Saint John‘s On The Lake

Saint John‘s On The Lake

1840 N Prospect Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53202 View Map

Saint John‘s On The Lake is a Luxury Senior Living Home in Wisconsin

Saint John‘s On The… is a Luxury Senior Living Home in Wisconsin

icon
Care Cost Calculator: See Prices in Your Area Care Cost Calculator: See Prices in Your Area icon
Overview of Saint John‘s on the Lake

Saint John’s On The Lake, located at 1840 N Prospect Ave in Milwaukee, Wisconsin, is an esteemed senior living community that offers an exceptional retirement experience. Nestled in a prime location, this vibrant community provides breathtaking views of Lake Michigan and convenient access to the city’s amenities. With its elegant architecture and serene surroundings, Saint John’s On The Lake presents a tranquil yet vibrant oasis for its residents. Saint John’s offers the full continuum of care including, independent living, assisted living, memory care, and skilled nursing care.

This community provides spacious apartments with modern amenities. Each residence is thoughtfully designed to provide comfort, style, and a sense of belonging. Residents can indulge in gourmet dining experiences, engaging social activities, and access top-notch amenities such as a fitness center, warm-water pool, and beautifully landscaped gardens. Saint John’s On The Lake is dedicated to fostering an active and fulfilling lifestyle for its residents, ensuring they have every opportunity to pursue their passions, nurture relationships, and embrace their future years with grace and joy.

(414) 272-2022

Quality ratings

Measured by Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS)

Nurse hours per resident 5.10/day Wisconsin avg: 4.28/day
Overall rating Info Official CMS rating based on health inspections, staffing and quality measures.
4/5
Wisconsin avg: 3.0/5
Health Inspection Info Official CMS rating based on deficiencies found during state health inspections.
3/5
Wisconsin avg: 2.8/5
Staffing Info Official CMS rating based on nurse staffing hours per resident per day.
5/5
Wisconsin avg: 3.6/5
Quality Measures Info Official CMS rating based on clinical outcomes for residents.
3/5
Wisconsin avg: 3.1/5

Capacity and availability

Smaller home

May offer a more intimate, personalized care environment.

Total beds 27

This home usually has availability

Lower occupancy suggests more openings may be available.

Lower demand than the Wisconsin average
Occupancy rate 72.7%
Residents per day (avg) 21
Occupancy rate
72.7%
Residents per day (avg)
21

Who this home usually serves

TYPE OF STAY

Mix of rehab and long-term care

This home supports both short-term rehab and long-term care, with residents staying for a wide range of durations.

Breakdown by payment type

Medicare

48% of new residents, usually for short-term rehab.

Typical stay 17 days

Private pay

51% of new residents, often for short stays.

Typical stay 4 - 5 months

Medicaid

1% of new residents, often for long-term daily care.

Typical stay 3 - 4 years

Finances and operations

Voluntary non-profit home
Church
Home revenue
$4.8M
Operating deficit
-$833.1K
Voluntary non-profit home Church
Home revenue
$4,813,467.00
Operating deficit
$-833,116.00
Payroll costs Info The portion of the home's budget spent on staff, including nurses, caregivers, and other employees who support care and operations.
$2.6M
54% of revenue
Other operating costs Info All remaining costs needed to run the home, such as food, utilities, building maintenance, supplies and administrative expenses.
$3.0M
Total costs $5.6M
Bed community size
27-bed community
A moderately sized community that may balance personal attention with shared amenities and social activities.
Walk Score
Walk Score: 92 / 100
Walker's paradise. Daily errands do not require a car, with many shops and services nearby.
BBB Rating
BBB Rating: A+ (Not Accredited)
An independent rating from the Better Business Bureau based on factors such as complaint history, transparency, and business practices.
How BBB ratings work

Client group served

Physically Disabled
Irreversible Dementia Alzeimers
Advanced Aged

About this community

Facility Type
Skilled Care
License Date
January 8, 2020

Additional licensing details

CMS Certification Number: 525539
County: MILWAUKEE
Waiver certified: No

Ownership & operating entity

Saint John‘s On The Lake is legally operated by SAINT JOHN'S COMMUNITIES INC, and administrated by MATTHEW LOYD.

Profit status: NONPROFIT

Staffing

Key information about the people who lead and staff this community.

Leadership

Contact: MEIGHAN BENTZ

Contact Information

Fax: (414) 897-8247

Additional Policies & Features

Gender Served: Both

Rate Information

Monthly Rate Range $7,275 - $8,990

What does this home offer?

Room sizes icon
Room sizes icon

Room Sizes: 475 / 600 - 1350 / 875 - 1675 sq. ft.

Housing options icon
Housing options icon

Housing Options: Studio / 1 Bed / 2 Bed

Building type icon
Building type icon

Building Type: High-rise

Fitness and recreation icon
Fitness and recreation icon

Fitness and Recreation

Transportation services icon
Transportation services icon

Transportation Services

Types of Care at Saint John‘s On The Lake

Independent Living Assisted Living Memory Care
Contact Saint John‘s On The Lake

Compare Assisted Living around Milwaukee

The information below is reported by the Wisconsin Department of Health Services, Division of Quality Assurance.
New Perspective Senior Living | North Shore
AL

Assisted Living For seniors needing help with daily tasks but not full-time nursing.

Brown Deer
$336 - $3,800
60
Yes
A+
18
RYAN NOVACZYK
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Studio / 1 Bed / 2 Bed
Ameira Orchids Assisted Living
AL

Assisted Living For seniors needing help with daily tasks but not full-time nursing.

IL

Independent Living For self-sufficient seniors seeking community and minimal assistance.

MC

Memory Care Specialized care for those with Memory Loss, Alzheimer's, or dementia, ensuring safety and support.

SNF

Nursing Homes 24/7 care needed

WI 53224 (Pheasant Run)
$4,041 - $5,411
50
No
-
14
ATIYAH NICHOLS
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Studio / 1 Bed / 2 Bed
Saint John‘s On The Lake
SNF

Nursing Home 24/7 care needed

AL

Assisted Living For seniors needing help with daily tasks but not full-time nursing.

IL

Independent Living For self-sufficient seniors seeking community and minimal assistance.

MC

Memory Care Specialized care for those with Memory Loss, Alzheimer's, or dementia, ensuring safety and support.

Milwaukee (Lower East Side)
$7,275 - $8,990
30
No
A+
92
LOYD, MATTHEW
72.7%
$4,997,564.00
$2,601,201.00
52%
21.30
4/5
5.0967
3/5
5/5
3/5
1
13
1
-4%
+19%
+4%
Studio / 1 Bed / 2 Bed
LJB Adult Living
AL

Assisted Living For seniors needing help with daily tasks but not full-time nursing.

Milwaukee (Old North Milwaukee)
$0 - $0
4
No
A+
69
LATICE EVANS
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Studio / 1 Bed / 2 Bed
Close To Home Senior Living
AL

Assisted Living For seniors needing help with daily tasks but not full-time nursing.

Milwaukee
-
-
No
-
57
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Private Rooms

Living Spaces & Floor Plans

John P1
John P2
John P3

Places of interest near Saint John‘s On The Lake

Address 1.5 miles from city center — 0.62 miles to nearest hospital (Ascension Columbia St. Mary's Hospital - Milwaukee Campus)

Address 1840 N Prospect Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53202

Calculate Travel Distance to Saint John‘s On The Lake

Add your location

Address

Staffing Data

Source: CMS Payroll-Based Journal (Q2 2025)

102
Total Staff
59
Employees
43
Contractors
12,469
Total Hours (Quarter)
22
Avg Staff/Day
6.2
Avg Shift (hrs)
Nursing Staff Breakdown
Role Count Avg Shift (hrs) Uses Contractors?
Registered Nurse138.5 Yes
Licensed Practical Nurse127.6 Yes
Certified Nursing Assistant587.1 Yes
Staff by Category
Administration
3 staff
2.4hs shift avg
Nursing Staff
83 staff
7.4hs shift avg
Physicians & Practitioners
3 staff
4.1hs shift avg
Therapy Services
6 staff
4.1hs shift avg
Activities & Recreation
0 staff
0hs shift avg
Social Services
4 staff
3.3hs shift avg
Dietary Services
2 staff
3.3hs shift avg
Other Services
1 staff
7.8hs shift avg
Contractor Analysis
4.1%
of total hours from contractors
517 contractor hours this quarter
Certified Nursing Assistant: 30 Registered Nurse: 6 Licensed Practical Nurse: 4 Medical Director: 2 Occupational Therapy Assistant: 1
Role Employees Contractors Total Staff Total Hours Days Worked % of Days Avg Shift (hrs)
Certified Nursing Assistant2830585,73691100%7.1
Registered Nurse76131,99691100%8.5
Licensed Practical Nurse84121,62791100%7.6
Mental Health Service Worker1014625965%7.8
Nurse Practitioner1014435965%7.5
Dietitian2023688593%3.3
Other Social Services Staff2023176976%2.8
Clinical Nurse Specialist2023116470%2.5
Occupational Therapy Aide1012793842%7.3
Speech Language Pathologist1012325763%4.1
Physical Therapy Assistant1012285560%4.1
Qualified Social Worker2022104651%4.5
Respiratory Therapy Technician2021326470%2.1
Administrator101962426%4
Medical Director022191314%0.8
Occupational Therapy Assistant0111633%5.3

Health Inspection History

Total Health inspections 3
50% below Wisconsin average
Wisconsin average: 6.0

Last Health inspection on Jun 2025

Total Health citations 13
52% below Wisconsin average
Wisconsin average: 27.3

4.33 citations per inspection (avg)

Citations origin

Citations can result from standard inspections or complaint-based investigations.

Standard inspections 13 citations
Complaint investigations 1 citations
Breakdown of citations
Critical Health citations 0
100% below Wisconsin average
Wisconsin average: 0.9
Serious Health citations 1
17% below Wisconsin average
Wisconsin average: 1.2
Moderate Health citations 12

Minor Health citations 0
Citations history (last 3 years)
Abuse/Neglect moderate citation Jun 03, 2025
Corrected

Environmental moderate citation Jun 03, 2025
Corrected

Infection Control moderate citation Jun 03, 2025
Corrected

Infection Control moderate citation Jun 03, 2025
Corrected

Facility Characteristics

Source: CMS Long-Term Care Facility Characteristics (Data as of Jan 2026)

Ownership: Non-Profit (Church)
Resident Census by Payment Source
20 Total Residents
Medicare 3 (15%)
Medicaid 1 (5%)
Private Pay/Other 16 (80%)
Programs & Services
Residents' Group
Family Member Group
CCRC
Family Engagement

Active councils help families stay involved in care decisions and facility operations.

Quality of care over time

These measures show how residents usually do over time at this home, based on health outcomes and preventive care.

High-risk clinical events score 14.3
37% worse than Wisconsin average
Wisconsin average: 10.5
Functional decline score 28.8
30% worse than Wisconsin average
Wisconsin average: 22.1
Long-Stay Resident Measures
Daily care & independence

Need for Help with Daily Activities Increased 22.2%
26% above Wisconsin average.

Walking Ability Worsened 33.6%
47% above Wisconsin average.

Low Risk Long-Stay Residents with Bowel/Bladder Incontinence 30.7%
18% above Wisconsin average.
Safety & clinical stability

Falls with Major Injury 4.2%
31% above Wisconsin average.

High Risk Residents with Pressure Ulcers 3.4%
38% below Wisconsin average.

Urinary Tract Infection 4.3%
35% above Wisconsin average.
Emotional & behavioral wellbeing

Depressive Symptoms 0.0%
100% below Wisconsin average.

Antipsychotic Use 2.8%
83% below Wisconsin average.
Preventive care

Pneumococcal Vaccine 100.0%
4% above Wisconsin average.

Influenza Vaccine 100.0%
5% above Wisconsin average.
Nutrition & physical health

Lost Too Much Weight 8.3%
71% above Wisconsin average.
Short-stay resident measures
Pneumococcal Vaccine 93.3%

7% better than Wisconsin average
Antipsychotic medication increase 0.0%

100% better than Wisconsin average
Influenza Vaccine 100.0%

22% better than Wisconsin average

Penalties and fines

Federal penalties imposed by CMS for regulatory violations, including civil money penalties (fines) and denials of payment for new Medicare/Medicaid admissions.

Source: CMS Penalties Database (Data as of Jan 2026)

Total fines amount $33K
This home paid 66% less in fines than the state average.
Wisconsin average: $95K
Number of Fines 1
This home received 52% fewer fines than the state average.
Wisconsin average: 2.1
Payment Denials 1
This home had 51% more payment denials than the state average.
Wisconsin average: 0.7
Penalty History

Penalties are imposed by CMS for violations of federal nursing home regulations.

Civil Money Penalty Feb 21, 2023
$33K
Payment Denial Feb 21, 2023
26 days

Last updated: Jan 2026

Guides for Better Senior Living

Care Cost Calculator: See Prices in Your Area

Nursing Home Data Explorer

Don’t Wait Too Long: 7 Red Flag Signs Your Parent Needs Assisted Living Now

The True Cost of Assisted Living in 2025 – And How Families Are Paying For It

Understanding Senior Living Costs: Pricing Models, Discounts & Financial Assistance

Financial Aid for Wisconsin Seniors

Get financial aid guidance

Family Care Program

WI Medicaid Family Care

Age 65+ or disabled, Wisconsin resident, Medicaid-eligible, long-term care need.

~$2,829/month (300% FBR, individual).

$2,000 (individual), $3,000 (couple).

Managed care model; rural/urban balance.

Wisconsin Caregiver Support Program

WI NFCSP Respite

Caregiver of someone 60+ (or with dementia), Wisconsin resident.

No strict limit; prioritizes low-income.

Not applicable.

High rural demand; ADRC coordination.

IRIS (Include, Respect, I Self-Direct)

Wisconsin IRIS

Age 65+ (or disabled 18+), WI resident, Medicaid-eligible, NFLOC.

~$2,829/month; QIT optional.

$2,000 (individual), $3,000 (couple).

Flexible budget; serves ~20,000; participant hires caregivers.

SeniorCare Prescription Drug Assistance

Wisconsin SeniorCare

Age 65+, WI resident, US citizen/qualified immigrant, not on full Medicaid.

~$24,980-$34,980/year (Level 1-2B, individual); varies by level.

None.

Four benefit levels; serves ~50,000 annually.

Medicare Savings Program (MSP)

Wisconsin Medicare Savings Program

Age 65+ or disabled, WI resident, Medicare Part A/B.

~$2,510/month (QMB), ~$3,380/month (SLMB), ~$3,598/month (QI)—individual.

$9,430 (individual), $14,130 (couple).

Includes Extra Help for Part D; no waitlist.

Wisconsin Home Energy Assistance Program (WHEAP)

Wisconsin WHEAP

Age 60+ prioritized, WI resident, low-income household.

~$3,970/month (185% FPL).

Not assessed.

Covers gas, electric, wood; crisis aid available.

Senior Community Service Employment Program (SCSEP)

Wisconsin SCSEP

Age 55+, unemployed, low-income, WI resident.

~$1,983/month (125% FPL).

Not specified.

Priority for veterans, rural residents; Goodwill/AARP partnership.

VA Aid and Attendance (A&A) and Housebound Benefits

Wisconsin VA Aid and Attendance/Housebound

Age 65+ or disabled veteran/spouse, WI resident, wartime service, ADL help (A&A) or homebound.

Net income < ~$1,984/month (veteran with dependent, A&A); pension offsets income.

~$155,356 (net worth).

High rural veteran use; supports care costs.

Property Tax Deferral Loan Program

Wisconsin Property Tax Deferral Loan

Age 65+, WI resident, homeowner, live in home 6+ months/year.

~$24,980/year (household).

Home equity < $500,000; limited other assets.

Saves ~$500-$1,500/year; interest ~2%-3%.

Senior Farmers’ Market Nutrition Program (SFMNP)

Wisconsin SFMNP

Age 60+, WI resident, low-income.

~$2,322/month (185% FPL).

Not assessed.

Vouchers (~$45/season); serves ~15,000 annually.

Who we are

Your Senior Care Partner, Every Step of the Way

We help families find affordable senior communities and unlock same day discounts, Medicaid, and Medicare options tailored to your needs.

Contact us Today
Tour Icon
Planning a tour? Check our touring checklist.
Chat Icon
Thinking of living here? We can help you speak to a current resident