Page 2 of Best Nursing Homes in Erie, PA

Why trust this guide? Our editorial team analyzed 11 nursing homes in Erie, PA using Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) data, inspection records, complaints, amenities, and facility-level details. How we rank nursing homes in PA

Reviewed by

Dr. Jordan Weiss

Last updated

Jul 2026

We analyzed

11 homes

Other senior care options in Erie:

Assisted Living Memory Care Independent Living

Avg Overall CMS Rating: 3.6/ 5The average Overall CMS Rating for all CMS-certified nursing homes in Erie, PA. Ratings combine health inspections, staffing, and quality measures, with inspections weighted most. Individual facilities can vary widely from this average.

National Average: 3.2/ 5

Avg Staffing Rating: 3.1/ 5The average Staffing Rating across all CMS-certified nursing homes in Erie, PA. Reflects nursing staff hours per resident per day (including RNs), adjusted for residents' care needs. Individual facilities can vary widely from this average.

National Average: 3.4/ 5

Avg Health Insp. Rating: 3.6/ 5The average Health Inspection Rating across all CMS-certified nursing homes in Erie, PA. Based on each facility's recent inspections and complaint investigations, weighing the number, scope, and severity of deficiencies. Individual facilities can vary widely from this average.

National Average: 3.0/ 5

Compare Nursing Homes around Erie (Metro Area)

The information below is reported by the Pennsylvania Department of Human Services and Department of Health.

CMS & PA Dept. of Health data


Presbyterian Lodge	NH AL HOS IL PC RESC SNF	Erie (Southwest Erie)	51 Facility 51 PA AVG 94 Rank #437 / 554	93.1% Facility 93.1% PA AVG 68.1 Rank #40 / 508	+37%	4.60 Facility 4.60 PA AVG 4.15 Rank #69 / 198	+64%	+11%	$0 Facility $0 PA AVG $61.2k Rank #1 / 201	-	6 Facility 6 PA AVG 31.3 Rank #36 / 196	3.0 Facility 3.0 PA AVG 4.4 Rank #67 / 196	-	48	-	71 Facility 71 PA AVG 46 Rank #134 / 667	Millcreek Manor	$5.4MFiscal year ending 09/2022These figures are from this home's most recent complete cost report — an older period than most facilities report. Compare with that in mind. Facility $5.4MFiscal year ending 09/2022These figures are from this home's most recent complete cost report — an older period than most facilities report. Compare with that in mind. PA AVG $32.8M Rank #193 / 200	$3.9MFiscal year ending 09/2022These figures are from this home's most recent complete cost report — an older period than most facilities report. Compare with that in mind. Facility $3.9MFiscal year ending 09/2022These figures are from this home's most recent complete cost report — an older period than most facilities report. Compare with that in mind. PA AVG $6.7M Rank #182 / 200	72.8%Fiscal year ending 09/2022These figures are from this home's most recent complete cost report — an older period than most facilities report. Compare with that in mind. Facility 72.8%Fiscal year ending 09/2022These figures are from this home's most recent complete cost report — an older period than most facilities report. Compare with that in mind. PA AVG 40% Rank #20 / 200	395474
Saint Mary’s at Asbury Ridge	NH AL IL MC RC SNF	Erie	164 Facility 164 PA AVG 94 Rank #40 / 554	-	-	4.97 Facility 4.97 PA AVG 4.15 Rank #43 / 198	+70%	+20%	$0 Facility $0 PA AVG $61.2k Rank #1 / 201	-	4 Facility 4 PA AVG 31.3 Rank #18 / 196	1.3 Facility 1.3 PA AVG 4.4 Rank #11 / 196	-	75	-	3 Facility 3 PA AVG 46 Rank #651 / 667	Bridget Barber	$15.5MFiscal year ending 12/2023 Facility $15.5MFiscal year ending 12/2023 PA AVG $32.8M Rank #105 / 200	$8.8MFiscal year ending 12/2023 Facility $8.8MFiscal year ending 12/2023 PA AVG $6.7M Rank #89 / 200	56.8%Fiscal year ending 12/2023 Facility 56.8%Fiscal year ending 12/2023 PA AVG 40% Rank #81 / 200	396081
Manchester Commons of Presbyterian Senior Care	NH AL	Erie	80 Facility 80 PA AVG 94 Rank #293 / 554	80.0% Facility 80.0% PA AVG 68.1 Rank #146 / 508	+17%	4.95 Facility 4.95 PA AVG 4.15 Rank #51 / 198	+13%	+19%	$0 Facility $0 PA AVG $61.2k Rank #1 / 201	88 Facility 88 PA AVG 83 Rank #162 / 460	15 Facility 15 PA AVG 31.3 Rank #89 / 196	5.0 Facility 5.0 PA AVG 4.4 Rank #134 / 196	-	64	-	48 Facility 48 PA AVG 46 Rank #303 / 667	Presbyterian Homes In The Presbytery Of Lake Erie	$14.0MFiscal year ending 12/2023 Facility $14.0MFiscal year ending 12/2023 PA AVG $32.8M Rank #120 / 200	$7.4MFiscal year ending 12/2023 Facility $7.4MFiscal year ending 12/2023 PA AVG $6.7M Rank #107 / 200	53.1%Fiscal year ending 12/2023 Facility 53.1%Fiscal year ending 12/2023 PA AVG 40% Rank #94 / 200	395996
Walnut Creek Healthcare and Rehabilitation Center	NH AL	Erie (Westwind)	115 Facility 115 PA AVG 94 Rank #152 / 554	90.4% Facility 90.4% PA AVG 68.1 Rank #57 / 508	+33%	-	+79%	-	$0 Facility $0 PA AVG $61.2k Rank #1 / 201	-	11 Facility 11 PA AVG 31.3 Rank #69 / 196	2.2 Facility 2.2 PA AVG 4.4 Rank #42 / 196	-	104	A	32 Facility 32 PA AVG 46 Rank #444 / 667	Guardian Healthcare Gol Group, LLC	$11.1MFiscal year ending 12/2023 Facility $11.1MFiscal year ending 12/2023 PA AVG $32.8M Rank #129 / 200	$5.8MFiscal year ending 12/2023 Facility $5.8MFiscal year ending 12/2023 PA AVG $6.7M Rank #152 / 200	52.6%Fiscal year ending 12/2023 Facility 52.6%Fiscal year ending 12/2023 PA AVG 40% Rank #150 / 200	395200
LECOM at Village Square	NH SNF	Erie	110 Facility 110 PA AVG 94 Rank #165 / 554	91.2% Facility 91.2% PA AVG 68.1 Rank #51 / 508	+34%	4.69 Facility 4.69 PA AVG 4.15 Rank #61 / 198	+24%	+13%	$15.0k Facility $15.0k PA AVG $61.2k Rank #157 / 201	-	21 Facility 21 PA AVG 31.3 Rank #112 / 196	5.3 Facility 5.3 PA AVG 4.4 Rank #146 / 196	1	100	-	72 Facility 72 PA AVG 46 Rank #131 / 667	Vincent Fierro	$7.6MFiscal year ending 06/2024 Facility $7.6MFiscal year ending 06/2024 PA AVG $32.8M Rank #184 / 200	$5.0MFiscal year ending 06/2024 Facility $5.0MFiscal year ending 06/2024 PA AVG $6.7M Rank #175 / 200	66.2%Fiscal year ending 06/2024 Facility 66.2%Fiscal year ending 06/2024 PA AVG 40% Rank #38 / 200	395672
Nightingale Nursing and Rehab Center	NH AL	Erie (Southeast Erie)	117 Facility 117 PA AVG 94 Rank #150 / 554	-	-	4.00 Facility 4.00 PA AVG 4.15 Rank #118 / 198	-7%	-4%	$0 Facility $0 PA AVG $61.2k Rank #1 / 201	81 Facility 81 PA AVG 83 Rank #274 / 460	14 Facility 14 PA AVG 31.3 Rank #84 / 196	2.8 Facility 2.8 PA AVG 4.4 Rank #61 / 196	-	14	-	71 Facility 71 PA AVG 46 Rank #134 / 667	Erie Snf Operations Holdings LLC	$14.9MFiscal year ending 12/2023 Facility $14.9MFiscal year ending 12/2023 PA AVG $32.8M Rank #92 / 200	$7.9MFiscal year ending 12/2023 Facility $7.9MFiscal year ending 12/2023 PA AVG $6.7M Rank #112 / 200	52.8%Fiscal year ending 12/2023 Facility 52.8%Fiscal year ending 12/2023 PA AVG 40% Rank #154 / 200	395042
Pennsylvania Soldiers‘ and Sailors‘ Home	NH AL	Erie	107 Facility 107 PA AVG 94 Rank #179 / 554	96.0% Facility 96.0% PA AVG 68.1 Rank #15 / 508	+41%	7.67 Facility 7.67 PA AVG 4.15 Rank #1 / 198	-	+85%	$176.3k Facility $176.3k PA AVG $61.2k Rank #197 / 201	-	-	-	-	103	-	44 Facility 44 PA AVG 46 Rank #349 / 667	-	-	-	-	39A434
Greenfield Health and Rehabilitation	NH HOS PC RC SNF	Erie	133 Facility 133 PA AVG 94 Rank #85 / 554	50.4% Facility 50.4% PA AVG 68.1 Rank #420 / 508	-26%	3.22 Facility 3.22 PA AVG 4.15 Rank #190 / 198	-12%	-22%	$0 Facility $0 PA AVG $61.2k Rank #1 / 201	-	42 Facility 42 PA AVG 31.3 Rank #155 / 196	3.2 Facility 3.2 PA AVG 4.4 Rank #79 / 196	-	67	-	51 Facility 51 PA AVG 46 Rank #274 / 667	-	$6.6MFiscal year ending 12/2022These figures are from this home's most recent complete cost report — an older period than most facilities report. Compare with that in mind. Facility $6.6MFiscal year ending 12/2022These figures are from this home's most recent complete cost report — an older period than most facilities report. Compare with that in mind. PA AVG $32.8M Rank #177 / 200	$3.7MFiscal year ending 12/2022These figures are from this home's most recent complete cost report — an older period than most facilities report. Compare with that in mind. Facility $3.7MFiscal year ending 12/2022These figures are from this home's most recent complete cost report — an older period than most facilities report. Compare with that in mind. PA AVG $6.7M Rank #193 / 200	55.6%Fiscal year ending 12/2022These figures are from this home's most recent complete cost report — an older period than most facilities report. Compare with that in mind. Facility 55.6%Fiscal year ending 12/2022These figures are from this home's most recent complete cost report — an older period than most facilities report. Compare with that in mind. PA AVG 40% Rank #141 / 200	395262

Nursing Home Explorer

Explore open rooms

Overview of Asbury Springhill

Asbury Springhill provides independent living, assisted living, memory care, and nursing care services for seniors in Erie. The community provides high-quality senior care that allows residents to stay active and maintain individuality; they ensure that residents live their best lives by creating an environment that cultivates personal growth and blossoming friendships in a cozy setting.
Asbury Springhill lets us residents expect more with the benefits they receive during their stay. They have provided individualized care plans with programs and services that are flexible for comfort and stability. They provide 24-hour licensed support by a team of professional and compassionate care staff, beautiful and thoughtfully designed interiors, and specialized programming for holistic wellness.

Share This Listing

« Previous 1 2

Ranking Methodology

How we rank these nursing homes

Every nursing home above is evaluated across five weighted categories using CMS data including Care Compare, Payroll-Based Journal, and Medicare Cost Reports.

CMS data
5 weighted categories
Updated quarterly

Full methodology

Weighting overview

35%
Care Quality
20%
Staffing
20%
Regulatory
20%
Operational
5%
Environment

Care Quality 35%

The largest single share of every ranking. CMS star ratings and quality measures that reflect actual care delivered to residents.

Includes
Overall Rating
Health Inspection
QM Rating
Long-Stay QM
Short-Stay QM

Staffing Adequacy 20%

The strongest predictor of resident outcomes. Volume and stability of nursing care, drawn from CMS Payroll-Based Journal.

Includes
Nurse Hrs/Res/Day
RN vs State
Total Nurse Staff Hrs vs State
RN Turnover

Regulatory & Safety Record 20%

Inspection patterns that star ratings can mask. We weight per-inspection rates more heavily than raw counts.

Includes
Citations
Citations/Inspection
Severe Citations
Fines
Accreditations

Operational & Financial Stability 20%

Stable operations and sound finances are leading indicators of consistent care over time.

Includes
Occupancy vs State
Avg Length of Stay
Revenue
Payroll %
Years in Operation
Admin Tenure

Environment & Accessibility 5%

Context that matters to families but doesn't directly measure clinical care. Weighted lower for nursing homes than for assisted or independent living.

Includes
Walk Score
BBB Rating

Who we are

Your Senior Care Partner, Every Step of the Way

We help families find affordable senior communities and unlock same day discounts, Medicaid, and Medicare options tailored to your needs.

What's the difference between assisted living and a nursing home in Pennsylvania?

Assisted living in Pennsylvania is a residential model focused on housing, hospitality, and help with daily activities. Nursing homes (skilled nursing facilities) provide 24/7 medical care from licensed nurses for residents with significant health needs, and are regulated more strictly under both state and federal CMS rules.

Does Pennsylvania Medicaid cover nursing home care?

Yes — Pennsylvania Medicaid covers nursing home care for residents who meet income, asset, and medical-need eligibility requirements. Most CMS-certified nursing homes accept Medicaid as a primary payer once long-term-care eligibility is established.

What is nursing home care?

Nursing homes (also called skilled nursing facilities) provide 24/7 medical care from licensed nurses, rehabilitation services, and long-term custodial care for residents with significant health or functional needs.

How many nursing homes are listed on this page?

This page features 11 nursing homes in Erie, PA. Use the filters and comparison tools above to compare ratings, amenities, and pricing.

How do I choose the right nursing home in Erie, PA?

Start by matching the level of care offered to the resident's current and anticipated needs, then compare licensing status, staff-to-resident ratios, recent inspection results, and pricing. Tour at least two or three communities in Erie, PA, talk to current residents and families, and confirm what is included in the base rate versus billed as add-on services.

What should I look for when visiting nursing homes in Erie, PA?

Pay attention to staff interactions with residents, cleanliness and odor, food quality at meal times, the activity calendar, and how questions about pricing and care plans are answered. Ask to see the most recent state inspection report, the move-out / level-of-care-change policy, and a sample monthly bill that lists every fee.