Assisted Living Magazine — Lawsuit Report

Morningside Nursing and Rehabilitation Center

📍 1000 Pelham Parkway South, Bronx, New York, 10461

Owner: Morningside Acquisition 1, Llc (For Profit)

Lawsuit Summary

Total Cases
43
Active Cases
14
14 active
Stayed / Paused
2
2 Stayed
Closed
27
1 Disposed — Consolidated Into26 Disposed
Since
2015
Most Recent
2026
Next Court Date
May 04, 2026
This facility is currently involved in 14 active lawsuits.

Cases

43 cases · Click to expand details (43 from 2010 – present; older years: list only)
#CourtYearIndex NumberStatusCase TypePlaintiff / PetitionerPlaintiff FirmDefendant / RespondentDefendant FirmAppearanceJustice
1Bronx Supreme Court2026816297/2025EActiveMedical MalpracticeSANTOS, ANGELSINEL & OLESEN, PLLCMORNINGSIDE ACQUISITION I, LLC d/b/a MORNINGSIDE NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTER et alSHAUB, AHMUTY, CITRIN & SPRATT, LLP06/15/2026Frishman, Hon. Michael A.▼
Case Info
Court
Bronx Supreme Court
Index Number
816297/2025E
Status
Active
Year Filed
2026
Case Name
SANTOS, ANGEL vs. MORNINGSIDE ACQUISITION I, LLC d/b/a MORNINGSIDE NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTER et al
Case Type
Tort-Medical, Dental, or Podiatric Malpractice
Track
Complex
RJI Filed
03/09/2026
NOI Due
06/10/2027
NOI Filed
Calendar Number
—
Jury Status
Justice
Frishman, Hon. Michael A.
Next Appearance
06/15/2026
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
SANTOS, ANGEL
Attorney / FirmSINEL & OLESEN, PLLC
Defendant / Respondent
MORNINGSIDE ACQUISITION I, LLC d/b/a MORNINGSIDE NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTER et al
Attorneys / FirmsSHAUB, AHMUTY, CITRIN & SPRATT, LLP
Motions (1)
#Date FiledFiled ByRelief SoughtSubmit DateAnswerStatusDecisionOrder Signed
103/09/2026Extend - Time03/30/2026NoDecided: 04/07/2026 Granted Before Justice: Frishman, Hon. Michael A.Short Form Order04/07/2026
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (52)
Doc #Date FiledDocumentDescriptionMotion #Filing UserFile
108/01/2025SUMMONS + COMPLAINT+ Certificate of MeritElliot B Sinel
209/17/2025COMPLAINT (AMENDED)Amended Verified ComplaintElliot B Sinel
309/19/2025SUMMONS - SUPPLEMENTAL (PRE RJI)Supplemental SummonsElliot B Sinel
410/07/2025AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEAffidavit of Service for Montefiore Medical Center (Facility)Elliot B Sinel
510/07/2025AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEAffidavit of Service for Montefiore Medical Center (SOS)Elliot B Sinel
610/07/2025AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEAffidavit of Service for Morningside Nursing (Facility)Elliot B Sinel
710/07/2025AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEAffidavit of Service for Morningside Nursing (SOS)Elliot B Sinel
810/07/2025AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEAffidavit of Service for Rebekah Rehab (Facility)Elliot B Sinel
910/07/2025AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEAffidavit of Service for Rebekah Rehab (SOS)Elliot B Sinel
1010/07/2025AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEAffidavit of Service for VNS Choice (SOS)Elliot B Sinel
2Westchester Supreme Court202550668/2025ActiveMedical MalpracticeDAWSON, TANYA et alTHE GOUGH LAW FIRMMORNINGSIDE ACQUISITION 1 LLC et alBARKER PATTERSON NICHOLS, LLP06/04/2026Koba, Hon. Nancy Quinn▼
Case Info
Court
Westchester Supreme Court
Index Number
50668/2025
Status
Active
Year Filed
2025
Case Name
DAWSON, TANYA et al vs. MORNINGSIDE ACQUISITION 1 LLC et al
Case Type
Tort-Medical, Dental, or Podiatric Malpractice
Track
Complex
RJI Filed
08/27/2025
NOI Due
11/28/2026
NOI Filed
Calendar Number
—
Jury Status
Justice
Koba, Hon. Nancy Quinn
Next Appearance
06/04/2026
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
DAWSON, TANYA et al
Attorney / FirmTHE GOUGH LAW FIRM
Defendant / Respondent
MORNINGSIDE ACQUISITION 1 LLC et al
Attorneys / FirmsBARKER PATTERSON NICHOLS, LLP
Motions
No motions recorded for this case.
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (33)
Doc #Date FiledDocumentDescriptionMotion #Filing UserFile
111/14/2024SUMMONS + COMPLAINTDeborah Gough
212/23/2024ANSWERVerified Answer with initial demandsGerasimia Stathatos
312/23/2024STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILINGGerasimia Stathatos
412/30/2024AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEDeborah Gough
512/30/2024AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEDeborah Gough
601/06/2025NOTICE OF MOTION121Kayla Gloria-Marie Nieves
701/06/2025AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION121Kayla Gloria-Marie Nieves
801/06/2025EXHIBIT(S)Plaintiffs Summons and Complaint121Kayla Gloria-Marie Nieves
901/06/2025EXHIBIT(S)Defendants Verified Answer and Various Demands, including a Demand for Venue Change121Kayla Gloria-Marie Nieves
1001/06/2025EXHIBIT(S)Admission Agreement121Kayla Gloria-Marie Nieves
3Bronx Supreme Court2025800136/2025EDisposedMedical MalpracticeGAVIRIA, ALFREDO et alSINEL & OLESEN, PLLCMORNINGSIDE ACQUISITION 1, LLC d/b/a MORNINGSIDE NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTERShaub, Ahmuty, Citrin & Spratt, LLP06/03/2025Frishman, Hon. Michael A.▼
Case Info
Court
Bronx Supreme Court
Index Number
800136/2025E
Status
Disposed
Year Filed
2025
Case Name
GAVIRIA, ALFREDO et al vs. MORNINGSIDE ACQUISITION 1, LLC d/b/a MORNINGSIDE NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTER
Case Type
Tort-Medical, Dental, or Podiatric Malpractice
Track
Complex
RJI Filed
04/01/2025
NOI Due
07/03/2026
NOI Filed
Calendar Number
—
Jury Status
Justice
Frishman, Hon. Michael A.
Next Appearance
06/03/2025
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
GAVIRIA, ALFREDO et al
Attorney / FirmSINEL & OLESEN, PLLC
Defendant / Respondent
MORNINGSIDE ACQUISITION 1, LLC d/b/a MORNINGSIDE NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTER
Attorneys / FirmsShaub, Ahmuty, Citrin & Spratt, LLP
Motions (1)
#Date FiledFiled ByRelief SoughtSubmit DateAnswerStatusDecisionOrder Signed
104/01/2025Dismiss06/03/2025NoDecided: 10/07/2025 Granted Before Justice: Frishman, Hon. Michael A.Short Form Order10/07/2025
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (16)
Doc #Date FiledDocumentDescriptionMotion #Filing UserFile
101/03/2025SUMMONS + COMPLAINTand Certificate of MeritElliot B Sinel
203/26/2025AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEAffidavit of Service for Morningisde Acquisition LLC (Facility)Elliot B Sinel
303/26/2025AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEAffidavit of Service for Morningisde Acquisition LLC (Facility)Elliot B Sinel
403/26/2025AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEAffidavit of Service for Morningisde Acquisition LLC (SOS)Elliot B Sinel
504/01/2025NOTICE OF MOTION1William E Bird
604/01/2025AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION1William E Bird
704/01/2025EXHIBIT(S)S&C1William E Bird
804/01/2025STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING1William E Bird
904/01/2025RJI -RE: NOTICE OF MOTION1William E Bird
1004/22/2025STIPULATION - ADJOURNMENT OF MOTIONStipulation adjourning Defendant's motion1Elliot B Sinel
4Bronx Supreme Court2025800600/2025EDisposedMedical MalpracticeADEMAJ, HASAN et alTHE LAW OFFICE OF JESSE D. CAPELL, PLLCMORNINGSIDE NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTER et alShaub, Ahmuty, Citrin & Spratt, LLP07/14/2025Gerez, Hon. Alicia▼
Case Info
Court
Bronx Supreme Court
Index Number
800600/2025E
Status
Disposed
Year Filed
2025
Case Name
ADEMAJ, HASAN et al vs. MORNINGSIDE NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTER et al
Case Type
Tort-Medical, Dental, or Podiatric Malpractice
Track
Complex
RJI Filed
05/15/2025
NOI Due
08/16/2026
NOI Filed
Calendar Number
—
Jury Status
Justice
Gerez, Hon. Alicia
Next Appearance
07/14/2025
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
ADEMAJ, HASAN et al
Attorney / FirmTHE LAW OFFICE OF JESSE D. CAPELL, PLLC
Defendant / Respondent
MORNINGSIDE NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTER et al
Attorneys / FirmsShaub, Ahmuty, Citrin & Spratt, LLP
Motions (1)
#Date FiledFiled ByRelief SoughtSubmit DateAnswerStatusDecisionOrder Signed
105/22/2025Dismiss07/14/2025NoDecided: 10/16/2025 Granted Before Justice: Gerez, Hon. AliciaMemorandum10/16/2025
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (27)
Doc #Date FiledDocumentDescriptionMotion #Filing UserFile
101/09/2025SUMMONS + COMPLAINTJesse D. Capell
203/17/2025AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEJesse D. Capell
303/19/2025AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEJesse D. Capell
403/25/2025AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEJesse D. Capell
504/09/2025ANSWERLaura M Papa
604/09/2025DEMAND FOR BILL OF PARTICULARSOn Behalf of Morningside Acquisition 1, LLCLaura M Papa
704/09/2025DEMAND FOR BILL OF PARTICULARSOn Behalf of Morningside Acquisition 1, LLC d/b/a Morningside Nursing and Rehabilitation CenterLaura M Papa
804/09/2025NOTICE OF DEPOSITIONLaura M Papa
904/09/2025DEMAND FOR:Combined Initial DemandsLaura M Papa
1004/09/2025STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILINGLaura M Papa
5Bronx Supreme Court2025802376/2025EDisposedMedical MalpracticeXIAMORA GONZALEZ-TAYLOR as Administratrix of the Estate of DELFINA-GONZALEZ and XIAMORA GONZALEZ-TAYLOR, Individually,Greenstein & Pittari, LLPMORNINGSIDE NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTERBARKER PATTERSON NICHOLS, LLP04/15/2025Frishman, Hon. Michael A.▼
Case Info
Court
Bronx Supreme Court
Index Number
802376/2025E
Status
Disposed
Year Filed
2025
Case Name
XIAMORA GONZALEZ-TAYLOR as Administratrix of the Estate of DELFINA-GONZALEZ and XIAMORA GONZALEZ-TAYLOR, Individually, vs. MORNINGSIDE NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTER
Case Type
Tort-Medical, Dental, or Podiatric Malpractice
Track
Complex
RJI Filed
03/17/2025
NOI Due
06/18/2026
NOI Filed
Calendar Number
—
Jury Status
Justice
Frishman, Hon. Michael A.
Next Appearance
04/15/2025
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
XIAMORA GONZALEZ-TAYLOR as Administratrix of the Estate of DELFINA-GONZALEZ and XIAMORA GONZALEZ-TAYLOR, Individually,
Attorney / FirmGreenstein & Pittari, LLP
Defendant / Respondent
MORNINGSIDE NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTER
Attorneys / FirmsBARKER PATTERSON NICHOLS, LLP
Motions (1)
#Date FiledFiled ByRelief SoughtSubmit DateAnswerStatusDecisionOrder Signed
103/17/2025Change Venue04/15/2025NoDecided: 07/01/2025 Denied Before Justice: Frishman, Hon. Michael A.Short Form Order07/01/2025
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (21)
Doc #Date FiledDocumentDescriptionMotion #Filing UserFile
101/30/2025SUMMONS + COMPLAINTRobert J Greenstein
201/30/2025EXHIBIT(S)DecreeRobert J Greenstein
302/17/2025AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEMORNINGSIDE NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTERRobert J Greenstein
402/17/2025STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILINGRobert J Greenstein
503/03/2025ANSWERanswer and various discovery demands including demand change venueGerasimia Stathatos
603/03/2025STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILINGGerasimia Stathatos
703/17/2025NOTICE OF MOTION1Kayla Gloria-Marie Nieves
803/17/2025AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION1Kayla Gloria-Marie Nieves
903/17/2025EXHIBIT(S)Summons and Complaint1Kayla Gloria-Marie Nieves
1003/17/2025EXHIBIT(S)Defendants Verified Answer and Various Demands, including a Demand for Venue Change1Kayla Gloria-Marie Nieves
6Bronx Supreme Court2025803672/2024EActiveMedical MalpracticeRODRIGUEZ, ANGEL L.SINEL & OLESEN, PLLCMORNINGSIDE ACQUISITION I, LLC d/b/a MORNINGSIDE NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTER et alBARKER PATTERSON NICHOLS, LLP05/12/2026Frishman, Hon. Michael A.▼
Case Info
Court
Bronx Supreme Court
Index Number
803672/2024E
Status
Active
Year Filed
2025
Case Name
RODRIGUEZ, ANGEL L. vs. MORNINGSIDE ACQUISITION I, LLC d/b/a MORNINGSIDE NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTER et al
Case Type
Tort-Medical, Dental, or Podiatric Malpractice
Track
Complex
RJI Filed
01/29/2025
NOI Due
05/02/2026
NOI Filed
Calendar Number
—
Jury Status
Justice
Frishman, Hon. Michael A.
Next Appearance
05/12/2026
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
RODRIGUEZ, ANGEL L.
Attorney / FirmSINEL & OLESEN, PLLC
Defendant / Respondent
MORNINGSIDE ACQUISITION I, LLC d/b/a MORNINGSIDE NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTER et al
Attorneys / FirmsBARKER PATTERSON NICHOLS, LLP
Motions (1)
#Date FiledFiled ByRelief SoughtSubmit DateAnswerStatusDecisionOrder Signed
101/29/2025Extend - Time02/19/2025NoDecided: 05/01/2025 Granted Before Justice: Frishman, Hon. Michael A.Short Form Order05/01/2025
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (44)
Doc #Date FiledDocumentDescriptionMotion #Filing UserFile
103/04/2024SUMMONS + COMPLAINT+ Certificate of MeritElliot B Sinel
205/17/2024SUMMONS (PRE RJI) (AMENDED)Amended SummonsElliot B Sinel
305/17/2024COMPLAINT (AMENDED)Amended ComplaintElliot B Sinel
406/13/2024AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEAffidavit of Service for Calvary Hospital (Facility)Elliot B Sinel
506/13/2024AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEAffidavit of Service for Calvary Hospital (SOS)Elliot B Sinel
606/13/2024AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEAffidavit of Service for Morningside Nursing (Facility)Elliot B Sinel
706/13/2024AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEAffidavit of Service for Morningside Nursing (SOS)Elliot B Sinel
806/18/2024ANSWERanswer to amended complaint and various demands including change of venueGerasimia Stathatos
906/18/2024STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILINGGerasimia Stathatos
1007/17/2024ANSWERCalvary HopsitalRegina Marie Sagesser
7Bronx Supreme Court2025809983/2025EStayedMedical MalpracticeMORRIS, BEVERLY et alDUFFY & DUFFY, PLLCMORNINGSIDE ACQUISITION I, LLC, d/b/a MORNINGSIDE NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTERWilson Elser Moskowitz Edelman & Dicker LLP08/11/2025Frishman, Hon. Michael A.▼
Case Info
Court
Bronx Supreme Court
Index Number
809983/2025E
Status
Stayed
Year Filed
2025
Case Name
MORRIS, BEVERLY et al vs. MORNINGSIDE ACQUISITION I, LLC, d/b/a MORNINGSIDE NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTER
Case Type
Tort-Medical, Dental, or Podiatric Malpractice
Track
Complex
RJI Filed
07/03/2025
NOI Due
NOI Filed
Calendar Number
—
Jury Status
Justice
Frishman, Hon. Michael A.
Next Appearance
08/11/2025
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
MORRIS, BEVERLY et al
Attorney / FirmDUFFY & DUFFY, PLLC
Defendant / Respondent
MORNINGSIDE ACQUISITION I, LLC, d/b/a MORNINGSIDE NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTER
Attorneys / FirmsWilson Elser Moskowitz Edelman & Dicker LLP
Motions (1)
#Date FiledFiled ByRelief SoughtSubmit DateAnswerStatusDecisionOrder Signed
107/03/2025Compel Arbitration08/11/2025NoDecided: 10/06/2025 Granted Before Justice: Frishman, Hon. Michael A.Short Form Order10/06/2025
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (17)
Doc #Date FiledDocumentDescriptionMotion #Filing UserFile
105/05/2025SUMMONS + COMPLAINTSummons and Complaint w/verificationDamien Smith
206/20/2025AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEMORNINGSIDE ACQUISITION I, LLCDamien Smith
306/20/2025STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILINGDamien Smith
406/23/2025AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEMORNINGSIDE NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTERDamien Smith
506/25/2025AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEMORNINGSIDE ACQUISITION I LLCDamien Smith
607/03/2025NOTICE OF MOTION1Lori Rosen Semlies
707/03/2025AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION1Lori Rosen Semlies
807/03/2025EXHIBIT(S)Summons and Complaint1Lori Rosen Semlies
907/03/2025EXHIBIT(S)Nash Admission Agreement1Lori Rosen Semlies
1007/03/2025EXHIBIT(S)Nash Power of Attorney1Lori Rosen Semlies
8Bronx Supreme Court2025818305/2024EDisposedMedical MalpracticeDAWSON, TANYA et alTHE GOUGH LAW FIRMMORNINGSIDE ACQUISITION 1 LLC et alBARKER PATTERSON NICHOLS, LLP02/03/2025Gerez, Hon. Alicia▼
Case Info
Court
Bronx Supreme Court
Index Number
818305/2024E
Status
Disposed
Year Filed
2025
Case Name
DAWSON, TANYA et al vs. MORNINGSIDE ACQUISITION 1 LLC et al
Case Type
Tort-Medical, Dental, or Podiatric Malpractice
Track
Complex
RJI Filed
01/07/2025
NOI Due
04/10/2026
NOI Filed
Calendar Number
—
Jury Status
Justice
Gerez, Hon. Alicia
Next Appearance
02/03/2025
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
DAWSON, TANYA et al
Attorney / FirmTHE GOUGH LAW FIRM
Defendant / Respondent
MORNINGSIDE ACQUISITION 1 LLC et al
Attorneys / FirmsBARKER PATTERSON NICHOLS, LLP
Motions (1)
#Date FiledFiled ByRelief SoughtSubmit DateAnswerStatusDecisionOrder Signed
101/07/2025Change Venue02/03/2025NoDecided: 05/15/2025 Granted Before Justice: Gerez, Hon. AliciaShort Form Order05/15/2025
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (33)
Doc #Date FiledDocumentDescriptionMotion #Filing UserFile
111/14/2024SUMMONS + COMPLAINTDeborah Gough
212/23/2024ANSWERVerified Answer with initial demandsGerasimia Stathatos
312/23/2024STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILINGGerasimia Stathatos
412/30/2024AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEDeborah Gough
512/30/2024AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEDeborah Gough
601/06/2025NOTICE OF MOTION121Kayla Gloria-Marie Nieves
701/06/2025AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION121Kayla Gloria-Marie Nieves
801/06/2025EXHIBIT(S)Plaintiffs Summons and Complaint121Kayla Gloria-Marie Nieves
901/06/2025EXHIBIT(S)Defendants Verified Answer and Various Demands, including a Demand for Venue Change121Kayla Gloria-Marie Nieves
1001/06/2025EXHIBIT(S)Admission Agreement121Kayla Gloria-Marie Nieves
9Bronx Supreme Court2025819564/2023EActiveMedical MalpracticeBETTY OQUENDOSINEL & OLESEN, PLLCAMERICARE INC. et alHarris Beach Murtha Cullina PLLC06/16/2026Frishman, Hon. Michael A.▼
Case Info
Court
Bronx Supreme Court
Index Number
819564/2023E
Status
Active
Year Filed
2025
Case Name
BETTY OQUENDO vs. AMERICARE INC. et al
Case Type
Tort-Medical, Dental, or Podiatric Malpractice
Track
Complex
RJI Filed
12/09/2025
NOI Due
03/12/2027
NOI Filed
Calendar Number
—
Jury Status
Justice
Frishman, Hon. Michael A.
Next Appearance
06/16/2026
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
BETTY OQUENDO
Attorney / FirmSINEL & OLESEN, PLLC
Defendant / Respondent
AMERICARE INC. et al
Attorneys / FirmsHarris Beach Murtha Cullina PLLC
Motions (1)
#Date FiledFiled ByRelief SoughtSubmit DateAnswerStatusDecisionOrder Signed
103/11/2026Extend - Time04/15/2026NoBefore Justice: Frishman, Hon. Michael A.
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (49)
Doc #Date FiledDocumentDescriptionMotion #Filing UserFile
112/07/2023SUMMONS + COMPLAINT+ Certificate of MeritElliot B Sinel
202/23/2024AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEAffidavit of Service for Americare (SOS)Elliot B Sinel
302/23/2024AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEAffidavit of Service for Montefiore Medical Center (SOS)Elliot B Sinel
402/23/2024AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEAffidavit of Service for Morningside Nursing (SOS)Elliot B Sinel
503/06/2024ANSWERanswer and various discovery demands including demand change venue -MorningsideGerasimia Stathatos
603/06/2024STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILINGGerasimia Stathatos
703/15/2024ANSWERVerified AnswerJames Stephen Makris
803/15/2024DEMAND FOR BILL OF PARTICULARSDemand for Bill of ParticularsJames Stephen Makris
903/15/2024DEMAND FOR:Combined DemandsJames Stephen Makris
1003/15/2024DEMAND FOR:Notice of Discovery and Inspection for Social MediaJames Stephen Makris
10Bronx Supreme Court2025819593/2025EDisposedMedical MalpracticeJIMENEZ, AUREASALZMAN & WINER LLPMORNINGSIDE NURSING & REHABILITATION CENTERBARKER PATTERSON NICHOLS, LLP12/03/2025Gerez, Hon. Alicia▼
Case Info
Court
Bronx Supreme Court
Index Number
819593/2025E
Status
Disposed
Year Filed
2025
Case Name
JIMENEZ, AUREA vs. MORNINGSIDE NURSING & REHABILITATION CENTER
Case Type
Tort-Medical, Dental, or Podiatric Malpractice
Track
Complex
RJI Filed
10/08/2025
NOI Due
01/09/2027
NOI Filed
Calendar Number
—
Jury Status
Justice
Gerez, Hon. Alicia
Next Appearance
12/03/2025
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
JIMENEZ, AUREA
Attorney / FirmSALZMAN & WINER LLP
Defendant / Respondent
MORNINGSIDE NURSING & REHABILITATION CENTER
Attorneys / FirmsBARKER PATTERSON NICHOLS, LLP
Motions (1)
#Date FiledFiled ByRelief SoughtSubmit DateAnswerStatusDecisionOrder Signed
110/08/2025Dismiss12/03/2025NoDecided: 03/30/2026 Granted Before Justice: Gerez, Hon. AliciaMemorandum03/30/2026
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (11)
Doc #Date FiledDocumentDescriptionMotion #Filing UserFile
109/16/2025SUMMONS + COMPLAINTHarvey Alan Winer
210/01/2025AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEMORNINGSIDE NURSING & REHABILITATION CENTERHarvey Alan Winer
310/01/2025STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILINGHarvey Alan Winer
410/08/2025NOTICE OF MOTION1Nicole A. Wolfer
510/08/2025AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION1Nicole A. Wolfer
610/08/2025EXHIBIT(S)Ex A - S&C.pdf1Nicole A. Wolfer
710/08/2025RJI -RE: NOTICE OF MOTION1Nicole A. Wolfer
810/21/2025LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGELetter requesting adjournment of MS #11Joseph Choonbum Kim
904/14/2026DECISION + ORDER ON MOTIONDated March 30 20261Christina Fernandez
1004/15/2026NOTICE OF ENTRY1Nicole A. Wolfer
11Bronx Supreme Court2025821099/2024EActiveRP-Mortgage Foreclosure-ResidentialLAKEVIEW LOAN SERVICING, LLCGREENSPOON MARDER LLPWILLIAMS, NICOLLE et alMORNINGSIDE ACQUISITIONS I, LLC D/B/A MORNINGSIDE NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTER11/07/2025Semaj, Hon. Naita A.▼
Case Info
Court
Bronx Supreme Court
Index Number
821099/2024E
Status
Active
Year Filed
2025
Case Name
LAKEVIEW LOAN SERVICING, LLC vs. WILLIAMS, NICOLLE et al
Case Type
RP-Mortgage Foreclosure-Residential
Track
Standard
RJI Filed
03/12/2025
NOI Due
03/12/2026
NOI Filed
Calendar Number
—
Jury Status
Justice
Semaj, Hon. Naita A.
Next Appearance
11/07/2025
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
LAKEVIEW LOAN SERVICING, LLC
Attorney / FirmGREENSPOON MARDER LLP
Defendant / Respondent
WILLIAMS, NICOLLE et al
Attorneys / FirmsMORNINGSIDE ACQUISITIONS I, LLC D/B/A MORNINGSIDE NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTER
Motions (1)
#Date FiledFiled ByRelief SoughtSubmit DateAnswerStatusDecisionOrder Signed
110/06/2025Amend Caption/Pleadings11/07/2025NoDecided: 01/21/2026 Granted Before Justice: Semaj, Hon. Naita A.Long Form Order01/21/2026
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (67)
Doc #Date FiledDocumentDescriptionMotion #Filing UserFile
112/20/2024SUMMONS WITH NOTICEEileen Martinez
212/20/2024CONSENT TO EFILINGEileen Martinez
312/20/2024CERTIFICATE OF MERITEileen Martinez
412/20/2024NOTICE OF PENDENCYEileen Martinez
512/20/2024COMPLAINTEileen Martinez
612/20/2024EXHIBIT(S)Exhibits to ComplaintEileen Martinez
701/02/2025AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEAffirmation of Service- CAVALRY SPV I, LLC AS ASSIGNEE OF SYNCHRONY BANK FORMERLY KNOWN AS GECAPITAL RETAIL BANKRaspreet Bhatia
801/02/2025STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILINGAUTHORIZATION FORMRaspreet Bhatia
901/03/2025AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEService - CAPITAL ONE, NATIONAL ASSOCIATION, SUCCESSOR BY MERGER TO CAPITAL ONE BANK (USA), NATIONAL ASSOCIATION - 59118577Raspreet Bhatia
1001/06/2025AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEService - MORNINGSIDE ACQUISITIONS I, LLC D/B/A MORNING SIDE NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTER - 59137951Raspreet Bhatia
12Westchester Supreme Court202450242/2025ActiveMedical MalpracticeTOTINO as Administrator of the Estate of NANCY FRANCO, MARIABAMUNDO ZWAL SCHERMERHORN & CAFFREY, LLPMORNINGSIDE NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTER et alBARKER PATTERSON NICHOLS, LLP05/21/2026Koba, Hon. Nancy Quinn▼
Case Info
Court
Westchester Supreme Court
Index Number
50242/2025
Status
Active
Year Filed
2024
Case Name
TOTINO as Administrator of the Estate of NANCY FRANCO, MARIA vs. MORNINGSIDE NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTER et al
Case Type
Tort-Medical, Dental, or Podiatric Malpractice
Track
Complex
RJI Filed
07/24/2024
NOI Due
10/25/2025
NOI Filed
Calendar Number
—
Jury Status
Justice
Koba, Hon. Nancy Quinn
Next Appearance
05/21/2026
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
TOTINO as Administrator of the Estate of NANCY FRANCO, MARIA
Attorney / FirmBAMUNDO ZWAL SCHERMERHORN & CAFFREY, LLP
Defendant / Respondent
MORNINGSIDE NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTER et al
Attorneys / FirmsBARKER PATTERSON NICHOLS, LLP
Motions
No motions recorded for this case.
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (62)
Doc #Date FiledDocumentDescriptionMotion #Filing UserFile
106/12/2024SUMMONS + COMPLAINTSummons & Verified ComplaintMichael C Zwal
207/09/2024ANSWERanswer and various discovery demands including demand change venueGerasimia Stathatos
307/09/2024STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILINGGerasimia Stathatos
407/10/2024AFFIRMATIONOpposition to venue change demandMichael C Zwal
507/10/2024EXHIBIT(S)Death CertificateMichael C Zwal
607/10/2024EXHIBIT(S)Letters TestamentaryMichael C Zwal
707/24/2024ANSWERVerified Answer and Initial Discovery Demands obo Cassena Care LLCGerasimia Stathatos
807/24/2024STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILINGGerasimia Stathatos
907/24/2024NOTICE OF MOTION12001Kayla Gloria-Marie Nieves
1007/24/2024AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT12001Kayla Gloria-Marie Nieves
13Westchester Supreme Court202450413/2024ActiveMedical MalpracticeBERMAN, THE ESTATE OF SELMANAPOLI SHKOLNIK LLPMORNINGSIDE ACQUISITION 1, LLC d/b/a MORNINGSIDE NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTER et alBARKER PATTERSON NICHOLS, LLP05/04/2026▼
Case Info
Court
Westchester Supreme Court
Index Number
50413/2024
Status
Active
Year Filed
2024
Case Name
BERMAN, THE ESTATE OF SELMA vs. MORNINGSIDE ACQUISITION 1, LLC d/b/a MORNINGSIDE NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTER et al
Case Type
Tort-Medical, Dental, or Podiatric Malpractice
Track
Complex
RJI Filed
07/24/2024
NOI Due
10/25/2025
NOI Filed
02/05/2026
Calendar Number
—
Jury Status
Jury At Plaintiff's Request
Justice
Next Appearance
05/04/2026
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
BERMAN, THE ESTATE OF SELMA
Attorney / FirmNAPOLI SHKOLNIK LLP
Defendant / Respondent
MORNINGSIDE ACQUISITION 1, LLC d/b/a MORNINGSIDE NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTER et al
Attorneys / FirmsBARKER PATTERSON NICHOLS, LLP
Motions
No motions recorded for this case.
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (69)
Doc #Date FiledDocumentDescriptionMotion #Filing UserFile
109/15/2023SUMMONS + COMPLAINTTia Olivia Garcia
211/27/2023AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICECASSENA CARE, LLCTia Olivia Garcia
311/27/2023STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILINGTia Olivia Garcia
412/04/2023AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICECASSENA CARE, LLCTia Olivia Garcia
512/04/2023AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEMORNINGSIDE ACQUISITION 1, LLC D/B/A MORNINGSIDE NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTERTia Olivia Garcia
612/07/2023NOTICE OF MOTIONNotice of Motion to Dismiss1BXJamie Sarah Gewurz
712/07/2023AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORTAffirmation in Support1BXJamie Sarah Gewurz
812/07/2023EXHIBIT(S)Exhibit A - Summons and Complaint1BXJamie Sarah Gewurz
912/07/2023EXHIBIT(S)Exhibit B - Affidavits of Service1BXJamie Sarah Gewurz
1012/07/2023RJI FROM PRIOR COUNTY (COPY)Original document type was RJI -RE: NOTICE OF MOTION1BXJamie Sarah Gewurz
14Bronx Supreme Court2024807589/2024EDisposedMedical MalpracticeDAWSON, TANYATHE GOUGH LAW FIRMMORNINGSIDE ACQUISITION 1 LLC et alBARKER PATTERSON NICHOLS, LLP09/09/2024Frishman, Hon. Michael A.▼
Case Info
Court
Bronx Supreme Court
Index Number
807589/2024E
Status
Disposed
Year Filed
2024
Case Name
DAWSON, TANYA vs. MORNINGSIDE ACQUISITION 1 LLC et al
Case Type
Tort-Medical, Dental, or Podiatric Malpractice
Track
Complex
RJI Filed
06/06/2024
NOI Due
09/07/2025
NOI Filed
Calendar Number
—
Jury Status
Justice
Frishman, Hon. Michael A.
Next Appearance
09/09/2024
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
DAWSON, TANYA
Attorney / FirmTHE GOUGH LAW FIRM
Defendant / Respondent
MORNINGSIDE ACQUISITION 1 LLC et al
Attorneys / FirmsBARKER PATTERSON NICHOLS, LLP
Motions (1)
#Date FiledFiled ByRelief SoughtSubmit DateAnswerStatusDecisionOrder Signed
106/06/2024Dismiss09/09/2024NoDecided: 10/25/2024 Granted Before Justice: Frishman, Hon. Michael A.Memorandum10/25/2024
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (21)
Doc #Date FiledDocumentDescriptionMotion #Filing UserFile
104/27/2024SUMMONS + COMPLAINTDeborah Gough
205/23/2024AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEDeborah Gough
305/23/2024AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEDeborah Gough
406/06/2024NOTICE OF MOTION1Kayla Gloria-Marie Nieves
506/06/2024AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT1Kayla Gloria-Marie Nieves
606/06/2024EXHIBIT(S)Exhibit A - Email1Kayla Gloria-Marie Nieves
706/06/2024AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE1Kayla Gloria-Marie Nieves
806/06/2024STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING1Kayla Gloria-Marie Nieves
906/06/2024RJI -RE: NOTICE OF MOTION1Kayla Gloria-Marie Nieves
1006/11/2024STIPULATION - ADJOURNMENT OF MOTION1Deborah Gough
15Bronx Supreme Court2024807999/2024EDisposedMedical MalpracticeDEHAYES, DIANNEKrentsel & Guzman, LLPMORNINGSIDE NURSING & REHABILITATION CENTERGOLDBERG SEGALLA LLP10/22/2025Frishman, Hon. Michael A.▼
Case Info
Court
Bronx Supreme Court
Index Number
807999/2024E
Status
Disposed
Year Filed
2024
Case Name
DEHAYES, DIANNE vs. MORNINGSIDE NURSING & REHABILITATION CENTER
Case Type
Tort-Medical, Dental, or Podiatric Malpractice
Track
Complex
RJI Filed
11/06/2024
NOI Due
02/07/2026
NOI Filed
Calendar Number
—
Jury Status
Justice
Frishman, Hon. Michael A.
Next Appearance
10/22/2025
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
DEHAYES, DIANNE
Attorney / FirmKrentsel & Guzman, LLP
Defendant / Respondent
MORNINGSIDE NURSING & REHABILITATION CENTER
Attorneys / FirmsGOLDBERG SEGALLA LLP
Motions (2)
#Date FiledFiled ByRelief SoughtSubmit DateAnswerStatusDecisionOrder Signed
209/05/2025Vacate - Decision/Order/Judgment/Award10/22/2025NoDecided: 11/03/2025 Denied Before Justice: Frishman, Hon. Michael A.Short Form Order11/03/2025
104/10/2025Dismiss05/06/2025NoDecided: 07/10/2025 Granted Before Justice: Frishman, Hon. Michael A.Memorandum07/10/2025
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (50)
Doc #Date FiledDocumentDescriptionMotion #Filing UserFile
105/15/2024SUMMONS + COMPLAINTJonathan Joseph Panarella
205/15/2024CERTIFICATE OF MERITJonathan Joseph Panarella
305/15/2024STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILINGJonathan Joseph Panarella
406/06/2024AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEMORNINGSIDE NURSING &REHABILITATION CENTER / AFFIDAVITJonathan Joseph Panarella
506/06/2024STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILINGJonathan Joseph Panarella
607/10/2024ANSWERDefendant's Verified AnswerEdward Vincent Schwendemann
707/26/2024ANSWER (AMENDED)Defendant's Amended Verified AnswerEdward Vincent Schwendemann
811/06/2024PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE REQUESTJonathan Joseph Panarella
911/06/2024AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEJonathan Joseph Panarella
1011/06/2024STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILINGJonathan Joseph Panarella
16Bronx Supreme Court2024809526/2024EDisposedMedical MalpracticeTOTINO as Administrator of the Estate of NANCY FRANCO, MARIABAMUNDO ZWAL SCHERMERHORN & CAFFREY, LLPMORNINGSIDE NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTER et alBARKER PATTERSON NICHOLS, LLP08/21/2024Gerez, Hon. Alicia▼
Case Info
Court
Bronx Supreme Court
Index Number
809526/2024E
Status
Disposed
Year Filed
2024
Case Name
TOTINO as Administrator of the Estate of NANCY FRANCO, MARIA vs. MORNINGSIDE NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTER et al
Case Type
Tort-Medical, Dental, or Podiatric Malpractice
Track
Complex
RJI Filed
07/24/2024
NOI Due
10/25/2025
NOI Filed
Calendar Number
—
Jury Status
Justice
Gerez, Hon. Alicia
Next Appearance
08/21/2024
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
TOTINO as Administrator of the Estate of NANCY FRANCO, MARIA
Attorney / FirmBAMUNDO ZWAL SCHERMERHORN & CAFFREY, LLP
Defendant / Respondent
MORNINGSIDE NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTER et al
Attorneys / FirmsBARKER PATTERSON NICHOLS, LLP
Motions (1)
#Date FiledFiled ByRelief SoughtSubmit DateAnswerStatusDecisionOrder Signed
107/24/2024Change Venue08/21/2024NoDecided: 02/13/2025 Granted Before Justice: Gerez, Hon. AliciaMemorandum02/13/2025
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (62)
Doc #Date FiledDocumentDescriptionMotion #Filing UserFile
106/12/2024SUMMONS + COMPLAINTSummons & Verified ComplaintMichael C Zwal
207/09/2024ANSWERanswer and various discovery demands including demand change venueGerasimia Stathatos
307/09/2024STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILINGGerasimia Stathatos
407/10/2024AFFIRMATIONOpposition to venue change demandMichael C Zwal
507/10/2024EXHIBIT(S)Death CertificateMichael C Zwal
607/10/2024EXHIBIT(S)Letters TestamentaryMichael C Zwal
707/24/2024ANSWERVerified Answer and Initial Discovery Demands obo Cassena Care LLCGerasimia Stathatos
807/24/2024STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILINGGerasimia Stathatos
907/24/2024NOTICE OF MOTION12001Kayla Gloria-Marie Nieves
1007/24/2024AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT12001Kayla Gloria-Marie Nieves
17Bronx Supreme Court2024809868/2024EDisposedMedical MalpracticeHOPE GREEN, AS PROPOSED ADMINISTRATOR OF THE ESTATE OF RUBY GREEN, DECEASEDKrentsel & Guzman, LLPMORNINGSIDE NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTERGOLDBERG SEGALLA LLP09/27/2024Frishman, Hon. Michael A.▼
Case Info
Court
Bronx Supreme Court
Index Number
809868/2024E
Status
Disposed
Year Filed
2024
Case Name
HOPE GREEN, AS PROPOSED ADMINISTRATOR OF THE ESTATE OF RUBY GREEN, DECEASED vs. MORNINGSIDE NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTER
Case Type
Tort-Medical, Dental, or Podiatric Malpractice
Track
Complex
RJI Filed
08/09/2024
NOI Due
11/10/2025
NOI Filed
Calendar Number
—
Jury Status
Justice
Frishman, Hon. Michael A.
Next Appearance
09/27/2024
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
HOPE GREEN, AS PROPOSED ADMINISTRATOR OF THE ESTATE OF RUBY GREEN, DECEASED
Attorney / FirmKrentsel & Guzman, LLP
Defendant / Respondent
MORNINGSIDE NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTER
Attorneys / FirmsGOLDBERG SEGALLA LLP
Motions (1)
#Date FiledFiled ByRelief SoughtSubmit DateAnswerStatusDecisionOrder Signed
108/09/2024Dismiss09/27/2024NoDecided: 10/25/2024 Granted Before Justice: Frishman, Hon. Michael A.Memorandum10/25/2024
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (23)
Doc #Date FiledDocumentDescriptionMotion #Filing UserFile
106/18/2024SUMMONS + COMPLAINTJonathan Joseph Panarella
206/18/2024CERTIFICATE OF MERITJonathan Joseph Panarella
306/18/2024STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILINGJonathan Joseph Panarella
407/05/2024AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEAffidavit of Service on Morningside Nursing and Rehabilitation CenterJonathan Joseph Panarella
507/05/2024STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILINGJonathan Joseph Panarella
608/09/2024NOTICE OF MOTIONNotice of Motion to Dismiss for Lack of Capacity1Edward Vincent Schwendemann
708/09/2024AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTIONAffirmation in Support of Motion to Dismiss1Edward Vincent Schwendemann
808/09/2024EXHIBIT(S)Summons & Complaint dated 5.18.231Edward Vincent Schwendemann
908/09/2024EXHIBIT(S)Notice of Entry1Edward Vincent Schwendemann
1008/09/2024EXHIBIT(S)New Summons & Complaint1Edward Vincent Schwendemann
18Bronx Supreme Court2024813176/2023EActiveNegligenceRUIZ, EDDALEELever & Ecker, PLLCMORNINGSIDE ACQUISITION I, LLC et alABRAMS, FENSTERMAN, FENSTERMAN, EISMAN, FORMATO, FERRARA & WOLF, LLP06/03/2025Semaj, Hon. Naita A.▼
Case Info
Court
Bronx Supreme Court
Index Number
813176/2023E
Status
Active
Year Filed
2024
Case Name
RUIZ, EDDALEE vs. MORNINGSIDE ACQUISITION I, LLC et al
Case Type
Tort-Other Negligence
Track
Standard
RJI Filed
02/05/2024
NOI Due
02/04/2025
NOI Filed
Calendar Number
—
Jury Status
Justice
Semaj, Hon. Naita A.
Next Appearance
06/03/2025
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
RUIZ, EDDALEE
Attorney / FirmLever & Ecker, PLLC
Defendant / Respondent
MORNINGSIDE ACQUISITION I, LLC et al
Attorneys / FirmsABRAMS, FENSTERMAN, FENSTERMAN, EISMAN, FORMATO, FERRARA & WOLF, LLP
Motions
No motions recorded for this case.
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (28)
Doc #Date FiledDocumentDescriptionMotion #Filing UserFile
108/28/2023SUMMONS + COMPLAINTPhilip J Sporn
209/14/2023AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEPhilip J Sporn
309/14/2023AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEPhilip J Sporn
409/14/2023AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEPhilip J Sporn
509/14/2023STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILINGPhilip J Sporn
610/17/2023SUBSTITUTION OF ATTORNEY (PRE RJI)Adam Chanan Weiss
701/02/2024ANSWERDavid Todd Verschell
801/02/2024NOTICE OF DEPOSITION UPON ORAL EXAMINATIONDavid Todd Verschell
901/02/2024DEMAND FOR BILL OF PARTICULARSDavid Todd Verschell
1001/02/2024NOTICE OF DISCOVERY AND INSPECTIONDavid Todd Verschell
19Bronx Supreme Court2024819617/2024EDisposedMedical MalpracticePAZ, VANIAKHAVINSON & ASSOCIATES PCMORNINGSIDE NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTER et alBARKER PATTERSON NICHOLS, LLP02/06/2025Frishman, Hon. Michael A.▼
Case Info
Court
Bronx Supreme Court
Index Number
819617/2024E
Status
Disposed
Year Filed
2024
Case Name
PAZ, VANIA vs. MORNINGSIDE NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTER et al
Case Type
Tort-Medical, Dental, or Podiatric Malpractice
Track
Complex
RJI Filed
12/30/2024
NOI Due
04/02/2026
NOI Filed
Calendar Number
—
Jury Status
Justice
Frishman, Hon. Michael A.
Next Appearance
02/06/2025
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
PAZ, VANIA
Attorney / FirmKHAVINSON & ASSOCIATES PC
Defendant / Respondent
MORNINGSIDE NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTER et al
Attorneys / FirmsBARKER PATTERSON NICHOLS, LLP
Motions (1)
#Date FiledFiled ByRelief SoughtSubmit DateAnswerStatusDecisionOrder Signed
101/09/2025Change Venue02/06/2025NoDecided: 03/26/2025 Granted Before Justice: Frishman, Hon. Michael A.Memorandum03/26/2025
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (19)
Doc #Date FiledDocumentDescriptionMotion #Filing UserFile
112/02/2024SUMMONS + COMPLAINTS&CEugene A. Khavinson
212/13/2024AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEEugene A. Khavinson
312/13/2024STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILINGEugene A. Khavinson
412/19/2024AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEEugene A. Khavinson
512/26/2024ANSWERVerified Answer and Various Discovery DemandsGerasimia Stathatos
612/26/2024STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILINGGerasimia Stathatos
1112/30/2024PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE REQUESTEugene A. Khavinson
1212/30/2024RJI -RE: REQUEST FOR PRELIMINARY CONFERENCEEugene A. Khavinson
1301/09/2025NOTICE OF MOTION1Kayla Gloria-Marie Nieves
1401/09/2025AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION1Kayla Gloria-Marie Nieves
20Albany Supreme Court2024906861-24DisposedSP-CPLR Article 78 (Body or Officer)The New York State Health Facilities Association, Inc. et alO'CONNELL & ARONOWITZ, P.C.McDonald M.D., JamesATTORNEY GENERAL03/12/2025Silverman, Hon. Adam W.▼
Case Info
Court
Albany Supreme Court
Index Number
906861-24
Status
Disposed
Year Filed
2024
Case Name
The New York State Health Facilities Association, Inc. et al vs. McDonald M.D., James
Case Type
SP-CPLR Article 78 (Body or Officer)
Track
Standard
RJI Filed
07/18/2024
NOI Due
07/18/2025
NOI Filed
Calendar Number
—
Jury Status
Justice
Silverman, Hon. Adam W.
Next Appearance
03/12/2025
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
The New York State Health Facilities Association, Inc. et al
Attorney / FirmO'CONNELL & ARONOWITZ, P.C.
Defendant / Respondent
McDonald M.D., James
Attorneys / FirmsATTORNEY GENERAL
Motions (1)
#Date FiledFiled ByRelief SoughtSubmit DateAnswerStatusDecisionOrder Signed
107/18/2024Vacate - Decision/Order/Judgment/Award05/29/2025NoDecided: 05/29/2025 Withdrawn Before Justice: Silverman, Hon. Adam W.Long Form Order
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (48)
Doc #Date FiledDocumentDescriptionMotion #Filing UserFile
107/18/2024PETITIONCornelius D. Murray
207/18/2024EXHIBIT(S)Ex. A to Petition MDS Assessment FormCornelius D. Murray
307/18/2024EXHIBIT(S)Ex. B to Petition State Plan Amendment 21-0050Cornelius D. Murray
407/18/2024EXHIBIT(S)Ex. C to Petition CMS letter approving SPACornelius D. Murray
507/18/2024EXHIBIT(S)Ex. D to Petition DAL dated July 7, 2022Cornelius D. Murray
607/18/2024EXHIBIT(S)Ex. E to Petition DAL dated March 8, 2023Cornelius D. Murray
707/18/2024EXHIBIT(S)Ex. F to Petition State Register dated March 27, 2024Cornelius D. Murray
807/18/2024EXHIBIT(S)Ex. G to Petition State Plan Amendment 24-0043Cornelius D. Murray
907/18/2024EXHIBIT(S)Ex. H to Petition Hanse letter to Commissioner of Health dated April 30, 2024Cornelius D. Murray
1007/18/2024EXHIBIT(S)Ex. I to Petition Hanse letter to Commissioner of Health dated June 3, 2024Cornelius D. Murray
21Bronx Supreme Court2023807771/2023EDisposedMedical MalpracticeGREEN, HOPEKrentsel & Guzman, LLPMORNINGSIDE NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTERGOLDBERG SEGALLA LLP08/24/2023Capella, Hon. Joseph E.▼
Case Info
Court
Bronx Supreme Court
Index Number
807771/2023E
Status
Disposed
Year Filed
2023
Case Name
GREEN, HOPE vs. MORNINGSIDE NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTER
Case Type
Tort-Medical, Dental, or Podiatric Malpractice
Track
Standard
RJI Filed
07/14/2023
NOI Due
07/13/2024
NOI Filed
Calendar Number
—
Jury Status
Justice
Capella, Hon. Joseph E.
Next Appearance
08/24/2023
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
GREEN, HOPE
Attorney / FirmKrentsel & Guzman, LLP
Defendant / Respondent
MORNINGSIDE NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTER
Attorneys / FirmsGOLDBERG SEGALLA LLP
Motions (1)
#Date FiledFiled ByRelief SoughtSubmit DateAnswerStatusDecisionOrder Signed
107/14/2023Dismiss08/24/2023NoDecided: 12/18/2023 Granted Before Justice: Capella, Hon. Joseph E.Short Form Order12/18/2023
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (15)
Doc #Date FiledDocumentDescriptionMotion #Filing UserFile
105/18/2023SUMMONS + COMPLAINTJonathan Joseph Panarellapdf
205/18/2023STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILINGJonathan Joseph Panarella
306/06/2023AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEMORNINGSIDE NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTER / AFFIDAVITJonathan Joseph Panarella
406/06/2023STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILINGJonathan Joseph Panarella
507/14/2023NOTICE OF MOTIONNotice of Motion to Dismiss1Edward Vincent Schwendemannpdf
607/14/2023AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTIONAffirmation in Support of Motion to Dismiss1Edward Vincent Schwendemann
707/14/2023EXHIBIT(S)Summons & Complaint1Edward Vincent Schwendemann
807/14/2023AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEAffirmation of Service1Edward Vincent Schwendemann
907/14/2023RJI -RE: NOTICE OF MOTION1Edward Vincent Schwendemannpdf
1007/19/2023AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION1Jonathan Joseph Panarella
22Bronx Supreme Court2023809418/2023EActiveMedical MalpracticeDAVID ESCOBAR, as Administrator of the Estate of AMERICA LEBRON, Deceased,KRAMER & POLLACK, LLPMORNINGSIDE ACQUISITION I, LLC d/b/a MORNINGSIDE NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTER,GOLDBERG SEGALLA LLP05/05/2026Gerez, Hon. Alicia▼
Case Info
Court
Bronx Supreme Court
Index Number
809418/2023E
Status
Active
Year Filed
2023
Case Name
DAVID ESCOBAR, as Administrator of the Estate of AMERICA LEBRON, Deceased, vs. MORNINGSIDE ACQUISITION I, LLC d/b/a MORNINGSIDE NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTER,
Case Type
Tort-Medical, Dental, or Podiatric Malpractice
Track
Complex
RJI Filed
11/20/2023
NOI Due
02/20/2025
NOI Filed
Calendar Number
—
Jury Status
Justice
Gerez, Hon. Alicia
Next Appearance
05/05/2026
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
DAVID ESCOBAR, as Administrator of the Estate of AMERICA LEBRON, Deceased,
Attorney / FirmKRAMER & POLLACK, LLP
Defendant / Respondent
MORNINGSIDE ACQUISITION I, LLC d/b/a MORNINGSIDE NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTER,
Attorneys / FirmsGOLDBERG SEGALLA LLP
Motions
No motions recorded for this case.
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (20)
Doc #Date FiledDocumentDescriptionMotion #Filing UserFile
106/19/2023SUMMONS + COMPLAINTRobyn Leibowitz Schmigelskipdf
206/19/2023EXHIBIT(S)DECREE APPOINTING ADMINISTRATORRobyn Leibowitz Schmigelski
306/26/2023AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEAOS for MorningsideRobyn Leibowitz Schmigelski
409/25/2023DEMAND FOR CHANGE OF PLACE OF TRIALDemand to Change VenueEdward Vincent Schwendemann
509/25/2023ANSWERDefendant's Verified AnswerEdward Vincent Schwendemannpdf
611/20/2023NOTICE OF MEDICAL MALPRACTICERobyn Leibowitz Schmigelski
711/20/2023RJI -RE: NOTICE OF MEDICAL, DENTAL OR PODIATRIC MALPRACTICERobyn Leibowitz Schmigelski
811/20/2023PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE REQUESTRobyn Leibowitz Schmigelski
902/26/2024ORDER - PRELIMINARY CONFERENCEDATED 2/26/2024Ashley Williams
1006/07/2024ORDER ( PROPOSED )Compliance Conference Order 6/12/24Robyn Leibowitz Schmigelski
23Bronx Supreme Court2023810640/2022EActiveOM-OtherMORNINGSIDE ACQUISITION I, LLC d/b/a MORNINGSIDE NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTER as Successor to MORNINGSIDE HOUSE NURSING HOME COMPANY, INC.CASSENA CARESINGLETARY, MICHAEL01/23/2024Brigantti, Hon. Mary Ann▼
Case Info
Court
Bronx Supreme Court
Index Number
810640/2022E
Status
Active
Year Filed
2023
Case Name
MORNINGSIDE ACQUISITION I, LLC d/b/a MORNINGSIDE NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTER as Successor to MORNINGSIDE HOUSE NURSING HOME COMPANY, INC. vs. SINGLETARY, MICHAEL
Case Type
OM-Other
Track
Standard
RJI Filed
08/21/2023
NOI Due
08/20/2024
NOI Filed
Calendar Number
—
Jury Status
Justice
Brigantti, Hon. Mary Ann
Next Appearance
01/23/2024
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
MORNINGSIDE ACQUISITION I, LLC d/b/a MORNINGSIDE NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTER as Successor to MORNINGSIDE HOUSE NURSING HOME COMPANY, INC.
Attorney / FirmCASSENA CARE
Defendant / Respondent
SINGLETARY, MICHAEL
Attorneys / Firms
Motions (1)
#Date FiledFiled ByRelief SoughtSubmit DateAnswerStatusDecisionOrder Signed
108/21/2023Judgment - Default01/23/2024NoDecided: 04/19/2024 Granted to the Extent of the Order Before Justice: Brigantti, Hon. Mary AnnMemorandum04/19/2024
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (17)
Doc #Date FiledDocumentDescriptionMotion #Filing UserFile
107/21/2022SUMMONS + COMPLAINTAngela Cristina Bellizzipdf
208/12/2022AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEMICHAEL SINGLETARYAngela Cristina Bellizzi
308/12/2022STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILINGAUTHORIZATIONAngela Cristina Bellizzi
408/21/2023NOTICE OF MOTION1Angela Cristina Bellizzipdf
508/21/2023AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT1Angela Cristina Bellizzi
608/21/2023EXHIBIT(S)summons and verified complaint1Angela Cristina Bellizzi
708/21/2023EXHIBIT(S)Affidavit of Service1Angela Cristina Bellizzi
808/21/2023EXHIBIT(S)Additional Mailing of Summons and Complaint1Angela Cristina Bellizzi
908/21/2023EXHIBIT(S)Itemized Bill1Angela Cristina Bellizzi
1008/21/2023EXHIBIT(S)Medicaid Budget1Angela Cristina Bellizzi
24Bronx Supreme Court2023814221/2023EDisposedMedical MalpracticeBERMAN, THE ESTATE OF SELMANAPOLI SHKOINIK, PLLCMORNINGSIDE ACQUISITION 1, LLC d/b/a MORNINGSIDE NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTER et alBarker Patterson Nichols, LLP05/01/2024Capella, Hon. Joseph E.▼
Case Info
Court
Bronx Supreme Court
Index Number
814221/2023E
Status
Disposed
Year Filed
2023
Case Name
BERMAN, THE ESTATE OF SELMA vs. MORNINGSIDE ACQUISITION 1, LLC d/b/a MORNINGSIDE NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTER et al
Case Type
Tort-Medical, Dental, or Podiatric Malpractice
Track
Complex
RJI Filed
12/07/2023
NOI Due
03/09/2025
NOI Filed
Calendar Number
—
Jury Status
Justice
Capella, Hon. Joseph E.
Next Appearance
05/01/2024
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
BERMAN, THE ESTATE OF SELMA
Attorney / FirmNAPOLI SHKOINIK, PLLC
Defendant / Respondent
MORNINGSIDE ACQUISITION 1, LLC d/b/a MORNINGSIDE NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTER et al
Attorneys / FirmsBarker Patterson Nichols, LLP
Motions (2)
#Date FiledFiled ByRelief SoughtSubmit DateAnswerStatusDecisionOrder Signed
201/25/2024Change Venue05/01/2024NoDecided: 06/12/2024 Granted Before Justice: Capella, Hon. Joseph E.Memorandum06/12/2024
112/07/2023Dismiss01/08/2024NoDecided: 01/17/2024 Withdrawn Before Justice: Capella, Hon. Joseph E.Short Form Order01/24/2024
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (69)
Doc #Date FiledDocumentDescriptionMotion #Filing UserFile
109/15/2023SUMMONS + COMPLAINTTia Olivia Garciapdf
211/27/2023AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICECASSENA CARE, LLCTia Olivia Garcia
311/27/2023STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILINGTia Olivia Garcia
412/04/2023AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICECASSENA CARE, LLCTia Olivia Garcia
512/04/2023AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEMORNINGSIDE ACQUISITION 1, LLC D/B/A MORNINGSIDE NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTERTia Olivia Garcia
612/07/2023NOTICE OF MOTIONNotice of Motion to Dismiss1BXJamie Sarah Gewurzpdf
712/07/2023AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORTAffirmation in Support1BXJamie Sarah Gewurz
812/07/2023EXHIBIT(S)Exhibit A - Summons and Complaint1BXJamie Sarah Gewurz
912/07/2023EXHIBIT(S)Exhibit B - Affidavits of Service1BXJamie Sarah Gewurz
1012/07/2023RJI FROM PRIOR COUNTY (COPY)Original document type was RJI -RE: NOTICE OF MOTION1BXJamie Sarah Gewurz
25Bronx Supreme Court2023815725/2023EDisposedMedical MalpracticeDEHAYES, DIANNEKrentsel & Guzman, LLPMORNINGSIDE NURSING & REHABILITATION CENTERGOLDBERG SEGALLA LLP08/09/2024Capella, Hon. Joseph E.▼
Case Info
Court
Bronx Supreme Court
Index Number
815725/2023E
Status
Disposed
Year Filed
2023
Case Name
DEHAYES, DIANNE vs. MORNINGSIDE NURSING & REHABILITATION CENTER
Case Type
Tort-Medical, Dental, or Podiatric Malpractice
Track
Standard
RJI Filed
10/18/2023
NOI Due
10/17/2024
NOI Filed
Calendar Number
—
Jury Status
Justice
Capella, Hon. Joseph E.
Next Appearance
08/09/2024
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
DEHAYES, DIANNE
Attorney / FirmKrentsel & Guzman, LLP
Defendant / Respondent
MORNINGSIDE NURSING & REHABILITATION CENTER
Attorneys / FirmsGOLDBERG SEGALLA LLP
Motions (3)
#Date FiledFiled ByRelief SoughtSubmit DateAnswerStatusDecisionOrder Signed
306/10/2024Renew/Reargue/Resettle/Reconsider08/09/2024NoDecided: 10/18/2024 Granted Before Justice: Capella, Hon. Joseph E.Short Form Order10/18/2024
211/21/2023Amend Caption/Pleadings04/17/2024NoDecided: 04/17/2024 Denied Before Justice: Capella, Hon. Joseph E.Short Form Order04/17/2024
110/18/2023Dismiss12/11/2023NoDecided: 04/10/2024 Granted Before Justice: Capella, Hon. Joseph E.Short Form Order04/10/2024
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (39)
Doc #Date FiledDocumentDescriptionMotion #Filing UserFile
110/06/2023SUMMONS + COMPLAINTJonathan Joseph Panarellapdf
210/06/2023STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILINGJonathan Joseph Panarella
310/17/2023AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEMORNINGSIDE NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTER / AFFIDAVITJonathan Joseph Panarella
410/17/2023STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILINGJonathan Joseph Panarella
510/18/2023NOTICE OF MOTIONNotice of Motion to Dismiss1Edward Vincent Schwendemannpdf
610/18/2023AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTIONAffirmation in Support of Motion to Dismiss1Edward Vincent Schwendemann
710/18/2023EXHIBIT(S)Plaintiff's Initial Summons & Complaint1Edward Vincent Schwendemann
810/18/2023EXHIBIT(S)E-Filed Order with Notice of Entry1Edward Vincent Schwendemann
910/18/2023EXHIBIT(S)Plaintiff's New Summons & Complaint1Edward Vincent Schwendemann
1010/18/2023RJI -RE: NOTICE OF MOTION1Edward Vincent Schwendemannpdf
26Bronx Supreme Court2023819016/2022EDisposedMedical MalpracticeDIANNE DEHAYES, as Proposed Administratrix Of the Estate of MARIA VELEZ, DeceasedKrentsel & Guzman, LLPMORNINGSIDE NURSING & REHABILITATION CENTERGOLDBERG SEGALLA LLP02/10/2023Capella, Hon. Joseph E.▼
Case Info
Court
Bronx Supreme Court
Index Number
819016/2022E
Status
Disposed
Year Filed
2023
Case Name
DIANNE DEHAYES, as Proposed Administratrix Of the Estate of MARIA VELEZ, Deceased vs. MORNINGSIDE NURSING & REHABILITATION CENTER
Case Type
Tort-Medical, Dental, or Podiatric Malpractice
Track
Complex
RJI Filed
01/12/2023
NOI Due
04/14/2024
NOI Filed
Calendar Number
—
Jury Status
Justice
Capella, Hon. Joseph E.
Next Appearance
02/10/2023
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
DIANNE DEHAYES, as Proposed Administratrix Of the Estate of MARIA VELEZ, Deceased
Attorney / FirmKrentsel & Guzman, LLP
Defendant / Respondent
MORNINGSIDE NURSING & REHABILITATION CENTER
Attorneys / FirmsGOLDBERG SEGALLA LLP
Motions (1)
#Date FiledFiled ByRelief SoughtSubmit DateAnswerStatusDecisionOrder Signed
101/12/2023Dismiss02/10/2023NoDecided: 03/22/2023 Granted Before Justice: Capella, Hon. Joseph E.Short Form Order03/22/2023
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (12)
Doc #Date FiledDocumentDescriptionMotion #Filing UserFile
112/20/2022SUMMONS + COMPLAINTJonathan Joseph Panarellapdf
212/20/2022STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILINGJonathan Joseph Panarella
312/29/2022AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEMORNINGSIDE NURSING & REHABILITATION CENTER / AFFIDAVITJonathan Joseph Panarella
412/29/2022STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILINGJonathan Joseph Panarella
501/12/2023NOTICE OF MOTIONNotice of Motion to Dismiss1Edward Vincent Schwendemannpdf
601/12/2023AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTIONAffirmation in Support of Motion1Edward Vincent Schwendemann
701/12/2023EXHIBIT(S)Summons & Complaint1Edward Vincent Schwendemann
801/12/2023AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEAffirmation of Service1Edward Vincent Schwendemann
901/12/2023RJI -RE: NOTICE OF MOTION1Edward Vincent Schwendemannpdf
1001/12/2023ADDENDUM - GENERAL (840A)1Edward Vincent Schwendemann
27Westchester Supreme Court202250178/2022Disposed-Court Date/Application PendingNegligenceGASKIN, MELISSA et alDUFFY & DUFFY, PLLCMORNINGSIDE ACQUISITION I, LLC, d/b/a MORNINGSIDE NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTERGOLDBERG SEGALLA LLP06/26/2026▼
Case Info
Court
Westchester Supreme Court
Index Number
50178/2022
Status
Disposed-Court Date/Application Pending
Year Filed
2022
Case Name
GASKIN, MELISSA et al vs. MORNINGSIDE ACQUISITION I, LLC, d/b/a MORNINGSIDE NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTER
Case Type
Tort-Other Negligence
Track
Standard
RJI Filed
04/05/2022
NOI Due
04/05/2023
NOI Filed
09/11/2023
Calendar Number
—
Jury Status
Jury At Plaintiff's Request
Justice
Next Appearance
06/26/2026
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
GASKIN, MELISSA et al
Attorney / FirmDUFFY & DUFFY, PLLC
Defendant / Respondent
MORNINGSIDE ACQUISITION I, LLC, d/b/a MORNINGSIDE NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTER
Attorneys / FirmsGOLDBERG SEGALLA LLP
Motions
No motions recorded for this case.
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (79)
Doc #Date FiledDocumentDescriptionMotion #Filing UserFile
108/16/2021SUMMONS + COMPLAINTSUMMONS AND COMPLAINT W/VERIFICATION PAGEDamien Smithpdf
310/22/2021STIPULATION - OTHER - ( REQUEST TO SO ORDER )STIPULATION TO AMEND CAPTIONDamien Smith
411/03/2021AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEMORNINGSIDE NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTERMichael E Duffy
511/03/2021AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEMORNINGSIDE ACQUISITION I, LLCMichael E Duffy
611/03/2021STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILINGMichael E Duffy
1211/10/2021AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEMORNINGSIDE ACQUISITION I, LLCMichael E Duffy
1311/12/2021RJI FROM PRIOR COUNTY (COPY)RJI WITH STIPULATION TO AMEND CAPTION AND COMPLAINT; Original document type was RJI -RE: OTHERDamien Smith
1411/12/2021ADDENDUM - GENERAL (840A)Damien Smith
1511/17/2021DEMAND FOR CHANGE OF PLACE OF TRIALDemand to Change VenueEdward Vincent Schwendemann
1611/17/2021ANSWERDefendant's Verified AnswerEdward Vincent Schwendemannpdf
28Bronx Supreme Court2022809531/2022EStayedMedical MalpracticeAYALA, VICTORIAKrentsel & Guzman, LLPMORNINGSIDE NURSING & REHABILITATION CENTER et alWilson Elser Moskowitz Edelman & Dicker LLP07/08/2026Gerez, Hon. Alicia▼
Case Info
Court
Bronx Supreme Court
Index Number
809531/2022E
Status
Stayed
Year Filed
2022
Case Name
AYALA, VICTORIA vs. MORNINGSIDE NURSING & REHABILITATION CENTER et al
Case Type
Tort-Medical, Dental, or Podiatric Malpractice
Track
Complex
RJI Filed
09/14/2022
NOI Due
NOI Filed
Calendar Number
—
Jury Status
Justice
Gerez, Hon. Alicia
Next Appearance
07/08/2026
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
AYALA, VICTORIA
Attorney / FirmKrentsel & Guzman, LLP
Defendant / Respondent
MORNINGSIDE NURSING & REHABILITATION CENTER et al
Attorneys / FirmsWilson Elser Moskowitz Edelman & Dicker LLP
Motions (1)
#Date FiledFiled ByRelief SoughtSubmit DateAnswerStatusDecisionOrder Signed
105/02/2024Appoint - Guardian01/29/2025NoDecided: 02/05/2025 Denied Before Justice: Gerez, Hon. AliciaShort Form Order02/05/2025
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (53)
Doc #Date FiledDocumentDescriptionMotion #Filing UserFile
106/27/2022SUMMONS + COMPLAINTJonathan Joseph Panarellapdf
206/27/2022STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILINGJonathan Joseph Panarella
307/06/2022AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEMORNINGSIDE NURSING & REHABILITATION CENTER / AFFIDAVITJonathan Joseph Panarella
407/06/2022STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILINGJonathan Joseph Panarella
507/15/2022AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEMOUNT SINAI MORNINGSIDE HOSPITAL / AFFIDAVITJonathan Joseph Panarella
608/10/2022ANSWEROn behalf of St. Luke's-Roosevelt Hospital Center s/h/a Mount Sinai Morningside HospitalLaura M Papapdf
708/10/2022DEMAND FOR BILL OF PARTICULARSOn behalf of St. Luke's-Roosevelt Hospital Center s/h/a Mount Sinai Morningside HospitalLaura M Papa
808/10/2022NOTICE OF DEPOSITIONOf Victoria AyalaLaura M Papa
908/10/2022STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILINGLaura M Papa
1008/22/2022ANSWERLori Rosen Semliespdf
29Bronx Supreme Court2022812842/2021EActiveMedical MalpracticeMORALES, SANDRA et alDUFFY & DUFFY, PLLCMORNINGSIDE ACQUISITION I, LLC d/b/a MORNINGSIDE NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTERSHEELEY LLP04/10/2023Gerez, Hon. Alicia▼
Case Info
Court
Bronx Supreme Court
Index Number
812842/2021E
Status
Active
Year Filed
2022
Case Name
MORALES, SANDRA et al vs. MORNINGSIDE ACQUISITION I, LLC d/b/a MORNINGSIDE NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTER
Case Type
Tort-Medical, Dental, or Podiatric Malpractice
Track
Complex
RJI Filed
03/01/2022
NOI Due
06/02/2023
NOI Filed
Calendar Number
—
Jury Status
Justice
Gerez, Hon. Alicia
Next Appearance
04/10/2023
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
MORALES, SANDRA et al
Attorney / FirmDUFFY & DUFFY, PLLC
Defendant / Respondent
MORNINGSIDE ACQUISITION I, LLC d/b/a MORNINGSIDE NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTER
Attorneys / FirmsSHEELEY LLP
Motions
No motions recorded for this case.
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (24)
Doc #Date FiledDocumentDescriptionMotion #Filing UserFile
109/23/2021SUMMONS + COMPLAINTDamien Smithpdf
210/01/2021AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEMORNINGSIDE ACQUISITION I, LLCDamien Smith
310/01/2021AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEMORNINGSIDE ACQUISITION I, LLCDamien Smith
410/01/2021STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILINGDamien Smith
510/08/2021AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEMORNINGSIDE NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTERDamien Smith
610/27/2021PROOF OF SERVICEAffidavit of Service - Notice of CommencementDamien Smith
710/27/2021EXHIBIT(S)Notice of Commencement/Summons and Complaint and Affidavit of ServiceDamien Smith
812/15/2021ANSWERVerified AnswerScott M Zimmermanpdf
912/15/2021DEMAND FOR BILL OF PARTICULARSDemand for Bill of ParticularsScott M Zimmerman
1012/15/2021DEMAND FOR:Combined DemandsScott M Zimmerman
30Queens Supreme Court2021717442/2019ActiveOM-OtherMorningside Acquisition I, LLC d/b/a Morningside Nursing and Rehabilitation CenterCASSENA CARELamb, Philip12/06/2022Compliance Conf Judge,▼
Case Info
Court
Queens Supreme Court
Index Number
717442/2019
Status
Active
Year Filed
2021
Case Name
Morningside Acquisition I, LLC d/b/a Morningside Nursing and Rehabilitation Center vs. Lamb, Philip
Case Type
OM-Other
Track
Standard
RJI Filed
07/29/2021
NOI Due
07/29/2022
NOI Filed
Calendar Number
—
Jury Status
Justice
Compliance Conf Judge,
Next Appearance
12/06/2022
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
Morningside Acquisition I, LLC d/b/a Morningside Nursing and Rehabilitation Center
Attorney / FirmCASSENA CARE
Defendant / Respondent
Lamb, Philip
Attorneys / Firms
Motions (1)
#Date FiledFiled ByRelief SoughtSubmit DateAnswerStatusDecisionOrder Signed
102/11/2022Strike Pleadings04/20/2022YesDecided: 04/20/2022 Granted to the Extent of the Order Before Justice: Esposito, Hon. Joseph J.Short Form Order
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (31)
Doc #Date FiledDocumentDescriptionMotion #Filing UserFile
110/14/2019SUMMONS + COMPLAINTAngela Cristina Bellizzipdf
211/13/2019AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEPHILIP LAMBAngela Cristina Bellizzi
311/13/2019STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILINGAUTHORIZATIONAngela Cristina Bellizzi
411/25/2019ANSWERPhilip Lambpdf
507/29/2021PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE REQUESTPlaintiff's Request for Preliminary Conference ReportAngela Cristina Bellizzi
607/29/2021AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEAffidavit of Service for Request for Preliminary Service and Request for Judicial InterventionAngela Cristina Bellizzi
707/29/2021RJI -RE: REQUEST FOR PRELIMINARY CONFERENCERequest for Judicial InterventionAngela Cristina Bellizzi
808/18/2021LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGELetter to Pro-Se Defendant concerning Preliminary ConferenceAngela Cristina Bellizzi
908/25/2021ORDER - PRELIMINARY CONFERENCEKianna Vanputten
1011/18/2021LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGELetter to Pro-Se DefendantAngela Cristina Bellizzi
31Bronx Supreme Court2021811124/2021EDisposedMedical MalpracticeGASKIN, MELISSA et alDUFFY & DUFFY, PLLCMORNINGSIDE ACQUISITION I, LLC, d/b/a MORNINGSIDE NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTERGOLDBERG SEGALLA LLP01/04/2022Capella, Hon. Joseph E.▼
Case Info
Court
Bronx Supreme Court
Index Number
811124/2021E
Status
Disposed
Year Filed
2021
Case Name
GASKIN, MELISSA et al vs. MORNINGSIDE ACQUISITION I, LLC, d/b/a MORNINGSIDE NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTER
Case Type
Tort-Medical, Dental, or Podiatric Malpractice
Track
Complex
RJI Filed
11/15/2021
NOI Due
02/16/2023
NOI Filed
Calendar Number
—
Jury Status
Justice
Capella, Hon. Joseph E.
Next Appearance
01/04/2022
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
GASKIN, MELISSA et al
Attorney / FirmDUFFY & DUFFY, PLLC
Defendant / Respondent
MORNINGSIDE ACQUISITION I, LLC, d/b/a MORNINGSIDE NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTER
Attorneys / FirmsGOLDBERG SEGALLA LLP
Motions (1)
#Date FiledFiled ByRelief SoughtSubmit DateAnswerStatusDecisionOrder Signed
112/03/2021Change Venue01/04/2022NoDecided: 01/26/2022 Granted Before Justice: Capella, Hon. Joseph E.Short Form Order01/26/2022
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (79)
Doc #Date FiledDocumentDescriptionMotion #Filing UserFile
108/16/2021SUMMONS + COMPLAINTSUMMONS AND COMPLAINT W/VERIFICATION PAGEDamien Smithpdf
310/22/2021STIPULATION - OTHER - ( REQUEST TO SO ORDER )STIPULATION TO AMEND CAPTIONDamien Smith
411/03/2021AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEMORNINGSIDE NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTERMichael E Duffy
511/03/2021AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEMORNINGSIDE ACQUISITION I, LLCMichael E Duffy
611/03/2021STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILINGMichael E Duffy
1211/10/2021AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEMORNINGSIDE ACQUISITION I, LLCMichael E Duffy
1311/12/2021RJI FROM PRIOR COUNTY (COPY)RJI WITH STIPULATION TO AMEND CAPTION AND COMPLAINT; Original document type was RJI -RE: OTHERDamien Smith
1411/12/2021ADDENDUM - GENERAL (840A)Damien Smith
1511/17/2021DEMAND FOR CHANGE OF PLACE OF TRIALDemand to Change VenueEdward Vincent Schwendemann
1611/17/2021ANSWERDefendant's Verified AnswerEdward Vincent Schwendemannpdf
32Westchester Supreme Court201967819/2019Disposed-Court Date/Application PendingMedical MalpracticeMartinez, HazelBORNSTEIN & EMANUEL, P.C.Morningside Nursing and Rehabilitation Center et alKaufman Borgeest & Ryan LLP06/26/2026▼
Case Info
Court
Westchester Supreme Court
Index Number
67819/2019
Status
Disposed-Court Date/Application Pending
Year Filed
2019
Case Name
Martinez, Hazel vs. Morningside Nursing and Rehabilitation Center et al
Case Type
Tort-Other Professional Malpractice
Track
Standard
RJI Filed
10/18/2019
NOI Due
10/17/2020
NOI Filed
11/05/2024
Calendar Number
—
Jury Status
Jury At Plaintiff's Request
Justice
Next Appearance
06/26/2026
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
Martinez, Hazel
Attorney / FirmBORNSTEIN & EMANUEL, P.C.
Defendant / Respondent
Morningside Nursing and Rehabilitation Center et al
Attorneys / FirmsKaufman Borgeest & Ryan LLP
Motions (4)
#Date FiledFiled ByRelief SoughtSubmit DateAnswerStatusDecisionOrder Signed
402/03/2025Judgment - Summary04/04/2025NoDecided: 04/29/2025 Granted Before Justice: D'Alessio, Hon. Christie LynneLong Form Order
308/19/2021Consolidate10/06/2021NoDecided: 12/30/2021 Granted Before Justice: Walker, Hon. Sam D.Memorandum
207/01/2021Consolidate10/06/2021NoDecided: 12/30/2021 Granted Before Justice: Walker, Hon. Sam D.Memorandum
110/30/2019Change Venue12/04/2019YesDecided: 03/30/2020 Granted Before Justice: Walker, Hon. Sam D.Memorandum
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (160)
Doc #Date FiledDocumentDescriptionMotion #Filing UserFile
110/18/2019SUMMONS + COMPLAINTOriginal Summons + Complaint filed in Bronx CountyChristine A Stea Turianopdf
210/18/2019NOTICE OF MOTIONNotice of Motion to Change Venue to Westchester1Christine A Stea Turianopdf
310/18/2019AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTIONAff in Support of Motion to Change VenueChristine A Stea Turiano
410/18/2019EXHIBIT(S)Ex. A ComplaintChristine A Stea Turiano
510/18/2019EXHIBIT(S)Defendant AnswersChristine A Stea Turiano
610/18/2019EXHIBIT(S)Ex. C Admission AgreementChristine A Stea Turiano
710/18/2019AFFIDAVITAff of Service of Motion to Change VenueChristine A Stea Turiano
810/18/2019RJI -RE: NOTICE OF MOTIONRJIChristine A Stea Turianopdf
911/05/2019STIPULATION - ADJOURNMENT OF MOTION1Kenneth Bornstein
1011/15/2019AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION1Kenneth Bornstein
33Bronx Supreme Court201922483/2019E (0022483/2019)DisposedMedical MalpracticeTORRES, CARMENSinel & Olesen, PLLCMOUNT SINAI HEALTH SYSTEM,LAW OFFICE OF CHARLES SIEGEL12/03/2025Gerez, Hon. Alicia▼
Case Info
Court
Bronx Supreme Court
Index Number
22483/2019E (0022483/2019)
Status
Disposed
Year Filed
2019
Case Name
TORRES, CARMEN vs. MOUNT SINAI HEALTH SYSTEM,
Case Type
Tort-Medical, Dental, or Podiatric Malpractice
Track
Complex
RJI Filed
10/02/2019
NOI Due
09/30/2022
NOI Filed
09/19/2022
Calendar Number
2022-02007
Jury Status
Jury At Plaintiff's Request
Justice
Gerez, Hon. Alicia
Next Appearance
12/03/2025
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
TORRES, CARMEN
Attorney / FirmSinel & Olesen, PLLC
Defendant / Respondent
MOUNT SINAI HEALTH SYSTEM,
Attorneys / FirmsLAW OFFICE OF CHARLES SIEGEL
Motions (2)
#Date FiledFiled ByRelief SoughtSubmit DateAnswerStatusDecisionOrder Signed
202/12/2020Change Venue03/12/2020NoDecided: 07/01/2020 Denied Before Justice: Capella, Hon. Joseph E.Memorandum07/01/2020
110/02/2019Extend - Time10/23/2019NoDecided: 12/10/2019 Granted Before Justice: Capella, Hon. Joseph E.Short Form Order12/10/2019
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (50)
Doc #Date FiledDocumentDescriptionMotion #Filing UserFile
102/28/2019SUMMONS + COMPLAINT+ Certificate of MeritElliot B Sinelpdf
205/31/2019AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEAffidavit of Service for Morningside Nursing and Rehabilitation CenterElliot B Sinel
306/07/2019AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEAffidavit of Service for Mount Sinai Health SystemElliot B Sinel
406/18/2019AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEAffidavit of Service for Mount Sinai St.Luke'sElliot B Sinel
506/25/2019ANSWERAnswer for Mt. Sinai and St. Luke'sRichard Ngpdf
606/25/2019ANSWERCathy Ann Gallagherpdf
706/25/2019DEMAND FOR BILL OF PARTICULARSCathy Ann Gallagher
806/25/2019DEMAND FOR:Combined DemandsCathy Ann Gallagher
906/27/2019AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEAffidavit of Service for Mount Sinai Health System, Inc.Elliot B Sinel
1006/27/2019AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEAffidavit of Service for Morningside House Nursing Home CompanyElliot B Sinel
34Bronx Supreme Court201927974/2019E (0027974/2019)DisposedMedical MalpracticeVASQUEZ, ARELISSinel & Olesen, PLLCMORNINGSIDE ACQUISITION I, LLCMORNINGSIDE NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTER09/09/2020Capella, Hon. Joseph E.▼
Case Info
Court
Bronx Supreme Court
Index Number
27974/2019E (0027974/2019)
Status
Disposed
Year Filed
2019
Case Name
VASQUEZ, ARELIS vs. MORNINGSIDE ACQUISITION I, LLC
Case Type
Tort-Medical, Dental, or Podiatric Malpractice
Track
Complex
RJI Filed
11/04/2019
NOI Due
02/04/2021
NOI Filed
Calendar Number
—
Jury Status
Justice
Capella, Hon. Joseph E.
Next Appearance
09/09/2020
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
VASQUEZ, ARELIS
Attorney / FirmSinel & Olesen, PLLC
Defendant / Respondent
MORNINGSIDE ACQUISITION I, LLC
Attorneys / FirmsMORNINGSIDE NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTER
Motions (1)
#Date FiledFiled ByRelief SoughtSubmit DateAnswerStatusDecisionOrder Signed
111/04/2019Consolidate01/21/2020NoDecided: 01/21/2020 Denied Before Justice: Capella, Hon. Joseph E.Short Form Order01/21/2020
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (14)
Doc #Date FiledDocumentDescriptionMotion #Filing UserFile
107/11/2019SUMMONS + COMPLAINTElliot B Sinelpdf
208/09/2019AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEAffidavit of Service for Morningside Acquisition I, LLCElliot B Sinel
308/09/2019AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEAffidavit of Service for Morningside Nursing and Rehabilitation CenterElliot B Sinel
408/09/2019AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEAffidavit of Service for Morningside Acquisition I, LLCElliot B Sinel
508/28/2019ANSWERKathryn Marie Sullivanpdf
608/28/2019NOTICE OF DEPOSITION UPON ORAL EXAMINATIONKathryn Marie Sullivan
711/04/2019NOTICE OF MOTIONNotice of Motion001Elliot B Sinelpdf
811/04/2019AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTIONAffirmation in Support001Elliot B Sinel
911/04/2019EXHIBIT(S)Pleadings for Index No.: 34568/2018E001Elliot B Sinel
1011/04/2019EXHIBIT(S)Pleadings for Index No.: 27974/2019E001Elliot B Sinel
35Bronx Supreme Court201929138/2019E (0029138/2019)DisposedSP-OtherPADILLA, MILAGROSHarris, Keenan & Goldfarb PLLCMORNINGSIDE NURSING &Kaufman Borgeest & Ryan LLP03/02/2020Rosado, Hon. Llinet M.▼
Case Info
Court
Bronx Supreme Court
Index Number
29138/2019E (0029138/2019)
Status
Disposed
Year Filed
2019
Case Name
PADILLA, MILAGROS vs. MORNINGSIDE NURSING &
Case Type
SP-Other
Track
Standard
RJI Filed
08/06/2019
NOI Due
08/05/2020
NOI Filed
Calendar Number
—
Jury Status
Justice
Rosado, Hon. Llinet M.
Next Appearance
03/02/2020
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
PADILLA, MILAGROS
Attorney / FirmHarris, Keenan & Goldfarb PLLC
Defendant / Respondent
MORNINGSIDE NURSING &
Attorneys / FirmsKaufman Borgeest & Ryan LLP
Motions (3)
#Date FiledFiled ByRelief SoughtSubmit DateAnswerStatusDecisionOrder Signed
302/11/2020Compel03/02/2020NoDecided: 03/02/2020 Decided Before Justice: Franco, Hon. RubenShort Form Order03/02/2020
208/14/2019Other12/09/2019NoDecided: 12/09/2019 Denied Before Justice: Franco, Hon. RubenShort Form Order12/09/2019
108/14/2019Other11/12/2019NoDecided: 11/12/2019 Decided Before Justice: Mills, Hon. Donna M.11/15/2019
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (30)
Doc #Date FiledDocumentDescriptionMotion #Filing UserFile
108/06/2019PETITIONPetitionSeth A Harris
208/06/2019ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE ( PROPOSED )Order to Show Cause001Seth A Harrispdf
308/06/2019AFFIDAVITPlaintiff's AffidavitSeth A Harris
408/06/2019AFFIRMATION OF GOOD FAITHAffirmation of Good FaithSeth A Harris
508/06/2019EXHIBIT(S)Ex A - Order Appointing Guardian Ad LitemSeth A Harris
608/06/2019EXHIBIT(S)Ex B - letter 5.6.19Seth A Harris
708/06/2019EXHIBIT(S)Ex C - Letters 5.22.19 and 6.3.19Seth A Harris
808/06/2019EXHIBIT(S)Ex - D - letter dated 6.12.19Seth A Harris
908/06/2019RJI -RE: ORDER TO SHOW CAUSESeth A Harrispdf
1008/14/2019PETITION (AMENDED)Amended PetitionSeth A Harris
36Bronx Supreme Court201933019/2018E (0033019/2018)ActiveMedical MalpracticeHARRISON, DONALD RAYThe Fink Law Firm, P.C.MORNINGSIDE NURSING ANDDOUGLAS AND LONDON, P.C.05/04/2026Capella, Hon. Joseph E.▼
Case Info
Court
Bronx Supreme Court
Index Number
33019/2018E (0033019/2018)
Status
Active
Year Filed
2019
Case Name
HARRISON, DONALD RAY vs. MORNINGSIDE NURSING AND
Case Type
Tort-Medical, Dental, or Podiatric Malpractice
Track
Complex
RJI Filed
05/07/2019
NOI Due
06/28/2024
NOI Filed
05/17/2024
Calendar Number
2024-01387
Jury Status
Jury At Plaintiff's Request
Justice
Capella, Hon. Joseph E.
Next Appearance
05/04/2026
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
HARRISON, DONALD RAY
Attorney / FirmThe Fink Law Firm, P.C.
Defendant / Respondent
MORNINGSIDE NURSING AND
Attorneys / FirmsDOUGLAS AND LONDON, P.C.
Motions (1)
#Date FiledFiled ByRelief SoughtSubmit DateAnswerStatusDecisionOrder Signed
110/18/2022Strike Pleadings11/18/2022NoDecided: 11/18/2022 Withdrawn Before Justice: Capella, Hon. Joseph E.Short Form Order11/18/2022
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (47)
Doc #Date FiledDocumentDescriptionMotion #Filing UserFile
111/14/2018SUMMONS + COMPLAINTSteven Mitchell Finkpdf
211/26/2018AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEaos all defsSteven Mitchell Fink
302/12/2019ANSWERAndrew Thomas Sheeleypdf
402/12/2019DEMAND FOR BILL OF PARTICULARSDemand for Verified Bill of ParticularsAndrew Thomas Sheeley
502/12/2019DEMAND FOR:Combined Discovery DemandsAndrew Thomas Sheeley
605/07/2019NOTICE OF CHANGE OF FIRM NAME OR ADDRESS (PRE RJI)Notice of Change of Firm Name and AddressAndrew Thomas Sheeley
705/07/2019NOTICE OF MEDICAL MALPRACTICEnotice of medical malpractice and AOSSteven Mitchell Fink
805/07/2019EXHIBIT(S)S&CSteven Mitchell Fink
905/07/2019EXHIBIT(S)bpSteven Mitchell Fink
1005/07/2019EXHIBIT(S)medical exchange redactedSteven Mitchell Fink
37Bronx Supreme Court201831406/2017E (0031406/2017)Disposed-Consolidated IntoMedical MalpracticeSAMTULA, MARIERODMAN AND CAMPBELL PCMORNINGSIDE NURSINGNewfield, Biondo & Carlino LLC09/24/2018McKeon, Hon. Douglas E.▼
Case Info
Court
Bronx Supreme Court
Index Number
31406/2017E (0031406/2017)
Status
Disposed-Consolidated Into
Year Filed
2018
Case Name
SAMTULA, MARIE vs. MORNINGSIDE NURSING
Case Type
Tort-Medical, Dental, or Podiatric Malpractice
Track
Complex
RJI Filed
03/09/2018
NOI Due
06/10/2019
NOI Filed
Calendar Number
—
Jury Status
Justice
McKeon, Hon. Douglas E.
Next Appearance
09/24/2018
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
SAMTULA, MARIE
Attorney / FirmRODMAN AND CAMPBELL PC
Defendant / Respondent
MORNINGSIDE NURSING
Attorneys / FirmsNewfield, Biondo & Carlino LLC
Motions (1)
#Date FiledFiled ByRelief SoughtSubmit DateAnswerStatusDecisionOrder Signed
103/12/2018Change Venue07/11/2018NoDecided: 08/09/2018 Denied Before Justice: McKeon, Hon. Douglas E.Memorandum08/09/2018
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (75)
Doc #Date FiledDocumentDescriptionMotion #Filing UserFile
111/29/2017SUMMONS + COMPLAINTHugh W. Campbellpdf
212/20/2017AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEMorningside Acquisition 1, LLCHugh W. Campbell
312/20/2017AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEVNSHugh W. Campbell
401/11/2018ANSWERCharmagne A Paduapdf
501/11/2018DEMAND FOR BILL OF PARTICULARSCharmagne A Padua
601/11/2018DEMAND FOR:Charmagne A Padua
701/11/2018NOTICE OF DEPOSITION UPON ORAL EXAMINATIONCharmagne A Padua
801/11/2018AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICECharmagne A Padua
901/18/2018ANSWERMichael Eric Gallaypdf
1001/18/2018DEMAND FOR BILL OF PARTICULARSMichael Eric Gallay
38Bronx Supreme Court201723003/2017E (0023003/2017)ActiveMedical MalpracticeSAMTULA, MARIERODMAN AND CAMPBELL PCNEW YORK CITY HEALTH ANDNEW YORK CITY HEALTH & HOSPITALS CORP.05/05/2026Gerez, Hon. Alicia▼
Case Info
Court
Bronx Supreme Court
Index Number
23003/2017E (0023003/2017)
Status
Active
Year Filed
2017
Case Name
SAMTULA, MARIE vs. NEW YORK CITY HEALTH AND
Case Type
Tort-Medical, Dental, or Podiatric Malpractice
Track
Complex
RJI Filed
05/03/2017
NOI Due
08/04/2018
NOI Filed
Calendar Number
—
Jury Status
Justice
Gerez, Hon. Alicia
Next Appearance
05/05/2026
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
SAMTULA, MARIE
Attorney / FirmRODMAN AND CAMPBELL PC
Defendant / Respondent
NEW YORK CITY HEALTH AND
Attorneys / FirmsNEW YORK CITY HEALTH & HOSPITALS CORP.
Motions (2)
#Date FiledFiled ByRelief SoughtSubmit DateAnswerStatusDecisionOrder Signed
205/08/2018Consolidate07/11/2018NoDecided: 08/09/2018 Granted Before Justice: Silver, Hon. George J.Memorandum08/09/2018
105/03/2017Amend Caption/Pleadings06/06/2017NoDecided: 07/19/2017 Granted Before Justice: Danziger, Hon. Mitchell J.Short Form Order07/19/2017
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (76)
Doc #Date FiledDocumentDescriptionMotion #Filing UserFile
104/13/2017SUMMONS + COMPLAINTHugh W. Campbellpdf
205/03/2017NOTICE OF MOTION001Hugh W. Campbellpdf
305/03/2017AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION001Hugh W. Campbell
405/03/2017EXHIBIT(S)Notice of Claim001Hugh W. Campbell
505/03/2017EXHIBIT(S)Amended Notice of Claim001Hugh W. Campbell
605/03/2017EXHIBIT(S)Summons and Complaint001Hugh W. Campbell
705/03/2017EXHIBIT(S)Death Certificate001Hugh W. Campbell
805/03/2017EXHIBIT(S)Letters of Administration001Hugh W. Campbell
905/03/2017AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE001Hugh W. Campbell
1005/03/2017RJI -RE: NOTICE OF MOTION001Hugh W. Campbellpdf
39Bronx Supreme Court201726788/2016E (0026788/2016)DisposedNegligenceFERGUSON, JAMESMORELLI LAW FIRM, PLLC.MORNINGSIDE HOUSE NURSING HOMEMORNINGSIDE HOUSE NURSING HOME11/23/2020Guzman, Hon. Wilma▼
Case Info
Court
Bronx Supreme Court
Index Number
26788/2016E (0026788/2016)
Status
Disposed
Year Filed
2017
Case Name
FERGUSON, JAMES vs. MORNINGSIDE HOUSE NURSING HOME
Case Type
Tort-Other Negligence
Track
Standard
RJI Filed
07/18/2017
NOI Due
07/18/2018
NOI Filed
Calendar Number
—
Jury Status
Justice
Guzman, Hon. Wilma
Next Appearance
11/23/2020
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
FERGUSON, JAMES
Attorney / FirmMORELLI LAW FIRM, PLLC.
Defendant / Respondent
MORNINGSIDE HOUSE NURSING HOME
Attorneys / FirmsMORNINGSIDE HOUSE NURSING HOME
Motions
No motions recorded for this case.
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (27)
Doc #Date FiledDocumentDescriptionMotion #Filing UserFile
110/05/2016SUMMONS + COMPLAINTSara Ann Mahoneypdf
210/12/2016AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICESara Ann Mahoney
310/12/2016AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICESara Ann Mahoney
410/12/2016AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICESara Ann Mahoney
510/12/2016STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILINGSara Ann Mahoney
610/17/2016AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICESara Ann Mahoney
711/17/2016AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICESara Ann Mahoney
811/17/2016STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILINGSara Ann Mahoney
912/05/2016ANSWERLori Rosen Semliespdf
1012/05/2016DEMAND FOR:Combined DemandsLori Rosen Semlies
40Bronx Supreme Court201626947/2015E (0026947/2015)DisposedNegligenceSANTIAGO, SONIAMORGAN & MORGAN NEW YORK, PLLCMORNINGSIDE NURSINGNorthwell Health03/30/2023Thompson, Hon. Kenneth▼
Case Info
Court
Bronx Supreme Court
Index Number
26947/2015E (0026947/2015)
Status
Disposed
Year Filed
2016
Case Name
SANTIAGO, SONIA vs. MORNINGSIDE NURSING
Case Type
Tort-Other Negligence
Track
Standard
RJI Filed
05/13/2016
NOI Due
05/13/2017
NOI Filed
Calendar Number
—
Jury Status
Justice
Thompson, Hon. Kenneth
Next Appearance
03/30/2023
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
SANTIAGO, SONIA
Attorney / FirmMORGAN & MORGAN NEW YORK, PLLC
Defendant / Respondent
MORNINGSIDE NURSING
Attorneys / FirmsNorthwell Health
Motions (3)
#Date FiledFiled ByRelief SoughtSubmit DateAnswerStatusDecisionOrder Signed
304/02/2019Strike Pleadings06/06/2019NoDecided: 06/06/2019 Granted Before Justice: Douglas, Hon. Laura G.Short Form Order06/06/2019
210/23/2017Change Venue11/17/2017NoDecided: 01/02/2018 Denied Before Justice: Tapia, Hon. FernandoShort Form Order01/02/2018
105/13/2016Dismiss06/03/2016NoDecided: 12/14/2016 Granted Before Justice: Tapia, Hon. FernandoShort Form Order12/14/2016
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (101)
Doc #Date FiledDocumentDescriptionMotion #Filing UserFile
112/18/2015SUMMONS + COMPLAINTSummons, Complaint & Attorney VerificationJames G. Kapralospdf
204/07/2016STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILINGFred Robert Rosenthal
304/07/2016AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEFred Robert Rosenthal
404/07/2016AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEFred Robert Rosenthal
504/08/2016STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILINGFred Robert Rosenthal
604/08/2016AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEFred Robert Rosenthal
704/08/2016AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEFred Robert Rosenthal
804/08/2016AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEFred Robert Rosenthal
904/08/2016AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEFred Robert Rosenthal
1005/13/2016NOTICE OF MOTION001Randi Kim Lehrmanpdf
41Westchester Supreme Court201552430/2016DisposedMedical MalpracticeFORD, BRIGGETTDAVID GROSSMAN & ASSOC. PLLCMORNINGSIDE NURSING ANDKaufman Borgeest & Ryan LLP09/27/2019▼
Case Info
Court
Westchester Supreme Court
Index Number
52430/2016
Status
Disposed
Year Filed
2015
Case Name
FORD, BRIGGETT vs. MORNINGSIDE NURSING AND
Case Type
Tort-Medical, Dental, or Podiatric Malpractice
Track
Complex
RJI Filed
10/12/2015
NOI Due
01/12/2017
NOI Filed
09/15/2017
Calendar Number
—
Jury Status
Jury At Plaintiff's Request
Justice
Next Appearance
09/27/2019
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
FORD, BRIGGETT
Attorney / FirmDAVID GROSSMAN & ASSOC. PLLC
Defendant / Respondent
MORNINGSIDE NURSING AND
Attorneys / FirmsKaufman Borgeest & Ryan LLP
Motions (16)
#Date FiledFiled ByRelief SoughtSubmit DateAnswerStatusDecisionOrder Signed
1101/09/2019Compel Arbitration02/15/2019NoDecided: 02/15/2019 Interim Decision Before Justice: Colabella, Hon. NicholasOral
1101/09/2019Compel Arbitration02/15/2019NoDecided: 05/20/2019 Decided Before Justice: Walker, Hon. Sam D.Memorandum
1001/04/2019Judgment - Declaratory02/15/2019NoDecided: 02/15/2019 Interim Decision Before Justice: Colabella, Hon. NicholasOral
1001/04/2019Judgment - Declaratory02/15/2019NoDecided: 05/20/2019 Decided Before Justice: Walker, Hon. Sam D.Memorandum
912/31/2018Judgment - Declaratory01/03/2019NoDecided: 01/03/2019 Denied Before Justice: Colabella, Hon. NicholasShort Form Order
811/26/2018Sanctions02/15/2019NoDecided: 02/15/2019 Interim Decision Before Justice: Colabella, Hon. NicholasOral
811/26/2018Sanctions02/15/2019NoDecided: 02/15/2019 Denied Before Justice: Walker, Hon. Sam D.Oral
711/06/2018Attorney - Disqualify/Relieve/Substitute/Withdraw11/29/2018NoDecided: 02/15/2019 Interim Decision Before Justice: Colabella, Hon. NicholasOral
711/06/2018Attorney - Disqualify/Relieve/Substitute/Withdraw11/29/2018NoDecided: 11/29/2018 Interim Decision Before Justice: Colabella, Hon. NicholasOral
711/06/2018Attorney - Disqualify/Relieve/Substitute/Withdraw11/29/2018NoDecided: 02/15/2019 Granted Before Justice: Walker, Hon. Sam D.Oral
610/30/2017Judgment - Summary02/14/2018YesDecided: 06/25/2018 Denied Before Justice: Giacomo, Hon. William J.Long Form Order06/25/2018
508/28/2017Sanctions10/23/2017NoDecided: 01/22/2018 Denied Before Justice: Giacomo, Hon. William J.Long Form Order01/22/2018
408/02/2017Judgment - Summary09/18/2017NoDecided: 01/22/2018 Denied Before Justice: Giacomo, Hon. William J.Long Form Order01/22/2018
305/19/2017DEFENDANTJudgment - Summary09/18/2017NoDecided: 01/22/2018 Denied Before Justice: Giacomo, Hon. William J.Long Form Order01/22/2018
204/05/2017PLAINTIFFVacate/Strike - Note of Issue/Jury Demand/From Trial Calendar05/15/2017NoDecided: 08/07/2017 Decided Before Justice: Lefkowitz, Hon. Joan B.Long Form Order
102/23/2017PLAINTIFFProtective Order03/21/2017NoDecided: 03/21/2017 Withdrawn Before Justice: Compliance Part,Oral
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (382)
Doc #Date FiledDocumentDescriptionMotion #Filing UserFile
102/06/2015SUMMONS WITH NOTICESummons with Notice FordSheryl Rose Menkespdf
207/14/2015COMPLAINTVerified ComplaintSheryl Rose Menkespdf
307/14/2015AFFIDAVITAffidavit of ServiceSheryl Rose Menkes
407/31/2015ANSWEREricka Fangpdf
509/28/2015DEMAND FOR CHANGE OF PLACE OF TRIALNotice to Change VenueEricka Fang
609/29/2015AFFIRMATIONAff in opp to DEF's change of venue demandSheryl Rose Menkes
709/29/2015EXHIBIT(S)Defendant's AnswerSheryl Rose Menkes
810/12/2015NOTICE OF MOTIONMotion to Change Venue001BEricka Fangpdf
910/12/2015EXHIBIT(S)Exhibit A001BEricka Fang
1010/12/2015EXHIBIT(S)Exhibit B001BEricka Fang
42Bronx Supreme Court201522011/2015E (0022011/2015)DisposedMedical MalpracticeSANTIAGO, SONIAMORGAN & MORGAN NEW YORK, PLLCMORNINGSIDE NURSING ANDKaufman Borgeest & Ryan LLP09/24/2015Green, Hon. Stanley▼
Case Info
Court
Bronx Supreme Court
Index Number
22011/2015E (0022011/2015)
Status
Disposed
Year Filed
2015
Case Name
SANTIAGO, SONIA vs. MORNINGSIDE NURSING AND
Case Type
Tort-Medical, Dental, or Podiatric Malpractice
Track
Complex
RJI Filed
08/06/2015
NOI Due
11/06/2016
NOI Filed
Calendar Number
—
Jury Status
Justice
Green, Hon. Stanley
Next Appearance
09/24/2015
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
SANTIAGO, SONIA
Attorney / FirmMORGAN & MORGAN NEW YORK, PLLC
Defendant / Respondent
MORNINGSIDE NURSING AND
Attorneys / FirmsKaufman Borgeest & Ryan LLP
Motions (1)
#Date FiledFiled ByRelief SoughtSubmit DateAnswerStatusDecisionOrder Signed
108/06/2015Dismiss09/24/2015NoDecided: 10/02/2015 Decided Before Justice: Green, Hon. StanleyShort Form Order10/02/2015
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (37)
Doc #Date FiledDocumentDescriptionMotion #Filing UserFile
104/10/2015SUMMONS + COMPLAINTSummons, Complaint and Attorney VerificationJames G. Kapralospdf
208/03/2015SUMMONS (PRE RJI) (AMENDED)Amended Summons and ComplaintJames G. Kapralospdf
308/04/2015STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILINGFred Robert Rosenthal
408/04/2015PROOF OF SERVICEFred Robert Rosenthal
508/04/2015PROOF OF SERVICEFred Robert Rosenthal
608/06/2015RJI -RE: NOTICE OF MOTIONNeed Judge AssignedJacqueline Mandellpdf
708/06/2015NOTICE OF MOTIONTo Dismiss Plaintiff's Complaint001Jacqueline Mandellpdf
808/06/2015AFFIRMATIONIn Support of Motion001Jacqueline Mandell
908/06/2015EXHIBIT(S)Summons with Notice001Jacqueline Mandell
1008/06/2015STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILINGFred Robert Rosenthal
43Bronx Supreme Court201524932/2014E (0024932/2014)DisposedOM-OtherNEMBHARD, ERROLMORNINGSIDE HOUSE NURSINGMorningside Nursing and Rehabilitation Center09/23/2019Gonzalez, Hon. Lizbeth▼
Case Info
Court
Bronx Supreme Court
Index Number
24932/2014E (0024932/2014)
Status
Disposed
Year Filed
2015
Case Name
NEMBHARD, ERROL vs. MORNINGSIDE HOUSE NURSING
Case Type
OM-Other
Track
Standard
RJI Filed
02/04/2015
NOI Due
02/04/2016
NOI Filed
Calendar Number
—
Jury Status
Justice
Gonzalez, Hon. Lizbeth
Next Appearance
09/23/2019
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
NEMBHARD, ERROL
Attorney / Firm
Defendant / Respondent
MORNINGSIDE HOUSE NURSING
Attorneys / FirmsMorningside Nursing and Rehabilitation Center
Motions (2)
#Date FiledFiled ByRelief SoughtSubmit DateAnswerStatusDecisionOrder Signed
203/04/2015Dismiss02/26/2016NoDecided: 10/03/2016 Denied Before Justice: Johnson, Hon. Robert T.Memorandum10/03/2016
102/04/2015Extend - Time02/23/2015NoDecided: 02/23/2015 Granted Before Justice: Gonzalez, Hon. LizbethShort Form Order02/23/2015
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (34)
Doc #Date FiledDocumentDescriptionMotion #Filing UserFile
110/21/2014SUMMONS + COMPLAINTGareth W Stewartpdf
210/31/2014PROOF OF SERVICEGareth W Stewart
311/13/2014STIPULATION - OTHERStipulation Extending Time to Respond to ComplaintBarbara E. Hoey
401/05/2015STIPULATION - OTHERStipulation extending time to respond to complaint to February 9, 2015Barbara E. Hoey
501/15/2015SUMMONS (PRE RJI) (AMENDED)Summons amended as to caption (defendants added)Gareth W Stewartpdf
601/15/2015COMPLAINT (AMENDED)Complaint amended as to caption (defendants added)Gareth W Stewartpdf
702/04/2015ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE ( PROPOSED )001Celena R Mayopdf
802/04/2015AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF PROPOSED OSC/EXPARTE APP001Celena R Mayo
902/04/2015EXHIBIT(S)Summons & Complaint.001Celena R Mayo
1002/04/2015EXHIBIT(S)Various Email Correspondence001Celena R Mayo