Lawsuit Summary

Total Cases
18
Active Cases
4
4 active
Stayed / Paused
1
1 Stayed
Closed
13
13 Disposed
Since
2008
Most Recent
2025
Next Court Date
Apr 28, 2026
This facility is currently involved in 4 active lawsuits.

Cases

18 cases · Click to expand details (25 from 2010 – present; older years: list only)
#CourtYearIndex NumberStatusCase TypePlaintiff / PetitionerPlaintiff FirmDefendant / RespondentDefendant FirmAppearanceJustice
1Erie Supreme Court2025808560/2024ActiveNegligenceSIMPSON, BONNIEANDREWS, BERNSTEIN & MARANTO, PLLCOUR LADY OF PEACE NURSING CARE RESIDENCE et alSTILLWELL VISCO06/18/2026Greenan III, Hon. Gerald J.
Case Info
Court
Erie Supreme Court
Index Number
808560/2024
Status
Active
Year Filed
2025
Case Name
SIMPSON, BONNIE vs. OUR LADY OF PEACE NURSING CARE RESIDENCE et al
Case Type
Tort-Other Negligence
Track
Standard
RJI Filed
03/20/2025
NOI Due
03/20/2026
NOI Filed
Calendar Number
Jury Status
Justice
Greenan III, Hon. Gerald J.
Next Appearance
06/18/2026
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
SIMPSON, BONNIE
Attorney / FirmANDREWS, BERNSTEIN & MARANTO, PLLC
Defendant / Respondent
OUR LADY OF PEACE NURSING CARE RESIDENCE et al
Attorneys / FirmsSTILLWELL VISCO
Motions (2)
#Date FiledFiled ByRelief SoughtSubmit DateAnswerStatusDecisionOrder Signed
211/14/2025Compel04/22/2026NoDecided: 04/22/2026 Marked Off Before Justice: Greenan III, Hon. Gerald J.
103/20/2025Discovery04/22/2025NoDecided: 04/22/2025 Withdrawn Before Justice: Greenan III, Hon. Gerald J.
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (24)
Doc #Date FiledDocumentDescriptionMotion #Filing UserFile
106/12/2024SUMMONS + COMPLAINTThomas P. Kotrys
207/19/2024ANSWERJohn Michael Visco
307/19/2024NOTICE OF DEPOSITIONJohn Michael Visco
408/05/2024AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEThomas P. Kotrys
508/05/2024AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEThomas P. Kotrys
608/05/2024AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEThomas P. Kotrys
708/05/2024AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEThomas P. Kotrys
803/20/2025NOTICE OF MOTION001John Michael Visco
903/20/2025AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION001John Michael Visco
1003/20/2025EXHIBIT(S)S&C001John Michael Visco
2Niagara Supreme Court2024E182200/2024ActiveTortTHE ESTATE OF PATRICIA C. ROSSNapoli Shkolnik, PLLCOUR LADY OF PEACE NURSING CARE RESIDENCE et alABC CORPORATION05/27/2026CARUSO, Hon. FRANK
Case Info
Court
Niagara Supreme Court
Index Number
E182200/2024
Status
Active
Year Filed
2024
Case Name
THE ESTATE OF PATRICIA C. ROSS vs. OUR LADY OF PEACE NURSING CARE RESIDENCE et al
Case Type
Tort-Other
Track
Standard
RJI Filed
04/29/2024
NOI Due
04/29/2025
NOI Filed
Calendar Number
Jury Status
Justice
CARUSO, Hon. FRANK
Next Appearance
05/27/2026
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
THE ESTATE OF PATRICIA C. ROSS
Attorney / FirmNapoli Shkolnik, PLLC
Defendant / Respondent
OUR LADY OF PEACE NURSING CARE RESIDENCE et al
Attorneys / FirmsABC CORPORATION
Motions (3)
#Date FiledFiled ByRelief SoughtSubmit DateAnswerStatusDecisionOrder Signed
311/19/2025Discovery12/11/2025NoDecided: 12/11/2025 Withdrawn Before Justice: CARUSO, Hon. FRANK
203/28/2025Dismiss05/21/2025NoDecided: 05/21/2025 Withdrawn Before Justice: CARUSO, Hon. FRANKSo-Ordered Stipulation05/21/2025
104/29/2024Dismiss12/05/2024NoDecided: 12/05/2024 Denied Before Justice: CARUSO, Hon. FRANKOral12/23/2024
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (42)
Doc #Date FiledDocumentDescriptionMotion #Filing UserFile
101/12/2024SUMMONS + COMPLAINTJoseph Leonard Ciaccio
204/11/2024AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEOUR LADY OF PEACE NURSING CARE RESIDENCEJoseph Leonard Ciaccio
304/11/2024STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILINGJoseph Leonard Ciaccio
404/18/2024ANSWERJohn Michael Visco
504/18/2024NOTICE OF DEPOSITIONJohn Michael Visco
604/29/2024NOTICE OF MOTION001John Michael Visco
704/29/2024AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION001John Michael Visco
804/29/2024EXHIBIT(S)S&C001John Michael Visco
904/29/2024RJI -RE: NOTICE OF MOTION001John Michael Visco
1004/29/2024ADDENDUM - GENERAL (840A)001John Michael Visco
3Erie Supreme Court2023810608/2022DisposedNegligencePACIFICO, LAWRENCE A.BROWN CHIARI LLPOUR LADY OF PEACE NURSING CARE RESIDENCE et alHUTCHESON, AFFRONTI & DEISINGER, P.C.03/12/2026Pace, Hon. Edward A.
Case Info
Court
Erie Supreme Court
Index Number
810608/2022
Status
Disposed
Year Filed
2023
Case Name
PACIFICO, LAWRENCE A. vs. OUR LADY OF PEACE NURSING CARE RESIDENCE et al
Case Type
Tort-Other Negligence
Track
Standard
RJI Filed
04/17/2023
NOI Due
04/16/2024
NOI Filed
Calendar Number
Jury Status
Justice
Pace, Hon. Edward A.
Next Appearance
03/12/2026
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
PACIFICO, LAWRENCE A.
Attorney / FirmBROWN CHIARI LLP
Defendant / Respondent
OUR LADY OF PEACE NURSING CARE RESIDENCE et al
Attorneys / FirmsHUTCHESON, AFFRONTI & DEISINGER, P.C.
Motions (2)
#Date FiledFiled ByRelief SoughtSubmit DateAnswerStatusDecisionOrder Signed
203/02/2026Compromise03/06/2026NoDecided: 03/06/2026 Granted Before Justice: Pace, Hon. Edward A.Long Form Order03/06/2026
107/17/2024Compel09/05/2024NoDecided: 09/05/2024 Withdrawn Before Justice: Pace, Hon. Edward A.Oral
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (24)
Doc #Date FiledDocumentDescriptionMotion #Filing UserFile
109/06/2022SUMMONS + COMPLAINTTheresa M Walsh
209/13/2022AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEOur Lady of Peace Inc.Angelo Salvatore Gambino
309/22/2022AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEAngelo Salvatore Gambino
410/05/2022ANSWERJohn Michael Visco
510/14/2022AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEAngelo Salvatore Gambino
610/14/2022AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEAngelo Salvatore Gambino
704/17/2023RJI -RE: REQUEST FOR PRELIMINARY CONFERENCEAngelo Salvatore Gambino
807/12/2024NOTICE OF MOTIONNOM001Adriana Rose Argento
907/12/2024AFFIRMATIONAtty Aff & word count001Adriana Rose Argento
1007/12/2024EXHIBIT(S)Ex A - S&C001Adriana Rose Argento
4Erie Supreme Court2023813762/2020StayedNegligenceCONSIGLIO, RUTHIE A.RICHMOND VONA LLCOUR LADY OF PEACE, INC. d/b/a OUR LADY OF PEACE NURSING CARE RESIDENCESTILLWELL VISCO05/04/2026Siragusa, Hon. Michael A.
Case Info
Court
Erie Supreme Court
Index Number
813762/2020
Status
Stayed
Year Filed
2023
Case Name
CONSIGLIO, RUTHIE A. vs. OUR LADY OF PEACE, INC. d/b/a OUR LADY OF PEACE NURSING CARE RESIDENCE
Case Type
Tort-Other Negligence
Track
Standard
RJI Filed
08/23/2023
NOI Due
NOI Filed
Calendar Number
Jury Status
Justice
Siragusa, Hon. Michael A.
Next Appearance
05/04/2026
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
CONSIGLIO, RUTHIE A.
Attorney / FirmRICHMOND VONA LLC
Defendant / Respondent
OUR LADY OF PEACE, INC. d/b/a OUR LADY OF PEACE NURSING CARE RESIDENCE
Attorneys / FirmsSTILLWELL VISCO
Motions
No motions recorded for this case.
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (7)
Doc #Date FiledDocumentDescriptionMotion #Filing UserFile
110/30/2020SUMMONS + COMPLAINTKristopher Anton Schwarzmueller
211/13/2020AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEKristopher Anton Schwarzmueller
312/17/2020ANSWERJohn Michael Visco
412/17/2020NOTICE OF DEPOSITIONJohn Michael Visco
508/23/2023RJI -RE: REQUEST FOR PRELIMINARY CONFERENCEKristopher Anton Schwarzmueller
608/23/2023ADDENDUM - GENERAL (840A)Kristopher Anton Schwarzmueller
701/02/2024CONSENT TO CHANGE ATTORNEY (POST RJI)Kristopher Anton Schwarzmueller
5Niagara Supreme Court2023E175620/2021DisposedNegligenceRODGERS, JIM A.BROWN CHIARI LLPOUR LADY OF PEACE NURSING CARE RESIDENCE et alSTILLWELL VISCO01/12/2024Sedita III, Hon. Frank A.
Case Info
Court
Niagara Supreme Court
Index Number
E175620/2021
Status
Disposed
Year Filed
2023
Case Name
RODGERS, JIM A. vs. OUR LADY OF PEACE NURSING CARE RESIDENCE et al
Case Type
Tort-Other Negligence
Track
Standard
RJI Filed
07/20/2023
NOI Due
05/30/2024
NOI Filed
Calendar Number
Jury Status
Justice
Sedita III, Hon. Frank A.
Next Appearance
01/12/2024
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
RODGERS, JIM A.
Attorney / FirmBROWN CHIARI LLP
Defendant / Respondent
OUR LADY OF PEACE NURSING CARE RESIDENCE et al
Attorneys / FirmsSTILLWELL VISCO
Motions
No motions recorded for this case.
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (13)
Doc #Date FiledDocumentDescriptionMotion #Filing UserFile
107/29/2021SUMMONS + COMPLAINTTheresa M Walsh
208/24/2021AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEOur Lady of Peace Nursing Care ResidenceDavid William Olson
308/24/2021AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEOur Lady of Peace, Inc.David William Olson
409/02/2021ANSWERJohn Michael Visco
509/02/2021NOTICE OF DEPOSITIONJohn Michael Visco
607/20/2023RJI -RE: REQUEST FOR PRELIMINARY CONFERENCEDavid William Olson
707/26/2023NOTICE OF PRELIMINARY CONFERENCECarol Thurnherr
807/27/2023STIPULATION - OTHER - ( REQUEST TO SO ORDER )David William Olson
908/04/2023STIPULATION - AMENDING CAPTIONCarol Thurnherr
1008/04/2023NOTICE TO COUNTY CLERK - AMENDMENT OF CAPTIONDavid William Olson
6Niagara Supreme Court2023E178372/2022DisposedNegligenceFURMAN, SHARONBROWN CHIARI LLPOUR LADY OF PEACE NURSING CARE RESIDENCE et alSTILLWELL VISCO03/19/2025Sedita III, Hon. Frank A.
Case Info
Court
Niagara Supreme Court
Index Number
E178372/2022
Status
Disposed
Year Filed
2023
Case Name
FURMAN, SHARON vs. OUR LADY OF PEACE NURSING CARE RESIDENCE et al
Case Type
Tort-Other Negligence
Track
Standard
RJI Filed
05/09/2023
NOI Due
05/02/2024
NOI Filed
05/03/2024
Calendar Number
Jury Status
Jury At Plaintiff's Request
Justice
Sedita III, Hon. Frank A.
Next Appearance
03/19/2025
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
FURMAN, SHARON
Attorney / FirmBROWN CHIARI LLP
Defendant / Respondent
OUR LADY OF PEACE NURSING CARE RESIDENCE et al
Attorneys / FirmsSTILLWELL VISCO
Motions (2)
#Date FiledFiled ByRelief SoughtSubmit DateAnswerStatusDecisionOrder Signed
211/20/2024Compromise12/04/2024NoDecided: 12/04/2024 Granted Before Justice: Sedita III, Hon. Frank A.Short Form Order12/04/2024
105/09/2023Discovery06/15/2023NoDecided: 06/15/2023 Withdrawn Before Justice: Sedita III, Hon. Frank A.Sua Sponte
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (34)
Doc #Date FiledDocumentDescriptionMotion #Filing UserFile
110/14/2022SUMMONS + COMPLAINTTheresa M Walsh
212/19/2022AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEOUR LADY OF PEACE NURSING CARE RESIDENCEBrian Robert Hogan
312/19/2022AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEOUR LADY OF PEACE, INC.Brian Robert Hogan
401/04/2023ANSWERJohn Michael Visco
501/06/2023AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEASCENSION LIVINGBrian Robert Hogan
601/06/2023AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEASCENSION HEALTH CARE NETWORK, INC.Brian Robert Hogan
1505/09/2023NOTICE OF MOTION1John Michael Visco
1605/09/2023AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION1John Michael Visco
1705/09/2023EXHIBIT(S)S&C1John Michael Visco
1805/09/2023EXHIBIT(S)Answer1John Michael Visco
7Niagara Supreme Court2023E178424/2022ActiveNegligenceDOMPKOWSKI, SANDRABROWN CHIARI LLPOUR LADY OF PEACE NURSING CARE RESIDENCE et alHUTCHESON, AFFRONTI & DEISINGER, P.C.04/28/2026CARUSO, Hon. FRANK
Case Info
Court
Niagara Supreme Court
Index Number
E178424/2022
Status
Active
Year Filed
2023
Case Name
DOMPKOWSKI, SANDRA vs. OUR LADY OF PEACE NURSING CARE RESIDENCE et al
Case Type
Tort-Other Negligence
Track
Standard
RJI Filed
05/09/2023
NOI Due
05/08/2024
NOI Filed
Calendar Number
Jury Status
Justice
CARUSO, Hon. FRANK
Next Appearance
04/28/2026
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
DOMPKOWSKI, SANDRA
Attorney / FirmBROWN CHIARI LLP
Defendant / Respondent
OUR LADY OF PEACE NURSING CARE RESIDENCE et al
Attorneys / FirmsHUTCHESON, AFFRONTI & DEISINGER, P.C.
Motions (3)
#Date FiledFiled ByRelief SoughtSubmit DateAnswerStatusDecisionOrder Signed
308/08/2025Discovery10/02/2025NoDecided: 10/02/2025 Granted to the Extent of the Order Before Justice: CARUSO, Hon. FRANKOral10/16/2025
207/30/2025Discovery08/19/2025NoDecided: 08/19/2025 Withdrawn Before Justice: CARUSO, Hon. FRANK
105/09/2023Dismiss06/06/2023NoDecided: 06/06/2023 Withdrawn Before Justice: CARUSO, Hon. FRANK
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (33)
Doc #Date FiledDocumentDescriptionMotion #Filing UserFile
110/24/2022SUMMONS + COMPLAINTTheresa M Walsh
202/24/2023AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEOur Lady of Peace, Inc.Theresa M Walsh
303/08/2023ANSWERJohn Michael Visco
403/08/2023NOTICE OF DEPOSITIONJohn Michael Visco
503/09/2023AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEOLP Nursing Care ResidenceTheresa M Walsh
603/09/2023AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEAscension LivingTheresa M Walsh
703/09/2023AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEAscension Health Care Network IncTheresa M Walsh
805/09/2023NOTICE OF MOTION1John Michael Visco
905/09/2023AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION1John Michael Visco
1005/09/2023EXHIBIT(S)Exhibit A - S&C1John Michael Visco
8Niagara Supreme Court2023E178446/2022DisposedNegligenceIRISH, DARLENEOUR LADY OF PEACE NURSING CARE RESIDENCE et alSTILLWELL VISCO12/10/2025Sedita III, Hon. Frank A.
Case Info
Court
Niagara Supreme Court
Index Number
E178446/2022
Status
Disposed
Year Filed
2023
Case Name
IRISH, DARLENE vs. OUR LADY OF PEACE NURSING CARE RESIDENCE et al
Case Type
Tort-Other Negligence
Track
Standard
RJI Filed
05/04/2023
NOI Due
05/02/2024
NOI Filed
01/06/2025
Calendar Number
25-005
Jury Status
Jury At Plaintiff's Request
Justice
Sedita III, Hon. Frank A.
Next Appearance
12/10/2025
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
IRISH, DARLENE
Attorney / Firm
Defendant / Respondent
OUR LADY OF PEACE NURSING CARE RESIDENCE et al
Attorneys / FirmsSTILLWELL VISCO
Motions (3)
#Date FiledFiled ByRelief SoughtSubmit DateAnswerStatusDecisionOrder Signed
311/14/2025Compromise12/15/2025NoDecided: 12/15/2025 Granted Before Justice: Sedita III, Hon. Frank A.Short Form Order12/15/2025
206/23/2025Judgment - Summary10/15/2025NoDecided: 10/15/2025 Closed Before Justice: Sedita III, Hon. Frank A.
105/04/2023Dismiss06/01/2023NoDecided: 06/01/2023 Withdrawn Before Justice: Sedita III, Hon. Frank A.Oral
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (70)
Doc #Date FiledDocumentDescriptionMotion #Filing UserFile
110/26/2022SUMMONS + COMPLAINTTheresa M Walsh
202/13/2023AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEOur Lady of Peace, Inc.Theresa M Walsh
303/08/2023ANSWERJohn Michael Visco
403/08/2023NOTICE OF DEPOSITIONJohn Michael Visco
503/08/2023AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEOUR LADY OF PEACE NURSING CARE RESIDENCETheresa M Walsh
603/08/2023AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEASCENSION LIVINGTheresa M Walsh
703/08/2023AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEASCENSION HEALTH CARE NETWORK, INC.Theresa M Walsh
805/04/2023NOTICE OF MOTION1John Michael Visco
905/04/2023AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION1John Michael Visco
1005/04/2023EXHIBIT(S)Exhibit A - S&C1John Michael Visco
9Niagara Supreme Court2021E171545/2020DisposedTortSHIRA, MARY D et alBROWN CHIARI LLPOUR LADY OF PEACE NURSING CARE RESIDENCE et alStillwell Midgley05/09/2024CARUSO, Hon. FRANK
Case Info
Court
Niagara Supreme Court
Index Number
E171545/2020
Status
Disposed
Year Filed
2021
Case Name
SHIRA, MARY D et al vs. OUR LADY OF PEACE NURSING CARE RESIDENCE et al
Case Type
Tort-Other
Track
Standard
RJI Filed
05/11/2021
NOI Due
05/11/2022
NOI Filed
Calendar Number
Jury Status
Justice
CARUSO, Hon. FRANK
Next Appearance
05/09/2024
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
SHIRA, MARY D et al
Attorney / FirmBROWN CHIARI LLP
Defendant / Respondent
OUR LADY OF PEACE NURSING CARE RESIDENCE et al
Attorneys / FirmsStillwell Midgley
Motions (2)
#Date FiledFiled ByRelief SoughtSubmit DateAnswerStatusDecisionOrder Signed
204/23/2024Approve Settlement05/09/2024NoDecided: 05/09/2024 Granted Before Justice: CARUSO, Hon. FRANKShort Form Order05/09/2024
112/16/2022Discovery02/08/2023NoDecided: 02/08/2023 Withdrawn Before Justice: CARUSO, Hon. FRANK
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (24)
Doc #Date FiledDocumentDescriptionMotion #Filing UserFile
102/07/2020SUMMONSSummonsAngelo Salvatore Gambino
202/07/2020COMPLAINTComplaintAngelo Salvatore Gambino
302/27/2020ANSWERJohn Michael Visco
402/27/2020NOTICE OF DEPOSITION UPON ORAL EXAMINATIONJohn Michael Visco
502/28/2020AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEAOS 2-11-2020 OLP Nursing Care ResidenceAngelo Salvatore Gambino
602/28/2020AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEAOS 2-11-2020 OLPAngelo Salvatore Gambino
705/11/2021RJI -RE: REQUEST FOR PRELIMINARY CONFERENCEJeffrey Michael Shalke
812/12/2022NOTICE OF MOTION1Jesse Allen Drumm
912/12/2022AFFIRMATION1Jesse Allen Drumm
1012/12/2022EXHIBIT(S)Summons and Complaint1Jesse Allen Drumm
10Niagara Supreme Court2021E171805/2020DisposedTortCrogan, Richard et alLIPSITZ GREEN SCIME CAMBRIA LLPOur Lady of Peace Nursing Care Residence et alStillwell Midgley08/09/2023Sedita III, Hon. Frank A.
Case Info
Court
Niagara Supreme Court
Index Number
E171805/2020
Status
Disposed
Year Filed
2021
Case Name
Crogan, Richard et al vs. Our Lady of Peace Nursing Care Residence et al
Case Type
Tort-Other
Track
Standard
RJI Filed
01/07/2021
NOI Due
01/07/2022
NOI Filed
02/24/2022
Calendar Number
22-037
Jury Status
Jury At Plaintiff's Request
Justice
Sedita III, Hon. Frank A.
Next Appearance
08/09/2023
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
Crogan, Richard et al
Attorney / FirmLIPSITZ GREEN SCIME CAMBRIA LLP
Defendant / Respondent
Our Lady of Peace Nursing Care Residence et al
Attorneys / FirmsStillwell Midgley
Motions (3)
#Date FiledFiled ByRelief SoughtSubmit DateAnswerStatusDecisionOrder Signed
302/22/2021Protective Order03/16/2021NoDecided: 03/16/2021 Withdrawn Before Justice: Sedita III, Hon. Frank A.Memorandum
201/08/2021Dismiss03/16/2021NoDecided: 03/16/2021 Withdrawn Before Justice: Sedita III, Hon. Frank A.Memorandum
101/07/2021Discovery03/16/2021NoDecided: 03/16/2021 Withdrawn Before Justice: Sedita III, Hon. Frank A.Memorandum
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (48)
Doc #Date FiledDocumentDescriptionMotion #Filing UserFile
103/04/2020SUMMONS + COMPLAINTDale James Bauman
205/14/2020ANSWERJohn Michael Visco
305/14/2020NOTICE OF DEPOSITIONJohn Michael Visco
405/14/2020NOTICE OF DEPOSITIONJohn Michael Visco
505/26/2020STIPULATION - AMENDING PLEADING(S)Stipulation to Amend ComplaintDale James Bauman
605/26/2020NOTICE TO COUNTY CLERK - AMENDMENT OF CAPTIONDale James Bauman
705/26/2020SUMMONS - SUPPLEMENTAL (PRE RJI)Dale James Bauman
805/26/2020COMPLAINT (AMENDED)Dale James Bauman
906/29/2020AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEof Summons & Complaint on Our Lady of Peace Nursing Care Residence d/b/a Our Lady of Peace, Inc.Dale James Bauman
1007/07/2020ANSWER (AMENDED)John Michael Visco
11Niagara Supreme Court2021E172412/2020ActiveNegligenceHEWITT II, LYLE S.BROWN CHIARI LLPMOUNT ST. MARY'S HOSPITAL AND HEALTH CENTER et alStillwell Midgley06/01/2026Giacobbe, Hon. Mario A.
Case Info
Court
Niagara Supreme Court
Index Number
E172412/2020
Status
Active
Year Filed
2021
Case Name
HEWITT II, LYLE S. vs. MOUNT ST. MARY'S HOSPITAL AND HEALTH CENTER et al
Case Type
Tort-Other Negligence
Track
Standard
RJI Filed
05/11/2021
NOI Due
05/11/2022
NOI Filed
Calendar Number
Jury Status
Justice
Giacobbe, Hon. Mario A.
Next Appearance
06/01/2026
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
HEWITT II, LYLE S.
Attorney / FirmBROWN CHIARI LLP
Defendant / Respondent
MOUNT ST. MARY'S HOSPITAL AND HEALTH CENTER et al
Attorneys / FirmsStillwell Midgley
Motions
No motions recorded for this case.
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (10)
Doc #Date FiledDocumentDescriptionMotion #Filing UserFile
107/08/2020SUMMONS + COMPLAINTTheresa M Walsh
208/04/2020AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEJeffrey Michael Shalke
308/04/2020AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEJeffrey Michael Shalke
408/04/2020AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEJeffrey Michael Shalke
508/04/2020AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEJeffrey Michael Shalke
608/18/2020STIPULATION - DISCONTINUANCE (PRE RJI)John Michael Visco
708/25/2020ANSWERJohn Michael Visco
808/25/2020NOTICE OF DEPOSITIONJohn Michael Visco
905/11/2021RJI -RE: REQUEST FOR PRELIMINARY CONFERENCEJeffrey Michael Shalke
1003/10/2026CONSENT TO CHANGE ATTORNEY (POST RJI)Kevin Vasquez Hutcheson
12Niagara Supreme Court2021E173456/2020DisposedNegligenceBENNERT, ANNETTE F.BROWN CHIARI LLPOUR LADY OF PEACE NURSING CARE RESIDENCE et alStillwell Midgley01/13/2022CARUSO, Hon. FRANK
Case Info
Court
Niagara Supreme Court
Index Number
E173456/2020
Status
Disposed
Year Filed
2021
Case Name
BENNERT, ANNETTE F. vs. OUR LADY OF PEACE NURSING CARE RESIDENCE et al
Case Type
Tort-Other Negligence
Track
Standard
RJI Filed
05/24/2021
NOI Due
05/24/2022
NOI Filed
Calendar Number
Jury Status
Justice
CARUSO, Hon. FRANK
Next Appearance
01/13/2022
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
BENNERT, ANNETTE F.
Attorney / FirmBROWN CHIARI LLP
Defendant / Respondent
OUR LADY OF PEACE NURSING CARE RESIDENCE et al
Attorneys / FirmsStillwell Midgley
Motions (1)
#Date FiledFiled ByRelief SoughtSubmit DateAnswerStatusDecisionOrder Signed
112/14/2021Approve Settlement01/13/2022NoDecided: 01/13/2022 Granted Before Justice: CARUSO, Hon. FRANKOral01/18/2022
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (10)
Doc #Date FiledDocumentDescriptionMotion #Filing UserFile
110/31/2020SUMMONS + COMPLAINTTheresa M Walsh
212/02/2020ANSWERJohn Michael Visco
312/02/2020NOTICE OF DEPOSITIONJohn Michael Visco
412/02/2020AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEMichele Ann Braun
512/02/2020AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEMichele Ann Braun
605/24/2021RJI -RE: REQUEST FOR PRELIMINARY CONFERENCEMichele Ann Braun
712/14/2021NOTICE OF PETITION1Michael Christopher Scinta
812/14/2021ORDER ( PROPOSED )1Michael Christopher Scinta
901/18/2022ORDER - COMPROMISE & SETTLEMENT1Corinne Cleri
1003/18/2022STIPULATION - DISCONTINUANCE (POST RJI)John Michael Visco
13Erie Supreme Court2020808955/2019DisposedNegligenceLAURENDI, CARMEN J.Tiveron Law, PLLCOUR LADY OF PEACE NURSING CARE RESIDENCEStillwell Midgley09/21/2023Siragusa, Hon. Michael A.
Case Info
Court
Erie Supreme Court
Index Number
808955/2019
Status
Disposed
Year Filed
2020
Case Name
LAURENDI, CARMEN J. vs. OUR LADY OF PEACE NURSING CARE RESIDENCE
Case Type
Tort-Other Negligence
Track
Standard
RJI Filed
01/30/2020
NOI Due
01/29/2021
NOI Filed
08/01/2023
Calendar Number
2023-1521
Jury Status
Justice
Siragusa, Hon. Michael A.
Next Appearance
09/21/2023
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
LAURENDI, CARMEN J.
Attorney / FirmTiveron Law, PLLC
Defendant / Respondent
OUR LADY OF PEACE NURSING CARE RESIDENCE
Attorneys / FirmsStillwell Midgley
Motions (2)
#Date FiledFiled ByRelief SoughtSubmit DateAnswerStatusDecisionOrder Signed
206/08/2023Dismiss07/19/2023NoDecided: 07/19/2023 Signed Before Justice: Nowak, Hon. Henry J.So-Ordered Stipulation07/19/2023
101/30/2020Discovery04/02/2020NoDecided: 04/02/2020 Withdrawn Before Justice: Nowak, Hon. Henry J.
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (53)
Doc #Date FiledDocumentDescriptionMotion #Filing UserFile
107/19/2019SUMMONS + COMPLAINTRyan Charles Johnsenpdf
207/26/2019SUMMONS - SUPPLEMENTAL (PRE RJI)Ryan Charles Johnsenpdf
307/26/2019COMPLAINT (AMENDED)Ryan Charles Johnsenpdf
407/31/2019AFFIDAVITAffidavit of Service on Our Lady of Peace Nursing Case ResidenceRyan Charles Johnsen
508/15/2019ANSWERJohn Michael Viscopdf
608/15/2019NOTICE OF DEPOSITIONJohn Michael Visco
701/30/2020NOTICE OF MOTION001Alexandra Starr Balmer
801/30/2020AFFIDAVIT001Alexandra Starr Balmer
901/30/2020EXHIBIT(S)S&C001Alexandra Starr Balmer
1001/30/2020EXHIBIT(S)Supplemental Summons001Alexandra Starr Balmer
14Erie Supreme Court2020806734/2018DisposedNegligenceJANIK, LORI A.BROWN CHIARI LLPOUR LADY OF PEACE NURSING CARE RESIDENCE et alStillwell Midgley09/07/2023Siragusa, Hon. Michael A.
Case Info
Court
Erie Supreme Court
Index Number
806734/2018
Status
Disposed
Year Filed
2020
Case Name
JANIK, LORI A. vs. OUR LADY OF PEACE NURSING CARE RESIDENCE et al
Case Type
Tort-Other Negligence
Track
Standard
RJI Filed
11/04/2020
NOI Due
11/04/2021
NOI Filed
04/12/2023
Calendar Number
2023-700
Jury Status
Jury At Plaintiff's Request
Justice
Siragusa, Hon. Michael A.
Next Appearance
09/07/2023
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
JANIK, LORI A.
Attorney / FirmBROWN CHIARI LLP
Defendant / Respondent
OUR LADY OF PEACE NURSING CARE RESIDENCE et al
Attorneys / FirmsStillwell Midgley
Motions (1)
#Date FiledFiled ByRelief SoughtSubmit DateAnswerStatusDecisionOrder Signed
112/19/2022Examination Order03/30/2023YesDecided: 03/30/2023 Withdrawn Before Justice: Siragusa, Hon. Michael A.Oral
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (26)
Doc #Date FiledDocumentDescriptionMotion #Filing UserFile
104/27/2018SUMMONS + COMPLAINTColleen Faheypdf
206/25/2018SUMMONS (PRE RJI) (AMENDED)Colleen Faheypdf
306/25/2018COMPLAINT (AMENDED)Colleen Faheypdf
407/18/2018ANSWERJohn Michael Viscopdf
507/29/2018AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEOLPColleen Fahey
607/29/2018AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEOLP IncColleen Fahey
701/30/2019CONSENT TO CHANGE ATTORNEY (PRE RJI)John Michael Visco
811/04/2020RJI -RE: REQUEST FOR PRELIMINARY CONFERENCEColleen Fahey
912/21/2020ORDER - CASE SCHEDULINGWendy Haseley
1010/22/2021ORDER - CASE SCHEDULINGAmended Case Scheduling OrderWendy Haseley
15Niagara Supreme Court2020E170529/2019DisposedNegligenceROSINI, REBECCA J et alBROWN CHIARI LLPOUR LADY OF PEACE NURSING CARE RESIDENCE et alStillwell Midgley03/06/2025CARUSO, Hon. FRANK
Case Info
Court
Niagara Supreme Court
Index Number
E170529/2019
Status
Disposed
Year Filed
2020
Case Name
ROSINI, REBECCA J et al vs. OUR LADY OF PEACE NURSING CARE RESIDENCE et al
Case Type
Tort-Other Negligence
Track
Standard
RJI Filed
10/13/2020
NOI Due
10/13/2021
NOI Filed
Calendar Number
Jury Status
Justice
CARUSO, Hon. FRANK
Next Appearance
03/06/2025
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
ROSINI, REBECCA J et al
Attorney / FirmBROWN CHIARI LLP
Defendant / Respondent
OUR LADY OF PEACE NURSING CARE RESIDENCE et al
Attorneys / FirmsStillwell Midgley
Motions (1)
#Date FiledFiled ByRelief SoughtSubmit DateAnswerStatusDecisionOrder Signed
102/14/2025Compromise03/06/2025NoDecided: 03/06/2025 Granted Before Justice: CARUSO, Hon. FRANKOral03/19/2025
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (10)
Doc #Date FiledDocumentDescriptionMotion #Filing UserFile
110/24/2019SUMMONS + COMPLAINTTheresa M Walsh
212/11/2019AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEOur Lady of Peace, Inc.Theresa M Walsh
312/23/2019ANSWERJohn Michael Visco
412/23/2019NOTICE OF DEPOSITIONJohn Michael Visco
512/30/2019AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEOur Lady of PeaceTheresa M Walsh
610/13/2020RJI -RE: REQUEST FOR PRELIMINARY CONFERENCETheresa M Walsh
702/12/2025NOTICE OF PETITION1Michael Christopher Scinta
802/12/2025ORDER ( PROPOSED )1Michael Christopher Scinta
903/10/2025ORDER (PROPOSED) (AMENDED)1Michael Christopher Scinta
1003/19/2025ORDER - COMPROMISE & SETTLEMENT1Corinne Cleri
16Niagara Supreme Court2020E173434/2020DisposedNegligenceKOK, NOREENOUR LADY OF PEACE NURSING CARE RESIDENCE et al12/03/2020CARUSO, Hon. FRANK
Case Info
Court
Niagara Supreme Court
Index Number
E173434/2020
Status
Disposed
Year Filed
2020
Case Name
KOK, NOREEN vs. OUR LADY OF PEACE NURSING CARE RESIDENCE et al
Case Type
Tort-Other Negligence
Track
Standard
RJI Filed
10/29/2020
NOI Due
10/29/2021
NOI Filed
Calendar Number
Jury Status
Justice
CARUSO, Hon. FRANK
Next Appearance
12/03/2020
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
KOK, NOREEN
Attorney / Firm
Defendant / Respondent
OUR LADY OF PEACE NURSING CARE RESIDENCE et al
Attorneys / Firms
Motions (1)
#Date FiledFiled ByRelief SoughtSubmit DateAnswerStatusDecisionOrder Signed
110/29/2020Compromise12/03/2020NoDecided: 12/03/2020 Granted Before Justice: CARUSO, Hon. FRANKOral12/03/2020
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints
No eFiled documents available for this case.
17Niagara Supreme Court2019E161551/2017DisposedNegligenceNOWICKI, SHIRLEY et alBROWN CHIARI LLPOUR LADY OF PEACE NURSING CARE RESIDENCE et alStillwell Midgley03/10/2022Sedita III, Hon. Frank A.
Case Info
Court
Niagara Supreme Court
Index Number
E161551/2017
Status
Disposed
Year Filed
2019
Case Name
NOWICKI, SHIRLEY et al vs. OUR LADY OF PEACE NURSING CARE RESIDENCE et al
Case Type
Tort-Other Negligence
Track
Standard
RJI Filed
10/31/2019
NOI Due
10/30/2020
NOI Filed
Calendar Number
Jury Status
Justice
Sedita III, Hon. Frank A.
Next Appearance
03/10/2022
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
NOWICKI, SHIRLEY et al
Attorney / FirmBROWN CHIARI LLP
Defendant / Respondent
OUR LADY OF PEACE NURSING CARE RESIDENCE et al
Attorneys / FirmsStillwell Midgley
Motions (1)
#Date FiledFiled ByRelief SoughtSubmit DateAnswerStatusDecisionOrder Signed
111/12/2019Discovery01/21/2020NoDecided: 01/21/2020 Withdrawn Before Justice: Kloch, Hon. Richard C.
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (16)
Doc #Date FiledDocumentDescriptionMotion #Filing UserFile
105/12/2017SUMMONS + COMPLAINTSummons & ComplaintMichael Christopher Scintapdf
206/12/2017ANSWERJohn Michael Viscopdf
307/06/2017AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEOur Lady of Peace ResidenceMichael Christopher Scinta
407/06/2017AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEOur Lady of Peace, Inc.Michael Christopher Scinta
501/30/2019CONSENT TO CHANGE ATTORNEY (PRE RJI)John Michael Visco
604/30/2019STIPULATION - OTHER - ( REQUEST TO SO ORDER )Eleanor Bliss Ferry
710/31/2019RJI -RE: REQUEST FOR PRELIMINARY CONFERENCEEleanor Bliss Ferry
811/07/2019NOTICE OF MOTION1Eleanor Bliss Ferrypdf
911/07/2019AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT1Eleanor Bliss Ferry
1011/07/2019EXHIBIT(S)Summons & Complaint1Eleanor Bliss Ferry
18Niagara Supreme Court2008132931-G (0132931/2008)DisposedMedical MalpracticeNIXDORFMICHAEL C. SCINTA, ESQ.OUR LADY OF PEACE NURSING CARE RESIDENCEJOHN M. VISCO, ESQ.05/01/2018RALPH A. BONIELLO, III