We arrange tours, appointments, and even moving support so you don’t have to
2
Better Homes, Better Value
Best price guarantee, avoid bad communities, and find trusted options within budget
3
Personalized Guidance
From lifestyle matching to help with insurance and financial assistance, we make sure the community is the right fit
Assisted Living Magazine — Lawsuit Report
Palm Gardens Center For Nursing And Rehabilitation
📍 615 AVE. C, BROOKLYN, KINGS, NY, 11218
Owner: —
Lawsuit Summary
Total Cases
27
Active Cases
11
9 active · 2 restored
Stayed / Paused
1
1 Stayed — Court Date / Application Pending
Closed
15
15 Disposed
Since
2012
Most Recent
2025
Next Court Date
May 01, 2026
This facility is currently involved in 11 active lawsuits.
Cases
27 cases · Click to expand details (51 from 2010 – present; older years: list only)
#
Court
Year
Index Number
Status
Case Type
Plaintiff / Petitioner
Plaintiff Firm
Defendant / Respondent
Defendant Firm
Appearance
Justice
1
Kings Supreme Court
2025
503361/2025
Disposed
SP-Other
Webley, Claudette
PARKER WAICHMAN LLP
Palm Gardens Care Center, LLC d/b/a Palm Gardens Center for Nursing and Rehabilitation
Palm Gardens Care Center, LLC d/b/a Palm Gardens Center for Nursing and Rehabilitation
04/09/2025
Levine, Hon. Katherine A.
▼
Case Info
Court
Kings Supreme Court
Index Number
503361/2025
Status
Disposed
Year Filed
2025
Case Name
Webley, Claudette vs. Palm Gardens Care Center, LLC d/b/a Palm Gardens Center for Nursing and Rehabilitation
Case Type
SP-Other
Track
Standard
RJI Filed
01/29/2025
NOI Due
01/29/2026
NOI Filed
Calendar Number
—
Jury Status
Justice
Levine, Hon. Katherine A.
Next Appearance
04/09/2025
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
Webley, Claudette
Attorney / FirmPARKER WAICHMAN LLP
Defendant / Respondent
Palm Gardens Care Center, LLC d/b/a Palm Gardens Center for Nursing and Rehabilitation
Attorneys / FirmsPalm Gardens Care Center, LLC d/b/a Palm Gardens Center for Nursing and Rehabilitation
Motions (1)
#
Date Filed
Filed By
Relief Sought
Submit Date
Answer
Status
Decision
Order Signed
1
01/29/2025
Discovery - Pre-Action
04/09/2025
No
Decided: 04/09/2025 Granted Before Justice: Levine, Hon. Katherine A.
Short Form Order
04/09/2025
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (11)
Doc #
Date Filed
Document
Description
Motion #
Filing User
File
1
01/29/2025
PETITION
Petition
Steve Fils-Aime
2
01/29/2025
ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE - ACCOMPANYING COMMENCEMENT DOC(S) (PROPOSED)
Order to Show Cause - proposed
Steve Fils-Aime
3
01/29/2025
AFFIRMATION OF GOOD FAITH
Affirmation of Good Faith
Steve Fils-Aime
4
01/29/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Exhibit A: medical record request (redacted of DOB & SSN)
Steve Fils-Aime
5
01/29/2025
RJI -RE: ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE
Steve Fils-Aime
6
01/29/2025
ADDENDUM - GENERAL (840A)
Steve Fils-Aime
7
03/03/2025
ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE-SIGNED
1
Christopher Brullo
8
03/10/2025
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
PALM GARDENS CARE CENTER, LLC, D/B/A PALM GARDENS CENTER FOR NURSING AND REHABILITATION
1
Steve Fils-Aime
9
03/10/2025
STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING
1
Steve Fils-Aime
10
04/17/2025
ORDER - MOTION- SHORT FORM
Dated 4/9/25
1
Henry Y Huang
11
04/21/2025
NOTICE OF ENTRY/COPY OF ENTERED ORDER/PROOF OF SERVICE
Notice of Entry, Decision/Order and Affidavit of Service
Steve Fils-Aime
2
Kings Supreme Court
2025
520600/2024
Stayed
Negligence
DUNBAR, ANTHONY
SWARTZ CULLETON FERRIS PLLC
PALM GARDENS CARE CENTER, LLC d/b/a PALM GARDENS CENTER FOR NURSING AND REHABILITATION
Lewis Johs Avallone Aviles, LLP
06/18/2026
Rivera, Hon. Francois A.
▼
Case Info
Court
Kings Supreme Court
Index Number
520600/2024
Status
Stayed-Court Date/Application Pending
Year Filed
2025
Case Name
DUNBAR, ANTHONY vs. PALM GARDENS CARE CENTER, LLC d/b/a PALM GARDENS CENTER FOR NURSING AND REHABILITATION
Case Type
Tort-Other Negligence
Track
Complex
RJI Filed
01/14/2025
NOI Due
03/19/2026
NOI Filed
Calendar Number
—
Jury Status
Justice
Rivera, Hon. Francois A.
Next Appearance
06/18/2026
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
DUNBAR, ANTHONY
Attorney / FirmSWARTZ CULLETON FERRIS PLLC
Defendant / Respondent
PALM GARDENS CARE CENTER, LLC d/b/a PALM GARDENS CENTER FOR NURSING AND REHABILITATION
Attorneys / FirmsLewis Johs Avallone Aviles, LLP
Motions (2)
#
Date Filed
Filed By
Relief Sought
Submit Date
Answer
Status
Decision
Order Signed
2
11/28/2025
Dismiss
No
Before Justice: Rivera, Hon. Francois A.
1
10/22/2025
Leave to File
Yes
Before Justice: Rivera, Hon. Francois A.
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (51)
Doc #
Date Filed
Document
Description
Motion #
Filing User
File
1
07/31/2024
SUMMONS + COMPLAINT
Verified Summons and Complaint
Amy Raphael Shane
2
07/31/2024
CERTIFICATE OF MERIT
Certificate of Merit
Amy Raphael Shane
3
08/07/2024
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
secretary of state
Brett Evan Zuckerman
4
08/07/2024
STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING
Brett Evan Zuckerman
5
08/07/2024
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
Brett Evan Zuckerman
6
08/13/2024
STIPULATION - TIME TO ANSWER
Greg Michael Mondelli
7
09/12/2024
ANSWER
Verified Answer, Demand for BP, Notice of EBT and various discovery demands
Greg Michael Mondelli
8
01/14/2025
PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE REQUEST
Christopher J. Culleton
9
01/14/2025
RJI -RE: REQUEST FOR PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE
Christopher J. Culleton
10
01/14/2025
ADDENDUM - GENERAL (840A)
Christopher J. Culleton
11
03/05/2025
THIRD PARTY SUMMONS/COMPLAINT
Third Party S&C
Greg Michael Mondelli
12
03/05/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex A S&C
Greg Michael Mondelli
13
03/05/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex B Answer and Demand for BP
Greg Michael Mondelli
14
03/05/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex C BP
Greg Michael Mondelli
15
03/05/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex D Palm Gardens Contract
Greg Michael Mondelli
16
03/07/2025
ORDER - PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE
Robert Lynch
17
04/08/2025
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
Affidavit of Service-Citi
Greg Michael Mondelli
18
04/08/2025
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
Affidavit of Service-Hacker
Greg Michael Mondelli
19
07/15/2025
ANSWER TO THIRD PARTY COMPLAINT
Melanie Irina Wiener
20
07/15/2025
NOTICE OF DEPOSITION
Melanie Irina Wiener
21
08/04/2025
SUMMONS (POST RJI) (AMENDED)
Amended Summons
Christopher J. Culleton
22
08/04/2025
COMPLAINT (AMENDED)
Amended Complaint
Christopher J. Culleton
23
08/25/2025
ANSWER
ANSWER TO AMENDED COMPLAINT
Melanie Irina Wiener
24
08/25/2025
NOTICE TO TAKE DEPOSITION
Notice To Take Deposition of Plaintiff
Melanie Irina Wiener
25
08/25/2025
NOTICE TO TAKE DEPOSITION
Notice To Take Deposition of Palm Gardens
Melanie Irina Wiener
26
08/27/2025
ANSWER
VErified Answer to Amended Complaint and Notice of EBT
Greg Michael Mondelli
27
10/22/2025
NOTICE OF MOTION
Motion for Leave of Court to File Amended Complaint
1
Christopher J. Culleton
28
10/22/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Plaintiff's Verified Summons and Complaint
1
Christopher J. Culleton
29
10/22/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Defendant's Verified Answer
1
Christopher J. Culleton
30
10/22/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Defendant's Third-Party Summons and Complaint
1
Christopher J. Culleton
31
10/22/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Third-Party Defendants' Verified Answer
1
Christopher J. Culleton
32
10/22/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Plaintiff's Amended Complaint
1
Christopher J. Culleton
33
10/22/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Third-Party Defendants' Answer to Third Party Complaint
1
Christopher J. Culleton
34
10/22/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Defendant and Third-Party Plaintiff's Answer to Plaintiff's Amended Complaint
1
Christopher J. Culleton
35
10/22/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Plaintiff's Second Amended Complaint
1
Christopher J. Culleton
36
11/28/2025
NOTICE OF CROSS-MOTION
2
Melanie Irina Wiener
37
11/28/2025
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF CROSS-MOTION
2
Melanie Irina Wiener
38
11/28/2025
MEMORANDUM IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION AND IN SUPPORT OF CROSS-MOTION
2
Melanie Irina Wiener
39
12/02/2025
STIPULATION - ADJOURNMENT OF MOTION
Executed Stipulation to Adjorn
2
Christopher J. Culleton
40
12/24/2025
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO CROSS-MOTION
Affirmation in Support
2
Christopher J. Culleton
41
12/24/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Original Complaint
2
Christopher J. Culleton
42
12/24/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Third Party Action
2
Christopher J. Culleton
43
12/24/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
First Amended Complaint
2
Christopher J. Culleton
44
12/24/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Answer to First Amended Complaint
2
Christopher J. Culleton
45
12/24/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Second Amended Complaint
2
Christopher J. Culleton
46
01/26/2026
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN REPLY
2
Melanie Irina Wiener
47
01/30/2026
ORDER - MOTION- SHORT FORM
DATED 1/29/26 MOTION SEQ 1 AND 2
1
Maureen Lawton
48
02/10/2026
COMPLAINT (AMENDED)
Second Amended Complaint (redlined)
Christopher J. Culleton
49
02/24/2026
COMPLAINT (AMENDED)
Correct Second Amended Complaint
Christopher J. Culleton
50
03/25/2026
LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE
Letter requesting to stay case due to death of plaintiff
Christopher J. Culleton
51
03/30/2026
ORDER - MOTION- SHORT FORM
dated 3/26/26 motion seq 1 and 2
1
Maureen Lawton
3
Kings Supreme Court
2025
512028/2024
Disposed
Tort
GEORGE ROSA, AS ADMINISTRATOR OF THE ESTATE OF MIRIAM ROSA, DECEASED
Krentsel & Guzman, LLP
PALM GARDENS CARE CENTER, LLC D/B/A PALM GARDENS CENTER FOR NURSING AND REHABILITATION
JOSEPH D. FURLONG
07/17/2025
Swern, Hon. Anne J.
▼
Case Info
Court
Kings Supreme Court
Index Number
512028/2024
Status
Disposed
Year Filed
2025
Case Name
GEORGE ROSA, AS ADMINISTRATOR OF THE ESTATE OF MIRIAM ROSA, DECEASED vs. PALM GARDENS CARE CENTER, LLC D/B/A PALM GARDENS CENTER FOR NURSING AND REHABILITATION
Case Type
Tort-Other
Track
Complex
RJI Filed
02/12/2025
NOI Due
05/16/2026
NOI Filed
Calendar Number
—
Jury Status
Justice
Swern, Hon. Anne J.
Next Appearance
07/17/2025
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
GEORGE ROSA, AS ADMINISTRATOR OF THE ESTATE OF MIRIAM ROSA, DECEASED
Attorney / FirmKrentsel & Guzman, LLP
Defendant / Respondent
PALM GARDENS CARE CENTER, LLC D/B/A PALM GARDENS CENTER FOR NURSING AND REHABILITATION
Attorneys / FirmsJOSEPH D. FURLONG
Motions (2)
#
Date Filed
Filed By
Relief Sought
Submit Date
Answer
Status
Decision
Order Signed
2
05/06/2025
Dismiss
07/17/2025
Yes
Decided: 07/17/2025 Granted Before Justice: Swern, Hon. Anne J.
Memorandum
08/26/2025
1
02/12/2025
Dismiss
05/01/2025
Yes
Decided: 05/01/2025 Marked Off Before Justice: Swern, Hon. Anne J.
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (102)
Doc #
Date Filed
Document
Description
Motion #
Filing User
File
1
04/29/2024
SUMMONS + COMPLAINT
Jonathan Joseph Panarella
2
04/29/2024
STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING
Jonathan Joseph Panarella
3
05/02/2024
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
PALM GARDENS CARE CENTER LLC / D/B/A PALM GARDENS CENTER FOR NURSING AND REHABILITATION / AFFIDAVIT
Jonathan Joseph Panarella
4
05/02/2024
STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING
Jonathan Joseph Panarella
5
05/08/2024
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
Affidavit of Service on Palm Gardens Care Center, LLC D/B/A Palm Gardens Center For Nursing and Rehabilitation
Jonathan Joseph Panarella
6
05/20/2024
LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE
Lori Michele Shapiro
7
05/20/2024
STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING
Lori Michele Shapiro
8
05/22/2024
STIPULATION - TIME TO ANSWER
Lori Michele Shapiro
9
08/14/2024
STIPULATION - TIME TO ANSWER
Lori Michele Shapiro
10
11/18/2024
STIPULATION - OTHER
Stip ETR to 2.17.25
Dylan Corey Braverman
11
11/18/2024
STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING
Dylan Corey Braverman
12
02/12/2025
NOTICE OF MOTION
1
Joseph Duffy Furlong
13
02/12/2025
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION
1
Joseph Duffy Furlong
14
02/12/2025
MEMORANDUM OF LAW
1
Joseph Duffy Furlong
15
02/12/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex A - MOL
1
Joseph Duffy Furlong
16
02/12/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex B - Affirmation of Izabella Rypina, RN.pdf
1
Joseph Duffy Furlong
17
02/12/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex C - Stipulation.pdf
1
Joseph Duffy Furlong
18
02/12/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex D - S&C.pdf
1
Joseph Duffy Furlong
19
02/12/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex E - Palm Gardens COVID-19 Protocols.pdf
1
Joseph Duffy Furlong
20
02/12/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex F - Palm Gardens Records_Redacted_Part1.pdf
1
Joseph Duffy Furlong
21
02/12/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex F - Palm Gardens Records_Redacted_Part2.pdf
1
Joseph Duffy Furlong
22
02/12/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex G - Wrest.pdf
1
Joseph Duffy Furlong
23
02/12/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex H - Hagquist.pdf
1
Joseph Duffy Furlong
24
02/12/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex I - Hohler.pdf
1
Joseph Duffy Furlong
25
02/12/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex J - Mirabella.pdf
1
Joseph Duffy Furlong
26
02/12/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex K - Gerber.pdf
1
Joseph Duffy Furlong
27
02/12/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex L - Bushart.pdf
1
Joseph Duffy Furlong
28
02/12/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex M - Brzozowiec.pdf
1
Joseph Duffy Furlong
29
02/12/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex N - Spanos.pdf
1
Joseph Duffy Furlong
30
02/12/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex O - Revell.pdf
1
Joseph Duffy Furlong
31
02/12/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex P - Martino.pdf
1
Joseph Duffy Furlong
32
02/12/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex Q - Shankle.pdf
1
Joseph Duffy Furlong
33
02/12/2025
RJI -RE: NOTICE OF MOTION
1
Joseph Duffy Furlong
34
02/12/2025
ADDENDUM - GENERAL (840A)
1
Joseph Duffy Furlong
35
03/10/2025
STIPULATION - ADJOURNMENT OF MOTION
Stipulation to Adjourn Motion Sequence 01 Returnable 3/27 to 4/28/25
1
Jonathan Joseph Panarella
36
03/10/2025
STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING
1
Jonathan Joseph Panarella
37
04/22/2025
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION
1
Jonathan Joseph Panarella
38
04/22/2025
AFFIRMATION
Word Count Certification
1
Jonathan Joseph Panarella
39
04/22/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
NYS Assembly Memorandum in Support of Legislation for a new Bill, Sponsored by Assembly Member Kim
1
Jonathan Joseph Panarella
40
04/22/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Floor Debate Transcript
1
Jonathan Joseph Panarella
41
04/22/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Affidavit of NYS Assembly Member Ronald T. Kim
1
Jonathan Joseph Panarella
42
04/22/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Order in Robertson v. Humboldt House Rehabilitation
1
Jonathan Joseph Panarella
43
04/22/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Decision in Gonnelly v. Newburgh Operations, LLC
1
Jonathan Joseph Panarella
44
04/22/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Decision in Lara v. S&J Operational, LLC
1
Jonathan Joseph Panarella
45
04/22/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Appellate Division Decision & Order in Holder v. Jacob
1
Jonathan Joseph Panarella
46
04/22/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Attorney General's Report
1
Jonathan Joseph Panarella
47
04/22/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Testimony of Andrew Cuomo
1
Jonathan Joseph Panarella
48
04/22/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Testimony of Howard A. Zucker, M.D.
1
Jonathan Joseph Panarella
49
04/22/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
CMS Memo
1
Jonathan Joseph Panarella
50
04/22/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Decision in Pierro v. Carmel Richmond Healthcare
1
Jonathan Joseph Panarella
51
04/22/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Plaintiff's Expert Report of Ernest Tosh
1
Jonathan Joseph Panarella
52
04/22/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Decision in Samanowitz v. Sunharbor
1
Jonathan Joseph Panarella
53
04/22/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Physician's Affidavit
1
Jonathan Joseph Panarella
54
04/22/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Court Orders
1
Jonathan Joseph Panarella
55
04/22/2025
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
1
Jonathan Joseph Panarella
56
04/24/2025
ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE
Michelle Shamell
57
04/25/2025
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN REPLY
1
Joseph Duffy Furlong
58
04/25/2025
STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING
1
Joseph Duffy Furlong
59
05/06/2025
NOTICE OF MOTION
2
Joseph Duffy Furlong
60
05/06/2025
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION
2
Joseph Duffy Furlong
61
05/06/2025
MEMORANDUM OF LAW
2
Joseph Duffy Furlong
62
05/06/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex A - MOL.pdf
2
Joseph Duffy Furlong
63
05/06/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex B - Affirmation of Izabella Rypina, RN.pdf
2
Joseph Duffy Furlong
64
05/06/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex C - Stipulation.pdf
2
Joseph Duffy Furlong
65
05/06/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex D - S&C.pdf
2
Joseph Duffy Furlong
66
05/06/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex E - Palm Gardens COVID-19 Protocols.pdf
2
Joseph Duffy Furlong
67
05/06/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex F - Palm Gardens Records_Redacted_Part1.pdf
2
Joseph Duffy Furlong
68
05/06/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex F - Palm Gardens Records_Redacted_Part2.pdf
2
Joseph Duffy Furlong
69
05/06/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex G - Wrest.pdf
2
Joseph Duffy Furlong
70
05/06/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex H - Hagquist.pdf
2
Joseph Duffy Furlong
71
05/06/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex I - Hohler.pdf
2
Joseph Duffy Furlong
72
05/06/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex J - Mirabella.pdf
2
Joseph Duffy Furlong
73
05/06/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex K - Gerber.pdf
2
Joseph Duffy Furlong
74
05/06/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex L - Bushart.pdf
2
Joseph Duffy Furlong
75
05/06/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex M - Brzozowiec.pdf
2
Joseph Duffy Furlong
76
05/06/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex N - Spanos.pdf
2
Joseph Duffy Furlong
77
05/06/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex O - Revell.pdf
2
Joseph Duffy Furlong
78
05/06/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex P - Martino.pdf
2
Joseph Duffy Furlong
79
05/06/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex Q - Shankle.pdf
2
Joseph Duffy Furlong
80
07/10/2025
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION
2
Jonathan Joseph Panarella
81
07/10/2025
AFFIRMATION
Word Count Certification
2
Jonathan Joseph Panarella
82
07/10/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
NYS Assembly Memorandum in Support of Legislation for a new Bill, Sponsored by Assembly Member Kim
2
Jonathan Joseph Panarella
83
07/10/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Floor Debate Transcript
2
Jonathan Joseph Panarella
84
07/10/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Affidavit of NYS Assembly Member Ronald T. Kim
2
Jonathan Joseph Panarella
85
07/10/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Order in Robertson v. Humboldt House Rehabilitation
2
Jonathan Joseph Panarella
86
07/10/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Decision in Gonnelly v. Newburgh Operations, LLC
2
Jonathan Joseph Panarella
87
07/10/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Decision in Lara v. S&J Operational, LLC
2
Jonathan Joseph Panarella
88
07/10/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Appellate Division Decision & Order in Holder v. Jacob
2
Jonathan Joseph Panarella
89
07/10/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Attorney General's Report
2
Jonathan Joseph Panarella
90
07/10/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Testimony of Andrew Cuomo
2
Jonathan Joseph Panarella
91
07/10/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Testimony of Howard A. Zucker, M.D.
2
Jonathan Joseph Panarella
92
07/10/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
CMS Memo
2
Jonathan Joseph Panarella
93
07/10/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Decision in Pierro v. Carmel Richmond Healthcare
2
Jonathan Joseph Panarella
94
07/10/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Plaintiff's Expert Report of Ernest Tosh
2
Jonathan Joseph Panarella
95
07/10/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Decision in Samanowitz v. Sunharbor
2
Jonathan Joseph Panarella
96
07/10/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Physician's Affidavit
2
Jonathan Joseph Panarella
97
07/10/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Court Orders
2
Jonathan Joseph Panarella
98
07/10/2025
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
2
Jonathan Joseph Panarella
99
07/10/2025
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN REPLY
2
Joseph Duffy Furlong
100
07/10/2025
STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING
2
Joseph Duffy Furlong
101
09/05/2025
DECISION + ORDER ON MOTION
2
Lauren Mcfowler-Ray
102
09/22/2025
NOTICE OF ENTRY
2
Joseph Duffy Furlong
4
Kings Supreme Court
2023
532361/2022
Active
Negligence
Crawford, Tonya
Alonso Krangle LLP
Palm Gardens Care Center, LLC d/b/a Palm Gardens Center for Nursing and Rehabilitation et al
CNH Operating, LLC d/b/a The Chateau at Brooklyn Rehabilitation and Nursing Center
06/15/2026
Ward, Hon. Kerry J.
▼
Case Info
Court
Kings Supreme Court
Index Number
532361/2022
Status
Active
Year Filed
2023
Case Name
Crawford, Tonya vs. Palm Gardens Care Center, LLC d/b/a Palm Gardens Center for Nursing and Rehabilitation et al
Case Type
Tort-Other Negligence
Track
Complex
RJI Filed
01/04/2023
NOI Due
06/05/2026
NOI Filed
Calendar Number
—
Jury Status
Justice
Ward, Hon. Kerry J.
Next Appearance
06/15/2026
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
Crawford, Tonya
Attorney / FirmAlonso Krangle LLP
Defendant / Respondent
Palm Gardens Care Center, LLC d/b/a Palm Gardens Center for Nursing and Rehabilitation et al
Attorneys / FirmsCNH Operating, LLC d/b/a The Chateau at Brooklyn Rehabilitation and Nursing Center
Motions (5)
#
Date Filed
Filed By
Relief Sought
Submit Date
Answer
Status
Decision
Order Signed
5
11/17/2025
Strike Pleadings
12/12/2025
Yes
Decided: 12/12/2025 Withdrawn Before Justice: Central Compliance Part,
4
06/02/2025
Extend - Time
06/26/2025
Yes
Decided: 06/26/2025 Granted Before Justice: Ruchelsman, Hon. Leon
Short Form Order
06/26/2025
3
04/14/2023
Amend Caption/Pleadings
04/24/2023
No
Decided: 04/24/2023 Granted Before Justice: Sweeney, Hon. Peter Paul
Short Form Order
04/24/2023
2
02/15/2023
DEFENDANT
Dismiss
05/15/2023
Yes
Decided: 05/15/2023 Granted Before Justice: Sweeney, Hon. Peter Paul
Short Form Order
05/15/2023
1
01/04/2023
DEFENDANT
Dismiss
04/24/2023
Yes
Decided: 04/24/2023 Granted Before Justice: Sweeney, Hon. Peter Paul
Short Form Order
04/24/2023
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (82)
Doc #
Date Filed
Document
Description
Motion #
Filing User
File
1
11/04/2022
SUMMONS + COMPLAINT
David Bruce Krangle
2
12/27/2022
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
David Bruce Krangle
3
12/27/2022
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
David Bruce Krangle
4
12/27/2022
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
David Bruce Krangle
5
12/27/2022
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
David Bruce Krangle
6
01/04/2023
NOTICE OF MOTION
1
Kenneth Andrew Laub
7
01/04/2023
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT
1
Kenneth Andrew Laub
8
01/04/2023
EXHIBIT(S)
Summons and Complaint
1
Kenneth Andrew Laub
9
01/04/2023
EXHIBIT(S)
Affidavits of Service
1
Kenneth Andrew Laub
10
01/04/2023
RJI -RE: NOTICE OF MOTION
1
Kenneth Andrew Laub
11
01/25/2023
ANSWER
Verified Answer
David H Sculnick
12
01/25/2023
DEMAND FOR BILL OF PARTICULARS
Demand for Bill of Particulars
David H Sculnick
13
01/25/2023
DEMAND FOR:
Combined Demands
David H Sculnick
14
01/25/2023
DEMAND FOR:
Notice of Discovery and Inspection for Social Media
David H Sculnick
15
02/14/2023
NOTICE OF MOTION
Notice of Motion
2
Edward John Robinson
16
02/14/2023
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT
Affirmation In Support
2
Edward John Robinson
17
02/14/2023
EXHIBIT(S)
Summons and Complaint
2
Edward John Robinson
18
02/14/2023
EXHIBIT(S)
Verified Answer
2
Edward John Robinson
19
02/14/2023
EXHIBIT(S)
DiBitetto v New Vanderbilt
2
Edward John Robinson
20
02/14/2023
EXHIBIT(S)
Price v KFG operating
2
Edward John Robinson
21
02/14/2023
EXHIBIT(S)
Hill v Staten Island
2
Edward John Robinson
22
02/14/2023
EXHIBIT(S)
Mota v St Patricks Home for Age and infirm
2
Edward John Robinson
23
04/14/2023
NOTICE OF CROSS-MOTION
3
David Bruce Krangle
24
04/14/2023
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION AND IN SUPPORT OF CROSS-MOTION
3
David Bruce Krangle
25
04/14/2023
EXHIBIT(S)
Letters of Administration
3
David Bruce Krangle
26
04/14/2023
EXHIBIT(S)
Proposed Stipulation
3
David Bruce Krangle
27
04/14/2023
EXHIBIT(S)
Proposed Amended Complaint
3
David Bruce Krangle
28
04/14/2023
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
3
David Bruce Krangle
29
04/17/2023
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION
3
David H Sculnick
30
04/18/2023
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO CROSS-MOTION
Affirmation in Partial Opposition
3
Kenneth Andrew Laub
31
04/18/2023
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
3
Kenneth Andrew Laub
32
04/25/2023
ORDER - AMENDING CAPTION
DTD 4/24/2023
1
Marilyn Sanders
33
05/08/2023
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION
2
David Bruce Krangle
34
05/08/2023
EXHIBIT(S)
Court Order regarding lack of capacity
2
David Bruce Krangle
35
05/08/2023
EXHIBIT(S)
Stipulation
2
David Bruce Krangle
36
05/08/2023
EXHIBIT(S)
Supreme Court Decisions
2
David Bruce Krangle
37
05/08/2023
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
2
David Bruce Krangle
38
05/09/2023
NOTICE OF ENTRY
David Bruce Krangle
39
05/12/2023
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN REPLY
Reply Affirmation
3
Edward John Robinson
40
05/12/2023
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN REPLY
Reply Affirmation (Previously filed under the incorrect motion #3)
2
Edward John Robinson
41
05/17/2023
ORDER - OTHER
dtd 5/15/2023
2
Talik Rhett
42
05/24/2023
NOTICE OF ENTRY
Notice of Entry
Edward John Robinson
43
06/06/2023
COMPLAINT (AMENDED)
David Bruce Krangle
44
06/06/2023
ANSWER (AMENDED)
Edward John Robinson
45
06/08/2023
ANSWER
Verified Answer to Amended Complaint
Kenneth Andrew Laub
46
06/08/2023
NOTICE OF DEPOSITION
Kenneth Andrew Laub
47
06/08/2023
DEMAND FOR BILL OF PARTICULARS
Kenneth Andrew Laub
48
06/09/2023
STIPULATION - OTHER
Edward John Robinson
49
08/02/2023
PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE REQUEST
David Bruce Krangle
50
09/05/2023
ORDER - PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE
Robert Lynch
51
12/04/2023
ORDER ( PROPOSED )
Proposed Compliance Conference Order
David Bruce Krangle
52
12/07/2023
ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE
dated 12/5/2023
Alex Cao
53
02/07/2024
RESPONSE TO DEMAND
Michael William Terlizzi
54
02/12/2024
RESPONSE TO DEMAND
Michael William Terlizzi
55
02/14/2024
DEMAND FOR:
Demand for Arons Authorization
Adam J. Fischkelta
56
11/11/2024
ORDER ( PROPOSED )
Proposed Final Pre-Note Order
David Bruce Krangle
57
11/21/2024
ORDER - OTHER
dated 11/18/24
Henry Y Huang
58
12/17/2024
LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE
Correspondence requesting deposition of non-party witness
Adam J. Fischkelta
59
03/06/2025
DEMAND FOR:
Post-EBT Demand for Discovery & Inspection
Dante G Esser
60
03/06/2025
DEMAND FOR:
Demand for Authorizations
Dante G Esser
61
03/06/2025
DEMAND FOR:
Post-EBT Demand for Non-Party EBTs
Dante G Esser
62
03/07/2025
DEMAND FOR:
Post-EBT Demand for Non-Party EBTs
Kenneth Andrew Laub
63
03/07/2025
DEMAND FOR:
Notice for Discovery and Inspection
Kenneth Andrew Laub
64
03/07/2025
DEMAND FOR:
Demand for Authorizations
Kenneth Andrew Laub
65
06/02/2025
NOTICE OF MOTION
4
David Bruce Krangle
66
06/02/2025
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT
Affirmation in Support
4
David Bruce Krangle
67
06/02/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Exhibit A - Emails dated 8.21.24 and 8.28.24
4
David Bruce Krangle
68
06/02/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Exhibit B - Email dated 3.3.25
4
David Bruce Krangle
69
06/02/2025
AFFIRMATION OF GOOD FAITH
4
David Bruce Krangle
70
06/02/2025
AFFIRMATION
Part 130 Certification
4
David Bruce Krangle
71
06/02/2025
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
4
David Bruce Krangle
72
07/09/2025
ORDER - OTHER
dated 06/26/25
4
Rosa Anzalone
73
11/14/2025
NOTICE OF MOTION
5
David Bruce Krangle
74
11/14/2025
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT
5
David Bruce Krangle
75
11/14/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Email Chain
5
David Bruce Krangle
76
11/14/2025
AFFIRMATION OF GOOD FAITH
5
David Bruce Krangle
77
11/14/2025
AFFIRMATION
Part 130 Certification
5
David Bruce Krangle
78
11/14/2025
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
5
David Bruce Krangle
79
12/09/2025
ORDER ( PROPOSED )
Proposed Final Conference Order
David Bruce Krangle
80
12/16/2025
STIPULATION - WITHDRAWING MOTION/ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE
5
Ben Baxter Evans
81
12/19/2025
ORDER - OTHER
(FINAL PRE-NOTE) dated 12/11/2025
Robert Topscher
82
01/14/2026
NOTICE OF CHANGE OF FIRM NAME OR ADDRESS (POST RJI)
Letter - Change of Address
Kenneth Andrew Laub
5
Kings Supreme Court
2022
530534/2021
Active
Medical Malpractice
BRATHWAITE, ORIOLE
FRIEDMAN SANCHEZ, LLP
PALM GARDENS CENTER
Lewis Johs Avallone Aviles, LLP
11/19/2025
Sheares, Hon. Robin K.
▼
Case Info
Court
Kings Supreme Court
Index Number
530534/2021
Status
Active
Year Filed
2022
Case Name
BRATHWAITE, ORIOLE vs. PALM GARDENS CENTER
Case Type
Tort-Medical, Dental, or Podiatric Malpractice
Track
Complex
RJI Filed
01/28/2022
NOI Due
06/07/2024
NOI Filed
04/16/2024
Calendar Number
—
Jury Status
Jury At Plaintiff's Request
Justice
Sheares, Hon. Robin K.
Next Appearance
11/19/2025
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
BRATHWAITE, ORIOLE
Attorney / FirmFRIEDMAN SANCHEZ, LLP
Defendant / Respondent
PALM GARDENS CENTER
Attorneys / FirmsLewis Johs Avallone Aviles, LLP
Motions
No motions recorded for this case.
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (14)
Doc #
Date Filed
Document
Description
Motion #
Filing User
File
1
11/30/2021
SUMMONS + COMPLAINT
Andrew Michael Friedman
2
12/13/2021
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
Andrew Michael Friedman
3
01/19/2022
ANSWER
Verified Answer, Demand for BP, Notice of EBT and various discovery demands
Greg Michael Mondelli
4
01/28/2022
BILL OF PARTICULARS
Anne Elisabeth Klootwyk
5
01/28/2022
NOTICE OF MEDICAL MALPRACTICE
Anne Elisabeth Klootwyk
6
01/28/2022
PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE REQUEST
Anne Elisabeth Klootwyk
7
01/28/2022
RJI -RE: REQUEST FOR PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE
Anne Elisabeth Klootwyk
8
03/08/2022
ORDER - PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE
Robert Lynch
9
11/30/2022
ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE
DTD 11/29/22 (DEFAULT)
Marilyn Sanders
10
12/14/2023
STIPULATION - OTHER - ( REQUEST TO SO ORDER )
Andrew Michael Friedman
11
12/21/2023
ORDER ( PROPOSED )
Emil Joseph Sanchez
12
12/27/2023
ORDER - OTHER
dtd 11/21/2023
Talik Rhett
13
04/16/2024
NOTE OF ISSUE:WITH JURY
Andrew Michael Friedman
14
01/14/2026
NOTICE OF CHANGE OF FIRM NAME OR ADDRESS (POST RJI)
Letter - Change of Address
Kenneth Andrew Laub
6
Kings Supreme Court
2021
505067/2021
Active
Negligence
Puig, Rita
Trolman Glaser Corley & Lichtman, P.C.
Palm Gardens Care Center, LLC d/b/a Palms Gardens Center for Nursing and Rehabilitation
SHELLEY LLP
09/19/2024
Cohen, Hon. Caroline Piela
▼
Case Info
Court
Kings Supreme Court
Index Number
505067/2021
Status
Active
Year Filed
2021
Case Name
Puig, Rita vs. Palm Gardens Care Center, LLC d/b/a Palms Gardens Center for Nursing and Rehabilitation
PALM GARDENS CARE CENTER LLC, d/b/a PALM GARDENS CENTER FOR NURSING AND REHABILITATION
Wilson Elser Moskowitz Edelman & Dicker LLP
05/18/2026
Green, Hon. Desmond A.
▼
Case Info
Court
Kings Supreme Court
Index Number
517990/2020
Status
Active-Restored
Year Filed
2021
Case Name
MICHAEL KANSCAR, as Administrator of the Estate of IRENA MAZUREK, deceased, vs. PALM GARDENS CARE CENTER LLC, d/b/a PALM GARDENS CENTER FOR NURSING AND REHABILITATION
Case Type
Tort-Other Negligence
Track
Standard
RJI Filed
01/28/2021
NOI Due
05/08/2026
NOI Filed
Calendar Number
—
Jury Status
Justice
Green, Hon. Desmond A.
Next Appearance
05/18/2026
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
MICHAEL KANSCAR, as Administrator of the Estate of IRENA MAZUREK, deceased,