Court

2014

64532/2014

Disposed

Comm-Contract

MERIT ADJUSTORS, INC.

WILKOFSKY, FRIEDMAN, KAREL, ETC.

BROOKHAVEN REHABILITATION &

SALAMON & GRUBER

01/28/2015

▼

Case Info

Court

Westchester Supreme Court

Index Number

64532/2014

Status

Disposed

Year Filed

2014

Case Name

MERIT ADJUSTORS, INC. vs. BROOKHAVEN REHABILITATION &

Case Type

Comm-Contract

Track

Standard

RJI Filed

10/31/2014

NOI Due

10/31/2015

NOI Filed

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

Next Appearance

01/28/2015

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

MERIT ADJUSTORS, INC.

Attorney / FirmWILKOFSKY, FRIEDMAN, KAREL, ETC.

Defendant / Respondent

BROOKHAVEN REHABILITATION &

Attorneys / FirmsSALAMON & GRUBER

Motions

No motions recorded for this case.

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints (9)

Doc #	Date Filed	Document	Description	Filing User	File
1	09/15/2014	SUMMONS		Harry A Cummins	pdf
2	09/15/2014	COMPLAINT		Harry A Cummins	pdf
3	09/15/2014	SUMMONS - SUPPLEMENTAL (PRE RJI)		Harry A Cummins	pdf
4	09/29/2014	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE		Harry A Cummins
5	10/16/2014	ANSWER	Answer	Sanford Strenger	pdf
6	10/16/2014	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service	Sanford Strenger
7	10/31/2014	RJI -RE: REQUEST FOR PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE		Harry A Cummins
8	10/31/2014	PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE REQUEST		Harry A Cummins
9	01/28/2015	STIPULATION - DISCONTINUANCE (POST RJI)	Stipulation of Discontinuance	Sanford Strenger	pdf

Westchester Supreme Court

2013

58104/2011

Disposed

SP-Other

BROOKHAVEN REHABILITATION

Abrams Fensterman, LLP

ROBERTSON, EMERSON

01/14/2014

▼

Case Info

Court

Westchester Supreme Court

Index Number

58104/2011

Status

Disposed

Year Filed

2013

Case Name

BROOKHAVEN REHABILITATION vs. ROBERTSON, EMERSON

Case Type

SP-Other

Track

Standard

RJI Filed

02/26/2013

NOI Due

02/26/2014

NOI Filed

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

Next Appearance

01/14/2014

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

BROOKHAVEN REHABILITATION

Attorney / FirmAbrams Fensterman, LLP

Defendant / Respondent

ROBERTSON, EMERSON

Attorneys / Firms

Motions

No motions recorded for this case.

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints (15)

Doc #	Date Filed	Document	Description	Filing User	File
1	11/03/2011	SUMMONS + COMPLAINT		Angela C Bellizzi	pdf
2	11/03/2011	STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING		Angela C Bellizzi
3	12/01/2011	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE		Angela C Bellizzi
4	12/01/2011	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE		Angela C Bellizzi
5	12/01/2011	STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING		Angela C Bellizzi
6	01/06/2012	ANSWER	Answer	Alvin James Thomas	pdf
7	02/26/2013	RJI -RE: REQUEST FOR PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE	RJI	Angela C Bellizzi
8	02/26/2013	PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE REQUEST	Request For PC	Angela C Bellizzi
9	02/26/2013	STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING	Statement Of Authorization	Angela C Bellizzi
10	04/26/2013	ORDER - PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE		Dora N Hancock
11	12/03/2013	STIPULATION - SETTLEMENT (POST RJI)	Stipulation Of Settlement	Angela C Bellizzi
12	12/03/2013	AFFIDAVIT	Affidavit Of Confession Of Judgment	Angela C Bellizzi
13	12/03/2013	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Affidavit Of Service	Angela C Bellizzi
14	12/03/2013	JUDGMENT -TO COUNTY CLERK (PROPOSED)	Judgment With Supporting Papers	Angela C Bellizzi	pdf
15	02/10/2014	JUDGMENT	JUDGMENT entered in the office of the County Clerk on February 10, 2014	Debra Beth Rothstein	pdf

Kings Supreme Court

2012

501420/2012

Disposed

Comm-Other

JANKLOWICZ,JACK

Weiss Zarett Brofman Sonnenklar & Levy, P.C.

LANDA,BENJAMIN

Forest Hills Health Care Center LLC

02/28/2020

Knipel, Hon. Lawrence S.

▼

Case Info

Court

Kings Supreme Court

Index Number

501420/2012

Status

Disposed

Year Filed

2012

Case Name

JANKLOWICZ,JACK vs. LANDA,BENJAMIN

Case Type

Comm-Other

Track

Standard

RJI Filed

07/03/2012

NOI Due

07/03/2013

NOI Filed

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

Knipel, Hon. Lawrence S.

Next Appearance

02/28/2020

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

JANKLOWICZ,JACK

Attorney / FirmWeiss Zarett Brofman Sonnenklar & Levy, P.C.

Defendant / Respondent

LANDA,BENJAMIN

Attorneys / FirmsForest Hills Health Care Center LLC

Motions (7)

#	Date Filed	Relief Sought	Submit Date	Answer	Status	Decision	Order Signed
7	08/27/2018	Restore	09/21/2018	Yes	Decided: 09/21/2018 Granted Before Justice: Knipel, Hon. Lawrence S.	Short Form Order	09/21/2018
6	06/07/2018	Vacate/Strike - Note of Issue/Jury Demand/From Trial Calendar	09/21/2018	Yes	Decided: 09/21/2018 Granted Before Justice: Knipel, Hon. Lawrence S.	Short Form Order	09/21/2018
5	04/08/2015	Retention/Release	09/23/2016	No	Decided: 09/23/2016 Withdrawn Before Justice: Knipel, Hon. Lawrence S.	Oral	09/23/2016
4	12/03/2014	Dismiss	09/23/2016	No	Decided: 09/23/2016 Granted Before Justice: Knipel, Hon. Lawrence S.	Short Form Order	09/23/2016
3	12/01/2014	Dismiss	09/23/2016	No	Decided: 09/23/2016 Granted Before Justice: Knipel, Hon. Lawrence S.	Short Form Order	09/23/2016
2	08/24/2012	Dismiss	04/08/2013	Yes	Decided: 10/09/2013 Granted Before Justice: Schmidt, Hon. David	Memorandum	10/09/2013
1	08/02/2012	Dismiss	04/08/2013	Yes	Decided: 10/09/2013 Granted Before Justice: Schmidt, Hon. David	Memorandum	10/09/2013

Decisions (1)

Court	Index Number	Case Name	Motion #	Scanned On
Kings Supreme Court	501420/2012	JANKLOWICZ,JACK vs. LANDA,BENJAMIN	100	04/09/2015

Complaints (183)

Doc #	Date Filed	Document	Description	Motion #	Filing User	File
1	06/06/2012	SUMMONS + COMPLAINT			Matthew Dollinger	pdf
2	06/18/2012	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE			Floyd G Grossman
3	06/18/2012	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE			Floyd G Grossman
4	06/18/2012	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE			Floyd G Grossman
5	07/02/2012	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service on 1040 Central Avenue Realty, LLC		Floyd G Grossman
6	07/02/2012	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service on Brookhaven Rehabilitation and Health Care Center, LLC		Floyd G Grossman
7	07/02/2012	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service on Eastchester Rehabilitation and Health Care Center, LLC		Floyd G Grossman
8	07/02/2012	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service on Eastrock Realty Associates, LLC		Floyd G Grossman
9	07/02/2012	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service on Forest Hills Care Center LLC		Floyd G Grossman
10	07/02/2012	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service on Forest Hills Estate Associates, LLC		Floyd G Grossman
11	07/02/2012	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service on Golden Gate Nursing Home Management, LLC		Floyd G Grossman
12	07/02/2012	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service on Golden Gate Nursing Realty, LLC		Floyd G Grossman
13	07/02/2012	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service on Golden Gate Rehabilitation and Health Care Center, LLC		Floyd G Grossman
14	07/02/2012	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service on Willoughby Rehabiliation and Health Care Center, LLC		Floyd G Grossman
15	07/02/2012	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service on Woodmere Rehabilitation and Health Care Center, Inc.		Floyd G Grossman
16	07/03/2012	NOTICE OF MOTION	Notice of Motion to Dismiss Complaint	001	Sarah C Lichtenstein	pdf
17	07/03/2012	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION		001	Sarah C Lichtenstein
18	07/03/2012	EXHIBIT(S)	Summons and Complaint	001	Sarah C Lichtenstein
19	07/03/2012	MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN SUPPORT		001	Sarah C Lichtenstein
20	07/03/2012	RJI -RE: NOTICE OF MOTION		001	Sarah C Lichtenstein	pdf
21	07/05/2012	AFFIRMATION	re: Service of Motion on Non-Appearing Defendants	001	Sarah C Lichtenstein
22	08/16/2012	NOTICE OF MOTION	Amended Notice of Motion to Dismiss	002	Seth Eisenberger	pdf
23	08/16/2012	MEMORANDUM OF LAW	Memorandum of Law in Support of Motion to Dismiss	002	Seth Eisenberger
24	08/16/2012	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION	Philipson Affirmation in Support of Motion	002	Seth Eisenberger
25	08/16/2012	EXHIBIT(S)	Ex A - Complaint	002	Seth Eisenberger
26	08/16/2012	EXHIBIT(S)	Ex B - Split Rock K1	002	Seth Eisenberger
27	08/16/2012	EXHIBIT(S)	Ex C - Eastchester K1	002	Seth Eisenberger
28	08/16/2012	EXHIBIT(S)	Ex D - DOH Split Rock	002	Seth Eisenberger
29	08/16/2012	EXHIBIT(S)	DH Approval Letter	002	Seth Eisenberger
30	08/16/2012	EXHIBIT(S)	DOH Eastchester	002	Seth Eisenberger
31	08/16/2012	EXHIBIT(S)	Eastchester Operating Agreement	002	Seth Eisenberger
32	08/16/2012	EXHIBIT(S)	Ex H - Brookhaven Op Agr	002	Seth Eisenberger
42	08/22/2012	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION	Affirmation In Opposition To the Motion to Dismiss by Benjamin Landa, Et Al, ("The Benjamin Motion")	001	Matthew Dollinger
43	08/22/2012	AFFIRMATION	Affirmation Submitted Under CPLR 3211(d) ("Facts Unavailable to Opposing Party")	001	Matthew Dollinger
44	08/22/2012	EXHIBIT(S)	Sentosa Care, LLC letter dated August 29, 2008	001	Matthew Dollinger
45	08/22/2012	EXHIBIT(S)	Sentosa Care, LLC letter dated July 16, 2008	001	Matthew Dollinger
46	08/22/2012	EXHIBIT(S)	Eastchester Rehabilitation and Health Care Center, LLC Members' Certificate	001	Matthew Dollinger
47	08/22/2012	EXHIBIT(S)	Eastchester Rehabilitation and Health Care Center, LLC Amendment To Loan Agreement	001	Matthew Dollinger
48	08/22/2012	EXHIBIT(S)	Redacted Operating Agreement of Eastchester Rehabilitation and Health Care Center, LLC	001	Matthew Dollinger
49	08/22/2012	EXHIBIT(S)	Official Checks and letter dated January 15, 2003 from Benjamin Landa to Jack Janklowitz	001	Matthew Dollinger
50	08/22/2012	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE		001	Matthew Dollinger
51	08/23/2012	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service	002	Seth Eisenberger
52	09/11/2012	MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN REPLY	in further Support of Motion to Dismiss Complaint	001	Sarah C Lichtenstein
53	09/11/2012	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE		001	Sarah C Lichtenstein
54	09/13/2012	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION	Affirmation in Opposition to the Motion to Dismiss by Bent Philipson, Et Al	002	Matthew Dollinger
55	09/13/2012	AFFIRMATION	Affirmation Submitted Under CPLR 3211(d) (Facts Unavailable to Opposing Party)	002	Matthew Dollinger
56	09/13/2012	EXHIBIT(S)	Letter from SentosaCare to Jack Janklowitz dated August 29, 2008	002	Matthew Dollinger
57	09/13/2012	EXHIBIT(S)	Letter from SentosaCare to Jack Janklowitz dated July 16, 2008	002	Matthew Dollinger
58	09/13/2012	EXHIBIT(S)	Eastchester Rehabilitation and Health Care Center, LLC Members' Certificate	002	Matthew Dollinger
59	09/13/2012	EXHIBIT(S)	Eastchester Rehabilitation and Health Care Center, LLC and Bank of America, N.A., Fifth Amendment to Loan Agreement	002	Matthew Dollinger
60	09/13/2012	EXHIBIT(S)	Operating Agreement of Eastchester Rehabilitation and Health Care Center (redacted)	002	Matthew Dollinger
61	09/13/2012	EXHIBIT(S)	Official Checks	002	Matthew Dollinger
62	09/13/2012	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Affirmation of Service regarding the Bent Motion	002	Matthew Dollinger
63	10/24/2012	EXHIBIT(S)	Corrected Exhibit 5 to filed documents 42 and 54		Floyd G Grossman
64	10/24/2012	MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN REPLY	Reply Memorandum in Further Support to Dismiss	002	Seth Eisenberger
65	05/21/2014	NOTICE OF APPEARANCE (POST RJI)			Franklyn H Snitow
66	06/12/2014	DECISION + ORDER ON MOTION	Dated 10/9/13. Filed CC 6/12/14	001	Craig Schatzman	pdf
67	06/12/2014	NOTICE OF ENTRY		001	Sarah C Lichtenstein
68	06/12/2014	EXHIBIT(S)	Entered Order	001	Sarah C Lichtenstein
69	07/03/2014	COMPLAINT (AMENDED)	Amended Complaint		Franklyn H Snitow	pdf
70	08/15/2014	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE			Seth Eisenberger
71	08/15/2014	STIPULATION - OTHER			Seth Eisenberger
72	09/09/2014	STIPULATION - SO ORDERED			Brad Coven
73	09/17/2014	NOTICE OF MOTION	to Dismiss Amended Complaint	3	Sarah C Lichtenstein	pdf
74	09/17/2014	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION	of Benjamin Landa	3	Sarah C Lichtenstein
75	09/17/2014	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION	of Sarah C. Lichtenstein	3	Sarah C Lichtenstein
76	09/17/2014	EXHIBIT(S)	Complaint	3	Sarah C Lichtenstein
77	09/17/2014	EXHIBIT(S)	Decision and Order	3	Sarah C Lichtenstein
78	09/17/2014	EXHIBIT(S)	Amended Complaint	3	Sarah C Lichtenstein
79	09/17/2014	EXHIBIT(S)	Brookhaven Operating Agreement	3	Sarah C Lichtenstein
80	09/17/2014	EXHIBIT(S)	Golden Gate Operating Agreement	3	Sarah C Lichtenstein
81	09/17/2014	EXHIBIT(S)	Eastchester Operating Agreement	3	Sarah C Lichtenstein
82	09/17/2014	EXHIBIT(S)	Plaintiffs' Exs. 6 and 5	3	Sarah C Lichtenstein
83	09/17/2014	EXHIBIT(S)	West Lawrence Operating Agreement	3	Sarah C Lichtenstein
84	09/17/2014	EXHIBIT(S)	Wausau Amended Complaint	3	Sarah C Lichtenstein
85	09/17/2014	MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN SUPPORT	of Motion to Dismiss Amended Complaint	3	Sarah C Lichtenstein
86	09/17/2014	NOTICE OF MOTION	Notice of Motion to Dismiss Amended Complaint	4	Seth Eisenberger	pdf
87	09/17/2014	AFFIRMATION	Affirmation of Seth Eisenberger	4	Seth Eisenberger
88	09/17/2014	EXHIBIT(S)	Amended Complaint	4	Seth Eisenberger
89	09/17/2014	EXHIBIT(S)	Brookhaven Operating Agreement	4	Seth Eisenberger
90	09/17/2014	EXHIBIT(S)	Golden Gate Operating Agreement	4	Seth Eisenberger
91	09/17/2014	EXHIBIT(S)	Eastchester Operating Agreement	4	Seth Eisenberger
92	09/17/2014	EXHIBIT(S)	West Lawrence Operating Agreement	4	Seth Eisenberger
93	09/17/2014	MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN SUPPORT		4	Seth Eisenberger
94	09/17/2014	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE		4	Seth Eisenberger
95	09/19/2014	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION	of Benjamin Landa (supplemental)	3	Sarah C Lichtenstein
96	09/19/2014	EXHIBIT(S)	Meadow Park Operating Agreement	3	Sarah C Lichtenstein
97	10/31/2014	STIPULATION - OTHER	Stipulation of Adjournment on Consent		Franklyn H Snitow
98	11/21/2014	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION	Franklyn H. Snitow Affirmation in Opposition to Defendant's Motion to Dismiss the Amended Complaint	3	Franklyn H Snitow
99	11/21/2014	EXHIBIT(S)	Order - Janklowicz v. Landa	3	Franklyn H Snitow
100	11/21/2014	EXHIBIT(S)	Deft's MOL in Support of Motion to Dismiss	3	Franklyn H Snitow
101	11/21/2014	EXHIBIT(S)	MOL in Support of Motion to Dismiss	3	Franklyn H Snitow
102	11/21/2014	EXHIBIT(S)	Short Form Order	3	Franklyn H Snitow
103	11/21/2014	EXHIBIT(S)	Operating Agreement - Brookhaven	3	Franklyn H Snitow
104	11/21/2014	EXHIBIT(S)	Operating Agreement - Eastchester	3	Franklyn H Snitow
105	11/21/2014	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION	Affirmation of Janklowicz	3	Franklyn H Snitow
106	11/21/2014	MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN OPPOSITION		3	Franklyn H Snitow
107	11/21/2014	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION	Franklyn H. Snitow Affirmation in Opposition to Defendant's Motion to Dismiss the Amended Complaint	4	Franklyn H Snitow
108	11/21/2014	EXHIBIT(S)	Order - Janklowicz v. Landa	4	Franklyn H Snitow
109	11/21/2014	EXHIBIT(S)	Deft's MOL in Support of Motion to Dismiss	4	Franklyn H Snitow
110	11/21/2014	EXHIBIT(S)	MOL in Support of Motion to Dismiss	4	Franklyn H Snitow
111	11/21/2014	EXHIBIT(S)	Short Form Order	4	Franklyn H Snitow
112	11/21/2014	EXHIBIT(S)	Operating Agreement - Brookhaven	4	Franklyn H Snitow
113	11/21/2014	EXHIBIT(S)	Operating Agreement - Eastchester	4	Franklyn H Snitow
114	11/21/2014	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION	Affirmation of Janklowicz	4	Franklyn H Snitow
115	11/21/2014	MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN OPPOSITION	MOL in Opposition to Motion to Dismiss	4	Franklyn H Snitow
116	01/09/2015	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN REPLY	Reply Affirmation of Seth Eisenberger In Further Support of the Bent Defendants' Motion to Dismiss	4	Seth Eisenberger
117	01/09/2015	MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN REPLY	Memorandum of Law In Further Support of Motion to Dismiss	4	Seth Eisenberger
118	01/09/2015	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Affirmation of Service for Reply	4	Seth Eisenberger
119	01/09/2015	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN REPLY	in further Support of Motion to Dismiss Amended Complaint of Sarah C. Lichtenstein	3	Sarah C Lichtenstein
120	01/09/2015	EXHIBIT(S)	Notice of Motion to Dismiss Complaint	3	Sarah C Lichtenstein
121	01/09/2015	MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN REPLY	in further Support of Motion to Dismiss Amended Complaint	3	Sarah C Lichtenstein
122	04/07/2015	ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE ( PROPOSED )			Floyd G Grossman	pdf
123	04/07/2015	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT	Affirmation in Support of the Plaintiffs' Order to Show Cause for a Stay		Floyd G Grossman
124	04/07/2015	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT	Affirmation in Support of the Plaintiffs' Order to SHow Cause for a Stay - Janklowicz		Floyd G Grossman
125	04/07/2015	EXHIBIT(S)	Amended Complaint		Floyd G Grossman
126	04/07/2015	EXHIBIT(S)	Decision & Order		Floyd G Grossman
127	04/07/2015	EXHIBIT(S)	Notice		Floyd G Grossman
128	04/07/2015	EXHIBIT(S)	Operating Agreement		Floyd G Grossman
129	04/07/2015	EXHIBIT(S)	Executor's Deed		Floyd G Grossman
130	04/07/2015	EXHIBIT(S)	Order to Show Cause letter		Floyd G Grossman
131	04/07/2015	AFFIRMATION	Emergency Affirmation		Floyd G Grossman
132	04/17/2015	ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE - CONFORMED COPY	Refer to Document # 122		Floyd G Grossman	pdf
133	04/20/2015	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION	for Preliminary Injunction of Bent Philipson		Sarah C Lichtenstein
134	04/20/2015	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION	for Preliminary Injunction of Sarah C. Lichtenstein		Sarah C Lichtenstein
135	04/20/2015	EXHIBIT(S)	Order to Show Cause		Sarah C Lichtenstein
136	04/20/2015	EXHIBIT(S)	Notice to Redeem Member Interests		Sarah C Lichtenstein
137	04/20/2015	EXHIBIT(S)	Notice of Default in Posting Bond		Sarah C Lichtenstein
138	04/20/2015	EXHIBIT(S)	Notice of Frivolous Conduct and Intent to Seek Sanctions		Sarah C Lichtenstein
139	04/20/2015	MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN OPPOSITION	to Motion for Preliminary Injunction		Sarah C Lichtenstein
140	04/22/2015	ORDER - ADMINISTRATIVE	dated 4/16/15		Loriann Urkonis
141	05/12/2015	STIPULATION - ADJOURNMENT OF CONFERENCE	to coincide with return date on motions		Sarah C Lichtenstein
142	02/25/2016	STIPULATION - OTHER	Stipulation to Adjourn Motion Sequence #3, #4 & #5		Floyd G Grossman
143	03/30/2016	STIPULATION - ADJOURNMENT OF MOTION	Stip of adjournment for Motion Seq. #3, #4 and #5	3	Alex Benjamin Leibson
144	03/30/2016	STIPULATION - ADJOURNMENT OF CONFERENCE			Alex Benjamin Leibson
145	05/19/2016	STIPULATION - ADJOURNMENT OF ORAL ARGUMENT		3	Alex Benjamin Leibson
146	05/19/2016	STIPULATION - ADJOURNMENT OF CONFERENCE			Alex Benjamin Leibson
147	06/22/2016	STIPULATION - ADJOURNMENT OF CONFERENCE			Alex Benjamin Leibson
148	06/22/2016	STIPULATION - ADJOURNMENT OF MOTION	Adjourning motion sequences 3, 4 and 5	3	Alex Benjamin Leibson
149	07/14/2016	STIPULATION - ADJOURNMENT OF CONFERENCE			Alex Benjamin Leibson
150	07/14/2016	STIPULATION - ADJOURNMENT OF ORAL ARGUMENT	Adjourning motion sequences 3, 4 and 5	3	Alex Benjamin Leibson
151	07/26/2016	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE			Michael J Spithogiannis
152	07/26/2016	EXHIBIT(S)	Notice of Withdrawal of Motion (Mot. Seq. #5)		Michael J Spithogiannis
153	08/01/2016	NOTICE OF CHANGE OF FIRM NAME OR ADDRESS (POST RJI)	Notice of Change of Firm Name & Address 8-1-2016		Elliot J Rosner
154	09/23/2016	DECISION + ORDER ON MOTION	This order also decides Motion sequence #4.	3	Averell Golub	pdf
155	10/04/2016	NOTICE OF ENTRY	Notice of Entry of 9/23/2016 decision & order	3	Matthew F Didora
156	10/14/2016	ANSWER	Answer		Keith J. Singer	pdf
157	11/03/2016	NOTICE OF APPEAL/RADI/COPY OF ORDER/PROOF OF SERVICE			Michael J Spithogiannis	pdf
158	11/03/2016	ANSWER (AMENDED)			Alex Benjamin Leibson	pdf
159	11/21/2016	REPLY TO COUNTERCLAIM(S)	Plaintiffs' Reply to Counterclaims		Franklyn H Snitow
160	12/07/2016	STIPULATION - DISCOVERY			Michael J Spithogiannis
161	11/23/2016	ORDER - PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE	dated 11/18/16		Maureen Lawton
162	12/15/2016	STIPULATION - OTHER			Floyd G Grossman
163	12/23/2016	STIPULATION - OTHER	Stipulation Extending Time To Answer		Michael J Spithogiannis
164	01/26/2017	STIPULATION - TIME TO ANSWER			Michael J Spithogiannis	pdf
165	01/31/2017	ANSWER WITH COUNTER-CLAIM(S)			Seth Eisenberger	pdf
166	02/16/2017	REPLY TO COUNTERCLAIM(S)	Reply to Counterclaim of Defendant Eastchester Rehabilitation and Health Care Center, LLC		Elliot J Rosner
167	07/25/2017	ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE			Averell Golub
168	08/09/2017	CONSENT TO CHANGE ATTORNEY (POST RJI)			Floyd G Grossman
169	03/28/2018	STIPULATION - OTHER - ( REQUEST TO SO ORDER )			Elliot J Rosner
170	03/30/2018	STIPULATION - SO ORDERED	Case restored, parties to appear COM-4 on 4/27/18 , etc.		Averell Golub
171	04/26/2018	STIPULATION - ADJOURNMENT OF CONFERENCE			Michael J Spithogiannis
172	05/16/2018	NOTE OF ISSUE:WITHOUT JURY			Elliot J Rosner
173	05/31/2018	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE	Letter to Justice Knipel		Floyd G Grossman
174	06/06/2018	NOTICE OF MOTION		6	Alex Benjamin Leibson	pdf
175	06/06/2018	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION		6	Alex Benjamin Leibson
176	06/06/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Note of Issue	6	Alex Benjamin Leibson
177	06/06/2018	MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN SUPPORT		6	Alex Benjamin Leibson
178	08/10/2018	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION		6	Elliot J Rosner
179	08/10/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Note of Issue Served on 5-16-2018	6	Elliot J Rosner
180	08/10/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Confirmation Notice re Note of Issue	6	Elliot J Rosner
181	08/10/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	So-Ordered Stipulation re Note of Issue	6	Elliot J Rosner
182	08/20/2018	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN REPLY		6	Alex Benjamin Leibson
183	08/20/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Preliminary Conference Order	6	Alex Benjamin Leibson
184	08/24/2018	NOTICE OF MOTION		7	Alex Benjamin Leibson	pdf
185	08/24/2018	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION		7	Alex Benjamin Leibson
186	08/24/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Note of Issue	7	Alex Benjamin Leibson
187	08/24/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Motion to Vacate Note of Issue	7	Alex Benjamin Leibson
188	09/24/2018	DECISION + ORDER ON MOTION		7	Averell Golub	pdf
189	09/25/2018	DECISION + ORDER ON MOTION		6	Averell Golub	pdf
190	05/02/2019	STIPULATION - ADJOURNMENT OF CONFERENCE			Alex Benjamin Leibson
191	07/11/2019	STIPULATION - ADJOURNMENT OF CONFERENCE			Alex Benjamin Leibson
192	08/20/2020	STIPULATION - DISCONTINUANCE (POST RJI)			Alex Benjamin Leibson	pdf