Who is the owner of The Hurlbut?

The Hurlbut is legally operated by The Hurlbut, LLC (For Profit).

Is The Hurlbut in a walkable area?

The Hurlbut has a walk score of 44. Somewhat walkable. A few nearby services may be reachable on foot, but most trips require transportation.

What is the license number of The Hurlbut?

According to NY state health department records, The Hurlbut's license number is 2750308N.

What is the occupancy rate at The Hurlbut?

The Hurlbut's occupancy is 63%.

Are pets allowed at The Hurlbut?

No, The Hurlbut has a no-pet policy.

Does The Hurlbut operate as a for-profit or non-profit?

The Hurlbut is registered as a for-profit in NY.

The Hurlbut | 2-Star Nursing Home in Rochester, NY

Lawsuit Summary

Total Cases

Active Cases

3 active

Stayed / Paused

1 Stayed

Closed

4 Disposed — Consolidated Into85 Disposed

Since

2010

Most Recent

2025

Next Court Date

Jul 09, 2026

This facility is currently involved in 3 active lawsuits.

Cases

93 cases · Click to expand details (69 from 2010 to present; 24 older listed only)

Court

Year

Index Number

Status

Case Type

Plaintiff / Petitioner

Plaintiff Firm

Defendant / Respondent

Defendant Firm

Appearance

Justice

Monroe Supreme Court

2025

E2024017634

Active

Medical Malpractice

VAZQUEZ-SIMMONS, MERCEDES

DOMINIC PELLEGRINO

THE UNIVERSITY OF ROCHESTER et al

OSBORN, REED & BURKE, LLP

07/30/2026

Cariola, Hon. Elena F.

▼

Case Info

Court

Monroe Supreme Court

Index Number

E2024017634

Status

Active

Year Filed

2025

Case Name

Case Type

Tort-Medical, Dental, or Podiatric Malpractice

Track

RJI Filed

NOI Due

NOI Filed

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

Cariola, Hon. Elena F.

Next Appearance

07/30/2026

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

VAZQUEZ-SIMMONS, MERCEDES

Attorney / FirmDOMINIC PELLEGRINO

Defendant / Respondent

THE UNIVERSITY OF ROCHESTER et al

Attorneys / FirmsOSBORN, REED & BURKE, LLP

Motions

No motions recorded for this case.

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints

No eFiled documents available for this case.

St. Lawrence Supreme Court

2025

SC-25-36

Disposed

SCAR-Small Claims Assessment Review

Hurlbut, Michael R

Town of Louisville

08/18/2025

▼

Case Info

Court

St. Lawrence Supreme Court

Index Number

SC-25-36

Status

Disposed

Year Filed

2025

Case Name

Case Type

SCAR-Small Claims Assessment Review

Track

RJI Filed

NOI Due

NOI Filed

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

Next Appearance

08/18/2025

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

Hurlbut, Michael R

Attorney / Firm

Defendant / Respondent

Town of Louisville

Attorneys / FirmsTown of Louisville

Motions

No motions recorded for this case.

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints

No eFiled documents available for this case.

Oneida Supreme Court

2024

EFCA2022-002942

Disposed

OM-Other

DISCOVER BANK

KIRSCHENBAUM & PHILLIPS, P.C.

HURLBUT, CURTIS J

LAW OFFICE OF STEPHANIE ROWE TURNER

05/02/2024

Gigliotti, Hon. Louis P.

▼

Case Info

Court

Oneida Supreme Court

Index Number

EFCA2022-002942

Status

Disposed

Year Filed

2024

Case Name

Case Type

OM-Other

Track

RJI Filed

NOI Due

NOI Filed

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

Gigliotti, Hon. Louis P.

Next Appearance

05/02/2024

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

DISCOVER BANK

Attorney / FirmKIRSCHENBAUM & PHILLIPS, P.C.

Defendant / Respondent

HURLBUT, CURTIS J

Attorneys / FirmsLAW OFFICE OF STEPHANIE ROWE TURNER

Motions

No motions recorded for this case.

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints

No eFiled documents available for this case.

Livingston Supreme Court

2023

000319-2023

Stayed

Tort

Culhane, Catherine E.

FINKELSTEIN & PARTNERS

Conesus Lake Nursing Home et al

09/11/2026

Noto, Hon. Jennifer M.

▼

Case Info

Court

Livingston Supreme Court

Index Number

000319-2023

Status

Stayed

Year Filed

2023

Case Name

Culhane, Catherine E. vs. Conesus Lake Nursing Home et al

Case Type

Tort-Other

Track

Standard

RJI Filed

07/28/2023

NOI Due

NOI Filed

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

Noto, Hon. Jennifer M.

Next Appearance

09/11/2026

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

Culhane, Catherine E.

Attorney / FirmFINKELSTEIN & PARTNERS

Defendant / Respondent

Conesus Lake Nursing Home et al

Attorneys / Firms

Motions (1)

#	Date Filed	Filed By	Relief Sought	Submit Date	Answer	Status	Decision	Order Signed
1	07/28/2023		Dismiss	09/01/2023	No	Decided: 09/01/2023 Withdrawn Before Justice: Noto, Hon. Jennifer M.	Short Form Order

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints (57)

Doc #	Date Filed	Document	Description	Motion #	Filing User
1	05/15/2023	SUMMONS + COMPLAINT	Summons and Verified Complaint dated 5/15/23		Lawrence D Lissauer
2	05/15/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit A-Letters Testamentary		Lawrence D Lissauer
3	05/15/2023	STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING	Statement of Auth dated 5/15/23		Lawrence D Lissauer
4	06/26/2023	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Conesus Lake Nursing & Rehabilitation-aff of serv s/c		Lawrence D Lissauer
5	06/26/2023	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Conesus Lake Nursing Home-aff of serv s/c		Lawrence D Lissauer
6	06/26/2023	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Hurlbut Care Communities-aff of serv s/c		Lawrence D Lissauer
7	06/26/2023	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Robert Hurlbut-aff of serv s/c		Lawrence D Lissauer
8	06/26/2023	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Avon Nursing & Rehabilitation-aff of serv s/c		Lawrence D Lissauer
9	06/26/2023	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Mark Cutletta-aff of serv s/c		Lawrence D Lissauer
10	06/26/2023	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Bridgett Chasko-aff of serv s/c		Lawrence D Lissauer
11	06/26/2023	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Hurlbut Heath Consulting, Inc.-aff of serv s/c		Lawrence D Lissauer
12	06/26/2023	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Conesus Lake Nursing Home LLC-aff of serv s/c		Lawrence D Lissauer
13	06/26/2023	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Conesus Lake Nursing Home LLC d/b/a Conesus Lake Nursing Home-aff of serv s/c		Lawrence D Lissauer
14	06/26/2023	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Conesus Lake Nursing Home LLC d/b/a Conesus Lake Nursing & Rehabilitation-aff of serv s/c		Lawrence D Lissauer
15	06/26/2023	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Avon Nursing Home LLC d/b/a Avon Nursing & Rehabilitation-aff of serv s/c		Lawrence D Lissauer
16	06/26/2023	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Avon Nursing Home LLC-aff of serv s/c		Lawrence D Lissauer
17	07/28/2023	ANSWER			Mallory Kass Smith
18	07/28/2023	NOTICE OF MOTION	Notice of Motion to Dismiss Complaint	1	Mallory Kass Smith
19	07/28/2023	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION	Affirmation of Mallory Smith	1	Mallory Kass Smith
20	07/28/2023	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION	Affidavit of Bridgett Chasko	1	Mallory Kass Smith
21	07/28/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	7.31.19 agreement	1	Mallory Kass Smith
22	07/28/2023	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION	Affidavit of Mark Curletta	1	Mallory Kass Smith
23	07/28/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	7.1.22 Agreement	1	Mallory Kass Smith
24	07/28/2023	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION	Affidavit of Robert W. Hurlbut	1	Mallory Kass Smith
25	07/28/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Trademark Electronic Search System (TESS)	1	Mallory Kass Smith
26	07/28/2023	RJI -RE: NOTICE OF MOTION		1	Mallory Kass Smith
27	07/28/2023	ADDENDUM - GENERAL (840A)		1	Mallory Kass Smith
28	07/31/2023	COURT NOTICE			Kathleen Schrider
28-1	07/31/2023	ATTACHMENT TO COURT NOTICE	In-Person Appearance Required 09.08.23		Kathleen Schrider
29	08/25/2023	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION	Affirmation in Opposition	1	Lawrence D Lissauer
30	08/25/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	MedicareGov - Conesus Lake NH Ownership (8.18.23 dated)	1	Lawrence D Lissauer
31	08/25/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	MedicareGov -Curletta Avon NH Ownership (8.18.23 dated)	1	Lawrence D Lissauer
32	08/25/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	MedicareGov -Hurlbut Care proof of Name for C. Lake (8.24.23 dated)	1	Lawrence D Lissauer
33	08/25/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	MedicareGov -Hurlbut Care proof of Name for Avon NH (8.24.23 dated)	1	Lawrence D Lissauer
34	08/25/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Hurlbut Care Comm- Best Nursing Homes (8.24.23 dated)	1	Lawrence D Lissauer
35	08/25/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Hurlbut Care Comm- Best Nursing Homes- Conesus (8.24.23 dated)	1	Lawrence D Lissauer
36	08/25/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Hurlbut Care Comm- Best Nursing Homes- Avon (8.24.23 dated)	1	Lawrence D Lissauer
37	08/25/2023	STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING	Statement of Auth	1	Lawrence D Lissauer
38	09/01/2023	STIPULATION - PARTIAL DISCONTINUANCE (POST RJI)	Partial Stipulation of Discontinuance as against Bridgett Chasko, Mark Curletta, and Hurlbut Care Communities Without Prejudice		Mallory Kass Smith
39	09/01/2023	NOTICE OF WITHDRAWAL OF MOTION / ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE		1	Mallory Kass Smith
40	12/15/2023	STIPULATION - AMENDING CAPTION			Mallory Kass Smith
41	01/29/2025	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE	Letter to Court requesting a Preliminary Conference		Lawrence D Lissauer
42	01/29/2025	STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING			Lawrence D Lissauer
43	02/07/2025	COURT NOTICE			Louis D. Annunziata
43-1	02/07/2025	ATTACHMENT TO COURT NOTICE	In-Person Appearance 03.14.25.		Louis D. Annunziata
44	04/11/2025	ORDER - CASE SCHEDULING	Scheduling Order		Shannon N Agosto
45	08/18/2025	COURT NOTICE			Louis D. Annunziata
45-1	08/18/2025	ATTACHMENT TO COURT NOTICE	In-Person Appearance 10.31.25.		Louis D. Annunziata
46	09/04/2025	ORDER - REFERENCE TO ADR	Order of Referral to Mediation		Shannon N Agosto
47	10/29/2025	COURT NOTICE			Kathleen Schrider
47-1	10/29/2025	ATTACHMENT TO COURT NOTICE	In-Person Appearance 12.19.25		Kathleen Schrider
48	12/10/2025	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE	Plaintiff's Letter to Court re Status Letter and Request for rescheduling of the 12.19.25 IP Pre-Trial Conf. dated 12.10.25		Lawrence D Lissauer
49	12/12/2025	COURT NOTICE			Daisy Renz
49-1	12/12/2025	ATTACHMENT TO COURT NOTICE	NTA In-Person Appearance 02.20.26		Daisy Renz
50	05/28/2026	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE	Plaintiff's Status Letter to Court and Request for an Adjournment of the 6.12.66 conference dated 5.28.26		Lawrence D Lissauer
51	06/01/2026	COURT NOTICE			Kathleen Schrider
51-1	06/01/2026	ATTACHMENT TO COURT NOTICE	In-Person Appearance 09.11.26		Kathleen Schrider

Albany Supreme Court

2023

903081-23

Disposed

SP-CPLR Article 78 (Body or Officer)

Grand South Point, LLC d/b/a The Grand Rehabilitation and Nursing at South Point et al

HARTER SECREST & EMERY LLP

McDonald M.D., M.P.H., James V. et al

ATTORNEY GENERAL

08/14/2025

Schreibman, Hon. Julian D.

▼

Case Info

Court

Albany Supreme Court

Index Number

903081-23

Status

Disposed

Year Filed

2023

Case Name

Grand South Point, LLC d/b/a The Grand Rehabilitation and Nursing at South Point et al vs. McDonald M.D., M.P.H., James V. et al

Case Type

SP-CPLR Article 78 (Body or Officer)

Track

Standard

RJI Filed

04/07/2023

NOI Due

04/06/2024

NOI Filed

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

Schreibman, Hon. Julian D.

Next Appearance

08/14/2025

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

Grand South Point, LLC d/b/a The Grand Rehabilitation and Nursing at South Point et al

Attorney / FirmHARTER SECREST & EMERY LLP

Defendant / Respondent

McDonald M.D., M.P.H., James V. et al

Attorneys / FirmsATTORNEY GENERAL

Motions (4)

#	Date Filed	Relief Sought	Submit Date	Answer	Status	Order Signed
4	03/14/2025	Dismiss	04/16/2026	No	Decided: 04/16/2026 Granted to the Extent of the Order Before Justice: Schreibman, Hon. Julian D.	04/16/2026
3	01/12/2024	Other	01/03/2025	No	Decided: 01/03/2025 Granted Before Justice: Schreibman, Hon. Julian D.
2	10/02/2023	Dismiss	01/14/2025	No	Decided: 01/14/2025 Closed Before Justice: Schreibman, Hon. Julian D.
1	04/07/2023	Other	04/16/2026	No	Decided: 04/16/2026 Dismissed Before Justice: Schreibman, Hon. Julian D.	04/16/2026

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints (192)

Doc #	Date Filed	Document	Description	Motion #	Filing User
1	04/07/2023	PETITION			Francis Paul Greene
2	04/07/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	List of Plaintiffs		Francis Paul Greene
3	04/07/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	3/7/23 Dear Administrator Letter		Francis Paul Greene
4	04/07/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Executive Order 4		Francis Paul Greene
5	04/07/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Executive Order 4.1		Francis Paul Greene
6	04/07/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Executive Order 4.2		Francis Paul Greene
7	04/07/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Executive Order 4.3		Francis Paul Greene
8	04/07/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Executive Order 4.4		Francis Paul Greene
9	04/07/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Executive Order 4.5		Francis Paul Greene
10	04/07/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Executive Order 4.6		Francis Paul Greene
11	04/07/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Executive Order 4.7		Francis Paul Greene
12	04/07/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Executive Order 4.8		Francis Paul Greene
13	04/07/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Executive Order 4.9		Francis Paul Greene
14	04/07/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Executive Order 4.10		Francis Paul Greene
15	04/07/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Executive Order 4.11		Francis Paul Greene
16	04/07/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Executive Order 4.12		Francis Paul Greene
17	04/07/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Executive Order 4.13		Francis Paul Greene
18	04/07/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Executive Order 4.14		Francis Paul Greene
19	04/07/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Executive Order 4.15		Francis Paul Greene
20	04/07/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Executive Order 4.16		Francis Paul Greene
21	04/07/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Executive Order 4.17		Francis Paul Greene
22	04/07/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Executive Order 4.18		Francis Paul Greene
23	04/07/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Executive Order 4.19		Francis Paul Greene
24	04/07/2023	NOTICE OF PETITION		1	Francis Paul Greene
25	04/07/2023	SUMMONS WITH NOTICE (FEE PREVIOUSLY PAID)			Francis Paul Greene
26	04/07/2023	RJI -RE: NOTICE OF PETITION			Francis Paul Greene
27	04/07/2023	ADDENDUM - GENERAL (840A)			Francis Paul Greene
28	04/25/2023	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE			Francis Paul Greene
29	04/25/2023	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE			Francis Paul Greene
30	04/25/2023	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE			Francis Paul Greene
31	05/04/2023	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE	requesting first adjournment of the Article 78 return date and deadline to respond to the Complaint	1	Mark George Mitchell
32	05/05/2023	PETITION (AMENDED)			Francis Paul Greene
33	05/05/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	List of Plaintiff-Petitioners		Francis Paul Greene
34	05/05/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	3/7/23 Dear Administrator Letter		Francis Paul Greene
35	05/05/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Executive Order 4		Francis Paul Greene
36	05/05/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Executive Order 4.1		Francis Paul Greene
37	05/05/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Executive Order 4.2		Francis Paul Greene
38	05/05/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Executive Order 4.3		Francis Paul Greene
39	05/05/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Executive Order 4.4		Francis Paul Greene
40	05/05/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Executive Order 4.5		Francis Paul Greene
41	05/05/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Executive Order 4.6		Francis Paul Greene
42	05/05/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Executive Order 4.7		Francis Paul Greene
43	05/05/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Executive Order 4.8		Francis Paul Greene
44	05/05/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Executive Order 4.9		Francis Paul Greene
45	05/05/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Executive Order 4.10		Francis Paul Greene
46	05/05/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Executive Order 4.11		Francis Paul Greene
47	05/05/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Executive Order 4.12		Francis Paul Greene
48	05/05/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Executive Order 4.13		Francis Paul Greene
49	05/05/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Executive Order 4.14		Francis Paul Greene
50	05/05/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Executive Order 4.15		Francis Paul Greene
51	05/05/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Executive Order 4.16		Francis Paul Greene
52	05/05/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Executive Order 4.17		Francis Paul Greene
53	05/05/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Executive Order 4.18		Francis Paul Greene
54	05/05/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Executive Order 4.19		Francis Paul Greene
55	05/10/2023	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE	confirming first adjournment	1	Mark George Mitchell
56	06/16/2023	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE	Requesting Second Adjournment	1	Francis Paul Greene
57	06/21/2023	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE			Francis Paul Greene
58	07/25/2023	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE	requesting permission to file a Memorandum of Law that exceeds the page limit and word limit under Rule 202.8-b	1	Mark George Mitchell
59	07/25/2023	LETTER/CORRESPONDENCE - SO ORDERED		1	Teresa Thomas
60	07/26/2023	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE	Request to So Order	1	Francis Paul Greene
61	07/31/2023	LETTER/CORRESPONDENCE - SO ORDERED		1	Teresa Thomas
62	10/02/2023	NOTICE OF MOTION		2	Mark George Mitchell
63	10/02/2023	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION	of Tracy L. Hennige	2	Mark George Mitchell
64	10/02/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Comissioner and PHHPC approvals of regulation	2	Mark George Mitchell
65	10/02/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	paramount authority authorization	2	Mark George Mitchell
66	10/02/2023	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION	of Mark G. Mitchell	2	Mark George Mitchell
67	10/02/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Amended Petition/Complaint in this proceeding	2	Mark George Mitchell
68	10/02/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Corrected Decision and Order of dismissal in Grand South Point I	2	Mark George Mitchell
69	10/02/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Amended Complaint in Grand South Point I	2	Mark George Mitchell
70	10/02/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Court Notice about filing of Amended Complaint in Grand South Point I	2	Mark George Mitchell
71	10/02/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Defendants' principal Memorandum of Law in Grand South Point I	2	Mark George Mitchell
72	10/02/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Plaintiffs' Memorandum of Law in Grand South Point I	2	Mark George Mitchell
73	10/02/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Part I of 2023 Session Laws, Chapter 57	2	Mark George Mitchell
74	10/02/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Notice of Adoption in New York State Register	2	Mark George Mitchell
75	10/02/2023	MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN SUPPORT		2	Mark George Mitchell
76	10/02/2023	NO FEE AUTHORIZATION (LETTER/ORDER/AFFIRMATION)		2	Mark George Mitchell
77	10/02/2023	PROOF OF SERVICE		2	Mark George Mitchell
78	12/14/2023	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE		1	Francis Paul Greene
79	12/18/2023	ORDER - CASE SCHEDULING	Scheduling Order		Teresa Thomas
80	01/12/2024	NOTICE OF MOTION		3	Francis Paul Greene
81	01/12/2024	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION		3	Francis Paul Greene
82	01/12/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Verified Petition and Complaint	3	Francis Paul Greene
83	01/12/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Amended Verified Petition and Complaint	3	Francis Paul Greene
84	01/12/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	6/16/23 Letter	3	Francis Paul Greene
85	01/12/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	6/21/23 Letter	3	Francis Paul Greene
86	01/12/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	7/26/23 So-Ordered Letter	3	Francis Paul Greene
87	01/12/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Defendants' Notice of Motion to Dismiss	3	Francis Paul Greene
88	01/12/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Email Correspondence re proposed amended pleading	3	Francis Paul Greene
89	01/12/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	12/14/23 Letter	3	Francis Paul Greene
90	01/12/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Proposed Second Amended Verified Petition and Complaint	3	Francis Paul Greene
91	01/12/2024	MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN SUPPORT		3	Francis Paul Greene
92	02/07/2024	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE	requesting adjournment of deadlines for Plaintiffs-Petitioners' motion for leave to amend, on consent	3	Mark George Mitchell
93	02/08/2024	LETTER/CORRESPONDENCE - SO ORDERED		3	Teresa Thomas
94	02/23/2024	MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN OPPOSITION		3	Mark George Mitchell
95	02/23/2024	PROOF OF SERVICE		3	Mark George Mitchell
96	03/18/2024	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE	Request to So Order		Francis Paul Greene
97	03/20/2024	LETTER/CORRESPONDENCE - SO ORDERED		3	Teresa Thomas
98	03/28/2024	MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN REPLY		3	Francis Paul Greene
99	07/16/2024	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE	providing status update and addressing impact of the Appellate Division's Opinion and Order	1	Mark George Mitchell
100	07/17/2024	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE	Status Update		Francis Paul Greene
101	07/17/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	6/14/24 DAL		Francis Paul Greene
102	09/26/2024	COURT NOTICE			Teresa Thomas
103	10/22/2024	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE	Request to So Order		Francis Paul Greene
104	10/24/2024	COURT NOTICE			Teresa Thomas
105	12/31/2024	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE		3	Francis Paul Greene
106	01/09/2025	ORDER ( PROPOSED )		3	Francis Paul Greene
107	01/10/2025	COMPLAINT (AMENDED)	Second Amended Verified Petition & Complaint		Francis Paul Greene
108	01/10/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Plaintiffs		Francis Paul Greene
109	01/10/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	FAQs		Francis Paul Greene
110	01/10/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Medicaid Global Spending Cap Report		Francis Paul Greene
111	01/10/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	3/7/23 DAL		Francis Paul Greene
112	01/10/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Lutheran Article		Francis Paul Greene
113	01/10/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	EO 4		Francis Paul Greene
114	01/10/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	EO 4.1		Francis Paul Greene
115	01/10/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	EO 4.2		Francis Paul Greene
116	01/10/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	EO 4.3		Francis Paul Greene
117	01/10/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	EO 4.4		Francis Paul Greene
118	01/10/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	EO 4.5		Francis Paul Greene
119	01/10/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	EO 4.6		Francis Paul Greene
120	01/10/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	EO 4.7		Francis Paul Greene
121	01/10/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	EO 4.8		Francis Paul Greene
122	01/10/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	EO 4.9		Francis Paul Greene
123	01/10/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	EO 4.10		Francis Paul Greene
124	01/10/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	EO 4.11		Francis Paul Greene
125	01/10/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	EO 4.12		Francis Paul Greene
126	01/10/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	EO 4.13		Francis Paul Greene
127	01/10/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	EO 4.14		Francis Paul Greene
128	01/10/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	EO 4.15		Francis Paul Greene
129	01/10/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	EO 4.16		Francis Paul Greene
130	01/10/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	EO 4.17		Francis Paul Greene
131	01/10/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	EO 4.18		Francis Paul Greene
132	01/10/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	EO 4.19		Francis Paul Greene
133	01/10/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	EO 4.20		Francis Paul Greene
134	01/10/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	EO 4.21		Francis Paul Greene
135	01/10/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	EO 4.22		Francis Paul Greene
136	01/10/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Commissioner's Determination		Francis Paul Greene
137	01/10/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	9/11/23 DAL		Francis Paul Greene
138	01/10/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	12/21/23 DAL		Francis Paul Greene
139	01/14/2025	ORDER - CASE SCHEDULING			Teresa Thomas
140	01/14/2025	DECISION + ORDER ON MOTION		3	Teresa Thomas
141	03/14/2025	NOTICE OF MOTION		4	Mark George Mitchell
142	03/14/2025	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION	of Valerie A. Deetz	4	Mark George Mitchell
143	03/14/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Commissioner and Council approvals	4	Mark George Mitchell
144	03/14/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Paramount authority authorization	4	Mark George Mitchell
145	03/14/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	State Plan Amendment approval	4	Mark George Mitchell
146	03/14/2025	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION	of Mark G. Mitchell	4	Mark George Mitchell
147	03/14/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Second Amended Petition/Complaint	4	Mark George Mitchell
148	03/14/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Grand South Point I Corrected Decision and Order	4	Mark George Mitchell
149	03/14/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Amended Complaint in Grand South Point I	4	Mark George Mitchell
150	03/14/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Court notice about filing Amended Complaint	4	Mark George Mitchell
151	03/14/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Defendants' Memorandum of Law in Grand South Point I	4	Mark George Mitchell
152	03/14/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Plaintiffs' Memorandum of Law in Grand South Point I	4	Mark George Mitchell
153	03/14/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Appellate Division's Opinion and Order in Grand South Point I	4	Mark George Mitchell
154	03/14/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Plaintiffs' appellate brief	4	Mark George Mitchell
155	03/14/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Defendants' appellate brief	4	Mark George Mitchell
156	03/14/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Plaintiffs' reply appellate brief	4	Mark George Mitchell
157	03/14/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Defendants' appellate post-argument submission	4	Mark George Mitchell
158	03/14/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Plaintiffs' appellate post-argument submission	4	Mark George Mitchell
159	03/14/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Part I, 2023 Session Laws, Chapter 57	4	Mark George Mitchell
160	03/14/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Notice of Adoption, State Register	4	Mark George Mitchell
161	03/14/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	CMS approval of state plan amendment	4	Mark George Mitchell
162	03/14/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Decision and Order in LeadingAge case	4	Mark George Mitchell
163	03/14/2025	MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN SUPPORT		4	Mark George Mitchell
164	03/14/2025	NO FEE AUTHORIZATION (LETTER/ORDER/AFFIRMATION)		4	Mark George Mitchell
165	03/14/2025	PROOF OF SERVICE		4	Mark George Mitchell
166	04/15/2025	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE	Request to So Order		Francis Paul Greene
167	04/21/2025	LETTER/CORRESPONDENCE - SO ORDERED		4	Teresa Thomas
168	04/29/2025	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE	Request to So Order		Francis Paul Greene
169	04/30/2025	LETTER/CORRESPONDENCE - SO ORDERED		4	Teresa Thomas
170	05/23/2025	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION	Attorney Affirmation	4	Francis Paul Greene
171	05/23/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	SPA Application	4	Francis Paul Greene
172	05/23/2025	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION	Murray Affidavit	4	Francis Paul Greene
173	05/23/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Quality Pool Top-Performing Nursing Homes	4	Francis Paul Greene
174	05/23/2025	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION	Kaufman Affirmation	4	Francis Paul Greene
175	05/23/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Seagate Nursing Home Staffing Supplemental	4	Francis Paul Greene
176	05/23/2025	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION	Curletta Affidavit	4	Francis Paul Greene
177	05/23/2025	MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN OPPOSITION		4	Francis Paul Greene
178	05/28/2025	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE	requesting, on consent, a new deadline for Defendants-Respondents to file their reply papers, as well as an adjournment of the oral argument currently scheduled for June 2, 2025	4	Mark George Mitchell
179	05/29/2025	LETTER/CORRESPONDENCE - SO ORDERED	Granting adjournment and setting forth new date for oral argument	4	Teresa Thomas
180	07/01/2025	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN REPLY	of Mark G. Mitchell	4	Mark George Mitchell
181	07/01/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Plaintiffs-Petitioners' motion for leave to appeal to the Court of Appeals in Grand South Point I	4	Mark George Mitchell
182	07/01/2025	MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN REPLY		4	Mark George Mitchell
183	07/01/2025	PROOF OF SERVICE		4	Mark George Mitchell
184	01/08/2026	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE			Francis Paul Greene
185	01/16/2026	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE	Plaintiffs-Petitioners' filing at Dkt. No. 184 should not be considered		Mark George Mitchell
186	01/20/2026	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE	1/20/26 Letter to Justice Schreibman	4	Francis Paul Greene
187	04/16/2026	DECISION + ORDER ON MOTION	Decision, Order & Judgment	1	Teresa Thomas
188	04/16/2026	DECISION + ORDER ON MOTION	Decision, Order & Judgment	4	Teresa Thomas
189	04/17/2026	NOTICE OF ENTRY		4	Mark George Mitchell
190	04/17/2026	PROOF OF SERVICE		4	Mark George Mitchell
191	05/12/2026	NOTICE OF APPEAL			Francis Paul Greene
192	05/20/2026	OTHER COURT FILED DOCUMENT	COPY NOTICE OF APPEAL D/O/J EXHIBITS SENT TO APP DIV		Albany Wsuser

Monroe Supreme Court

2023

E2022010777

Disposed

Comm-Business Entity

Owen, Christine

Harris Beach Murtha Cullina PLLC

Hurlbut, Robert W et al

PULLANO & FARROW

08/20/2024

Ciaccio, Hon. Christopher S.

▼

Case Info

Court

Monroe Supreme Court

Index Number

E2022010777

Status

Disposed

Year Filed

2023

Case Name

Case Type

Comm-Business Entity

Track

RJI Filed

NOI Due

NOI Filed

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

Ciaccio, Hon. Christopher S.

Next Appearance

08/20/2024

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

Owen, Christine

Attorney / FirmHarris Beach Murtha Cullina PLLC

Defendant / Respondent

Hurlbut, Robert W et al

Attorneys / FirmsPULLANO & FARROW

Motions

No motions recorded for this case.

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints

No eFiled documents available for this case.

Monroe Supreme Court

2023

E2023001460

Disposed

Comm-Contract

The Hurlbut, LLC.

Catholic Charities of the Diocese of Rochester d/b/a Catholic Charities Family and Community Services, Guardian for John F. Vassallo, an Incapacitated Person et al

ROBERT G. TRUSIAK, ATTORNEY AT LAW

11/28/2023

Doyle, Hon. Daniel J.

▼

Case Info

Court

Monroe Supreme Court

Index Number

E2023001460

Status

Disposed

Year Filed

2023

Case Name

Case Type

Comm-Contract

Track

RJI Filed

NOI Due

NOI Filed

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

Doyle, Hon. Daniel J.

Next Appearance

11/28/2023

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

The Hurlbut, LLC.

Attorney / Firm

Defendant / Respondent

Catholic Charities of the Diocese of Rochester d/b/a Catholic Charities Family and Community Services, Guardian for John F. Vassallo, an Incapacitated Person et al

Attorneys / FirmsROBERT G. TRUSIAK, ATTORNEY AT LAW

Motions

No motions recorded for this case.

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints

No eFiled documents available for this case.

Monroe Supreme Court

2023

E2023002281

Disposed

Comm-Contract

The Hurlbut, LLC

LAW OFFICES OF PULLANO & FARROW PLLC

Sherry, Mary Rita et al

02/11/2025

Doyle, Hon. Daniel J.

▼

Case Info

Court

Monroe Supreme Court

Index Number

E2023002281

Status

Disposed

Year Filed

2023

Case Name

Case Type

Comm-Contract

Track

RJI Filed

NOI Due

NOI Filed

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

Doyle, Hon. Daniel J.

Next Appearance

02/11/2025

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

The Hurlbut, LLC

Attorney / FirmLAW OFFICES OF PULLANO & FARROW PLLC

Defendant / Respondent

Sherry, Mary Rita et al

Attorneys / Firms

Motions

No motions recorded for this case.

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints

No eFiled documents available for this case.

Oneida Supreme Court

2023

EFCA2022-000705

Disposed

Tort

Vaccaro, James

Passalacqua & Associates LLC

Hawkins & Hurlbut Sanitation

Smith, Sovik, Kendrick & Sugnet, P.C.

03/28/2024

Clark, Hon. Bernadette T.

▼

Case Info

Court

Oneida Supreme Court

Index Number

EFCA2022-000705

Status

Disposed

Year Filed

2023

Case Name

Case Type

Tort-Motor Vehicle

Track

RJI Filed

NOI Due

NOI Filed

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

Clark, Hon. Bernadette T.

Next Appearance

03/28/2024

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

Vaccaro, James

Attorney / FirmPassalacqua & Associates LLC

Defendant / Respondent

Hawkins & Hurlbut Sanitation

Attorneys / FirmsSmith, Sovik, Kendrick & Sugnet, P.C.

Motions

No motions recorded for this case.

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints

No eFiled documents available for this case.

Erie Supreme Court

2022

810469/2021

Disposed

Negligence

NEUREUTHER, JOANNE

BROWN CHIARI LLP

THE UNITY HOSPITAL OF ROCHESTER et al

OSBORN, REED & BURKE, LLP

03/23/2026

Siwek, Hon. Donna M.

▼

Case Info

Court

Erie Supreme Court

Index Number

810469/2021

Status

Disposed

Year Filed

2022

Case Name

NEUREUTHER, JOANNE vs. THE UNITY HOSPITAL OF ROCHESTER et al

Case Type

Tort-Other Negligence

Track

Standard

RJI Filed

05/31/2022

NOI Due

05/31/2023

NOI Filed

02/28/2025

Calendar Number

2025-0448

Jury Status

Jury At Plaintiff's Request

Justice

Siwek, Hon. Donna M.

Next Appearance

03/23/2026

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

NEUREUTHER, JOANNE

Attorney / FirmBROWN CHIARI LLP

Defendant / Respondent

THE UNITY HOSPITAL OF ROCHESTER et al

Attorneys / FirmsOSBORN, REED & BURKE, LLP

Motions (1)

#	Date Filed	Filed By	Relief Sought	Submit Date	Answer	Status	Decision	Order Signed
1	03/01/2023		Strike Pleadings	03/28/2023	No	Decided: 03/28/2023 Withdrawn Before Justice: Siwek, Hon. Donna M.

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints (31)

Doc #	Date Filed	Document	Description	Motion #	Filing User
1	07/30/2021	SUMMONS + COMPLAINT			Theresa M Walsh
2	08/23/2021	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Rochester General Health System		Theresa M Walsh
3	08/23/2021	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Rohm Services Corp		Theresa M Walsh
4	08/23/2021	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	The Hurlbut LLC		Theresa M Walsh
5	08/23/2021	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	The Unity Hospital of Rochester		Theresa M Walsh
6	08/23/2021	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Rochester Regional Health		Theresa M Walsh
7	08/23/2021	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	The Hurlbut LLC d/b/a The Hurlbut		Theresa M Walsh
8	08/23/2021	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Hurlbut Care Communities		Theresa M Walsh
9	08/23/2021	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Robert W. Hurlbut		Theresa M Walsh
10	09/07/2021	ANSWER WITH CROSS-CLAIM(S)			Mallory Kass Smith
11	09/22/2021	ANSWER WITH CROSS-CLAIM(S)	Answer w.x-claim (Unity, RGH, RRH)		Christian Carlo Casini
12	09/22/2021	DEMAND FOR BILL OF PARTICULARS			Christian Carlo Casini
13	09/22/2021	DEMAND FOR:	Art. 31 Discl. Demands		Christian Carlo Casini
14	09/22/2021	DEMAND FOR:	Demand for Medicaid.Medicare Lien Info		Christian Carlo Casini
15	09/22/2021	NOTICE OF DEPOSITION UPON ORAL EXAMINATION			Christian Carlo Casini
16	09/22/2021	AFFIDAVIT			Christian Carlo Casini
17	05/31/2022	RJI -RE: OTHER	court conference to discuss discovery dispute		Mallory Kass Smith
18	02/22/2023	ORDER - CASE SCHEDULING			Roxanne M. Jones
19	03/01/2023	NOTICE OF MOTION		001	Michael Francis Higgins
20	03/01/2023	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT		001	Michael Francis Higgins
21	03/01/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Defendants Combined Discovery Demands	001	Michael Francis Higgins
22	03/01/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Good faith Letter August 22 22	001	Michael Francis Higgins
23	03/01/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Good Faith Letter September 16 22	001	Michael Francis Higgins
24	03/01/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Meet and Confer Request	001	Michael Francis Higgins
25	03/01/2023	MEMORANDUM OF LAW		001	Michael Francis Higgins
26	03/28/2023	NOTICE OF WITHDRAWAL OF MOTION / ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE		001	Michael Francis Higgins
27	07/23/2024	NOTICE OF APPEARANCE (POST RJI)			Paul Francis Keneally
28	02/28/2025	NOTE OF ISSUE:WITH JURY			Theresa M Walsh
29	04/01/2025	STIPULATION - DISCONTINUANCE (POST RJI)			Paul Francis Keneally
30	04/01/2025	ORDER - REFERENCE TO ADR			Roxanne M. Jones
31	04/16/2026	STIPULATION - DISCONTINUANCE (POST RJI)			Aimee La Fever Koch

Livingston Supreme Court

2022

000813-2021

Active

Negligence

Hynes, Johanna as Proposed Executrix

BROWN CHIARI LLP

Conesus Lake Nursing Home et al

LAW OFFICES OF PULLANO & FARROW PLLC

07/27/2026

Van Allen, Hon. Kevin

▼

Case Info

Court

Livingston Supreme Court

Index Number

000813-2021

Status

Active

Year Filed

2022

Case Name

Hynes, Johanna as Proposed Executrix vs. Conesus Lake Nursing Home et al

Case Type

Tort-Other Negligence

Track

Standard

RJI Filed

11/28/2022

NOI Due

10/02/2023

NOI Filed

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

Van Allen, Hon. Kevin

Next Appearance

07/27/2026

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

Hynes, Johanna as Proposed Executrix

Attorney / FirmBROWN CHIARI LLP

Defendant / Respondent

Conesus Lake Nursing Home et al

Attorneys / FirmsLAW OFFICES OF PULLANO & FARROW PLLC

Motions

No motions recorded for this case.

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints (57)

Doc #	Date Filed	Document	Description	Filing User
1	10/01/2021	SUMMONS + COMPLAINT		Theresa M Walsh
2	12/22/2021	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Conesus Lake NH	Theresa M Walsh
3	12/22/2021	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Hurlbut Care Communities	Theresa M Walsh
4	12/22/2021	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Robert Hurlbut	Theresa M Walsh
5	12/22/2021	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Rohm Service Corp.	Theresa M Walsh
6	01/03/2022	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Conesus Lake NH LLC	Theresa M Walsh
7	01/06/2022	ANSWER		Mallory Kass Smith
8	11/28/2022	RJI -RE: REQUEST FOR PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE	request for Court Conference to set a deadline for plaintiffs discovery responses.	Mallory Kass Smith
9	02/01/2023	COURT NOTICE		Dina M Provo
9-1	02/01/2023	ATTACHMENT TO COURT NOTICE	Virtual appearance information for 2.7.23	Dina M Provo
10	02/24/2023	ORDER ( PROPOSED )	Proposed Scheduling Order	Mallory Kass Smith
11	02/27/2023	ORDER - CASE SCHEDULING		Theresa M Bancroft
12	07/17/2023	COURT NOTICE		Kathleen Schrider
12-1	07/17/2023	ATTACHMENT TO COURT NOTICE		Kathleen Schrider
13	09/18/2023	COURT NOTICE		Kathleen Schrider
13-1	09/18/2023	ATTACHMENT TO COURT NOTICE		Kathleen Schrider
14	10/04/2023	ORDER ( PROPOSED )		Mallory Kass Smith
15	10/11/2023	ORDER - CASE SCHEDULING	Amended Scheduling Order	Theresa M Bancroft
16	11/14/2023	COURT NOTICE		Kathleen Schrider
16-1	11/14/2023	ATTACHMENT TO COURT NOTICE	NTA 01.02.24 Virtual Appearance	Kathleen Schrider
17	01/02/2024	COURT NOTICE		Kathleen Schrider
17-1	01/02/2024	ATTACHMENT TO COURT NOTICE	NTA 03.08.24 Virtual Appearance	Kathleen Schrider
18	03/11/2024	COURT NOTICE		Kathleen Schrider
18-1	03/11/2024	ATTACHMENT TO COURT NOTICE	NTA 05.13.24 Virtual Appearance	Kathleen Schrider
19	05/14/2024	COURT NOTICE		Kathleen Schrider
19-1	05/14/2024	ATTACHMENT TO COURT NOTICE	NTA 07.08.24 Virtual Appearance	Kathleen Schrider
20	07/08/2024	COURT NOTICE		Kathleen Schrider
20-1	07/08/2024	ATTACHMENT TO COURT NOTICE	NTA 09.23.24 Virtual Appearance	Kathleen Schrider
21	07/23/2024	NOTICE OF APPEARANCE (POST RJI)		Paul Francis Keneally
22	09/23/2024	COURT NOTICE		Kathleen Schrider
22-1	09/23/2024	ATTACHMENT TO COURT NOTICE	NTA 12.09.24 Virtual Appearance	Kathleen Schrider
23	10/15/2024	STIPULATION - DISCONTINUANCE (POST RJI)	Stipulation of Discontinuance with Prejudice as Against Defendant ROHM Services Corporation Only	Paul Francis Keneally
24	12/10/2024	COURT NOTICE		Kathleen Schrider
24-1	12/10/2024	ATTACHMENT TO COURT NOTICE	NTA 02.24.25 Virtual Appearance	Kathleen Schrider
25	02/24/2025	COURT NOTICE		Louis D. Annunziata
25-1	02/24/2025	ATTACHMENT TO COURT NOTICE	Virtual Appearance Notice 04.21.25.	Louis D. Annunziata
26	03/14/2025	COURT NOTICE		Daisy Renz
26-1	03/14/2025	ATTACHMENT TO COURT NOTICE	NTA Virtual Appearance 04.21.25	Daisy Renz
27	04/22/2025	COURT NOTICE		Kathleen Schrider
27-1	04/22/2025	ATTACHMENT TO COURT NOTICE	NTA 05.19.25 Virtual Appearance	Kathleen Schrider
28	05/20/2025	COURT NOTICE		Kathleen Schrider
28-1	05/20/2025	ATTACHMENT TO COURT NOTICE	NTA 07.14.25 Virtual Appearance	Kathleen Schrider
29	07/15/2025	COURT NOTICE		Kathleen Schrider
29-1	07/15/2025	ATTACHMENT TO COURT NOTICE	NTA 08.18.25 Virtual Appearance	Kathleen Schrider
30	08/25/2025	COURT NOTICE		Louis D. Annunziata
30-1	08/25/2025	ATTACHMENT TO COURT NOTICE	Virtual Appearance Notice 10.27.25.	Louis D. Annunziata
31	10/28/2025	COURT NOTICE		Kathleen Schrider
31-1	10/28/2025	ATTACHMENT TO COURT NOTICE	NTA 12.08.25 Virtual Appearance	Kathleen Schrider
32	12/09/2025	COURT NOTICE		Kathleen Schrider
33	12/22/2025	COURT NOTICE		Daisy Renz
33-1	12/22/2025	ATTACHMENT TO COURT NOTICE	NTA Virtual Appearance 03.09.26	Daisy Renz
34	03/02/2026	COURT NOTICE		Louis D. Annunziata
34-1	03/02/2026	ATTACHMENT TO COURT NOTICE	Virtual Appearance Notice 04.20.26	Louis D. Annunziata
35	04/21/2026	COURT NOTICE		Louis D. Annunziata
35-1	04/21/2026	ATTACHMENT TO COURT NOTICE	Virtual Appearance Notice 06.15.26	Louis D. Annunziata
36	06/12/2026	COURT NOTICE		Kathleen Schrider
36-1	06/12/2026	ATTACHMENT TO COURT NOTICE	NTA 07.27.26 Virtual Appearance	Kathleen Schrider

Monroe Supreme Court

2022

E2019008665

Disposed

Comm-Contract

THE HURLBUT, LLC

Pullano & Farrow PLLC

SCHOTTMILLER, DAWN

LACY KATZEN LLP

03/14/2023

Doyle, Hon. Daniel J.

▼

Case Info

Court

Monroe Supreme Court

Index Number

E2019008665

Status

Disposed

Year Filed

2022

Case Name

THE HURLBUT, LLC vs. SCHOTTMILLER, DAWN

Case Type

Comm-Contract

Track

Standard

RJI Filed

07/12/2022

NOI Due

07/12/2023

NOI Filed

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

Doyle, Hon. Daniel J.

Next Appearance

03/14/2023

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

THE HURLBUT, LLC

Attorney / FirmPullano & Farrow PLLC

Defendant / Respondent

SCHOTTMILLER, DAWN

Attorneys / FirmsLACY KATZEN LLP

Motions (1)

#	Date Filed	Filed By	Relief Sought	Submit Date	Answer	Status	Decision	Order Signed
1	07/12/2022		Other	08/23/2022	No	Decided: 08/29/2022 Denied Before Justice: Doyle, Hon. Daniel J.	Short Form Order	08/29/2022

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints (37)

Doc #	Date Filed	Document	Description	Motion #	Filing User
1	09/11/2019	SUMMONS + COMPLAINT			Michael Paul Scott-Kristansen
2	09/11/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	Admission Agreement		Michael Paul Scott-Kristansen
3	09/11/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	Billing Statement		Michael Paul Scott-Kristansen
4	09/25/2019	PROOF OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service (CPLR 3215) - Dawn Schottmiller		Michael Paul Scott-Kristansen
5	10/03/2019	PROOF OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service - Dawn Schottmiller		Michael Paul Scott-Kristansen
6	11/19/2019	ANSWER			Michael Joseph Wegman
7	12/09/2019	ANSWER (AMENDED)			Mark H Stein
8	11/10/2021	SUMMONS AND INTERPLEADER COMPLAINT - CPLR 1006(b)			David D. Macknight
9	11/10/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Complaint (Hurlbut)		David D. Macknight
10	11/10/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Amended Answer		David D. Macknight
11	11/10/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	MCDSS Determination		David D. Macknight
12	11/10/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Power of Attorney		David D. Macknight
13	11/12/2021	SUMMONS AND INTERPLEADER COMPLAINT - CPLR 1006(b)	Exhibits filed on 11/10/21 remain the same		David D. Macknight
14	11/16/2021	ANSWER TO THIRD PARTY COMPLAINT			Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
15	11/24/2021	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE			David D. Macknight
16	11/24/2021	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE			David D. Macknight
17	07/12/2022	NOTICE OF MOTION	Notice of Motion to Dismiss Third-Party Complaint	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
18	07/12/2022	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION		1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
19	07/12/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Power of Attorney	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
20	07/12/2022	MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN SUPPORT		1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
21	07/12/2022	PROOF OF SERVICE		1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
22	07/12/2022	RJI -RE: OTHER	Dismiss Third-Party Complaint	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
23	07/28/2022	PROOF OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
24	08/16/2022	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION		1	David D. Macknight
25	08/16/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Email 7/29/21 fr. Atty. MacKnight to Atty. McDonald	1	David D. Macknight
26	08/16/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Email 7/29/21 from Atty. McDonald to Atty. MacKnight	1	David D. Macknight
27	08/16/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Email 8/31/21 fr. Atty. MacDonald to Atty. MacKnight	1	David D. Macknight
28	08/16/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Revised Notice	1	David D. Macknight
29	08/16/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Statement from Westgate	1	David D. Macknight
30	08/16/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Complaint	1	David D. Macknight
31	08/16/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Amended Summons & Amended Interpleader Complaint	1	David D. Macknight
32	08/16/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Answer to Amended 3rd Party Complaint	1	David D. Macknight
33	08/16/2022	MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN OPPOSITION		1	David D. Macknight
34	08/29/2022	ORDER - DISMISSAL	DISMISS 3RD PARTY COMPLAINT	1	Sue Lerkins
35	12/13/2022	NOTICE OF APPEARANCE (POST RJI)			Langston David Mcfadden
36	01/03/2023	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE			Langston David Mcfadden
37	03/07/2023	STIPULATION - DISCONTINUANCE (POST RJI)	Stipulation of Discontinuance		Langston David Mcfadden

Monroe Supreme Court

2022

E2021007193

Disposed

Negligence

CARTWRIGHT, CHERYL A.

BROWN CHIARI LLP

HORNELL GARDENS NURSING & REHABILITATION et al

LAW OFFICES OF PULLANO & FARROW PLLC

07/27/2023

Dinolfo, Hon. Vincent

▼

Case Info

Court

Monroe Supreme Court

Index Number

E2021007193

Status

Disposed

Year Filed

2022

Case Name

CARTWRIGHT, CHERYL A. vs. HORNELL GARDENS NURSING & REHABILITATION et al

Case Type

Tort-Other Negligence

Track

Standard

RJI Filed

08/15/2022

NOI Due

08/15/2023

NOI Filed

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

Dinolfo, Hon. Vincent

Next Appearance

07/27/2023

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

CARTWRIGHT, CHERYL A.

Attorney / FirmBROWN CHIARI LLP

Defendant / Respondent

HORNELL GARDENS NURSING & REHABILITATION et al

Attorneys / FirmsLAW OFFICES OF PULLANO & FARROW PLLC

Motions (1)

#	Date Filed	Filed By	Relief Sought	Submit Date	Answer	Status	Decision	Order Signed
1	09/05/2023		Approve Settlement	10/05/2023	No	Decided: 10/05/2023 Granted Before Justice: Dinolfo, Hon. Vincent	Short Form Order	10/05/2023

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints (24)

Doc #	Date Filed	Document	Description	Motion #	Filing User
1	08/03/2021	SUMMONS + COMPLAINT			Theresa M Walsh
2	09/13/2021	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE			Jeffrey Michael Shalke
3	09/13/2021	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE			Jeffrey Michael Shalke
4	09/13/2021	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE			Jeffrey Michael Shalke
5	09/13/2021	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE			Jeffrey Michael Shalke
6	09/16/2021	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE			Jeffrey Michael Shalke
7	09/16/2021	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE			Jeffrey Michael Shalke
8	09/16/2021	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE			Jeffrey Michael Shalke
9	09/20/2021	ANSWER			Mallory Kass Smith
10	08/15/2022	RJI -RE: REQUEST FOR PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE			Jeffrey Michael Shalke
11	08/16/2022	ORDER - CASE SCHEDULING			Donna Brett
12	09/05/2023	NOTICE OF PETITION		1	Michael Christopher Scinta
13	09/05/2023	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT	Petition of Cheryl Cartwright	1	Michael Christopher Scinta
14	09/05/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Death Certificate	1	Michael Christopher Scinta
15	09/05/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Medicare File Closure Letter	1	Michael Christopher Scinta
16	09/05/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Optum Final Demand	1	Michael Christopher Scinta
17	09/05/2023	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT	Affirmation of Michael C. Scinta, Esq.	1	Michael Christopher Scinta
18	09/05/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Letters Testamentary	1	Michael Christopher Scinta
19	09/05/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Medicare File Closure Letter	1	Michael Christopher Scinta
20	09/05/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Optum Final Demand	1	Michael Christopher Scinta
21	09/05/2023	ORDER ( PROPOSED )		1	Michael Christopher Scinta
22	10/06/2023	ORDER - OTHER			Sheena Ruff
23	11/13/2023	STIPULATION - DISCONTINUANCE (POST RJI)			Mallory Kass Smith
24	01/18/2024	ORDER - AMENDED			Donna Brett

Monroe Supreme Court

2022

E2022000707

Disposed

Comm-Contract

The Hurlbut, LLC

Pullano & Farrow PLLC

Miller, Robert

Valleriani, Hon. Sam L.

▼

Case Info

Court

Monroe Supreme Court

Index Number

E2022000707

Status

Disposed

Year Filed

2022

Case Name

The Hurlbut, LLC vs. Miller, Robert

Case Type

Comm-Contract

Track

Standard

RJI Filed

01/28/2022

NOI Due

01/28/2023

NOI Filed

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

Valleriani, Hon. Sam L.

Next Appearance

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

The Hurlbut, LLC

Attorney / FirmPullano & Farrow PLLC

Defendant / Respondent

Miller, Robert

Attorneys / Firms

Motions (1)

#	Date Filed	Filed By	Relief Sought	Submit Date	Answer	Status	Decision	Order Signed
1	01/28/2022		Judgment - Summary in Lieu of Complaint		No

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints (6)

Doc #	Date Filed	Document	Description	Filing User
1	01/28/2022	SUMMONS		Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
2	01/28/2022	NOTICE OF MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT IN LIEU OF COMPLAINT		Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
3	01/28/2022	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION		Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
4	01/28/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Judgment entered December 27, 2010	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
5	01/28/2022	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION	Affidavit of Anne Clayton	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
6	01/28/2022	RJI -RE: NOTICE OF MOTION		Ryan Joseph Mcdonald

Monroe Supreme Court

2022

E2022001940

Disposed

Comm-Contract

The Hurlbut, LLC

Pullano & Farrow PLLC

Werner, Mark

11/17/2022

Valleriani, Hon. Sam L.

▼

Case Info

Court

Monroe Supreme Court

Index Number

E2022001940

Status

Disposed

Year Filed

2022

Case Name

The Hurlbut, LLC vs. Werner, Mark

Case Type

Comm-Contract

Track

Standard

RJI Filed

09/29/2022

NOI Due

09/29/2023

NOI Filed

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

Valleriani, Hon. Sam L.

Next Appearance

11/17/2022

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

The Hurlbut, LLC

Attorney / FirmPullano & Farrow PLLC

Defendant / Respondent

Werner, Mark

Attorneys / Firms

Motions (1)

#	Date Filed	Filed By	Relief Sought	Submit Date	Answer	Status	Decision	Order Signed
1	09/29/2022		Judgment - Default	08/29/2023	No	Decided: 08/29/2023 Closed Before Justice: Valleriani, Hon. Sam L.	Short Form Order

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints (22)

Doc #	Date Filed	Document	Description	Motion #	Filing User
1	03/17/2022	SUMMONS + COMPLAINT			Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
2	03/17/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Power of Attorney document		Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
3	03/17/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Admission Agreement		Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
4	03/17/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Itemized Statement		Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
5	05/04/2022	PROOF OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service		Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
6	05/18/2022	PROOF OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service and Notice Pursuant to CPLR 3215		Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
7	09/29/2022	NOTICE OF MOTION		1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
8	09/29/2022	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION		1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
9	09/29/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Summons and Complaint	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
10	09/29/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Admission Agreement	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
11	09/29/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Affidavit of Service	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
12	09/29/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Affidavit of Service and CPLR 3215(g)(3) Notice	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
13	09/29/2022	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION	Affidavit of Anne Clayton	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
14	09/29/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	monthly statements	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
15	09/29/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Account statement	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
16	09/29/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Account statement	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
17	09/29/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Medicaid Budget Letters	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
18	09/29/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Admission Agreement	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
19	09/29/2022	MEMORANDUM OF LAW		1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
20	09/29/2022	RJI -RE: NOTICE OF MOTION		1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
21	10/14/2022	PROOF OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
22	12/19/2022	NOTICE OF APPEARANCE (POST RJI)			Langston David Mcfadden

Monroe Supreme Court

2022

E2022002226

Active

Negligence

SWEATMAN, KAREN

BROWN CHIARI LLP

THE HURLBUT et al

LAW OFFICES OF PULLANO & FARROW PLLC

07/09/2026

Skinner, Hon. Erin S.

▼

Case Info

Court

Monroe Supreme Court

Index Number

E2022002226

Status

Active

Year Filed

2022

Case Name

SWEATMAN, KAREN vs. THE HURLBUT et al

Case Type

Tort-Other Negligence

Track

Standard

RJI Filed

10/18/2022

NOI Due

06/26/2025

NOI Filed

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

Skinner, Hon. Erin S.

Next Appearance

07/09/2026

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

SWEATMAN, KAREN

Attorney / FirmBROWN CHIARI LLP

Defendant / Respondent

THE HURLBUT et al

Attorneys / FirmsLAW OFFICES OF PULLANO & FARROW PLLC

Motions (2)

#	Date Filed	Filed By	Relief Sought	Submit Date	Answer	Status	Decision	Order Signed
2	03/21/2023		Dismiss	06/23/2023	No	Decided: 06/23/2023 Granted to the Extent of the Order Before Justice: Colaiacovo, Hon. Emilio L.
1	10/18/2022		Dismiss	03/20/2023	No	Decided: 03/20/2023 Withdrawn Before Justice: Colaiacovo, Hon. Emilio L.

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints (83)

Doc #	Date Filed	Document	Description	Motion #	Filing User
1	03/25/2022	SUMMONS + COMPLAINT			Theresa M Walsh
2	07/15/2022	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	ROHM Services Corp		Theresa M Walsh
3	07/15/2022	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	The Hurlbut LLC		Theresa M Walsh
4	10/07/2022	STIPULATION - TIME TO ANSWER			Mallory Kass Smith
5	10/18/2022	NOTICE OF MOTION		1	Mallory Kass Smith
6	10/18/2022	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT	Affirmation of Mallory Smith, Esq. in support of Motion to dismiss	1	Mallory Kass Smith
7	10/18/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	42 U.S.C.A. 247d-6d	1	Mallory Kass Smith
8	10/18/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Declaration Under the Public Readiness and Emergency Preparedness Act for Medical Countermeasures Against COVID19	1	Mallory Kass Smith
9	10/18/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	1 ADVISORY OPINION ON THE PUBLIC READINESS AND EMERGENCY PREPAREDNESS ACT AND THE MARCH 10, 2020 DECLARATION UNDER THE ACT APRIL 17, 2020, AS MODIFIED ON MAY 19, 2020	1	Mallory Kass Smith
10	10/18/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	ADVISORY OPINION 20-04 ON THE PUBLIC READINESS AND EMERGENCY PREPAREDNESS ACT AND THE SECRETARYS DECLARATION UNDER THE ACT OCTOBER 22, 2020, AS MODIFIED ON OCTOBER 23, 2020	1	Mallory Kass Smith
11	10/18/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	ADVISORY OPINION 21-01 ON THE PUBLIC READINESS AND EMERGENCY PREPAREDNESS ACT SCOPE OF PREEMPTION PROVISION JANUARY 8, 2021	1	Mallory Kass Smith
12	10/18/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	8.14.20 DOH letter	1	Mallory Kass Smith
13	10/18/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Executive Order 202	1	Mallory Kass Smith
14	10/18/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Executive Order 202.6	1	Mallory Kass Smith
15	10/18/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Executive Order 202.8	1	Mallory Kass Smith
16	10/18/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Executive Order 202.10	1	Mallory Kass Smith
17	10/18/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Executive Order 202.14	1	Mallory Kass Smith
18	10/18/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Executive Order 202.28	1	Mallory Kass Smith
19	10/18/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	3.25.20 DOH Advisory	1	Mallory Kass Smith
20	10/18/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	ARTICLE 30D EMERGENCY OR DISASTER TREATMENT PROTECTION ACT	1	Mallory Kass Smith
21	10/18/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	8.25.22 Order	1	Mallory Kass Smith
22	10/18/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	3.23.22 Judgement Entry	1	Mallory Kass Smith
23	10/18/2022	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT	Affidavit of Robert G. Hurlbut	1	Mallory Kass Smith
24	10/18/2022	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT	Affidavit of Robert W. Hurlbut	1	Mallory Kass Smith
25	10/18/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Trademark	1	Mallory Kass Smith
26	10/18/2022	MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN SUPPORT		1	Mallory Kass Smith
27	10/18/2022	RJI -RE: NOTICE OF MOTION		1	Mallory Kass Smith
28	10/27/2022	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE		1	Mallory Kass Smith
29	11/17/2022	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE		1	Jesse Allen Drumm
30	02/01/2023	STIPULATION - OTHER - ( REQUEST TO SO ORDER )			Jesse Allen Drumm
31	02/03/2023	STIPULATION - SO ORDERED	STIPULATED ORDER TO SUBSTITUTE PLAINTIFF		Jennifer Gee
32	02/03/2023	NOTICE TO COUNTY CLERK - AMENDMENT OF CAPTION			Jesse Allen Drumm
33	03/03/2023	COMPLAINT (AMENDED)			Jesse Allen Drumm
34	03/20/2023	NOTICE OF MOTION	Notice of Motion for Summary Judgement in Favor of Defendants	002	Mallory Kass Smith
35	03/20/2023	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT	Affirmation of Mallory Smith, Esq. in support of motion to dismiss	002	Mallory Kass Smith
36	03/20/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Public Readiness and Emergency Preparedness Act (PREP Act)	002	Mallory Kass Smith
37	03/20/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Declaration Under the Public Readiness and Emergency Preparedness Act for Medical Countermeasures Against COVID-19	002	Mallory Kass Smith
38	03/20/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Dept of Health & Human Servs., Advisory Opinion on the Public Readiness and Emergency Preparedness Act and The March 10, 2020 Declaration Under the Act	002	Mallory Kass Smith
39	03/20/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Dept of Health & Human Servs., Advisory Opinion 20-04 on the Public Readiness and Emergency Preparedness Act and The Secretarys Declaration Under the Act	002	Mallory Kass Smith
40	03/20/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Dept of Health & Human Servs., Advisory Opinion 21-01 on the Public Readiness and Emergency Preparedness Act Scope of Preemption Provision (Jan. 8, 2021	002	Mallory Kass Smith
41	03/20/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Letter from Robert P. Charrow, Gen. Counsel, Dept of Health & Human Servs., to Thomas Barker, Foley Hoag LLP (Aug. 14, 2020)	002	Mallory Kass Smith
42	03/20/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	N.Y. Executive Order 202	002	Mallory Kass Smith
43	03/20/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	N.Y. Executive Order 202.6	002	Mallory Kass Smith
44	03/20/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	N.Y. Executive Order 202.8	002	Mallory Kass Smith
45	03/20/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	N.Y. Executive Order 202.10	002	Mallory Kass Smith
46	03/20/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	N.Y. Executive Order 202.14	002	Mallory Kass Smith
47	03/20/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	N.Y. Executive Order 202.28	002	Mallory Kass Smith
48	03/20/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	N.Y. Dept of Health, Advisory: Hospital Discharges and Admissions to Nursing Homes (Mar. 25, 2020)	002	Mallory Kass Smith
49	03/20/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Version of the EDTPA in effect between March 7, 2020 and August 2, 2020 (New York Public Health Law 3080-3082)	002	Mallory Kass Smith
50	03/20/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Shankle v. the Heights of Summerlin, No. A-21-836257-C (Nev. Distr. Ct., Aug. 25, 2022)	002	Mallory Kass Smith
51	03/20/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Saltanovich v. Sea View Hosp. Rehab. Ctr., No. 151312/2021 (Sup. Ct., Richmond Cnty. May 17, 2022)	002	Mallory Kass Smith
52	03/20/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Damon v. Clove Lakes Healthcare, No. 150031/2022 (Sup. Ct., Richmond Cnty. Jun. 21, 2022)	002	Mallory Kass Smith
53	03/20/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Garcia v. New York City Health and Hosps. Corp., No. 159046/2020 (Sup. Ct., N.Y. Cnty. Jul. 6, 2022)	002	Mallory Kass Smith
54	03/20/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	DeFonce v. Sky View Nursing and Rehab. Ctr., No. 61757/2022 (Sup. Ct., Westchester Cnty. Jan. 6, 2023)	002	Mallory Kass Smith
55	03/20/2023	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION	Affidavit of Robert G. Hurlbut in support of motion to dismiss	002	Mallory Kass Smith
56	03/20/2023	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION	Affidavit of Robert W. Hurlbut in support of motion to dismiss	002	Mallory Kass Smith
57	03/20/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Trademark information (TESS)	002	Mallory Kass Smith
58	03/20/2023	MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN SUPPORT		002	Mallory Kass Smith
59	04/07/2023	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION		002	Jesse Allen Drumm
60	04/17/2023	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN REPLY		002	Mallory Kass Smith
61	04/17/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	3.22.23 decision	002	Mallory Kass Smith
62	04/17/2023	MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN REPLY		002	Mallory Kass Smith
63	06/15/2023	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE	Letter re Supplemental Authority re Hasan Decision - as per 22 NYCRR 202.8-c	002	Mallory Kass Smith
64	06/15/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Supplemental Authority - Hasan Decision/Order	002	Mallory Kass Smith
65	06/21/2023	NOTICE OF APPEARANCE (POST RJI)	Notice of Appearance as Co-Counsel		Jeffrey Thomas Wolber
66	07/19/2023	ORDER - (PROPOSED) "SUBMIT ORDER" PER JUDGES DECISION		002	Mallory Kass Smith
67	07/19/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Decision	002	Mallory Kass Smith
68	07/28/2023	ORDER - MOTION - LONG FORM		002	Jennifer Gee
69	07/28/2023	NOTICE OF ENTRY		002	Mallory Kass Smith
70	08/08/2023	ANSWER			Mallory Kass Smith
71	08/09/2023	ORDER - CASE SCHEDULING			Jennifer Gee
72	08/17/2023	NOTICE OF APPEAL		002	Jesse Allen Drumm
73	08/17/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Notice of Appeal Exhibit A Notice of Entry & Order	002	Jesse Allen Drumm
74	08/17/2023	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE		002	Jesse Allen Drumm
75	08/24/2023	NOTICE OF CROSS APPEAL			Mallory Kass Smith
76	08/24/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Notice of Entry of Order		Mallory Kass Smith
77	08/24/2023	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE			Mallory Kass Smith
78	02/02/2024	NOTICE OF COMPLETION OF LIMITED SCOPE APPEARANCE			Jeffrey Thomas Wolber
79	05/09/2025	ORDER - CASE SCHEDULING			Jodi Smith-Schuler
80	07/07/2025	OTHER COURT FILED DOCUMENT	MEMORANDUM AND ORDER		Ccuser Monroecc
81	10/21/2025	ORDER - CASE SCHEDULING			Jodi Smith-Schuler
82	06/05/2026	ORDER - CASE SCHEDULING			Jodi Smith-Schuler
83	06/05/2026	ORDER - MEDIATION			Jodi Smith-Schuler

Monroe Supreme Court

2022

E2022002631

Disposed-Court Date/Application Pending

Negligence

JACKSON, L. BRUCE

BROWN CHIARI LLP

THE HURLBUT et al

LAW OFFICES OF PULLANO & FARROW PLLC

09/12/2024

Waldorf, Hon. Joseph D.

▼

Case Info

Court

Monroe Supreme Court

Index Number

E2022002631

Status

Disposed-Court Date/Application Pending

Year Filed

2022

Case Name

JACKSON, L. BRUCE vs. THE HURLBUT et al

Case Type

Tort-Other Negligence

Track

Standard

RJI Filed

10/17/2022

NOI Due

09/06/2024

NOI Filed

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

Waldorf, Hon. Joseph D.

Next Appearance

09/12/2024

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

JACKSON, L. BRUCE

Attorney / FirmBROWN CHIARI LLP

Defendant / Respondent

THE HURLBUT et al

Attorneys / FirmsLAW OFFICES OF PULLANO & FARROW PLLC

Motions (3)

#	Date Filed	Relief Sought	Submit Date	Answer	Status
3	11/14/2025	Approve Settlement		No	Before Justice: Waldorf, Hon. Joseph D.
2	03/21/2023	Dismiss	06/23/2023	No	Decided: 06/23/2023 Granted to the Extent of the Order Before Justice: Colaiacovo, Hon. Emilio L.
1	10/17/2022	Dismiss	03/20/2023	No	Decided: 03/20/2023 Withdrawn Before Justice: Colaiacovo, Hon. Emilio L.

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints (99)

Doc #	Date Filed	Document	Description	Motion #	Filing User
1	04/04/2022	SUMMONS + COMPLAINT			Theresa M Walsh
2	08/08/2022	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	The Hurlbut LLC		Theresa M Walsh
3	08/08/2022	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Rohm Services Corp		Theresa M Walsh
4	10/05/2022	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Hurlbut Care Communities		Theresa M Walsh
5	10/05/2022	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Robert W. Hurlbut		Theresa M Walsh
6	10/05/2022	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	The Hurlbut		Theresa M Walsh
7	10/07/2022	STIPULATION - TIME TO ANSWER			Mallory Kass Smith
30	10/17/2022	RJI -RE: NOTICE OF MOTION			Mallory Kass Smith
31	10/17/2022	NOTICE OF MOTION	Notice of Motion to Dismiss Complaint	1	Mallory Kass Smith
32	10/18/2022	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT	Affirmation of Mallory Smith, Esq.	1	Mallory Kass Smith
33	10/18/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	42 U.S.C.A. 247d-6d	1	Mallory Kass Smith
34	10/18/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Declaration Under the Public Readiness and Emergency Preparedness Act for Medical Countermeasures Against COVID19	1	Mallory Kass Smith
35	10/18/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	ADVISORY OPINION ON THE PUBLIC READINESS AND EMERGENCY PREPAREDNESS ACT AND THE MARCH 10, 2020 DECLARATION UNDER THE ACT APRIL 17, 2020, AS MODIFIED ON MAY 19, 2020	1	Mallory Kass Smith
36	10/18/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	ADVISORY OPINION 20-04 ON THE PUBLIC READINESS AND EMERGENCY PREPAREDNESS ACT AND THE SECRETARYS DECLARATION UNDER THE ACT OCTOBER 22, 2020, AS MODIFIED ON OCTOBER 23, 2020	1	Mallory Kass Smith
37	10/18/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	ADVISORY OPINION 21-01 ON THE PUBLIC READINESS AND EMERGENCY PREPAREDNESS ACT SCOPE OF PREEMPTION PROVISION JANUARY 8, 2021	1	Mallory Kass Smith
38	10/18/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	8.14.20 DOH letter	1	Mallory Kass Smith
39	10/18/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Executive Order 202	1	Mallory Kass Smith
40	10/18/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Executive Order 202.6	1	Mallory Kass Smith
41	10/18/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Executive Order 202.8	1	Mallory Kass Smith
42	10/18/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Executive Order 202.10	1	Mallory Kass Smith
43	10/18/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Executive Order 202.14	1	Mallory Kass Smith
44	10/18/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Executive Order 202.28	1	Mallory Kass Smith
45	10/18/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	3.25.20 DOH Advisory	1	Mallory Kass Smith
46	10/18/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	ARTICLE 30D EMERGENCY OR DISASTER TREATMENT PROTECTION ACT	1	Mallory Kass Smith
47	10/18/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	8.25.22 Order	1	Mallory Kass Smith
48	10/18/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	3.23.22 Judgement Entry	1	Mallory Kass Smith
49	10/18/2022	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT	Affidavit of Robert G. Hurlbut	1	Mallory Kass Smith
50	10/18/2022	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT	Affidavit of Robert W. Hurlbut	1	Mallory Kass Smith
51	10/18/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Trademark	1	Mallory Kass Smith
52	10/18/2022	MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN SUPPORT		1	Mallory Kass Smith
53	10/27/2022	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE		1	Mallory Kass Smith
54	11/06/2022	COURT NOTICE	Filing on Behalf of - Hon. Vincent M. Dinolfo		Benjamin Skomsky
55	01/04/2023	STIPULATION - OTHER - ( REQUEST TO SO ORDER )	Stipulated Order to Substitute Plaintiff		Jesse Allen Drumm
56	01/25/2023	STIPULATION - SO ORDERED	STIPULATED ORDER TO SUBSTITUTE PLAINTIFF		Jennifer Gee
57	01/25/2023	NOTICE TO COUNTY CLERK - AMENDMENT OF CAPTION			Jesse Allen Drumm
58	03/03/2023	COMPLAINT (AMENDED)			Jesse Allen Drumm
59	03/20/2023	NOTICE OF MOTION	Notice of Motion for Summary Judgement in Favor of Defendants	002	Mallory Kass Smith
60	03/20/2023	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT	Affirmation of Mallory Smith, Esq. in support of Motion to dismiss	002	Mallory Kass Smith
61	03/20/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Public Readiness and Emergency Preparedness Act (PREP Act)	002	Mallory Kass Smith
62	03/20/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Declaration Under the Public Readiness and Emergency Preparedness Act for Medical Countermeasures Against COVID-19	002	Mallory Kass Smith
63	03/20/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Dept of Health & Human Servs., Advisory Opinion on the Public Readiness and Emergency Preparedness Act and The March 10, 2020 Declaration Under the Act	002	Mallory Kass Smith
64	03/20/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Dept of Health & Human Servs., Advisory Opinion 20-04 on the Public Readiness and Emergency Preparedness Act and The Secretarys Declaration Under the Act (Oct. 22, 2020)	002	Mallory Kass Smith
65	03/20/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Dept of Health & Human Servs., Advisory Opinion 21-01 on the Public Readiness and Emergency Preparedness Act Scope of Preemption Provision	002	Mallory Kass Smith
66	03/20/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Letter from Robert P. Charrow, Gen. Counsel, Dept of Health & Human Servs., to Thomas Barker, Foley Hoag LLP (Aug. 14, 2020)	002	Mallory Kass Smith
67	03/20/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	N.Y. Executive Order 202	002	Mallory Kass Smith
68	03/20/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	N.Y. Executive Order 202.6	002	Mallory Kass Smith
69	03/20/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	N.Y. Executive Order 202.8	002	Mallory Kass Smith
70	03/20/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	N.Y. Executive Order 202.10	002	Mallory Kass Smith
71	03/20/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	N.Y. Executive Order 202.14	002	Mallory Kass Smith
72	03/20/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	N.Y. Executive Order 202.28	002	Mallory Kass Smith
73	03/20/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	N.Y. Dept of Health, Advisory: Hospital Discharges and Admissions to Nursing Homes (Mar. 25, 2020)	002	Mallory Kass Smith
74	03/20/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Version of the EDTPA in effect between March 7, 2020 and August 2, 2020 (New York Public Health Law 3080-3082)	002	Mallory Kass Smith
75	03/20/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Shankle v. the Heights of Summerlin, No. A-21-836257-C (Nev. Distr. Ct., Aug. 25, 2022)	002	Mallory Kass Smith
76	03/20/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Saltanovich v. Sea View Hosp. Rehab. Ctr., No. 151312/2021 (Sup. Ct., Richmond Cnty. May 17, 2022)	002	Mallory Kass Smith
77	03/20/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Damon v. Clove Lakes Healthcare, No. 150031/2022 (Sup. Ct., Richmond Cnty. Jun. 21, 2022)	002	Mallory Kass Smith
78	03/20/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Garcia v. New York City Health and Hosps. Corp., No. 159046/2020 (Sup. Ct., N.Y. Cnty. Jul. 6, 2022)	002	Mallory Kass Smith
79	03/20/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	DeFonce v. Sky View Nursing and Rehab. Ctr., No. 61757/2022 (Sup. Ct., Westchester Cnty. Jan. 6, 2023)	002	Mallory Kass Smith
80	03/20/2023	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT	Affidavit of Robert G. Hurlbut in support of motion to dismiss	002	Mallory Kass Smith
81	03/20/2023	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT	Affidavit of Robert W. Hurlbut	002	Mallory Kass Smith
82	03/20/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Trademark information (TESS)	002	Mallory Kass Smith
83	03/20/2023	MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN SUPPORT		002	Mallory Kass Smith
84	04/07/2023	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION		002	Jesse Allen Drumm
88	04/17/2023	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN REPLY		002	Mallory Kass Smith
89	04/17/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	3.22.23 decision	002	Mallory Kass Smith
90	04/17/2023	MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN REPLY		002	Mallory Kass Smith
91	06/15/2023	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE	Letter re Supplemental Authority re Hasan Decision - as per 22 NYCRR 202.8-c	002	Mallory Kass Smith
92	06/15/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Supplemental Authority - Hasan Decision/Order	002	Mallory Kass Smith
93	06/21/2023	NOTICE OF APPEARANCE (POST RJI)	Notice of Appearance as Co-Counsel		Jeffrey Thomas Wolber
94	07/19/2023	ORDER - (PROPOSED) "SUBMIT ORDER" PER JUDGES DECISION		002	Mallory Kass Smith
95	07/19/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Decision	002	Mallory Kass Smith
96	07/28/2023	ORDER - MOTION - LONG FORM		002	Jennifer Gee
97	07/28/2023	NOTICE OF ENTRY		002	Mallory Kass Smith
98	08/08/2023	ANSWER			Mallory Kass Smith
99	08/09/2023	ORDER - CASE SCHEDULING			Jennifer Gee
100	08/17/2023	NOTICE OF APPEAL		002	Jesse Allen Drumm
101	08/17/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Notice of Appeal Exhibit A Notice of Entry & Order	002	Jesse Allen Drumm
102	08/17/2023	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE		002	Jesse Allen Drumm
103	08/24/2023	NOTICE OF CROSS APPEAL			Mallory Kass Smith
104	08/24/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Notice of Entry of Order		Mallory Kass Smith
105	08/24/2023	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE			Mallory Kass Smith
106	02/02/2024	NOTICE OF COMPLETION OF LIMITED SCOPE APPEARANCE			Jeffrey Thomas Wolber
107	02/20/2024	ORDER - CASE SCHEDULING	Amended Scheduling Order		Emma Laws
108	09/13/2024	ORDER - DISMISSAL			Joseph D. Waldorf
109	11/14/2025	NOTICE OF PETITION		3	Michael Christopher Scinta
110	11/14/2025	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT	Petition of L. Bruce Jackson	3	Michael Christopher Scinta
111	11/14/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Death Certificate	3	Michael Christopher Scinta
112	11/14/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Medicare File Closure Letter	3	Michael Christopher Scinta
113	11/14/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Optum File Closure Letter	3	Michael Christopher Scinta
114	11/14/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Medicaid Lien Notice	3	Michael Christopher Scinta
115	11/14/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Medicaid Lien Agreement	3	Michael Christopher Scinta
116	11/14/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Hurlbut Claim	3	Michael Christopher Scinta
117	11/14/2025	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT	Affirmation of Michael Scinta, Esq.	3	Michael Christopher Scinta
118	11/14/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Letters of Administration	3	Michael Christopher Scinta
119	11/14/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Medicare File Closure Letter	3	Michael Christopher Scinta
120	11/14/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Optum File Closure Letter	3	Michael Christopher Scinta
121	11/14/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Medicaid Lien Notice	3	Michael Christopher Scinta
122	11/14/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Medicaid Lien Agreement	3	Michael Christopher Scinta
123	11/14/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Hurlbut Claim	3	Michael Christopher Scinta
124	11/14/2025	ORDER ( PROPOSED )		3	Michael Christopher Scinta

Monroe Supreme Court

2022

E2022002911

Disposed

Negligence

CORDARO, JENNY

BROWN CHIARI LLP

THE HURLBUT et al

LAW OFFICES OF PULLANO & FARROW PLLC

03/31/2025

Nasca, Hon. Kevin M.

▼

Case Info

Court

Monroe Supreme Court

Index Number

E2022002911

Status

Disposed

Year Filed

2022

Case Name

CORDARO, JENNY vs. THE HURLBUT et al

Case Type

Tort-Other Negligence

Track

Standard

RJI Filed

10/17/2022

NOI Due

12/20/2024

NOI Filed

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

Nasca, Hon. Kevin M.

Next Appearance

03/31/2025

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

CORDARO, JENNY

Attorney / FirmBROWN CHIARI LLP

Defendant / Respondent

THE HURLBUT et al

Attorneys / FirmsLAW OFFICES OF PULLANO & FARROW PLLC

Motions (4)

#	Date Filed	Relief Sought	Submit Date	Answer	Status	Decision	Order Signed
3	01/07/2025	Compromise	02/21/2025	No	Decided: 02/21/2025 Decision Reserved Before Justice: Nasca, Hon. Kevin M.
3	01/07/2025	Compromise	02/21/2025	No	Decided: 03/31/2025 Granted Before Justice: Nasca, Hon. Kevin M.	Short Form Order	05/15/2025
2	03/21/2023	Dismiss	06/23/2023	No	Decided: 06/23/2023 Granted to the Extent of the Order Before Justice: Colaiacovo, Hon. Emilio L.
1	10/17/2022	Dismiss	03/20/2023	No	Decided: 03/20/2023 Withdrawn Before Justice: Colaiacovo, Hon. Emilio L.

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints (99)

Doc #	Date Filed	Document	Description	Motion #	Filing User
1	04/12/2022	SUMMONS + COMPLAINT			Theresa M Walsh
2	06/23/2022	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	The Hurlbut, LLC		Jesse Allen Drumm
3	06/23/2022	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	The Hurlbut, LLC dba The Hurlbut		Jesse Allen Drumm
4	06/23/2022	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	ROHM Services Corporation		Jesse Allen Drumm
5	07/07/2022	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Hurlbut Care Communities		Jesse Allen Drumm
6	07/07/2022	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Robert W. Hurlbut		Jesse Allen Drumm
7	07/15/2022	STIPULATION - OTHER	Stipulation to extend time for Defendant to Answer Complaint		Mallory Kass Smith
8	08/26/2022	STIPULATION - TIME TO ANSWER			Mallory Kass Smith
9	10/07/2022	STIPULATION - TIME TO ANSWER			Mallory Kass Smith
10	10/17/2022	NOTICE OF MOTION	Notice of Motion to Dismiss Complaint	1	Mallory Kass Smith
11	10/17/2022	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT	Affirmation of Mallory Smith, Esq.	1	Mallory Kass Smith
12	10/17/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	42 U.S.C.A. 247d-6d	1	Mallory Kass Smith
13	10/17/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Declaration Under the Public Readiness and Emergency Preparedness Act for Medical Countermeasures Against COVID19	1	Mallory Kass Smith
14	10/17/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	ADVISORY OPINION ON THE PUBLIC READINESS AND EMERGENCY PREPAREDNESS ACT AND THE MARCH 10, 2020 DECLARATION UNDER THE ACT APRIL 17, 2020, AS MODIFIED ON MAY 19, 2020	1	Mallory Kass Smith
15	10/17/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	ADVISORY OPINION 20-04 ON THE PUBLIC READINESS AND EMERGENCY PREPAREDNESS ACT AND THE SECRETARYS DECLARATION UNDER THE ACT OCTOBER 22, 2020, AS MODIFIED ON OCTOBER 23, 2020	1	Mallory Kass Smith
16	10/17/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	ADVISORY OPINION 21-01 ON THE PUBLIC READINESS AND EMERGENCY PREPAREDNESS ACT SCOPE OF PREEMPTION PROVISION JANUARY 8, 2021	1	Mallory Kass Smith
17	10/17/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	8.14.20 DOH letter	1	Mallory Kass Smith
18	10/17/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Executive Order 202	1	Mallory Kass Smith
19	10/17/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Executive Order 202.6	1	Mallory Kass Smith
20	10/17/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Executive Order 202.8	1	Mallory Kass Smith
21	10/17/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Executive Order 202.10	1	Mallory Kass Smith
22	10/17/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	202.14	1	Mallory Kass Smith
23	10/17/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Executive Order 202.28	1	Mallory Kass Smith
24	10/17/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	3.25.20 DOH Advisory	1	Mallory Kass Smith
25	10/17/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	EMERGENCY OR DISASTER TREATMENT PROTECTION ACT	1	Mallory Kass Smith
26	10/17/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	8.25.22 Order	1	Mallory Kass Smith
27	10/17/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	3.23.22 Judgement Entry	1	Mallory Kass Smith
28	10/17/2022	AFFIDAVIT	Affidavit of Robert G. Hurlbut	1	Mallory Kass Smith
29	10/17/2022	AFFIDAVIT	Affidavit of Robert W. Hurlbut	1	Mallory Kass Smith
30	10/17/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Trademark	1	Mallory Kass Smith
31	10/17/2022	MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN SUPPORT		1	Mallory Kass Smith
32	10/17/2022	RJI -RE: NOTICE OF MOTION		1	Mallory Kass Smith
33	10/27/2022	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE		1	Mallory Kass Smith
34	11/01/2022	COURT NOTICE			Matthew Dunham
35	03/03/2023	COMPLAINT (AMENDED)			Jesse Allen Drumm
36	03/20/2023	NOTICE OF MOTION	Notice of Motion for Summary Judgement in Favor of Defendants	002	Mallory Kass Smith
37	03/20/2023	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT	Affirmation of Mallory Smith, Esq. in support of Motion to dismiss	002	Mallory Kass Smith
38	03/20/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Public Readiness and Emergency Preparedness Act (PREP Act)	002	Mallory Kass Smith
39	03/20/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Declaration Under the Public Readiness and Emergency Preparedness Act for Medical Countermeasures Against COVID-19	002	Mallory Kass Smith
40	03/20/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Dept of Health & Human Servs., Advisory Opinion on the Public Readiness and Emergency Preparedness Act and The March 10, 2020 Declaration Under the Act	002	Mallory Kass Smith
41	03/20/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Dept of Health & Human Servs., Advisory Opinion 20-04 on the Public Readiness and Emergency Preparedness Act and The Secretarys Declaration Under the Act	002	Mallory Kass Smith
42	03/20/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Dept of Health & Human Servs., Advisory Opinion 21-01 on the Public Readiness and Emergency Preparedness Act Scope of Preemption Provision	002	Mallory Kass Smith
43	03/20/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Letter from Robert P. Charrow, Gen. Counsel, Dept of Health & Human Servs., to Thomas Barker, Foley Hoag LLP	002	Mallory Kass Smith
44	03/20/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	N.Y. Executive Order 202	002	Mallory Kass Smith
45	03/20/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	N.Y. Executive Order 202.6	002	Mallory Kass Smith
46	03/20/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	N.Y. Executive Order 202.8	002	Mallory Kass Smith
47	03/20/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	N.Y. Executive Order 202.10	002	Mallory Kass Smith
48	03/20/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	N.Y. Executive Order 202.14	002	Mallory Kass Smith
49	03/20/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	N.Y. Executive Order 202.28	002	Mallory Kass Smith
50	03/20/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	N.Y. Dept of Health, Advisory: Hospital Discharges and Admissions to Nursing Homes	002	Mallory Kass Smith
51	03/20/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Version of the EDTPA in effect between March 7, 2020 and August 2, 2020 (New York Public Health Law 3080-3082)	002	Mallory Kass Smith
52	03/20/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Shankle v. the Heights of Summerlin, No. A-21-836257-C (Nev. Distr. Ct., Aug. 25, 2022)	002	Mallory Kass Smith
53	03/20/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Saltanovich v. Sea View Hosp. Rehab. Ctr., No. 151312/2021 (Sup. Ct., Richmond Cnty. May 17, 2022)	002	Mallory Kass Smith
54	03/20/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Damon v. Clove Lakes Healthcare, No. 150031/2022 (Sup. Ct., Richmond Cnty. Jun. 21, 2022)	002	Mallory Kass Smith
55	03/20/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Garcia v. New York City Health and Hosps. Corp., No. 159046/2020 (Sup. Ct., N.Y. Cnty. Jul. 6, 2022)	002	Mallory Kass Smith
56	03/20/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	DeFonce v. Sky View Nursing and Rehab. Ctr., No. 61757/2022 (Sup. Ct., Westchester Cnty. Jan. 6, 2023)	002	Mallory Kass Smith
57	03/20/2023	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT	Affidavit of Robert G. Hurlbut in support of motion to dismiss	002	Mallory Kass Smith
58	03/20/2023	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION	Affidavit of Robert W. Hurlbut in support of motion to dismiss	002	Mallory Kass Smith
59	03/20/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Trademark information (TESS)	002	Mallory Kass Smith
60	03/20/2023	MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN SUPPORT		002	Mallory Kass Smith
61	04/07/2023	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION		002	Jesse Allen Drumm
62	04/17/2023	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN REPLY		002	Mallory Kass Smith
63	04/17/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	3.22.23 decision	002	Mallory Kass Smith
64	04/17/2023	MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN REPLY		002	Mallory Kass Smith
65	06/15/2023	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE	Letter re Supplemental Authority re Hasan Decision - as per 22 NYCRR 202.8-c	002	Mallory Kass Smith
66	06/15/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Supplemental Authority - Hasan Decision/Order	002	Mallory Kass Smith
67	06/21/2023	NOTICE OF APPEARANCE (POST RJI)	Notice of Appearance as Co-Counsel		Jeffrey Thomas Wolber
68	07/19/2023	ORDER - (PROPOSED) "SUBMIT ORDER" PER JUDGES DECISION		002	Mallory Kass Smith
69	07/19/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Decision	002	Mallory Kass Smith
70	07/19/2023	ORDER - MOTION - LONG FORM		002	Jennifer Gee
71	07/19/2023	NOTICE OF ENTRY		002	Mallory Kass Smith
72	07/31/2023	ANSWER			Mallory Kass Smith
73	08/09/2023	ORDER - CASE SCHEDULING			Jennifer Gee
74	08/17/2023	NOTICE OF APPEAL		002	Jesse Allen Drumm
75	08/17/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Notice of Appeal Exhibit A Notice of Entry & Order	002	Jesse Allen Drumm
76	08/17/2023	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE		002	Jesse Allen Drumm
77	08/24/2023	NOTICE OF CROSS APPEAL			Mallory Kass Smith
78	08/24/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Notice of Entry of Order		Mallory Kass Smith
79	08/24/2023	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE			Mallory Kass Smith
80	02/02/2024	NOTICE OF COMPLETION OF LIMITED SCOPE APPEARANCE			Jeffrey Thomas Wolber
81	03/01/2024	ORDER - CASE SCHEDULING	Scheduling Order		Lori P Allen
82	08/21/2024	ORDER - AMENDED	First Amended Scheduling Order		Lori P Allen
83	01/07/2025	NOTICE OF PETITION		3	Michael Christopher Scinta
84	01/07/2025	ORDER ( PROPOSED )		3	Michael Christopher Scinta
85	01/09/2025	COURT NOTICE		3	Lori P Allen
86	03/05/2025	AFFIDAVIT		3	Michael Christopher Scinta
87	03/05/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	death certificate	3	Michael Christopher Scinta
88	03/05/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Medicare letter	3	Michael Christopher Scinta
89	03/05/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Medicaid lien	3	Michael Christopher Scinta
90	03/05/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Medicaid lien agreement	3	Michael Christopher Scinta
91	03/05/2025	AFFIRMATION		3	Michael Christopher Scinta
92	03/05/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Letters of Administration	3	Michael Christopher Scinta
93	03/05/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Medicare letter	3	Michael Christopher Scinta
94	03/05/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Medicaid lien	3	Michael Christopher Scinta
95	03/05/2025	EXHIBIT(S)	Medicaid lien agreement	3	Michael Christopher Scinta
96	03/06/2025	COURT NOTICE			Lori P Allen
97	05/15/2025	ORDER ( PROPOSED )	revised proposed order		Michael Christopher Scinta
98	05/15/2025	ORDER - OTHER		3	Lori P Allen
99	06/16/2025	STIPULATION - DISCONTINUANCE (POST RJI)			Langston David Mcfadden

Monroe Supreme Court

2022

E2022002932

Disposed

Negligence

PROSEUS, BARBARA

BROWN CHIARI LLP

THE HURLBUT et al

LAW OFFICES OF PULLANO & FARROW PLLC

06/23/2023

Colaiacovo, Hon. Emilio L.

▼

Case Info

Court

Monroe Supreme Court

Index Number

E2022002932

Status

Disposed

Year Filed

2022

Case Name

PROSEUS, BARBARA vs. THE HURLBUT et al

Case Type

Tort-Other Negligence

Track

Standard

RJI Filed

10/17/2022

NOI Due

10/17/2023

NOI Filed

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

Colaiacovo, Hon. Emilio L.

Next Appearance

06/23/2023

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

PROSEUS, BARBARA

Attorney / FirmBROWN CHIARI LLP

Defendant / Respondent

THE HURLBUT et al

Attorneys / FirmsLAW OFFICES OF PULLANO & FARROW PLLC

Motions (2)

#	Date Filed	Filed By	Relief Sought	Submit Date	Answer	Status	Decision	Order Signed
2	03/21/2023		Dismiss	06/23/2023	No	Decided: 06/23/2023 Granted to the Extent of the Order Before Justice: Colaiacovo, Hon. Emilio L.
1	10/17/2022		Dismiss	03/20/2023	No	Decided: 03/20/2023 Withdrawn Before Justice: Colaiacovo, Hon. Emilio L.

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints (80)

Doc #	Date Filed	Document	Description	Motion #	Filing User
1	04/13/2022	SUMMONS + COMPLAINT			Theresa M Walsh
2	06/27/2022	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	The Hurlbut		Jesse Allen Drumm
3	06/27/2022	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	The Hurlbut, LLC		Jesse Allen Drumm
4	06/27/2022	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	ROHM Services Corporation		Jesse Allen Drumm
5	07/14/2022	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Hurlbut Care Communities		Jesse Allen Drumm
6	07/14/2022	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Robert W. Hurlbut		Jesse Allen Drumm
8	07/18/2022	STIPULATION - OTHER	Stipulation extending time for Defendants to Answer Complaint		Mallory Kass Smith
9	08/26/2022	STIPULATION - TIME TO ANSWER			Mallory Kass Smith
10	10/07/2022	STIPULATION - TIME TO ANSWER			Mallory Kass Smith
11	10/17/2022	NOTICE OF MOTION	Notice of Motion to Dismiss Complaint	1	Mallory Kass Smith
12	10/17/2022	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT	Affirmation of Mallory Smith, Esq.	1	Mallory Kass Smith
13	10/17/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	42 U.S.C.A. 247d-6d	1	Mallory Kass Smith
14	10/17/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Declaration Under the Public Readiness and Emergency Preparedness Act for Medical Countermeasures Against COVID19	1	Mallory Kass Smith
15	10/17/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	ADVISORY OPINION ON THE PREP ACT AND THE MARCH 10, 2020 DECLARATION UNDER THE ACT APRIL 17, 2020, AS MODIFIED ON MAY 19, 2020	1	Mallory Kass Smith
16	10/17/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	ADVISORY OPINION 20-04 ON THE PREP ACT AND THE SECRETARYS DECLARATION UNDER THE ACT OCTOBER 22, 2020, AS MODIFIED ON OCTOBER 23, 2020	1	Mallory Kass Smith
17	10/17/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	ADVISORY OPINION 21-01 ON THE PREP ACT SCOPE OF PREEMPTION PROVISION JANUARY 8, 2021	1	Mallory Kass Smith
18	10/17/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	8.14.20 DOH letter	1	Mallory Kass Smith
19	10/17/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Executive Order 202	1	Mallory Kass Smith
20	10/17/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Executive Order 202.16	1	Mallory Kass Smith
21	10/17/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Executive Order 202.8	1	Mallory Kass Smith
22	10/17/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Executive Order 202.10	1	Mallory Kass Smith
23	10/17/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Executive Order 202.14	1	Mallory Kass Smith
24	10/17/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Executive Order 202.28	1	Mallory Kass Smith
25	10/17/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	2.25.20 DOH advisory	1	Mallory Kass Smith
26	10/17/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Emergency or disaster treatment protection act	1	Mallory Kass Smith
27	10/17/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	8.25.22 Order	1	Mallory Kass Smith
28	10/17/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	3.23.22 Judgement Entry	1	Mallory Kass Smith
29	10/17/2022	AFFIDAVIT	Affidavit of Robert G. Hurlbut	1	Mallory Kass Smith
30	10/17/2022	AFFIDAVIT	Affidavit of Robert W. Hurlbut	1	Mallory Kass Smith
31	10/17/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Trademark	1	Mallory Kass Smith
32	10/17/2022	MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN SUPPORT		1	Mallory Kass Smith
33	10/17/2022	RJI -RE: NOTICE OF MOTION		1	Mallory Kass Smith
34	10/27/2022	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE		1	Mallory Kass Smith
35	11/17/2022	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE		1	Jesse Allen Drumm
36	02/01/2023	STIPULATION - OTHER - ( REQUEST TO SO ORDER )			Jesse Allen Drumm
37	02/03/2023	STIPULATION - SO ORDERED	STIPULATED ORDER TO SUBSTITUTE PLAINTIFF		Jennifer Gee
38	02/03/2023	NOTICE TO COUNTY CLERK - AMENDMENT OF CAPTION			Jesse Allen Drumm
39	03/03/2023	COMPLAINT (AMENDED)			Jesse Allen Drumm
40	03/20/2023	NOTICE OF MOTION	Notice of Motion for Summary Judgment in Favor of Defendants	002	Mallory Kass Smith
41	03/20/2023	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT	Affirmation of Mallory Smith, Esq.	002	Mallory Kass Smith
42	03/20/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Public Readiness and Emergency Preparedness Act (PREP Act)	002	Mallory Kass Smith
43	03/20/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Copy of the Declaration Under the Public Readiness and Emergency Preparedness Act for Medical Countermeasures Against COVID-19	002	Mallory Kass Smith
44	03/20/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Dept of Health & Human Servs., Advisory Opinion on the Public Readiness and Emergency Preparedness Act and The March 10, 2020 Declaration Under the Act	002	Mallory Kass Smith
45	03/20/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Copy of Dept of Health & Human Servs., Advisory Opinion 20-04 on the Public Readiness and Emergency Preparedness Act and The Secretarys Declaration Under the Act	002	Mallory Kass Smith
46	03/20/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Copy of Dept of Health & Human Servs., Advisory Opinion 21-01 on the Public Readiness and Emergency Preparedness Act Scope of Preemption Provision	002	Mallory Kass Smith
47	03/20/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Letter from Robert P. Charrow, Gen. Counsel, Dept of Health & Human Servs., to Thomas Barker, Foley Hoag LLP (Aug. 14, 2020)	002	Mallory Kass Smith
48	03/20/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Copy of N.Y. Executive Order 202 (Mar. 7, 2020	002	Mallory Kass Smith
49	03/20/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	E.O. 202.6	002	Mallory Kass Smith
50	03/20/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	E.O. 202.8	002	Mallory Kass Smith
51	03/20/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	E.O. 202.10	002	Mallory Kass Smith
52	03/20/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	E.O. 202.14	002	Mallory Kass Smith
53	03/20/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	E.O. 202.28	002	Mallory Kass Smith
54	03/20/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	N.Y. Dept of Health, Advisory: Hospital Discharges and Admissions to Nursing Homes (Mar. 25, 2020)	002	Mallory Kass Smith
55	03/20/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Version of the EDTPA in effect between March 7, 2020 and August 2, 2020 (New York Public Health Law 3080-3082)	002	Mallory Kass Smith
56	03/20/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Shankle v. the Heights of Summerlin, No. A-21-836257-C (Nev. Distr. Ct., Aug. 25, 2022)	002	Mallory Kass Smith
57	03/20/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Saltanovich v. Sea View Hosp. Rehab. Ctr., No. 151312/2021 (Sup. Ct., Richmond Cnty. May 17, 2022)	002	Mallory Kass Smith
58	03/20/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Damon v. Clove Lakes Healthcare, No. 150031/2022 (Sup. Ct., Richmond Cnty. Jun. 21, 2022)	002	Mallory Kass Smith
59	03/20/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Garcia v. New York City Health and Hosps. Corp., No. 159046/2020 (Sup. Ct., N.Y. Cnty. Jul. 6, 2022)	002	Mallory Kass Smith
60	03/20/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	DeFonce v. Sky View Nursing and Rehab. Ctr., No. 61757/2022 (Sup. Ct., Westchester Cnty. Jan. 6, 2023)	002	Mallory Kass Smith
61	03/20/2023	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT	Affidavit of Robert G. Hurlbut	002	Mallory Kass Smith
62	03/20/2023	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT	Affidavit of Robert W. Hurlbut	002	Mallory Kass Smith
63	03/20/2023	MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN SUPPORT		002	Mallory Kass Smith
64	03/20/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit A to Affidavit of Robert W. Hurlbut	002	Mallory Kass Smith
65	04/07/2023	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION		002	Jesse Allen Drumm
66	04/17/2023	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN REPLY		002	Mallory Kass Smith
67	04/17/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	3.22.23 decision	002	Mallory Kass Smith
68	04/17/2023	MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN REPLY		002	Mallory Kass Smith
69	06/15/2023	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE	Letter re Supplemental Authority re Hasan Decision - as per 22 NYCRR 202.8-c	002	Mallory Kass Smith
70	06/15/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Supplemental Authority - Hasan Decision/Order	002	Mallory Kass Smith
71	06/21/2023	NOTICE OF APPEARANCE (POST RJI)	Notice of Appearance as Co-Counsel		Jeffrey Thomas Wolber
72	07/19/2023	ORDER - (PROPOSED) "SUBMIT ORDER" PER JUDGES DECISION		002	Mallory Kass Smith
73	07/19/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Decision	002	Mallory Kass Smith
74	07/19/2023	ORDER - MOTION - LONG FORM		002	Jennifer Gee
75	07/19/2023	NOTICE OF ENTRY		002	Mallory Kass Smith
76	08/17/2023	NOTICE OF APPEAL		002	Jesse Allen Drumm
77	08/17/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Notice of Appeal Exhibit A Notice of Entry & Order	002	Jesse Allen Drumm
78	08/17/2023	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE		002	Jesse Allen Drumm
79	08/24/2023	NOTICE OF CROSS APPEAL			Mallory Kass Smith
80	08/24/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Notice of Entry of Order		Mallory Kass Smith
81	08/24/2023	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE			Mallory Kass Smith

Monroe Supreme Court

2022

E2022003012

Disposed

Negligence

PECKHAM, JOHN

BROWN CHIARI LLP

THE HURLBUT et al

LAW OFFICES OF PULLANO & FARROW PLLC

06/23/2023

Colaiacovo, Hon. Emilio L.

▼

Case Info

Court

Monroe Supreme Court

Index Number

E2022003012

Status

Disposed

Year Filed

2022

Case Name

PECKHAM, JOHN vs. THE HURLBUT et al

Case Type

Tort-Other Negligence

Track

Standard

RJI Filed

10/17/2022

NOI Due

NOI Filed

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

Colaiacovo, Hon. Emilio L.

Next Appearance

06/23/2023

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

PECKHAM, JOHN

Attorney / FirmBROWN CHIARI LLP

Defendant / Respondent

THE HURLBUT et al

Attorneys / FirmsLAW OFFICES OF PULLANO & FARROW PLLC

Motions (2)

#	Date Filed	Filed By	Relief Sought	Submit Date	Answer	Status	Decision	Order Signed
2	03/21/2023		Dismiss	06/23/2023	No	Decided: 06/23/2023 Granted to the Extent of the Order Before Justice: Colaiacovo, Hon. Emilio L.
1	10/17/2022		Dismiss	03/20/2023	No	Decided: 03/20/2023 Withdrawn Before Justice: Cariola, Hon. Elena F.

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints (79)

Doc #	Date Filed	Document	Description	Motion #	Filing User
1	04/15/2022	SUMMONS + COMPLAINT			Theresa M Walsh
2	08/04/2022	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	The Hurlbut, LLC dba The Hurlbut		Jesse Allen Drumm
3	08/04/2022	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	The Hurlbut, LLC		Jesse Allen Drumm
4	08/04/2022	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	ROHM Services Corporation		Jesse Allen Drumm
5	08/12/2022	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Hurlbut Care Communities		Jesse Allen Drumm
6	08/12/2022	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Robert W. Hurlbut		Jesse Allen Drumm
7	08/26/2022	STIPULATION - TIME TO ANSWER			Mallory Kass Smith
8	10/07/2022	STIPULATION - TIME TO ANSWER			Mallory Kass Smith
9	10/17/2022	NOTICE OF MOTION	Notice of Motion to dismiss complaint	1	Mallory Kass Smith
10	10/17/2022	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT	Affirmation of Mallory Smith, Esq.	1	Mallory Kass Smith
11	10/17/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	42 U.S.C.A. 247d-6d	1	Mallory Kass Smith
12	10/17/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Declaration Under the Public Readiness and Emergency Preparedness Act for Medical Countermeasures Against COVID19	1	Mallory Kass Smith
13	10/17/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	ADVISORY OPINION ON THE PUBLIC READINESS AND EMERGENCY PREPAREDNESS ACT AND THE MARCH 10, 2020 DECLARATION UNDER THE ACT APRIL 17, 2020, AS MODIFIED ON MAY 19, 2020	1	Mallory Kass Smith
14	10/17/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	ADVISORY OPINION 20-04 ON THE PUBLIC READINESS AND EMERGENCY PREPAREDNESS ACT AND THE SECRETARYS DECLARATION UNDER THE ACT OCTOBER 22, 2020, AS MODIFIED ON OCTOBER 23, 2020	1	Mallory Kass Smith
15	10/17/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	ADVISORY OPINION 21-01 ON THE PUBLIC READINESS AND EMERGENCY PREPAREDNESS ACT SCOPE OF PREEMPTION PROVISION JANUARY 8, 2021	1	Mallory Kass Smith
16	10/17/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	8.14.20 DOH letter	1	Mallory Kass Smith
17	10/17/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Executive Order 202	1	Mallory Kass Smith
18	10/17/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Executive Order 202.6	1	Mallory Kass Smith
19	10/17/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Executive Order 202.8	1	Mallory Kass Smith
20	10/17/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Executive Order 202.10	1	Mallory Kass Smith
21	10/17/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Executive Order 202.14	1	Mallory Kass Smith
22	10/17/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Executive Order 202.28	1	Mallory Kass Smith
23	10/17/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	3.25.20 DOH Advisory	1	Mallory Kass Smith
24	10/17/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	ARTICLE 30D EMERGENCY OR DISASTER TREATMENT PROTECTION ACT	1	Mallory Kass Smith
25	10/17/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	8.25.22 Order	1	Mallory Kass Smith
26	10/17/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	3.23.22 Judgement Entry	1	Mallory Kass Smith
27	10/17/2022	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT	Affidavit of Robert G. Hurlbut	1	Mallory Kass Smith
28	10/17/2022	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT	Affidavit of Robert W. Hurlbut	1	Mallory Kass Smith
29	10/17/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Trademark	1	Mallory Kass Smith
30	10/17/2022	MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN SUPPORT		1	Mallory Kass Smith
31	10/17/2022	RJI -RE: NOTICE OF MOTION		1	Mallory Kass Smith
32	10/27/2022	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE		1	Mallory Kass Smith
33	11/17/2022	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE		1	Jesse Allen Drumm
34	02/03/2023	STIPULATION - OTHER - ( REQUEST TO SO ORDER )			Jesse Allen Drumm
35	02/06/2023	STIPULATION - SO ORDERED	STIPULATED ORDER TO SUBSTITUTE PLAINTIFF		Jennifer Gee
36	02/07/2023	NOTICE TO COUNTY CLERK - AMENDMENT OF CAPTION			Jesse Allen Drumm
37	03/03/2023	COMPLAINT (AMENDED)			Jesse Allen Drumm
38	03/20/2023	NOTICE OF MOTION	Notice of Motion for Summary Judgement in Favor of Defendants	002	Mallory Kass Smith
39	03/20/2023	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT	Affirmation of Mallory Smith, Esq. in support of Motion to dismiss	002	Mallory Kass Smith
40	03/20/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Public Readiness and Emergency Preparedness Act (PREP Act)	002	Mallory Kass Smith
41	03/20/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Declaration Under the Public Readiness and Emergency Preparedness Act for Medical Countermeasures Against COVID-19	002	Mallory Kass Smith
42	03/20/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Dept of Health & Human Servs., Advisory Opinion on the Public Readiness and Emergency Preparedness Act and The March 10, 2020 Declaration Under the Act	002	Mallory Kass Smith
43	03/20/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Dept of Health & Human Servs., Advisory Opinion 20-04 on the Public Readiness and Emergency Preparedness Act and The Secretarys Declaration Under the Act (Oct. 22, 2020)	002	Mallory Kass Smith
44	03/20/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Dept of Health & Human Servs., Advisory Opinion 21-01 on the Public Readiness and Emergency Preparedness Act Scope of Preemption Provision (Jan. 8, 2021)	002	Mallory Kass Smith
45	03/20/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Letter from Robert P. Charrow, Gen. Counsel, Dept of Health & Human Servs., to Thomas Barker, Foley Hoag LLP (Aug. 14, 2020)	002	Mallory Kass Smith
46	03/20/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	N.Y. Executive Order 202	002	Mallory Kass Smith
47	03/20/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	N.Y. Executive Order 202.6	002	Mallory Kass Smith
48	03/20/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	N.Y. Executive Order 202.8	002	Mallory Kass Smith
49	03/20/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	N.Y. Executive Order 202.10	002	Mallory Kass Smith
50	03/20/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	N.Y. Executive Order 202.14	002	Mallory Kass Smith
51	03/20/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	N.Y. Executive Order 202.28	002	Mallory Kass Smith
52	03/20/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	N.Y. Dept of Health, Advisory: Hospital Discharges and Admissions to Nursing Homes (Mar. 25, 2020)	002	Mallory Kass Smith
53	03/20/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Version of the EDTPA in effect between March 7, 2020 and August 2, 2020 (New York Public Health Law 3080-3082)	002	Mallory Kass Smith
54	03/20/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Shankle v. the Heights of Summerlin, No. A-21-836257-C (Nev. Distr. Ct., Aug. 25, 2022)	002	Mallory Kass Smith
55	03/20/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Saltanovich v. Sea View Hosp. Rehab. Ctr., No. 151312/2021 (Sup. Ct., Richmond Cnty. May 17, 2022)	002	Mallory Kass Smith
56	03/20/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Damon v. Clove Lakes Healthcare, No. 150031/2022 (Sup. Ct., Richmond Cnty. Jun. 21, 2022)	002	Mallory Kass Smith
57	03/20/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Garcia v. New York City Health and Hosps. Corp., No. 159046/2020 (Sup. Ct., N.Y. Cnty. Jul. 6, 2022)	002	Mallory Kass Smith
58	03/20/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	DeFonce v. Sky View Nursing and Rehab. Ctr., No. 61757/2022 (Sup. Ct., Westchester Cnty. Jan. 6, 2023)	002	Mallory Kass Smith
59	03/20/2023	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT	Affidavit of Robert G. Hurlbut in support of motion to dismiss	002	Mallory Kass Smith
60	03/20/2023	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT	Affidavit of Robert W. Hurlbut	002	Mallory Kass Smith
61	03/20/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Trademark information (TESS)	002	Mallory Kass Smith
62	03/20/2023	MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN SUPPORT		002	Mallory Kass Smith
63	04/07/2023	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION		002	Jesse Allen Drumm
64	04/17/2023	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN REPLY		002	Mallory Kass Smith
65	04/17/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	3.22.23 decision	002	Mallory Kass Smith
66	04/17/2023	MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN REPLY		002	Mallory Kass Smith
67	06/15/2023	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE	Letter re Supplemental Authority re Hasan Decision - as per 22 NYCRR 202.8-c	002	Mallory Kass Smith
68	06/15/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Supplemental Authority - Hasan Decision/Order	002	Mallory Kass Smith
69	06/21/2023	NOTICE OF APPEARANCE (POST RJI)	Notice of Appearance as Co-Counsel		Jeffrey Thomas Wolber
70	07/19/2023	ORDER - (PROPOSED) "SUBMIT ORDER" PER JUDGES DECISION		002	Mallory Kass Smith
71	07/19/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Decision	002	Mallory Kass Smith
72	07/28/2023	ORDER - MOTION - LONG FORM		002	Jennifer Gee
73	07/28/2023	NOTICE OF ENTRY		002	Mallory Kass Smith
74	08/17/2023	NOTICE OF APPEAL		002	Jesse Allen Drumm
75	08/17/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Notice of Appeal Exhibit A Notice of Entry & Order	002	Jesse Allen Drumm
76	08/17/2023	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE		002	Jesse Allen Drumm
77	08/24/2023	NOTICE OF CROSS APPEAL			Mallory Kass Smith
78	08/24/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Notice of Entry of Order		Mallory Kass Smith
79	08/24/2023	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE			Mallory Kass Smith

Monroe Supreme Court

2022

I2010013467

Disposed

OM-Other

THE HURLBUT, LLC

Pullano & Farrow PLLC

MILLER, ROBERT

05/05/2022

Valleriani, Hon. Sam L.

▼

Case Info

Court

Monroe Supreme Court

Index Number

I2010013467

Status

Disposed

Year Filed

2022

Case Name

THE HURLBUT, LLC vs. MILLER, ROBERT

Case Type

OM-Other

Track

Standard

RJI Filed

01/28/2022

NOI Due

01/28/2023

NOI Filed

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

Valleriani, Hon. Sam L.

Next Appearance

05/05/2022

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

THE HURLBUT, LLC

Attorney / FirmPullano & Farrow PLLC

Defendant / Respondent

MILLER, ROBERT

Attorneys / Firms

Motions (1)

#	Date Filed	Filed By	Relief Sought	Submit Date	Answer	Status	Decision	Order Signed
1	02/25/2022		Judgment - Summary	05/05/2022	No	Decided: 05/05/2022 Granted Before Justice: Valleriani, Hon. Sam L.	Short Form Order	05/09/2022

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints (13)

Doc #	Date Filed	Document	Description	Motion #	Filing User
1	10/15/2010	COUNTY CLERK MINUTES -PRIOR TO CONVERSION			Ariana C Rivera Cuevas
2	02/18/2022	CONSENT TO EFILING			Ariana C Rivera Cuevas
3	01/28/2022	RJI -RE: OTHER	Summary Judgment in Lieu of Complaint		Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
4	02/25/2022	NOTICE OF MOTION	Notice of Motion in Lieu of Complaint	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
5	02/25/2022	SUMMONS + COMPLAINT	Summons only	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
6	02/25/2022	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION	Affidavit of Anne Clayton	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
7	02/25/2022	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION	Attorney Affirmation	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
8	02/25/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Judgment filed on 12/27/2010	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
9	03/25/2022	PROOF OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
10	03/25/2022	PROOF OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
11	05/06/2022	ORDER ( PROPOSED )		1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
12	05/11/2022	ORDER - OTHER		1	Chery A Porter
13	01/24/2023	NOTICE OF APPEARANCE (POST RJI)			Sarah Nicole Pittman

Monroe Supreme Court

2021

E2020004192

Disposed

Comm-Contract

The Hurlbut, LLC

Pullano & Farrow PLLC

Medina, Catherine

01/26/2022

Donofrio, Hon. Gail A.

▼

Case Info

Court

Monroe Supreme Court

Index Number

E2020004192

Status

Disposed

Year Filed

2021

Case Name

The Hurlbut, LLC vs. Medina, Catherine

Case Type

Comm-Contract

Track

Standard

RJI Filed

06/25/2021

NOI Due

06/25/2022

NOI Filed

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

Donofrio, Hon. Gail A.

Next Appearance

01/26/2022

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

The Hurlbut, LLC

Attorney / FirmPullano & Farrow PLLC

Defendant / Respondent

Medina, Catherine

Attorneys / Firms

Motions (2)

#	Date Filed	Filed By	Relief Sought	Submit Date	Answer	Status	Decision	Order Signed
1	06/25/2021		Judgment - Summary	01/26/2022	No	Decided: 01/26/2022 Decision Reserved Before Justice: Donofrio, Hon. Gail A.	Oral
1	06/25/2021		Judgment - Summary	01/26/2022	No	Decided: 04/08/2022 Granted Before Justice: Donofrio, Hon. Gail A.		04/21/2022

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints (43)

Doc #	Date Filed	Document	Description	Motion #	Filing User
1	06/30/2020	SUMMONS + COMPLAINT	Summons and Complaint		Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
2	06/30/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Admission Agreement and Attachment C		Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
3	06/30/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Department of Health's Determination		Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
4	06/30/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Account invoice/bill		Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
5	07/16/2020	PROOF OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service		Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
6	07/16/2020	PROOF OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service - CPLR 3215		Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
7	06/25/2021	NOTICE OF MOTION		1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
8	06/25/2021	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION	Attorney Affirmation	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
9	06/25/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Summons and Complaint	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
10	06/25/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Affidavit of Service	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
11	06/25/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Answer	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
12	06/25/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Transcript	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
13	06/25/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Summons and Complaint	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
14	06/25/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Invoice/bill dated November 20, 2020	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
15	06/25/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Admission Agreement	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
16	06/25/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Answer	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
17	06/25/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Demand for a Verified Bill of Particulars	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
18	06/25/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Demand for Discovery and Inspection	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
19	06/25/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Citizens Bank account statement	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
20	06/25/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Copies of deposit slips	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
21	06/25/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Medicaid Budget Letters	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
22	06/25/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Medicaid documents	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
23	06/25/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Decision After Fair Hearing	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
24	06/25/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Photographs	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
25	06/25/2021	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION	Affidavit of Anne Clayton	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
26	06/25/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Monthly statements	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
27	06/25/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Account statement dated June 20, 2020	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
28	06/25/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Account statement dated May 20, 2021	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
29	06/25/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Medicaid budget letters	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
30	06/25/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Admission Agreement	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
31	06/25/2021	MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN SUPPORT		1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
32	06/25/2021	RJI -RE: NOTICE OF MOTION		1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
33	06/29/2021	PROOF OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
34	01/12/2022	COURT NOTICE			Kathleen M Saltrelli
35	04/26/2022	ORDER - SUMMARY JUDGMENT		1	Kathleen M Saltrelli
36	04/20/2022	AFFIRMATION OF ATTORNEY FEES		1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
37	04/20/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Contract (Admission Agreement & Personal Agreement)	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
38	04/20/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Invoices	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
39	04/20/2022	ORDER ( PROPOSED )		1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
40	04/21/2022	ORDER - SUMMARY JUDGMENT		1	Kathleen M Saltrelli
41	04/28/2022	JUDGMENT -TO COUNTY CLERK (PROPOSED)			Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
42	06/09/2022	NOTICE OF ENTRY		1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
43	06/09/2022	PROOF OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald

Monroe Supreme Court

2021

E2020005072

Disposed

Comm-Contract

The Hurlbut, LLC

Pullano & Farrow PLLC

Proia, Amanda

PANZARELLA & COIA PC

02/28/2023

Vazzana, Hon. James A.

▼

Case Info

Court

Monroe Supreme Court

Index Number

E2020005072

Status

Disposed

Year Filed

2021

Case Name

The Hurlbut, LLC vs. Proia, Amanda

Case Type

Comm-Contract

Track

Standard

RJI Filed

07/26/2021

NOI Due

07/26/2022

NOI Filed

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

Vazzana, Hon. James A.

Next Appearance

02/28/2023

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

The Hurlbut, LLC

Attorney / FirmPullano & Farrow PLLC

Defendant / Respondent

Proia, Amanda

Attorneys / FirmsPANZARELLA & COIA PC

Motions (3)

#	Date Filed	Relief Sought	Submit Date	Answer	Status	Decision	Order Signed
2	05/31/2022	Judgment - Summary	08/31/2022	No	Decided: 08/31/2022 Decision Reserved Before Justice: Donofrio, Hon. Gail A.
2	05/31/2022	Judgment - Summary	08/31/2022	No	Decided: 09/19/2022 Denied Before Justice: Donofrio, Hon. Gail A.	Oral	09/19/2022
1	07/26/2021	Subpoena	11/10/2021	No	Decided: 11/10/2021 Decided Before Justice: Donofrio, Hon. Gail A.	Oral	11/30/2021

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints (60)

Doc #	Date Filed	Document	Description	Motion #	Filing User
1	07/23/2020	SUMMONS + COMPLAINT	Summons and Complaint		Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
2	07/23/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Power of Attorney document		Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
3	07/23/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Admission Agreement		Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
4	07/23/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Account Invoice/Bill		Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
5	08/13/2020	PROOF OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service		Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
6	08/13/2020	PROOF OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service by Mail - CPLR 3215		Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
7	09/25/2020	ANSWER			Richard Coia
8	09/25/2020	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Mailing		Richard Coia
9	07/26/2021	NOTICE OF MOTION	Notice of Motion for Judicial Subpoena	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
10	07/26/2021	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION	Attorney Affirmation in Support of Mt for Judicial Subpoena	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
11	07/26/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Judicial Subpoena Duces Tecum with POA	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
12	07/26/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Deposition Transcript	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
13	07/26/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Answer	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
14	07/26/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit D - Complaint	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
15	07/26/2021	RJI -RE: NOTICE OF MOTION		1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
16	07/26/2021	ADDENDUM - COMMERCIAL DIVISION (840C)		1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
17	09/17/2021	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION		1	Richard Coia
18	10/28/2021	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN REPLY		1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
19	10/28/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Admission Agreement	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
20	10/28/2021	PROOF OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
21	11/24/2021	ORDER ( PROPOSED )		1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
22	11/24/2021	SUBPOENA ( REQUEST TO SO ORDER )		1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
23	11/30/2021	SUBPOENA - SO ORDERED		1	Kathleen M Saltrelli
24	11/30/2021	DECISION + ORDER ON MOTION		1	Kathleen M Saltrelli
25	12/13/2021	NOTICE OF ENTRY		1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
26	12/13/2021	PROOF OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service - Richard Coia	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
27	12/13/2021	PROOF OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service - JPMorgan Chase Bank	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
28	05/31/2022	NOTICE OF MOTION		2	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
29	05/31/2022	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION	Attorney Affirmation	2	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
30	05/31/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Summons and Complaint	2	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
31	05/31/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Affidavits of Service	2	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
32	05/31/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Answer	2	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
33	05/31/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Discovery Demands	2	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
34	05/31/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Deposition Transcript	2	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
35	05/31/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Order and Judicial Subpoena	2	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
36	05/31/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Subpoena response	2	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
37	05/31/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Medicaid documents	2	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
38	05/31/2022	MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN SUPPORT		2	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
39	05/31/2022	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION	Affidavit of Anne Clayton	2	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
40	05/31/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	monthly statements	2	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
41	05/31/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Account statement	2	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
42	05/31/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Account statement	2	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
43	05/31/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Medicaid Recoveries authorization	2	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
44	05/31/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Medicaid documents	2	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
45	05/31/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Admission Agreement	2	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
46	05/31/2022	PROOF OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service	2	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
47	06/03/2022	COURT NOTICE			Kathleen M Saltrelli
48	08/03/2022	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION		2	Richard Coia
49	08/03/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Personal Agreement	2	Richard Coia
50	08/03/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	first page of decision	2	Richard Coia
51	08/03/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	letters	2	Richard Coia
52	08/03/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	letter	2	Richard Coia
53	08/03/2022	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE		2	Richard Coia
54	08/10/2022	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN REPLY	Reply Affidavit in Further Support of Summary Judgment	2	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
55	08/10/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Documents from Medicaid Recoveries	2	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
56	08/10/2022	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN REPLY	Reply Affirmation in Further Support of Summary Judgment	2	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
57	08/10/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Communications regarding Medicaid denial & Letters	2	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
58	09/19/2022	ORDER - SUMMARY JUDGMENT		2	Kathleen M Saltrelli
59	01/10/2023	NOTICE OF APPEARANCE (POST RJI)			Langston David Mcfadden
60	02/21/2023	STIPULATION - DISCONTINUANCE (POST RJI)			Richard Coia

Monroe Supreme Court

2021

E2020005761

Disposed

Comm-Contract

The Hurlbut, LLC

Pullano & Farrow PLLC

McClure, Dana

10/12/2021

Odorisi, Hon. J. Scott

▼

Case Info

Court

Monroe Supreme Court

Index Number

E2020005761

Status

Disposed

Year Filed

2021

Case Name

The Hurlbut, LLC vs. McClure, Dana

Case Type

Comm-Contract

Track

Complex

RJI Filed

08/03/2021

NOI Due

11/04/2022

NOI Filed

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

Odorisi, Hon. J. Scott

Next Appearance

10/12/2021

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

The Hurlbut, LLC

Attorney / FirmPullano & Farrow PLLC

Defendant / Respondent

McClure, Dana

Attorneys / Firms

Motions (1)

#	Date Filed	Filed By	Relief Sought	Submit Date	Answer	Status	Decision	Order Signed
1	08/03/2021		Judgment - Default	10/12/2021	No	Decided: 10/12/2021 Granted Before Justice: Odorisi, Hon. J. Scott	Short Form Order	10/13/2021

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints (41)

Doc #	Date Filed	Document	Description	Motion #	Filing User
1	08/05/2020	SUMMONS + COMPLAINT	Summons and Complaint		Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
2	08/05/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Power of Attorney Document		Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
3	08/05/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Admission Agreement		Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
4	08/05/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Account Invoice/Bill		Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
5	08/05/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Deed		Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
6	08/24/2020	PROOF OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service		Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
7	08/24/2020	PROOF OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service by Mail - CPLR 3215		Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
8	08/03/2021	NOTICE OF MOTION		1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
9	08/03/2021	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION	Attorney Affirmation	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
10	08/03/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Power of Attorney document	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
11	08/03/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Summons and Complaint	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
12	08/03/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Affidavit of Service	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
13	08/03/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Affidavit of Mailing	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
14	08/03/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Itemized statement	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
15	08/03/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Testimony Transcript	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
16	08/03/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Medicaid budget letter	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
17	08/03/2021	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION	Affidavit of Anne Clayton	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
18	08/03/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Monthly statements	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
19	08/03/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Account statement	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
20	08/03/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Account statement	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
21	08/03/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Medicaid budget letter	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
22	08/03/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Admission Agreement	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
23	08/03/2021	MEMORANDUM OF LAW		1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
24	08/03/2021	RJI -RE: NOTICE OF MOTION		1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
25	08/05/2021	PROOF OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
26	08/12/2021	COURT NOTICE		1	Maureen P Ware
27	08/13/2021	PROOF OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
28	09/22/2021	AFFIDAVIT	Affidavit of Military Investigation		Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
29	10/13/2021	COURT NOTICE		1	Maureen P Ware
30	10/27/2021	AFFIRMATION OF ATTORNEY FEES		1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
31	10/27/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Contract	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
32	10/27/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Invoices	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
33	10/27/2021	ORDER ( PROPOSED )		1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
34	10/29/2021	ORDER - DEFAULT JUDGMENT		1	Maureen P Ware
35	12/13/2021	JUDGMENT -TO COUNTY CLERK (PROPOSED)			Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
36	12/13/2021	NOTICE OF ENTRY		1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
37	12/13/2021	PROOF OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
38	01/26/2023	NOTICE OF APPEARANCE (POST RJI)			Langston David Mcfadden
39	04/19/2024	NOTICE OF ENTRY	Notice of Entry & Judgment	1	Spencer Lee Ash
40	04/19/2024	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Service of Notice of Entry & Judgment	1	Spencer Lee Ash
41	09/10/2024	AFFIDAVIT OF PUBLICATION			Spencer Lee Ash

Monroe Supreme Court

2021

E2020008542

Disposed

Negligence

KINLEY, JOIANN

BROWN CHIARI LLP

SENECA NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTER et al

LAW OFFICES OF PULLANO & FARROW PLLC

04/24/2025

Skinner, Hon. Erin S.

▼

Case Info

Court

Monroe Supreme Court

Index Number

E2020008542

Status

Disposed

Year Filed

2021

Case Name

KINLEY, JOIANN vs. SENECA NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTER et al

Case Type

Tort-Other Negligence

Track

Standard

RJI Filed

12/07/2021

NOI Due

12/15/2023

NOI Filed

12/14/2023

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Jury At Plaintiff's Request

Justice

Skinner, Hon. Erin S.

Next Appearance

04/24/2025

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

KINLEY, JOIANN

Attorney / FirmBROWN CHIARI LLP

Defendant / Respondent

SENECA NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTER et al

Attorneys / FirmsLAW OFFICES OF PULLANO & FARROW PLLC

Motions (1)

#	Date Filed	Filed By	Relief Sought	Submit Date	Answer	Status	Decision	Order Signed
1	12/19/2024		Approve Settlement	02/14/2025	No	Decided: 02/14/2025 Denied Before Justice: Skinner, Hon. Erin S.	Short Form Order	02/14/2025

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints (80)

Doc #	Date Filed	Document	Description	Motion #	Filing User
1	10/30/2020	SUMMONS + COMPLAINT			Theresa M Walsh
2	11/20/2020	ANSWER WITH CROSS-CLAIM(S)	Answer w.x-claims (Hill Haven, RGH)		Christian Carlo Casini
3	11/20/2020	DEMAND FOR BILL OF PARTICULARS			Christian Carlo Casini
4	11/20/2020	DEMAND FOR:	CPLR Art. 31 Demands		Christian Carlo Casini
5	11/20/2020	DEMAND FOR:	Dem. Medicaid.Medicare Lien Info.		Christian Carlo Casini
6	11/20/2020	NOTICE OF DEPOSITION UPON ORAL EXAMINATION			Christian Carlo Casini
7	11/20/2020	AFFIDAVIT			Christian Carlo Casini
8	12/02/2020	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	AOS 11-12-2020 S&C Efile notice BVRNC Operating LLC		Angelo Salvatore Gambino
9	12/02/2020	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	AOS 11-12-2020 S&C Efile notice BVRNC Realty LLC		Angelo Salvatore Gambino
10	12/02/2020	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	AOS 11-12-2020 S&C Efile notice Hill Haven Nursing Home		Angelo Salvatore Gambino
11	12/02/2020	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	AOS 11-12-2020 S&C Efile notice Robert W. Hurlbut		Angelo Salvatore Gambino
12	12/02/2020	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	AOS 11-12-2020 S&C Efile notice ROHM Services Corp.		Angelo Salvatore Gambino
13	12/02/2020	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	AOS 11-12-2020 S&C Efile notice Sodus Rehab & Nursing Center		Angelo Salvatore Gambino
14	12/02/2020	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	AOS 11-17-2020 S&C Efile notice Rochester General Health System		Angelo Salvatore Gambino
15	12/02/2020	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	AOS 11-17-2020 S&C Efile notice Rochester General Long Term Care Inc.		Angelo Salvatore Gambino
16	12/02/2020	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	AOS 11-17-2020 S&C Efile notice Rochester Regional Health		Angelo Salvatore Gambino
17	12/02/2020	ANSWER WITH CROSS-CLAIM(S)			Mallory Kass Smith
18	12/09/2020	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	AOS 11-19-2020 S&C Efile notice Seneca Nursing and Rehab Ctr LLC		Angelo Salvatore Gambino
19	12/09/2020	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	AOS 11-19-2020 S&C Efile notice Seneca Nursing and Rehab Ctr		Angelo Salvatore Gambino
20	12/11/2020	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	AOS 11-20-2020 S&C Efiled notice Barth		Angelo Salvatore Gambino
21	12/11/2020	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	AOS 11-20-2020 S&C Efiled notice Walden		Angelo Salvatore Gambino
22	12/11/2020	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	AOS 11-20-2020 S&C Efiled notice Zagelbaum		Angelo Salvatore Gambino
23	12/31/2020	ANSWER WITH CROSS-CLAIM(S)	Answer with Cross-Claim and Initial Demands as to BVRNC Operating LLC d/b/a Sodus Rehabilitation & Nursing Center		Casey Mary Hughes
24	12/31/2020	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE			Casey Mary Hughes
25	12/31/2020	AFFIRMATION	Affirmation of Redaction		Casey Mary Hughes
26	12/31/2020	ANSWER WITH CROSS-CLAIM(S)	Answer with Cross-Claim and Initial Demands as to BVRNC Realty LLC		Casey Mary Hughes
27	12/31/2020	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE			Casey Mary Hughes
28	12/31/2020	AFFIRMATION	Affirmation of Redaction		Casey Mary Hughes
29	12/31/2020	ANSWER WITH CROSS-CLAIM(S)	Answer with Cross-Claim and Initial Demands as to Alexander Barth		Casey Mary Hughes
30	12/31/2020	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE			Casey Mary Hughes
31	12/31/2020	AFFIRMATION	Affirmation of Redaction		Casey Mary Hughes
32	12/31/2020	ANSWER WITH CROSS-CLAIM(S)	Answer with Cross-Claim and Initial Demands as to Yehudah Walden		Casey Mary Hughes
33	12/31/2020	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE			Casey Mary Hughes
34	12/31/2020	AFFIRMATION	Affirmation of Redaction		Casey Mary Hughes
35	12/31/2020	ANSWER WITH CROSS-CLAIM(S)	Answer with Cross-Claim and Initial Demands as to Ephraim Zagelbaum		Casey Mary Hughes
36	12/31/2020	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE			Casey Mary Hughes
37	12/31/2020	AFFIRMATION	Affirmation of Redaction		Casey Mary Hughes
38	12/31/2020	AFFIRMATION	Statement of Authorization for Electronic Filing		Casey Mary Hughes
39	12/07/2021	RJI -RE: REQUEST FOR PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE			Angelo Salvatore Gambino
40	12/07/2021	ADDENDUM - GENERAL (840A)			Angelo Salvatore Gambino
41	01/06/2022	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE	So Ordered		Christian Carlo Casini
42	01/10/2022	ORDER - CASE SCHEDULING			Sue Lerkins
43	11/15/2022	ORDER - (PROPOSED) "SUBMIT ORDER" PER JUDGES DECISION	Amended Scheduling Order		Mallory Kass Smith
44	11/16/2022	ORDER - CASE SCHEDULING			Sue Lerkins
45	03/17/2023	STIPULATION - OTHER - ( REQUEST TO SO ORDER )	Stipulated Order to Substitute Plaintiff		Angelo Salvatore Gambino
46	03/23/2023	STIPULATION - SO ORDERED			Sue Lerkins
47	06/28/2023	LETTER/CORRESPONDENCE FROM COURT			Tammy M Buck
48	07/27/2023	ORDER - CASE SCHEDULING			Tammy M Buck
49	08/31/2023	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE			Angelo Salvatore Gambino
50	08/31/2023	ORDER - CASE SCHEDULING			Tammy M Buck
51	12/14/2023	NOTE OF ISSUE:WITH JURY			Angelo Salvatore Gambino
52	01/03/2024	ORDER - TRIAL SCHEDULING			Tammy M Buck
53	01/03/2024	ORDER - TRIAL SCHEDULING			Tammy M Buck
54	01/29/2024	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE	Letter to Court re: SJ extension		Kristen Elizabeth Griffin
55	01/29/2024	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE			Kristen Elizabeth Griffin
56	02/22/2024	STIPULATION - DISCONTINUANCE ( REQUEST TO SO ORDER )	Partial Stipulation of Discontinuance		Aimee La Fever Koch
57	02/22/2024	STIPULATION - SO ORDERED			Tammy M Buck
58	07/23/2024	NOTICE OF APPEARANCE (POST RJI)			Paul Francis Keneally
59	07/29/2024	STIPULATION - SETTLEMENT (POST RJI)	Stipulation of Settlement (Sodus)		Kristen Elizabeth Griffin
60	07/31/2024	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE	Letter to Court re: Settlement		Kristen Elizabeth Griffin
61	12/05/2024	NOTICE TO COUNTY CLERK - AMENDMENT OF CAPTION			Michael Christopher Scinta
62	12/19/2024	NOTICE OF PETITION		1	Michael Christopher Scinta
63	12/19/2024	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT	Joiann Kinley Affidavit	1	Michael Christopher Scinta
64	12/19/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Death Certificate	1	Michael Christopher Scinta
65	12/19/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Medicare Final Demand	1	Michael Christopher Scinta
66	12/19/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Precision Resolution Final Invoice	1	Michael Christopher Scinta
67	12/19/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Wayne County DSS Lien	1	Michael Christopher Scinta
68	12/19/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Wayne County DSS Final Demand	1	Michael Christopher Scinta
69	12/19/2024	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT	Affirmation of Michael Scinta, Esq.	1	Michael Christopher Scinta
70	12/19/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Letters Testamentary	1	Michael Christopher Scinta
71	12/19/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Medicare Final Demand	1	Michael Christopher Scinta
72	12/19/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Precision Resolution Final Invoice	1	Michael Christopher Scinta
73	12/19/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Wayne County DSS Lien	1	Michael Christopher Scinta
74	12/19/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Wayne County DSS Final Demand	1	Michael Christopher Scinta
75	12/19/2024	ORDER ( PROPOSED )		1	Michael Christopher Scinta
76	12/30/2024	COURT NOTICE		1	Erin Tubbs
77	02/14/2025	ORDER - OTHER	Decision & Order	1	Jodi Smith-Schuler
78	03/27/2025	COURT NOTICE			Jodi Smith-Schuler
79	05/29/2025	STIPULATION - DISCONTINUANCE (POST RJI)	Stipulation of Discontinuance with Prejudice as to ROHM Services Corporation ONLY		Paul Francis Keneally
80	06/10/2025	STIPULATION - DISCONTINUANCE (POST RJI)			Langston David Mcfadden

Monroe Supreme Court

2021

E2021000347

Disposed

Comm-Contract

THE HURLBUT, LLC

Pullano & Farrow PLLC

HOOD, BENJAMIN

11/01/2023

Vazzana, Hon. James A.

▼

Case Info

Court

Monroe Supreme Court

Index Number

E2021000347

Status

Disposed

Year Filed

2021

Case Name

THE HURLBUT, LLC vs. HOOD, BENJAMIN

Case Type

Comm-Contract

Track

Standard

RJI Filed

06/18/2021

NOI Due

06/18/2022

NOI Filed

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

Vazzana, Hon. James A.

Next Appearance

11/01/2023

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

THE HURLBUT, LLC

Attorney / FirmPullano & Farrow PLLC

Defendant / Respondent

HOOD, BENJAMIN

Attorneys / Firms

Motions (2)

#	Date Filed	Filed By	Relief Sought	Submit Date	Answer	Status	Decision	Order Signed
2	08/14/2024		Vacate - Decision/Order/Judgment/Award	08/20/2024	No	Decided: 08/20/2024 Granted Before Justice: Vazzana, Hon. James A.	Short Form Order	08/20/2024
1	06/18/2021		Judgment - Default	11/01/2023	No	Decided: 11/01/2023 Granted Before Justice: Vazzana, Hon. James A.	Short Form Order	11/21/2023

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints (60)

Doc #	Date Filed	Document	Description	Motion #	Filing User
1	01/14/2021	SUMMONS + COMPLAINT			Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
2	01/14/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Admission Agreement		Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
3	01/14/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Invoice for Services		Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
4	01/28/2021	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE			Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
5	01/29/2021	PROOF OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service by Mail - CPLR 3215		Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
6	06/18/2021	NOTICE OF MOTION		1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
7	06/18/2021	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION		1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
8	06/18/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Summons and Complaint	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
9	06/18/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Affidavit of Service	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
10	06/18/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Affidavit of Mailing	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
11	06/18/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Demand Letters	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
12	06/18/2021	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION	Affidavit of Anne Clayton	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
13	06/18/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	monthly statements	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
14	06/18/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Fidelis Care document	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
15	06/18/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Medicaid Budget Letters	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
16	06/18/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Admission Agreement	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
17	06/18/2021	MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN SUPPORT		1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
18	06/18/2021	RJI -RE: NOTICE OF MOTION		1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
19	06/22/2021	PROOF OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
20	08/11/2021	PROOF OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
21	09/20/2021	ORDER ( PROPOSED )		1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
22	09/20/2021	DECISION + ORDER ON MOTION		1	Kathleen M Saltrelli
23	09/21/2021	NOTICE OF ENTRY		1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
24	09/21/2021	PROOF OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
25	02/01/2022	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION	Anne Clayton Supplemental Affidavit	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
26	02/01/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Medicaid Budget Letters	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
27	02/01/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Contract - VNA Homecare Options, LLC	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
28	02/01/2022	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION	Attorney's Supplemental Affirmation	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
29	02/01/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Summons & Complaint	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
30	02/01/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Affidavit of Service for Summons & Complaint	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
31	02/01/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Affidavit of Service CPLR 3215 for Summons & Complaint	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
32	02/01/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Death Certificate	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
33	02/01/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Medicaid Budget Letters	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
34	02/01/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Contract VNA Homecare Options, LLC	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
35	02/01/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Invoices	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
36	02/01/2022	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Service of Supplemental Affidavit and Affirmation	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
37	01/26/2023	NOTICE OF APPEARANCE (PRE RJI)			Langston David Mcfadden
38	08/28/2023	COURT NOTICE			Bryan Dibiase
39	09/05/2023	PROOF OF SERVICE	Service of motion papers and court notice	1	Sarah Nicole Pittman
40	11/20/2023	AFFIRMATION OF ATTORNEY FEES		1	Sarah Nicole Pittman
41	11/20/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Admission Agreement	1	Sarah Nicole Pittman
43	11/20/2023	ORDER ( PROPOSED )		1	Sarah Nicole Pittman
44	11/20/2023	EXHIBIT(S)	Invoices (Exhibit B to Attorney Fee Affirmation)	1	Sarah Nicole Pittman
45	11/21/2023	ORDER - DEFAULT JUDGMENT		1	Bryan Dibiase
46	11/22/2023	NOTICE OF ENTRY	Notice of Entry & Order	1	Sarah Nicole Pittman
47	11/22/2023	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Service of Notice of Entry & Order	1	Sarah Nicole Pittman
48	11/28/2023	AFFIDAVIT	Affidavit of Military Investigation of Benjamin Hood	1	Sarah Nicole Pittman
49	11/28/2023	JUDGMENT -TO COUNTY CLERK (PROPOSED)		1	Sarah Nicole Pittman
50	11/30/2023	JUDGMENT			Ccuser Monroecc
51	12/08/2023	NOTICE OF ENTRY	Notice of Entry & Judgment	1	Langston David Mcfadden
52	12/08/2023	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Service of Notice of Entry & Judgment	1	Langston David Mcfadden
53	08/14/2024	ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE ( PROPOSED )		2	Spencer Lee Ash
54	08/14/2024	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF PROPOSED OSC/EXPARTE APP		2	Spencer Lee Ash
55	08/14/2024	EXHIBIT(S)	Obituary	2	Spencer Lee Ash
56	08/14/2024	ORDER ( PROPOSED )		2	Spencer Lee Ash
57	08/20/2024	ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE		2	Bryan Dibiase
58	08/15/2024	ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE ( PROPOSED )			Spencer Lee Ash
59	08/21/2024	ORDER - OTHER		2	Bryan Dibiase
60	09/05/2024	NOTICE OF ENTRY		2	Spencer Lee Ash
61	09/16/2024	JUDGMENT - VACATED			Ccuser Monroecc

Monroe Supreme Court

2020

E2019010163

Disposed

Comm-Contract

THE HURLBUT, LLC

Pullano & Farrow PLLC

GARDNER, CHARLES S et al

03/08/2022

Doyle, Hon. Daniel J.

▼

Case Info

Court

Monroe Supreme Court

Index Number

E2019010163

Status

Disposed

Year Filed

2020

Case Name

THE HURLBUT, LLC vs. GARDNER, CHARLES S et al

Case Type

Comm-Contract

Track

Standard

RJI Filed

08/14/2020

NOI Due

08/14/2021

NOI Filed

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

Doyle, Hon. Daniel J.

Next Appearance

03/08/2022

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

THE HURLBUT, LLC

Attorney / FirmPullano & Farrow PLLC

Defendant / Respondent

GARDNER, CHARLES S et al

Attorneys / Firms

Motions (2)

#	Date Filed	Filed By	Relief Sought	Submit Date	Answer	Status	Decision	Order Signed
1	08/14/2020		Judgment - Default	09/14/2021	No	Decided: 09/14/2021 Decision Reserved Before Justice: Doyle, Hon. Daniel J.
1	08/14/2020		Judgment - Default	09/14/2021	No	Decided: 02/28/2022 Decided Before Justice: Doyle, Hon. Daniel J.	Short Form Order	02/28/2022

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints (37)

Doc #	Date Filed	Document	Description	Motion #	Filing User
1	10/28/2019	SUMMONS + COMPLAINT			Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
2	10/28/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	Admission Agreement		Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
3	10/28/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	Account Invoice/Bill		Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
4	11/14/2019	PROOF OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service - Charles Gardner		Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
5	11/14/2019	PROOF OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service - Marcia Gardner		Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
6	11/14/2019	PROOF OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service CPLR 3215		Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
7	08/14/2020	NOTICE OF MOTION	Notice of Motion For Default Judgment	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
8	08/14/2020	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION	Attorney Affirmation	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
9	08/14/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Summons and Complaint	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
10	08/14/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Affidavits of Service	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
11	08/14/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Affidavit of Mailing	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
12	08/14/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Admission Agreement	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
13	08/14/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Itemized Statement	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
14	08/14/2020	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION	Affidavit of Anne Clayton	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
15	08/14/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Monthly Statements	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
16	08/14/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Account Statement	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
17	08/14/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Recent Account Statement	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
18	08/14/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Medicaid Budget Letters	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
19	08/14/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Admission Agreement	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
20	08/14/2020	PROOF OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service by Mail	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
21	08/14/2020	RJI -RE: NOTICE OF MOTION		1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
22	08/21/2020	COURT NOTICE			Mary E Wagner
22-1	08/21/2020	ATTACHMENT TO COURT NOTICE			Mary E Wagner
23	08/24/2020	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service by Mail	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
24	07/23/2021	PROOF OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
25	02/09/2022	AFFIRMATION OF ATTORNEY FEES	Attorney Fee Affirmation	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
26	02/09/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Invoices	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
27	02/09/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Admission agreement	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
28	02/09/2022	ORDER ( PROPOSED )		1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
29	02/14/2022	ORDER - DEFAULT JUDGMENT		1	Sue Lerkins
30	03/01/2022	ORDER - DEFAULT JUDGMENT	Corrected order - default judgment	1	Sue Lerkins
31	03/07/2022	JUDGMENT -TO COUNTY CLERK (PROPOSED)	(Charles S. Gardner)		Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
32	03/07/2022	JUDGMENT -TO COUNTY CLERK (PROPOSED)	(Marcia L. Gardner)		Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
33	03/08/2022	NOTICE OF ENTRY		1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
34	03/08/2022	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
35	03/24/2022	PROOF OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service	1	Ryan Joseph Mcdonald
36	05/26/2022	OTHER COURT FILED DOCUMENT	TRANS. OF JDGMNT RECEIPT RECVD WAYNE COUNTY		Ccuser Monroecc

Monroe Supreme Court

2020

E2020000547

Disposed

Tort

King, Sabrina

LIPSITZ GREEN SCIME CAMBRIA LLP

Westgate Nursing Home, Inc.

UNDERBERG & KESSLER LLP

04/27/2022

Donofrio, Hon. Gail A.

▼

Case Info

Court

Monroe Supreme Court

Index Number

E2020000547

Status

Disposed

Year Filed

2020

Case Name

King, Sabrina vs. Westgate Nursing Home, Inc.

Case Type

Tort-Other

Track

Standard

RJI Filed

09/16/2020

NOI Due

09/16/2021

NOI Filed

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

Donofrio, Hon. Gail A.

Next Appearance

04/27/2022

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

King, Sabrina

Attorney / FirmLIPSITZ GREEN SCIME CAMBRIA LLP

Defendant / Respondent

Westgate Nursing Home, Inc.

Attorneys / FirmsUNDERBERG & KESSLER LLP

Motions (1)

#	Date Filed	Filed By	Relief Sought	Submit Date	Answer	Status	Decision	Order Signed
1	09/16/2020		Compel	11/30/2020	No	Decided: 11/30/2020 Withdrawn Before Justice: Piampiano, Hon. James J.

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints (36)

Doc #	Date Filed	Document	Description	Motion #	Filing User
1	01/15/2020	SUMMONS + COMPLAINT			Dale James Bauman
2	02/05/2020	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Re. Westgate Nursing Home, Inc. d/b/a Creekview Nursing and Rehab Center		Dale James Bauman
3	02/05/2020	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Re. Hurlbut Health Consulting		Dale James Bauman
4	02/05/2020	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Re. Hurlbut RHCF Partnership		Dale James Bauman
5	02/05/2020	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Re. Rohm Services Corporation		Dale James Bauman
6	02/05/2020	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Re. RHH RHCF Corporation		Dale James Bauman
7	02/05/2020	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Re. The Hurlbut, LLC		Dale James Bauman
8	02/13/2020	ANSWER WITH CROSS-CLAIM(S)			Mallory Kass Smith
9	02/17/2020	ANSWER	Defendant Westgate d/b/a Creekview Answer		Jessie Gregorio
10	02/17/2020	ANSWER	Defendant Paragon Answer		Jessie Gregorio
11	07/22/2020	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE			Dale James Bauman
12	09/16/2020	NOTICE OF MOTION	Defendants Notice of Motion to Compel	1	Jessie Gregorio
13	09/16/2020	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION	Defs Aff in Supp of Motion to Compel	1	Jessie Gregorio
14	09/16/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Summons and Complaint	1	Jessie Gregorio
15	09/16/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Defendant Westgate Answer	1	Jessie Gregorio
16	09/16/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Def Paragon Answer	1	Jessie Gregorio
17	09/16/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Def Westgate DVBOP	1	Jessie Gregorio
18	09/16/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Def Paragon DVBOP	1	Jessie Gregorio
19	09/16/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Def Westgate Art 31 Demands	1	Jessie Gregorio
20	09/16/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Def Paragon Art 31 Demands	1	Jessie Gregorio
21	09/16/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Defs Demand for Medicare Medicaid Lien Info	1	Jessie Gregorio
22	09/16/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Defs Notice to Produce	1	Jessie Gregorio
23	09/16/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Defs Notice to take EBT	1	Jessie Gregorio
24	09/16/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Defs Demand for HIPAA Az	1	Jessie Gregorio
25	09/16/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Defs Aff Mailing	1	Jessie Gregorio
26	09/16/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Defs Good Faith Ltr 6/4/20	1	Jessie Gregorio
27	09/16/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Defs Good Faith Ltr 7/22/20	1	Jessie Gregorio
28	09/16/2020	RJI -RE: NOTICE OF MOTION		1	Jessie Gregorio
29	09/16/2020	ADDENDUM - GENERAL (840A)		1	Jessie Gregorio
30	09/21/2020	COURT NOTICE		1	Donna M. Brongo
30-1	09/21/2020	ATTACHMENT TO COURT NOTICE		1	Donna M. Brongo
31	10/14/2020	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE	Ltr to Judge Request Adjournment of Motion	1	Jessie Gregorio
32	11/25/2020	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION	Bauman Affirmation	1	Dale James Bauman
33	11/30/2020	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE	Ltr to Judge Piampiano withdraw Defs Motion to Compel	1	Jessie Gregorio
34	03/04/2022	ORDER - MEDIATION			Kathleen M Saltrelli
35	08/05/2022	STIPULATION - DISCONTINUANCE (POST RJI)			Colin Dunn Ramsey

Monroe Supreme Court

2020

E2020003488

Disposed-Consolidated Into

RP-Tax Certiorari

In the Matter of the Application for Review Under Article 7 of the Real Property Tax Law of a Tax Assessment by Shore Winds Properties LLC and Robert H. Hurlbut

KAVINOKY COOK LLP

The Board of Assessment Review for the City of Rochester et al

The Board of Assessment Review for the City of Rochester

11/06/2023

Doyle, Hon. Daniel J.

▼

Case Info

Court

Monroe Supreme Court

Index Number

E2020003488

Status

Disposed-Consolidated Into

Year Filed

2020

Case Name

In the Matter of the Application for Review Under Article 7 of the Real Property Tax Law of a Tax Assessment by Shore Winds Properties LLC and Robert H. Hurlbut vs. The Board of Assessment Review for the City of Rochester et al

Case Type

RP-Tax Certiorari

Track

Complex

RJI Filed

05/29/2020

NOI Due

05/29/2024

NOI Filed

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

Doyle, Hon. Daniel J.

Next Appearance

11/06/2023

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

In the Matter of the Application for Review Under Article 7 of the Real Property Tax Law of a Tax Assessment by Shore Winds Properties LLC and Robert H. Hurlbut

Attorney / FirmKAVINOKY COOK LLP

Defendant / Respondent

The Board of Assessment Review for the City of Rochester et al

Attorneys / FirmsThe Board of Assessment Review for the City of Rochester

Motions (1)

#	Date Filed	Filed By	Relief Sought	Submit Date	Answer	Status	Decision	Order Signed
1	05/29/2020		Tax Assessment Review	07/23/2020	No	Decided: 07/23/2020 Decided Before Justice: Donofrio, Hon. Gail A.

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints (39)

Doc #	Date Filed	Document	Description	Motion #	Filing User
1	05/29/2020	PETITION			Scott Christopher Becker
2	05/29/2020	NOTICE OF PETITION ACCOMPANYING COMMENCEMENT DOC(S)		1	Scott Christopher Becker
3	05/29/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Side Number 1		Scott Christopher Becker
4	05/29/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit A to Side Number 1		Scott Christopher Becker
5	05/29/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Side Number 2		Scott Christopher Becker
6	05/29/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit A to Side Number 2		Scott Christopher Becker
7	05/29/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Side Number 3		Scott Christopher Becker
8	05/29/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit A to Side Number 3		Scott Christopher Becker
9	05/29/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Side Number 4		Scott Christopher Becker
10	05/29/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit A to Side Number 4		Scott Christopher Becker
11	05/29/2020	AFFIRMATION	Commercial Division Addendum to RJI		Scott Christopher Becker
12	05/29/2020	RJI -RE: NOTICE OF PETITION	Prior tax year assigned to Judge Donfrio		Scott Christopher Becker
13	05/29/2020	ADDENDUM - GENERAL (840A)			Scott Christopher Becker
14	06/09/2020	COURT NOTICE			Lisa Cohan
15	06/10/2020	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Affidavit Proof of Service on a Corporation	1	Scott Christopher Becker
16	06/10/2020	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service by Mail	1	Scott Christopher Becker
17	07/14/2020	NOTICE OF APPEARANCE (PRE RJI)			John M. Campolieto
18	07/14/2020	STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING			John M. Campolieto
19	07/17/2020	ORDER ( PROPOSED )	Proposed Scheduling Order		Scott Christopher Becker
20	07/17/2020	ORDER - OTHER	SCHEDULING ORDER		Kathleen M Saltrelli
21	11/06/2020	ORDER ( PROPOSED )	Amended Scheduling Order		Scott Christopher Becker
22	11/11/2020	ORDER - OTHER	AMENDED SCHEDULING ORDER		Kathleen M Saltrelli
23	06/18/2021	ORDER ( PROPOSED )	Amended Scheduling Order		Scott Christopher Becker
24	10/12/2021	ORDER - AMENDED	AMENDED SCHEDULING ORDER		Kathleen M Saltrelli
25	12/15/2021	ORDER ( PROPOSED )	Amended Scheduling Order		Scott Christopher Becker
26	12/22/2021	ORDER - AMENDED	Scheduling Order		Kathleen M Saltrelli
27	01/06/2022	NOTICE OF ENTRY	Notice of Entry		Scott Christopher Becker
28	04/28/2022	ORDER ( PROPOSED )	Amended Scheduling Order		Scott Christopher Becker
29	05/03/2022	ORDER - CASE SCHEDULING			Maureen P Ware
30	07/27/2022	ORDER ( PROPOSED )	Amended Scheduling Order		Scott Christopher Becker
31	07/28/2022	ORDER - CASE SCHEDULING			Maureen P Ware
32	08/05/2022	NOTICE OF ENTRY	Notice of Entry		Scott Christopher Becker
33	05/09/2023	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE	Letter to Judge Odorisi / appraisal exchange date		Scott Christopher Becker
34	05/16/2023	ORDER - CASE SCHEDULING			Maureen P Ware
35	05/16/2023	NOTICE OF ENTRY	Notice of Entry		Scott Christopher Becker
36	07/06/2023	LETTER/CORRESPONDENCE - SO ORDERED			Sue Lerkins
37	07/25/2023	COURT NOTICE			Michael Habich
38	03/08/2024	ORDER ( PROPOSED )	Scheduling Order		Scott Christopher Becker
39	03/11/2024	ORDER - CONSOLIDATION	CASE SCHEDULING		Sue Lerkins

Monroe Supreme Court

2020

E2020006494

Disposed

SP-Other

Hurlbut, Robert W.

LAW OFFICES OF PULLANO & FARROW PLLC

Leo M. Bean Funeral Home, Inc. d/b/a Leo M. Bean and Sons Funeral Home et al

Leo M. Bean Funeral Home, Inc. d/b/a Leo M. Bean and Sons Funeral Home

07/07/2022

Ciaccio, Hon. Christopher S.

▼

Case Info

Court

Monroe Supreme Court

Index Number

E2020006494

Status

Disposed

Year Filed

2020

Case Name

Hurlbut, Robert W. vs. Leo M. Bean Funeral Home, Inc. d/b/a Leo M. Bean and Sons Funeral Home et al

Case Type

SP-Other

Track

Standard

RJI Filed

08/25/2020

NOI Due

08/25/2021

NOI Filed

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

Ciaccio, Hon. Christopher S.

Next Appearance

07/07/2022

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

Hurlbut, Robert W.

Attorney / FirmLAW OFFICES OF PULLANO & FARROW PLLC

Defendant / Respondent

Leo M. Bean Funeral Home, Inc. d/b/a Leo M. Bean and Sons Funeral Home et al

Attorneys / FirmsLeo M. Bean Funeral Home, Inc. d/b/a Leo M. Bean and Sons Funeral Home

Motions (9)

#	Date Filed	Relief Sought	Submit Date	Answer	Status	Decision
7	02/10/2021	Other	03/10/2021	No	Decided: 03/10/2021 Decision Reserved Before Justice: Doyle, Hon. Daniel J.	Oral
7	02/10/2021	Other	03/10/2021	No	Decided: 03/10/2022 Decided Before Justice: Doyle, Hon. Daniel J.
6	12/30/2020	Compel	08/22/2022	No	Decided: 08/22/2022 Closed Before Justice: Ciaccio, Hon. Christopher S.
5	12/07/2020	Renew/Reargue/Resettle/Reconsider	03/19/2021	No	Decided: 03/19/2021 Denied Before Justice: Doyle, Hon. Daniel J.	Short Form Order
4	12/03/2020	Other	08/22/2022	No	Decided: 08/22/2022 Closed Before Justice: Ciaccio, Hon. Christopher S.
3	12/03/2020	Protective Order	03/19/2021	No	Decided: 03/19/2021 Granted Before Justice: Doyle, Hon. Daniel J.	Short Form Order
2	08/27/2020	Seal	08/28/2020	No	Decided: 08/28/2020 Granted Before Justice: Piampiano, Hon. James J.
1	08/25/2020	Injunction/Restraining Order	09/01/2020	No	Decided: 09/01/2020 Decided Before Justice: Piampiano, Hon. James J.
1	08/25/2020	Injunction/Restraining Order	09/01/2020	No	Decided: 09/01/2020 Decision Reserved Before Justice: Piampiano, Hon. James J.

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints (134)

Doc #	Date Filed	Document	Description	Motion #	Filing User
1	08/25/2020	PETITION			Langston David Mcfadden
2	08/25/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Appointment of Agent to Control Disposition of Remains		Langston David Mcfadden
3	08/25/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	HC-PRI		Langston David Mcfadden
4	08/25/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	7.28.20 Dr. Mendelson report		Langston David Mcfadden
5	08/25/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	8.24.20 ltr to Leo M. Bean Funeral Home		Langston David Mcfadden
6	08/25/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	8.24.20 ltr from Foss to McFadden		Langston David Mcfadden
7	08/25/2020	ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE ( PROPOSED )		1	Langston David Mcfadden
8	08/25/2020	RJI -RE: ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE			Langston David Mcfadden
9	08/25/2020	ADDENDUM - GENERAL (840A)			Langston David Mcfadden
10	08/25/2020	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE			Langston David Mcfadden
11	08/26/2020	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE		1	Douglas Alan Foss
12	08/26/2020	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE		1	Christian Nicholas Valentino
13	08/27/2020	ORDER - OTHER	Order to Show Cause signed by Justice Piampiano		Mary E Wagner
14	08/26/2020	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE		1	Christian Nicholas Valentino
15	08/27/2020	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE		1	Christian Nicholas Valentino
16	08/27/2020	ANSWER IN SPECIAL PROCEEDING		1	Douglas Alan Foss
17	08/27/2020	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE	of Christine A. Owen	1	Douglas Alan Foss
18	08/27/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	2020-08-03 Deposition Transcript of Lizbeth Gonzalez	1	Douglas Alan Foss
19	08/27/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	2020-01-07 Transcript of Incident at 200 Sheldon Road	1	Douglas Alan Foss
20	08/27/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	2020-08-24 Letter from Foss to McFadden (responding to Valentino letter to Bean Funeral Home)	1	Douglas Alan Foss
21	08/27/2020	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE	of Daniel A. Mendelson, M.D.	1	Douglas Alan Foss
22	08/27/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	2019-08-05 Assessment (Dr. Mendelson)_Redacted	1	Douglas Alan Foss
23	08/27/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Aug 2020 evaluation - redacted	1	Douglas Alan Foss
24	08/27/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Dr. Daniel Mendelson CV dated 7.15.2020	1	Douglas Alan Foss
25	08/27/2020	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE	of John F. Speranza, Esq.	1	Douglas Alan Foss
26	08/27/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Order Appointing Guardian Ad Litem dated 5.29.2019	1	Douglas Alan Foss
27	08/27/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Appointment of Agent to Control Disposition of Remains dated 9.12.2017	1	Douglas Alan Foss
28	08/27/2020	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE	of Philip L. Burke, Esq.	1	Douglas Alan Foss
29	08/27/2020	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE	of Christen C. Bruu, Esq.	1	Douglas Alan Foss
30	08/27/2020	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE	of Thanhsamay Howard	1	Douglas Alan Foss
31	08/27/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Caregivers' License - Thanhsamay Howard (LPN)	1	Douglas Alan Foss
32	08/27/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	2020-07-02 Deposition Transcript of Thanhsamay Howard	1	Douglas Alan Foss
33	08/27/2020	MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN OPPOSITION	to Petition	1	Douglas Alan Foss
34	08/28/2020	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT		1	Christian Nicholas Valentino
35	08/28/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Letter from Phil Burke 5.30.19	1	Christian Nicholas Valentino
36	08/28/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Dr. Mendelson's records	1	Christian Nicholas Valentino
37	08/28/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Order appointing Guardian Ad Litem	1	Christian Nicholas Valentino
38	08/28/2020	MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN SUPPORT		1	Christian Nicholas Valentino
39	10/15/2020	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE		1	Douglas Alan Foss
40	10/30/2020	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE	re Discovery Issues		Douglas Alan Foss
41	11/05/2020	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE			Christian Nicholas Valentino
42	11/09/2020	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE		1	Christian Nicholas Valentino
43	11/09/2020	ORDER ( PROPOSED )		1	Christian Nicholas Valentino
44	11/10/2020	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE		1	Douglas Alan Foss
45	11/11/2020	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE		1	Christian Nicholas Valentino
46	11/11/2020	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE		1	Kyle Douglas Gooch
47	11/11/2020	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE	corrected version of Doc. 21 - Affirmation of Dr. Mendelson	1	Kyle Douglas Gooch
48	11/12/2020	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE			Christian Nicholas Valentino
49	11/12/2020	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE		1	Douglas Alan Foss
50	12/03/2020	NOTICE OF MOTION	for Protective Order	3	Douglas Alan Foss
51	12/03/2020	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT	of Douglas A. Foss	3	Douglas Alan Foss
52	12/03/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Proposed Confidentiality Order	3	Douglas Alan Foss
53	12/03/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	PHL Section 18 Request	3	Douglas Alan Foss
54	12/03/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Subpoena Duces Tecum	3	Douglas Alan Foss
55	12/03/2020	MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN SUPPORT		3	Douglas Alan Foss
56	12/03/2020	NOTICE OF MOTION	for Scheduling Order	4	Douglas Alan Foss
57	12/03/2020	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION	of Douglas A. Foss	4	Douglas Alan Foss
58	12/07/2020	NOTICE OF MOTION	for Partial Summary Determination	5	Douglas Alan Foss
59	12/07/2020	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION	of Douglas A. Foss	5	Douglas Alan Foss
60	12/07/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	2020-09-01 Transcript of Hearing on OTSC	5	Douglas Alan Foss
61	12/07/2020	MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN SUPPORT		5	Douglas Alan Foss
62	12/09/2020	COURT NOTICE		3	Donna M. Brongo
62-1	12/09/2020	ATTACHMENT TO COURT NOTICE		3	Donna M. Brongo
63	12/09/2020	COURT NOTICE		4	Donna M. Brongo
63-1	12/09/2020	ATTACHMENT TO COURT NOTICE		4	Donna M. Brongo
64	12/09/2020	COURT NOTICE		5	Donna M. Brongo
64-1	12/09/2020	ATTACHMENT TO COURT NOTICE		5	Donna M. Brongo
65	12/30/2020	NOTICE OF CROSS-MOTION	Notice of Cross Motion for leave to secure records from CAH Caring Hearts and Motion to Compel Production	6	Christian Nicholas Valentino
66	12/30/2020	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN FURTHER SUPPORT OF CROSS-MOTION	Attorney Affirmation In Support of Cross Motion	6	Christian Nicholas Valentino
67	12/30/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	9.3.20 request for records to CAH Caring Hearts	6	Christian Nicholas Valentino
68	12/30/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	e-mail Douglas Foss agreeing to accept service of subpoena to CAH Caring Hearts	6	Christian Nicholas Valentino
69	12/30/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Subpoena issued to CAH Caring Hearts	6	Christian Nicholas Valentino
70	12/30/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Affidavit of Service for Subpoena to CAH Caring Hearts	6	Christian Nicholas Valentino
71	12/30/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Good faith e-mail from Christian Valentino to Douglas Foss Re: Production of CAH Caring Hearts records	6	Christian Nicholas Valentino
72	01/05/2021	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION		5	Christian Nicholas Valentino
73	01/05/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Transcript of Judge Piampiano's decision	5	Christian Nicholas Valentino
74	01/05/2021	MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN OPPOSITION		5	Christian Nicholas Valentino
75	01/05/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Transcript of Judge Piampiano's Decision	5	Christian Nicholas Valentino
76	01/05/2021	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION		4	Christian Nicholas Valentino
77	01/05/2021	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION		3	Christian Nicholas Valentino
78	01/05/2021	MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN OPPOSITION		3	Christian Nicholas Valentino
79	01/05/2021	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO CROSS-MOTION		6	Douglas Alan Foss
80	01/05/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	email correspondence dated December 8, 2020	6	Douglas Alan Foss
81	01/05/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Surrogate's Court Order dated May 20, 2020	6	Douglas Alan Foss
82	01/05/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	email dated July 24, 2020	6	Douglas Alan Foss
83	01/05/2021	COURT NOTICE			Bianca Gauthier
84	01/22/2021	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE		3	Douglas Alan Foss
85	01/22/2021	ORDER ( PROPOSED )	Revised Proposed Confidentiality Order	3	Douglas Alan Foss
87	01/22/2021	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE		3	Christian Nicholas Valentino
88	01/22/2021	ORDER ( PROPOSED )		3	Christian Nicholas Valentino
89	01/22/2021	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE		1	Christian Nicholas Valentino
90	01/22/2021	ORDER ( PROPOSED )		1	Christian Nicholas Valentino
91	01/22/2021	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE		3	Kyle Douglas Gooch
92	01/29/2021	NOTICE OF APPEARANCE (POST RJI)			Heidi Schult Gregory
93	01/29/2021	NOTICE OF MOTION (AMENDED)		5	Douglas Alan Foss
94	01/29/2021	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT		5	Douglas Alan Foss
95	01/29/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Receipt and Release of Fiduciary and Refunding Agreement	5	Douglas Alan Foss
96	01/29/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Email dated 06.09.2017 re request for Client File Directive	5	Douglas Alan Foss
97	01/29/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Client File Directive dated 06.14.2017	5	Douglas Alan Foss
98	01/29/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Receipt and Release of Fiduciary and Refunding Agreement dated 10.25.2016	5	Douglas Alan Foss
99	01/29/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Emails dated 09.07.2017 re RHH Corp.	5	Douglas Alan Foss
100	01/29/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Email dated 09.07.2017 and attachment re Consent	5	Douglas Alan Foss
101	01/29/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Letter dated 09.13.2017 forwarding Consent	5	Douglas Alan Foss
102	01/29/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Memo to File from Burke re 09.12.2017 Meeting	5	Douglas Alan Foss
103	01/29/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Transfers of Interests in Entities (from the Estate to the Marital Trust) dated 03.31.2014	5	Douglas Alan Foss
104	01/29/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Materials from RHH Corp. Joint Annual Meeting 01.21.2015	5	Douglas Alan Foss
105	01/29/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Materials from ROHM Joint Annual Meeting 01.21.2015	5	Douglas Alan Foss
106	01/29/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Materials from RHH Mendon Properties Annual Joint Meeting 01.21.2015	5	Douglas Alan Foss
107	01/29/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	2017 Warrant and Satisfaction of Judgment	5	Douglas Alan Foss
108	01/29/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Response from Bonadio - Tax Year 2015	5	Douglas Alan Foss
109	01/29/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	2018 eFile Signature Authorizations	5	Douglas Alan Foss
110	01/29/2021	MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN SUPPORT		5	Douglas Alan Foss
111	02/01/2021	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE		5	Christian Nicholas Valentino
112	02/10/2021	NOTICE OF MOTION	to Reassign this proceeding to Hon. Christopher S. Ciaccio	7	Douglas Alan Foss
113	02/10/2021	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION	in support of Motion to Reassign	7	Douglas Alan Foss
114	02/15/2021	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION	Attorney Affidavit in Opposition to Respondent's Motion Seeking Leave to Reargue and Renew	5	Christian Nicholas Valentino
115	02/15/2021	MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN OPPOSITION	Memorandum of Law in Opposition to Respondent's Motion Seeking Leave to Reargue and Renew	5	Christian Nicholas Valentino
116	02/22/2021	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN REPLY	in Further Support of Respondent's Motion to Reargue and Renew	5	Douglas Alan Foss
117	02/22/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	2020-09-03 [012] Will of Testator (filed by Petitioner)	5	Douglas Alan Foss
118	02/22/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Email chain dated January 28, 2021 from Dan O'Brien (re Greene documents)	5	Douglas Alan Foss
119	02/22/2021	MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN REPLY	in Further Support of Respondent's Motion to Reargue and Renew	5	Douglas Alan Foss
120	03/24/2021	ORDER - OTHER		3	Martin P Mccarthy
121	04/01/2021	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE			Douglas Alan Foss
122	04/01/2021	ORDER ( PROPOSED )			Douglas Alan Foss
123	04/08/2021	LETTER/CORRESPONDENCE - TO COURT			Christian Nicholas Valentino
124	04/08/2021	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE			Kyle Douglas Gooch
125	04/09/2021	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE		5	Christian Nicholas Valentino
126	04/12/2021	DECISION + ORDER ON MOTION		5	Martin P Mccarthy
127	04/16/2021	NOTICE OF APPEAL	of Decision and Order dated April 2, 2021 and entered April 12, 2021	5	Douglas Alan Foss
128	05/27/2021	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE			Kyle Douglas Gooch
129	07/11/2022	NOTICE OF ENTRY			Kyle Douglas Gooch
130	12/30/2022	ORDER ( PROPOSED )		4	Christian Nicholas Valentino
131	01/03/2023	ORDER - OTHER	Notice of Voluntary Discontinuance & Order		Tamra M Diamond
132	01/13/2023	ORDER - AMENDED	Amended Notice of Voluntary Discontinuance & Order		Tamra M Diamond

Monroe Supreme Court

2019

E2018008058

Disposed

Negligence

Ulscht, Elizabeth

BROWN CHIARI LLP

The Hurlbut et al

LAW OFFICES OF PULLANO & FARROW PLLC

09/24/2021

Ark, Hon. John J.

▼

Case Info

Court

Monroe Supreme Court

Index Number

E2018008058

Status

Disposed

Year Filed

2019

Case Name

Ulscht, Elizabeth vs. The Hurlbut et al

Case Type

Tort-Other Negligence

Track

Standard

RJI Filed

08/15/2019

NOI Due

12/31/2020

NOI Filed

02/03/2021

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Jury At Plaintiff's Request

Justice

Ark, Hon. John J.

Next Appearance

09/24/2021

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

Ulscht, Elizabeth

Attorney / FirmBROWN CHIARI LLP

Defendant / Respondent

The Hurlbut et al

Attorneys / FirmsLAW OFFICES OF PULLANO & FARROW PLLC

Motions (1)

#	Date Filed	Filed By	Relief Sought	Submit Date	Answer	Status	Decision	Order Signed
1	08/15/2019		Discovery	08/22/2019	No	Decided: 08/22/2019 Withdrawn Before Justice: Martin, Hon. Debra A.

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints (27)

Doc #	Date Filed	Document	Description	Motion #	Filing User
1	10/08/2018	SUMMONS + COMPLAINT			Theresa M Walsh
2	11/20/2018	ANSWER			Katerina Marie Kramarchyk
3	12/12/2018	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	The Hurlbut, LLC		Brian Robert Hogan
4	12/12/2018	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Rohm Services Corporation		Brian Robert Hogan
5	12/12/2018	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Robert Hurlbut		Brian Robert Hogan
6	08/15/2019	NOTICE OF MOTION		1	Mallory Kass Smith
7	08/15/2019	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION		1	Mallory Kass Smith
8	08/15/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	Summons and Complaint	1	Mallory Kass Smith
9	08/15/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	Answer	1	Mallory Kass Smith
10	08/15/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	Letter and Demands to Plaintiff	1	Mallory Kass Smith
11	08/15/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	e-mail to Plaintiff Re: overdue discovery	1	Mallory Kass Smith
12	08/15/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	Good faith letter to Plaintiff Re: overdue discovery responses	1	Mallory Kass Smith
13	08/15/2019	MEMORANDUM OF LAW		1	Mallory Kass Smith
14	08/15/2019	RJI -RE: NOTICE OF MOTION		1	Mallory Kass Smith
15	08/15/2019	ADDENDUM - GENERAL (840A)		1	Mallory Kass Smith
16	09/05/2019	ORDER - PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE	Ph Conf scheduled for 2/10/20 at 10:00. The Court will initiate.		Jennifer Palmesano
17	02/12/2020	ORDER - MEDIATION			Jennifer Palmesano
18	10/23/2020	ORDER - OTHER			Jennifer Palmesano
19	02/03/2021	NOTE OF ISSUE:WITH JURY			Brian Robert Hogan
20	03/26/2021	ORDER - TRIAL SCHEDULING			Jennifer Palmesano
21	03/29/2021	ORDER - AMENDED	Amended Trial Order		Jennifer Palmesano
22	07/27/2021	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE			Brian Robert Hogan
23	08/06/2021	ORDER - TRIAL SCHEDULING			Maureen P Ware
24	11/15/2021	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE			Brian Robert Hogan
25	11/19/2021	STIPULATION - SETTLEMENT - ( REQUEST TO SO ORDER )			Michael Christopher Scinta
26	11/23/2021	STIPULATION - SO ORDERED			Donna M. Brongo
27	12/06/2021	STIPULATION - DISCONTINUANCE (POST RJI)			Mallory Kass Smith

Monroe Supreme Court

2019

E2019002882

Disposed

SP-Other

Hurlbut, Robert W.

LAW OFFICES OF PULLANO & FARROW PLLC

Owen, Christine

Harris Beach Murtha Cullina PLLC

Odorisi, Hon. J. Scott

▼

Case Info

Court

Monroe Supreme Court

Index Number

E2019002882

Status

Disposed

Year Filed

2019

Case Name

Hurlbut, Robert W. vs. Owen, Christine

Case Type

SP-Other

Track

Standard

RJI Filed

03/28/2019

NOI Due

03/27/2020

NOI Filed

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

Odorisi, Hon. J. Scott

Next Appearance

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

Hurlbut, Robert W.

Attorney / FirmLAW OFFICES OF PULLANO & FARROW PLLC

Defendant / Respondent

Owen, Christine

Attorneys / FirmsHarris Beach Murtha Cullina PLLC

Motions (2)

#	Date Filed	Filed By	Relief Sought	Submit Date	Answer	Status	Decision	Order Signed
2	05/22/2019		Dismiss	06/26/2019	No	Decided: 06/26/2019 Closed Before Justice: Odorisi, Hon. J. Scott		06/26/2019
1	03/28/2019		Other	06/26/2019	No	Decided: 06/26/2019 Closed Before Justice: Odorisi, Hon. J. Scott		06/26/2019

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints (36)

Doc #	Date Filed	Document	Description	Motion #	Filing User
1	03/28/2019	PETITION	Verified Petition		Christina Marie Deats
2	03/28/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	Will		Christina Marie Deats
3	03/28/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	Power of Attorney Forms		Christina Marie Deats
4	03/28/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	Marital Trust Memorandum		Christina Marie Deats
5	03/28/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	Demand Letter		Christina Marie Deats
6	03/28/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	Demand Letter Response		Christina Marie Deats
7	03/28/2019	NOTICE OF PETITION ACCOMPANYING COMMENCEMENT DOC(S)		1	Christina Marie Deats
8	03/28/2019	RJI -RE: NOTICE OF PETITION			Christina Marie Deats
9	04/08/2019	COURT NOTICE		1	Maureen P Ware
10	05/22/2019	NOTICE OF CROSS-PETITION		2	Douglas Alan Foss
11	05/22/2019	ANSWER IN SPECIAL PROCEEDING	Verified Answer and Cross-Petition	2	Douglas Alan Foss
12	05/22/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	Article V of Will	2	Douglas Alan Foss
13	05/22/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	Promissory Note	2	Douglas Alan Foss
14	05/22/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	Power of Attorney dated February 22, 2017 (with revocation)	2	Douglas Alan Foss
15	05/22/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	May 9, 2018 Letter from Phil Burke RE theft from home	2	Douglas Alan Foss
16	05/22/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	May 15, 2018 Burke letter to Peter Abdella Esq. HSEmery re personal property remova	2	Douglas Alan Foss
17	05/22/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	Transcription of VMM	2	Douglas Alan Foss
18	05/22/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	(REDACTED) Order of Protection	2	Douglas Alan Foss
19	05/22/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	March 1, 2019 letter from Phil Burke RE Robert's failure to follow directions	2	Douglas Alan Foss
20	05/22/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	Burke and Hurlbut letters	2	Douglas Alan Foss
21	05/22/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	Marital Trust Statement for 2018	2	Douglas Alan Foss
22	05/22/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	May 16, 2019 email from Harris Beach to Respondent (RE impending filing)	2	Douglas Alan Foss
23	05/22/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	(REDACTED) USA Payroll - 4th Quarter 2018 Tax Returns	2	Douglas Alan Foss
24	05/22/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	(REDACTED) Denise LaPlante submissions	2	Douglas Alan Foss
25	05/22/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	(REDACTED) Selected Licensure Documentation	2	Douglas Alan Foss
26	05/31/2019	COURT NOTICE			Leslie E Swift
27	06/05/2019	ANSWER IN SPECIAL PROCEEDING	Verified Reply to Verified Cross-Petition	2	Christina Marie Deats
28	06/05/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	Order Appointing Guardian Ad Litem	2	Christina Marie Deats
29	06/12/2019	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN REPLY	Respondent's Reply to Petitioner's Reply to Cross-Petition	2	Douglas Alan Foss
30	06/12/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	2019-05-03 Petition for Permission to Resign as Trustees	2	Douglas Alan Foss
31	06/12/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	2019-05-30 P. Burke Letter to Surrogate	2	Douglas Alan Foss
32	06/12/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	2019-06-06 Email from Principal Court Attorney	2	Douglas Alan Foss
33	06/12/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	Transcription of Voicemail Messages	2	Douglas Alan Foss
34	06/12/2019	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN REPLY	Affidavit of Lisa Reichart	2	Douglas Alan Foss
35	06/27/2019	ORDER - TRANSFER	transferred to Monroe County Surrogate's Court		Maureen P Ware
36	06/27/2019	COURT NOTICE			Leslie E Swift

Monroe Supreme Court

2019

E2019003795

Disposed

Negligence

TRINIDAD, MAGALY

BROWN CHIARI LLP

FORT TRYON CENTER FOR REHABILITATION AND NURSING et al

FORT TRYON CENTER FOR REHABILITATION AND NURSING

04/23/2025

Waldorf, Hon. Joseph D.

▼

Case Info

Court

Monroe Supreme Court

Index Number

E2019003795

Status

Disposed

Year Filed

2019

Case Name

TRINIDAD, MAGALY vs. FORT TRYON CENTER FOR REHABILITATION AND NURSING et al

Case Type

Tort-Other Negligence

Track

Standard

RJI Filed

10/08/2019

NOI Due

10/07/2020

NOI Filed

03/27/2024

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Jury At Plaintiff's Request

Justice

Waldorf, Hon. Joseph D.

Next Appearance

04/23/2025

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

TRINIDAD, MAGALY

Attorney / FirmBROWN CHIARI LLP

Defendant / Respondent

FORT TRYON CENTER FOR REHABILITATION AND NURSING et al

Attorneys / FirmsFORT TRYON CENTER FOR REHABILITATION AND NURSING

Motions (1)

#	Date Filed	Filed By	Relief Sought	Submit Date	Answer	Status	Decision	Order Signed
1	03/28/2025		Approve Settlement	04/23/2025	No	Decided: 04/23/2025 Granted Before Justice: Waldorf, Hon. Joseph D.	Oral	04/24/2025

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints (34)

Doc #	Date Filed	Document	Description	Filing User
1	04/24/2019	SUMMONS + COMPLAINT		Theresa M Walsh
2	05/18/2019	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Fort Tryon LLC	Theresa M Walsh
3	05/18/2019	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Rohm Services	Theresa M Walsh
4	05/18/2019	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	The Brightonian Inc	Theresa M Walsh
5	05/29/2019	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Fort Tryon Center for Rehabilitation	Theresa M Walsh
6	05/29/2019	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Hurlbut Care Communities	Theresa M Walsh
7	05/29/2019	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	R. Hurlbut	Theresa M Walsh
8	05/29/2019	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Highland Hospital	Theresa M Walsh
9	05/29/2019	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	University of Rochester Medical Center	Theresa M Walsh
10	06/04/2019	ANSWER WITH CROSS-CLAIM(S)		Christian Carlo Casini
11	06/04/2019	DEMAND FOR BILL OF PARTICULARS		Christian Carlo Casini
12	06/04/2019	DEMAND FOR:	Article 31 Discovery Demands	Christian Carlo Casini
13	06/04/2019	DEMAND FOR:	Demand for Medicaid.Medicare Lien Info	Christian Carlo Casini
14	06/04/2019	NOTICE OF DEPOSITION UPON ORAL EXAMINATION		Christian Carlo Casini
15	06/04/2019	ACKNOWLEDGEMENT OF SERVICE		Christian Carlo Casini
16	06/05/2019	ANSWER	Verified Answer	Langston David Mcfadden
17	06/21/2019	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE		Langston David Mcfadden
18	10/08/2019	RJI -RE: REQUEST FOR PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE		Mallory Kass Smith
19	10/18/2019	COURT NOTICE		Patricia A Whitcroft
20	11/26/2019	COURT NOTICE		Patricia A Whitcroft
21	12/09/2019	ANSWER	Verified Answer	Caitlin Anne Robin
22	01/10/2020	COURT NOTICE		Patricia A Whitcroft
23	10/20/2022	STIPULATION - AMENDING PLEADING(S)		Mallory Kass Smith
24	10/20/2022	ANSWER WITH CROSS-CLAIM(S)	Amended Answer with Crossclaim	Mallory Kass Smith
25	03/14/2024	ORDER - CASE SCHEDULING		Emma Laws
26	03/27/2024	NOTE OF ISSUE:WITH JURY		Theresa M Walsh
27	04/12/2024	ORDER - MEDIATION		Emma Laws
28	08/02/2024	ORDER - TRIAL SCHEDULING		Emma Laws
29	08/21/2024	STIPULATION - OTHER - ( REQUEST TO SO ORDER )		Aimee La Fever Koch
30	08/23/2024	STIPULATION OF PARTIAL DISCONTINUANCE - SO ORDERED		Joseph D. Waldorf
31	12/16/2024	TRIAL DOCUMENTS	Defendants' CPLR 3101 Disclosure	Di Ying
32	12/16/2024	TRIAL DOCUMENTS	Defendants' Demand for Trial AZ	Di Ying
33	12/17/2024	TRIAL DOCUMENTS	Expert Witness Disclosure	Langston David Mcfadden
56	06/13/2025	STIPULATION - DISCONTINUANCE (POST RJI)		Langston David Mcfadden

Monroe Supreme Court

2019

E2019004702

Disposed-Consolidated Into

RP-Tax Certiorari

Shore Winds Properties LLC and Robert H. Hurlbut

KAVINOKY COOK LLP

City of Rochester et al

11/06/2023

Doyle, Hon. Daniel J.

▼

Case Info

Court

Monroe Supreme Court

Index Number

E2019004702

Status

Disposed-Consolidated Into

Year Filed

2019

Case Name

Shore Winds Properties LLC and Robert H. Hurlbut vs. City of Rochester et al

Case Type

RP-Tax Certiorari

Track

Complex

RJI Filed

05/21/2019

NOI Due

05/21/2023

NOI Filed

05/17/2023

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

Doyle, Hon. Daniel J.

Next Appearance

11/06/2023

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

Shore Winds Properties LLC and Robert H. Hurlbut

Attorney / FirmKAVINOKY COOK LLP

Defendant / Respondent

City of Rochester et al

Attorneys / Firms

Motions (1)

#	Date Filed	Filed By	Relief Sought	Submit Date	Answer	Status	Decision	Order Signed
1	05/21/2019	PETITIONER	Tax Assessment Review	12/27/2019	No	Decided: 12/27/2019 Marked Off Before Justice: Odorisi, Hon. J. Scott

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints (41)

Doc #	Date Filed	Document	Description	Motion #	Filing User
1	05/21/2019	PETITION			Scott Christopher Becker
2	05/21/2019	NOTICE OF PETITION ACCOMPANYING COMMENCEMENT DOC(S)		1	Scott Christopher Becker
3	05/21/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	Side Number 1		Scott Christopher Becker
4	05/21/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit A to Side Number 1		Scott Christopher Becker
5	05/21/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	Side Number 2		Scott Christopher Becker
6	05/21/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit A to Side Number 2		Scott Christopher Becker
7	05/21/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	Side Number 3		Scott Christopher Becker
8	05/21/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit A to Side Number 3		Scott Christopher Becker
9	05/21/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	Side Number 4		Scott Christopher Becker
10	05/21/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit A to Side Number 4		Scott Christopher Becker
11	05/21/2019	AFFIRMATION	Commercial Division Addendum to RJI		Scott Christopher Becker
12	05/21/2019	RJI -RE: NOTICE OF PETITION	Commercial Division Addendum filed as Affirmation		Scott Christopher Becker
13	05/21/2019	ADDENDUM - GENERAL (840A)			Scott Christopher Becker
14	06/06/2019	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Affidavit Proof of Service on a Corporation	1	Scott Christopher Becker
15	06/06/2019	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service by Mail	1	Scott Christopher Becker
16	07/17/2020	ORDER ( PROPOSED )	Proposed Scheduling Order		Scott Christopher Becker
17	07/17/2020	ORDER - OTHER	SCHEDULING ORDER		Kathleen M Saltrelli
18	07/30/2020	NOTICE OF APPEARANCE (POST RJI)			John M. Campolieto
19	07/30/2020	STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING			John M. Campolieto
20	10/07/2020	COURT NOTICE			Lisa Cohan
21	11/06/2020	ORDER ( PROPOSED )	Amended Scheduling Order		Scott Christopher Becker
22	11/11/2020	ORDER - OTHER	AMENDED SCHEDULING ORDER		Kathleen M Saltrelli
23	06/18/2021	ORDER ( PROPOSED )	Amended Scheduling Order		Scott Christopher Becker
24	06/22/2021	COURT NOTICE			Kathleen M Saltrelli
25	10/12/2021	ORDER - AMENDED	AMENDED SCHEDULING ORDER		Kathleen M Saltrelli
26	12/15/2021	ORDER ( PROPOSED )	Amended Scheduling Order		Scott Christopher Becker
27	12/22/2021	ORDER - AMENDED	Scheduling Order		Kathleen M Saltrelli
28	01/06/2022	NOTICE OF ENTRY	Notice of Entry		Scott Christopher Becker
29	04/28/2022	ORDER ( PROPOSED )	Amended Scheduling Order		Scott Christopher Becker
30	05/03/2022	ORDER - CASE SCHEDULING			Maureen P Ware
31	07/27/2022	ORDER ( PROPOSED )	Amended Scheduling Order		Scott Christopher Becker
32	07/28/2022	ORDER - CASE SCHEDULING			Maureen P Ware
33	08/05/2022	NOTICE OF ENTRY	Notice of Entry		Scott Christopher Becker
34	05/09/2023	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE	Letter to Judge Odorisi / appraisal exchange date		Scott Christopher Becker
35	05/16/2023	ORDER - CASE SCHEDULING			Maureen P Ware
36	05/16/2023	NOTICE OF ENTRY	Notice of Entry		Scott Christopher Becker
37	05/16/2023	STATEMENT OF INCOME AND EXPENSES	Statement Pursuant to 22 N.Y.C.R.R. 2020.59(b)		Scott Christopher Becker
38	05/17/2023	NOTE OF ISSUE:WITHOUT JURY	Note of Issue		Scott Christopher Becker
39	07/25/2023	COURT NOTICE			Michael Habich
40	03/08/2024	ORDER ( PROPOSED )	Scheduling Order		Scott Christopher Becker
41	03/12/2024	ORDER - CONSOLIDATION	CASE SCHEDULING		Sue Lerkins

Monroe Supreme Court

2019

E2019006304

Disposed

Negligence

ROTHDIENER, GEORGIA BETH

LACY KATZEN LLP

THE HURLBUT, LLC

LAW OFFICES OF PULLANO & FARROW PLLC

07/21/2020

Donofrio, Hon. Gail A.

▼

Case Info

Court

Monroe Supreme Court

Index Number

E2019006304

Status

Disposed

Year Filed

2019

Case Name

ROTHDIENER, GEORGIA BETH vs. THE HURLBUT, LLC

Case Type

Tort-Other Negligence

Track

Standard

RJI Filed

10/29/2019

NOI Due

07/01/2020

NOI Filed

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

Donofrio, Hon. Gail A.

Next Appearance

07/21/2020

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

ROTHDIENER, GEORGIA BETH

Attorney / FirmLACY KATZEN LLP

Defendant / Respondent

THE HURLBUT, LLC

Attorneys / FirmsLAW OFFICES OF PULLANO & FARROW PLLC

Motions (1)

#	Date Filed	Filed By	Relief Sought	Submit Date	Answer	Status	Decision	Order Signed
1	06/30/2020	PLAINTIFF	Approve Settlement	07/17/2020	No	Decided: 07/17/2020 Granted Before Justice: Donofrio, Hon. Gail A.	Short Form Order	07/17/2020

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints (31)

Doc #	Date Filed	Document	Description	Motion #	Filing User
1	07/10/2019	SUMMONS			John Mark Wells
2	07/10/2019	COMPLAINT			John Mark Wells
3	07/10/2019	EXHIBIT(S)	Decree Granting Administration w/Limitations and Letters of Administration w/Limitations		John Mark Wells
4	07/10/2019	CERTIFICATE OF MERIT			John Mark Wells
5	07/30/2019	CERTIFICATE OF MERIT			John Mark Wells
6	08/19/2019	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE			John Mark Wells
7	09/05/2019	ANSWER			Mallory Kass Smith
8	10/29/2019	NOTICE OF MEDICAL MALPRACTICE			John Mark Wells
9	10/29/2019	RJI -RE: NOTICE OF MEDICAL, DENTAL OR PODIATRIC MALPRACTICE			John Mark Wells
10	10/30/2019	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Notice to Medicaid Pursuant to CPLR 306-c		John Mark Wells
11	12/04/2019	COURT NOTICE			Maureen P Ware
12	12/11/2019	ORDER - CASE SCHEDULING			Maureen P Ware
13	02/24/2020	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE			John Mark Wells
14	03/06/2020	LETTER/CORRESPONDENCE FROM COURT			Rochelle Coley
17	06/30/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Optum Correspondence	1	John Mark Wells
20	06/30/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Letters of Administration	1	John Mark Wells
21	06/30/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Retainer Agreement	1	John Mark Wells
25	07/13/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	7/7/2020 final lien amount letter	1	John Mark Wells
28	08/24/2020	ORDER ( PROPOSED )	Stipulated Order		Mallory Kass Smith
29	08/27/2020	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE			John Mark Wells
30	08/31/2020	ORDER - OTHER	STIPULATED ORDER		Kathleen M Saltrelli
31	09/03/2020	NOTICE OF MOTION (AMENDED)	Notice of Motion - redacted	1	John Mark Wells
32	09/03/2020	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT	Attorney Affirmation - redacted	1	John Mark Wells
33	09/03/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Medicaid Lien	1	John Mark Wells
34	09/03/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	6/19/2020 Letter to County re: lien redacted	1	John Mark Wells
35	09/03/2020	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT	Affidavit in Support - redacted	1	John Mark Wells
36	09/03/2020	ORDER ( PROPOSED )	Proposed Order - redacted	1	John Mark Wells
37	09/03/2020	ORDER ( PROPOSED )	Proposed Order - redacted	1	John Mark Wells
38	09/03/2020	ORDER ( PROPOSED )	Copy of signed Final Order dated 7/17/2020 - redacted	1	John Mark Wells
39	09/04/2020	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION	Supplmental Attorney Affirmation - redacted	1	John Mark Wells
40	09/10/2020	STIPULATION - DISCONTINUANCE (POST RJI)			Mallory Kass Smith

Monroe Supreme Court

2019

I2018006329

Disposed

Negligence

Joseph, Mary

The Hurlbut Nursing Home

FELDMAN KIEFFER LLP

10/12/2022

Donofrio, Hon. Gail A.

▼

Case Info

Court

Monroe Supreme Court

Index Number

I2018006329

Status

Disposed

Year Filed

2019

Case Name

Joseph, Mary vs. The Hurlbut Nursing Home

Case Type

Tort-Other Negligence

Track

Standard

RJI Filed

02/22/2019

NOI Due

02/22/2020

NOI Filed

03/29/2022

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Jury Trial

Justice

Donofrio, Hon. Gail A.

Next Appearance

10/12/2022

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

Joseph, Mary

Attorney / Firm

Defendant / Respondent

The Hurlbut Nursing Home

Attorneys / FirmsFELDMAN KIEFFER LLP

Motions (7)

#	Date Filed	Relief Sought	Submit Date	Answer	Status	Decision	Order Signed
5	07/21/2022	Judgment - Summary	10/12/2022	No	Decided: 10/12/2022 Closed Before Justice: Donofrio, Hon. Gail A.
5	07/21/2022	Judgment - Summary	10/12/2022	No	Decided: 10/12/2022 Granted Before Justice: Donofrio, Hon. Gail A.	Short Form Order	10/13/2022
4	06/10/2021	Dismiss	08/02/2021	No	Decided: 08/02/2021 Granted Before Justice: Donofrio, Hon. Gail A.
4	06/10/2021	Dismiss	08/02/2021	No	Decided: 08/02/2021 Denied Before Justice: Donofrio, Hon. Gail A.		09/14/2021
3	12/02/2020	Preclude	02/24/2021	No	Decided: 02/24/2021 Granted Before Justice: Donofrio, Hon. Gail A.	Oral	03/25/2021
2	11/04/2019	Discovery	11/19/2019	No	Decided: 11/19/2019 Granted Before Justice: Odorisi, Hon. J. Scott	Short Form Order	11/19/2019
1	03/19/2019	Dismiss	05/28/2019	No	Decided: 05/28/2019 Denied Before Justice: Odorisi, Hon. J. Scott	Short Form Order	05/28/2019

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints (60)

Doc #	Date Filed	Document	Description	Motion #	Filing User
1	12/10/2018	COUNTY CLERK MINUTES -PRIOR TO CONVERSION			Ariana C Rivera Cuevas
2	11/20/2020	CONSENT TO EFILING			Ariana C Rivera Cuevas
3	11/25/2020	AFFIDAVIT			Ccuser Monroecc
4	12/02/2020	NOTICE OF MOTION		3	Stephen Matthew Sorrels
5	12/02/2020	AFFIRMATION		3	Stephen Matthew Sorrels
6	12/02/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Notice of Motion	3	Stephen Matthew Sorrels
7	12/02/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Transcript	3	Stephen Matthew Sorrels
8	12/02/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	12-19-19 Letter & Order	3	Stephen Matthew Sorrels
9	12/02/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Letter to court	3	Stephen Matthew Sorrels
10	12/02/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	122019 Letter to Court	3	Stephen Matthew Sorrels
11	12/02/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Medical Records	3	Stephen Matthew Sorrels
12	12/02/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	012420 Correspondence	3	Stephen Matthew Sorrels
13	12/02/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Grievance Letter	3	Stephen Matthew Sorrels
14	12/02/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	1-24-20 Correspondence	3	Stephen Matthew Sorrels
15	12/02/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	Attorney Grievance Letter 036020	3	Stephen Matthew Sorrels
16	12/02/2020	EXHIBIT(S)	NOE with Order	3	Stephen Matthew Sorrels
17	12/02/2020	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE		3	Stephen Matthew Sorrels
18	12/11/2020	COURT NOTICE			Kathleen M Saltrelli
19	03/25/2021	ORDER ( PROPOSED )			Stephen Matthew Sorrels
20	03/25/2021	ORDER - OTHER			Kathleen M Saltrelli
21	03/30/2021	NOTICE OF ENTRY			Stephen Matthew Sorrels
22	03/30/2021	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE			Stephen Matthew Sorrels
23	06/10/2021	NOTICE OF MOTION		4	Stephen Matthew Sorrels
24	06/10/2021	AFFIRMATION		4	Stephen Matthew Sorrels
25	06/10/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Affirmation 10-31-19	4	Stephen Matthew Sorrels
26	06/10/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Affirmation -12-2-2020	4	Stephen Matthew Sorrels
27	06/10/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Feb 24 2021 Motion Transcript	4	Stephen Matthew Sorrels
28	06/10/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	March 25, 2021 Order	4	Stephen Matthew Sorrels
29	06/10/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Notice of Entry 03-30-21	4	Stephen Matthew Sorrels
30	06/10/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Affidavit of Service	4	Stephen Matthew Sorrels
31	06/10/2021	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE		4	Stephen Matthew Sorrels
32	06/11/2021	COURT NOTICE			Kathleen M Saltrelli
33	06/22/2021	LETTER/CORRESPONDENCE - TO COURT			Stephen Matthew Sorrels
34	08/31/2021	ORDER - (PROPOSED) "SUBMIT ORDER" PER JUDGES DECISION		4	Stephen Matthew Sorrels
35	08/31/2021	EXHIBIT(S)	Transcript of Decision	4	Stephen Matthew Sorrels
36	09/14/2021	DECISION + ORDER ON MOTION		4	Kathleen M Saltrelli
37	09/15/2021	NOTICE OF ENTRY		4	Jonathan Jeffery Schutrum
38	09/15/2021	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE		4	Jonathan Jeffery Schutrum
39	09/15/2021	LETTER/CORRESPONDENCE - TO COURT		4	Jonathan Jeffery Schutrum
40	09/15/2021	DECISION + ORDER ON MOTION		4	Kathleen M Saltrelli
41	03/24/2022	NOTE OF ISSUE:WITH JURY			Ccuser Monroecc
42	07/21/2022	NOTICE OF MOTION		5	Adam Christopher Ferrandino
43	07/21/2022	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION		5	Adam Christopher Ferrandino
44	07/21/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Affidavit	5	Adam Christopher Ferrandino
45	07/21/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Summons and Complaint	5	Adam Christopher Ferrandino
46	07/21/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Answer	5	Adam Christopher Ferrandino
47	07/21/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Discovery Demands	5	Adam Christopher Ferrandino
48	07/21/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Order	5	Adam Christopher Ferrandino
49	07/21/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Notice of Entry	5	Adam Christopher Ferrandino
50	07/21/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Affidavit of Service	5	Adam Christopher Ferrandino
51	07/21/2022	STATEMENT OF MATERIAL FACTS		5	Adam Christopher Ferrandino
52	07/21/2022	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE		5	Adam Christopher Ferrandino
53	07/22/2022	LETTER/CORRESPONDENCE - TO COURT	Copy of Letter to Plaintiff advising of return date of Motion with enclosure and Affidavit of Service	5	Adam Christopher Ferrandino
54	07/28/2022	COURT NOTICE			Kathleen M Saltrelli
55	07/28/2022	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE	Letter to Plaintiff w/Court Notice and Affidavit of Service	5	Adam Christopher Ferrandino
56	09/28/2022	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN REPLY		5	Adam Christopher Ferrandino
57	09/28/2022	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE		5	Adam Christopher Ferrandino
58	10/13/2022	DECISION + ORDER ON MOTION		5	Kathleen M Saltrelli
59	10/14/2022	NOTICE OF ENTRY		5	Adam Christopher Ferrandino
60	10/14/2022	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE		5	Adam Christopher Ferrandino

Monroe Supreme Court

2018

2017/03042 (0003042/2017)

Disposed

Comm-Other

THE HURLBUT LLC

PULLANO & FARROW, LAW OFFICE

MARY MCARTHY

06/07/2018

Martin, Hon. Debra A.

▼

Case Info

Court

Monroe Supreme Court

Index Number

2017/03042 (0003042/2017)

Status

Disposed

Year Filed

2018

Case Name

THE HURLBUT LLC vs. MARY MCARTHY

Case Type

Comm-Other

Track

Standard

RJI Filed

04/12/2018

NOI Due

04/12/2019

NOI Filed

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

Martin, Hon. Debra A.

Next Appearance

06/07/2018

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

THE HURLBUT LLC

Attorney / FirmPULLANO & FARROW, LAW OFFICE

Defendant / Respondent

MARY MCARTHY

Attorneys / Firms

Motions (1)

#	Date Filed	Filed By	Relief Sought	Submit Date	Answer	Status	Decision	Order Signed
1	04/02/2018		Other	05/23/2018	No	Decided: 05/23/2018 Decided Before Justice: Martin, Hon. Debra A.		05/23/2018

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints

No eFiled documents available for this case.

Monroe Supreme Court

2018

2017/08149 (0008149/2017)

Disposed

OM-Other

CITIBANK NA

Forster & Garbus1

ROBERT D HURLBUT

ROBERT HURLBUT PRO SE

02/26/2019

Taddeo, Hon. Ann Marie

▼

Case Info

Court

Monroe Supreme Court

Index Number

2017/08149 (0008149/2017)

Status

Disposed

Year Filed

2018

Case Name

CITIBANK NA vs. ROBERT D HURLBUT

Case Type

OM-Other

Track

Standard

RJI Filed

03/05/2018

NOI Due

03/05/2019

NOI Filed

08/30/2018

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

Taddeo, Hon. Ann Marie

Next Appearance

02/26/2019

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

CITIBANK NA

Attorney / FirmForster & Garbus1

Defendant / Respondent

ROBERT D HURLBUT

Attorneys / FirmsROBERT HURLBUT PRO SE

Motions

No motions recorded for this case.

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints

No eFiled documents available for this case.

Monroe Supreme Court

2018

E2017000549 (3000549/2017)

Disposed

Medical Malpractice

JOSE MARTIN CASTILLO AS ADMINISTRATOR OF THE

Gomez & Becker, LLP

THE UNITY HOSPITAL OF ROCHESTER, ROCHEST

Osborn, Reed & Burke, LLP

11/10/2022

Doran, Hon. Craig J.

▼

Case Info

Court

Monroe Supreme Court

Index Number

E2017000549 (3000549/2017)

Status

Disposed

Year Filed

2018

Case Name

JOSE MARTIN CASTILLO AS ADMINISTRATOR OF THE vs. THE UNITY HOSPITAL OF ROCHESTER, ROCHEST

Case Type

Tort-Medical, Dental, or Podiatric Malpractice

Track

Complex

RJI Filed

01/25/2018

NOI Due

01/05/2022

NOI Filed

01/14/2022

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Jury At Plaintiff's Request

Justice

Doran, Hon. Craig J.

Next Appearance

11/10/2022

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

JOSE MARTIN CASTILLO AS ADMINISTRATOR OF THE

Attorney / FirmGomez & Becker, LLP

Defendant / Respondent

THE UNITY HOSPITAL OF ROCHESTER, ROCHEST

Attorneys / FirmsOsborn, Reed & Burke, LLP

Motions

No motions recorded for this case.

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints (33)

Doc #	Date Filed	Document	Description	Filing User
1	04/22/2017	SUMMONS + COMPLAINT		Rafael Omar Gomez
2	04/22/2017	CERTIFICATE OF MERIT		Rafael Omar Gomez
3	05/10/2017	ANSWER WITH CROSS-CLAIM(S)	Answer	Christian Carlo Casini
4	05/10/2017	DEMAND FOR:	CPLR Art. 31 Discl. Demands	Christian Carlo Casini
5	05/10/2017	DEMAND FOR BILL OF PARTICULARS	Dem. for Verf. Bill of Particulars	Christian Carlo Casini
6	05/10/2017	DEMAND FOR:	Dem. for Medicaid.Medicare Lien Info.	Christian Carlo Casini
7	05/10/2017	NOTICE OF DEPOSITION UPON ORAL EXAMINATION	EBT Notice	Christian Carlo Casini
8	05/10/2017	ACKNOWLEDGEMENT OF SERVICE	Acknowledgment of Service	Christian Carlo Casini
9	07/10/2017	ANSWER WITH CROSS-CLAIM(S)		Candace Marie Curran
10	07/10/2017	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE		Candace Marie Curran
11	01/25/2018	NOTICE OF MEDICAL MALPRACTICE		Rafael Omar Gomez
12	01/25/2018	RJI -RE: NOTICE OF MEDICAL, DENTAL OR PODIATRIC MALPRACTICE		Rafael Omar Gomez
13	03/29/2018	ORDER - CASE SCHEDULING		Rebecca Klymn
14	01/18/2020	COURT NOTICE		Tammy M Buck
15	01/22/2020	ORDER - CASE SCHEDULING		Tammy M Buck
16	01/24/2020	NOTICE OF APPEARANCE (POST RJI)		Maura C. Mcguire
17	02/21/2020	ORDER - CASE SCHEDULING		Tammy M Buck
18	06/02/2020	NOTICE TO COUNTY CLERK - AMENDMENT OF CAPTION	Notice to Amend Caption on Stipulation	Rafael Omar Gomez
19	08/05/2020	ORDER - CASE SCHEDULING		Tammy M Buck
20	01/19/2021	ORDER - CASE SCHEDULING		Tammy M Buck
21	01/29/2021	SUBSTITUTION OF ATTORNEY (POST RJI)		Rafael Omar Gomez
22	07/22/2021	ORDER - CASE SCHEDULING		Tammy M Buck
23	09/22/2021	LETTER/CORRESPONDENCE - TO COURT		Rafael Omar Gomez
24	10/26/2021	ORDER - CASE SCHEDULING	5th Amended Scheduling Order	Nicole Botti
25	01/07/2022	COURT NOTICE		Nicole Botti
26	01/14/2022	NOTE OF ISSUE:WITH JURY		Rafael Omar Gomez
27	01/14/2022	COURT NOTICE		Jeanna J. Savage
28	03/04/2022	COURT NOTICE		Nicole Botti
29	04/19/2022	COURT NOTICE		Jeanna J. Savage
30	07/01/2022	ORDER ( PROPOSED )		Michael Christopher Pretsch
31	07/06/2022	ORDER - MEDIATION		Jeanna J. Savage
32	07/25/2022	ORDER - TRIAL SCHEDULING		Nicole Botti
33	01/30/2023	STIPULATION - SO ORDERED		Lea T Nacca

Monroe Supreme Court

2018

E2017003306 (3003306/2017)

Disposed

Tort

PEARCE, KENNETH G

BROWN CHIARI LLP

PENFIELD PLACE NURSING & REHABILITATION

Pullano & Farrow

07/02/2019

Taddeo, Hon. Ann Marie

▼

Case Info

Court

Monroe Supreme Court

Index Number

E2017003306 (3003306/2017)

Status

Disposed

Year Filed

2018

Case Name

PEARCE, KENNETH G vs. PENFIELD PLACE NURSING & REHABILITATION

Case Type

Tort-Other

Track

Standard

RJI Filed

05/01/2018

NOI Due

05/01/2019

NOI Filed

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

Taddeo, Hon. Ann Marie

Next Appearance

07/02/2019

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

PEARCE, KENNETH G

Attorney / FirmBROWN CHIARI LLP

Defendant / Respondent

PENFIELD PLACE NURSING & REHABILITATION

Attorneys / FirmsPullano & Farrow

Motions

No motions recorded for this case.

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints (18)

Doc #	Date Filed	Document	Description	Filing User
1	12/19/2017	SUMMONS + COMPLAINT		Theresa M Walsh
2	01/10/2018	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Christine Hurlbut	David William Olson
3	01/10/2018	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Hurlbut Care Communities	David William Olson
4	01/10/2018	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Penfield Place, LLC	David William Olson
5	01/10/2018	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Robert W. Hurlbut	David William Olson
6	01/10/2018	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	ROHM Services Corporation	David William Olson
7	01/10/2018	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Penfield Place Nursing & Rehabilitation	David William Olson
8	02/09/2018	ANSWER		Katerina Marie Kramarchyk
9	05/01/2018	RJI -RE: REQUEST FOR PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE		David William Olson
10	05/01/2018	ADDENDUM - GENERAL (840A)		David William Olson
11	05/09/2018	COURT NOTICE		Patricia A Whitcroft
12	10/03/2018	COURT NOTICE		Patricia A Whitcroft
13	03/08/2019	STIPULATION - DISCONTINUANCE (POST RJI)	Stipulation of Discontinuance against Christine Owen	Michael Paul Scott-Kristansen
14	03/26/2019	ORDER - MEDIATION		Patricia A Whitcroft
15	03/27/2019	LETTER/CORRESPONDENCE FROM COURT		Rochelle Coley
16	04/05/2019	LETTER/CORRESPONDENCE FROM COURT		Rochelle Coley
17	05/09/2019	LETTER/CORRESPONDENCE FROM COURT		Rochelle Coley
18	09/10/2020	STIPULATION - DISCONTINUANCE (POST RJI)		Langston David Mcfadden

Monroe Supreme Court

2018

E2018002574 (3002574/2018)

Disposed

Medical Malpractice

BARBARA A LADIEU AS EXECUTRIX OF THE EST

MEGGESTO, CROSSETT & VALERINO LLP

THE HURLBUT LLC AKA THE HURLBUT NURSING

LAW OFFICES OF PULLANO & FARROW PLLC

09/18/2019

Rosenbaum, Hon. Matthew A.

▼

Case Info

Court

Monroe Supreme Court

Index Number

E2018002574 (3002574/2018)

Status

Disposed

Year Filed

2018

Case Name

BARBARA A LADIEU AS EXECUTRIX OF THE EST vs. THE HURLBUT LLC AKA THE HURLBUT NURSING

Case Type

Tort-Medical, Dental, or Podiatric Malpractice

Track

Complex

RJI Filed

06/18/2018

NOI Due

06/03/2019

NOI Filed

05/31/2019

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Jury At Plaintiff's Request

Justice

Rosenbaum, Hon. Matthew A.

Next Appearance

09/18/2019

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

BARBARA A LADIEU AS EXECUTRIX OF THE EST

Attorney / FirmMEGGESTO, CROSSETT & VALERINO LLP

Defendant / Respondent

THE HURLBUT LLC AKA THE HURLBUT NURSING

Attorneys / FirmsLAW OFFICES OF PULLANO & FARROW PLLC

Motions

No motions recorded for this case.

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints (22)

Doc #	Date Filed	Document	Description	Filing User
1	04/16/2018	SUMMONS + COMPLAINT		James Anthony Meggesto
2	05/01/2018	ACKNOWLEDGEMENT OF SERVICE		James Anthony Meggesto
3	05/16/2018	ANSWER	Verified Answer	Michael Paul Scott-Kristansen
4	06/18/2018	RJI -RE: NOTICE OF MEDICAL, DENTAL OR PODIATRIC MALPRACTICE		James Anthony Meggesto
5	06/22/2018	NOTICE OF MEDICAL MALPRACTICE		James Anthony Meggesto
6	07/24/2018	ORDER - CASE SCHEDULING		Rebecca Klymn
7	09/18/2018	ORDER ( PROPOSED )		James Anthony Meggesto
8	09/24/2018	ORDER ( PROPOSED )	Scheduling Order	James Anthony Meggesto
9	09/25/2018	ORDER - CASE SCHEDULING		Rebecca Klymn
10	01/04/2019	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE		James Anthony Meggesto
11	01/04/2019	ORDER ( PROPOSED )		James Anthony Meggesto
12	01/07/2019	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE		Michael Paul Scott-Kristansen
13	01/17/2019	ORDER - CASE SCHEDULING		Rebecca Klymn
14	03/25/2019	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE		James Anthony Meggesto
15	03/25/2019	ORDER ( PROPOSED )		James Anthony Meggesto
16	04/16/2019	ORDER - CASE SCHEDULING		Rebecca Klymn
17	05/16/2019	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service of Nicole Depuyt	James Anthony Meggesto
18	05/20/2019	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service of Denise Caluorie	James Anthony Meggesto
19	05/20/2019	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service of Cole Sanders	James Anthony Meggesto
20	05/31/2019	NOTE OF ISSUE:WITH JURY		James Anthony Meggesto
21	12/30/2019	STIPULATION - DISCONTINUANCE (POST RJI)		Langston David Mcfadden
22	01/18/2020	COURT NOTICE		Tammy M Buck

Monroe Supreme Court

2018

E2018003289 (3003289/2018)

Disposed-Consolidated Into

RP-Tax Certiorari

TAX ASSESSMENT BY SHORE WINDS PROPERTIES LLC AND ROBERT H HURLBUT

KAVINOKYCOOK LLP

ASSESSMENT REVIEW FOR THE CITY OF ROCHESTER,

The Assessor of the City of Rochester

11/06/2023

Doyle, Hon. Daniel J.

▼

Case Info

Court

Monroe Supreme Court

Index Number

E2018003289 (3003289/2018)

Status

Disposed-Consolidated Into

Year Filed

2018

Case Name

TAX ASSESSMENT BY SHORE WINDS PROPERTIES LLC AND ROBERT H HURLBUT vs. ASSESSMENT REVIEW FOR THE CITY OF ROCHESTER,

Case Type

RP-Tax Certiorari

Track

Standard

RJI Filed

05/10/2018

NOI Due

05/10/2022

NOI Filed

05/10/2022

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

Doyle, Hon. Daniel J.

Next Appearance

11/06/2023

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

TAX ASSESSMENT BY SHORE WINDS PROPERTIES LLC AND ROBERT H HURLBUT

Attorney / FirmKAVINOKYCOOK LLP

Defendant / Respondent

ASSESSMENT REVIEW FOR THE CITY OF ROCHESTER,

Attorneys / FirmsThe Assessor of the City of Rochester

Motions (1)

#	Date Filed	Filed By	Relief Sought	Submit Date	Answer	Status	Decision	Order Signed
1	05/10/2018	PLAINTIFF	Other	12/17/2019	No	Decided: 12/17/2019 Decided Before Justice: Doyle, Hon. Daniel J.

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints (37)

Doc #	Date Filed	Document	Description	Motion #	Filing User
1	05/10/2018	PETITION			Wayne D. Wisbaum
2	05/10/2018	NOTICE OF PETITION ACCOMPANYING COMMENCEMENT DOC(S)		1	Wayne D. Wisbaum
3	05/10/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Side Number 1		Wayne D. Wisbaum
4	05/10/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit A to Side Number 1		Wayne D. Wisbaum
5	05/10/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Side Number 2		Wayne D. Wisbaum
6	05/10/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit A to Side Number 2		Wayne D. Wisbaum
7	05/10/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Side Number 3		Wayne D. Wisbaum
8	05/10/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit A to Side Number 3		Wayne D. Wisbaum
9	05/10/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Side Number 4		Wayne D. Wisbaum
10	05/10/2018	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit A to Side Number 4		Wayne D. Wisbaum
11	05/10/2018	RJI -RE: NOTICE OF PETITION	Commercial Division Addendum Attached		Wayne D. Wisbaum
12	05/24/2018	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Affidavit Proof of Service on a Corporation	1	Wayne D. Wisbaum
13	05/24/2018	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service by Mail	1	Wayne D. Wisbaum
14	06/06/2018	NOTICE OF APPEARANCE (POST RJI)		1	Alison K.L. Moyer
15	07/17/2020	ORDER ( PROPOSED )	Proposed Scheduling Order		Scott Christopher Becker
16	07/17/2020	ORDER - OTHER	SCHEDULING ORDER		Kathleen M Saltrelli
17	10/07/2020	COURT NOTICE			Lisa Cohan
18	11/06/2020	ORDER ( PROPOSED )	Amended Scheduling Order		Scott Christopher Becker
19	11/16/2020	ORDER - OTHER	AMENDED SCHEDULING ORDER		Kathleen M Saltrelli
20	06/18/2021	ORDER ( PROPOSED )	Amended Scheduling Order		Scott Christopher Becker
21	10/12/2021	ORDER - AMENDED	AMENDED SCHEDULING ORDER		Kathleen M Saltrelli
22	12/15/2021	ORDER ( PROPOSED )	Amended Scheduling Order		Scott Christopher Becker
23	12/22/2021	ORDER - AMENDED	Scheduling Order		Kathleen M Saltrelli
24	01/06/2022	NOTICE OF ENTRY	Notice of Entry		Scott Christopher Becker
25	04/28/2022	ORDER ( PROPOSED )	Amended Scheduling Order		Scott Christopher Becker
26	05/17/2022	ORDER - CASE SCHEDULING			Maureen P Ware
27	05/10/2022	STATEMENT OF INCOME AND EXPENSES	Statement Pursuant to 22 N.Y.C.R.R. 2020.59(b)		Scott Christopher Becker
28	05/10/2022	NOTE OF ISSUE:WITHOUT JURY	Note of Issue		Scott Christopher Becker
29	07/27/2022	ORDER ( PROPOSED )	Amended Scheduling Order		Scott Christopher Becker
30	07/28/2022	ORDER - CASE SCHEDULING			Maureen P Ware
31	08/05/2022	NOTICE OF ENTRY	Notice of Entry		Scott Christopher Becker
32	05/09/2023	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE	Letter to Judge Odorisi / appraisal exchange date		Scott Christopher Becker
33	05/16/2023	ORDER - CASE SCHEDULING			Maureen P Ware
34	05/16/2023	NOTICE OF ENTRY	Notice of Entry		Scott Christopher Becker
35	07/25/2023	COURT NOTICE			Michael Habich
36	03/08/2024	ORDER ( PROPOSED )	Scheduling Order		Scott Christopher Becker
37	03/12/2024	ORDER - CONSOLIDATION	CASE SCHEDULING		Sue Lerkins

Monroe Supreme Court

2018

I2017011047

Disposed

RP-Mortgage Foreclosure-Residential

Bank of America, N.A.

Frenkel Lambert Weisman & Gordon, LLP

Litzenberger, Kenneth

MONROE COUNTY ATTYS OFFICE

06/07/2022

Valleriani, Hon. Sam L.

▼

Case Info

Court

Monroe Supreme Court

Index Number

I2017011047

Status

Disposed

Year Filed

2018

Case Name

Bank of America, N.A. vs. Litzenberger, Kenneth

Case Type

RP-Mortgage Foreclosure-Residential

Track

Standard

RJI Filed

09/21/2018

NOI Due

11/25/2020

NOI Filed

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

Valleriani, Hon. Sam L.

Next Appearance

06/07/2022

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

Bank of America, N.A.

Attorney / FirmFrenkel Lambert Weisman & Gordon, LLP

Defendant / Respondent

Litzenberger, Kenneth

Attorneys / FirmsMONROE COUNTY ATTYS OFFICE

Motions (4)

#	Date Filed	Relief Sought	Submit Date	Answer	Status	Decision	Order Signed
4	04/27/2022	Judgment - Foreclosure & Sale	06/07/2022	No	Decided: 06/07/2022 Granted Before Justice: Valleriani, Hon. Sam L.	Short Form Order	06/07/2022
3	01/09/2020	Order of Reference/Referee to Compute	02/06/2020	No	Decided: 02/06/2020 Granted Before Justice: Taylor, Hon. William K.	Short Form Order	02/06/2020
2	02/06/2019	Leave to File	02/26/2019	No	Decided: 02/26/2019 Granted Before Justice: Odorisi, Hon. J. Scott	Short Form Order	02/26/2019
1	09/21/2018	Extend - Time	10/23/2018	No	Decided: 10/23/2018 Granted Before Justice: Odorisi, Hon. J. Scott	Short Form Order	10/23/2018

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints (48)

Doc #	Date Filed	Document	Description	Motion #	Filing User
1	11/08/2017	COUNTY CLERK MINUTES -PRIOR TO CONVERSION			Ariana C Rivera Cuevas
2	01/11/2021	CONSENT TO EFILING			Ariana C Rivera Cuevas
3	04/30/2021	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	notice of Conversion		Robert Steven Tremaroli
4	10/25/2021	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE	Deadline Extension Request		Linda P. Manfredi
5	02/15/2022	NOTICE OF PENDENCY	2nd LP		Todd C Falasco
6	04/27/2022	NOTICE OF MOTION		4	Linda P. Manfredi
7	04/27/2022	AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION		4	Linda P. Manfredi
8	04/27/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Certificate of Merit	4	Linda P. Manfredi
9	04/27/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Note	4	Linda P. Manfredi
10	04/27/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Mortgage	4	Linda P. Manfredi
11	04/27/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Assignment	4	Linda P. Manfredi
12	04/27/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Notice of Default	4	Linda P. Manfredi
13	04/27/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	90 day notice	4	Linda P. Manfredi
14	04/27/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Department of Defense	4	Linda P. Manfredi
15	04/27/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Summons and Complaint	4	Linda P. Manfredi
16	04/27/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Notice of Pendency	4	Linda P. Manfredi
17	04/27/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Affidavits of Service	4	Linda P. Manfredi
18	04/27/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	3215 Mailing	4	Linda P. Manfredi
19	04/27/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Affidavit of Merit	4	Linda P. Manfredi
20	04/27/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Affirmation of Regularity	4	Linda P. Manfredi
21	04/27/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Order of Reference	4	Linda P. Manfredi
22	04/27/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Notice of Entry	4	Linda P. Manfredi
23	04/27/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Oath	4	Linda P. Manfredi
24	04/27/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Affirmation of Legal fees	4	Linda P. Manfredi
25	04/27/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Death Certificate	4	Linda P. Manfredi
26	04/27/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Notice of Apperance	4	Linda P. Manfredi
27	04/27/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Supplemental Summons	4	Linda P. Manfredi
28	04/27/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Amended Notice of Pendency	4	Linda P. Manfredi
29	04/27/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Order permitting service by publication	4	Linda P. Manfredi
30	04/27/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Affidavit of publication	4	Linda P. Manfredi
31	04/27/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Second summons	4	Linda P. Manfredi
32	04/27/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	2nd action discontinuance	4	Linda P. Manfredi
33	04/27/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Order extending time to serve	4	Linda P. Manfredi
34	04/27/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	Loan modification	4	Linda P. Manfredi
35	04/27/2022	EXHIBIT(S)	convert to e-file	4	Linda P. Manfredi
36	04/27/2022	ORDER ( PROPOSED )		4	Linda P. Manfredi
37	04/27/2022	BILL OF COSTS		4	Linda P. Manfredi
38	04/27/2022	REFEREE REPORT OF AMOUNT DUE		4	Linda P. Manfredi
39	04/27/2022	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE		4	Linda P. Manfredi
40	05/11/2022	NOTICE OF MOTION (AMENDED)		4	Linda P. Manfredi
41	05/11/2022	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE		4	Linda P. Manfredi
42	06/10/2022	JUDGMENT OF FORECLOSURE AND SALE		4	Chery A Porter
43	07/22/2022	AFFIDAVIT			Robert Steven Tremaroli
44	07/22/2022	NOTICE OF SALE			Robert Steven Tremaroli
45	08/26/2022	NOTICE OF ENTRY			George James Mullane
46	08/26/2022	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE			George James Mullane
47	10/20/2022	REFEREE REPORT OF SALE			Robert Steven Tremaroli
48	10/26/2022	FORECLOSURE ACTION SURPLUS MONIES FORM			Robert Steven Tremaroli

Monroe Supreme Court

2017

2016/05927 (0005927/2016)

Disposed

Comm-Other

THE HURLBUT LLC

PULLANO & FARROW, LAW OFFICE

WILLIAM HAEFELE, JUDY ANGE, INDIVID

JUDY ANGE PRO SE

12/11/2018

Doyle, Hon. Daniel J.

▼

Case Info

Court

Monroe Supreme Court

Index Number

2016/05927 (0005927/2016)

Status

Disposed

Year Filed

2017

Case Name

THE HURLBUT LLC vs. WILLIAM HAEFELE, JUDY ANGE, INDIVID

Case Type

Comm-Other

Track

Complex

RJI Filed

05/15/2017

NOI Due

NOI Filed

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

Doyle, Hon. Daniel J.

Next Appearance

12/11/2018

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

THE HURLBUT LLC

Attorney / FirmPULLANO & FARROW, LAW OFFICE

Defendant / Respondent

WILLIAM HAEFELE, JUDY ANGE, INDIVID

Attorneys / FirmsJUDY ANGE PRO SE

Motions (3)

#	Date Filed	Relief Sought	Submit Date	Answer	Status	Order Signed
3	11/26/2018	Discontinue	12/11/2018	No	Decided: 12/11/2018 Granted Before Justice: Doyle, Hon. Daniel J.	12/11/2018
2	06/12/2017	Other	09/07/2017	No	Decided: 09/07/2017 Decided Before Justice: Doyle, Hon. Daniel J.	09/07/2017
1	05/15/2017	Other	09/07/2017	No	Decided: 09/07/2017 Decided Before Justice: Doyle, Hon. Daniel J.	09/07/2017

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints

No eFiled documents available for this case.

Oneida Supreme Court

2017

CA2012-000608 (1300608/2012)

Disposed

Tort

PALMISANO,PETER B

NIEVES,LUIS F/HAWKINS & HURLBUT SANITAT

04/20/2017

Siegel, Hon. Norman I.

▼

Case Info

Court

Oneida Supreme Court

Index Number

CA2012-000608 (1300608/2012)

Status

Disposed

Year Filed

2017

Case Name

PALMISANO,PETER B vs. NIEVES,LUIS F/HAWKINS & HURLBUT SANITAT

Case Type

Tort-Motor Vehicle

Track

Standard

RJI Filed

02/28/2017

NOI Due

02/28/2018

NOI Filed

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

Siegel, Hon. Norman I.

Next Appearance

04/20/2017

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

PALMISANO,PETER B

Attorney / Firm

Defendant / Respondent

NIEVES,LUIS F/HAWKINS & HURLBUT SANITAT

Attorneys / Firms

Motions (1)

#	Date Filed	Filed By	Relief Sought	Submit Date	Answer	Status	Decision	Order Signed
1	02/28/2017		Other	04/20/2017	No	Decided: 04/20/2017 Decided Before Justice: Siegel, Hon. Norman I.		04/20/2017

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints

No eFiled documents available for this case.

Monroe Supreme Court

2017

E2017000777 (3000777/2017)

Disposed-Consolidated Into

RP-Tax Certiorari

SHORE WINDS PROPERTIES LLC AND ROBERT H HURLBUT

KAVINOKYCOOK LLP

THE BOARD OF ASSESSMENT REVIEW FOR THE

CORPORATION COUNSELS OFFICE

11/06/2023

Doyle, Hon. Daniel J.

▼

Case Info

Court

Monroe Supreme Court

Index Number

E2017000777 (3000777/2017)

Status

Disposed-Consolidated Into

Year Filed

2017

Case Name

SHORE WINDS PROPERTIES LLC AND ROBERT H HURLBUT vs. THE BOARD OF ASSESSMENT REVIEW FOR THE

Case Type

RP-Tax Certiorari

Track

Standard

RJI Filed

05/16/2017

NOI Due

05/16/2021

NOI Filed

05/06/2021

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

Doyle, Hon. Daniel J.

Next Appearance

11/06/2023

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

SHORE WINDS PROPERTIES LLC AND ROBERT H HURLBUT

Attorney / FirmKAVINOKYCOOK LLP

Defendant / Respondent

THE BOARD OF ASSESSMENT REVIEW FOR THE

Attorneys / FirmsCORPORATION COUNSELS OFFICE

Motions

No motions recorded for this case.

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints (39)

Doc #	Date Filed	Document	Description	Motion #	Filing User
1	05/16/2017	PETITION			Wayne D. Wisbaum
2	05/16/2017	NOTICE OF PETITION ACCOMPANYING COMMENCEMENT DOC(S)		1	Wayne D. Wisbaum
3	05/16/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Side Number 1		Wayne D. Wisbaum
4	05/16/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Side Number 2		Wayne D. Wisbaum
5	05/16/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit A to Side Number 2		Wayne D. Wisbaum
6	05/16/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Side Number 3		Wayne D. Wisbaum
7	05/16/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit A to Side Number 3		Wayne D. Wisbaum
8	05/16/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Side Number 4		Wayne D. Wisbaum
9	05/16/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Exhibit A to Side Number 4		Wayne D. Wisbaum
10	05/16/2017	RJI -RE: NOTICE OF PETITION	Commercial Division Addendum Attached		Wayne D. Wisbaum
11	05/16/2017	EXHIBIT(S)	Complaint		Wayne D. Wisbaum
12	05/23/2017	NOTICE OF PETITION (AMENDED)	Amended Judge Information	1	Wayne D. Wisbaum
13	06/05/2017	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Affidavit Proof of Service on a Corporation	1	Wayne D. Wisbaum
14	06/05/2017	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service by Mail	1	Wayne D. Wisbaum
15	12/06/2017	ORDER - CASE SCHEDULING			Concetta C Giliberti
16	07/17/2020	ORDER ( PROPOSED )	Proposed Scheduling Order		Scott Christopher Becker
17	07/17/2020	ORDER - OTHER	SCHEDULING ORDER		Kathleen M Saltrelli
18	10/07/2020	COURT NOTICE			Lisa Cohan
19	11/06/2020	ORDER ( PROPOSED )	Amended Scheduling Order		Scott Christopher Becker
20	11/11/2020	ORDER - OTHER	AMENDED SCHEDULING ORDER		Kathleen M Saltrelli
21	05/06/2021	STATEMENT OF INCOME AND EXPENSES	Statement Pursuant to 22 N.Y.C.R.R. 2020.59(b)		Scott Christopher Becker
22	05/06/2021	NOTE OF ISSUE:WITHOUT JURY	Note of Issue		Scott Christopher Becker
23	06/18/2021	ORDER ( PROPOSED )	Amended Scheduling Order		Scott Christopher Becker
24	06/22/2021	COURT NOTICE			Kathleen M Saltrelli
25	10/12/2021	ORDER - AMENDED	AMENDED SCHEDULING ORDER		Kathleen M Saltrelli
26	12/15/2021	ORDER ( PROPOSED )	Amended Scheduling Order		Scott Christopher Becker
27	12/22/2021	ORDER - AMENDED	Scheduling Order		Kathleen M Saltrelli
28	01/06/2022	NOTICE OF ENTRY	Notice of Entry		Scott Christopher Becker
29	04/28/2022	ORDER ( PROPOSED )	Amended Scheduling Order		Scott Christopher Becker
30	05/17/2022	ORDER - CASE SCHEDULING			Maureen P Ware
31	07/27/2022	ORDER ( PROPOSED )	Amended Scheduling Order		Scott Christopher Becker
32	07/28/2022	ORDER - CASE SCHEDULING			Maureen P Ware
33	08/05/2022	NOTICE OF ENTRY	Notice of Entry		Scott Christopher Becker
34	05/09/2023	LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE	Letter to Judge Odorisi / appraisal exchange date		Scott Christopher Becker
35	05/16/2023	ORDER - CASE SCHEDULING			Maureen P Ware
36	05/16/2023	NOTICE OF ENTRY	Notice of Entry		Scott Christopher Becker
37	07/25/2023	COURT NOTICE			Michael Habich
38	03/08/2024	ORDER ( PROPOSED )	Scheduling Order		Scott Christopher Becker
39	03/12/2024	ORDER - CONSOLIDATION	CASE SCHEDULING		Sue Lerkins

Ontario Supreme Court

2016

113555-2016 (1113555/2016)

Disposed

RP-Other

HURLBUT

BIRNBAUM

11/30/2017

Martin, Hon. Debra A.

▼

Case Info

Court

Ontario Supreme Court

Index Number

113555-2016 (1113555/2016)

Status

Disposed

Year Filed

2016

Case Name

HURLBUT vs. BIRNBAUM

Case Type

RP-Other

Track

Standard

RJI Filed

02/02/2016

NOI Due

02/01/2017

NOI Filed

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

Martin, Hon. Debra A.

Next Appearance

11/30/2017

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

HURLBUT

Attorney / Firm

Defendant / Respondent

BIRNBAUM

Attorneys / Firms

Motions

No motions recorded for this case.

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints

No eFiled documents available for this case.

Monroe Supreme Court

2016

2016/01226 (0001226/2016)

Disposed

OM-Other

ROBERT W HURLBUT

WOLFORD LAW FIRM LLP

JAY B BIRNBAUM

Nixon Peabody LLP

12/01/2017

Martin, Hon. Debra A.

▼

Case Info

Court

Monroe Supreme Court

Index Number

2016/01226 (0001226/2016)

Status

Disposed

Year Filed

2016

Case Name

ROBERT W HURLBUT vs. JAY B BIRNBAUM

Case Type

OM-Other

Track

Standard

RJI Filed

02/02/2016

NOI Due

02/01/2017

NOI Filed

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

Martin, Hon. Debra A.

Next Appearance

12/01/2017

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

ROBERT W HURLBUT

Attorney / FirmWOLFORD LAW FIRM LLP

Defendant / Respondent

JAY B BIRNBAUM

Attorneys / FirmsNixon Peabody LLP

Motions (1)

#	Date Filed	Filed By	Relief Sought	Submit Date	Answer	Status	Decision	Order Signed
1	02/02/2016		Other	02/02/2016	No	Decided: 02/02/2016 Closed Before Justice: Martin, Hon. Debra A.

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints

No eFiled documents available for this case.

Monroe Supreme Court

2016

2016/01229 (0001229/2016)

Disposed

OM-Other

THE APPLICATION OF ROBERT W HURLBUT

WOLFORD LAW FIRM LLP

JAY B BIRNBAUM THE HOLDER OF ONE-HAL

Nixon Peabody LLP

01/03/2018

Martin, Hon. Debra A.

▼

Case Info

Court

Monroe Supreme Court

Index Number

2016/01229 (0001229/2016)

Status

Disposed

Year Filed

2016

Case Name

THE APPLICATION OF ROBERT W HURLBUT vs. JAY B BIRNBAUM THE HOLDER OF ONE-HAL

Case Type

OM-Other

Track

Standard

RJI Filed

02/02/2016

NOI Due

02/01/2017

NOI Filed

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

Martin, Hon. Debra A.

Next Appearance

01/03/2018

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

THE APPLICATION OF ROBERT W HURLBUT

Attorney / FirmWOLFORD LAW FIRM LLP

Defendant / Respondent

JAY B BIRNBAUM THE HOLDER OF ONE-HAL

Attorneys / FirmsNixon Peabody LLP

Motions (1)

#	Date Filed	Filed By	Relief Sought	Submit Date	Answer	Status	Decision	Order Signed
1	02/02/2016		Other	06/06/2016	No	Decided: 06/06/2016 Decided Before Justice: Martin, Hon. Debra A.		06/06/2016

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints

No eFiled documents available for this case.

Monroe Supreme Court

2016

2016/03769 (0003769/2016)

Disposed

RP-Mortgage Foreclosure-Residential

CALIBER HOME LOANS INC

GROSS POLOWY ORLANS LLC

DAWN L BOWERMAN, KEVIN R BOWERMANAMERICR

MEDAILLE COLLEGE PRO SE

04/27/2017

(Foreclosure Part 2), FPB

▼

Case Info

Court

Monroe Supreme Court

Index Number

2016/03769 (0003769/2016)

Status

Disposed

Year Filed

2016

Case Name

CALIBER HOME LOANS INC vs. DAWN L BOWERMAN, KEVIN R BOWERMANAMERICR

Case Type

RP-Mortgage Foreclosure-Residential

Track

Standard

RJI Filed

05/05/2016

NOI Due

05/05/2017

NOI Filed

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

(Foreclosure Part 2), FPB

Next Appearance

04/27/2017

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

CALIBER HOME LOANS INC

Attorney / FirmGROSS POLOWY ORLANS LLC

Defendant / Respondent

DAWN L BOWERMAN, KEVIN R BOWERMANAMERICR

Attorneys / FirmsMEDAILLE COLLEGE PRO SE

Motions (1)

#	Date Filed	Filed By	Relief Sought	Submit Date	Answer	Status	Decision	Order Signed
1	03/29/2017		Other	04/27/2017	No	Decided: 04/27/2017 Decided Before Justice: Doyle, Hon. Daniel J.		04/27/2017

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints

No eFiled documents available for this case.

Ontario Supreme Court

2015

112748-2015 (1112748/2015)

Disposed

RP-Tax Certiorari

BIRNBAUM / HURLBUT C CANANDAIGUA

THE BOARD OF ASSESSMENT REVIEW FOR THE

02/09/2017

Doyle, Hon. Daniel J.

▼

Case Info

Court

Ontario Supreme Court

Index Number

112748-2015 (1112748/2015)

Status

Disposed

Year Filed

2015

Case Name

BIRNBAUM / HURLBUT C CANANDAIGUA vs. THE BOARD OF ASSESSMENT REVIEW FOR THE

Case Type

RP-Tax Certiorari

Track

Standard

RJI Filed

07/06/2015

NOI Due

07/06/2019

NOI Filed

Calendar Number

EFILED

Jury Status

Justice

Doyle, Hon. Daniel J.

Next Appearance

02/09/2017

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

BIRNBAUM / HURLBUT C CANANDAIGUA

Attorney / Firm

Defendant / Respondent

THE BOARD OF ASSESSMENT REVIEW FOR THE

Attorneys / Firms

Motions (1)

#	Date Filed	Filed By	Relief Sought	Submit Date	Answer	Status	Decision	Order Signed
1	07/06/2015	PLAINTIFF	Other	07/06/2015	No	Decided: 09/24/2015 Decided Before Justice: Doyle, Hon. Daniel J.		09/24/2015

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints (14)

Doc #	Date Filed	Document	Description	Motion #	Filing User	File
1	07/06/2015	PETITION			Wayne D. Wisbaum
2	07/06/2015	NOTICE OF PETITION ACCOMPANYING COMMENCEMENT DOC(S)		001	Wayne D. Wisbaum
3	07/06/2015	RJI -RE: NOTICE OF PETITION	RJI with Commercial Division Addendum		Wayne D. Wisbaum
4	07/06/2015	EXHIBIT(S)	Complaint		Wayne D. Wisbaum
5	07/09/2015	NOTICE OF MOTION (AMENDED)	Motion with date and time	001	Cynthia C Gillette	pdf
6	07/28/2015	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Affidavit Proof of Service on a Corporation	001	Wayne D. Wisbaum
7	07/28/2015	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE	Affidavit of Service by Mail	001	Wayne D. Wisbaum
8	08/27/2015	CONSENT TO EFILING			John Todd Refermat
9	08/28/2015	ANSWER			Katherine E. Gavett	pdf
10	09/08/2015	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE			Katherine E. Gavett
11	09/21/2015	ANSWER			John Todd Refermat	pdf
12	09/21/2015	INTERROGATORIES			John Todd Refermat
13	09/21/2015	AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE			John Todd Refermat
14	02/09/2017	STIPULATION - DISCONTINUANCE (POST RJI)	Stipulation of Discontinuance		Wayne D. Wisbaum	pdf

Monroe Supreme Court

2015

2014/12223 (0012223/2014)

Disposed

Comm-Contract

THE HURLBUT LLC

IONIE JOHNSON AND CORDEL ROUSSEAUINDIVID

12/07/2015

Rosenbaum, Hon. Matthew A.

▼

Case Info

Court

Monroe Supreme Court

Index Number

2014/12223 (0012223/2014)

Status

Disposed

Year Filed

2015

Case Name

THE HURLBUT LLC vs. IONIE JOHNSON AND CORDEL ROUSSEAUINDIVID

Case Type

Comm-Contract

Track

Standard

RJI Filed

03/05/2015

NOI Due

03/04/2016

NOI Filed

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

Rosenbaum, Hon. Matthew A.

Next Appearance

12/07/2015

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

THE HURLBUT LLC

Attorney / Firm

Defendant / Respondent

IONIE JOHNSON AND CORDEL ROUSSEAUINDIVID

Attorneys / Firms

Motions

No motions recorded for this case.

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints

No eFiled documents available for this case.

Monroe Supreme Court

2015

2014/12224 (0012224/2014)

Disposed

Comm-Other

THE HURLBUT LLC

PULLANO & FARROW, LAW OFFICE

MARY ELLEN LUNDY AND PAUL LUNDY INDIVID

MARY ELLEN LUNDY PRO SE

12/22/2016

Frazee, Hon. Evelyn

▼

Case Info

Court

Monroe Supreme Court

Index Number

2014/12224 (0012224/2014)

Status

Disposed

Year Filed

2015

Case Name

THE HURLBUT LLC vs. MARY ELLEN LUNDY AND PAUL LUNDY INDIVID

Case Type

Comm-Other

Track

Standard

RJI Filed

08/14/2015

NOI Due

08/13/2016

NOI Filed

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

Frazee, Hon. Evelyn

Next Appearance

12/22/2016

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

THE HURLBUT LLC

Attorney / FirmPULLANO & FARROW, LAW OFFICE

Defendant / Respondent

MARY ELLEN LUNDY AND PAUL LUNDY INDIVID

Attorneys / FirmsMARY ELLEN LUNDY PRO SE

Motions (3)

#	Date Filed	Relief Sought	Submit Date	Answer	Status	Order Signed
3	11/03/2016	Other	12/15/2016	No	Decided: 12/15/2016 Decided Before Justice: Frazee, Hon. Evelyn	12/15/2016
2	08/20/2015	Other	10/15/2015	No	Decided: 10/15/2015 Decided Before Justice: Frazee, Hon. Evelyn	10/15/2015
1	08/14/2015	Other	10/15/2015	No	Decided: 10/15/2015 Decided Before Justice: Frazee, Hon. Evelyn	10/15/2015

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints

No eFiled documents available for this case.

Monroe Supreme Court

2014

2012/08406 (0008406/2012)

Disposed

Comm-Other

JAY B BIRNBAUM

Nixon Peabody LLP

ROBERT W HURLBUT

WOLFORD LAW FIRM LLP

01/03/2018

Martin, Hon. Debra A.

▼

Case Info

Court

Monroe Supreme Court

Index Number

2012/08406 (0008406/2012)

Status

Disposed

Year Filed

2014

Case Name

JAY B BIRNBAUM vs. ROBERT W HURLBUT

Case Type

Comm-Other

Track

Standard

RJI Filed

01/02/2014

NOI Due

01/02/2015

NOI Filed

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

Martin, Hon. Debra A.

Next Appearance

01/03/2018

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

JAY B BIRNBAUM

Attorney / FirmNixon Peabody LLP

Defendant / Respondent

ROBERT W HURLBUT

Attorneys / FirmsWOLFORD LAW FIRM LLP

Motions

No motions recorded for this case.

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints

No eFiled documents available for this case.

Monroe Supreme Court

2014

2013/11045 (0011045/2013)

Disposed

SP-Other

THE HURLBUT LLC

CARL DANIELS

CARL DANIELS PRO SE

06/19/2014

Taddeo, Hon. Ann Marie

▼

Case Info

Court

Monroe Supreme Court

Index Number

2013/11045 (0011045/2013)

Status

Disposed

Year Filed

2014

Case Name

THE HURLBUT LLC vs. CARL DANIELS

Case Type

SP-Other

Track

Standard

RJI Filed

03/11/2014

NOI Due

03/11/2015

NOI Filed

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

Taddeo, Hon. Ann Marie

Next Appearance

06/19/2014

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

THE HURLBUT LLC

Attorney / Firm

Defendant / Respondent

CARL DANIELS

Attorneys / FirmsCARL DANIELS PRO SE

Motions

No motions recorded for this case.

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints

No eFiled documents available for this case.

Monroe Supreme Court

2014

2014/04623 (0004623/2014)

Disposed

Tort

LOIS COACHMAN

LOIS COACHMAN PRO SE

THE HURLBUT NURSING HOME INC

PETRONE PETRONE PC

05/19/2015

Odorisi, Hon. J. Scott

▼

Case Info

Court

Monroe Supreme Court

Index Number

2014/04623 (0004623/2014)

Status

Disposed

Year Filed

2014

Case Name

LOIS COACHMAN vs. THE HURLBUT NURSING HOME INC

Case Type

Tort-Other

Track

Standard

RJI Filed

08/05/2014

NOI Due

08/05/2015

NOI Filed

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

Odorisi, Hon. J. Scott

Next Appearance

05/19/2015

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

LOIS COACHMAN

Attorney / FirmLOIS COACHMAN PRO SE

Defendant / Respondent

THE HURLBUT NURSING HOME INC

Attorneys / FirmsPETRONE PETRONE PC

Motions (2)

#	Date Filed	Filed By	Relief Sought	Submit Date	Answer	Status	Decision	Order Signed
2	03/17/2015	DEFENDANT	Other	05/19/2015	No	Decided: 05/19/2015 Decided Before Justice: Odorisi, Hon. J. Scott		05/19/2015
1	10/21/2014	PLAINTIFF	Other	12/16/2014	No	Decided: 12/16/2014 Decided Before Justice: Odorisi, Hon. J. Scott		12/16/2014

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints

No eFiled documents available for this case.

Monroe Supreme Court

2013

2012/09931 (0009931/2012)

Disposed

Comm-Other

THE HURLBUT LLC

OLIVER ASSING AND COREY MINTON

03/16/2016

Stander, Hon. Thomas A.

▼

Case Info

Court

Monroe Supreme Court

Index Number

2012/09931 (0009931/2012)

Status

Disposed

Year Filed

2013

Case Name

THE HURLBUT LLC vs. OLIVER ASSING AND COREY MINTON

Case Type

Comm-Other

Track

Standard

RJI Filed

01/15/2013

NOI Due

01/15/2014

NOI Filed

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

Stander, Hon. Thomas A.

Next Appearance

03/16/2016

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

THE HURLBUT LLC

Attorney / Firm

Defendant / Respondent

OLIVER ASSING AND COREY MINTON

Attorneys / Firms

Motions (1)

#	Date Filed	Filed By	Relief Sought	Submit Date	Answer	Status	Decision	Order Signed
1	02/21/2015	PLAINTIFF	Other	12/23/2015	No	Decided: 12/23/2015 Decided Before Justice: Stander, Hon. Thomas A.		12/23/2015

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints

No eFiled documents available for this case.

Monroe Supreme Court

2013

2012/10104 (0010104/2012)

Disposed

Comm-Other

THE HURLBUT LLC

AUBREY J BROWN AND THOMAS J HARRIS

AUBREY J BROWN PRO SE

12/17/2015

Stander, Hon. Thomas A.

▼

Case Info

Court

Monroe Supreme Court

Index Number

2012/10104 (0010104/2012)

Status

Disposed

Year Filed

2013

Case Name

THE HURLBUT LLC vs. AUBREY J BROWN AND THOMAS J HARRIS

Case Type

Comm-Other

Track

Standard

RJI Filed

07/24/2013

NOI Due

07/24/2014

NOI Filed

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

Stander, Hon. Thomas A.

Next Appearance

12/17/2015

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

THE HURLBUT LLC

Attorney / Firm

Defendant / Respondent

AUBREY J BROWN AND THOMAS J HARRIS

Attorneys / FirmsAUBREY J BROWN PRO SE

Motions (1)

#	Date Filed	Filed By	Relief Sought	Submit Date	Answer	Status	Decision	Order Signed
1	07/24/2013	PLAINTIFF	Other	11/15/2013	No	Decided: 11/15/2013 Decided Before Justice: Stander, Hon. Thomas A.		11/15/2013

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints

No eFiled documents available for this case.

Monroe Supreme Court

2013

2013/01338 (0001338/2013)

Disposed

Comm-Other

THE HURLBUT LLC

ESTHER ADAMS, MARGARET BRIDGELANDAND MIC

ESTHER ADAMS PRO SE

06/24/2014

Taddeo, Hon. Ann Marie

▼

Case Info

Court

Monroe Supreme Court

Index Number

2013/01338 (0001338/2013)

Status

Disposed

Year Filed

2013

Case Name

THE HURLBUT LLC vs. ESTHER ADAMS, MARGARET BRIDGELANDAND MIC

Case Type

Comm-Other

Track

Standard

RJI Filed

07/25/2013

NOI Due

07/25/2014

NOI Filed

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

Taddeo, Hon. Ann Marie

Next Appearance

06/24/2014

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

THE HURLBUT LLC

Attorney / Firm

Defendant / Respondent

ESTHER ADAMS, MARGARET BRIDGELANDAND MIC

Attorneys / FirmsESTHER ADAMS PRO SE

Motions

No motions recorded for this case.

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints

No eFiled documents available for this case.

Monroe Supreme Court

2013

2013/03285 (0003285/2013)

Disposed

Comm-Other

THE HURLBUT LLC

JANICE HARRIS

JANICE HARRIS PRO SE

07/16/2013

Stander, Hon. Thomas A.

▼

Case Info

Court

Monroe Supreme Court

Index Number

2013/03285 (0003285/2013)

Status

Disposed

Year Filed

2013

Case Name

THE HURLBUT LLC vs. JANICE HARRIS

Case Type

Comm-Other

Track

Standard

RJI Filed

07/15/2013

NOI Due

07/15/2014

NOI Filed

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

Stander, Hon. Thomas A.

Next Appearance

07/16/2013

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

THE HURLBUT LLC

Attorney / Firm

Defendant / Respondent

JANICE HARRIS

Attorneys / FirmsJANICE HARRIS PRO SE

Motions (1)

#	Date Filed	Filed By	Relief Sought	Submit Date	Answer	Status	Decision	Order Signed
1	07/15/2013		Other	10/07/2013	No	Decided: 10/07/2013 Signed Before Justice: Stander, Hon. Thomas A.

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints

No eFiled documents available for this case.

Monroe Supreme Court

2013

2013/07499 (0007499/2013)

Disposed

Comm-Other

THE HURLBUT LLC

ETHEL LOWE AND JAMES LOWE

ETHEL LOWE PRO SE

10/17/2014

Stander, Hon. Thomas A.

▼

Case Info

Court

Monroe Supreme Court

Index Number

2013/07499 (0007499/2013)

Status

Disposed

Year Filed

2013

Case Name

THE HURLBUT LLC vs. ETHEL LOWE AND JAMES LOWE

Case Type

Comm-Other

Track

Standard

RJI Filed

07/09/2013

NOI Due

07/09/2014

NOI Filed

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

Stander, Hon. Thomas A.

Next Appearance

10/17/2014

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

THE HURLBUT LLC

Attorney / Firm

Defendant / Respondent

ETHEL LOWE AND JAMES LOWE

Attorneys / FirmsETHEL LOWE PRO SE

Motions (2)

#	Date Filed	Filed By	Relief Sought	Submit Date	Answer	Status	Decision	Order Signed
2	08/26/2014	PLAINTIFF	Other	10/17/2014	No	Decided: 10/17/2014 Decided Before Justice: Stander, Hon. Thomas A.		10/17/2014
1	09/05/2013	DEFENDANT	Other	11/01/2013	No	Decided: 11/01/2013 Decided Before Justice: Stander, Hon. Thomas A.		11/01/2013

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints

No eFiled documents available for this case.

Monroe Supreme Court

2013

2013/07710 (0007710/2013)

Disposed

Comm-Other

THE HURLBUT LLC

JESSICA MCEWEN AND PONCHANDRA MCEWEN-

JESSICA MCEWEN PRO SE

12/23/2014

Taddeo, Hon. Ann Marie

▼

Case Info

Court

Monroe Supreme Court

Index Number

2013/07710 (0007710/2013)

Status

Disposed

Year Filed

2013

Case Name

THE HURLBUT LLC vs. JESSICA MCEWEN AND PONCHANDRA MCEWEN-

Case Type

Comm-Other

Track

Standard

RJI Filed

07/15/2013

NOI Due

07/15/2014

NOI Filed

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

Taddeo, Hon. Ann Marie

Next Appearance

12/23/2014

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

THE HURLBUT LLC

Attorney / Firm

Defendant / Respondent

JESSICA MCEWEN AND PONCHANDRA MCEWEN-

Attorneys / FirmsJESSICA MCEWEN PRO SE

Motions

No motions recorded for this case.

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints

No eFiled documents available for this case.

Chautauqua Supreme Court

2013

K1-2012-001680 (1001680/2012)

Disposed

RP-Mortgage Foreclosure-Residential

WELLS

GROSS POLOWY ORLANS LLC

HURLBUT

DANIEL J. HURLBUT

01/15/2014

Chimes, Hon. Deborah

▼

Case Info

Court

Chautauqua Supreme Court

Index Number

K1-2012-001680 (1001680/2012)

Status

Disposed

Year Filed

2013

Case Name

WELLS vs. HURLBUT

Case Type

RP-Mortgage Foreclosure-Residential

Track

Standard

RJI Filed

01/30/2013

NOI Due

01/30/2014

NOI Filed

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

Chimes, Hon. Deborah

Next Appearance

01/15/2014

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

WELLS

Attorney / FirmGROSS POLOWY ORLANS LLC

Defendant / Respondent

HURLBUT

Attorneys / FirmsDANIEL J. HURLBUT

Motions

No motions recorded for this case.

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints

No eFiled documents available for this case.

Oswego Supreme Court

2012

11-1307 (0001307/2011)

Disposed

RP-Mortgage Foreclosure-Residential

ALLIANCE BANK

HURLBUT

11/21/2012

McCarthy, Hon. James W.

▼

Case Info

Court

Oswego Supreme Court

Index Number

11-1307 (0001307/2011)

Status

Disposed

Year Filed

2012

Case Name

ALLIANCE BANK vs. HURLBUT

Case Type

RP-Mortgage Foreclosure-Residential

Track

Standard

RJI Filed

02/01/2012

NOI Due

01/31/2013

NOI Filed

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

McCarthy, Hon. James W.

Next Appearance

11/21/2012

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

ALLIANCE BANK

Attorney / Firm

Defendant / Respondent

HURLBUT

Attorneys / Firms

Motions (3)

#	Date Filed	Relief Sought	Submit Date	Answer	Status	Order Signed
3	10/26/2012	Other	11/21/2012	No	Decided: 11/21/2012 Decided Before Justice: McCarthy, Hon. James W.	11/21/2012
2	06/13/2012	Other	07/05/2012	No	Decided: 07/05/2012 Decided Before Justice: McCarthy, Hon. James W.	07/05/2012
1	02/01/2012	Other	06/07/2012	No	Decided: 06/07/2012 Decided Before Justice: McCarthy, Hon. James W.	06/07/2012

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints

No eFiled documents available for this case.

St. Lawrence Supreme Court

2011

134907 (0134907/2011)

Disposed

OTHER

TWIN RIVERS FEDERAL CREDIT UNION

CHANDLER, FLOYD J

HURLBUT, BRIAN M., JR., AND RACHAEL

03/07/2014

HON DAVID DEMAREST

▼

Case Info

Court

St. Lawrence Supreme Court

Index Number

134907 (0134907/2011)

Status

Disposed

Year Filed

2011

Case Name

TWIN RIVERS FEDERAL CREDIT UNION vs. HURLBUT, BRIAN M., JR., AND RACHAEL

Case Type

OTHER

Track

Standard

RJI Filed

02/23/2011

NOI Due

NOI Filed

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

HON DAVID DEMAREST

Next Appearance

03/07/2014

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

TWIN RIVERS FEDERAL CREDIT UNION

Attorney / FirmCHANDLER, FLOYD J

Defendant / Respondent

HURLBUT, BRIAN M., JR., AND RACHAEL

Attorneys / Firms

Motions (1)

#	Date Filed	Filed By	Relief Sought	Submit Date	Answer	Status	Decision	Order Signed
1	03/03/2014	Plaintiff	OSC - RELIEF FROM DEFENDANT JU	03/07/2014	No	Decided: 03/07/2014 GRANTED Before Justice: HON DAVID DEMAREST	Other

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints

No eFiled documents available for this case.

Monroe Supreme Court

2011

2009/11019 (0011019/2009)

Disposed

COMMERCIAL DIV-CONTRACT CASES

THE HURLBUT LLC

HARTER SECREST & EMERY ESQS

CHARLES BERTINO AND KATHLEEN BERTINO

FERO PILATO & INGERSOLL ESQS

04/30/2013

HON. MATTHEW A. ROSENBAUM

▼

Case Info

Court

Monroe Supreme Court

Index Number

2009/11019 (0011019/2009)

Status

Disposed

Year Filed

2011

Case Name

THE HURLBUT LLC vs. CHARLES BERTINO AND KATHLEEN BERTINO

Case Type

COMMERCIAL DIV-CONTRACT CASES

Track

Standard

RJI Filed

04/19/2011

NOI Due

NOI Filed

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

HON. MATTHEW A. ROSENBAUM

Next Appearance

04/30/2013

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

THE HURLBUT LLC

Attorney / FirmHARTER SECREST & EMERY ESQS

Defendant / Respondent

CHARLES BERTINO AND KATHLEEN BERTINO

Attorneys / FirmsFERO PILATO & INGERSOLL ESQS

Motions (3)

#	Date Filed	Filed By	Relief Sought	Submit Date	Answer	Status	Decision
3	03/27/2013	Plaintiff	STRIKE ANSWER & GRANT JUDGMENT	04/25/2013	No	Decided: 04/25/2013 MOTION GRANTED Before Justice: HON. MATTHEW A. ROSENBAUM	Other
2	01/31/2012	Plaintiff	DEFAULT JUDGMENT	03/08/2012	No	Decided: 03/12/2012 MOTION WITHDRAWN Before Justice: HON. MATTHEW A. ROSENBAUM	Other
1	08/17/2011	Defendant	SUMMARY JUDGMENT	09/13/2011	No	Decided: 09/13/2011 RSERVE DECISION - DECISION ISS Before Justice: HON. MATTHEW A. ROSENBAUM	Other

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints

No eFiled documents available for this case.

St. Lawrence Supreme Court

2010

132954 (0132954/2010)

Disposed

Foreclosure Conf Ineligible

MASSENA SAVINGS AND LOAN

PEASE, DANIEL S

HURLBUT, BRIAN M. CINDEE

06/17/2010

HON DAVID DEMAREST

▼

Case Info

Court

St. Lawrence Supreme Court

Index Number

132954 (0132954/2010)

Status

Disposed

Year Filed

2010

Case Name

MASSENA SAVINGS AND LOAN vs. HURLBUT, BRIAN M. CINDEE

Case Type

Foreclosure Conf Ineligible

Track

Standard

RJI Filed

05/27/2010

NOI Due

NOI Filed

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

HON DAVID DEMAREST

Next Appearance

06/17/2010

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

MASSENA SAVINGS AND LOAN

Attorney / FirmPEASE, DANIEL S

Defendant / Respondent

HURLBUT, BRIAN M. CINDEE

Attorneys / Firms

Motions

No motions recorded for this case.

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints

No eFiled documents available for this case.

St. Lawrence Supreme Court

2010

133853 (0133853/2010)

Disposed

Res. Foreclosure Conf Eligible

MASSENA SAVINGS AND LOAN

PEASE, DANIEL S

HURLBUT, BRIAN M., JR., RACHEAL P. HURL

COLLINS, JOHN K

05/31/2011

HON DAVID DEMAREST

▼

Case Info

Court

St. Lawrence Supreme Court

Index Number

133853 (0133853/2010)

Status

Disposed

Year Filed

2010

Case Name

MASSENA SAVINGS AND LOAN vs. HURLBUT, BRIAN M., JR., RACHEAL P. HURL

Case Type

Res. Foreclosure Conf Eligible

Track

Other

RJI Filed

11/09/2010

NOI Due

NOI Filed

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

HON DAVID DEMAREST

Next Appearance

05/31/2011

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

MASSENA SAVINGS AND LOAN

Attorney / FirmPEASE, DANIEL S

Defendant / Respondent

HURLBUT, BRIAN M., JR., RACHEAL P. HURL

Attorneys / FirmsCOLLINS, JOHN K

Motions

No motions recorded for this case.

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints

No eFiled documents available for this case.

Monroe Supreme Court

2010

2010/05005 (0005005/2010)

Disposed

COMMERCIAL DIV-CONTRACT CASES

THE HURLBUT LLC

HARTER SECREST & EMERY ESQS

MARY DORAN AND SUZANNE ALLEN

KRUK & CAMPBELL P.C.

02/17/2011

HON. KENNETH R. FISHER

▼

Case Info

Court

Monroe Supreme Court

Index Number

2010/05005 (0005005/2010)

Status

Disposed

Year Filed

2010

Case Name

THE HURLBUT LLC vs. MARY DORAN AND SUZANNE ALLEN

Case Type

COMMERCIAL DIV-CONTRACT CASES

Track

Standard

RJI Filed

09/23/2010

NOI Due

NOI Filed

Calendar Number

—

Jury Status

Justice

HON. KENNETH R. FISHER

Next Appearance

02/17/2011

Parties

Plaintiff / Petitioner

THE HURLBUT LLC

Attorney / FirmHARTER SECREST & EMERY ESQS

Defendant / Respondent

MARY DORAN AND SUZANNE ALLEN

Attorneys / FirmsKRUK & CAMPBELL P.C.

Motions (2)

#	Date Filed	Filed By	Relief Sought	Submit Date	Answer	Status	Decision	Order Signed
2	12/06/2010	Defendant	SUMMARY JUDGMENT	02/16/2011	No	Decided: 02/16/2011 DECISION RSERVED - MOTION GRAN Before Justice: HON. KENNETH R. FISHER	Other
1	09/23/2010	Defendant	DISMISS	10/27/2010	No	Decided: 10/27/2010 COURT RSERVES DECISION - MOTIO Before Justice: HON. KENNETH R. FISHER	Other

Decisions

No decisions available for this case.

Complaints

No eFiled documents available for this case.

Oneida Supreme Court

2009

CA2008-001111 (1301111/2008)

Disposed

MOTOR VEHICLE

JOHNSON,TRACY

QUATTROCCI, ROBERT

HAWKINS & HURLBUT SANITATION INC/JOHN F

HANCOCK & ESTABROOK

05/03/2011

HON. ANTHONY F. SHAHEEN

—

Oswego Supreme Court

2008

06-1856 (0001856/2006)

Disposed

OTHER REAL PROPERTY

HURLBUT

DOUGLAS M. MCRAE, ESQ.

SITZER

TIMOTHY J. KIRWAN, ESQ.

03/23/2009

HON. NORMAN W. SEITER, JR.

—

Essex Supreme Court

2008

13-2007 (0000013/2007)

Disposed

CONTRACT

WARD LUMBER COMPANY, INC.

MARTINEAU, JAMES A.

HURLBUT BRIAN D/B/A HURLBUT CONSTRU

11/20/2008

HON JAMES P. DAWSON, J.S.C.

—

Monroe Supreme Court

2008

2003/12685 (0012685/2003)

Disposed

Tort

CHARLES HEALEY, AS THE ADMINISTRATOR OF

ALEXANDER AND CATALANO

ROBERT H. HURLBUT, ROBERT W. HURLBUT

BROWN & TARANTINO

05/07/2009

HON. MATTHEW A. ROSENBAUM

—

Steuben Supreme Court

2006

92987 (0092987/2006)

Disposed

Medical Malpractice

MACHEDA

ROBERT E LAHM

HURLBUT

EDWARD L OWEN

06/28/2006

HON PETER C BRADSTREET

—

Oswego Supreme Court

2005

05-1220 (0001220/2005)

Disposed

TAX CERTIORARI

HURLBUT

DAVID S. KIMPEL, ESQ.

TOWN OF MEXICO ASSESSORS

02/17/2006

HON. JOHN J. ELLIOTT

—

St. Lawrence Supreme Court

2005

119636 (0119636/2005)

Disposed

UCMT-ABANDONMENT

HURLBUT, JOHN E.

HILL, NATASHA B

HURLBUT, SHERRY L.

SHERRY L HURLBUT

08/08/2005

HON KATHLEEN M ROGERS

—

Steuben Supreme Court

2005

90973 (0090973/2005)

Disposed

Foreclosure Conf Ineligible

HURLBUT

CHAUNCEY WATCHES

PARKS

PAUL A. ARGENTIERI

11/08/2006

HON PETER C BRADSTREET

—

St. Lawrence Supreme Court

2004

115561 (0115561/2004)

Disposed

CONTRACT

HURLBUT, BRIAN, INDIVIDUALLY AND D/B

ALMASIAN, MICHAEL V

JACKMAN, DAVID AND JUDY JA

DUPREY, MATHEW P

08/28/2006

HON DAVID DEMAREST

—

Seneca Supreme Court

2004

35482 (0035482/2004)

Disposed

TAX CERTIORARI

HURLBUT

WAYNE D WISBAUM

BOARD OF ASSESSMENT FOR TOWN OF WATERLOO

11/23/2004

HON W PATRICK FALVEY

—

Steuben Supreme Court

2004

89615 (0089615/2004)

Disposed

OTHER REAL PROPERTY

PARKS

PAUL A. ARGENTIERI

HURLBUT

CHAUNCEY WATCHES

08/19/2005

HON PETER C BRADSTREET

—

Oswego Supreme Court

2003

03-429 (0000429/2003)

Disposed

OTHER

FORD MOTOR CREDIT COMPANY

VALERIE N. SOLOMON, ESQ.

HURLBUT

06/13/2003

HON. JOHN J. ELLIOTT

—

Seneca Supreme Court

2003

34491 (0034491/2003)

Disposed

RP-Tax Certiorari

HURLBUT

BOARD OF ASSESSMENT REVIEW FOR THE TOWN

12/23/2004

Falvey, Hon. W. Patrick

—

St. Lawrence Supreme Court

2002

111025 (0111025/2002)

Disposed

UCMT-CRUEL & INHUMAN

HURLBUT, JANE T. (LASHOMB)

WELCH, JOSEPH T

HURLBUT, KENNETH B.

LEVATO, MICHAEL L

09/11/2002

HON KATHLEEN M ROGERS

—

St. Lawrence Supreme Court

2000

106530 (0106530/2000)

Disposed

Foreclosure Conf Ineligible

UNITED STATES OF AMERICA

MURPHY, GERALD N

HURLBUT, WORTH M., LEONA M. HURLBUT

PEETS, RANDY L

08/11/2003

HON DAVID DEMAREST

—

Monroe Supreme Court

1999

1999/08382 (0008382/1999)

Disposed

OTHER

JESSIE O. WOODY

JESSIE O. WOODY, PRO SE

THE HURLBUT

11/18/1999

HON. HAROLD L. GALLOWAY

—

Onondaga Supreme Court

1999

97-4694 (0004694/1997)

Disposed

OTHER

HURLBUT, HAROLD A. D/B/A HURLBUT AUTO

VALERINO, GARY J.

ZALEWSKI, MICHELLE; COOK, ROBERT JR.

02/25/2002

HON. CHARLES T. MAJOR, JHO

—

Monroe Supreme Court

1998

1998/01836 (0001836/1998)

Disposed

CONTRACT

ROBERT H. HURLBUT AND WESTFALL PARK AS

HARTER SECREST & EMERY ESQS

KENNETH R. VASILE AND FRANK C. ROMANO,

REDMOND & PARRINELLO ESQS

01/29/2001

HON. THOMAS A. STANDER

—

Monroe Supreme Court

1997

1997/02063 (0002063/1997)

Disposed

OTHER

THE TROY SAVINGS BANK

MARTIN, SHUDT, WALLACE ET AL

MARGARET M. LAZZARO, ROBERT H. HURLBUT

LEONARD RELIN, ESQ.

12/05/1997

HON. EDMUND A. CALVARUSO

—

Livingston Supreme Court

1997

692-1997 (0000692/1997)

Disposed

TAX CERTIORARI

HURLBUT

WAYNE D. WISBAUM

TOWN OF LIVONIA

02/17/1998

HON RONALD A CICORIA

—

Chemung Supreme Court

1997

97-1984 (0001984/1997)

Disposed

CONTRACT

CHEMUNG CANAL TRUST COMPANY

J. WILLIAM O'BRIEN, ESQ.

HURLBUT, EDWARD

DEFENDANT, PRO SE

10/06/1997

HON. WILLIAM N. ELLISON J.H.O.

—

Seneca Supreme Court

1996

28963 (0028963/1996)

Disposed

TAX CERTIORARI

HURLBUT

WAYNE D WISBAUM

TOWN WATERLOO

WILLIAM J KIRK

05/29/1997

HON DENNIS F BENDER

—

Erie Supreme Court

1994

0007532/1994

Disposed

FORECLOSURE - EX PARTE

FLEET REAL ESTATE FUNDING

BLOCK & COLUCCI

HURLBUT, MARK R.

THOMAS R. LOCHNER, ESQ.

11/18/1997

DAVID J. MAHONEY

—

Steuben Supreme Court

1989

61926 (0061926/1989)

Disposed

CONTRACT

NORSTAR HURLBUT

T RIEHLMAN

GARTH D HURLBUT

08/16/1989

DONALD G. PURPLE

—