Assisted Living Magazine — Lawsuit Report

Saints Joachim & Anne Nursing and Rehabilitation Center

📍 2720 SURF AVENUE, BROOKLYN, KINGS, NY, 11224

Owner: Caccavale, Charles

Lawsuit Summary

Total Cases
11
Active Cases
6
5 active · 1 restored
Closed
5
5 Disposed
Since
2015
Most Recent
2026
Next Court Date
Jul 16, 2026
This facility is currently involved in 6 active lawsuits.

Cases

11 cases · Click to expand details
#CourtYearIndex NumberStatusCase TypePlaintiff / PetitionerPlaintiff FirmDefendant / RespondentDefendant FirmAppearanceJustice
1Kings Supreme Court2026506426/2026ActiveTortALLAHVERDIYEVA, NARMINLEVITSKY LAW FIRM PLLCSAINTS JOACHIM AND ANNE NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTER et alSHEELEY LLP02/11/2027Levine, Hon. Katherine A.▼
Case Info
Court
Kings Supreme Court
Index Number
506426/2026
Status
Active
Year Filed
2026
Case Name
ALLAHVERDIYEVA, NARMIN vs. SAINTS JOACHIM AND ANNE NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTER et al
Case Type
Tort-Other
Track
Complex
RJI Filed
05/11/2026
NOI Due
06/14/2027
NOI Filed
Calendar Number
—
Jury Status
Justice
Levine, Hon. Katherine A.
Next Appearance
02/11/2027
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
ALLAHVERDIYEVA, NARMIN
Attorney / FirmLEVITSKY LAW FIRM PLLC
Defendant / Respondent
SAINTS JOACHIM AND ANNE NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTER et al
Attorneys / FirmsSHEELEY LLP
Motions
No motions recorded for this case.
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (14)
Doc #Date FiledDocumentDescriptionMotion #Filing UserFile
102/23/2026SUMMONS + COMPLAINTSummons and Complaint with Attorney's VerificationDmitry Levitskypdf
203/06/2026AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEDmitry Levitsky
303/06/2026STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILINGDmitry Levitsky
403/10/2026AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEDmitry Levitsky
503/11/2026AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEDmitry Levitsky
603/13/2026AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICESecretary of stateDmitry Levitsky
703/23/2026ANSWERDefendant's Verified Answer 03.23.26Collin Joseph Spearspdf
803/23/2026BILL OF PARTICULARSDefendant's Demand for Bill of Particulars 03.23.26Collin Joseph Spears
903/23/2026DEMAND FOR:Defendant's Combined Discovery Demands 03.23.26Collin Joseph Spears
1003/23/2026NOTICE OF DEPOSITIONDefendant's Deposition Notice for Plaintiff 03.23.26Collin Joseph Spears
2Kings Supreme Court2026521998/2025ActiveNegligencePANIAGUA, MARGARETSACCO & FILLASSAINTS JOACHIM & ANNE NURSING & REHABILITATION CENTERSHEELEY LLP10/15/2026Velasquez, Hon. Richard▼
Case Info
Court
Kings Supreme Court
Index Number
521998/2025
Status
Active
Year Filed
2026
Case Name
PANIAGUA, MARGARET vs. SAINTS JOACHIM & ANNE NURSING & REHABILITATION CENTER
Case Type
Tort-Other Negligence
Track
Complex
RJI Filed
01/28/2026
NOI Due
03/03/2027
NOI Filed
Calendar Number
—
Jury Status
Justice
Velasquez, Hon. Richard
Next Appearance
10/15/2026
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
PANIAGUA, MARGARET
Attorney / FirmSACCO & FILLAS
Defendant / Respondent
SAINTS JOACHIM & ANNE NURSING & REHABILITATION CENTER
Attorneys / FirmsSHEELEY LLP
Motions
No motions recorded for this case.
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (16)
Doc #Date FiledDocumentDescriptionMotion #Filing UserFile
107/02/2025SUMMONS + COMPLAINTSUMMONS & COMPLAINTJennifer Anne Flemingpdf
207/02/2025STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILINGSTATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILINGJennifer Anne Fleming
307/24/2025PROOF OF SERVICESaints Joachim & Anne Nursing & Rehabilitation CenterTonino Sacco
407/24/2025STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILINGTonino Sacco
508/25/2025STIPULATION - TIME TO ANSWERStipulation Extending Time to AnswerDaniel Phillip Rifkinpdf
608/26/2025ANSWERVerified AnswerDaniel Phillip Rifkinpdf
708/26/2025DEMAND FOR BILL OF PARTICULARSDemand for Bill of ParticularsDaniel Phillip Rifkin
808/26/2025DEMAND FOR:Defendant's Combined DemandsDaniel Phillip Rifkin
908/26/2025NOTICE OF DEPOSITIONNotice for Examination Before TrialDaniel Phillip Rifkin
1008/26/2025NOTICE OF DISCOVERY AND INSPECTIONNotice of Discovery and Inspection for Social MediaDaniel Phillip Rifkin
3Kings Supreme Court2025506588/2025ActiveNegligenceSKOLNICK, RICHARDJohn J. Ciafone, Esq., Attorney at LawSAINTS JOACHIM AND ANNE NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTER et alWilson Elser Moskowitz Edelman & Dicker LLP07/16/2026Green, Hon. Desmond A.▼
Case Info
Court
Kings Supreme Court
Index Number
506588/2025
Status
Active
Year Filed
2025
Case Name
SKOLNICK, RICHARD vs. SAINTS JOACHIM AND ANNE NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTER et al
Case Type
Tort-Other Negligence
Track
Complex
RJI Filed
10/31/2025
NOI Due
12/09/2026
NOI Filed
Calendar Number
—
Jury Status
Justice
Green, Hon. Desmond A.
Next Appearance
07/16/2026
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
SKOLNICK, RICHARD
Attorney / FirmJohn J. Ciafone, Esq., Attorney at Law
Defendant / Respondent
SAINTS JOACHIM AND ANNE NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTER et al
Attorneys / FirmsWilson Elser Moskowitz Edelman & Dicker LLP
Motions
No motions recorded for this case.
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (6)
Doc #Date FiledDocumentDescriptionMotion #Filing UserFile
102/25/2025SUMMONS + COMPLAINTwith Attorney VerificationJohn Joseph Ciafonepdf
202/26/2025AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEAOS-Saints Joachim and Anne Nursing...CenterJohn Joseph Ciafone
304/21/2025ANSWERLori Rosen Semliespdf
404/21/2025DEMAND FOR:BP and Combined DemandsLori Rosen Semlies
510/31/2025RJI -RE: REQUEST FOR PRELIMINARY CONFERENCEJohn Joseph Ciafone
612/30/2025ORDER - CASE SCHEDULINGDated December 19th, 2025Kaycee Jarrard
4New York Supreme Court2025101009/2025ActiveTortMILLER, IRIS AS SURVIVING SPOUSE AND PROPOSED ADMINISTRATOR OF THE ESTATE OF SMITH III, WILLIAM H.; DECEASEDMILLER, IRIS AS SURVIVING SPOUSE AND PROPOSED ADMINISTRATOR OF THE ESTATE OF SMITH III, WILLIAM H.; DECEASEDSAINTS JOACHIM & ANNE NURSING & REHABILITATION CENTERWilson Elser Moskowitz Edelman & Dicker LLP04/10/2026Kim, Hon. Judy H.▼
Case Info
Court
New York Supreme Court
Index Number
101009/2025
Status
Active
Year Filed
2025
Case Name
MILLER, IRIS AS SURVIVING SPOUSE AND PROPOSED ADMINISTRATOR OF THE ESTATE OF SMITH III, WILLIAM H.; DECEASED vs. SAINTS JOACHIM & ANNE NURSING & REHABILITATION CENTER
Case Type
Tort-Other
Track
Standard
RJI Filed
12/24/2025
NOI Due
12/24/2026
NOI Filed
Calendar Number
—
Jury Status
Justice
Kim, Hon. Judy H.
Next Appearance
04/10/2026
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
MILLER, IRIS AS SURVIVING SPOUSE AND PROPOSED ADMINISTRATOR OF THE ESTATE OF SMITH III, WILLIAM H.; DECEASED
Attorney / FirmMILLER, IRIS AS SURVIVING SPOUSE AND PROPOSED ADMINISTRATOR OF THE ESTATE OF SMITH III, WILLIAM H.; DECEASED
Defendant / Respondent
SAINTS JOACHIM & ANNE NURSING & REHABILITATION CENTER
Attorneys / FirmsWilson Elser Moskowitz Edelman & Dicker LLP
Motions (1)
#Date FiledFiled ByRelief SoughtSubmit DateAnswerStatusDecisionOrder Signed
112/24/2025Dismiss04/10/2026YesBefore Justice: Kim, Hon. Judy H.
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints
No eFiled documents available for this case.
5Kings Supreme Court2023512246/2022Active-RestoredNegligenceZOLFO, SUSANTrolman Glaser Corley & Lichtman, P.C.SAINTS JOACHIM and ANNE NURSING and REHABILITATION CENTERAmabile & Erman, P.C.07/22/2026Velasquez, Hon. Richard▼
Case Info
Court
Kings Supreme Court
Index Number
512246/2022
Status
Active-Restored
Year Filed
2023
Case Name
ZOLFO, SUSAN vs. SAINTS JOACHIM and ANNE NURSING and REHABILITATION CENTER
Case Type
Tort-Other Negligence
Track
Complex
RJI Filed
07/19/2023
NOI Due
09/04/2026
NOI Filed
Calendar Number
—
Jury Status
Justice
Velasquez, Hon. Richard
Next Appearance
07/22/2026
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
ZOLFO, SUSAN
Attorney / FirmTrolman Glaser Corley & Lichtman, P.C.
Defendant / Respondent
SAINTS JOACHIM and ANNE NURSING and REHABILITATION CENTER
Attorneys / FirmsAmabile & Erman, P.C.
Motions (2)
#Date FiledFiled ByRelief SoughtSubmit DateAnswerStatusDecisionOrder Signed
211/18/2025Restore12/19/2025YesDecided: 12/19/2025 Granted Before Justice: Central Compliance Part,Short Form Order12/23/2025
109/30/2025Extend - Time10/31/2025YesDecided: 10/31/2025 Denied Before Justice: Ruchelsman, Hon. LeonShort Form Order10/31/2025
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (30)
Doc #Date FiledDocumentDescriptionMotion #Filing UserFile
104/27/2022SUMMONS + COMPLAINTDavid B. Corleypdf
206/01/2022AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEDavid B. Corley
306/01/2022AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICESECRETARY OF STATEDavid B. Corley
409/12/2022ANSWERNicole Ann Callahanpdf
509/12/2022DEMAND FOR BILL OF PARTICULARSNicole Ann Callahan
609/12/2022NOTICE OF DEPOSITION UPON ORAL EXAMINATIONNicole Ann Callahan
709/12/2022DEMAND FOR:Combined Discovery DemandsNicole Ann Callahan
807/19/2023PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE REQUESTDavid B. Corley
907/19/2023RJI -RE: REQUEST FOR PRELIMINARY CONFERENCEDavid B. Corley
1009/07/2023ORDER - PRELIMINARY CONFERENCERobert Lynch
6Kings Supreme Court2022532880/2022DisposedNegligenceIRINA GALANOVA, as Proposed Executrix of the Estate of PETER GITZIS, DeceasedKrentsel & Guzman, LLPSAINTS JOACHIM & ANNE NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTERHall Booth Smith, P.C.05/08/2023Sweeney, Hon. Peter Paul▼
Case Info
Court
Kings Supreme Court
Index Number
532880/2022
Status
Disposed
Year Filed
2022
Case Name
IRINA GALANOVA, as Proposed Executrix of the Estate of PETER GITZIS, Deceased vs. SAINTS JOACHIM & ANNE NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTER
Case Type
Tort-Other Negligence
Track
Standard
RJI Filed
12/12/2022
NOI Due
12/12/2023
NOI Filed
Calendar Number
—
Jury Status
Justice
Sweeney, Hon. Peter Paul
Next Appearance
05/08/2023
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
IRINA GALANOVA, as Proposed Executrix of the Estate of PETER GITZIS, Deceased
Attorney / FirmKrentsel & Guzman, LLP
Defendant / Respondent
SAINTS JOACHIM & ANNE NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTER
Attorneys / FirmsHall Booth Smith, P.C.
Motions (2)
#Date FiledFiled ByRelief SoughtSubmit DateAnswerStatusDecisionOrder Signed
202/01/2023Dismiss05/08/2023YesDecided: 05/08/2023 Granted Before Justice: Sweeney, Hon. Peter PaulShort Form Order05/08/2023
112/12/2022Extend - Time12/21/2022NoDecided: 12/21/2022 Withdrawn Before Justice: Sweeney, Hon. Peter Paul
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (78)
Doc #Date FiledDocumentDescriptionMotion #Filing UserFile
111/09/2022SUMMONS + COMPLAINTJonathan Joseph Panarellapdf
211/09/2022STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILINGJonathan Joseph Panarella
311/17/2022AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICESAINTS JOACHIM AND ANNE NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTER / AFFIDAVITJonathan Joseph Panarella
411/17/2022STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILINGJonathan Joseph Panarella
511/29/2022AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICESAINTS JOACHIM AND ANNE NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTER / AFFIDAVITJonathan Joseph Panarella
612/12/2022ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE ( PROPOSED )Proposed OTSC with Interim ReliefJeffrey Thomas Wolberpdf
712/12/2022AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTIONAffirmation in Support of OTSCJeffrey Thomas Wolber
812/12/2022EMERGENCY APPLICATION - OTHERAffirmation of Emergency in Support of Request for Interim ReliefJeffrey Thomas Wolber
912/12/2022AFFIRMATION OF GOOD FAITHAffirmation of Good FaithJeffrey Thomas Wolber
1012/12/2022AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEAffirmation of ServiceJeffrey Thomas Wolber
7Kings Supreme Court2022532866/2022ActiveNegligenceBORKOWSKY, TAMAIRAKrentsel & Guzman, LLPSAINTS JOACHIM & ANNE NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTERHall Booth Smith, P.C.11/04/2024Sweeney, Hon. Peter Paul▼
Case Info
Court
Kings Supreme Court
Index Number
532866/2022
Status
Active
Year Filed
2022
Case Name
BORKOWSKY, TAMAIRA vs. SAINTS JOACHIM & ANNE NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTER
Case Type
Tort-Other Negligence
Track
Complex
RJI Filed
12/12/2022
NOI Due
03/14/2024
NOI Filed
Calendar Number
—
Jury Status
Justice
Sweeney, Hon. Peter Paul
Next Appearance
11/04/2024
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
BORKOWSKY, TAMAIRA
Attorney / FirmKrentsel & Guzman, LLP
Defendant / Respondent
SAINTS JOACHIM & ANNE NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTER
Attorneys / FirmsHall Booth Smith, P.C.
Motions (4)
#Date FiledFiled ByRelief SoughtSubmit DateAnswerStatusDecisionOrder Signed
404/15/2024Dismiss11/04/2024YesDecided: 08/15/2025 Granted to the Extent of the Order Before Justice: Sweeney, Hon. Peter PaulMemorandum08/15/2025
307/21/2023Amend Caption/Pleadings11/20/2023NoDecided: 11/20/2023 Granted Before Justice: Sweeney, Hon. Peter PaulShort Form Order11/20/2023
202/01/2023Dismiss11/20/2023YesDecided: 11/20/2023 Marked Off Before Justice: Sweeney, Hon. Peter Paul
112/12/2022Extend - Time12/20/2022NoDecided: 12/20/2022 Withdrawn Before Justice: Landicino, Hon. Carl J.
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (135)
Doc #Date FiledDocumentDescriptionMotion #Filing UserFile
111/09/2022SUMMONS + COMPLAINTJonathan Joseph Panarellapdf
211/09/2022STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILINGJonathan Joseph Panarella
311/18/2022AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICESAINTS JOACHIM AND ANNE NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTER / AFFIDAVITJonathan Joseph Panarella
411/18/2022STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILINGJonathan Joseph Panarella
511/29/2022AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICESAINTS JOACHIM AND ANNE NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTER / AFFIDAVITJonathan Joseph Panarella
612/12/2022ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE ( PROPOSED )Proposed OTSC with Interim ReliefJeffrey Thomas Wolberpdf
712/12/2022AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORTAffirmation in Support of OTSCJeffrey Thomas Wolber
812/12/2022EMERGENCY APPLICATION - OTHERAffirmation of Emergency in Support of Request for Interim ReliefJeffrey Thomas Wolber
912/12/2022AFFIRMATION OF GOOD FAITHAffirmation of Good FaithJeffrey Thomas Wolber
1012/12/2022AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEAffirmation of ServiceJeffrey Thomas Wolber
8Kings Supreme Court2021511346/2021DisposedNegligenceJANET CLAYTON as Administrator of the Estate of ISABELLA HIGHLAND et alGRUENBERG KELLY DELLASAINTS JOACHIM AND ANNE NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTER et alHammill Croutier Pender Koehler Lawless & Moulton, P.C.09/03/2025Jury Coordinating Part,▼
Case Info
Court
Kings Supreme Court
Index Number
511346/2021
Status
Disposed
Year Filed
2021
Case Name
JANET CLAYTON as Administrator of the Estate of ISABELLA HIGHLAND et al vs. SAINTS JOACHIM AND ANNE NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTER et al
Case Type
Tort-Other Negligence
Track
Standard
RJI Filed
08/10/2021
NOI Due
03/29/2024
NOI Filed
02/15/2024
Calendar Number
—
Jury Status
Jury At Plaintiff's Request
Justice
Jury Coordinating Part,
Next Appearance
09/03/2025
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
JANET CLAYTON as Administrator of the Estate of ISABELLA HIGHLAND et al
Attorney / FirmGRUENBERG KELLY DELLA
Defendant / Respondent
SAINTS JOACHIM AND ANNE NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTER et al
Attorneys / FirmsHammill Croutier Pender Koehler Lawless & Moulton, P.C.
Motions (4)
#Date FiledFiled ByRelief SoughtSubmit DateAnswerStatusDecisionOrder Signed
404/09/2024Judgment - Summary06/25/2024YesDecided: 06/25/2024 Granted Before Justice: Stein, Hon. Saul
310/02/2023Discovery10/18/2023YesDecided: 10/18/2023 Withdrawn Before Justice: Central Compliance Part,
207/10/2023Discovery08/03/2023YesDecided: 08/03/2023 Granted to the Extent of the Order Before Justice: Ruchelsman, Hon. LeonShort Form Order08/03/2023
108/10/2021Amend Caption/Pleadings08/17/2022YesDecided: 08/17/2022 Granted Before Justice: Wade, Hon. Carolyn E.08/17/2022
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (106)
Doc #Date FiledDocumentDescriptionMotion #Filing UserFile
105/13/2021SUMMONS + COMPLAINTSean Patrick Kellypdf
205/26/2021AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEaos saints joachim and anne nursing and rehabSean Patrick Kelly
305/26/2021STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILINGSean Patrick Kelly
405/27/2021AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEaos catholic charities brooklyn and queensSean Patrick Kelly
507/01/2021ANSWERAnswer with DemandsRichard C Koehlerpdf
608/10/2021NOTICE OF MOTION1Zachary Michael Beriloffpdf
708/10/2021AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION1Zachary Michael Beriloff
808/10/2021EXHIBIT(S)Summons & Complaint1Zachary Michael Beriloff
908/10/2021EXHIBIT(S)Answer1Zachary Michael Beriloff
1008/10/2021EXHIBIT(S)Proposed Amended Pleadings1Zachary Michael Beriloff
9Kings Supreme Court2018513297/2018DisposedNegligenceNAGER, JACKThe Ruth E Bernstein Law FirmSAINTS JOACHIM AND ANNEFumuso Christesen LLP04/18/2023Garson, Hon. Robin S.▼
Case Info
Court
Kings Supreme Court
Index Number
513297/2018
Status
Disposed
Year Filed
2018
Case Name
NAGER, JACK vs. SAINTS JOACHIM AND ANNE
Case Type
Tort-Other Negligence
Track
Complex
RJI Filed
12/19/2018
NOI Due
06/02/2023
NOI Filed
Calendar Number
—
Jury Status
Justice
Garson, Hon. Robin S.
Next Appearance
04/18/2023
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
NAGER, JACK
Attorney / FirmThe Ruth E Bernstein Law Firm
Defendant / Respondent
SAINTS JOACHIM AND ANNE
Attorneys / FirmsFumuso Christesen LLP
Motions (1)
#Date FiledFiled ByRelief SoughtSubmit DateAnswerStatusDecisionOrder Signed
105/02/2022Strike Pleadings05/26/2022YesDecided: 05/26/2022 Denied Before Justice: Knipel, Hon. Lawrence S.Short Form Order05/26/2022
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (40)
Doc #Date FiledDocumentDescriptionMotion #Filing UserFile
106/27/2018SUMMONSRuth E. Bernsteinpdf
206/27/2018COMPLAINTRuth E. Bernsteinpdf
311/02/2018ANSWERVERIFIED ANSWER - SAINTS JOACHIM & ANNE NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTERAlan James Fumusopdf
412/18/2018AFFIDAVITAffidavit of Service - Deft. SAINTS JOACHIM & ANNE NURSING & REHABILITATION CENTERRuth E. Bernstein
512/19/2018RJI -RE: REQUEST FOR PRELIMINARY CONFERENCERuth E. Bernstein
601/22/2019PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE REQUESTRuth E. Bernstein
701/31/2019ORDER - PRELIMINARY CONFERENCEMichael White-Masseria
807/23/2019ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCEorder dated July 19. 2019Daniella Grossman
911/12/2019ORDER - OTHERCentral Compliance Part Conference - dated 11/8/19Robert Topscher
1001/14/2020LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGEDefendant has failed to produce any discovery, in violation of the PC and CC Court Orders.Ruth E. Bernstein
10Kings Supreme Court2018512453/2017DisposedMedical MalpracticeHANNA, DEBRAANTIN EHRLICH & EPSTEINSAINTS JOACHIMFumuso Christesen LLP09/17/2026Settlement 6, Med Mal Early▼
Case Info
Court
Kings Supreme Court
Index Number
512453/2017
Status
Disposed
Year Filed
2018
Case Name
HANNA, DEBRA vs. SAINTS JOACHIM
Case Type
Tort-Medical, Dental, or Podiatric Malpractice
Track
Complex
RJI Filed
06/15/2018
NOI Due
01/13/2026
NOI Filed
01/12/2026
Calendar Number
—
Jury Status
Jury At Plaintiff's Request
Justice
Settlement 6, Med Mal Early
Next Appearance
09/17/2026
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
HANNA, DEBRA
Attorney / FirmANTIN EHRLICH & EPSTEIN
Defendant / Respondent
SAINTS JOACHIM
Attorneys / FirmsFumuso Christesen LLP
Motions (8)
#Date FiledFiled ByRelief SoughtSubmit DateAnswerStatusDecisionOrder Signed
803/16/2026Judgment - Summary06/22/2026YesDecided: 06/22/2026 Withdrawn Before Justice: Frias-Colon, Hon. Patria
703/16/2026Judgment - Summary06/16/2026YesDecided: 06/16/2026 Withdrawn Before Justice: Frias-Colon, Hon. PatriaShort Form Order06/16/2026
608/21/2025Restore09/30/2025NoDecided: 09/30/2025 Granted Before Justice: Frias-Colon, Hon. PatriaShort Form Order12/16/2025
509/06/2018Consolidate09/06/2018NoDecided: 09/06/2018 Granted to the Extent of the Order Before Justice: Steinhardt, Hon. MarshaShort Form Order09/06/2018
407/03/2018Strike Pleadings08/14/2018YesDecided: 08/14/2018 Withdrawn Before Justice: Spodek, Hon. Ellen M.Oral08/14/2018
306/27/2018Dismiss08/14/2018YesDecided: 08/14/2018 Withdrawn Before Justice: Spodek, Hon. Ellen M.Oral08/14/2018
206/20/2018Dismiss08/14/2018YesDecided: 08/14/2018 Withdrawn Before Justice: Spodek, Hon. Ellen M.Oral08/14/2018
106/15/2018Dismiss08/14/2018YesDecided: 08/14/2018 Withdrawn Before Justice: Spodek, Hon. Ellen M.Oral08/14/2018
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (172)
Doc #Date FiledDocumentDescriptionMotion #Filing UserFile
106/23/2017SUMMONSsummonsJeffrey S Antinpdf
206/23/2017COMPLAINTcomplaintJeffrey S Antinpdf
306/23/2017CERTIFICATE OF MERITcertificate of meritJeffrey S Antin
406/28/2017SUMMONS - SUPPLEMENTAL (PRE RJI)Scott W Epsteinpdf
506/28/2017COMPLAINT (AMENDED)Scott W Epsteinpdf
606/28/2017CERTIFICATE OF MERITScott W Epstein
710/02/2017AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEJeffrey S Antin
810/02/2017STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILINGJeffrey S Antin
910/04/2017AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEJeffrey S Antin
1010/10/2017AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEJeffrey S Antin
11Kings Supreme Court2015506700/2015DisposedMedical MalpracticeBERENTSEN, LORI ANNEShimko Law PCSAINTS JOACHIM & ANNEFumuso Christesen LLP07/14/2020Scheduling Judge, Trial▼
Case Info
Court
Kings Supreme Court
Index Number
506700/2015
Status
Disposed
Year Filed
2015
Case Name
BERENTSEN, LORI ANNE vs. SAINTS JOACHIM & ANNE
Case Type
Tort-Medical, Dental, or Podiatric Malpractice
Track
Complex
RJI Filed
12/22/2015
NOI Due
03/24/2017
NOI Filed
10/23/2018
Calendar Number
2018-014884T
Jury Status
Jury At Plaintiff's Request
Justice
Scheduling Judge, Trial
Next Appearance
07/14/2020
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
BERENTSEN, LORI ANNE
Attorney / FirmShimko Law PC
Defendant / Respondent
SAINTS JOACHIM & ANNE
Attorneys / FirmsFumuso Christesen LLP
Motions (4)
#Date FiledFiled ByRelief SoughtSubmit DateAnswerStatusDecisionOrder Signed
406/07/2018Restore06/25/2018NoDecided: 06/25/2018 Granted Before Justice: Central Compliance Part,Short Form Order06/25/2018
305/09/2017Strike Pleadings06/16/2017YesDecided: 06/16/2017 Withdrawn Before Justice: Dabiri, Hon. GloriaOral06/16/2017
202/08/2017Amend Caption/Parties03/10/2017NoDecided: 03/10/2017 Granted Before Justice: Dabiri, Hon. GloriaMemorandum03/10/2017
112/22/2015Judgment - Default02/05/2016YesDecided: 02/05/2016 Withdrawn Before Justice: Dabiri, Hon. GloriaOral02/05/2016
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (34)
Doc #Date FiledDocumentDescriptionMotion #Filing UserFile
106/01/2015SUMMONS + COMPLAINTDaniel Stephen Shimkopdf
207/24/2015AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICEDaniel Stephen Shimko
312/22/2015NOTICE OF MOTION1Daniel Stephen Shimkopdf
412/22/2015EXHIBIT(S)Summons & Complaint1Daniel Stephen Shimko
512/22/2015EXHIBIT(S)NPCL Affidavit of Service1Daniel Stephen Shimko
612/22/2015EXHIBIT(S)Affidavit of Service of Additional Mailing1Daniel Stephen Shimko
712/22/2015EXHIBIT(S)Power of Attorney1Daniel Stephen Shimko
812/22/2015EXHIBIT(S)Picture1Daniel Stephen Shimko
912/22/2015EXHIBIT(S)Plaintiff's Affidavit1Daniel Stephen Shimko
1012/22/2015RJI -RE: NOTICE OF MOTION1Daniel Stephen Shimkopdf