Stipulation Extending Time to Answer, Move or Otherwise Respond to the Complaint
Elizabeth Frances Lorell
5
10/27/2025
ANSWER
Defendants' Answer to Plaintiff's Complaint and Separate Defenses
Elizabeth Frances Lorell
6
01/22/2026
RJI -RE: REQUEST FOR PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE
Peter Douglas Valenzano
7
02/26/2026
ORDER - PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE
Thomas Gilmore
2
Bronx Supreme Court
2026
819994/2025E
Active
Medical Malpractice
BAEZ, SANTA
ADAMS LAW FIRM, P.C.
PREMIER HOME HEALTH CARE SERVICES, INC.
GARSON JAKUB & MORRIS, LLP
03/06/2026
Gerez, Hon. Alicia
▼
Case Info
Court
Bronx Supreme Court
Index Number
819994/2025E
Status
Active
Year Filed
2026
Case Name
BAEZ, SANTA vs. PREMIER HOME HEALTH CARE SERVICES, INC.
Case Type
Tort-Medical, Dental, or Podiatric Malpractice
Track
Complex
RJI Filed
02/03/2026
NOI Due
05/07/2027
NOI Filed
Calendar Number
—
Jury Status
Justice
Gerez, Hon. Alicia
Next Appearance
03/06/2026
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
BAEZ, SANTA
Attorney / FirmADAMS LAW FIRM, P.C.
Defendant / Respondent
PREMIER HOME HEALTH CARE SERVICES, INC.
Attorneys / FirmsGARSON JAKUB & MORRIS, LLP
Motions (2)
#
Date Filed
Filed By
Relief Sought
Submit Date
Answer
Status
Decision
Order Signed
2
02/03/2026
Amend Caption/Pleadings
03/06/2026
No
Before Justice: Gerez, Hon. Alicia
1
02/03/2026
Dismiss
02/19/2026
No
Before Justice: Gerez, Hon. Alicia
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (16)
Doc #
Date Filed
Document
Description
Motion #
Filing User
File
1
09/20/2025
SUMMONS + COMPLAINT
Jeffrey M Adams
2
12/30/2025
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
Jeffrey M Adams
3
01/23/2026
NOTICE OF MOTION
1
Andrew Macleod Harrison
4
01/23/2026
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION
1
Andrew Macleod Harrison
5
01/23/2026
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
1
Andrew Macleod Harrison
6
01/23/2026
RJI -RE: NOTICE OF MOTION
1
Andrew Macleod Harrison
7
01/31/2026
PROOF OF SERVICE
Notice of Commencement of Action CPLR 306-C
Jeffrey M Adams
8
02/03/2026
COMPLAINT (AMENDED)
Jeffrey M Adams
9
02/03/2026
NOTICE OF MOTION
2
Jeffrey M Adams
10
02/03/2026
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION
2
Jeffrey M Adams
11
02/03/2026
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION
1
Jeffrey M Adams
12
02/03/2026
EXHIBIT(S)
power of attorney
1
Jeffrey M Adams
13
02/18/2026
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN REPLY
1
Andrew Macleod Harrison
14
02/18/2026
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION
2
Andrew Macleod Harrison
15
02/18/2026
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN REPLY
and in Opposition
1
Jeffrey M Adams
16
02/18/2026
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN REPLY
and in Opposition
2
Jeffrey M Adams
3
New York Supreme Court
2023
161377/2023
Disposed
SP-CPLR Article 78 (Body or Officer)
BARELE, INC. d/b/a OMEGA HOME HEALTH CARE et al
Nixon Peabody LLP
CONTRACT DISPUTE RESOLUTION BOARD OF THE CITY OF NEW YORK et al
CONTRACT DISPUTE RESOLUTION BOARD OF THE CITY OF NEW YORK
01/26/2024
Moyne, Hon. Nicholas W.
▼
Case Info
Court
New York Supreme Court
Index Number
161377/2023
Status
Disposed
Year Filed
2023
Case Name
BARELE, INC. d/b/a OMEGA HOME HEALTH CARE et al vs. CONTRACT DISPUTE RESOLUTION BOARD OF THE CITY OF NEW YORK et al
Case Type
SP-CPLR Article 78 (Body or Officer)
Track
Standard
RJI Filed
11/20/2023
NOI Due
11/19/2024
NOI Filed
Calendar Number
—
Jury Status
Justice
Moyne, Hon. Nicholas W.
Next Appearance
01/26/2024
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
BARELE, INC. d/b/a OMEGA HOME HEALTH CARE et al
Attorney / FirmNixon Peabody LLP
Defendant / Respondent
CONTRACT DISPUTE RESOLUTION BOARD OF THE CITY OF NEW YORK et al
Attorneys / FirmsCONTRACT DISPUTE RESOLUTION BOARD OF THE CITY OF NEW YORK
Motions (1)
#
Date Filed
Filed By
Relief Sought
Submit Date
Answer
Status
Decision
Order Signed
1
11/20/2023
Article 78 (Body or Officer)
01/08/2024
No
Decided: 01/08/2024 Decided Before Justice: Moyne, Hon. Nicholas W.
Short Form Order
01/08/2024
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (41)
Doc #
Date Filed
Document
Description
Motion #
Filing User
File
1
11/20/2023
PETITION
Verified Petition
Justin Daniel Pfeiffer
2
11/20/2023
NOTICE OF PETITION
Notice of Petition Under Article 78
001
Justin Daniel Pfeiffer
3
11/20/2023
AFFIRMATION
Affirmation of Philip Rosenberg
Justin Daniel Pfeiffer
4
11/20/2023
EXHIBIT(S)
CDRB's Decision
Justin Daniel Pfeiffer
5
11/20/2023
EXHIBIT(S)
Home Attendant Agreement between HRA and Petitioner Barele
Justin Daniel Pfeiffer
6
11/20/2023
EXHIBIT(S)
Home Attendant Agreement between HRA and Petitioner Premier
Justin Daniel Pfeiffer
7
11/20/2023
EXHIBIT(S)
Closeout and funds recovery analysis letter from HRA dated October 20, 2008
Justin Daniel Pfeiffer
8
11/20/2023
EXHIBIT(S)
Closeout and funds recovery analysis letter from HRA dated October 20, 2008
Justin Daniel Pfeiffer
9
11/20/2023
EXHIBIT(S)
HCRA MOU
Justin Daniel Pfeiffer
10
11/20/2023
EXHIBIT(S)
Letter dated November 12, 2008
Justin Daniel Pfeiffer
11
11/20/2023
EXHIBIT(S)
Letter dated November 12, 2008
Justin Daniel Pfeiffer
12
11/20/2023
EXHIBIT(S)
Letter dated February 24, 2009
Justin Daniel Pfeiffer
13
11/20/2023
EXHIBIT(S)
Appeal Determination Letters from HRA's Attorney dated March 24, 2009
Justin Daniel Pfeiffer
14
11/20/2023
EXHIBIT(S)
Appeal Determination Letters from HRA's Attorney dated March 24, 2009
Justin Daniel Pfeiffer
15
11/20/2023
EXHIBIT(S)
Petitioners' Notices of Dispute dated April 24, 2009
Justin Daniel Pfeiffer
16
11/20/2023
EXHIBIT(S)
Petitioners' Notices of Dispute dated April 24, 2009
Justin Daniel Pfeiffer
17
11/20/2023
EXHIBIT(S)
Letter dated October 5, 2009
Justin Daniel Pfeiffer
18
11/20/2023
EXHIBIT(S)
Letter dated October 5, 2009
Justin Daniel Pfeiffer
19
11/20/2023
EXHIBIT(S)
Letter dated November 4, 2009
Justin Daniel Pfeiffer
20
11/20/2023
EXHIBIT(S)
Letter dated November 4, 2009
Justin Daniel Pfeiffer
21
11/20/2023
EXHIBIT(S)
HRA's letter dated May 5, 2010
Justin Daniel Pfeiffer
22
11/20/2023
EXHIBIT(S)
Notice of Claim dated July 9, 2010
Justin Daniel Pfeiffer
23
11/20/2023
EXHIBIT(S)
Notice of Claim dated July 9, 2010
Justin Daniel Pfeiffer
24
11/20/2023
EXHIBIT(S)
Determination of Comptroller of the City of New York dated November 30, 2010
Justin Daniel Pfeiffer
25
11/20/2023
EXHIBIT(S)
Determination of Comptroller of the City of New York dated April 26, 2011
Justin Daniel Pfeiffer
26
11/20/2023
EXHIBIT(S)
Barele's Petition to CDRB
Justin Daniel Pfeiffer
27
11/20/2023
EXHIBIT(S)
Premier's Petition to CDRB
Justin Daniel Pfeiffer
28
11/20/2023
EXHIBIT(S)
Lockstep agreement
Justin Daniel Pfeiffer
29
11/20/2023
EXHIBIT(S)
HRA's Joint Response
Justin Daniel Pfeiffer
30
11/20/2023
EXHIBIT(S)
Petitioner's Consolidated Reply
Justin Daniel Pfeiffer
31
11/20/2023
EXHIBIT(S)
CDRB letter requesting supplemental briefing
Justin Daniel Pfeiffer
32
11/20/2023
EXHIBIT(S)
Petitioner's Supplemental Brief
Justin Daniel Pfeiffer
33
11/20/2023
EXHIBIT(S)
HRA's Response to Petitioner's Supplemental Brief
Justin Daniel Pfeiffer
34
11/20/2023
MEMORANDUM OF LAW
Petitioner's Memorandum of Law in Support of Article 78 Petition
Justin Daniel Pfeiffer
35
11/20/2023
RJI -RE: NOTICE OF PETITION
Justin Daniel Pfeiffer
36
11/20/2023
ADDENDUM - GENERAL (840A)
Justin Daniel Pfeiffer
37
12/27/2023
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
Affidavit of Service of Art. 78 Petition and supporting papers upon Contract Dispute Resolution Board of the City of New York
001
Justin Daniel Pfeiffer
38
12/28/2023
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
Affidavit of Service of Art. 78 Petition and supporting papers upon The City of New York and the New York City Human Resources Administration
001
Justin Daniel Pfeiffer
39
01/04/2024
NOTICE OF WITHDRAWAL OF MOTION / ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE - IN SUBMISSIONS PART - RM 130
Notice of Withdrawal of Notice of Petition in Submissions Part - Room 130
001
Justin Daniel Pfeiffer
40
01/04/2024
NOTICE OF DISCONTINUANCE (POST RJI)
Notice of Voluntary Discontinuance
Justin Daniel Pfeiffer
41
01/08/2024
DECISION + ORDER ON MOTION
001
Michael Chu
4
New York Supreme Court
2023
161310/2023
Disposed
SP-CPLR Article 78 (Body or Officer)
Barele, Inc. et al
Nixon Peabody LLP
Contract Dispute Resolution Board of the City of New York et al
Contract Dispute Resolution Board of the City of New York
02/16/2024
Bluth, Hon. Arlene P.
▼
Case Info
Court
New York Supreme Court
Index Number
161310/2023
Status
Disposed
Year Filed
2023
Case Name
Barele, Inc. et al vs. Contract Dispute Resolution Board of the City of New York et al
Case Type
SP-CPLR Article 78 (Body or Officer)
Track
Standard
RJI Filed
11/21/2023
NOI Due
11/20/2024
NOI Filed
Calendar Number
—
Jury Status
Justice
Bluth, Hon. Arlene P.
Next Appearance
02/16/2024
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
Barele, Inc. et al
Attorney / FirmNixon Peabody LLP
Defendant / Respondent
Contract Dispute Resolution Board of the City of New York et al
Attorneys / FirmsContract Dispute Resolution Board of the City of New York
Motions (1)
#
Date Filed
Filed By
Relief Sought
Submit Date
Answer
Status
Decision
Order Signed
1
11/21/2023
Article 78 (Body or Officer)
02/16/2024
No
Decided: 02/20/2024 Decided Before Justice: Bluth, Hon. Arlene P.
Short Form Order
02/20/2024
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (48)
Doc #
Date Filed
Document
Description
Motion #
Filing User
File
1
11/16/2023
PETITION
Verified Petition under CPLR Art. 78
Justin Daniel Pfeiffer
2
11/16/2023
MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN SUPPORT
Memorandum of Law in support of Verified Petition
Justin Daniel Pfeiffer
3
11/16/2023
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT
Attorney Affirmation in support of Verified Petition
Justin Daniel Pfeiffer
4
11/16/2023
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex A to Affirmation
Justin Daniel Pfeiffer
5
11/16/2023
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex B to Affirmation
Justin Daniel Pfeiffer
6
11/16/2023
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex C to Affirmation
Justin Daniel Pfeiffer
7
11/16/2023
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex D to Affirmation
Justin Daniel Pfeiffer
8
11/16/2023
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex E to Affirmation
Justin Daniel Pfeiffer
9
11/16/2023
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex F to Affirmation
Justin Daniel Pfeiffer
10
11/16/2023
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex G to Affirmation
Justin Daniel Pfeiffer
11
11/16/2023
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex H to Affirmation
Justin Daniel Pfeiffer
12
11/16/2023
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex I to Affirmation
Justin Daniel Pfeiffer
13
11/16/2023
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex J to Affirmation
Justin Daniel Pfeiffer
14
11/16/2023
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex K to Affirmation
Justin Daniel Pfeiffer
15
11/16/2023
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex L to Affirmation
Justin Daniel Pfeiffer
16
11/16/2023
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex M to Affirmation
Justin Daniel Pfeiffer
17
11/16/2023
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex N to Affirmation
Justin Daniel Pfeiffer
18
11/16/2023
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex O to Affirmation
Justin Daniel Pfeiffer
19
11/16/2023
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex P to Affirmation
Justin Daniel Pfeiffer
20
11/16/2023
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex Q to Affirmation
Justin Daniel Pfeiffer
21
11/16/2023
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex R to Affirmation
Justin Daniel Pfeiffer
22
11/16/2023
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex S to Affirmation
Justin Daniel Pfeiffer
23
11/16/2023
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex T to Affirmation
Justin Daniel Pfeiffer
24
11/16/2023
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex U to Affirmation
Justin Daniel Pfeiffer
25
11/16/2023
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex V to Affirmation
Justin Daniel Pfeiffer
26
11/16/2023
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex W to Affirmation
Justin Daniel Pfeiffer
27
11/16/2023
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex X to Affirmation
Justin Daniel Pfeiffer
28
11/16/2023
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex Y to Affirmation
Justin Daniel Pfeiffer
29
11/16/2023
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex Z to Affirmation
Justin Daniel Pfeiffer
30
11/16/2023
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex AA to Affirmation
Justin Daniel Pfeiffer
31
11/16/2023
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex BB to Affirmation
Justin Daniel Pfeiffer
32
11/16/2023
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex CC to Affirmation
Justin Daniel Pfeiffer
33
11/16/2023
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex DD to Affirmation
Justin Daniel Pfeiffer
34
11/21/2023
NOTICE OF PETITION ACCOMPANYING COMMENCEMENT DOC(S)
Notice of Verified Petition under Article 78
001
Justin Daniel Pfeiffer
35
11/21/2023
RJI -RE: NOTICE OF PETITION
001
Justin Daniel Pfeiffer
36
01/03/2024
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
Affidavit of Service of Article 78 Petition and supporting papers upon respondents City of New York and NYC Human Resources Administration
001
Justin Daniel Pfeiffer
37
01/03/2024
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
Affidavit of Service of Article 78 Petition and supporting papers upon respondent Contract Dispute Resolution Board
001
Justin Daniel Pfeiffer
38
01/04/2024
STIPULATION - TIME TO ANSWER
Stipulation Extending Respondents' Time to Respond to Art. 78 Petition
001
Justin Daniel Pfeiffer
39
01/16/2024
ANSWER IN SPECIAL PROCEEDING
CDRB Answer
Frank Kun Ng
40
01/16/2024
EXHIBIT(S)
CDRB Decision
Frank Kun Ng
41
01/25/2024
ANSWER IN SPECIAL PROCEEDING
001
Margaret Amanda Devoe
42
01/25/2024
EXHIBIT(S)
April 15, 2005 Letter
001
Margaret Amanda Devoe
43
01/25/2024
EXHIBIT(S)
October 27, 2017 Email Chain
001
Margaret Amanda Devoe
44
01/25/2024
MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN SUPPORT
Memorandum of Law in Support of the Answer and in Opposition to the Petition
001
Margaret Amanda Devoe
45
01/25/2024
NOTICE OF APPEARANCE (POST RJI)
Notice of Appearance of Philip Rosenberg, Esq.
Philip E. Rosenberg
46
02/14/2024
MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN REPLY
Reply Memorandum of Law in further support of Art. 78 Petition
001
Justin Daniel Pfeiffer
47
02/23/2024
DECISION + ORDER ON MOTION
001
Gail N Redd
48
02/26/2024
NOTICE OF ENTRY
001
Margaret Amanda Devoe
5
Westchester Supreme Court
2023
67127/2023
Disposed
Comm-Contract
Perez, Cesar
DEREK SMITH LAW GROUP, PLLC
PREMIER HOME HEALTH CARE SERVICES, INC.
GREENBERG TRAURIG, LLP
08/16/2024
Walsh, Hon. Gretchen
▼
Case Info
Court
Westchester Supreme Court
Index Number
67127/2023
Status
Disposed
Year Filed
2023
Case Name
Perez, Cesar vs. PREMIER HOME HEALTH CARE SERVICES, INC.
Case Type
Comm-Contract
Track
Extended Track
RJI Filed
11/29/2023
NOI Due
07/21/2025
NOI Filed
Calendar Number
—
Jury Status
Justice
Walsh, Hon. Gretchen
Next Appearance
08/16/2024
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
Perez, Cesar
Attorney / FirmDEREK SMITH LAW GROUP, PLLC
Defendant / Respondent
PREMIER HOME HEALTH CARE SERVICES, INC.
Attorneys / FirmsGREENBERG TRAURIG, LLP
Motions (2)
#
Date Filed
Filed By
Relief Sought
Submit Date
Answer
Status
Decision
Order Signed
2
03/29/2024
Judgment - Summary
05/10/2024
No
Decided: 08/07/2024 Decided Before Justice: Walsh, Hon. Gretchen
Short Form Order
1
11/29/2023
Dismiss
02/23/2024
No
Decided: 02/23/2024 Decided Before Justice: Walsh, Hon. Gretchen
Short Form Order
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (48)
Doc #
Date Filed
Document
Description
Motion #
Filing User
File
1
09/20/2023
SUMMONS + COMPLAINT
Danilo Bandovic
2
09/29/2023
STIPULATION - TIME TO ANSWER
Nicholas Anthony Corsano
3
11/29/2023
NOTICE OF MOTION
1
Jerrold Foster Goldberg
4
11/29/2023
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION
1
Jerrold Foster Goldberg
5
11/29/2023
EXHIBIT(S)
Complaint
1
Jerrold Foster Goldberg
6
11/29/2023
MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN SUPPORT
1
Jerrold Foster Goldberg
7
11/29/2023
RJI -RE: NOTICE OF MOTION
1
Jerrold Foster Goldberg
8
11/29/2023
ADDENDUM - COMMERCIAL DIVISION (840C)
1
Jerrold Foster Goldberg
9
12/11/2023
NOTIFICATION FROM COURT
Preliminary Conference Appearance Notice
Heather Lorenzen
10
12/20/2023
ORDER - PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE
Elijah Newcomb
11
02/22/2024
COMPLAINT (AMENDED)
Danilo Bandovic
12
02/23/2024
DECISION + ORDER ON MOTION
1
Elijah Newcomb
13
03/05/2024
ANSWER
Verified Answer with Affirmative Defenses and Certificate of Service
Jerrold Foster Goldberg
14
03/29/2024
NOTICE OF MOTION
2
Jerrold Foster Goldberg
15
03/29/2024
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION
2
Jerrold Foster Goldberg
16
03/29/2024
EXHIBIT(S)
Amended Complaint
2
Jerrold Foster Goldberg
17
03/29/2024
EXHIBIT(S)
Verified Answer
2
Jerrold Foster Goldberg
18
03/29/2024
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION
2
Jerrold Foster Goldberg
19
03/29/2024
EXHIBIT(S)
Employment Agreement
2
Jerrold Foster Goldberg
20
03/29/2024
EXHIBIT(S)
Nov. 8, 2022 Email
2
Jerrold Foster Goldberg
21
03/29/2024
EXHIBIT(S)
Nov. 11, 2022 Email
2
Jerrold Foster Goldberg
22
03/29/2024
EXHIBIT(S)
Nov. 28, 2022 Email
2
Jerrold Foster Goldberg
23
03/29/2024
EXHIBIT(S)
Dec. 14, 2022 Email
2
Jerrold Foster Goldberg
24
03/29/2024
EXHIBIT(S)
Oct. 14-Dec. 21, 2022 Email
2
Jerrold Foster Goldberg
25
03/29/2024
EXHIBIT(S)
Dec. 2022 Calendar
2
Jerrold Foster Goldberg
26
03/29/2024
EXHIBIT(S)
Nov. 28 Notice
2
Jerrold Foster Goldberg
27
03/29/2024
EXHIBIT(S)
Dec. 1, 2022 Email
2
Jerrold Foster Goldberg
28
03/29/2024
EXHIBIT(S)
Dec. 8, 2022 Email
2
Jerrold Foster Goldberg
29
03/29/2024
EXHIBIT(S)
Pay Statements
2
Jerrold Foster Goldberg
30
03/29/2024
EXHIBIT(S)
Expense Reports
2
Jerrold Foster Goldberg
31
03/29/2024
STATEMENT OF MATERIAL FACTS
2
Jerrold Foster Goldberg
32
03/29/2024
MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN SUPPORT
2
Jerrold Foster Goldberg
33
04/30/2024
AFFIRMATION
Affirmation of Danilo Bandovic
2
Danilo Bandovic
34
04/30/2024
MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN OPPOSITION
MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN SUPPORT OF PLAINTIFFS OPPOSITION TO DEFENDANTS MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT
2
Danilo Bandovic
35
04/30/2024
RESPONSE TO STATEMENT OF MATERIAL FACTS
PLAINTIFFS RESPONSE TO DEFENDANTS STATEMENT OF MATERIAL FACTS
2
Danilo Bandovic
36
04/30/2024
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION
Affirmation of Plaintiff Cesar Perez
2
Danilo Bandovic
37
04/30/2024
EXHIBIT(S)
Employment Agreement
2
Danilo Bandovic
38
04/30/2024
EXHIBIT(S)
Fed Court Filing and Transcript - Blackstone
2
Danilo Bandovic
39
04/30/2024
EXHIBIT(S)
November 28 Termination Letter
2
Danilo Bandovic
40
04/30/2024
EXHIBIT(S)
Email to Blackstone Regarding Hearing
2
Danilo Bandovic
41
04/30/2024
EXHIBIT(S)
Email to Arbitrator Martin Scheinman
2
Danilo Bandovic
42
04/30/2024
EXHIBIT(S)
Premier Org Chart September 2021
2
Danilo Bandovic
43
04/30/2024
EXHIBIT(S)
Email Thread Between Mr. Schwabe and Mr. Perez
2
Danilo Bandovic
44
05/01/2024
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION
Supplemental Corrected Affidavit of Cesar Perez
2
Danilo Bandovic
45
05/09/2024
MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN REPLY
2
Nicholas Anthony Corsano
46
08/08/2024
DECISION + ORDER ON MOTION
2
Elijah Newcomb
47
08/08/2024
NOTICE OF ENTRY
Notice of Entry re: the Decision and Order
2
Nicholas Anthony Corsano
48
08/21/2024
NOTICE OF APPEAL/INFORMATIONAL STATEMENT/COPY OF ORDER/PROOF OF SERVICE
Danilo Bandovic
6
Bronx Supreme Court
2023
806254/2023E
Active
Negligence
Aikens, Cynthia
Sobo & Sobo
Premier Home Health Care Services, Inc. et al
MARTIN CLEARWATER & BELL, LLP
07/06/2026
Hummel, Hon. Veronica G.
▼
Case Info
Court
Bronx Supreme Court
Index Number
806254/2023E
Status
Active
Year Filed
2023
Case Name
Aikens, Cynthia vs. Premier Home Health Care Services, Inc. et al
Case Type
Tort-Other Negligence
Track
Standard
RJI Filed
08/21/2023
NOI Due
08/20/2024
NOI Filed
Calendar Number
—
Jury Status
Justice
Hummel, Hon. Veronica G.
Next Appearance
07/06/2026
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
Aikens, Cynthia
Attorney / FirmSobo & Sobo
Defendant / Respondent
Premier Home Health Care Services, Inc. et al
Attorneys / FirmsMARTIN CLEARWATER & BELL, LLP
Motions
No motions recorded for this case.
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (15)
Doc #
Date Filed
Document
Description
Motion #
Filing User
File
1
04/20/2023
SUMMONS + COMPLAINT
Gregory Marc Sobo
2
04/27/2023
AFFIDAVIT
Gregory Marc Sobo
3
06/30/2023
ANSWER
PREMIER HOME HEALTH CARE SERVICES, INC.
Conrad Aloysius Chayes
4
08/21/2023
RJI -RE: REQUEST FOR PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE
Gregory Marc Sobo
5
09/05/2023
ORDER - PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE
PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE ORDER AND CASE SCHEDULING ORDER DATED 09/01/2023
Michelle Alemany
6
11/17/2023
RESPONSE TO DEMAND
Ryan Thompson
7
11/17/2023
RESPONSE TO DEMAND
Ryan Thompson
8
11/17/2023
BILL OF PARTICULARS
Ryan Thompson
9
12/05/2023
ORDER - CASE SCHEDULING
Compliance Conference Scheduling Order
Amina Martin
10
01/08/2024
ORDER - CASE SCHEDULING
Compliance Conference Scheduling Order
Amina Martin
11
10/28/2024
DEMAND FOR:
AUTHORIZATIONS
Daniel Borbet
12
08/14/2025
STIPULATION - OTHER
STIPULATION
Lissette Rodriguez
13
11/14/2025
DEMAND FOR:
Authorizations
Daniel Borbet
14
11/14/2025
NOTICE OF DEPOSITION UPON ORAL EXAMINATION
Daniel Borbet
15
04/17/2026
DEMAND FOR:
Authorizations
Daniel Borbet
7
Bronx Supreme Court
2023
808149/2023E
Active
Medical Malpractice
Grisel Santiago as Administrator of the Estate of Carmen Santiago
Dalli & Marino, LLP
Premier Home Health Care Services, Inc. et al
Garson Jakub & Morris LLP
08/04/2026
Gerez, Hon. Alicia
▼
Case Info
Court
Bronx Supreme Court
Index Number
808149/2023E
Status
Active
Year Filed
2023
Case Name
Grisel Santiago as Administrator of the Estate of Carmen Santiago vs. Premier Home Health Care Services, Inc. et al
Case Type
Tort-Medical, Dental, or Podiatric Malpractice
Track
Complex
RJI Filed
12/15/2023
NOI Due
03/17/2025
NOI Filed
Calendar Number
—
Jury Status
Justice
Gerez, Hon. Alicia
Next Appearance
08/04/2026
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
Grisel Santiago as Administrator of the Estate of Carmen Santiago
Attorney / FirmDalli & Marino, LLP
Defendant / Respondent
Premier Home Health Care Services, Inc. et al
Attorneys / FirmsGarson Jakub & Morris LLP
Motions
No motions recorded for this case.
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (41)
Doc #
Date Filed
Document
Description
Motion #
Filing User
File
1
05/25/2023
SUMMONS + COMPLAINT
Salvatore Louis Marino
2
06/09/2023
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
Salvatore Louis Marino
3
06/09/2023
STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING
Salvatore Louis Marino
4
06/14/2023
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
Salvatore Louis Marino
5
06/14/2023
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
Salvatore Louis Marino
6
06/14/2023
STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING
Salvatore Louis Marino
7
06/26/2023
ANSWER
Verified Answer obo Deft. Throgs Neck Operating Co LLC
Keith Lawrence Kaplan
8
06/26/2023
DEMAND FOR BILL OF PARTICULARS
Demand for a Verified Bill of Particulars obo Deft. Throgs Neck Operating Co LLC
Keith Lawrence Kaplan
9
06/26/2023
NOTICE OF DEPOSITION
Notice of Depositions obo of Deft. Throgs Neck Operating Co LLC
Keith Lawrence Kaplan
10
06/26/2023
DEMAND FOR:
Combined Demands for D&I obo Deft. Throgs Neck Operating Co LLC
Keith Lawrence Kaplan
11
06/29/2023
ANSWER
VERIFIED ANSWER ON BEHALF OF DEFT NYCHHC
Jessica M. Seyer
12
06/29/2023
DEMAND FOR BILL OF PARTICULARS
ON BEHALF OF DEFT NYCHHC
Nicole Tracy Itkin
13
06/29/2023
NOTICE OF DEPOSITION UPON ORAL EXAMINATION
ON BEHALF OF DEFT NYCHHC
Nicole Tracy Itkin
14
06/29/2023
DEMAND FOR:
DEMAND FOR TAX RETURNS AND EMPLOYMENT RECORDS,NOTICE TO PRODUCE WITNESSES, DEMAND FOR EXPERT WITNESS INFO, DEMAND FOR INDEX NUMBER RECEIPT, DEMAND FOR DISCLOSURE OF MEDICARE/MEDICAID ELIGIBILITY,DEMAND FOR COLLATERAL SOURCE INFO AND VARIOUS OTHER DEMANDS
Nicole Tracy Itkin
15
11/06/2023
BILL OF PARTICULARS
Salvatore Louis Marino
16
11/06/2023
BILL OF PARTICULARS
Salvatore Louis Marino
17
11/09/2023
ANSWER
Andrew Seth Garson
18
11/09/2023
NOTICE OF DEPOSITION UPON ORAL EXAMINATION
Andrew Seth Garson
19
11/09/2023
DEMAND FOR BILL OF PARTICULARS
Andrew Seth Garson
20
11/09/2023
DEMAND FOR:
Andrew Seth Garson
21
11/10/2023
DEMAND FOR:
Demand for Authorizations
Keith Lawrence Kaplan
22
12/14/2023
BILL OF PARTICULARS
Salvatore Louis Marino
23
12/15/2023
PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE REQUEST
Salvatore Louis Marino
24
12/15/2023
RJI -RE: REQUEST FOR PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE
Salvatore Louis Marino
25
12/15/2023
ADDENDUM - GENERAL (840A)
Salvatore Louis Marino
26
12/15/2023
NOTICE OF MEDICAL MALPRACTICE
Salvatore Louis Marino
27
01/26/2024
RESPONSE TO DEMAND
Response to Plaintiff's Demand for Discovery and Inspection
Richard Thomas O'Brien
28
02/22/2024
RESPONSE TO DEMAND
Response to Plaintiff's Demand for a Bill of Particulars as to Affirmative Defenses
Richard Thomas O'Brien
29
03/28/2024
ORDER ( PROPOSED )
Proposed PC Order
Salvatore Louis Marino
30
04/17/2024
ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE
Dated April 3rd 2024
Michael Kenny
31
07/16/2024
DEMAND FOR:
Demand for Authorizations
Keith Lawrence Kaplan
32
08/14/2024
DEMAND FOR:
Demand for Non-Party Deposition
Keith Lawrence Kaplan
33
08/16/2024
ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE
DATED 08/06/2024
Michelle Alemany
34
12/09/2024
ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE
DATED 12/05/2024
Michelle Alemany
35
12/30/2024
DEMAND FOR:
Demand for Authorizations
Keith Lawrence Kaplan
36
02/04/2025
ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE
SO-ORDERED DATED 1/28/2025.
Lissette Rodriguez
37
04/03/2025
ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE
Dated April 1 2025
Michael Kenny
38
07/11/2025
ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE
Dated 6/23/2025
Shomari Dixon
39
10/07/2025
ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE
Dated 9/30/2025
Shomari Dixon
40
12/16/2025
NOTICE OF CHANGE OF FIRM NAME OR ADDRESS (POST RJI)
Andrew Seth Garson
41
04/07/2026
ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE
Dated 3/31/2026
Amanda Guzman
8
Bronx Supreme Court
2023
811293/2022E
Active
Medical Malpractice
ROHAN, DERRICK et al
SINEL & OLESEN, PLLC
PREMIER HOME HEALTH CARE SERVICES, INC. et al
Garson Jakub & Morris LLP
04/01/2026
Frishman, Hon. Michael A.
▼
Case Info
Court
Bronx Supreme Court
Index Number
811293/2022E
Status
Active
Year Filed
2023
Case Name
ROHAN, DERRICK et al vs. PREMIER HOME HEALTH CARE SERVICES, INC. et al
Case Type
Tort-Medical, Dental, or Podiatric Malpractice
Track
Complex
RJI Filed
08/04/2023
NOI Due
11/04/2024
NOI Filed
Calendar Number
—
Jury Status
Justice
Frishman, Hon. Michael A.
Next Appearance
04/01/2026
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
ROHAN, DERRICK et al
Attorney / FirmSINEL & OLESEN, PLLC
Defendant / Respondent
PREMIER HOME HEALTH CARE SERVICES, INC. et al
Attorneys / FirmsGarson Jakub & Morris LLP
Motions (1)
#
Date Filed
Filed By
Relief Sought
Submit Date
Answer
Status
Decision
Order Signed
1
08/04/2023
Leave to File
08/25/2023
No
Decided: 09/14/2023 Granted Before Justice: Frishman, Hon. Michael A.
Short Form Order
09/14/2023
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (78)
Doc #
Date Filed
Document
Description
Motion #
Filing User
File
1
08/03/2022
SUMMONS + COMPLAINT
+ Certificate of Merit
Elliot B Sinel
2
11/16/2022
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
Affidavit of Service for Premier Home Health Care Services, Inc.
Elliot B Sinel
3
12/09/2022
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
Affidavit of Service for Montefiore Medical Center
Elliot B Sinel
4
12/09/2022
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
Affidavit of Service for Premier Home Health Care Services
Elliot B Sinel
5
12/09/2022
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
Affidavit of Service of Montefiore Medical Center
Elliot B Sinel
6
12/09/2022
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
Affidavit of Service for VNS of NY Home Care II
Elliot B Sinel
7
12/09/2022
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
Affidavit of Service for VNS Choice
Elliot B Sinel
8
12/09/2022
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
Affidavit of Service for VNS of NY
Elliot B Sinel
9
12/09/2022
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
Affidavit of Service for VNS of NY Home Care
Elliot B Sinel
10
12/12/2022
ANSWER
Verified Answer
Betty Leigh Atlas
11
12/12/2022
DEMAND FOR:
Combined Demands
Betty Leigh Atlas
12
12/12/2022
DEMAND FOR BILL OF PARTICULARS
Demand for Bill of Particulars
Betty Leigh Atlas
13
12/12/2022
DEMAND FOR:
Demand for Disclosure of Medicare/Medicaid Benefits/Eligibility
Betty Leigh Atlas
14
12/12/2022
DEMAND FOR:
Demand for Expert Witness
Betty Leigh Atlas
15
12/12/2022
DEMAND FOR:
Demand for Prior Lawsuit Information
Betty Leigh Atlas
16
12/12/2022
ANSWER
Attorney Verification
Betty Leigh Atlas
17
12/12/2022
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
Affidavit of Service
Betty Leigh Atlas
18
12/21/2022
DEMAND FOR:
Demand for Disclosure of Medicare/Medicaid Benefits/Eligibility
Betty Leigh Atlas
19
12/21/2022
NOTICE OF DEPOSITION UPON ORAL EXAMINATION
Notice to take Deposition upon Oral Examination
Betty Leigh Atlas
20
12/21/2022
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
Affidavit of Service
Betty Leigh Atlas
21
12/28/2022
ANSWER
Verified Answer - VNSNY
James Samuel Newfield
22
01/13/2023
STIPULATION - TIME TO ANSWER
Stipulation Extending Time to Answer
Andrew Seth Garson
23
01/19/2023
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
Affidavit of Service for VNSNY CHHA
Elliot B Sinel
24
01/27/2023
STIPULATION - TIME TO ANSWER
Andrew Seth Garson
25
02/09/2023
STIPULATION - TIME TO ANSWER
Andrew Seth Garson
26
02/14/2023
ANSWER
Answer - Premier Home Health Care Services, Inc.
Shari Beth Fein
27
02/14/2023
NOTICE OF DEPOSITION UPON ORAL EXAMINATION
Notice to Take Deposition Upon Oral Examination
Shari Beth Fein
28
02/14/2023
DEMAND FOR BILL OF PARTICULARS
Demand for a Bill of Particulars
Shari Beth Fein
29
02/14/2023
DEMAND FOR:
Combined Demands
Shari Beth Fein
30
02/15/2023
DEMAND FOR BILL OF PARTICULARS
Demand For BP-CHHA
Donna-Marie Janet Woodstock
31
02/15/2023
DEMAND FOR BILL OF PARTICULARS
Demand BP- CHOICE
Donna-Marie Janet Woodstock
32
02/15/2023
DEMAND FOR:
COMBINED DEMAND - CHAA
Donna-Marie Janet Woodstock
33
02/15/2023
DEMAND FOR:
COMBINED DEMAND - CHOICE
Donna-Marie Janet Woodstock
34
02/15/2023
DEMAND FOR:
DEMAND FOR AUTHORIZATION - CHAA
Donna-Marie Janet Woodstock
35
02/15/2023
DEMAND FOR:
DEMAND FOR AUTHORIZATION - CHOICE
Donna-Marie Janet Woodstock
36
02/15/2023
NOTICE OF DEPOSITION UPON ORAL EXAMINATION
NOTICE OF DEPO. UPON ORAL EXAM. - CHAA
Donna-Marie Janet Woodstock
37
02/15/2023
NOTICE OF DEPOSITION UPON ORAL EXAMINATION
NOTICE OF DEPO. UPON ORAL EXAM. - CHOICE
Donna-Marie Janet Woodstock
38
08/04/2023
NOTICE OF MOTION
Motion for Late NMM
1
Elliot B Sinel
39
08/04/2023
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION
Affirmation in Support of Motion
1
Elliot B Sinel
40
08/04/2023
EXHIBIT(S)
Exhibit A - NMM, Plaintiff's Combined Response, Pleadings, BP
1
Elliot B Sinel
41
08/04/2023
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
Affirmation of Service
1
Elliot B Sinel
42
08/04/2023
RJI -RE: NOTICE OF MOTION
1
Elliot B Sinel
43
09/14/2023
DECISION + ORDER ON MOTION
Short Form Order dated 9/14/2023
1
Neil Espinal
44
09/16/2023
NOTICE OF ENTRY
Notice of Entry with Order
Elliot B Sinel
45
09/29/2023
DEMAND FOR:
Demand for Authorizations
James Samuel Newfield
46
10/03/2023
ORDER - PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE
DATED 10/3/2023
Ashley Williams
47
01/10/2024
RESPONSE TO DEMAND
Defendant Montefiore Medical Center's Response to Plaintiff's Combined Demands
Betty Leigh Atlas
48
01/10/2024
RESPONSE TO DEMAND
Defendant Montefiore Medical Center's Response to Plaintiff's Demand for a Verified Bill of Particulars as to Affirmative Defenses
Betty Leigh Atlas
49
01/10/2024
RESPONSE TO DEMAND
Defendant Montefiore Medical Center's Response to Plaintiff's Notice of Discovery and Inspection
Betty Leigh Atlas
50
01/10/2024
RESPONSE TO DEMAND
Defendant Montefiore Medical Center's Response to Plaintiff's Notice for Discovery and Inspection of Electronically Stored Information and Litigation Hold
Betty Leigh Atlas
51
01/10/2024
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
Affidavit of Service
Betty Leigh Atlas
52
01/24/2024
ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE
DATED 1/2/2024
Ashley Williams
53
02/06/2024
CONSENT TO CHANGE ATTORNEY (POST RJI)
James Samuel Newfield
54
04/02/2024
ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE
DATED 3/18/2024
Sara Mallach
55
06/04/2024
ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE
Dated 5/29/2024.
Ann Colon
56
08/05/2024
ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE
Dated July 31 2024-
Michael Kenny
57
10/18/2024
ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE
Dated October 8 2024
Michael Kenny
58
10/23/2024
DEMAND FOR:
Demand for Authorizations
Diana M Carlino
59
12/09/2024
ORDER ( PROPOSED )
Proposed Compliance Conference Order
Elliot B Sinel
60
12/11/2024
ORDER - COMPROMISE & SETTLEMENT
DATED 12/9/2024
Sara Mallach
61
02/12/2025
ORDER ( PROPOSED )
Proposed Compliance Conference Order
Elliot B Sinel
62
02/14/2025
ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE
SO-ORDERED DATED 2/12/2025.
Lissette Rodriguez
63
02/26/2025
DEMAND FOR:
Demand for Authorizations
James Samuel Newfield
64
05/05/2025
ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE
DATED 4/18/2025
Ashley Williams
65
05/12/2025
RESPONSE TO DEMAND
Defendant VNS Response to Verified Bill of Particulars
Donna-Marie Janet Woodstock
66
05/12/2025
RESPONSE TO DEMAND
Defendant VNS Response to Combined Demands
Donna-Marie Janet Woodstock
67
05/12/2025
RESPONSE TO DEMAND
Defendant VNS Response to Insurance Demand
Donna-Marie Janet Woodstock
68
05/12/2025
RESPONSE TO DEMAND
Defendant VNS Response Notice of Discovery & I.
Donna-Marie Janet Woodstock
69
05/12/2025
RESPONSE TO DEMAND
Defendant VNS Response Notice of D & I of ESI
Donna-Marie Janet Woodstock
70
07/02/2025
ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE
DATED 06/20/2025
Christopher M Morales
71
08/13/2025
ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE
DATED 08/01/2025
Michelle Alemany
72
09/23/2025
ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE
Dated 9/2/2025
Shomari Dixon
73
10/24/2025
ORDER ( PROPOSED )
Proposed CC Order (submitted on consent of all parties + in lieu of appearing in-person on 10/29/25)
Elliot B Sinel
74
11/13/2025
ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE
Dated 10/29/2025
Shomari Dixon
75
12/16/2025
NOTICE OF CHANGE OF FIRM NAME OR ADDRESS (POST RJI)
Andrew Seth Garson
76
01/13/2026
ORDER ( PROPOSED )
In lieu of appearing on 1.14.26
Elliot B Sinel
77
01/29/2026
ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE
DATED 1/13/2026
Shomari Dixon
78
03/31/2026
ORDER ( PROPOSED )
Proposed CCO in lieu of appearing on 4.1
Elliot B Sinel
9
Queens Supreme Court
2022
712302/2021
Active
Medical Malpractice
NADEL, BARBARA
SINEL & OLESEN PLLC
PREMIER HOME HEALTH CARE SERVICES, INC. et al
Garson Jakub & Morris LLP
04/29/2026
Catapano-Fox, Hon. Tracy A.
▼
Case Info
Court
Queens Supreme Court
Index Number
712302/2021
Status
Active
Year Filed
2022
Case Name
NADEL, BARBARA vs. PREMIER HOME HEALTH CARE SERVICES, INC. et al
Case Type
Tort-Medical, Dental, or Podiatric Malpractice
Track
Complex
RJI Filed
01/10/2022
NOI Due
02/02/2026
NOI Filed
02/09/2026
Calendar Number
—
Jury Status
Jury At Plaintiff's Request
Justice
Catapano-Fox, Hon. Tracy A.
Next Appearance
04/29/2026
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
NADEL, BARBARA
Attorney / FirmSINEL & OLESEN PLLC
Defendant / Respondent
PREMIER HOME HEALTH CARE SERVICES, INC. et al
Attorneys / FirmsGarson Jakub & Morris LLP
Motions (2)
#
Date Filed
Filed By
Relief Sought
Submit Date
Answer
Status
Decision
Order Signed
2
06/07/2023
Amend Caption/Pleadings
08/02/2023
Yes
Decided: 08/16/2023 Granted Before Justice: Catapano-Fox, Hon. Tracy A.
Short Form Order
1
04/21/2022
Extend - Time
06/01/2022
Yes
Decided: 10/05/2022 Granted Before Justice: O'Donoghue, Hon. Peter
Short Form Order
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (50)
Doc #
Date Filed
Document
Description
Motion #
Filing User
File
1
05/28/2021
SUMMONS + COMPLAINT
+ Certificate of Merit
Elliot B Sinel
2
07/27/2021
NOTICE OF APPEARANCE (PRE RJI)
Andrew Seth Garson
3
09/07/2021
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
Affidavit of Service for Premier Home Health Care Services, Inc.
Elliot B Sinel
4
09/07/2021
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
Affidavit of Priority Home Care Services, Inc.
Elliot B Sinel
5
09/07/2021
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
Affidavit of Service for QC Medi New York, Inc.
Elliot B Sinel
6
09/14/2021
NOTICE OF APPEARANCE (PRE RJI)
Ellen Nunno Corbo
7
09/14/2021
CONSENT TO EFILING
Ellen Nunno Corbo
8
09/15/2021
STIPULATION - TIME TO ANSWER
Elliot B Sinel
9
09/17/2021
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
Affidavit of Service for Priority Home Care Services, Inc.
Elliot B Sinel
10
09/17/2021
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
Affidavit of Service for Premier Home Health Care Services, Inc.
Elliot B Sinel
11
09/17/2021
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
Affidavit of Service for Serene Services Inc., d/b/a Serene Home Nursing Agency
Elliot B Sinel
12
09/17/2021
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
Affidavit of Service for QC - Medi New York Inc., d/b/a Kindred at Home
Elliot B Sinel
13
09/21/2021
ANSWER
Ellen Nunno Corbo
14
09/21/2021
ANSWER
Andrew Seth Garson
15
09/21/2021
NOTICE OF DEPOSITION UPON ORAL EXAMINATION
Andrew Seth Garson
16
09/21/2021
DEMAND FOR BILL OF PARTICULARS
Andrew Seth Garson
17
09/21/2021
DEMAND FOR:
Andrew Seth Garson
18
09/23/2021
STIPULATION - TIME TO ANSWER
Extension of Time to Answer on behalf of Sarene Services, Inc. d/b/a Serene Home Nursing Agency i/s/h/a Serene Services, Inc. d/b/a Serene Home Nursing Agency
Robert D Martin
19
09/28/2021
ANSWER
Verification
Louis Edward Jakub
20
10/22/2021
ANSWER
answer and initial demands for Sarene
Robert D Martin
21
11/11/2021
NOTICE OF CHANGE OF FIRM NAME OR ADDRESS (PRE RJI)
Elliot B Sinel
22
12/14/2021
NOTICE OF CHANGE OF ATTORNEY (PRE RJI)
Robert D Martin
23
12/29/2021
DEMAND FOR BILL OF PARTICULARS
Ellen Nunno Corbo
24
12/30/2021
DEMAND FOR:
Ellen Nunno Corbo
25
01/10/2022
PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE REQUEST
Robert D Martin
26
01/10/2022
AFFIRMATION
Affirmation of Good Faith
Robert D Martin
27
01/10/2022
RJI -RE: REQUEST FOR PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE
Robert D Martin
28
04/21/2022
NOTICE OF MOTION
Notice of Motion to File Late NMM
001
Elliot B Sinel
29
04/21/2022
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION
Affirmation in Support
001
Elliot B Sinel
30
04/21/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Exhibit A - NMM, Pleadings, BPs, Pl's Combined Response
001
Elliot B Sinel
31
04/21/2022
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
Affirmation of Service
001
Elliot B Sinel
32
06/16/2022
CONSENT TO CHANGE ATTORNEY (POST RJI)
Andrew F. Pisanelli
33
10/07/2022
ORDER - MOTION- SHORT FORM
GRANTED
001
Aimee Lopez
34
10/12/2022
NOTICE OF ENTRY
Notice of Entry with Order
Elliot B Sinel
35
05/24/2023
ORDER - PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE
Ahyana Guerra
36
06/07/2023
NOTICE OF MOTION
Motion to Amend Caption
002
Elliot B Sinel
37
06/07/2023
EXHIBIT(S)
S&C
002
Elliot B Sinel
38
06/07/2023
EXHIBIT(S)
DC and LOA
002
Elliot B Sinel
39
08/17/2023
DECISION + ORDER ON MOTION
002
Mandradeo Andrade Okeeffe
40
08/17/2023
NOTICE OF ENTRY
Notice of Entry with Order
Elliot B Sinel
41
08/23/2023
COMPLAINT (AMENDED)
+ Certificate of Merit
Elliot B Sinel
42
11/22/2023
ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE
Ahyana Guerra
43
06/07/2024
ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE
Kathleen Batyr
44
11/20/2024
STIPULATION - SO ORDERED
Stephanie Cruz-Goldberg
45
01/30/2025
CONSENT TO CHANGE ATTORNEY (PRE RJI)
Ellen Nunno Corbo
46
03/18/2025
STIPULATION - SO ORDERED
Stephanie Cruz-Goldberg
47
06/02/2025
ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE
Kathleen Batyr
48
10/06/2025
ORDER - OTHER
Roman Wojciech
49
12/10/2025
NOTICE OF CHANGE OF FIRM NAME OR ADDRESS (POST RJI)
Andrew Seth Garson
50
02/09/2026
NOTE OF ISSUE:WITH JURY
NOI with Order
Elliot B Sinel
10
Kings Supreme Court
2022
509172/2021
Active
Tort
Furman, Zina et al
SHAKHNEVICH LAW GROUP, P.C.
Premier Home Health Care Services, INC. et al
Garson Jakub & Morris LLP
05/14/2026
Capell, Hon. Heela D.
▼
Case Info
Court
Kings Supreme Court
Index Number
509172/2021
Status
Active
Year Filed
2022
Case Name
Furman, Zina et al vs. Premier Home Health Care Services, INC. et al
Case Type
Tort-Other
Track
Complex
RJI Filed
02/24/2022
NOI Due
06/26/2026
NOI Filed
Calendar Number
—
Jury Status
Justice
Capell, Hon. Heela D.
Next Appearance
05/14/2026
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
Furman, Zina et al
Attorney / FirmSHAKHNEVICH LAW GROUP, P.C.
Defendant / Respondent
Premier Home Health Care Services, INC. et al
Attorneys / FirmsGarson Jakub & Morris LLP
Motions (4)
#
Date Filed
Filed By
Relief Sought
Submit Date
Answer
Status
Decision
Order Signed
4
09/10/2025
Extend - Time
10/14/2025
No
Decided: 10/14/2025 Granted Before Justice: Central Compliance Part,
Short Form Order
10/14/2025
3
06/20/2024
Discovery
08/21/2024
Yes
Decided: 08/21/2024 Withdrawn Before Justice: Central Compliance Part,
2
04/05/2024
Extend - Time
05/06/2024
No
Decided: 05/06/2024 Granted Before Justice: Ruchelsman, Hon. Leon
Short Form Order
05/06/2024
1
05/27/2022
Dismiss
06/24/2022
Yes
Decided: 06/24/2022 Withdrawn Before Justice: Knipel, Hon. Lawrence S.
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (55)
Doc #
Date Filed
Document
Description
Motion #
Filing User
File
1
04/19/2021
SUMMONS + COMPLAINT
Steven Shakhnevich
2
04/23/2021
AFFIDAVIT
Steven Shakhnevich
3
05/06/2021
NOTICE OF APPEARANCE (PRE RJI)
Andrew Seth Garson
4
05/28/2021
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
Steven Shakhnevich
5
06/25/2021
ANSWER
Andrew Seth Garson
6
06/25/2021
NOTICE OF DEPOSITION UPON ORAL EXAMINATION
Andrew Seth Garson
7
06/25/2021
DEMAND FOR BILL OF PARTICULARS
Andrew Seth Garson
8
06/25/2021
DEMAND FOR:
Andrew Seth Garson
9
07/01/2021
ANSWER
Verification - Premier Home Health Care Services
Andrew Seth Garson
10
02/24/2022
PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE REQUEST
PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE REQUEST
Steven Shakhnevich
11
02/24/2022
RJI -RE: REQUEST FOR PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE
RJI
Steven Shakhnevich
12
03/31/2022
ORDER - PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE
Robert Lynch
13
05/26/2022
NOTICE OF MOTION
1
Janet Joanne Glore
14
05/26/2022
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION
1
Janet Joanne Glore
15
05/26/2022
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT
1
Janet Joanne Glore
16
05/26/2022
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
1
Janet Joanne Glore
17
05/26/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Exhibit A_Summons and Complaint
1
Janet Joanne Glore
18
05/26/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Exhibit B_Answer
1
Janet Joanne Glore
19
05/26/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Exhibit B_Demand for BP
1
Janet Joanne Glore
20
05/26/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Exhibit B_Combined Demands
1
Janet Joanne Glore
21
05/26/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Exhibit C_Good Faith Correspondences
1
Janet Joanne Glore
22
05/26/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Exhibit D_PC Order
1
Janet Joanne Glore
23
06/24/2022
STIPULATION - WITHDRAWING MOTION/ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE
1
Steven Shakhnevich
24
09/12/2022
ORDER ( PROPOSED )
Justin Todd Aronson
25
09/15/2022
ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE
dtd 9/12/22
Timothy Oreilly
26
09/12/2023
STIPULATION - DISCOVERY ( REQUEST TO SO ORDER )
Steven Shakhnevich
27
09/20/2023
ORDER - OTHER
final pre note dated 9/12/2023
Alex Cao
28
04/04/2024
NOTICE OF MOTION
Notice of Motion
2
Steven Shakhnevich
29
04/04/2024
AFFIRMATION OF GOOD FAITH
Affirmation of Good Faith
2
Steven Shakhnevich
30
04/04/2024
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION
Affirmation in Support of Motion
2
Steven Shakhnevich
31
04/04/2024
EXHIBIT(S)
Summons and Complaint
2
Steven Shakhnevich
32
04/04/2024
EXHIBIT(S)
Answer
2
Steven Shakhnevich
33
04/04/2024
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
Affirmation of Service
2
Steven Shakhnevich
34
05/13/2024
ORDER - OTHER
(Centralized Compliance Part) dated 5/6/2024
2
Robert Topscher
35
06/19/2024
NOTICE OF MOTION
3
Andrew Macleod Harrison
36
06/19/2024
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION
3
Andrew Macleod Harrison
37
06/19/2024
EXHIBIT(S)
Pltff Discovery Responses 6.4.22
3
Andrew Macleod Harrison
38
06/19/2024
EXHIBIT(S)
BP Objections
3
Andrew Macleod Harrison
39
06/19/2024
EXHIBIT(S)
Correspondence - LOA
3
Andrew Macleod Harrison
40
06/19/2024
EXHIBIT(S)
Good Faith Letters
3
Andrew Macleod Harrison
41
06/19/2024
EXHIBIT(S)
Demands for AZs 1.29.24
3
Andrew Macleod Harrison
42
07/17/2024
STIPULATION - ADJOURNMENT OF MOTION
2
Steven Shakhnevich
43
07/31/2024
ORDER - OTHER
dated 7/24/24
3
Madison Muldrow
44
08/21/2024
STIPULATION - WITHDRAWING MOTION/ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE
3
Steven Shakhnevich
45
04/07/2025
ORDER ( PROPOSED )
Proposed Final Pre-Note Order
Steven Shakhnevich
46
04/14/2025
ORDER - OTHER
dtd 04/09/2025 nsp final pre note
Tinsley Whitney
47
09/09/2025
NOTICE OF MOTION
Notice of Motion
4
Steven Shakhnevich
48
09/09/2025
AFFIRMATION OF GOOD FAITH
Affirmation of Good Faith
4
Steven Shakhnevich
49
09/09/2025
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION
Affirmation in Support of Motion
4
Steven Shakhnevich
50
09/09/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Exhibit A Summons and Complaint
4
Steven Shakhnevich
51
09/09/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Exhibit B Answer
4
Steven Shakhnevich
52
09/09/2025
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
Affirmation of Service
4
Steven Shakhnevich
53
10/17/2025
ORDER - OTHER
Dated 10/14/2025
4
Leonardo Tartamella
54
10/20/2025
NOTICE OF ENTRY/COPY OF ENTERED ORDER/PROOF OF SERVICE
4
Steven Shakhnevich
55
12/05/2025
NOTICE OF CHANGE OF FIRM NAME OR ADDRESS (POST RJI)
Andrew Seth Garson
11
Kings Supreme Court
2021
517331/2021
Active
Tort
Prazdnik, Yelizaveta et al
SHAKHNEVICH LAW GROUP, P.C.
Premier Home Health Care Services, INC. et al
Garson Jakub & Morris LLP
07/20/2026
Rivera, Hon. Francois A.
▼
Case Info
Court
Kings Supreme Court
Index Number
517331/2021
Status
Active
Year Filed
2021
Case Name
Prazdnik, Yelizaveta et al vs. Premier Home Health Care Services, INC. et al
Case Type
Tort-Other
Track
Complex
RJI Filed
10/11/2021
NOI Due
07/10/2026
NOI Filed
Calendar Number
—
Jury Status
Justice
Rivera, Hon. Francois A.
Next Appearance
07/20/2026
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
Prazdnik, Yelizaveta et al
Attorney / FirmSHAKHNEVICH LAW GROUP, P.C.
Defendant / Respondent
Premier Home Health Care Services, INC. et al
Attorneys / FirmsGarson Jakub & Morris LLP
Motions (3)
#
Date Filed
Filed By
Relief Sought
Submit Date
Answer
Status
Decision
Order Signed
3
05/21/2025
Extend - Time
06/20/2025
No
Decided: 06/20/2025 Granted Before Justice: Ruchelsman, Hon. Leon
Short Form Order
06/20/2025
2
10/27/2023
Extend - Time
12/06/2023
No
Decided: 12/06/2023 Granted to the Extent of the Order Before Justice: Ruchelsman, Hon. Leon
Short Form Order
12/06/2023
1
07/29/2022
Dismiss
08/18/2022
Yes
Decided: 08/18/2022 Granted to the Extent of the Order Before Justice: Knipel, Hon. Lawrence S.
08/18/2022
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (51)
Doc #
Date Filed
Document
Description
Motion #
Filing User
File
1
07/14/2021
SUMMONS + COMPLAINT
Steven Shakhnevich
2
07/28/2021
NOTICE OF APPEARANCE (PRE RJI)
Andrew Seth Garson
3
08/04/2021
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
Steven Shakhnevich
4
09/21/2021
ANSWER
Andrew Seth Garson
5
09/21/2021
NOTICE OF DEPOSITION UPON ORAL EXAMINATION
Andrew Seth Garson
6
09/21/2021
DEMAND FOR BILL OF PARTICULARS
Andrew Seth Garson
7
09/21/2021
DEMAND FOR:
Andrew Seth Garson
8
09/28/2021
ANSWER
Verification
Andrew Seth Garson
9
10/11/2021
PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE REQUEST
Preliminary Conference Request
Steven Shakhnevich
10
10/11/2021
RJI -RE: REQUEST FOR PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE
RJI
Steven Shakhnevich
11
11/08/2021
ORDER - PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE
Robert Lynch
12
05/17/2022
STIPULATION - DISCOVERY ( REQUEST TO SO ORDER )
Steven Shakhnevich
13
05/25/2022
ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE
Dated: 05/17/2022
Jazmin Sutherland
14
06/07/2022
DEMAND FOR:
Mary Judith Joseph
15
07/28/2022
NOTICE OF MOTION
Notice of Motion to Dismiss/Compel/Preclude
1
Mary Judith Joseph
16
07/28/2022
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT
Affirmation in Support of Motion
1
Mary Judith Joseph
17
07/28/2022
AFFIRMATION OF GOOD FAITH
1
Mary Judith Joseph
18
07/28/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Summons and Complaint
1
Mary Judith Joseph
19
07/28/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Verified Answer
1
Mary Judith Joseph
20
07/28/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Demand for Verified Bill of Particulars and Combined Demands
1
Mary Judith Joseph
21
07/28/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Preliminary Conference Order
1
Mary Judith Joseph
22
07/28/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Compliance Conference Order
1
Mary Judith Joseph
23
07/28/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Correspondence for discovery
1
Mary Judith Joseph
24
07/28/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Demand for Authorizations
1
Mary Judith Joseph
25
08/18/2022
ORDER ( PROPOSED )
1
Steven Shakhnevich
26
08/25/2022
ORDER - OTHER
dtd 8/18/22
1
Timothy Oreilly
27
04/05/2023
STIPULATION - DISCOVERY ( REQUEST TO SO ORDER )
Steven Shakhnevich
28
04/18/2023
ORDER - OTHER
dtd 4/13/23
Timothy Oreilly
29
10/26/2023
NOTICE OF MOTION
2
Steven Shakhnevich
30
10/26/2023
AFFIRMATION OF GOOD FAITH
2
Steven Shakhnevich
31
10/26/2023
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION
2
Steven Shakhnevich
32
10/26/2023
EXHIBIT(S)
Summons and Complaint
2
Steven Shakhnevich
33
10/26/2023
EXHIBIT(S)
Answer
2
Steven Shakhnevich
34
10/26/2023
EXHIBIT(S)
FCP Order
2
Steven Shakhnevich
35
10/26/2023
CERTIFICATION OF SIGNATURE ( ATTORNEY OR PARTY )
Word Count Certification
2
Steven Shakhnevich
36
10/26/2023
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
2
Steven Shakhnevich
37
12/11/2023
DECISION + ORDER ON MOTION
2
Lissette Morales
38
12/28/2023
LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE
Letter/Correspondence to Judge
Steven Shakhnevich
39
12/02/2024
ORDER ( PROPOSED )
Proposed Final Pre-Note Order
Steven Shakhnevich
40
12/11/2024
ORDER - OTHER
dtd 12/06/2024 nsp final pre note
Tinsley Whitney
41
05/20/2025
NOTICE OF MOTION
Notice of Motion
3
Steven Shakhnevich
42
05/20/2025
AFFIRMATION OF GOOD FAITH
Affirmation of Good Faith
3
Steven Shakhnevich
43
05/20/2025
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION
Affirmation in Support of Motion
3
Steven Shakhnevich
44
05/20/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Exhibit A Summons and Complaint
3
Steven Shakhnevich
45
05/20/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Exhibit B Answer
3
Steven Shakhnevich
46
05/20/2025
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
Affirmation of Service
3
Steven Shakhnevich
47
06/13/2025
AFFIRMATION
Affirmation in Response
3
Lisa Erin Galterio
48
06/30/2025
ORDER - MOTION- SHORT FORM
dated 6/20/25
3
Henry Y Huang
49
12/01/2025
ORDER ( PROPOSED )
Proposed Final Pre-Note Order
Steven Shakhnevich
50
12/16/2025
NOTICE OF CHANGE OF FIRM NAME OR ADDRESS (POST RJI)
Andrew Seth Garson
51
12/18/2025
ORDER - OTHER
Dated 12-3-2025
Anna Fagone
12
Bronx Supreme Court
2021
804849/2021E
Active
Medical Malpractice
BERRY, ANNA MARIE
Sinel & Olesen, PLLC
PREMIER HOME HEALTH CARE SERVICES, INC. et al
Aaronson Rappaport Feinstein & Deutsch, LLP
04/30/2026
Frishman, Hon. Michael A.
▼
Case Info
Court
Bronx Supreme Court
Index Number
804849/2021E
Status
Active
Year Filed
2021
Case Name
BERRY, ANNA MARIE vs. PREMIER HOME HEALTH CARE SERVICES, INC. et al
Decided: 09/16/2025 Granted to the Extent of the Order Before Justice: Frishman, Hon. Michael A.
Memorandum
09/16/2025
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (93)
Doc #
Date Filed
Document
Description
Motion #
Filing User
File
1
04/08/2021
SUMMONS + COMPLAINT
+ Certificate of Merit
Elliot B Sinel
2
07/15/2021
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
Affidavit of Service for Premier Home Health Care Services, Inc.
Elliot B Sinel
3
07/19/2021
ANSWER
Answer for Terence Cardinal Cooke Health Care Center
Thomas J Benvenuto
4
07/22/2021
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
Affidavit of Service for The Mount Sinai Hospital
Elliot B Sinel
5
07/22/2021
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
Affidavit of Service for The Mount Sinai Hospital
Elliot B Sinel
6
07/22/2021
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
Affidavit of Service for Mount Sinai Morningside
Elliot B Sinel
7
07/22/2021
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
Affidavit of Service for Premier Home Health Care Services Inc.
Elliot B Sinel
8
07/22/2021
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
Affidavit of Service for Premier Home Health Care Services Inc
Elliot B Sinel
9
07/22/2021
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
Affidavit of Service for Terence Cardinal Cooke Health Care Center
Elliot B Sinel
10
07/22/2021
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
Affidavit of Service for Terence Cardinal Cooke Health Care Center
Elliot B Sinel
11
07/27/2021
NOTICE OF APPEARANCE (PRE RJI)
Andrew Seth Garson
12
08/09/2021
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
Affidavit of Service for The St. Luke's Roosevelt Hospital Center
Elliot B Sinel
13
08/19/2021
ANSWER
for THE MOUNT SINAI HOSPITAL
Nicholas James Marotta
14
09/02/2021
ANSWER
for ST. LUKE'S ROOSEVELT HOSPITAL CENTER d/b/a MOUNT SINAI MORNINGSIDE s/h/a MOUNT SINAI MORNINGSIDE F/K/A ST. LUKE'S ROOSEVELT HOSPITAL
Nicholas James Marotta
15
09/10/2021
ANSWER
Andrew Seth Garson
16
09/10/2021
NOTICE OF DEPOSITION UPON ORAL EXAMINATION
Andrew Seth Garson
17
09/10/2021
DEMAND FOR BILL OF PARTICULARS
Andrew Seth Garson
18
09/10/2021
DEMAND FOR:
Andrew Seth Garson
19
09/14/2021
ANSWER
Verification
Andrew Seth Garson
20
09/15/2021
DEMAND FOR BILL OF PARTICULARS
o/b/o ST. LUKES ROOSEVELT HOSPITAL CENTER D/B/A MOUNT SINAI MORNINGSIDE S/H/A MOUNT SINAI MORNINGSIDE F/K/A ST. LUKE'S ROOSEVELT HOSPITAL
Phillip Walter Hosang
21
09/15/2021
NOTICE OF DEPOSITION
o/b/o ST. LUKES ROOSEVELT HOSPITAL CENTER D/B/A MOUNT SINAI MORNINGSIDE S/H/A MOUNT SINAI MORNINGSIDE F/K/A ST. LUKE'S ROOSEVELT HOSPITAL
Phillip Walter Hosang
22
09/15/2021
DEMAND FOR:
COMBINED DEMANDS o/b/o ST. LUKES ROOSEVELT HOSPITAL CENTER D/B/A MOUNT SINAI MORNINGSIDE S/H/A MOUNT SINAI MORNINGSIDE F/K/A ST. LUKE'S ROOSEVELT HOSPITAL
Phillip Walter Hosang
23
09/15/2021
DEMAND FOR BILL OF PARTICULARS
o/b/o THE MOUNT SINAI HOSPITAL
Phillip Walter Hosang
24
09/15/2021
NOTICE OF DEPOSITION
o/b/o THE MOUNT SINAI HOSPITAL
Phillip Walter Hosang
25
09/15/2021
DEMAND FOR:
COMBINED DEMANDS o/b/o THE MOUNT SINAI HOSPITAL
Phillip Walter Hosang
26
11/03/2021
PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE REQUEST
Request for Preliminary Conference
Elliot B Sinel
27
11/03/2021
NOTICE OF MEDICAL MALPRACTICE
Notice of Medical Malpractice
Elliot B Sinel
28
11/03/2021
RJI -RE: NOTICE OF MEDICAL, DENTAL OR PODIATRIC MALPRACTICE
Request for Judicial Intervention
Elliot B Sinel
29
11/11/2021
NOTICE OF CHANGE OF FIRM NAME OR ADDRESS (POST RJI)
Elliot B Sinel
30
03/01/2022
COURT NOTICE
Busharah James
30-1
03/01/2022
ATTACHMENT TO COURT NOTICE
Busharah James
31
03/01/2022
COURT NOTICE
Busharah James
31-1
03/01/2022
ATTACHMENT TO COURT NOTICE
Busharah James
32
06/03/2022
ORDER - PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE
STIPULATION SO-ORDERED DATED 6/1/2022
Jenny Leon
33
06/24/2022
CONSENT TO CHANGE ATTORNEY (POST RJI)
Melissa Stacy Goldberg
34
09/19/2022
ORDER ( PROPOSED )
Elliot B Sinel
35
09/27/2022
ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE
DATED 9/21/2022
Ashley Williams
36
01/13/2023
ORDER ( PROPOSED )
Elliot B Sinel
37
01/18/2023
ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE
DATED 1/16/2023
Ashley Williams
38
02/24/2023
RESPONSE TO DEMAND
Lisa Erin Galterio
39
02/24/2023
RESPONSE TO DEMAND
Lisa Erin Galterio
40
03/08/2023
ORDER ( PROPOSED )
Elliot B Sinel
41
03/15/2023
ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE
DATED: 3/8/23 ( SO ORDERED)
Sandra Riveralopez
42
07/10/2023
ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE
DATED 7/11/2023
Tamieka J Long
43
09/13/2023
ORDER ( PROPOSED )
Compliance Conference Order dated 9.13.2023
Elliot B Sinel
44
10/03/2023
ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE
DATED 09/13/2023
Michelle Alemany
45
10/12/2023
ORDER ( PROPOSED )
Compliance Conference Order
Elliot B Sinel
46
10/19/2023
ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE
SO, ORDERED: 10/12/2023.
Sandra Riveralopez
47
12/12/2023
ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE
DATED 11/21/2023
Ashley Williams
48
02/02/2024
ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE
Dated 1/18/2024
Shomari Dixon
49
04/02/2024
ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE
DATED 3/25/2024
Sara Mallach
50
05/21/2024
ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE
Dated 5/14/2024
Rosa E Matos
51
06/14/2024
NOTE OF ISSUE:WITH JURY
NOI with Order
Elliot B Sinel
52
09/12/2024
NOTICE OF MOTION
1
Ivelina Vasileva Popova
53
09/12/2024
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT
1
Ivelina Vasileva Popova
54
09/12/2024
STATEMENT OF MATERIAL FACTS
1
Ivelina Vasileva Popova
55
09/12/2024
EXHIBIT(S)
Physician's Affirmation - Dr. Lois
1
Ivelina Vasileva Popova
56
09/12/2024
EXHIBIT(S)
Nursing Affirmation - RN Dusseldorp
1
Ivelina Vasileva Popova
57
09/12/2024
EXHIBIT(S)
Summons & Complaint
1
Ivelina Vasileva Popova
58
09/12/2024
EXHIBIT(S)
Verified Answer - Premier
1
Ivelina Vasileva Popova
59
09/12/2024
EXHIBIT(S)
Bill of Particulars
1
Ivelina Vasileva Popova
60
09/12/2024
EXHIBIT(S)
EBT Transcript Plaintiff Anne Berry
1
Ivelina Vasileva Popova
61
09/12/2024
EXHIBIT(S)
EBT Transcript HHA Owusu
1
Ivelina Vasileva Popova
62
09/12/2024
EXHIBIT(S)
EBT Transcript NPW Anthony Berry
1
Ivelina Vasileva Popova
63
09/12/2024
EXHIBIT(S)
Premier Records
1
Ivelina Vasileva Popova
64
09/12/2024
EXHIBIT(S)
Dr. Sheinfeld Records
1
Ivelina Vasileva Popova
65
09/12/2024
EXHIBIT(S)
Mount Sinai Admission 10/10-10/11/2018
1
Ivelina Vasileva Popova
66
09/12/2024
EXHIBIT(S)
Morningside REcords pp. 1-193
1
Ivelina Vasileva Popova
67
09/12/2024
EXHIBIT(S)
Mount Sinai Admission 11/4-11/23 (selected records)
1
Ivelina Vasileva Popova
68
09/12/2024
EXHIBIT(S)
Morningside Records pp. 194-287
1
Ivelina Vasileva Popova
69
09/12/2024
EXHIBIT(S)
VNS Records pp. 1-121
1
Ivelina Vasileva Popova
70
09/12/2024
EXHIBIT(S)
VNS Records pp. 122-243
1
Ivelina Vasileva Popova
71
09/12/2024
EXHIBIT(S)
VNS Records pp. 244-312
1
Ivelina Vasileva Popova
72
09/12/2024
EXHIBIT(S)
VNS Records - pp. 313-484
1
Ivelina Vasileva Popova
73
09/12/2024
EXHIBIT(S)
VNS Records pp. 485-505
1
Ivelina Vasileva Popova
74
09/12/2024
EXHIBIT(S)
Terrence Cardinal Records
1
Ivelina Vasileva Popova
75
09/12/2024
EXHIBIT(S)
FDNY Ambulance Records
1
Ivelina Vasileva Popova
76
09/12/2024
EXHIBIT(S)
Cavalry Hospital Expiration Summary
1
Ivelina Vasileva Popova
77
09/12/2024
EXHIBIT(S)
Premier Policies
1
Ivelina Vasileva Popova
78
09/12/2024
EXHIBIT(S)
Note of Issue
1
Ivelina Vasileva Popova
79
09/12/2024
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
Attorney Affirmation of Service
1
Ivelina Vasileva Popova
80
09/19/2024
STIPULATION - ADJOURNMENT OF MOTION
Stip to Adjourn Def Premier Home Health's SJM (on consent of all parties)
1
Elliot B Sinel
81
11/26/2024
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION
Attorney Affirmation in Opposition
1
Elliot B Sinel
82
11/26/2024
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex. 1 - Plaintiff's Medical Expert Affirmation
1
Elliot B Sinel
83
11/26/2024
RESPONSE TO STATEMENT OF MATERIAL FACTS
Statement of Material Facts in Opposition
1
Elliot B Sinel
84
11/26/2024
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
Affirmation of Service
1
Elliot B Sinel
85
12/10/2024
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN REPLY
1
Ivelina Vasileva Popova
86
12/10/2024
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
1
Ivelina Vasileva Popova
87
04/30/2025
CONSENT TO CHANGE ATTORNEY (POST RJI)
Lori Ann Marano
88
09/19/2025
DECISION + ORDER ON MOTION
DATED 9-16-25
1
Adera Williams
89
10/03/2025
NOTICE OF ENTRY
Notice of Entry of MSJ Decision
1
Ivelina Vasileva Popova
90
11/03/2025
NOTICE OF APPEAL
Ivelina Vasileva Popova
91
11/26/2025
NOTICE OF CHANGE OF FIRM NAME OR ADDRESS (POST RJI)
Andrew Seth Garson
13
New York Supreme Court
2020
153867/2020
Stayed
Negligence
RUFFIN, SABRINA
Bell Law Group, PLLC
PREMIER HOME HEALTH CARE
JANE DOES 1-2 (being a fictitious name of the home health aids employed by defendant)
03/18/2024
Kim, Hon. Judy H.
▼
Case Info
Court
New York Supreme Court
Index Number
153867/2020
Status
Stayed
Year Filed
2020
Case Name
RUFFIN, SABRINA vs. PREMIER HOME HEALTH CARE
Case Type
Tort-Other Negligence
Track
Standard
RJI Filed
12/28/2020
NOI Due
05/31/2024
NOI Filed
Calendar Number
—
Jury Status
Justice
Kim, Hon. Judy H.
Next Appearance
03/18/2024
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
RUFFIN, SABRINA
Attorney / FirmBell Law Group, PLLC
Defendant / Respondent
PREMIER HOME HEALTH CARE
Attorneys / FirmsJANE DOES 1-2 (being a fictitious name of the home health aids employed by defendant)
Motions
No motions recorded for this case.
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (44)
Doc #
Date Filed
Document
Description
Motion #
Filing User
File
1
06/03/2020
SUMMONS + COMPLAINT
Summons & Complaint
Matthew Paul Madzelan
2
07/14/2020
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
AOS Premier Home Health Care Services
Matthew Paul Madzelan
3
07/28/2020
COMPLAINT (AMENDED)
Amended Complaint
Matthew Paul Madzelan
4
07/29/2020
ANSWER
Answer for Premier Home Health Care Services, Inc.
Jeffrey Allen Shor
5
07/29/2020
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
AOS
Jeffrey Allen Shor
6
07/29/2020
AFFIRMATION
Redaction Form
Jeffrey Allen Shor
7
07/29/2020
STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING
Jeffrey Allen Shor
8
08/03/2020
ANSWER (AMENDED)
Amended Answer to amended Complaint as to Defendant PREMIER HOME HEALTH CARE SERVICES
Ancy Thomas
9
08/03/2020
AFFIRMATION
Amended Redaction sheet for amended answer as to defendant, PREMIER HOME HEALTH CARE SERVICES, INC.
Ancy Thomas
10
12/28/2020
BILL OF PARTICULARS
Jeffrey Bloomfield
11
12/28/2020
RESPONSE TO DEMAND
Plaintiff Response to Combined Demands
Jeffrey Bloomfield
12
12/28/2020
DEMAND FOR:
Plaintiff Combined Demands
Jeffrey Bloomfield
13
12/28/2020
PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE REQUEST
Request for PC
Jeffrey Bloomfield
14
12/28/2020
RJI -RE: REQUEST FOR PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE
Jeffrey Bloomfield
15
12/28/2020
ADDENDUM - GENERAL (840A)
Jeffrey Bloomfield
16
06/17/2021
ORDER - PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE
Michelle A Cruz
17
11/04/2021
STIPULATION - SO ORDERED
Michelle A Cruz
18
02/25/2022
STIPULATION - SO ORDERED
Michelle A Cruz
19
03/24/2022
STIPULATION - SO ORDERED
Michelle A Cruz
20
05/02/2022
STIPULATION - SO ORDERED
Michelle A Cruz
21
06/21/2022
STIPULATION - DISCOVERY ( REQUEST TO SO ORDER )
Stipulation and Order
Eric Shawn Vogel
22
06/24/2022
ORDER - STATUS CONFERENCE
Michelle A Cruz
23
08/04/2022
DISCOVERY CONFERENCE NOTICE -FROM COURT
Jack Wong
24
08/08/2022
STIPULATION - OTHER
Stipulation
Eric Shawn Vogel
25
09/08/2022
STIPULATION - SO ORDERED
Eli Moskovitz
26
02/14/2023
STIPULATION - DISCOVERY ( REQUEST TO SO ORDER )
Vincent Guida
27
02/21/2023
ORDER - DISCOVERY STIPULATION
Susan Macleod
28
04/26/2023
ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE
Susan Macleod
29
07/07/2023
STIPULATION - SO ORDERED
Susan Macleod
30
09/21/2023
STIPULATION - OTHER - ( REQUEST TO SO ORDER )
Vincent Guida
31
09/25/2023
ORDER - DISCOVERY STIPULATION
Susan Macleod
32
11/03/2023
ORDER - DISCOVERY STIPULATION
Susan Macleod
33
11/20/2023
ORDER - DISCOVERY STIPULATION
Susan Macleod
34
01/17/2024
NOTICE OF DEPOSITION/SUBPOENA
Vincent Guida
35
01/17/2024
NOTICE OF DEPOSITION/SUBPOENA
Vincent Guida
36
01/17/2024
NOTICE OF DEPOSITION/SUBPOENA
Vincent Guida
37
01/17/2024
NOTICE OF DEPOSITION/SUBPOENA
Vincent Guida
38
01/17/2024
NOTICE OF DEPOSITION/SUBPOENA
Vincent Guida
39
01/26/2024
ORDER - DISCOVERY STIPULATION
Susan Macleod
40
02/14/2024
RESPONSE TO DEMAND
Plaintiff's Response to Demand for Authorizations
Vincent Guida
41
05/30/2024
STIPULATION - OTHER
Stipulation to extend time to file Note of Issue
Shoshanna Matatova
42
10/29/2024
LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE
Shoshanna Matatova
43
02/26/2025
NOTICE OF CHANGE OF FIRM NAME OR ADDRESS (POST RJI)
Decided: 02/02/2026 Denied Before Justice: Katsanos, Hon. John C.
Short Form Order
4
06/16/2025
Judgment - Summary
09/10/2025
Yes
Decided: 02/03/2026 Denied Before Justice: Katsanos, Hon. John C.
Short Form Order
3
05/01/2023
Preclude
06/12/2023
Yes
Decided: 06/12/2023 Withdrawn Before Justice: Ventura, Hon. Lourdes M.
Oral
2
07/14/2020
Strike Pleadings
07/27/2020
Yes
Decided: 07/27/2020 Withdrawn Before Justice: McDonald, Hon. Robert J.
Oral
07/27/2020
1
06/23/2020
Bill of Particulars
08/20/2020
Yes
Decided: 08/20/2020 Withdrawn Before Justice: McDonald, Hon. Robert J.
Oral
08/20/2020
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (168)
Doc #
Date Filed
Document
Description
Motion #
Filing User
File
1
11/18/2019
SUMMONS + COMPLAINT
Summons and Complaint
David B. Corley
2
12/04/2019
AFFIDAVIT
Affidavit of Service - Merline Louissant
David B. Corley
3
12/04/2019
AFFIDAVIT
Affidavit of Service - Senior Whole Health of New York, Inc.
David B. Corley
4
12/04/2019
AFFIDAVIT
Affidavit of Service - Premier Home Health Care Services, Inc.
David B. Corley
5
12/16/2019
ANSWER
Verified Answer
Hara Jessica Prager
6
12/16/2019
AFFIRMATION
Redaction Cover Page
Hara Jessica Prager
7
12/16/2019
AFFIRMATION
Affirmation to E-File
Hara Jessica Prager
8
12/20/2019
NOTICE OF APPEARANCE (PRE RJI)
Peter T. Shapiro
9
12/20/2019
STIPULATION - TIME TO ANSWER
Peter T. Shapiro
10
01/10/2020
ANSWER
Answer as to Merline Louissant with Initial Demands
Michael Anthony Derosa
11
01/10/2020
AFFIRMATION
Redaction Cover Sheet
Michael Anthony Derosa
12
01/10/2020
CONSENT TO EFILING
Michael Anthony Derosa
13
01/21/2020
NOTICE OF APPEARANCE (PRE RJI)
Stephanie Michelle Steinberg
14
01/21/2020
ANSWER WITH CROSS-CLAIM(S)
Verified Answer with Cross-Claims
Peter T. Shapiro
15
01/21/2020
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
Peter T. Shapiro
16
01/22/2020
ANSWER WITH CROSS-CLAIM(S)
Michael Anthony Derosa
17
01/22/2020
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
Michael Anthony Derosa
18
01/22/2020
CONSENT TO EFILING
Michael Anthony Derosa
19
02/26/2020
PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE REQUEST
David B. Corley
20
02/26/2020
RJI -RE: REQUEST FOR PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE
David B. Corley
21
05/01/2020
ORDER - PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE
Keelin M Reilly
22
06/23/2020
NOTICE OF MOTION
Notice of Motion to compel by Defendants, PREMIER HOME HEALTH CARE SERVICES, INC. and MERLINE LOUISSANT
001
Ancy Thomas
23
06/23/2020
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION
Affirmation in support of Motion to compel
001
Ancy Thomas
24
06/23/2020
AFFIRMATION OF GOOD FAITH
Affirmation of Good faith
001
Ancy Thomas
25
06/23/2020
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
Affirmation of Service as to Motion to Compel
001
Ancy Thomas
26
06/23/2020
AFFIRMATION
Redaction Cover page for Motion to compel
001
Ancy Thomas
27
06/23/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Plaintiffs Summons & Verified Complaint
001
Ancy Thomas
28
06/23/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Verified Answers on behalf of Defendants, PREMIER HOME HEALTH CARE SERVICES, INC. and MERLINE LOUISSANT
001
Ancy Thomas
29
06/23/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Demands for Verified Bills of Particulars on behalf of PREMIER HOME HEALTH CARE SERVICES, INC. and MERLINE LOUISSANT
001
Ancy Thomas
30
06/23/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Verified Answer on behalf of Co-Defendant, SENIOR WHOLE HEALTH OF NEW YORK, INC.;
001
Ancy Thomas
31
06/23/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Plaintiffs Verified Bill of Particulars for PREMIER HOME HEALTH CARE SERVICES, INC
001
Ancy Thomas
32
06/23/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Plaintiffs Verified Bill of Particulars for MERLINE LOUISSANT
001
Ancy Thomas
33
06/23/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Plaintiffs Verified Bill of Particulars for SENIOR WHOLE HEALTH OF NEW YORK, INC.;
001
Ancy Thomas
34
06/23/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Defendants initial correspondence dated March 23, 2020, requesting Supplemental Verified Bills of Particulars;
001
Ancy Thomas
35
06/23/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Plaintiffs April 14, 2020 response to Defendants initial correspondence;
001
Ancy Thomas
36
06/23/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Defendants follow-up correspondence dated May 4, 2020, requesting Supplemental Verified Bills of Particulars;
001
Ancy Thomas
37
06/23/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Plaintiffs May 6, 2020 response to Defendants follow-up correspondence
001
Ancy Thomas
38
06/24/2020
NOTICE TO ADMIT
NOTICE TO ADMIT on defendants Premier & Louisantt
David B. Corley
39
06/24/2020
BILL OF PARTICULARS
Jacqueline Haddad Supplemental BP Def MERLINE LOUISSANT
David B. Corley
40
06/24/2020
BILL OF PARTICULARS
Plaintiff's SUPPLEMENTAL BP Def PREMIEIR
David B. Corley
41
06/24/2020
BILL OF PARTICULARS
Plaintiff's Supplemental BP Def Seniors Whole Health
David B. Corley
42
06/29/2020
LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE
001
Michael Anthony Derosa
43
07/14/2020
NOTICE OF MOTION
Notice of Motion
002
Zachary Max Sherman
44
07/14/2020
AFFIRMATION OF GOOD FAITH
Affirmation of Good Faith
002
Zachary Max Sherman
45
07/14/2020
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION
Affirmation in Support
002
Zachary Max Sherman
46
07/14/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Plaintiff Notice to Admit
002
Zachary Max Sherman
47
07/14/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Summons and Complaint
002
Zachary Max Sherman
48
07/14/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Answer as to Premier and Louissant
002
Zachary Max Sherman
49
07/14/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Answer as to Senior Home Health
002
Zachary Max Sherman
50
07/14/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
BP as to Premier
002
Zachary Max Sherman
51
07/14/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
BP as to Louissant
002
Zachary Max Sherman
52
07/14/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
BP as to Senior Whole Health
002
Zachary Max Sherman
53
07/14/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Plaintiff Supplemental BPs
002
Zachary Max Sherman
54
07/14/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
June 29, 2020 Correspondence
002
Zachary Max Sherman
55
07/14/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
June 30, 2020 Correspondence
002
Zachary Max Sherman
56
07/14/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
July 14, 2020 Correspondence
002
Zachary Max Sherman
57
07/14/2020
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
AOS
002
Zachary Max Sherman
58
07/14/2020
AFFIRMATION
Redaction Form
002
Zachary Max Sherman
59
07/14/2020
AFFIRMATION
AZ for e-filing
002
Zachary Max Sherman
60
07/17/2020
NOTICE OF WITHDRAWAL OF MOTION / ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE
Letter to Court withdrawing Motion for Protective Order
002
Zachary Max Sherman
61
06/28/2021
ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE
Louisa Ammirati
62
06/29/2021
DEMAND FOR:
DFA dated 6/28/21 (as to plaintiff)
Conrad Aloysius Chayes
63
06/29/2021
DEMAND FOR:
NDI dated 6/28/21 (as to plaintiff)
Conrad Aloysius Chayes
64
06/29/2021
DEMAND FOR:
NDI dated 6/28/21 (as to codefendant Senior Whole Health of NY)
Conrad Aloysius Chayes
65
06/29/2021
STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING
Conrad Aloysius Chayes
66
08/11/2021
LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE
Casey Mary Hughes
67
08/11/2021
AFFIRMATION
Statement of Authorization for Electronic Filing
Casey Mary Hughes
68
09/14/2021
COURT NOTICE
Deana Allocco
69
01/11/2022
ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE
Kathleen Batyr
70
05/19/2022
ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE
Kathleen Batyr
71
05/19/2022
ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE
Kathleen Batyr
72
06/08/2022
RESPONSE TO DEMAND
SUPP. RESPONSE TO PLTF NDI 2-25-2020
Conrad Aloysius Chayes
73
12/07/2022
STIPULATION - DISCOVERY
Morgan Alexandra Corley
74
02/24/2023
NOTICE OF DEPOSITION/SUBPOENA
Notice of Deposition/Subpoena ALI
David B. Corley
75
02/24/2023
NOTICE OF DEPOSITION/SUBPOENA
Notice of Deposition/Subpoena ENCALADA
David B. Corley
76
03/06/2023
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
Affidavit of Service RE: Personal Service on Paola Encalada
David B. Corley
77
03/20/2023
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
Affidavit of Service Mail and Personal - Jocelyn Ali RE: Notice of Deposition Judicial Subpoena
David B. Corley
78
05/01/2023
NOTICE OF MOTION
Notice of Motion
003
Bindu R. Nair
79
05/01/2023
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT
Affirmation in Support
003
Bindu R. Nair
80
05/01/2023
AFFIRMATION OF GOOD FAITH
Affirmation of Good Faith
003
Bindu R. Nair
81
05/01/2023
EXHIBIT(S)
Summons and Verified Complaint
003
Bindu R. Nair
82
05/01/2023
EXHIBIT(S)
Verified Answers
003
Bindu R. Nair
83
05/01/2023
EXHIBIT(S)
Notice for Discovery and Inspection dated February 8, 2023
003
Bindu R. Nair
84
05/01/2023
EXHIBIT(S)
Correspondence dated March 8, 2023
003
Bindu R. Nair
85
05/01/2023
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
Affidavit of Service
003
Bindu R. Nair
86
05/01/2023
STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING
Statement of Authorization
003
Bindu R. Nair
87
06/05/2023
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION
(WITH DOCUMENT SPECIFICATIONS STATEMENT)
003
Conrad Aloysius Chayes
88
06/05/2023
EXHIBIT(S)
EBT OF MERLINE LOUISSANT
003
Conrad Aloysius Chayes
89
06/05/2023
EXHIBIT(S)
CPLR 3116
003
Conrad Aloysius Chayes
90
06/05/2023
EXHIBIT(S)
RESPONSE TO NOTICE OF DISCOVERY AND INSPECTION
003
Conrad Aloysius Chayes
91
06/09/2023
STIPULATION - WITHDRAWING MOTION/ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE
003
Victor Michael Ivanoff
92
06/13/2023
STIPULATION - SO ORDERED
Donna Fischbach
93
11/09/2023
ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE
Kathleen Batyr
94
08/22/2024
ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE
Kathleen Batyr
95
12/12/2024
ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE
Erica Nieves
96
02/14/2025
NOTE OF ISSUE:WITH JURY
Note of Issue w/attached orders
David B. Corley
97
02/19/2025
ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE
Kathleen Batyr
98
06/16/2025
NOTICE OF MOTION
Notice of Motion
004
Danielle Marie Olivero
99
06/16/2025
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT
Affirmation in Support
004
Danielle Marie Olivero
100
06/16/2025
STATEMENT OF MATERIAL FACTS
Statement of Material Facts
004
Danielle Marie Olivero
101
06/16/2025
MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN SUPPORT
Memorandum of Law in Support
004
Danielle Marie Olivero
102
06/16/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Pltf's Verified BoP & Supplemental BoP
004
Danielle Marie Olivero
103
06/16/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Deposition of Jacqueline Haddad dated 10.21.20
004
Danielle Marie Olivero
104
06/16/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Deposition of E. Kramer for Premier dated 2.4.21 & Notice to Execute
004
Danielle Marie Olivero
105
06/16/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Deposition Transcript of I. Idahosa for Senior Whole Health dated 11.23.21
004
Danielle Marie Olivero
106
06/16/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Deposition Transcript of M. Louissant dated 3.15.22 & Demand to Execute
004
Danielle Marie Olivero
107
06/16/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Health Service Vendor Agreement dated 8.1.10
004
Danielle Marie Olivero
108
06/16/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Administrative Agreement dated 9.1.16
004
Danielle Marie Olivero
109
06/16/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Signed Affirmation of Cheryl Parris RN
004
Danielle Marie Olivero
110
06/16/2025
STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING
Statement of Authorization
004
Danielle Marie Olivero
111
06/16/2025
NOTICE OF MOTION
005
Victor Michael Ivanoff
112
06/16/2025
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT
005
Victor Michael Ivanoff
113
06/16/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Affirmation Dr. Vincent Garbitelli
005
Victor Michael Ivanoff
114
06/16/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Summons & Verified Complaint
005
Victor Michael Ivanoff
115
06/16/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Verified Answers Premier Home and Ms. Louissant
005
Victor Michael Ivanoff
116
06/16/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Answers - Senior Whole Health of Ne York
005
Victor Michael Ivanoff
117
06/16/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Answer to Cross Claims
005
Victor Michael Ivanoff
118
06/16/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Bill of Particulars - Premier Home and Ms. Louissant
005
Victor Michael Ivanoff
119
06/16/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Supplemental Bill of Particulars
005
Victor Michael Ivanoff
120
06/16/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
EBT Transcript Jacqueline Haddad
005
Victor Michael Ivanoff
121
06/16/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Deposition Eileen Kramer, RN
005
Victor Michael Ivanoff
122
06/16/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Deposition - Iriowen Idahosa
005
Victor Michael Ivanoff
123
06/16/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Deposition - Merline Louissant
005
Victor Michael Ivanoff
124
06/16/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Deposition - Michael Haddad
005
Victor Michael Ivanoff
125
06/16/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Deposition - Paola Encalada
005
Victor Michael Ivanoff
126
06/16/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Deposition - Jocelyn Ali
005
Victor Michael Ivanoff
127
06/16/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Note of Issue
005
Victor Michael Ivanoff
128
06/16/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Records Premier Home
005
Victor Michael Ivanoff
129
06/16/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Premier Home Occurrence Report
005
Victor Michael Ivanoff
130
06/16/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Records Senior Whole Health of New York
005
Victor Michael Ivanoff
131
06/16/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Record of Jacobi Medical Center
005
Victor Michael Ivanoff
132
06/16/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Records New York Presbyterian Hospital
005
Victor Michael Ivanoff
133
06/16/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Records Sea Crest Nursing
005
Victor Michael Ivanoff
134
06/16/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Records Center for Advanced Cardiac Care
005
Victor Michael Ivanoff
135
06/16/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Records Vivian and Seymour Milstein Family Health Center
005
Victor Michael Ivanoff
136
06/16/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Record Flushing Hospital Medical Center
005
Victor Michael Ivanoff
137
06/16/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Death Certificate
005
Victor Michael Ivanoff
138
06/16/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Photographs
005
Victor Michael Ivanoff
139
06/16/2025
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
Affirmation of Service
005
Victor Michael Ivanoff
140
07/07/2025
STIPULATION - ADJOURNMENT OF MOTION
004
Morgan Alexandra Corley
141
07/07/2025
STIPULATION - ADJOURNMENT OF MOTION
005
Morgan Alexandra Corley
142
08/15/2025
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION
005
Morgan Alexandra Corley
143
08/15/2025
MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN OPPOSITION
005
Morgan Alexandra Corley
144
08/15/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Dr. Steier Expert Affirmation
005
Morgan Alexandra Corley
145
08/15/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Jacobi Records (Full Chart)
005
Morgan Alexandra Corley
146
08/15/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Northwell North Shore Records
005
Morgan Alexandra Corley
147
08/15/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Visiting Nurses Services Records
005
Morgan Alexandra Corley
148
08/20/2025
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION
Opposition to Senior Whole Health's summary judgment motion to dismiss cross-claim
004
Victor Michael Ivanoff
149
08/20/2025
AFFIRMATION
Response to Senior Whole Health's Statement of Undisputed Facts
004
Victor Michael Ivanoff
150
09/09/2025
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN REPLY
Affirmation in Reply to Co-defendants' Opposition
004
Danielle Marie Olivero
151
09/09/2025
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN REPLY
005
Victor Michael Ivanoff
152
02/03/2026
DECISION + ORDER ON MOTION
005
Brendan O'Hanlon
153
02/04/2026
DECISION + ORDER ON MOTION
004
Brendan O'Hanlon
154
02/11/2026
NOTICE OF ENTRY
Order with Notice of Entry Mot. Seq. 4
Morgan Alexandra Corley
155
02/11/2026
NOTICE OF ENTRY
Order with Notice of Entry Mot. Seq. 5
Morgan Alexandra Corley
156
03/04/2026
NOTICE OF CHANGE OF FIRM NAME OR ADDRESS (POST RJI)
Morgan Alexandra Corley
157
03/05/2026
NOTICE OF APPEAL/INFORMATIONAL STATEMENT/COPY OF ORDER/PROOF OF SERVICE
Notice of Appeal
004
Bindu R. Nair
158
03/13/2026
NOTICE OF MOTION
006
Andrew James Fisher
159
03/13/2026
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT
006
Andrew James Fisher
160
03/13/2026
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
006
Andrew James Fisher
161
03/13/2026
NOTICE OF APPEAL/INFORMATIONAL STATEMENT/COPY OF ORDER/PROOF OF SERVICE
Andrew James Fisher
162
03/24/2026
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION
006
Morgan Alexandra Corley
163
03/29/2026
RESPONSE TO DEMAND
Expert Exchange-Dr. Raven
Morgan Alexandra Corley
164
03/29/2026
RESPONSE TO DEMAND
Expert Exchange-Dr. Charash
Morgan Alexandra Corley
165
03/29/2026
RESPONSE TO DEMAND
Expert Exchange-Dr. Hughes
Morgan Alexandra Corley
166
03/29/2026
RESPONSE TO DEMAND
Expert Exhcange-Dr. Steier
Morgan Alexandra Corley
167
03/31/2026
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN REPLY
006
Andrew James Fisher
168
03/31/2026
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
006
Andrew James Fisher
15
Kings Supreme Court
2020
513354/2019
Active
Negligence
ASHKINAZI, RAKHIL
LAW OFFICES OF WILLIAM PAGER
PREMIER HOME HEALTH CARE
MARTIN CLEARWATER & BELL
12/13/2023
Barry, Hon. Rupert V.
▼
Case Info
Court
Kings Supreme Court
Index Number
513354/2019
Status
Active
Year Filed
2020
Case Name
ASHKINAZI, RAKHIL vs. PREMIER HOME HEALTH CARE
Case Type
Tort-Other Negligence
Track
Standard
RJI Filed
06/16/2020
NOI Due
09/16/2022
NOI Filed
Calendar Number
—
Jury Status
Justice
Barry, Hon. Rupert V.
Next Appearance
12/13/2023
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
ASHKINAZI, RAKHIL
Attorney / FirmLAW OFFICES OF WILLIAM PAGER
Defendant / Respondent
PREMIER HOME HEALTH CARE
Attorneys / FirmsMARTIN CLEARWATER & BELL
Motions (5)
#
Date Filed
Filed By
Relief Sought
Submit Date
Answer
Status
Decision
Order Signed
5
10/23/2023
Parties - Add/Substitute/Intervene
12/13/2023
Yes
Decided: 12/13/2023 Granted Before Justice: Barry, Hon. Rupert V.
Short Form Order
12/13/2023
4
09/08/2023
Dismiss
12/13/2023
Yes
Decided: 12/13/2023 Withdrawn Before Justice: Barry, Hon. Rupert V.
3
06/16/2021
Protective Order
09/16/2021
No
Decided: 09/16/2021 Denied Before Justice: Rivera, Hon. Francois A.
Memorandum
09/16/2021
2
06/07/2021
Strike Pleadings
09/16/2021
Yes
Decided: 09/16/2021 Granted Before Justice: Rivera, Hon. Francois A.
Memorandum
09/16/2021
1
02/19/2021
Dismiss
03/09/2021
Yes
Decided: 03/09/2021 Granted to the Extent of the Order Before Justice: Knipel, Hon. Lawrence S.
Short Form Order
03/11/2021
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (113)
Doc #
Date Filed
Document
Description
Motion #
Filing User
File
1
06/17/2019
SUMMONS + COMPLAINT
William Pager
2
06/25/2019
AFFIDAVIT
William Pager
3
06/25/2019
AFFIDAVIT
William Pager
4
06/25/2019
AFFIDAVIT
William Pager
5
07/01/2019
ANSWER
Answer Premier Home Health Care Services Inc
Jeffrey Allen Shor
6
07/01/2019
AFFIRMATION
Redaction Form PHHCS Inc
Jeffrey Allen Shor
7
07/01/2019
ANSWER
Answer Premier Home Health Care Services
Jeffrey Allen Shor
8
07/01/2019
AFFIRMATION
Redaction Form Premier Home Health Care Services
Jeffrey Allen Shor
9
07/01/2019
ANSWER
Answer Rumiya Turdumatova
Jeffrey Allen Shor
10
07/01/2019
AFFIRMATION
Redaction Form Turdumatova
Jeffrey Allen Shor
11
07/01/2019
STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING
Statement of Authorization
Jeffrey Allen Shor
12
07/30/2019
AFFIDAVIT
William Pager
13
06/16/2020
RJI -RE: REQUEST FOR PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE
William Pager
14
07/29/2020
STIPULATION - DISCOVERY ( REQUEST TO SO ORDER )
William Pager
15
10/27/2020
ORDER - PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE
Maura Alliano
16
12/11/2020
NOTIFICATION FROM COURT
Re: Kings County Supreme Civil Court Mediation Program
Michael Habich
17
02/19/2021
NOTICE OF MOTION
Notice of Motion to Dismiss
1
Casey Mary Hughes
18
02/19/2021
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION
Affirmation in Support of Motion to Dismiss
1
Casey Mary Hughes
19
02/19/2021
AFFIRMATION OF GOOD FAITH
Affirmation of Good Faith in Support of Motion to Dismiss
1
Casey Mary Hughes
20
02/19/2021
EXHIBIT(S)
Plaintiff's Summons & Complaint
1
Casey Mary Hughes
21
02/19/2021
EXHIBIT(S)
Verified Answers on behalf of Defendants, Premier Home Health Care Services, Premier Home Health Care Services, Inc., and Rumiya Turdumatova
1
Casey Mary Hughes
22
02/19/2021
EXHIBIT(S)
Plaintiff's Bills of Particulars dated March 10, 2020
1
Casey Mary Hughes
23
02/19/2021
EXHIBIT(S)
Defendants' Correspondence dated April 24, 2020, demanding Supplemental Bills of Particulars
1
Casey Mary Hughes
24
02/19/2021
EXHIBIT(S)
Defendants' Demands for Authorizations dated April 24, 2020, June 18, 2020, and June 23, 2020
1
Casey Mary Hughes
25
02/19/2021
EXHIBIT(S)
Defendants' correspondence dated June 23, 2020 demanding revised HIPAA-compliant authorizations for Plaintiff's medical records
1
Casey Mary Hughes
26
02/19/2021
EXHIBIT(S)
Preliminary Conference Order dated October 26, 2020
1
Casey Mary Hughes
27
02/19/2021
EXHIBIT(S)
Defendants' good faith correspondence dated November 2, 2020 and December 2, 2020
1
Casey Mary Hughes
28
02/19/2021
AFFIRMATION
Document Specifications Statement
1
Casey Mary Hughes
29
02/19/2021
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
1
Casey Mary Hughes
30
02/19/2021
AFFIRMATION
Statement of Authorization for Electronic Filing
1
Casey Mary Hughes
31
02/19/2021
AFFIRMATION
Affirmation of Redaction
1
Casey Mary Hughes
32
03/08/2021
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION
1
William Pager
33
03/08/2021
EXHIBIT(S)
Combined Demands
1
William Pager
34
03/08/2021
EXHIBIT(S)
Case Scheduling Order
1
William Pager
35
03/08/2021
EXHIBIT(S)
Bill of Particulars and Responses to Demands
1
William Pager
36
03/08/2021
EXHIBIT(S)
Responses to Demands
1
William Pager
37
03/08/2021
EXHIBIT(S)
Plaintiff's Objection
1
William Pager
38
03/08/2021
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
1
William Pager
39
03/08/2021
NOTICE OF CROSS-MOTION
William Pager
40
03/08/2021
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION AND IN SUPPORT OF CROSS-MOTION
William Pager
41
03/08/2021
EXHIBIT(S)
Combined Demands
William Pager
42
03/08/2021
EXHIBIT(S)
Case Scheduling Order
William Pager
43
03/08/2021
EXHIBIT(S)
Bill of Particulars and Responses to Demands
William Pager
44
03/08/2021
EXHIBIT(S)
Responses to Demands
William Pager
45
03/08/2021
EXHIBIT(S)
Plaintiff's Objection
William Pager
46
03/08/2021
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
William Pager
47
03/08/2021
LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE
Letter to Court objecting to Plaintiff's Cross-Motion/Opposition
Victor Michael Ivanoff
48
03/08/2021
LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE
Letter to Court objecting to Plaintiff's Cross-Motion/Opposition
1
Victor Michael Ivanoff
49
03/09/2021
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN REPLY
Defendants' Reply Affirmation
1
Victor Michael Ivanoff
50
03/09/2021
AFFIRMATION
Document Specifications Page for Reply Affirmation
1
Victor Michael Ivanoff
51
03/09/2021
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
Affirmation of Service for Reply Affirmation
1
Victor Michael Ivanoff
52
03/16/2021
ORDER - OTHER
dated 03/09/2021
1
Yvonne Vernon
53
03/18/2021
NOTICE OF ENTRY/COPY OF ENTERED ORDER/PROOF OF SERVICE
Order with Notice of Entry
1
Casey Mary Hughes
54
06/04/2021
NOTICE OF MOTION
2
William Pager
55
06/04/2021
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT
2
William Pager
56
06/04/2021
AFFIRMATION OF GOOD FAITH
2
William Pager
57
06/04/2021
EXHIBIT(S)
Combined Demands
2
William Pager
58
06/04/2021
EXHIBIT(S)
Response to Plaintiff's Combined Demands
2
William Pager
59
06/04/2021
EXHIBIT(S)
Order
2
William Pager
60
06/04/2021
EXHIBIT(S)
Plaintiff's E-mail Printout
2
William Pager
61
06/04/2021
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
2
William Pager
62
06/15/2021
NOTICE OF CROSS-MOTION
Notice of Cross-Motion
3
Casey Mary Hughes
63
06/15/2021
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION AND IN SUPPORT OF CROSS-MOTION
3
Casey Mary Hughes
64
06/15/2021
AFFIRMATION OF GOOD FAITH
3
Casey Mary Hughes
65
06/15/2021
AFFIRMATION
Document Specifications Statement
3
Casey Mary Hughes
66
06/15/2021
EXHIBIT(S)
Privilege Log for Occurrence Report and supporting materials at issue
3
Casey Mary Hughes
67
06/15/2021
EXHIBIT(S)
Affidavit of Margaret Furlong attesting to quality assurance practices of Premier Home
3
Casey Mary Hughes
68
06/15/2021
EXHIBIT(S)
Plaintiffs Summons & Complaint
3
Casey Mary Hughes
69
06/15/2021
EXHIBIT(S)
Verified Answers on behalf of Defendants, PREMIER HOME HEALTH CARE SERVICES, PREMIER HOME HEALTH CARE SERVICES, INC., and RUMIYA TURDUMATOVA
3
Casey Mary Hughes
70
06/15/2021
EXHIBIT(S)
Plaintiffs Combined Demands dated March 10, 2020
3
Casey Mary Hughes
71
06/15/2021
EXHIBIT(S)
Response to Plaintiffs Combined Demands dated June 18, 2020
3
Casey Mary Hughes
72
06/15/2021
EXHIBIT(S)
Defendants Correspondence dated May 5, 2021 supplementing Defendants Response to Plaintiffs Combined Demands
3
Casey Mary Hughes
73
06/15/2021
EXHIBIT(S)
Plaintiffs Bills of Particulars dated March 10, 2020
3
Casey Mary Hughes
74
06/15/2021
EXHIBIT(S)
Defendants correspondence dated April 24, 2020, demanding Supplemental Bills of Particulars
3
Casey Mary Hughes
75
06/15/2021
EXHIBIT(S)
Order dated March 9, 2021 (Hon. Lawrence Knipel, J.S.C.)
3
Casey Mary Hughes
76
06/15/2021
EXHIBIT(S)
Good Faith Correspondence dated May 5, 2021 demanding Supplemental Bills of Particulars per March 9, 2021 Order
3
Casey Mary Hughes
77
06/15/2021
EXHIBIT(S)
Defendants correspondence dated May 11, 2021 regarding Plaintiffs failure to appear for deposition per March 9, 2021 Order
3
Casey Mary Hughes
78
06/15/2021
EXHIBIT(S)
Defendants correspondence dated June 18, 2020 and March 9, 2021, regarding reimbursement of the reasonable costs of reproduction of Plaintiffs records with Premier Home
3
Casey Mary Hughes
79
06/15/2021
EXHIBIT(S)
Defendants correspondence dated June 15, 2021, enclosing Plaintiffs nonprivileged records with Premier Home to Plaintiffs counsel
3
Casey Mary Hughes
80
06/15/2021
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
3
Casey Mary Hughes
81
06/30/2021
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO CROSS-MOTION
3
William Pager
82
06/30/2021
EXHIBIT(S)
Bill of Particulars
3
William Pager
83
06/30/2021
EXHIBIT(S)
Response to Court Order
3
William Pager
84
06/30/2021
EXHIBIT(S)
Supplemental Bill of Particulars
3
William Pager
85
06/30/2021
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
3
William Pager
86
07/01/2021
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN REPLY
Reply Affirmation for Defendants' Cross-Motion
3
Victor Michael Ivanoff
87
07/01/2021
AFFIDAVIT
Document Specifications Page for Reply Affirmation
3
Victor Michael Ivanoff
88
07/01/2021
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
Affirmation of Service for Reply Affirmation
3
Victor Michael Ivanoff
89
07/07/2021
ORDER - OTHER
dtd 7/1/21
2
Timothy Oreilly
90
09/28/2021
ORDER - OTHER
DATED 09/16/21
2
Yvette Williams
91
09/28/2021
ORDER - OTHER
DATED 09/16/21
3
Yvette Williams
92
09/30/2021
NOTICE OF ENTRY/COPY OF ENTERED ORDER/PROOF OF SERVICE
2
William Pager
93
09/30/2021
NOTICE OF ENTRY/COPY OF ENTERED ORDER/PROOF OF SERVICE
3
William Pager
94
03/16/2022
STIPULATION - DISCOVERY ( REQUEST TO SO ORDER )
William Pager
95
03/31/2022
ORDER - OTHER
dtd 3/28/22
Timothy Oreilly
96
09/08/2023
NOTICE OF MOTION
TO DISMISS
4
Victor Michael Ivanoff
97
09/08/2023
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT
4
Victor Michael Ivanoff
98
09/08/2023
EXHIBIT(S)
S&C's
4
Victor Michael Ivanoff
99
09/08/2023
EXHIBIT(S)
Verified Answers Premier Home Health Care et al.
4
Victor Michael Ivanoff
100
09/08/2023
EXHIBIT(S)
CMS Medicare Ltr 4.13.22
4
Victor Michael Ivanoff
101
09/08/2023
EXHIBIT(S)
EMAIL Correspondence to P's counsel 4.18.22
4
Victor Michael Ivanoff
102
09/08/2023
EXHIBIT(S)
EMAIL Correspondence to P's counsel 7.7.22 & 8.29.22
4
Victor Michael Ivanoff
103
10/20/2023
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION
4
William Pager
104
10/20/2023
AFFIDAVIT
Affidavit of Compliance
4
William Pager
105
10/20/2023
EXHIBIT(S)
Incident Report
4
William Pager
106
10/20/2023
EXHIBIT(S)
Decree granting Administration
4
William Pager
107
10/20/2023
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
4
William Pager
108
10/20/2023
NOTICE OF MOTION
5
William Pager
109
10/20/2023
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT
5
William Pager
110
10/20/2023
AFFIDAVIT
Affidavit of Compliance
5
William Pager
111
10/20/2023
EXHIBIT(S)
Incident Report
5
William Pager
112
10/20/2023
EXHIBIT(S)
Decree granting Administration
5
William Pager
113
10/20/2023
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
5
William Pager
16
Bronx Supreme Court
2020
20099/2020E (0020099/2020)
Disposed
Negligence
GUTIERREZ, YOSELIN
MARGULIES AND ASSOCIATES
PREMIER HOME HEALTH CARE
Fullerton Beck, LLP
Taylor, Hon. Elizabeth A.
▼
Case Info
Court
Bronx Supreme Court
Index Number
20099/2020E (0020099/2020)
Status
Disposed
Year Filed
2020
Case Name
GUTIERREZ, YOSELIN vs. PREMIER HOME HEALTH CARE
Case Type
Tort-Other Negligence
Track
Standard
RJI Filed
06/04/2020
NOI Due
06/04/2021
NOI Filed
Calendar Number
—
Jury Status
Justice
Taylor, Hon. Elizabeth A.
Next Appearance
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
GUTIERREZ, YOSELIN
Attorney / FirmMARGULIES AND ASSOCIATES
Defendant / Respondent
PREMIER HOME HEALTH CARE
Attorneys / FirmsFullerton Beck, LLP
Motions (1)
#
Date Filed
Filed By
Relief Sought
Submit Date
Answer
Status
Decision
Order Signed
1
06/28/2021
Approve Settlement
12/14/2021
No
Decided: 12/14/2021 Signed Before Justice: Taylor, Hon. Elizabeth A.
Long Form Order
12/14/2021
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (26)
Doc #
Date Filed
Document
Description
Motion #
Filing User
File
1
01/03/2020
SUMMONS + COMPLAINT
Robert W. Margulies
2
01/30/2020
ANSWER
Dena Operman
3
01/30/2020
NOTICE OF DEPOSITION UPON ORAL EXAMINATION
Dena Operman
4
02/06/2020
AFFIDAVIT
Robert W Margulies
5
02/06/2020
STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING
Robert W Margulies
6
06/04/2020
PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE REQUEST
Robert W. Margulies
7
06/04/2020
AFFIRMATION
Robert W. Margulies
8
06/04/2020
RJI -RE: REQUEST FOR PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE
Robert W. Margulies
9
10/15/2020
CONSENT TO CHANGE ATTORNEY (POST RJI)
Dena Operman
10
10/15/2020
NOTICE OF APPEARANCE (POST RJI)
Dena Operman
11
03/26/2021
NOTICE OF CHANGE OF FIRM NAME OR ADDRESS (POST RJI)
Robert W. Margulies
12
06/28/2021
ORDER ( PROPOSED )
Order Approving Settlement per EPTL 5-4.6
Robert W. Margulies
13
06/28/2021
AFFIDAVIT
Plaintiff Affidavit approving settlement
Robert W. Margulies
14
06/28/2021
AFFIRMATION
Attorney Affirmation in Support of Settlement
Robert W. Margulies
15
06/28/2021
EXHIBIT(S)
Death Certificate
Robert W. Margulies
16
06/28/2021
EXHIBIT(S)
Letters of Administration
Robert W. Margulies
17
06/28/2021
EXHIBIT(S)
Retainer and Retainer Statement
Robert W. Margulies
18
06/28/2021
EXHIBIT(S)
Summons and Complaint
Robert W. Margulies
19
06/28/2021
EXHIBIT(S)
Bill of Particulars
Robert W. Margulies
20
06/28/2021
EXHIBIT(S)
Offer of Settlement letter
Robert W. Margulies
21
06/28/2021
EXHIBIT(S)
Case Disbursement list
Robert W. Margulies
22
06/28/2021
EXHIBIT(S)
Medicaid Lien Letter
Robert W. Margulies
23
06/28/2021
EXHIBIT(S)
Paid Funeral Bill, and No Medicare Lien letter
Robert W. Margulies
24
11/19/2021
NOTIFICATION FROM COURT
-Per Direction of the Court.
Michael Habich
25
01/13/2022
ORDER - OTHER
ORDER APPROVING SETTLEMENT DATED 12/14/2021
Yesenia Torres
26
01/14/2022
STIPULATION - DISCONTINUANCE (POST RJI)
Dena Operman
17
Bronx Supreme Court
2020
20145/2019E (0020145/2019)
Disposed
Negligence
ANDERSON, MARK
MARK E SEITELMAN LAW OFFICES, P.C.
PREMIER HOME HEALTH CARE
MARTIN CLEARWATER & BELL
12/08/2025
Guzman, Hon. Wilma
▼
Case Info
Court
Bronx Supreme Court
Index Number
20145/2019E (0020145/2019)
Status
Disposed
Year Filed
2020
Case Name
ANDERSON, MARK vs. PREMIER HOME HEALTH CARE
Case Type
Tort-Other Negligence
Track
Standard
RJI Filed
07/31/2020
NOI Due
02/28/2023
NOI Filed
Calendar Number
—
Jury Status
Justice
Guzman, Hon. Wilma
Next Appearance
12/08/2025
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
ANDERSON, MARK
Attorney / FirmMARK E SEITELMAN LAW OFFICES, P.C.
Defendant / Respondent
PREMIER HOME HEALTH CARE
Attorneys / FirmsMARTIN CLEARWATER & BELL
Motions (1)
#
Date Filed
Filed By
Relief Sought
Submit Date
Answer
Status
Decision
Order Signed
1
07/31/2020
Strike Pleadings
10/19/2020
No
Decided: 10/19/2020 Withdrawn Before Justice: Torres, Hon. Robert E.
Short Form Order
10/19/2020
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (28)
Doc #
Date Filed
Document
Description
Motion #
Filing User
File
1
01/04/2019
SUMMONS + COMPLAINT
Mark E Seitelman
2
04/10/2019
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
Mark E Seitelman
3
04/18/2019
AFFIRMATION
Redaction Cover Sheet
Jeffrey Allen Shor
4
04/18/2019
STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING
Statement of Authorization
Jeffrey Allen Shor
5
04/18/2019
ANSWER
Answer
Jeffrey Allen Shor
6
07/31/2020
NOTICE OF MOTION
Notice of Motion
001
Zachary Max Sherman
7
07/31/2020
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION
Affirmation in Support
001
Zachary Max Sherman
8
07/31/2020
AFFIRMATION OF GOOD FAITH
Affirmation of Good Faith
001
Zachary Max Sherman
9
07/31/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Plaintiffs Summons & Verified Complaint
001
Zachary Max Sherman
10
07/31/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Verified Answer on behalf of Defendant, PREMIER HOME HEALTH CARE SERVICES, INC.
001
Zachary Max Sherman
11
07/31/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Defendants Demand for Authorizations dated April 25, 2019
001
Zachary Max Sherman
12
07/31/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Defendants good faith correspondence dated October 29, 2019, February 18, 2020, and April 23, 2020
001
Zachary Max Sherman
13
07/31/2020
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
AOS
001
Zachary Max Sherman
14
07/31/2020
AFFIRMATION
Redaction Form
001
Zachary Max Sherman
15
07/31/2020
AFFIRMATION
AZ for E-Filing
001
Zachary Max Sherman
16
07/31/2020
RJI -RE: NOTICE OF MOTION
001
Zachary Max Sherman
17
08/26/2020
STIPULATION - ADJOURNMENT OF MOTION
adjourn from August 28, 2020 to September 28, 2020
001
Mark E Seitelman
18
09/25/2020
STIPULATION - ADJOURNMENT OF MOTION
Stipulation adjourning motion from September 28, 2020 to October 19, 2020
001
Sara A Coletti
19
10/15/2020
STIPULATION - WITHDRAWING MOTION/ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE
001
Victor Michael Ivanoff
20
10/15/2020
STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING
001
Victor Michael Ivanoff
21
11/02/2020
ORDER - MOTION- SHORT FORM
Dated 10/19/2020
001
Terrence Daly
22
08/20/2021
NOTICE OF DISCOVERY AND INSPECTION
Mark E Seitelman
23
08/20/2021
PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE REQUEST
Mark E Seitelman
24
08/26/2021
NOTIFICATION FROM COURT
Discovery Part Rules / Forms
Jason C Wright
25
11/19/2021
NOTIFICATION FROM COURT
-Per Direction of the Court.
Michael Habich
26
12/15/2021
ORDER - PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE
DATED 12/10/2021
Michelle Alemany
27
07/29/2022
ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE
Dated 07/27/2022
Shayna Laplante
28
12/08/2025
STIPULATION - DISCONTINUANCE (POST RJI)
Stipulation of Discontinuance
Karen Corbett
18
Nassau Supreme Court
2019
602061/2019
Disposed
OM-Other
CASAVECCHIA, KAREN
Noll Law Firm
PREMIER HOME HEALTH CARE
MARTIN CLEARWATER & BELL
01/20/2022
▼
Case Info
Court
Nassau Supreme Court
Index Number
602061/2019
Status
Disposed
Year Filed
2019
Case Name
CASAVECCHIA, KAREN vs. PREMIER HOME HEALTH CARE
Case Type
OM-Other
Track
Standard
RJI Filed
07/15/2019
NOI Due
11/18/2021
NOI Filed
08/27/2021
Calendar Number
2021H1178
Jury Status
Jury At Plaintiff's Request
Justice
Next Appearance
01/20/2022
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
CASAVECCHIA, KAREN
Attorney / FirmNoll Law Firm
Defendant / Respondent
PREMIER HOME HEALTH CARE
Attorneys / FirmsMARTIN CLEARWATER & BELL
Motions (2)
#
Date Filed
Filed By
Relief Sought
Submit Date
Answer
Status
Decision
Order Signed
2
10/22/2021
Judgment - Summary
01/20/2022
Yes
Decided: 01/20/2022 Withdrawn Before Justice: Cozzens Jr., Hon. R. Bruce
1
09/26/2019
Parties - Add/Substitute/Intervene
10/23/2019
Yes
Decided: 01/15/2020 Granted Before Justice: Cozzens Jr., Hon. R. Bruce
Short Form Order
01/15/2020
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (63)
Doc #
Date Filed
Document
Description
Motion #
Filing User
File
1
02/12/2019
SUMMONS + COMPLAINT
Richard E Noll
2
03/18/2019
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
Premier Home Health Care Services
Richard E Noll
3
03/21/2019
ANSWER
Answer
Jeffrey Allen Shor
4
03/21/2019
AFFIRMATION
Redaction form
Jeffrey Allen Shor
5
03/21/2019
STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING
Statement of Authorization
Jeffrey Allen Shor
6
07/15/2019
PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE REQUEST
Richard E Noll
7
07/15/2019
RJI -RE: REQUEST FOR PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE
Richard E Noll
8
07/22/2019
COURT NOTICE
Joyce Lopez
9
09/10/2019
ORDER - PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE
Maria Spagnuolo
10
09/25/2019
NOTICE OF MOTION
001
Richard E Noll
11
09/25/2019
AFFIRMATION
001
Richard E Noll
12
09/25/2019
EXHIBIT(S)
Pleadings
001
Richard E Noll
13
09/25/2019
EXHIBIT(S)
Defendants response
001
Richard E Noll
14
09/25/2019
EXHIBIT(S)
Supplemental Summons & Amended Complaint
001
Richard E Noll
15
01/24/2020
ORDER - AMENDING CAPTION
001
Arlene A Tiercy
16
01/16/2020
NOTICE OF ENTRY
Order with Notice of Entry
Richard E Noll
17
02/27/2020
ANSWER
Answer & Initial Demands of Defendant Cynthia Thomas
Alyssa Renee Rodriguez
18
02/27/2020
AFFIDAVIT
Redaction Cover Page
Alyssa Renee Rodriguez
19
08/16/2021
RESPONSE TO DEMAND
Richard E Noll
20
08/17/2021
STIPULATION - DISCOVERY ( REQUEST TO SO ORDER )
Richard E Noll
21
09/01/2021
ORDER - CERTIFICATION
Arlene A Tiercy
22
08/27/2021
NOTE OF ISSUE:WITH JURY
Richard E Noll
23
09/07/2021
NOTICE OF CHANGE OF FIRM NAME OR ADDRESS (PRE RJI)
Richard E Noll
24
10/21/2021
NOTICE OF MOTION
Notice of Motion in Support of Motion for Summary Judgment
002
Jonathan Christopher Lee
25
10/21/2021
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION
Affirmation in Support of Motion for Summary Judgment
002
Jonathan Christopher Lee
26
10/21/2021
STATEMENT OF MATERIAL FACTS
002
Jonathan Christopher Lee
27
10/21/2021
EXHIBIT(S)
Expert Affirmation of Vincent P. Garbitelli, M.D.
002
Jonathan Christopher Lee
28
10/21/2021
EXHIBIT(S)
Summons and Complaint
002
Jonathan Christopher Lee
29
10/21/2021
EXHIBIT(S)
Answers on behalf of Premier Home Health Care Services
002
Jonathan Christopher Lee
30
10/21/2021
EXHIBIT(S)
Plaintiff's Motion to Amend the Complaint
002
Jonathan Christopher Lee
31
10/21/2021
EXHIBIT(S)
Plaintiffs Supplemental Summons and Verified Amended Complaint;
002
Jonathan Christopher Lee
32
10/21/2021
EXHIBIT(S)
Order and Notice of Entry amending caption
002
Jonathan Christopher Lee
33
10/21/2021
EXHIBIT(S)
Verified Answer on behalf of Cynthia Thomas
002
Jonathan Christopher Lee
34
10/21/2021
EXHIBIT(S)
Plaintiffs Verified Bill of Particulars
002
Jonathan Christopher Lee
35
10/21/2021
EXHIBIT(S)
Deposition testimony of Karen Casavecchia
002
Jonathan Christopher Lee
36
10/21/2021
EXHIBIT(S)
Deposition Testimony of Cynthia Thomas
002
Jonathan Christopher Lee
37
10/21/2021
EXHIBIT(S)
Note of Issue and Certificate of Readiness for Trial
002
Jonathan Christopher Lee
38
10/21/2021
EXHIBIT(S)
Certification Order
002
Jonathan Christopher Lee
39
10/21/2021
EXHIBIT(S)
Premier Home Health Care's records
002
Jonathan Christopher Lee
40
10/21/2021
EXHIBIT(S)
Records from Franklin Hospital
002
Jonathan Christopher Lee
41
10/21/2021
EXHIBIT(S)
Records from South Nassau Communities Hospital
002
Jonathan Christopher Lee
42
10/21/2021
EXHIBIT(S)
Records from Mercy Medical Center Hospital
002
Jonathan Christopher Lee
43
10/21/2021
EXHIBIT(S)
Records from the office of Michael H. Brisman, M.D.
002
Jonathan Christopher Lee
44
10/21/2021
EXHIBIT(S)
Records from the office of Stewart Fox, M.D.
002
Jonathan Christopher Lee
45
10/21/2021
EXHIBIT(S)
Records from theoffice of Harold Sirota, D.O.
002
Jonathan Christopher Lee
46
11/18/2021
STIPULATION - ADJOURNMENT OF MOTION
002
Richard Edward Noll
47
01/12/2022
STIPULATION - WITHDRAWING MOTION/ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE
002
Graham Maxwell Gering
61
04/22/2022
WRONGFUL DEATH COMPROMISE ORDER (PROPOSED)
Richard Edward Noll
62
04/22/2022
AFFIRMATION
Richard Edward Noll
63
04/22/2022
AFFIDAVIT
Richard Edward Noll
64
04/22/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex 1 death certificate
Richard Edward Noll
65
04/22/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex 2 Letters of Administration
Richard Edward Noll
66
04/22/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex 3 Summons and Verified Complaint
Richard Edward Noll
67
04/22/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex 4 Verified Answer
Richard Edward Noll
68
04/22/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex 5 Verified Bill of Particulars
Richard Edward Noll
69
04/22/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex 6 - Settlement offer
Richard Edward Noll
70
04/22/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex 7 Law Office disbursements
Richard Edward Noll
71
04/22/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex 8 Retainer Agreement
Richard Edward Noll
72
04/22/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex 9 - Funeral bill
Richard Edward Noll
73
04/22/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex 10 Medicare lien
Richard Edward Noll
74
04/27/2022
AFFIRMATION
Richard Edward Noll
76
06/27/2022
STIPULATION - DISCONTINUANCE (POST RJI)
Stip of discontinuance with prejudice as to defendants Premier Home Health Care and Cynthia Thomas
Ex. D - Verified Bill of Particulars as to Premier
3
Jenna Lyn Fierstein
89
03/29/2024
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex. E - Verified Supplemental Bill of Particulars as to Premier
3
Jenna Lyn Fierstein
90
03/29/2024
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex. F - Plaintiff's Bill of Particulars as to Workmen's Circle
3
Jenna Lyn Fierstein
91
03/29/2024
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex. G - Premier's Records as to Diallo (part 1 of 2)
3
Jenna Lyn Fierstein
92
03/29/2024
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex. G - Premier's Records as to Diallo (part 2 of 2)
3
Jenna Lyn Fierstein
93
03/29/2024
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex. H - Premier's Records as to Decedent (part 1)
3
Jenna Lyn Fierstein
94
03/29/2024
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex. H - Premier's Records as to Decedent (part 2)
3
Jenna Lyn Fierstein
95
03/29/2024
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex. H - Premier's Records as to Decedent (part 3)
3
Jenna Lyn Fierstein
96
03/29/2024
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex. H - Premier's Records as to Decedent (part 4)
3
Jenna Lyn Fierstein
97
03/29/2024
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex. I - Plaintiff's Signed June 21, 2023 Deposition Transcript
3
Jenna Lyn Fierstein
98
03/29/2024
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex. J - Plaintiff's Signed October 18, 2023 Deposition Transcript
3
Jenna Lyn Fierstein
99
03/29/2024
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex. K - Montefiore Psychiatry Records
3
Jenna Lyn Fierstein
100
03/29/2024
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex. L - Montefiore North ER Records
3
Jenna Lyn Fierstein
101
03/29/2024
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex. M - Montefiore North PR Records
3
Jenna Lyn Fierstein
102
03/29/2024
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex. N - Montefiore Einstein 10N85 Records
3
Jenna Lyn Fierstein
103
03/29/2024
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex. O - Records of Priority Home Care (a Subsidiary of Premier)
3
Jenna Lyn Fierstein
104
03/29/2024
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex. P - Montefiore Medical Center North Records
3
Jenna Lyn Fierstein
105
03/29/2024
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex. Q - Records of True Care Home Health Care
3
Jenna Lyn Fierstein
106
03/29/2024
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex. R - Note of Issue with Affirmation and Certificate of Readiness
3
Jenna Lyn Fierstein
107
03/29/2024
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex. S - FDNY Records
3
Jenna Lyn Fierstein
108
03/29/2024
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex. T - Jewish Home Life Healthcare Records
3
Jenna Lyn Fierstein
109
03/29/2024
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex. U - Case Result for First Action on New York State Unified Court System Website
3
Jenna Lyn Fierstein
110
03/29/2024
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex. V - Order of Dismissal of First Action
3
Jenna Lyn Fierstein
111
03/29/2024
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex. W - So-Ordered Stipulation Withdrawing Wrongful Death Claims and Striking Claimed Losses for Same
3
Jenna Lyn Fierstein
112
03/29/2024
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex. X - Emails with Court Confirming Motion is Timely Filed on March 29, 2024
3
Jenna Lyn Fierstein
113
04/09/2024
STIPULATION - ADJOURNMENT OF MOTION
Stipulation to adjourn the motion
3
Elliot B Sinel
114
05/14/2024
STIPULATION - ADJOURNMENT OF MOTION
Stipulation to adjourn on consent
3
Elliot B Sinel
115
05/23/2024
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION
Plaintiff's Attorney Affirmation in Opposition
3
Elliot B Sinel
116
05/23/2024
EXHIBIT(S)
Plaintiff's Expert Affirmation in Opposition
3
Elliot B Sinel
117
05/23/2024
EXHIBIT(S)
Excerpt from Non-Party Montefiore Medical Records
3
Elliot B Sinel
118
05/23/2024
STATEMENT OF MATERIAL FACTS
Plaintiff's Statement of Material Facts in Opposition
3
Elliot B Sinel
119
06/05/2024
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN REPLY
Affirmation of Jenna L. Fierstein in Reply and Further Support of Premier's Motion for Summary Judgment and Dismissal of Plaintiff's Complaint
3
Jenna Lyn Fierstein
120
01/28/2025
DECISION + ORDER ON MOTION
Dated 1/21/2025
3
Shomari Dixon
121
01/28/2025
NOTICE OF ENTRY
Order with Notice of Entry
3
Jenna Lyn Fierstein
122
01/29/2025
NOTICE OF APPEAL
Notice of Appeal, Informational Statement, Notice of Entry, Order Appealed From, Affirmation of Service
3
Jenna Lyn Fierstein
123
01/29/2025
INFORMATIONAL STATEMENT
3
Jenna Lyn Fierstein
124
01/29/2025
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
Corrected Affirmation of Service for Notice of Appeal package (previously annexed at NYSCEF Doc. No.122)
3
Jenna Lyn Fierstein
125
02/27/2025
NOTICE OF MOTION
Notice of Motion for Leave to Reargue and, Upon Reargument, Granting Defendant Premier Summary Judgment Dismissing Plaintiff's Complaint Against It
4
Jenna Lyn Fierstein
126
02/27/2025
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION
Affirmation of Jenna L. Fierstein dated Feb. 27, 2025, in Support of Motion for Leave to Reargue and, Upon Reargument, Granting Premier Summary Judgment Dismissing Plaintiff's Complaint
4
Jenna Lyn Fierstein
127
02/27/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Exhibit 1 - Order dated Jan. 21, 2025 Entered Jan. 28, 2025, on Underlying Motion (Previously filed at Doc. No. 120)
Exhibit 3 - Plaintiff's Opposition to Premier's Summary Judgment Motion (Docs. 115-118)
4
Jenna Lyn Fierstein
149
02/27/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Exhibit 4 - Reply Affirmation on Underlying Motion (Doc. 119)
4
Jenna Lyn Fierstein
150
02/27/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Exhibit 2La - Part 1 of Exhibit 2L, Part 12 of Premier's Summary Judgment Motion (Doc.100)
4
Jenna Lyn Fierstein
151
02/27/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Exhibit 2Lb - Part 2 of Exhibit 2L, Part 12 of Premier's Summary Judgment Motion (Doc.100)
4
Jenna Lyn Fierstein
152
02/27/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Exhibit 2Lc - Part 3 of Exhibit 2L, Part 12 of Premier's Summary Judgment Motion (Doc.100)
4
Jenna Lyn Fierstein
153
02/27/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Exhibit 2Ld - Part 4 of Exhibit 2L, Part 12 of Premier's Summary Judgment Motion (Doc.100)
4
Jenna Lyn Fierstein
154
02/27/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Exhibit 2Le - Part 5 of Exhibit 2L, Part 12 of Premier's Summary Judgment Motion (Doc.100)
4
Jenna Lyn Fierstein
155
02/27/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Exhibit 2Lf - Part 6 of Exhibit 2L, Part 12 of Premier's Summary Judgment Motion (Doc.100)
4
Jenna Lyn Fierstein
156
02/27/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Exhibit 2Lg - Part 7 of 7 of Exhibit 2L, Part 12 of Premier's Summary Judgment Motion (Doc.100)
4
Jenna Lyn Fierstein
157
02/27/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Exhibit 2Ta - Part 1 of Exhibit 2T, Part 20 of Premier's Summary Judgment Motion (Doc.108)
4
Jenna Lyn Fierstein
158
02/27/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Exhibit 2Tb - Part 2 of Exhibit 2T, Part 20 of Premier's Summary Judgment Motion (Doc.108)
4
Jenna Lyn Fierstein
159
02/27/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Exhibit 2Tc - Part 3 of 3 of Exhibit 2T, Part 20 of Premier's Summary Judgment Motion (Doc.108)
4
Jenna Lyn Fierstein
160
02/27/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Exhibit 2Ma - Part 1 of Exhibit 2M, Part 13 of Premier's Summary Judgment Motion (Doc.101)
4
Jenna Lyn Fierstein
161
02/27/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Exhibit 2Mb - Part 2 of Exhibit 2M, Part 13 of Premier's Summary Judgment Motion (Doc.101)
4
Jenna Lyn Fierstein
162
02/27/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Exhibit 2Mc - Part 3 of Exhibit 2M, Part 13 of Premier's Summary Judgment Motion (Doc.101)
4
Jenna Lyn Fierstein
163
02/27/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Exhibit 2Md - Part 4 of Exhibit 2M, Part 13 of Premier's Summary Judgment Motion (Doc.101)
4
Jenna Lyn Fierstein
164
02/27/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Exhibit 2Me - Part 5 of Exhibit 2M, Part 13 of Premier's Summary Judgment Motion (Doc.101)
4
Jenna Lyn Fierstein
165
02/27/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Exhibit 2Mf - Part 6 of Exhibit 2M, Part 13 of Premier's Summary Judgment Motion (Doc.101)
4
Jenna Lyn Fierstein
166
02/27/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Exhibit 2Mg - Part 7 of Exhibit 2M, Part 13 of Premier's Summary Judgment Motion (Doc.101)
4
Jenna Lyn Fierstein
167
02/27/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Exhibit 2Mh - Part 8 of Exhibit 2M, Part 13 of Premier's Summary Judgment Motion (Doc.101)
4
Jenna Lyn Fierstein
168
02/27/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Exhibit 2Mi - Part 9 of Exhibit 2M, Part 13 of Premier's Summary Judgment Motion (Doc.101)
4
Jenna Lyn Fierstein
169
02/27/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Exhibit 2Mj - Part 10 of Exhibit 2M, Part 13 of Premier's Summary Judgment Motion (Doc.101)
4
Jenna Lyn Fierstein
170
02/27/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Exhibit 2Mk - Part 11 of Exhibit 2M, Part 13 of Premier's Summary Judgment Motion (Doc.101)
4
Jenna Lyn Fierstein
171
02/27/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Exhibit 2Ml - Part 12 of Exhibit 2M, Part 13 of Premier's Summary Judgment Motion (Doc.101)
4
Jenna Lyn Fierstein
172
02/27/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Exhibit 2Mm - Part 13 of Exhibit 2M, Part 13 of Premier's Summary Judgment Motion (Doc.101)
4
Jenna Lyn Fierstein
173
02/27/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Exhibit 2Mn - Part 14 of Exhibit 2M, Part 13 of Premier's Summary Judgment Motion (Doc.101)
4
Jenna Lyn Fierstein
174
02/27/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Exhibit 2Mo - Part 15 of Exhibit 2M, Part 13 of Premier's Summary Judgment Motion (Doc.101)
4
Jenna Lyn Fierstein
175
02/27/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Exhibit 2Mp - Part 16 of 16 of Exhibit 2M, Part 13 of Premier's Summary Judgment Motion (Doc.101)
4
Jenna Lyn Fierstein
176
02/27/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Exhibit 2Pa - Part 1 of Exhibit 2P, Part 16 of Premier's Summary Judgment Motion (Doc.104)
4
Jenna Lyn Fierstein
177
02/27/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Exhibit 2Pb - Part 2 of Exhibit 2P, Part 16 of Premier's Summary Judgment Motion (Doc.104)
4
Jenna Lyn Fierstein
178
02/27/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Exhibit 2Pc - Part 3 of Exhibit 2P, Part 16 of Premier's Summary Judgment Motion (Doc.104)
4
Jenna Lyn Fierstein
179
02/27/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Exhibit 2Pd - Part 4 of Exhibit 2P, Part 16 of Premier's Summary Judgment Motion (Doc.104)
4
Jenna Lyn Fierstein
180
02/27/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Exhibit 2Pe - Part 5 of Exhibit 2P, Part 16 of Premier's Summary Judgment Motion (Doc.104)
4
Jenna Lyn Fierstein
181
02/27/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Exhibit 2Pf - Part 6 of Exhibit 2P, Part 16 of Premier's Summary Judgment Motion (Doc.104)
4
Jenna Lyn Fierstein
182
02/27/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Exhibit 2Pg - Part 7 of Exhibit 2P, Part 16 of Premier's Summary Judgment Motion (Doc.104)
4
Jenna Lyn Fierstein
183
02/27/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Exhibit 2Ph - Part 8 of Exhibit 2P, Part 16 of Premier's Summary Judgment Motion (Doc.104)
4
Jenna Lyn Fierstein
184
02/27/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Exhibit 2Pi - Part 9 of Exhibit 2P, Part 16 of Premier's Summary Judgment Motion (Doc.104)
4
Jenna Lyn Fierstein
185
02/27/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Exhibit 2Pj - Part 10 of Exhibit 2P, Part 16 of Premier's Summary Judgment Motion (Doc.104)
4
Jenna Lyn Fierstein
186
02/27/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Exhibit 2Pk - Part 11 of Exhibit 2P, Part 16 of Premier's Summary Judgment Motion (Doc.104)
4
Jenna Lyn Fierstein
187
02/27/2025
EXHIBIT(S)
Exhibit 2Pl - Part 12 of 12 of Exhibit 2P, Part 16 of Premier's Summary Judgment Motion (Doc.104)
4
Jenna Lyn Fierstein
188
02/27/2025
LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE
Letter-Request for Oral Argument
4
Jenna Lyn Fierstein
189
03/10/2025
STIPULATION - ADJOURNMENT OF MOTION
Stipulation to adjourn the motion
4
Elliot B Sinel
190
04/03/2025
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION
Plaintiff's Attorney Affirmation in Opposition
4
Elliot B Sinel
191
04/17/2025
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN REPLY
4
Jenna Lyn Fierstein
192
05/19/2025
NOTICE OF CHANGE OF FIRM NAME OR ADDRESS (POST RJI)
Notice of Change of Firm Name
Christopher T Rogers
193
08/13/2025
ORDER - RENEW/REARGUE
SHORT FORM ORDER DATED 08/12/2025
4
Michelle Alemany
194
08/18/2025
NOTICE OF ENTRY
Notice of Entry
4
Christopher T Rogers
195
09/03/2025
LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE
Letter to Judge Perez Requesting Adjournment of Pretrial Conference in View of Pending Appeal from Jan. 21, 2025 Order on Premier's Motion for Summary Judgment Dismissing Complaint (Motion Seq. No. 003)
Jenna Lyn Fierstein
196
10/24/2025
COPY OF SUBPOENA
Lissette Rodriguez
197
01/29/2026
NOTICE OF CHANGE OF FIRM NAME OR ADDRESS (POST RJI)
Notice of Change of Firm Address
Christopher T Rogers
198
03/10/2026
DEMAND FOR:
Demand for Trial Authorizations, dated March 10, 2026
Decided: 03/08/2023 Denied Before Justice: Capella, Hon. Joseph E.
Short Form Order
03/08/2023
1
03/10/2017
Amend Caption/Pleadings
03/31/2017
No
Decided: 07/16/2018 Decided Before Justice: Higgitt, Hon. John R.
Short Form Order
07/16/2018
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (94)
Doc #
Date Filed
Document
Description
Motion #
Filing User
File
1
11/08/2016
SUMMONS + COMPLAINT
S&C, VERIFICATION & 3012A
Elliot B Sinel
2
11/13/2016
COMPLAINT (AMENDED)
AMENDED S&C
Elliot B Sinel
3
12/06/2016
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
AOS WORKMENS VIA SECY STATE AMENDED
Elliot B Sinel
4
12/07/2016
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
AOS JOPAL DBA WORKMENS
Elliot B Sinel
5
12/12/2016
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
AOS Premier Home Health Care Services
Elliot B Sinel
6
12/13/2016
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
AOS Jopal Bronx via facility
Elliot B Sinel
7
01/12/2017
ANSWER
Verified Answer to Plaintiff's Amended Verified Complaint
Christopher T Rogers
8
01/12/2017
DEMAND FOR:
Demand for a Certificate of Merit
Christopher T Rogers
9
01/12/2017
DEMAND FOR BILL OF PARTICULARS
Demand for a Verified Bill of Particulars
Christopher T Rogers
10
01/12/2017
DEMAND FOR:
Demand for Expert Witness Information
Christopher T Rogers
11
01/12/2017
DEMAND FOR:
Demand for Disclosure as to Medicare/Medicaid/Private Liens
Christopher T Rogers
12
01/12/2017
DEMAND FOR:
E-Discovery and Social Media Demand and Litigation Hold
Christopher T Rogers
13
01/12/2017
NOTICE OF DISCOVERY AND INSPECTION
Notice for Discovery and Inspection
Christopher T Rogers
14
01/12/2017
DEMAND FOR:
Supplemental Demand
Christopher T Rogers
15
01/12/2017
NOTICE OF DEPOSITION UPON ORAL EXAMINATION
Notice to Take Deposition Upon Oral Examination
Christopher T Rogers
16
03/10/2017
NOTICE OF MOTION
001
Elliot B Sinel
17
03/10/2017
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT
001
Elliot B Sinel
18
03/10/2017
EXHIBIT(S)
Death Certificate
001
Elliot B Sinel
19
03/10/2017
EXHIBIT(S)
Pleadings
001
Elliot B Sinel
20
03/10/2017
EXHIBIT(S)
Letters of Administration
001
Elliot B Sinel
21
03/10/2017
EXHIBIT(S)
Stipulation Amending Caption
001
Elliot B Sinel
22
03/10/2017
RJI -RE: NOTICE OF MOTION
001
Elliot B Sinel
23
03/21/2017
NOTICE OF CROSS-MOTION
Notice of Cross-Motion
001
Christopher T Rogers
24
03/21/2017
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF CROSS-MOTION
Affirmation in Support
001
Christopher T Rogers
25
03/21/2017
EXHIBIT(S)
Amended Summons and Amended Verified Complaint
001
Christopher T Rogers
26
03/21/2017
EXHIBIT(S)
Verified Answer
001
Christopher T Rogers
27
03/21/2017
EXHIBIT(S)
Letters of Administration
001
Christopher T Rogers
28
03/23/2017
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO CROSS-MOTION AND IN FURTHER SUPPORT OF MOTION
001
Elliot B Sinel
29
03/30/2017
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN REPLY
Reply Affirmation
001
Christopher T Rogers
30
08/29/2018
DECISION + ORDER ON MOTION
DATED 7/24/2018
001
Melanie Ocasio
31
08/30/2018
NOTICE OF ENTRY
Order with Notice of Entry
Christopher T Rogers
32
11/14/2018
STIPULATION - OTHER - ( REQUEST TO SO ORDER )
Elliot B Sinel
33
01/02/2019
STIPULATION - SO ORDERED
dated 10/10/2018
Rosa E Matos
34
01/04/2019
ANSWER
Answer to Amended Complaint
Lori Rosen Semlies
35
02/22/2019
DEMAND FOR:
Demand for BP & Combined Demands
Lori Rosen Semlies
36
03/05/2019
NOTICE OF MEDICAL MALPRACTICE
NMM, Pleadings, BPS, Responses
Elliot B Sinel
37
03/05/2019
PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE REQUEST
Request for Preliminary Conference
Elliot B Sinel
38
05/13/2019
ORDER - PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE
DATED 5/6/2019
Sandra Riveralopez
39
08/16/2019
ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE
DATED AUGUST 12,2019
Sandra Riveralopez
40
12/16/2019
STIPULATION - SO ORDERED
DATED 11/18/2019
Patricia Aversa
41
03/06/2020
ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE
2/24/2020
Melanie Ocasio
42
04/06/2022
NOTICE OF CHANGE OF FIRM NAME OR ADDRESS (POST RJI)
Notice of Address Change
Elliot B Sinel
43
08/30/2022
NOTICE OF MOTION
2
Juan David Lopez Guevara
44
08/30/2022
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT
2
Juan David Lopez Guevara
45
08/30/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Summons and Verified Complaint.
2
Juan David Lopez Guevara
46
08/30/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Answer on behalf of PREMIER AND DALIO dat....
2
Juan David Lopez Guevara
47
08/30/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Court order dated July 24, 2018;
2
Juan David Lopez Guevara
48
08/30/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Answer on behalf of WORKMENS dated Janua....
2
Juan David Lopez Guevara
49
08/30/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Summons and Complaint 2019 action against....
2
Juan David Lopez Guevara
50
08/30/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Bill of Particulars as to WORMENS in ori....
2
Juan David Lopez Guevara
51
08/30/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Bill of Particulars as to PREMIER and DIA....
2
Juan David Lopez Guevara
52
08/30/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Plaintiffs Affirmation in Support of Mot....
2
Juan David Lopez Guevara
53
08/30/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
WORKMENS nonparty Affirmation in support....
2
Juan David Lopez Guevara
54
08/30/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
PREMIER and DIALLOs Affirmation in Opposi....
2
Juan David Lopez Guevara
55
08/30/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Plaintiffs Reply Affirmation in Support o....
2
Juan David Lopez Guevara
56
08/30/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Court Order dated September 11 2019.
2
Juan David Lopez Guevara
57
08/30/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Discharge Summary Montefiore Hospital.
2
Juan David Lopez Guevara
58
08/30/2022
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
Certificate of Service
2
Juan David Lopez Guevara
59
09/13/2022
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION
2
Elliot B Sinel
60
09/13/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Various Pleadings (first action)
2
Elliot B Sinel
61
09/13/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Letters of Administration
2
Elliot B Sinel
62
09/13/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Court Order dated July 24, 2018
2
Elliot B Sinel
63
09/13/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
So-Ordered Stipulation dated October 10, 2018
2
Elliot B Sinel
64
09/13/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Various Amended Pleadings (first action)
2
Elliot B Sinel
65
09/13/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Bill of Particulars (Jopal Bronx, LLC)
2
Elliot B Sinel
66
09/13/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Pleadings (second action)
2
Elliot B Sinel
67
09/13/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Bill of Particulars (Premier Home Health Care Services)
2
Elliot B Sinel
68
09/13/2022
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
2
Elliot B Sinel
69
09/14/2022
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION
Non-Party Premier Home Health Care Services, Inc.'s Affirmation of Counsel, Jenna L. Fierstein, in Opposition to Defendant's Untimely and Improper Motion
2
Jenna Lyn Fierstein
70
09/14/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex. A - Summons & Complaint filed at NYSCEF Doc. 1 Herein
2
Jenna Lyn Fierstein
71
09/14/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex. B - Amended Complaint filed at Doc. 2 Herein
2
Jenna Lyn Fierstein
72
09/14/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex. C - Letters of Administration filed by Plaintiff at Doc. 20 Herein
2
Jenna Lyn Fierstein
73
09/14/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex. D - Stipulation Signed by Movant, but Not Premier, filed at Doc. 21 Herein
2
Jenna Lyn Fierstein
74
09/14/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex. E - Mtn Seq. 001, at Docs. 16-22 Herein
2
Jenna Lyn Fierstein
75
09/14/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex. F - Mtn Seq. 001, Cross-Motion, at Docs. 23-29 Herein
2
Jenna Lyn Fierstein
76
09/14/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex. G - Affidavit of Service for Summons & Complaint in 2019 Action (Doc. 2 Therein)
2
Jenna Lyn Fierstein
77
09/14/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex. H - Premier's Answer in 2019 Action (Doc. 3 Therein)
2
Jenna Lyn Fierstein
78
09/14/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex. I - Premier's Preliminary Discovery Demands in 2019 Action (Docs. 4-11 Therein)
2
Jenna Lyn Fierstein
79
09/14/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex. J - Preliminary Conference Request by Plaintiff in 2019 Action (Doc. 12 Therein)
2
Jenna Lyn Fierstein
80
09/14/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex. K - Order Scheduling Preliminary Conference in 2019 Action (Doc. 14 Therein)
2
Jenna Lyn Fierstein
81
09/14/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex. L - Notice of Motion for Plaintiff's Aug. 6, 2019 Motion in 2019 Action (Doc. 15 Therein)
2
Jenna Lyn Fierstein
82
09/14/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex. M - July 24, 2018 Order with Notice of Entry (Doc. 31 Herein)
2
Jenna Lyn Fierstein
83
09/14/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex. N - September 11, 2019 Order in 2019 Action with Notice of Entry (Doc. 31 Therein)
2
Jenna Lyn Fierstein
84
09/14/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex. O - Order on May 6, 2019 Preliminary Conference Held Herein (Doc. 38 Herein)
2
Jenna Lyn Fierstein
85
09/20/2022
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN REPLY
2
Juan David Lopez Guevara
86
09/20/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Emails to PREMIER's and DIALLO's counsel
2
Juan David Lopez Guevara
87
03/16/2023
ORDER - RENEW/REARGUE
SHORT FORM ORDER DATED 0308/2023
2
Michelle Alemany
88
03/16/2023
NOTICE OF ENTRY
Order Denying Motion with Notice of Entry
2
Jenna Lyn Fierstein
89
03/31/2023
NOTICE OF ENTRY
2
Anna Carmela Maria Borea
90
09/20/2023
STIPULATION - DISCOVERY ( REQUEST TO SO ORDER )
Stipulation dated 9.20.2023
Elliot B Sinel
91
05/14/2025
ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE
DATED 5/2/2025
Ashley Williams
92
07/01/2025
ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE
SO ORDERED DATED; JUNE 24, 2025
Sandra Riveralopez
93
09/18/2025
ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE
DATED 9/3/2025
Sara Mallach
94
11/03/2025
ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE
DATED 10/22/2025
Michelle Alemany
32
Bronx Supreme Court
2017
27950/2017E (0027950/2017)
Disposed
Medical Malpractice
DELVECCHIO, ANTHONY
Sinel & Olesen, PLLC
VISITING NURSE SERVICE OF
MARTIN CLEARWATER & BELL
03/19/2024
Capella, Hon. Joseph E.
▼
Case Info
Court
Bronx Supreme Court
Index Number
27950/2017E (0027950/2017)
Status
Disposed
Year Filed
2017
Case Name
DELVECCHIO, ANTHONY vs. VISITING NURSE SERVICE OF
Case Type
Tort-Medical, Dental, or Podiatric Malpractice
Track
Complex
RJI Filed
10/31/2017
NOI Due
10/15/2021
NOI Filed
10/15/2021
Calendar Number
2021-01515
Jury Status
Jury At Plaintiff's Request
Justice
Capella, Hon. Joseph E.
Next Appearance
03/19/2024
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
DELVECCHIO, ANTHONY
Attorney / FirmSinel & Olesen, PLLC
Defendant / Respondent
VISITING NURSE SERVICE OF
Attorneys / FirmsMARTIN CLEARWATER & BELL
Motions (2)
#
Date Filed
Filed By
Relief Sought
Submit Date
Answer
Status
Decision
Order Signed
2
12/14/2021
Dismiss
03/31/2022
No
Decided: 12/15/2022 Decided Before Justice: Capella, Hon. Joseph E.
Memorandum
12/15/2022
1
12/03/2021
Judgment - Summary
03/31/2022
No
Decided: 12/15/2022 Decided Before Justice: Capella, Hon. Joseph E.
Memorandum
12/15/2022
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (94)
Doc #
Date Filed
Document
Description
Motion #
Filing User
File
1
08/24/2017
SUMMONS + COMPLAINT
+ Certificate of Merit
Elliot B Sinel
2
09/25/2017
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
Affidavit of Service for Visiting Nurse Service
Elliot B Sinel
3
09/25/2017
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
Affidavit of Service for VNS Choice
Elliot B Sinel
4
09/25/2017
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
Affidavit of Service for Premier Home
Elliot B Sinel
5
09/27/2017
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
Affidavit of Service for Premier Home
Elliot B Sinel
6
10/13/2017
ANSWER
Delvecchio v. Premier Home Health Care Center - Answer Premier Home Health Care Center
Jeffrey Allen Shor
7
10/13/2017
AFFIRMATION
Delvecchio v. Premier Home Health Care Center - Redaction Form
Jeffrey Allen Shor
8
10/13/2017
STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR ELECTRONIC FILING
Statement of authorization for electronic filing - claus
Jeffrey Allen Shor
9
10/13/2017
ANSWER
Diana M Carlino
10
10/13/2017
DEMAND FOR:
Diana M Carlino
11
10/13/2017
DEMAND FOR BILL OF PARTICULARS
Diana M Carlino
12
10/31/2017
NOTICE OF MEDICAL MALPRACTICE
NMM, Pleadings, BPs, Responses
Elliot B Sinel
13
10/31/2017
PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE REQUEST
Request for Preliminary Conference
Elliot B Sinel
14
10/31/2017
RJI -RE: NOTICE OF MEDICAL, DENTAL OR PODIATRIC MALPRACTICE
RJI
Elliot B Sinel
15
02/27/2018
ORDER - PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE
dated 2/1/2018
Rosa E Matos
16
09/11/2018
ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE
dated 7/23/2018
Rosa E Matos
17
09/13/2018
DEMAND FOR:
Demand for Authorization
James Samuel Newfield
18
09/18/2018
DEMAND FOR:
Kierra Nicole Greenwood
19
11/27/2018
STIPULATION - SO ORDERED
DATED 11/19/2018
Wanda Delgado
20
03/12/2019
ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE
DATED 2/19/2019
Jenny Leon
21
06/27/2019
STIPULATION - SO ORDERED
DATED 6/10/2019
Melanie Ocasio
22
09/06/2019
STIPULATION - SO ORDERED
Dated: 08/26/2019
Julio Grandgerard
23
11/13/2019
STIPULATION - SO ORDERED
DATED: 10/28/19
Shayna Laplante
24
12/26/2019
NOTICE OF CHANGE OF ATTORNEY (POST RJI)
Elliot B Sinel
25
02/13/2020
STIPULATION - SO ORDERED
DATED: FEBRUARY 3, 2020
Sandra Riveralopez
26
12/02/2020
STIPULATION - DISCONTINUANCE (POST RJI)
partial- claims v. VNS before 5.1.13
Diana M Carlino
27
12/10/2020
ORDER ( PROPOSED )
Stipulation and Order (Proposed)
Elliot B Sinel
28
01/22/2021
STIPULATION - SO ORDERED
DATED 12/10/2020.
Lissette Rodriguez
29
10/06/2021
STIPULATION - SO ORDERED
DATED 9/8/2021
Attanya Douglas
30
10/15/2021
NOTE OF ISSUE:WITH JURY
Elliot B Sinel
31
12/03/2021
NOTICE OF MOTION
NOM for Summary Judgment
1
Victoria Lynn Mosca
32
12/03/2021
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION
1
Victoria Lynn Mosca
33
12/03/2021
INFORMATIONAL STATEMENT
Document Specifications Statement
1
Victoria Lynn Mosca
34
12/03/2021
AFFIDAVIT OF FACTS
Statement of Material Facts
1
Victoria Lynn Mosca
35
12/03/2021
EXHIBIT(S)
Expert Affirmation
1
Victoria Lynn Mosca
36
12/03/2021
EXHIBIT(S)
P's summons, complaint, and certificate
1
Victoria Lynn Mosca
37
12/03/2021
EXHIBIT(S)
Premier Home Health Care Answer
1
Victoria Lynn Mosca
38
12/03/2021
EXHIBIT(S)
Visiting Nurse Service Answer
1
Victoria Lynn Mosca
39
12/03/2021
EXHIBIT(S)
Verified BP to Premier Home Health Care
1
Victoria Lynn Mosca
40
12/03/2021
EXHIBIT(S)
Verified BP to Visiting Nurse Service
1
Victoria Lynn Mosca
41
12/03/2021
EXHIBIT(S)
EBT of P Anthony Del Vecchio
1
Victoria Lynn Mosca
42
12/03/2021
EXHIBIT(S)
Premier Home Health Care Records
1
Victoria Lynn Mosca
43
12/03/2021
EXHIBIT(S)
Visiting Nurse Service Records 1 of 2
1
Victoria Lynn Mosca
44
12/03/2021
EXHIBIT(S)
Visiting Nurse Service Records 2 of 2
1
Victoria Lynn Mosca
45
12/03/2021
EXHIBIT(S)
Montefiore Records
1
Victoria Lynn Mosca
46
12/03/2021
EXHIBIT(S)
Note of Issue
1
Victoria Lynn Mosca
47
12/14/2021
NOTICE OF MOTION
VNS/CHOICE Notice of Motion for Summary Judgment
2
Kierra Nicole Greenwood
48
12/14/2021
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION
2
Kierra Nicole Greenwood
49
12/14/2021
STATEMENT OF INCOME AND EXPENSES
2
Kierra Nicole Greenwood
50
12/14/2021
EXHIBIT(S)
Summons & Complaint
2
Kierra Nicole Greenwood
51
12/14/2021
EXHIBIT(S)
VNS and CHOICE Answer
2
Kierra Nicole Greenwood
52
12/14/2021
EXHIBIT(S)
BP as to VNS
2
Kierra Nicole Greenwood
53
12/14/2021
EXHIBIT(S)
Stipulation of Discontinuance
2
Kierra Nicole Greenwood
54
12/14/2021
EXHIBIT(S)
NOI
2
Kierra Nicole Greenwood
55
12/14/2021
EXHIBIT(S)
Montefiore records pt 1
2
Kierra Nicole Greenwood
56
12/14/2021
EXHIBIT(S)
VNS records
2
Kierra Nicole Greenwood
57
12/14/2021
EXHIBIT(S)
Overton Affidavit
2
Kierra Nicole Greenwood
58
12/14/2021
EXHIBIT(S)
Montefiore Homecare records
2
Kierra Nicole Greenwood
59
12/14/2021
EXHIBIT(S)
Choice Affidavit
2
Kierra Nicole Greenwood
60
12/14/2021
EXHIBIT(S)
Revised Exhibit F p. 1-225
2
Kierra Nicole Greenwood
61
12/14/2021
EXHIBIT(S)
Revised Exhibit F p. 226-350
2
Kierra Nicole Greenwood
62
12/14/2021
EXHIBIT(S)
Revised Exhibit F p. 351-625
2
Kierra Nicole Greenwood
63
12/14/2021
EXHIBIT(S)
Revised Exhibit F p. 626-800
2
Kierra Nicole Greenwood
64
12/14/2021
EXHIBIT(S)
Revised Exhibit F p. 801-999
2
Kierra Nicole Greenwood
65
12/14/2021
EXHIBIT(S)
Revised Exhibit F p. 1000-1223
2
Kierra Nicole Greenwood
66
12/20/2021
STIPULATION - ADJOURNMENT OF MOTION
1
Elliot B Sinel
67
12/20/2021
STIPULATION - ADJOURNMENT OF MOTION
2
Elliot B Sinel
68
02/11/2022
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION
1
Elliot B Sinel
69
02/11/2022
STATEMENT OF MATERIAL FACTS
1
Elliot B Sinel
70
02/11/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Redacted Expert Affirmation
1
Elliot B Sinel
71
02/11/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
part 1 of 5 -- pages 1 - 50
1
Elliot B Sinel
72
02/11/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
part 2 of 5 -- pages 51-100
1
Elliot B Sinel
73
02/11/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
part 3 of 5 -- pages 101-150
1
Elliot B Sinel
74
02/11/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
part 4 of 5 -- pages 151-200
1
Elliot B Sinel
75
02/11/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
part 5 of 5 -- pages 201-221
1
Elliot B Sinel
76
02/11/2022
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION
2
Elliot B Sinel
77
02/11/2022
STATEMENT OF MATERIAL FACTS
2
Elliot B Sinel
78
02/11/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Redacted Expert Affirmation
2
Elliot B Sinel
79
02/18/2022
STIPULATION - ADJOURNMENT OF MOTION
Adjourns Mot sequence nos. 1 and 2-as to all defendants
2
Charmagne A Padua
80
03/07/2022
AFFIRMATION
Reply Affirmation
1
Victoria Lynn Mosca
81
03/11/2022
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN REPLY
VNS Home Care,II and VNS Choice
2
Charmagne A Padua
82
03/11/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Certified Copy Home Care Records
2
Charmagne A Padua
83
03/11/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
EXHIBIT L PART 1
2
Charmagne A Padua
84
03/11/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
EXHIBIT L PART 2
2
Charmagne A Padua
85
04/05/2022
NOTICE OF CHANGE OF FIRM NAME OR ADDRESS (POST RJI)
Notice of Change of Address
Elliot B Sinel
86
12/23/2022
ORDER - DISMISSAL
Short Form Order and Decision and Order dated 12/15/2022
2
Neil Espinal
87
12/23/2022
ORDER - SUMMARY JUDGMENT
Short Form Order and Decision and Order dated 12/15/2022 DENIED
1
Neil Espinal
88
12/23/2022
NOTICE OF ENTRY
& Order-MSJ Decision-Grants VNS Choice, Denies VNS Home Care
2
Charmagne A Padua
89
12/27/2022
NOTICE OF ENTRY
Notice of Entry - Order re VNS SJM
Elliot B Sinel
90
12/27/2022
NOTICE OF ENTRY
Notice of Entry - Replacing Document #89 as erroneously filed
Elliot B Sinel
91
01/30/2023
NOTICE OF ENTRY
Notice of Entry
Elliot B Sinel
92
01/30/2024
RESPONSE TO DEMAND
Response to Plaintiff's Demand for Expert Witness Info
James Samuel Newfield
93
02/06/2024
CONSENT TO CHANGE ATTORNEY (POST RJI)
James Samuel Newfield
94
02/29/2024
DEMAND FOR:
VNS Demand for Trial Authorizations-Premier, Dr Gomez
Decided: 12/14/2022 Decided Before Justice: Cohen, Hon. David B.
Short Form Order
12/14/2022
7
04/01/2022
Class Action
06/03/2022
Yes
Decided: 11/10/2022 Decided Before Justice: Cohen, Hon. David B.
Memorandum-Submit Order/Judgment
11/10/2022
6
08/20/2020
Renew/Reargue/Resettle/Reconsider
10/13/2020
Yes
Decided: 11/13/2020 Decided Before Justice: Cohen, Hon. David B.
Short Form Order
11/13/2020
5
02/19/2020
Compel
10/13/2020
Yes
Decided: 10/13/2020 Decided Before Justice: Cohen, Hon. David B.
Short Form Order
10/13/2020
4
02/18/2020
Dismiss
07/16/2020
Yes
Decided: 07/16/2020 Decided Before Justice: Cohen, Hon. David B.
Short Form Order
07/16/2020
3
01/13/2020
Injunction/Restraining Order
07/16/2020
No
Decided: 07/16/2020 Decided Before Justice: Cohen, Hon. David B.
Short Form Order
07/16/2020
2
05/21/2018
Stay
01/09/2019
Yes
Decided: 01/09/2019 Decided Before Justice: Cohen, Hon. David B.
Short Form Order
01/09/2019
1
09/28/2016
Dismiss
09/27/2017
No
Decided: 12/18/2017 Decided Before Justice: Cohen, Hon. David B.
Short Form Order
12/18/2017
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (457)
Doc #
Date Filed
Document
Description
Motion #
Filing User
File
1
06/16/2016
SUMMONS + COMPLAINT
Lloyd R Ambinder
2
06/23/2016
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
Lloyd R Ambinder
3
07/13/2016
STIPULATION - TIME TO ANSWER
Stipulation Extend Time to Answer
James Edward Mcgrath
4
08/24/2016
STIPULATION - TIME TO ANSWER
Stipulation extending Defendants time to answer or otherwise respond to the Complaint
John B Fulfree
5
09/16/2016
NOTICE OF MOTION
Notice of Motion to Dismiss
001
John B Fulfree
6
09/16/2016
AFFIDAVIT
Affidavit of Alice J. Lousberg in Support of Motion to Dismiss
001
John B Fulfree
7
09/16/2016
EXHIBIT(S)
Lousberg Aff. Ex. A - Collective Bargaining Agreement
001
John B Fulfree
8
09/16/2016
EXHIBIT(S)
Lousberg Aff. Ex. B - 3/1/2012 MOA
001
John B Fulfree
9
09/16/2016
EXHIBIT(S)
Lousberg Aff. Ex. C - 6/23/2014 MOA
001
John B Fulfree
10
09/16/2016
EXHIBIT(S)
Lousberg Aff. Ex. D - 12/22/2015 MOA
001
John B Fulfree
11
09/16/2016
AFFIRMATION
Affirmation of James E. McGrath, III, Esq.
001
John B Fulfree
12
09/16/2016
EXHIBIT(S)
McGrath Affirm. Ex. E - NYSDOL Opinion Letter 3/11/2010
001
John B Fulfree
13
09/16/2016
EXHIBIT(S)
McGrath Affirm. Ex. F - NYSDOL Opinion Letter 8/26/2009
001
John B Fulfree
14
09/16/2016
MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN SUPPORT
Memorandum of Law in Support of Motion to Dismiss
001
John B Fulfree
15
09/16/2016
RJI -RE: NOTICE OF MOTION
Request for Judicial Intervention
001
John B Fulfree
16
09/21/2016
STIPULATION - BRIEFING SCHEDULE
Milana Dostanitch
17
10/12/2016
MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN OPPOSITION
001
Michele A. Moreno
18
11/01/2016
MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN REPLY
Reply Memorandum of Law in Further Support of Defendants Motion to Dismiss Plaintiffs Complaint
001
John B Fulfree
19
04/17/2017
LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE
001
Milana Dostanitch
20
04/17/2017
EXHIBIT(S)
Hon. Edmead's Decision 4-11-2017 Decision
001
Milana Dostanitch
21
04/18/2017
LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE
Defendant's Response and Opposition to Plaintiff's April 17, 2017 Correspondence
001
John B Fulfree
22
04/18/2017
AFFIDAVIT
Affidavit of Gregory Turchan with Exhibit A
001
John B Fulfree
23
04/20/2017
LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE
001
Ladonna Lusher
24
04/20/2017
LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE
Defendant's Response and Opposition to Plaintiff's April 20, 2017 Correspondence with Enclosure
001
John B Fulfree
25
10/10/2017
LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE
Letter to Justice Cohen from James E. McGrath, III
001
John B Fulfree
26
10/10/2017
EXHIBIT(S)
Enclosure - Letter to Justice Cohen from James E. McGrath, III
001
John B Fulfree
27
10/14/2017
LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE
001
Ladonna Lusher
28
10/16/2017
LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE
Letter to Justice Cohen from James E. McGrath, III
001
John B Fulfree
29
12/27/2017
ORDER - MOTION - LONG FORM
001
Ellen Apple
30
03/02/2018
NOTICE OF ENTRY
Lloyd R Ambinder
31
03/14/2018
ANSWER
John B Fulfree
32
03/19/2018
NOTICE OF APPEAL
John B Fulfree
33
03/19/2018
PRE-ARGUMENT STATEMENT
John B Fulfree
34
03/19/2018
EXHIBIT(S)
Exhibit A to Pre-Argument Statement
John B Fulfree
35
04/18/2018
NOTICE
Jack Wong
36
04/19/2018
PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE REQUEST
Ladonna Lusher
37
05/21/2018
NOTICE OF MOTION
Notice of Motion to Stay
002
John B Fulfree
38
05/21/2018
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION
Affirmation in Support of Motion to Stay
002
John B Fulfree
39
05/21/2018
EXHIBIT(S)
Decisions Granting Motions for Leave to Appeal
002
John B Fulfree
40
05/21/2018
EXHIBIT(S)
Complaint
002
John B Fulfree
41
05/21/2018
EXHIBIT(S)
Premier's Motion to Dismiss
002
John B Fulfree
42
05/21/2018
EXHIBIT(S)
Decision re: Premier's Motion to Dismiss
002
John B Fulfree
43
05/21/2018
EXHIBIT(S)
Notice of Entry
002
John B Fulfree
44
05/21/2018
EXHIBIT(S)
Answer
002
John B Fulfree
45
05/21/2018
EXHIBIT(S)
Notice of Appeal
002
John B Fulfree
46
05/21/2018
EXHIBIT(S)
Amicus Brief
002
John B Fulfree
47
05/21/2018
EXHIBIT(S)
March 11, 2010 DOL Opinion Letter
002
John B Fulfree
48
05/21/2018
EXHIBIT(S)
Nov. 14, 2013 DOL Opinion Letter
002
John B Fulfree
49
05/21/2018
EXHIBIT(S)
DOL Emergency Rule
002
John B Fulfree
50
05/21/2018
EXHIBIT(S)
Court of Appeals Docket
002
John B Fulfree
51
05/21/2018
EXHIBIT(S)
Vizeltir Complaint
002
John B Fulfree
52
05/21/2018
EXHIBIT(S)
Order Granting Stay - Vizeltir
002
John B Fulfree
53
05/21/2018
MEMORANDUM OF LAW
Memorandum of Law in Support of Motion to Stay
002
John B Fulfree
54
05/30/2018
AFFIRMATION
of LaDonna Lusher
002
Ladonna Lusher
55
05/30/2018
EXHIBIT(S)
Court of Appeals Decision List denying Moreno stay
002
Ladonna Lusher
56
05/30/2018
EXHIBIT(S)
Summons and Complaint
002
Ladonna Lusher
57
05/30/2018
EXHIBIT(S)
8-15-17 Order denying Ds Motion to appeal to COA
002
Ladonna Lusher
58
05/30/2018
EXHIBIT(S)
2017-11-21 Order Denying Appeal to COA
002
Ladonna Lusher
59
05/30/2018
EXHIBIT(S)
Sample paystub
002
Ladonna Lusher
60
05/30/2018
EXHIBIT(S)
S&A 12-hour complaint
002
Ladonna Lusher
61
05/30/2018
MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN OPPOSITION
002
Ladonna Lusher
62
06/05/2018
MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN REPLY
Reply Memorandum of Law in Further Support of Defendant's Motion to Stay
002
John B Fulfree
63
06/05/2018
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN REPLY
Reply Affirmation in Further Support of Motion to Stay
002
John B Fulfree
64
06/05/2018
EXHIBIT(S)
Order Granting Stay in Badzio v. Americare
002
John B Fulfree
65
06/06/2018
COURT NOTICE
Danielle Horry
66
06/19/2018
LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE
Michele A. Moreno
67
06/19/2018
EXHIBIT(S)
Decision and Order
Michele A. Moreno
68
06/22/2018
LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE
Letter to Justice Cohen from James E. McGrath, III in Response to Plaintiff's 6/19/18 Letter
John B Fulfree
69
06/22/2018
EXHIBIT(S)
Letter Enclosure - Kurovskaya Complaint
John B Fulfree
70
08/10/2018
LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE
Letter to Justice Cohen from John B. Fulfree
John B Fulfree
71
08/10/2018
EXHIBIT(S)
Decision and Order Granting Stay - Belabarodaya v. Carepro
John B Fulfree
72
08/27/2018
STIPULATION - ADJOURNMENT OF CONFERENCE
Stipulation Adjourning Preliminary Conference to 11/21/18
John B Fulfree
73
10/22/2018
LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE
Letter to Justice Cohen from John B. Fulfree
John B Fulfree
74
10/22/2018
EXHIBIT(S)
Decision and Order Granting Stay - Bernarez v. Alternate Staffing
John B Fulfree
75
10/22/2018
LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE
002
Michele A. Moreno
76
10/22/2018
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex. A - First Amended Complaint - Kurovskaya
002
Michele A. Moreno
77
10/22/2018
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex. B - 1st Choice Decision
002
Michele A. Moreno
78
10/22/2018
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex. C - Vizeltir Decision
002
Michele A. Moreno
79
12/14/2018
LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE
Letter to Judge re Motion to Stay
002
Michele A. Moreno
80
12/14/2018
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex. A - Decision and Order
002
Michele A. Moreno
81
12/17/2018
STIPULATION - ADJOURNMENT OF HEARING
Stipulation to Adjourn Motion Sequence No. 2 and Preliminary Conference
John B Fulfree
82
01/04/2019
LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE
Letter to Justice Cohen from James E. McGrath, III
002
John B Fulfree
83
01/04/2019
EXHIBIT(S)
Enclosure 1 - Court of Appeals Calendar
002
John B Fulfree
84
01/04/2019
EXHIBIT(S)
Enclosure 2 - Union Arbitration Letter
002
John B Fulfree
85
01/08/2019
LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE
Letter to Judge re Motion to Stay
002
Michele A. Moreno
86
01/08/2019
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex. A - InCare decision
002
Michele A. Moreno
87
01/08/2019
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex. B - York decision
002
Michele A. Moreno
88
01/10/2019
ORDER - PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE
Maria Abreu
89
01/10/2019
STIPULATION - SO ORDERED
002
Maria Abreu
90
05/09/2019
ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE
Maria Abreu
91
05/10/2019
SUMMONS (POST RJI) (AMENDED)
First Amended Summons
Ladonna Lusher
92
05/10/2019
COMPLAINT (AMENDED)
First Amended Complaint
Ladonna Lusher
93
07/05/2019
DECISION + ORDER ON MOTION
002
Tiffani Stevens
94
10/03/2019
ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE
Maria Abreu
95
11/08/2019
COMPLAINT (AMENDED)
Second Amended Complaint
Ladonna Lusher
122
12/19/2019
STIPULATION - SO ORDERED
Maria Abreu
123
12/20/2019
STIPULATION - OTHER - ( REQUEST TO SO ORDER )
Stipulation to Amend Caption
Ladonna Lusher
124
01/12/2020
ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE ( PROPOSED )
Michele A. Moreno
125
01/12/2020
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT
Affirmation in Support
Michele A. Moreno
126
01/12/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex. A - Dec 18 2017 Decision
Michele A. Moreno
127
01/12/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex. B - Second Amended Complaint
Michele A. Moreno
128
01/12/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex. C - Dec 24 2019 Arbitrator Email
Michele A. Moreno
129
01/12/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex. D - Jan 8 2020 Arbitrator Email
Michele A. Moreno
130
01/12/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex. E - Union Class Action Grievance
Michele A. Moreno
131
01/12/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex. F - Nov 7 2016 Union Letter
Michele A. Moreno
132
01/12/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex. G - Letter to Arbitrator re CPC case
Michele A. Moreno
133
01/12/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex. H - Letter to NLRB re CPC case
Michele A. Moreno
134
01/12/2020
MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN SUPPORT
Memorandum of Law in Support
Michele A. Moreno
135
01/13/2020
ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE ( PROPOSED )
003
Ladonna Lusher
136
01/13/2020
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT
003
Ladonna Lusher
137
01/13/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Dec 18 2017 Premier decision
003
Ladonna Lusher
138
01/13/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Second Amended Complaint
003
Ladonna Lusher
139
01/13/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Arbitrator E-mail
003
Ladonna Lusher
140
01/13/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Arbitator Email Jan 8
003
Ladonna Lusher
141
01/13/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Union's class action grievance
003
Ladonna Lusher
142
01/13/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Nov. 7, 2016 Union Letter
003
Ladonna Lusher
143
01/13/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Letter to Arbitrator re CPC
003
Ladonna Lusher
144
01/13/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Letter to NLRB re CPC
003
Ladonna Lusher
145
01/13/2020
MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN SUPPORT
003
Ladonna Lusher
146
01/13/2020
STIPULATION - SO ORDERED
Maria Abreu
147
01/13/2020
LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE
Submitting decision by J. Freed granting TRO and injunctive relief
003
Ladonna Lusher
148
01/13/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
1-13-2020 Decision by J. Freed granting TRO and Injunctive relief
003
Ladonna Lusher
149
01/14/2020
ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE
003
Danielle Horry
150
01/14/2020
NOTICE OF ENTRY
003
Ladonna Lusher
151
02/14/2020
NOTICE OF APPEARANCE (POST RJI)
Rebecca Kim Kimura
152
02/14/2020
STIPULATION - ADJOURNMENT OF CONFERENCE
Rebecca Kim Kimura
153
02/14/2020
MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN OPPOSITION
003
Rebecca Kim Kimura
154
02/14/2020
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION
003
Rebecca Kim Kimura
155
02/14/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Summons and Complaint
003
Rebecca Kim Kimura
156
02/14/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
March 11, 2010 Letter
003
Rebecca Kim Kimura
157
02/14/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
August 2009 Letter
003
Rebecca Kim Kimura
158
02/14/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
November 2013 Opinion Letter
003
Rebecca Kim Kimura
159
02/14/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
DOL Letter
003
Rebecca Kim Kimura
160
02/14/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Defendant's 4-18-2017 Letter
003
Rebecca Kim Kimura
161
02/14/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
December 2017 - Order
003
Rebecca Kim Kimura
162
02/14/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Notice of Appeal
003
Rebecca Kim Kimura
163
02/14/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Answer
003
Rebecca Kim Kimura
164
02/14/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Order on Motion to Stay
003
Rebecca Kim Kimura
165
02/14/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
First Amended Complaint
003
Rebecca Kim Kimura
166
02/14/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Class Action Grievance
003
Rebecca Kim Kimura
167
02/14/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
December 24, 2019 Letter
003
Rebecca Kim Kimura
168
02/14/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Union's January 14, 2020 Letter
003
Rebecca Kim Kimura
169
02/14/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
SAC
003
Rebecca Kim Kimura
170
02/14/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Hearing Transcript
003
Rebecca Kim Kimura
171
02/14/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Order on TRO
003
Rebecca Kim Kimura
172
02/14/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Aide Profile
003
Rebecca Kim Kimura
173
02/14/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
OSC Family Home Care Services
003
Rebecca Kim Kimura
174
02/14/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
FHC Affidavit
003
Rebecca Kim Kimura
175
02/14/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Chu Motion to Stay
003
Rebecca Kim Kimura
176
02/14/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Decision on Chu's Motion to Stay
003
Rebecca Kim Kimura
177
02/14/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
History of the General Hourly Minimum Wage in New York State
003
Rebecca Kim Kimura
178
02/14/2020
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION
003
Rebecca Kim Kimura
179
02/14/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
2009 CBA
003
Rebecca Kim Kimura
180
02/14/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
2014 MOA
003
Rebecca Kim Kimura
181
02/14/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
2015 MOA
003
Rebecca Kim Kimura
182
02/14/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
2016 MOA
003
Rebecca Kim Kimura
183
02/14/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Offer Letter 2017
003
Rebecca Kim Kimura
184
02/14/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Acknowledgment Grievance Procedure
003
Rebecca Kim Kimura
185
02/14/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
24 Hour Shift Agreement
003
Rebecca Kim Kimura
186
02/14/2020
NOTICE OF MOTION
004
Rebecca Kim Kimura
187
02/14/2020
MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN SUPPORT
004
Rebecca Kim Kimura
188
02/14/2020
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT
004
Rebecca Kim Kimura
189
02/14/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Summons and Complaint
004
Rebecca Kim Kimura
190
02/14/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
March 11, 2010 Letter
004
Rebecca Kim Kimura
191
02/14/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
August 2009 Letter
004
Rebecca Kim Kimura
192
02/14/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
November 2013 Opinion Letter
004
Rebecca Kim Kimura
193
02/14/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
DOL Letter
004
Rebecca Kim Kimura
194
02/14/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Defendant's April 18, 2017 Letter
004
Rebecca Kim Kimura
195
02/14/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
December 18, 2017 Order Denying Motion to Dismiss
004
Rebecca Kim Kimura
196
02/14/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Notice of Appeal
004
Rebecca Kim Kimura
197
02/14/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Answer
004
Rebecca Kim Kimura
198
02/14/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Order on Motion to Stay
004
Rebecca Kim Kimura
199
02/14/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
First Amended Complaint
004
Rebecca Kim Kimura
200
02/14/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Class Action Grievance
004
Rebecca Kim Kimura
201
02/14/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
December 24, 2019 Letter
004
Rebecca Kim Kimura
202
02/14/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Union January 14, 2020 Letter
004
Rebecca Kim Kimura
203
02/14/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
SAC
004
Rebecca Kim Kimura
204
02/14/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Hearing Transcript
004
Rebecca Kim Kimura
205
02/14/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Order on TRO
004
Rebecca Kim Kimura
206
02/14/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Aide Profile
004
Rebecca Kim Kimura
207
02/14/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
OSC Family Home Care Services
004
Rebecca Kim Kimura
208
02/14/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
FHC Affidavit
004
Rebecca Kim Kimura
209
02/14/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Chu Motion to Stay
004
Rebecca Kim Kimura
210
02/14/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Decision on Chu's Motion to Stay
004
Rebecca Kim Kimura
211
02/14/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
History of the General Hourly Minimum Wage in New York State
004
Rebecca Kim Kimura
212
02/14/2020
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION
004
Rebecca Kim Kimura
213
02/14/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
2009 CBA
004
Rebecca Kim Kimura
214
02/14/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
2014 MOA
004
Rebecca Kim Kimura
215
02/14/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
2015 MOA
004
Rebecca Kim Kimura
216
02/14/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
2016 MOA
004
Rebecca Kim Kimura
217
02/14/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Offer Letter 2017
004
Rebecca Kim Kimura
218
02/14/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Acknowledgment Grievance Procedure
004
Rebecca Kim Kimura
219
02/14/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
24 Hour Shift Agreement
004
Rebecca Kim Kimura
220
02/19/2020
NOTICE OF MOTION
005
Ladonna Lusher
221
02/19/2020
AFFIRMATION OF GOOD FAITH
005
Ladonna Lusher
222
02/19/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Second Amended Summons and Complaint
005
Ladonna Lusher
223
02/19/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Plaintiffs' First Pre-Cert Discovery Demands
005
Ladonna Lusher
224
02/19/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
4.6.17 Defendant's Letter re Discovery
005
Ladonna Lusher
225
02/19/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
2.3.18 Plaintiffs' Letter to Opposing Counsel re Discovery
005
Ladonna Lusher
226
02/19/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Preliminary Conference Order
005
Ladonna Lusher
227
02/19/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
2.8.2019 Cover Letter re Plaintiffs' Discovery Requests (second service)
005
Ladonna Lusher
228
02/19/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
5.8.19 Compliance Conference Order
005
Ladonna Lusher
229
02/19/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
5.17.19 Sampling Letter
005
Ladonna Lusher
230
02/19/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
10.2.19 Compliance Conference Order
005
Ladonna Lusher
231
02/19/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
12.18.19 Compliance Conference Stipulation
005
Ladonna Lusher
232
02/19/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
1.14.20 Order to Show Cause
005
Ladonna Lusher
233
02/19/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Proposed Order
005
Ladonna Lusher
234
02/19/2020
MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN SUPPORT
005
Ladonna Lusher
235
02/19/2020
NOTICE OF MOTION (AMENDED)
004
James Edward Mcgrath
236
03/02/2020
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION
004
James Edward Mcgrath
237
03/02/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Union's 02/28/2020 Letter to Mr. Scheinman
004
James Edward Mcgrath
238
03/02/2020
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION
003
James Edward Mcgrath
239
03/02/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Union's 02/28/2020 Letter to Mr. Scheinman
003
James Edward Mcgrath
240
03/02/2020
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION
Affirmation in Opposition
004
Michele A. Moreno
241
03/02/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex. A - Dec 18 2017 Decision and Order
004
Michele A. Moreno
242
03/02/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex. B - Jan 14 2020 Order to Show Cause
004
Michele A. Moreno
243
03/02/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex. C Jan 13 2020 Guzman Decision and Order
004
Michele A. Moreno
244
03/02/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex. D - Guzman stipulations
004
Michele A. Moreno
245
03/02/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex. E - Full Transcript Jan 14 hearing
004
Michele A. Moreno
246
03/02/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex. F - Excerpts from CBA - Alliance
004
Michele A. Moreno
247
03/02/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex. G - Excerpts from CBA - Hichez
004
Michele A. Moreno
248
03/02/2020
MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN OPPOSITION
Memorandum of Law in Opposition
004
Michele A. Moreno
249
03/02/2020
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN REPLY
Reply Affirmation
003
Michele A. Moreno
250
03/02/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex. I - Proposed Order
003
Michele A. Moreno
251
03/02/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex. J - Jan 14 2020 Order to Show Cause
003
Michele A. Moreno
252
03/02/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex. K - Excerpts from CBA in Alliance
003
Michele A. Moreno
253
03/02/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex. L - Excerpts from CBA in Hichez
003
Michele A. Moreno
254
03/02/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex. M - Full Transcript from Jan 14 2020 hearing
003
Michele A. Moreno
255
03/02/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex. N - Jan 13 2020 Guzman Decision and Order
003
Michele A. Moreno
256
03/02/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex. O - Guzman stipulations
003
Michele A. Moreno
257
03/02/2020
MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN REPLY
Memorandum of Law in Reply
003
Michele A. Moreno
258
03/10/2020
MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN OPPOSITION
Memo of Law in Opposition to Plaintiff's Motion to Compel Discovery, Limit Defendant's Grounds for Objections, and Extend the Pre-Certification Discovery and Note of Issue Deadline
005
Rebecca Kim Kimura
259
03/10/2020
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION
Affirmation of James E. McGrath, III.
005
Rebecca Kim Kimura
260
03/10/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Plaintiff's Discovery Demands
005
Rebecca Kim Kimura
261
03/10/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Order denying Motion to Dismiss
005
Rebecca Kim Kimura
262
03/10/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Notice of Entry of Order
005
Rebecca Kim Kimura
263
03/10/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Notice of Appeal
005
Rebecca Kim Kimura
264
03/10/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Answer
005
Rebecca Kim Kimura
265
03/10/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Andryeyeva et al., v. New York Health Care, Inc. - Decision as of March 7, 2018
005
Rebecca Kim Kimura
266
03/10/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Class Action Grievance
005
Rebecca Kim Kimura
267
03/10/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Order on Motion to Stay
005
Rebecca Kim Kimura
268
03/10/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Preliminary Conference Order dated January 9, 2019
005
Rebecca Kim Kimura
269
03/10/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Re-served Discovery demands
005
Rebecca Kim Kimura
270
03/10/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Agreement to Extend Discovery as of March 7, 2019
005
Rebecca Kim Kimura
271
03/10/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
First Amended Complaint
005
Rebecca Kim Kimura
272
03/10/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Compliance Conference Order as of May 8, 2019
005
Rebecca Kim Kimura
273
03/10/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Plaintiff's Letter with amended discovery demands as of May 17, 2019
005
Rebecca Kim Kimura
274
03/10/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Correspondence as of May 29, 2019 to respond to discover demands
005
Rebecca Kim Kimura
275
03/10/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Email dated as of May 31, 2019 in re mediation
005
Rebecca Kim Kimura
276
03/10/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Email in re: Mediation dated June 26, 2019
005
Rebecca Kim Kimura
277
03/10/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Correspondence as of June 26, 2019 and Stipulation
005
Rebecca Kim Kimura
278
03/10/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Correspondence as of October 1, 2019 and Stipulation
005
Rebecca Kim Kimura
279
03/10/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Compliance Conference Order as of October 2, 2019
005
Rebecca Kim Kimura
280
03/10/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Second Amended Complaint
005
Rebecca Kim Kimura
281
03/10/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Stipulation dated as of December 18, 2019
005
Rebecca Kim Kimura
282
03/10/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Stipulation dated as of December 20, 2019
005
Rebecca Kim Kimura
283
03/10/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Email from Arbitrator Scheinman as of December 24, 2019 Letter
005
Rebecca Kim Kimura
284
03/10/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Hearing Transcript as of January 14, 2020
005
Rebecca Kim Kimura
285
03/10/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Termporary Restraining Order entered as of January 14, 2020
005
Rebecca Kim Kimura
286
03/10/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Email from Ms. Lusher to Mr. McGrath, III., dated as of January 31, 2020
005
Rebecca Kim Kimura
287
03/10/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Email response from Mr. McGrath, III to Ms. Lusher email dated as of January 31, 2020
005
Rebecca Kim Kimura
288
03/10/2020
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION
Affidavit of Alice J. Lousberg in Support of Defendant's Motion in Opposition
005
Rebecca Kim Kimura
289
03/13/2020
STIPULATION - ADJOURNMENT OF MOTION -IN SUBMISSIONS PART -RM 130
005
Ladonna Lusher
290
03/16/2020
MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN REPLY
004
James Edward Mcgrath
291
03/17/2020
COURT NOTICE
004
Michele D Jenkins
292
03/19/2020
URGENT - COURT APPEARANCE UPDATE
Michael Habich
293
03/23/2020
LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE
003
James Edward Mcgrath
294
06/12/2020
STIPULATION - BRIEFING SCHEDULE
005
Ladonna Lusher
295
07/17/2020
LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE
Ladonna Lusher
296
07/17/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Decision and Order issued in Teshabaeva et al. v. Family Home Care Services of Brooklyn and Queens, Inc. et al.
Ladonna Lusher
297
07/20/2020
LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE
James Edward Mcgrath
298
07/20/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Award
James Edward Mcgrath
299
07/22/2020
DECISION + ORDER ON MOTION
003
Maria Abreu
300
07/22/2020
DECISION + ORDER ON MOTION
004
Maria Abreu
301
07/22/2020
LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE
Ladonna Lusher
302
07/22/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Order Granting Injunction and Denying Defendants Motion to Compel Arbitration
Ladonna Lusher
303
07/28/2020
STIPULATION - OTHER
James Edward Mcgrath
304
08/03/2020
STIPULATION - ADJOURNMENT OF MOTION -IN SUBMISSIONS PART -RM 130
005
Ladonna Lusher
305
08/19/2020
MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN REPLY
005
Ladonna Lusher
306
08/19/2020
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN REPLY
005
Ladonna Lusher
307
08/19/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
July 26 2020 Premier decision
005
Ladonna Lusher
308
08/19/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Dec 18 2017 Premier decision
005
Ladonna Lusher
309
08/20/2020
NOTICE OF MOTION
Premier's Motion to Renew and Reargue its Opposition to Plaintiff Application for an Injunction Motion to Compel Arbitration, Dismiss Second Amended Complaint and Stay the Action
006
James Edward Mcgrath
310
08/20/2020
MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN SUPPORT
Memo of Law in Support of Defendant's Motion to Renew and Reargue its Opposition to Plaintiff's Application for an Injunction, Motion to Compel Arbitration, Dismiss the Second Amended Complaint and Stay the Action
006
James Edward Mcgrath
311
08/20/2020
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION
Affirmation of James E. McGrath, III in Support of Motion to Renew and Reargue
006
James Edward Mcgrath
312
08/20/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Complaint
006
James Edward Mcgrath
313
08/20/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Class Action Grievance
006
James Edward Mcgrath
314
08/20/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Email dated December 24, 2019 from Arbitrator Scheinman
006
James Edward Mcgrath
315
08/20/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Memorandum of Agreement between Premier and the Union
006
James Edward Mcgrath
316
08/20/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Second Amended Complaint
006
James Edward Mcgrath
317
08/20/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
July 28, 2020 Stipulation
006
James Edward Mcgrath
318
08/20/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Temporary Restraining Order entered on January 14, 2020
006
James Edward Mcgrath
319
08/20/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
April 17, 2020 Arbitration Award
006
James Edward Mcgrath
320
08/20/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Premier's July 20, 2020 Letter
006
James Edward Mcgrath
321
08/20/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
July 22, 2020 Decision and Order
006
James Edward Mcgrath
322
09/03/2020
NOTICE OF CROSS-MOTION
Ladonna Lusher
323
09/03/2020
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION AND IN SUPPORT OF CROSS-MOTION
006
Ladonna Lusher
324
09/03/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Dec 18 2017 Decision and Order
006
Ladonna Lusher
325
09/03/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Jan 14 2020 Decision and Order
006
Ladonna Lusher
326
09/03/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Alvarado v. Alliance for Health Jan 13 2020 Order
006
Ladonna Lusher
327
09/03/2020
MEMORANDUM IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION AND IN SUPPORT OF CROSS-MOTION
006
Ladonna Lusher
328
09/04/2020
STIPULATION - ADJOURNMENT OF MOTION -IN SUBMISSIONS PART -RM 130
006
Rebecca Kim Kimura
329
09/16/2020
MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN REPLY
Reply Memo of Law in Further Support of Defendant's Motion to Renew and Reargue, Motion to Compel Arbitration, and Dismiss the Second Amended Complaint
006
James Edward Mcgrath
330
09/23/2020
LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE
005
James Edward Mcgrath
331
09/25/2020
ORDER (PROPOSED) (AMENDED)
Ladonna Lusher
332
10/13/2020
DECISION + ORDER ON MOTION
005
Maria Abreu
333
10/14/2020
NOTICE OF ENTRY
Ladonna Lusher
334
11/13/2020
DECISION + ORDER ON MOTION
006
David B. Cohen
335
11/13/2020
NOTICE OF ENTRY
Lloyd R Ambinder
336
12/08/2020
NOTICE OF ENTRY
Notice of Entry Motions 003 and 004
003
James Edward Mcgrath
337
12/08/2020
NOTICE OF APPEAL
Notice of Appeal - Defendant's Motion to Compel Arbitration and Plaintiff's motion for an injunction (Motions Seq# 003 and 004)
003
James Edward Mcgrath
338
12/08/2020
NOTICE OF APPEAL
Notice of Appeal - Defendant's Motion to Renew its Motion to Compel Arbitration and dismiss the Second Amended Complaint
006
James Edward Mcgrath
339
04/01/2021
NOTICE OF CHANGE OF FIRM NAME OR ADDRESS (POST RJI)
James Edward Mcgrath
340
04/01/2021
NOTICE OF CHANGE OF FIRM NAME OR ADDRESS (POST RJI)
Rebecca Kim Kimura
341
05/12/2021
NOTIFICATION FROM COURT
NOTICE OF ADR OPTIONS- PART 58
Michael Habich
342
06/01/2021
STIPULATION - OTHER
Stipulation to Extend Plaintiffs' Deadline to File Motion for Class Certification
Michele A. Moreno
343
06/25/2021
STIPULATION - OTHER
Stipulation to Extend Plaintiffs' Deadline to File Motion for Class Certification
Ladonna Lusher
344
08/13/2021
STIPULATION - OTHER
Stipulation to Extend Plaintiffs' Deadline to File Motion for Class Certification
Michele A. Moreno
345
10/14/2021
STIPULATION - OTHER
Stipulation to Extend Plaintiffs' Deadline to File Motion for Class Certification
Ladonna Lusher
346
12/17/2021
STIPULATION - OTHER
Stipulation to Extend Discovery and Deadline to File Motion for Class Certification
Michele A. Moreno
347
02/01/2022
STIPULATION - DISCOVERY
Ladonna Lusher
348
04/01/2022
NOTICE OF MOTION
007
Ladonna Lusher
349
04/01/2022
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION
007
Ladonna Lusher
350
04/01/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Adolphe v. Signature Care
007
Ladonna Lusher
351
04/01/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Konstantynovska v. Friendly
007
Ladonna Lusher
352
04/01/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Wallace v. Pleet
007
Ladonna Lusher
353
04/01/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Konstantynovska v. Caring Professionals
007
Ladonna Lusher
354
04/01/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
July 28 2020 Stipulation
007
Ladonna Lusher
355
04/01/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Collective Bargaining Agreement
007
Ladonna Lusher
356
04/01/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Affidavit of Boris Pustilnik
007
Ladonna Lusher
357
04/01/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Affidavit of Svetlana Semenov
007
Ladonna Lusher
358
04/01/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Affidavit of Patricia Hopson
007
Ladonna Lusher
359
04/01/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Orientation manual, job description
007
Ladonna Lusher
360
04/01/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Sampling of Duty Sheets
007
Ladonna Lusher
361
04/01/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Jones v. Premier Complaint
007
Ladonna Lusher
362
04/01/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Payroll and Time Sampling
007
Ladonna Lusher
363
04/01/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Named Plaintiff Pay Records
007
Ladonna Lusher
364
04/01/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Oct 13 2020 Order
007
Ladonna Lusher
365
04/01/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Website page
007
Ladonna Lusher
366
04/01/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Proposed Notice to Class
007
Ladonna Lusher
367
04/01/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Proposed Publication Order
007
Ladonna Lusher
368
04/01/2022
MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN SUPPORT
007
Ladonna Lusher
369
04/18/2022
STIPULATION - BRIEFING SCHEDULE
Stipulation to Modify Briefing Schedule on Class Certification Motion
Rebecca Kim Kimura
370
04/21/2022
REMITTITUR
Gordon Kagan
371
04/21/2022
NOTICE OF ENTRY
Notice of Entry on Decision and Order
Ladonna Lusher
372
04/22/2022
STIPULATION - ADJOURNMENT OF MOTION -IN SUBMISSIONS PART -RM 130
007
Rebecca Kim Kimura
373
04/29/2022
MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN OPPOSITION
Memorandum of Law In Opposition to Motion for Class Certification
007
James Edward Mcgrath
374
04/29/2022
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION
Affirmation of James E. McGrath, III
007
James Edward Mcgrath
375
04/29/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Getts Complaint
007
James Edward Mcgrath
376
04/29/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Second Amended Complaint
007
James Edward Mcgrath
377
04/29/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Stipulation re Orders
007
James Edward Mcgrath
378
04/29/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
March 11, 2010 Letter
007
James Edward Mcgrath
379
04/29/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Nov. 2013 Opinion Letter
007
James Edward Mcgrath
380
04/29/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
DAL Letter
007
James Edward Mcgrath
381
04/29/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Class Action Grievance
007
James Edward Mcgrath
382
04/29/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Dec. 24, 2019 Letter
007
James Edward Mcgrath
383
04/29/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
First Arbitration Award
007
James Edward Mcgrath
384
04/29/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Union's Jan. 14, 2020 Letter
007
James Edward Mcgrath
385
04/29/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Order Confirming First Arbitration Award
007
James Edward Mcgrath
386
04/29/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Second Arbitration Award
007
James Edward Mcgrath
387
04/29/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Supplement to Second Arbitration Award
007
James Edward Mcgrath
388
04/29/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
TRO
007
James Edward Mcgrath
389
04/29/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
PI Order
007
James Edward Mcgrath
390
04/29/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Appellate Division Order
007
James Edward Mcgrath
391
04/29/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
August 2009 Letter
007
James Edward Mcgrath
392
04/29/2022
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION
Affidavit of Jeannie O'Sullivan
007
James Edward Mcgrath
393
04/29/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
CBA 2009
007
James Edward Mcgrath
394
04/29/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
2014 MOA
007
James Edward Mcgrath
395
04/29/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
2016 MOA
007
James Edward Mcgrath
396
04/29/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
2015 MOA
007
James Edward Mcgrath
397
04/29/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Live-In Time Slip
007
James Edward Mcgrath
398
04/29/2022
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION
Affidavit of Alice Lousberg
007
James Edward Mcgrath
399
04/29/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Pustilnik Pre-Employment Screening App
007
James Edward Mcgrath
400
04/29/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Pustilnik Offer Letter
007
James Edward Mcgrath
401
04/29/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Pustilnik Orientation Acknowledgement
007
James Edward Mcgrath
402
04/29/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Pustilnik 24-Hour Shift Agreement
007
James Edward Mcgrath
403
04/29/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Pustilnik Activity Report
007
James Edward Mcgrath
404
04/29/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Pustilnik Pay Records
007
James Edward Mcgrath
405
04/29/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Hopson Activity Report
007
James Edward Mcgrath
406
04/29/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Hopson 24-Hour Shift Agreement
007
James Edward Mcgrath
407
04/29/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Hopson Note
007
James Edward Mcgrath
408
04/29/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Hopson Pay Records
007
James Edward Mcgrath
409
04/29/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Semenov 24-Hour Shift Agreement
007
James Edward Mcgrath
410
04/29/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Semenov Duty Sheets
007
James Edward Mcgrath
411
04/29/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Semenov Pay Records
007
James Edward Mcgrath
412
04/29/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Check Register Live-In Interruptions
007
James Edward Mcgrath
413
04/29/2022
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION
Affidavit of Marcos A. Maltez
007
James Edward Mcgrath
414
04/29/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Dec. 23, 2015 Email
007
James Edward Mcgrath
415
04/29/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
24-Hour Shift Agreement
007
James Edward Mcgrath
416
04/29/2022
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION
Affidavit of Alyssa Haskaj
007
James Edward Mcgrath
417
05/16/2022
STIPULATION - ADJOURNMENT OF MOTION -IN SUBMISSIONS PART -RM 130
007
Ladonna Lusher
418
05/23/2022
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN REPLY
007
Michele A. Moreno
419
05/23/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Affidavit of Bao Qin Wu
007
Michele A. Moreno
420
05/23/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Affidavit of Siu Ying Kwong
007
Michele A. Moreno
421
05/23/2022
MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN REPLY
007
Michele A. Moreno
422
05/25/2022
LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE
007
James Edward Mcgrath
423
05/27/2022
LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE
Response to Defendant's 5/25 Letter to Judge
007
Michele A. Moreno
424
06/30/2022
LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE
007
James Edward Mcgrath
425
06/30/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Opinion and Order
007
James Edward Mcgrath
426
07/11/2022
LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE
Letter in Response to Defendants June 30, 2022 Letter
007
Michele A. Moreno
427
08/05/2022
LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE
Letter to Judge re Class Certification Decision in Teshabaeva v. Family Home Care Services of Brooklyn & Queens
007
Michele A. Moreno
428
08/05/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex. A - July 15, 2022 Class Certification Decision in Teshabaeva v. Family Home Care Services of Brooklyn & Queens
007
Michele A. Moreno
429
11/14/2022
DECISION + ORDER ON MOTION
007
David B. Cohen
430
11/10/2022
ORDER ( PROPOSED )
007
Michele A. Moreno
431
11/10/2022
NOTICE OF ENTRY
Notice of Entry on Motion #7
007
Ladonna Lusher
432
11/17/2022
ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE ( PROPOSED )
008
James Edward Mcgrath
433
11/17/2022
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION
008
James Edward Mcgrath
434
11/17/2022
MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN SUPPORT
008
James Edward Mcgrath
435
11/18/2022
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
AFFIRMATION OF SERVICE
James Edward Mcgrath
436
11/23/2022
ORDER - OTHER (NON-MOTION)
SO ORDERED
Maria Abreu
437
11/29/2022
ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE
SO ORDERED
008
Maria Abreu
438
11/28/2022
NOTICE OF ENTRY
Notice of Entry -
Ladonna Lusher
439
12/15/2022
DECISION + ORDER ON MOTION
008
David B. Cohen
440
12/14/2022
NOTICE OF ENTRY
James Edward Mcgrath
441
12/14/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Decision and Order
James Edward Mcgrath
442
12/14/2022
AFFIRMATION
Affirmation of James E. McGrath, III
James Edward Mcgrath
443
12/14/2022
EXHIBIT(S)
Letter to A. Schwabe
James Edward Mcgrath
444
12/14/2022
NOTICE TO COUNTY CLERK CPLR 8019(C)
James Edward Mcgrath
445
12/21/2022
SERVICE ON SUPREME COURT CLERK (GENL. CLERK) W/COPY OF ORDER
James Edward Mcgrath
446
01/24/2023
NOTICE OF APPEARANCE (POST RJI)
Notice of Appeal of Jerrold F. Foster on behalf of Defendant Premier Home Health Care Services, Inc.
Jerrold Foster Goldberg
447
01/24/2023
NOTICE OF APPEARANCE (POST RJI)
Notice of Appearance on behalf of Defendant Premier Home Health Care Services, Inc.
Eric B Sigda
448
02/14/2023
ORDER - CASE SCHEDULING
Eli Moskovitz
449
03/10/2023
COMPLAINT (AMENDED)
Third Amended Complaint
Michele A. Moreno
450
03/30/2023
STIPULATION - TIME TO ANSWER
Eric B Sigda
451
03/30/2023
STIPULATION - OTHER - ( REQUEST TO SO ORDER )
Pustilnik v. Premier - Publication Stipulation
007
Ladonna Lusher
452
03/31/2023
STIPULATION - SO ORDERED
Eli Moskovitz
453
03/31/2023
COMPLAINT (AMENDED)
Third Amended Complaint -
Ladonna Lusher
454
04/13/2023
ANSWER
Answer to Third Amended Complaint
Eric B Sigda
455
04/28/2023
STIPULATION - DISCOVERY ( REQUEST TO SO ORDER )
Stipulation and Order Extending Time To Serve Discovery Demands
Eric B Sigda
456
05/04/2023
STIPULATION - SO ORDERED
Eli Moskovitz
457
06/07/2023
STIPULATION - DISCOVERY ( REQUEST TO SO ORDER )
Eric B Sigda
458
06/08/2023
STIPULATION - SO ORDERED
Brian Thompson
459
06/30/2023
STIPULATION - DISCOVERY ( REQUEST TO SO ORDER )
Stipulation and Proposed Order re Discovery
Eric B Sigda
460
08/14/2023
ADJOURNMENT OF CONFERENCE -REQUEST
Ladonna Lusher
461
08/16/2023
STIPULATION - SO ORDERED
Leni Silvestre
462
10/16/2023
STIPULATION - OTHER - ( REQUEST TO SO ORDER )
Eric B Sigda
463
10/17/2023
STIPULATION - SO ORDERED
Leni Silvestre
464
10/17/2023
NOTICE OF ENTRY
Notice of Entry - Stipulation and Order
Lloyd R Ambinder
465
12/08/2023
STIPULATION - DISCOVERY ( REQUEST TO SO ORDER )
Stipulation and Order to be So Ordered
Eric B Sigda
466
02/28/2024
STIPULATION - DISCOVERY ( REQUEST TO SO ORDER )
Eric B Sigda
467
02/28/2024
STIPULATION - SO ORDERED
Leni Silvestre
468
04/25/2024
STIPULATION - DISCOVERY ( REQUEST TO SO ORDER )
Stipulation and Order re Discovery - TO BE SO ORDERED
Eric B Sigda
469
04/29/2024
STIPULATION - SO ORDERED
Leni Silvestre
470
06/10/2024
STIPULATION - DISCOVERY ( REQUEST TO SO ORDER )
Pustilnik v. Premier - Stipulation Regarding Discovery June 2024
Ladonna Lusher
471
06/11/2024
ORDER - STATUS CONFERENCE
Leni Silvestre
472
09/09/2024
STIPULATION - DISCOVERY ( REQUEST TO SO ORDER )
Stipulation and Order re Discovery - TO BE SO ORDERED
Eric B Sigda
473
09/10/2024
STIPULATION - SO ORDERED
Leni Silvestre
474
11/05/2024
LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE
Letter to Clerk Re Removal of Appearance of Joel Goldenberg, Esq.
Ladonna Lusher
475
12/12/2024
STIPULATION - DISCOVERY ( REQUEST TO SO ORDER )
Proposed Stipulation re Discovery - to be SO ORDERED
Eric B Sigda
476
12/19/2024
STIPULATION - SO ORDERED
Leni Silvestre
477
03/12/2025
STIPULATION - DISCOVERY ( REQUEST TO SO ORDER )
Stipulation and Proposed Order to be SO ORDERED by Hon David B. Cohen
Eric B Sigda
478
03/14/2025
ORDER - STATUS CONFERENCE
Leni Silvestre
479
06/10/2025
STIPULATION - DISCOVERY ( REQUEST TO SO ORDER )
Eric B Sigda
480
09/11/2025
STIPULATION - DISCOVERY ( REQUEST TO SO ORDER )
Stipulation and Order
Eric B Sigda
481
09/19/2025
ORDER - STATUS CONFERENCE
Leni Silvestre
482
12/12/2025
STIPULATION - DISCOVERY ( REQUEST TO SO ORDER )
Ladonna Lusher
483
03/18/2026
STIPULATION - DISCOVERY ( REQUEST TO SO ORDER )
Eric B Sigda
34
Richmond Supreme Court
2016
150013/2016
Disposed
Tort
CIRILLO, MARIA
JOHN M. O'DOWD, JR
BRENT, ZENIA
12/21/2016
Troia, Hon. Charles M.
▼
Case Info
Court
Richmond Supreme Court
Index Number
150013/2016
Status
Disposed
Year Filed
2016
Case Name
CIRILLO, MARIA vs. BRENT, ZENIA
Case Type
Tort-Other
Track
Standard
RJI Filed
05/11/2016
NOI Due
05/11/2017
NOI Filed
Calendar Number
—
Jury Status
Justice
Troia, Hon. Charles M.
Next Appearance
12/21/2016
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
CIRILLO, MARIA
Attorney / FirmJOHN M. O'DOWD, JR
Defendant / Respondent
BRENT, ZENIA
Attorneys / Firms
Motions
No motions recorded for this case.
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (9)
Doc #
Date Filed
Document
Description
Motion #
Filing User
File
1
01/06/2016
SUMMONS + COMPLAINT
Summons and Complaint
John M. O'Dowd
2
01/08/2016
AFFIDAVIT
Notice of Commencement of Action
John M. O'Dowd
3
01/13/2016
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT OF SERVICE
AOS Premiere
John M. O'Dowd
4
02/26/2016
AFFIDAVIT
Affidavit of Service Brent
John M. O'Dowd
5
05/11/2016
PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE REQUEST
Request for PC
John M. O'Dowd
6
05/11/2016
RJI -RE: REQUEST FOR PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE
John M. O'Dowd
7
06/02/2016
ORDER - PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE
6/1/16 Conference
Paul Yu
8
10/27/2016
ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE
10/26/16 Conference
Paul Yu
9
11/23/2016
STIPULATION - DISCONTINUANCE (POST RJI)
Stipulation of Discontinuance
Kristen Marie Mitaritonna
35
New York Supreme Court
2016
805323/2015
Disposed
Medical Malpractice
LEKA, ELIZABETH
THE PERECMAN FIRM, P.L.L.C.
PREMIER HOME HEALTH CARE
HEALTHCARE RISK ADVISORS, THE DOCTORS COMPANY
03/12/2019
Rakower, Hon. Eileen A.
▼
Case Info
Court
New York Supreme Court
Index Number
805323/2015
Status
Disposed
Year Filed
2016
Case Name
LEKA, ELIZABETH vs. PREMIER HOME HEALTH CARE
Case Type
Tort-Medical, Dental, or Podiatric Malpractice
Track
Complex
RJI Filed
05/02/2016
NOI Due
08/03/2017
NOI Filed
Calendar Number
—
Jury Status
Justice
Rakower, Hon. Eileen A.
Next Appearance
03/12/2019
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
LEKA, ELIZABETH
Attorney / FirmTHE PERECMAN FIRM, P.L.L.C.
Defendant / Respondent
PREMIER HOME HEALTH CARE
Attorneys / FirmsHEALTHCARE RISK ADVISORS, THE DOCTORS COMPANY
Motions
No motions recorded for this case.
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (24)
Doc #
Date Filed
Document
Description
Motion #
Filing User
File
1
10/26/2015
SUMMONS + COMPLAINT
and Certificate of Merit
David H. Perecman
2
02/04/2016
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
of Summons and Complaint on Premier Home Health Care Services, Inc. through Secretary of State
David H. Perecman
3
02/04/2016
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
of Summons and Complaint on Jane Doe, Premier Home Health Care Services, Inc.
David H. Perecman
4
02/04/2016
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
of Summons and Complaint on Premier Home Health Care Services, Inc.
David H. Perecman
5
02/16/2016
BILL OF PARTICULARS
David H. Perecman
6
05/02/2016
PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE REQUEST
David H. Perecman
7
05/02/2016
RJI -RE: REQUEST FOR PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE
David H. Perecman
8
05/25/2016
ORDER - PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE
Lisa W Smalle
9
10/04/2016
ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE
Ofori Perry
10
01/04/2017
BILL OF PARTICULARS
Supplemental
David H. Perecman
11
01/18/2017
ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE
Lisa W Smalle
12
03/29/2017
ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE
Lisa W Smalle
13
06/15/2017
ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE
Susan Macleod
14
06/15/2017
ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE
Susan Macleod
15
07/21/2017
STIPULATION - ADJOURNMENT OF CONFERENCE
Stipulation Adjourning Conference
Nicole Ann Callahan
16
07/27/2017
STIPULATION - SO ORDERED
Susan Macleod
17
08/28/2017
ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE
Susan Macleod
18
11/22/2017
ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE
Susan Macleod
19
12/19/2017
STIPULATION - SO ORDERED
Susan Macleod
20
01/09/2018
STIPULATION - SO ORDERED
Susan Macleod
21
02/16/2018
OTHER COURT FILED DOCUMENT
Susan Macleod
22
05/04/2018
ADJOURNMENT OF CONFERENCE -REQUEST
Steven B Dorfman
23
03/13/2019
STIPULATION - SO ORDERED
Susan Macleod
24
05/21/2021
STIPULATION - DISCONTINUANCE (POST RJI)
As to Premier Home Health Care Services, Inc.
Ita Parnass
36
Suffolk Supreme Court
2016
017895/2015
Disposed
Tort
JAWORSKI, MONICA
FINZ & FINZ, P.C.
PREMIER HOME HEALTH CARE
Newfield, Biondo & Carlino LLC
12/13/2021
CCP-Justice,
▼
Case Info
Court
Suffolk Supreme Court
Index Number
017895/2015
Status
Disposed
Year Filed
2016
Case Name
JAWORSKI, MONICA vs. PREMIER HOME HEALTH CARE
Case Type
Tort-Other
Track
Complex
RJI Filed
06/01/2016
NOI Due
09/02/2017
NOI Filed
03/15/2021
Calendar Number
202100257OT
Jury Status
Jury At Plaintiff's Request
Justice
CCP-Justice,
Next Appearance
12/13/2021
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
JAWORSKI, MONICA
Attorney / FirmFINZ & FINZ, P.C.
Defendant / Respondent
PREMIER HOME HEALTH CARE
Attorneys / FirmsNewfield, Biondo & Carlino LLC
Motions (2)
#
Date Filed
Filed By
Relief Sought
Submit Date
Answer
Status
Decision
Order Signed
2
08/26/2020
Discovery
01/20/2021
No
Decided: 01/20/2021 Withdrawn Before Justice: Rouse, Hon. John H.
Oral
01/20/2021
1
10/24/2016
Dismiss
06/19/2019
No
Decided: 06/19/2019 Withdrawn Before Justice: Rouse, Hon. John H.
Oral
06/19/2019
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (30)
Doc #
Date Filed
Document
Description
Motion #
Filing User
File
1
08/21/2020
COUNTY CLERK MINUTES -PRIOR TO CONVERSION
Theresa Obrien
2
08/19/2020
CONSENT TO EFILING
Theresa Obrien
3
08/26/2020
NOTICE OF MOTION
VNS Notice-Mtn to Compel vs co-def Premier
002
Charmagne A Padua
4
08/26/2020
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT
VNS Motion to Compel vs co-def Premier
002
Charmagne A Padua
5
08/26/2020
AFFIRMATION OF GOOD FAITH
002
Charmagne A Padua
6
08/26/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Complaint
002
Charmagne A Padua
7
08/26/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Answer by Premier Home Health Care Services
002
Charmagne A Padua
8
08/26/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Prelim Conf Order dated 7/15/16
002
Charmagne A Padua
9
08/26/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Letters Testamentary & Death Certificate
002
Charmagne A Padua
10
08/26/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Stip to Amend Caption - substitute executrix
002
Charmagne A Padua
11
08/26/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Order dated 5/31/17
002
Charmagne A Padua
12
08/26/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Answer by VNS Choice
002
Charmagne A Padua
13
08/26/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Plaintiff's Bill of Particulars as to VNS Choice
002
Charmagne A Padua
14
08/26/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Order dated 4/11/18
002
Charmagne A Padua
15
08/26/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Plaintiff's Bill of Particulars as to Premier
002
Charmagne A Padua
16
08/26/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
VNS Choice Notice to Produce-as to Premier
002
Charmagne A Padua
17
08/26/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Objections by Premier to VNS Notice to Produce
002
Charmagne A Padua
18
08/26/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Good Faith Letter dated 2/7/20
002
Charmagne A Padua
19
11/17/2020
STIPULATION - ADJOURNMENT OF MOTION
002
Nicole Ann Callahan
20
12/08/2020
CONSENT TO CHANGE ATTORNEY (POST RJI)
Nicole Ann Callahan
21
01/12/2021
STIPULATION - WITHDRAWING MOTION/ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE
002
Kyle Anthony Schiedo
22
02/11/2021
LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE
Todd Mitchell Rubin
23
02/23/2021
ORDER ( PROPOSED )
Proposed Certification Order
Todd Mitchell Rubin
24
02/24/2021
ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE
Janet Dantuono
25
03/15/2021
NOTE OF ISSUE:WITH JURY
Todd Mitchell Rubin
26
04/07/2021
LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE
Todd Mitchell Rubin
27
11/16/2021
COURT NOTICE
Maryellen Haase
28
11/17/2021
LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE
Settlement notification to the Court
Todd Mitchell Rubin
29
01/05/2022
STIPULATION - DISCONTINUANCE (POST RJI)
on behalf of Premier Home Health Care Services
Nicole Ann Callahan
30
01/17/2022
STIPULATION - DISCONTINUANCE (POST RJI)
As to VNS CHOICE i/s/h/a VNS Choice Community Care
Decided: 05/01/2020 Granted Before Justice: Feinman, Hon. Thomas
Short Form Order
05/01/2020
4
07/09/2019
Judgment - Summary
09/25/2019
Yes
Decided: 09/25/2019 Withdrawn Before Justice: Murphy, Hon. Karen Veronica
Oral
09/25/2019
3
05/09/2019
Vacate - Decision/Order/Judgment/Award
06/13/2019
Yes
Decided: 08/29/2019 Granted Before Justice: Murphy, Hon. Karen Veronica
Short Form Order
08/29/2019
2
03/29/2019
Compel
05/20/2019
Yes
Decided: 08/29/2019 Decided Before Justice: Murphy, Hon. Karen Veronica
Short Form Order
08/29/2019
1
03/26/2018
Parties - Add/Substitute/Intervene
04/10/2018
Yes
Decided: 05/17/2018 Granted Before Justice: Murphy, Hon. Karen Veronica
Short Form Order
05/17/2018
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (111)
Doc #
Date Filed
Document
Description
Motion #
Filing User
File
1
06/12/2013
SUMMONS + COMPLAINT
Jonathan Caruselle Macri
2
06/27/2013
SUMMONS - SUPPLEMENTAL (PRE RJI)
Jonathan Caruselle Macri
3
06/27/2013
COMPLAINT (AMENDED)
Jonathan Caruselle Macri
4
08/05/2013
PROOF OF SERVICE
affidavits of service for all three defendants
Jonathan Caruselle Macri
5
09/05/2013
ANSWER WITH CROSS-CLAIM(S)
Ondine Slone
6
09/05/2013
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT OF SERVICE
Ondine Slone
7
02/26/2014
PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE REQUEST
Jonathan Caruselle Macri
8
02/26/2014
RJI -RE: REQUEST FOR PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE
Jonathan Caruselle Macri
9
02/26/2014
PROOF OF SERVICE
Jonathan Caruselle Macri
10
04/03/2014
ORDER - PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE
Signed 03/26/2014
Carmine Ambroselli
11
03/20/2018
NOTICE OF MOTION
001
Brett A Zekowski
12
03/20/2018
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT
001
Brett A Zekowski
13
03/20/2018
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT
001
Brett A Zekowski
14
03/20/2018
EXHIBIT(S)
SC
001
Brett A Zekowski
15
03/20/2018
EXHIBIT(S)
Answer
001
Brett A Zekowski
16
03/20/2018
EXHIBIT(S)
Supplemental Summons
001
Brett A Zekowski
17
03/20/2018
EXHIBIT(S)
Amended Answer
001
Brett A Zekowski
18
03/20/2018
EXHIBIT(S)
Letters of Administration
001
Brett A Zekowski
19
03/20/2018
EXHIBIT(S)
Retainer
001
Brett A Zekowski
20
03/20/2018
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
001
Brett A Zekowski
21
05/25/2018
ORDER - AMENDING CAPTION
Harriet Jenkins
22
11/19/2018
STIPULATION - SO ORDERED
William Cusick
23
02/26/2019
ORDER - CERTIFICATION
Christopher L Norman
24
03/14/2019
ANSWER
Frank J. Laurino
25
03/14/2019
AFFIDAVIT
Affidavit of Service
Frank J. Laurino
26
03/28/2019
NOTICE OF MOTION
Notice of Motion
002
Barbara-Ann Anzelmo
27
03/28/2019
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION
Suporting Affirmation
002
Barbara-Ann Anzelmo
28
03/28/2019
AFFIRMATION OF GOOD FAITH
Affirmation of Good Faith
002
Barbara-Ann Anzelmo
29
03/28/2019
EXHIBIT(S)
Pleadings
002
Barbara-Ann Anzelmo
30
03/28/2019
EXHIBIT(S)
Notice for Discovery and Inspection
002
Barbara-Ann Anzelmo
31
03/28/2019
EXHIBIT(S)
Transcrpit of Corinne Withropf
002
Barbara-Ann Anzelmo
32
03/28/2019
EXHIBIT(S)
Transcript of Rapid Transit Services, Inc.
002
Barbara-Ann Anzelmo
33
03/28/2019
EXHIBIT(S)
Transcript of Marie Doninelli
002
Barbara-Ann Anzelmo
34
03/28/2019
EXHIBIT(S)
Stipulation
002
Barbara-Ann Anzelmo
35
03/28/2019
EXHIBIT(S)
Response to Demands
002
Barbara-Ann Anzelmo
36
03/28/2019
EXHIBIT(S)
Transcrpit of Corinne Withropf
002
Barbara-Ann Anzelmo
37
03/28/2019
EXHIBIT(S)
Transcript of Rapid Transit Services, Inc.
002
Barbara-Ann Anzelmo
38
03/28/2019
EXHIBIT(S)
Transcript of Marie Doninelli
002
Barbara-Ann Anzelmo
39
03/28/2019
EXHIBIT(S)
Stipulation
002
Barbara-Ann Anzelmo
40
03/28/2019
EXHIBIT(S)
Response to Demands
002
Barbara-Ann Anzelmo
41
03/28/2019
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
Affidavit of Service
002
Barbara-Ann Anzelmo
42
04/24/2019
NOTE OF ISSUE:WITH JURY
Denny Tang
43
04/29/2019
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION
002
Kelly Marie Zic
44
04/29/2019
EXHIBIT(S)
3/4/19 post-ebt discovery response
002
Kelly Marie Zic
45
04/29/2019
EXHIBIT(S)
Premier employee manual
002
Kelly Marie Zic
46
05/09/2019
NOTICE OF MOTION
003
Barbara-Ann Anzelmo
47
05/09/2019
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION
Supporting Affirmations
003
Barbara-Ann Anzelmo
48
05/09/2019
EXHIBIT(S)
Exh A - Pleadings
003
Barbara-Ann Anzelmo
49
05/09/2019
EXHIBIT(S)
Exh B Note of Issue
003
Barbara-Ann Anzelmo
50
05/09/2019
EXHIBIT(S)
Exh C Discovery Notice
003
Barbara-Ann Anzelmo
51
05/09/2019
EXHIBIT(S)
Exh D - Discovery Response
003
Barbara-Ann Anzelmo
52
05/09/2019
EXHIBIT(S)
Exh E - Motion to Compel Discovery
003
Barbara-Ann Anzelmo
53
05/09/2019
AFFIDAVIT
Affidavit of Service
003
Barbara-Ann Anzelmo
54
05/15/2019
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN REPLY
Reply Affirmation
002
Barbara-Ann Anzelmo
55
05/15/2019
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
Affidavit
002
Barbara-Ann Anzelmo
56
07/08/2019
NOTICE OF MOTION
004
Kelly Marie Zic
57
07/08/2019
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION
004
Kelly Marie Zic
58
07/08/2019
EXHIBIT(S)
Supplemental Summons and Amended Complaint
004
Kelly Marie Zic
59
07/08/2019
EXHIBIT(S)
Answer of Premier Home and Doninelli
004
Kelly Marie Zic
60
07/08/2019
EXHIBIT(S)
Answer of Rapid Transit and Jones
004
Kelly Marie Zic
61
07/08/2019
EXHIBIT(S)
Bill of Particulars
004
Kelly Marie Zic
62
07/08/2019
EXHIBIT(S)
Court Order
004
Kelly Marie Zic
63
07/08/2019
EXHIBIT(S)
Corinne Withopf transcript
004
Kelly Marie Zic
64
07/08/2019
EXHIBIT(S)
James Jones Transcript
004
Kelly Marie Zic
65
07/08/2019
EXHIBIT(S)
Marie Doninelli Transcript
004
Kelly Marie Zic
66
07/08/2019
EXHIBIT(S)
Note of Issue
004
Kelly Marie Zic
67
07/08/2019
MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN SUPPORT
004
Kelly Marie Zic
68
07/30/2019
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION
Affirmation in Opposition
004
Barbara-Ann Anzelmo
69
07/30/2019
EXHIBIT(S)
Motion dated 3/26/19
004
Barbara-Ann Anzelmo
70
07/30/2019
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
Affidavit of Service
004
Barbara-Ann Anzelmo
71
09/04/2019
AFFIRMATION
AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION
Denny Tang
72
09/04/2019
EXHIBIT(S)
AFFIDAVIT - EXPERT
Denny Tang
73
09/06/2019
STIPULATION - OTHER
Denny Tang
74
09/16/2019
ORDER - VACATING NOTE OF ISSUE
Joyce Teller
75
09/19/2019
NOTICE OF ENTRY
Order with Notice of Entry
003
Barbara-Ann Anzelmo
76
09/19/2019
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
Affidavit of Service
003
Barbara-Ann Anzelmo
77
10/04/2019
NOTE OF ISSUE:WITH JURY
Denny Tang
78
10/10/2019
ORDER - CERTIFICATION
Christopher L Norman
79
11/25/2019
NOTICE OF MOTION
Notice of Motion
005
Kelly Marie Zic
80
11/25/2019
AFFIDAVIT
Affidavit of Jeanine Frumenti
005
Kelly Marie Zic
81
11/25/2019
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION
Affirmation in Support of Motion
005
Kelly Marie Zic
82
11/25/2019
MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN SUPPORT
Memo of Law
005
Kelly Marie Zic
83
11/25/2019
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex. A - Supp Summons and Amended Complaint
005
Kelly Marie Zic
84
11/25/2019
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex. B - Answer of Premier Home and Doninmelli
005
Kelly Marie Zic
85
11/25/2019
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex. C - Answer of Rapid Transit and James Jones
005
Kelly Marie Zic
86
11/25/2019
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex. D - BP
005
Kelly Marie Zic
87
11/25/2019
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex. E - Court Order
005
Kelly Marie Zic
88
11/25/2019
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex. F - Corrine Withopf transcript
005
Kelly Marie Zic
89
11/25/2019
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex. G - James Jones transcript
005
Kelly Marie Zic
90
11/25/2019
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex. H - Marie Doninelli transcript
005
Kelly Marie Zic
91
11/25/2019
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex. I - September 16, 2019 Letter and August 29, 2019 Court Order
005
Kelly Marie Zic
92
11/25/2019
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex. J - October 2, 2019 Certification Order
005
Kelly Marie Zic
93
11/25/2019
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex. K - Plaintiff's Note of Issue
005
Kelly Marie Zic
94
11/25/2019
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex. L - Marie Doninelli's Home Health Aide Certificate
005
Kelly Marie Zic
95
11/25/2019
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex. M - Premier Home Health Care Services, Inc.'s Home Health Aide Job Description
005
Kelly Marie Zic
96
12/10/2019
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION
Affirmation in Opposition
005
Barbara-Ann Anzelmo
97
12/10/2019
EXHIBIT(S)
Exhibit A
005
Barbara-Ann Anzelmo
98
12/10/2019
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
Affidavit of Service
005
Barbara-Ann Anzelmo
99
12/16/2019
STIPULATION - ADJOURNMENT OF MOTION
Stipulation to Adjourn Motion
005
Denny Tang
100
01/07/2020
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION
Affirmation in Opposition
004
Denny Tang
101
01/07/2020
EXHIBIT(S)
Expert Affidavit
004
Denny Tang
102
01/21/2020
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN REPLY
005
Kelly Marie Zic
103
01/21/2020
AFFIDAVIT
Frumenti Affidavit
005
Kelly Marie Zic
104
05/07/2020
ORDER - OTHER
005
Nicholas Vitale
105
05/05/2020
NOTICE OF ENTRY
Kelly Marie Zic
106
05/06/2020
NOTICE OF APPEAL
Notice of Appeal
005
Denny Tang
107
02/10/2022
SUBSTITUTION OF ATTORNEY (POST RJI)
Brian J Mcgovern
108
11/10/2022
NOTICE OF ENTRY
Ondine Slone
109
12/07/2022
APPELLATE COURT DECISION/ORDER (CERTIFIED COPY)
Zachary Pollock
110
12/19/2022
COURT NOTICE
Christopher Zanchelli
111
01/05/2023
LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE
Denny Tang
46
Nassau Supreme Court
2013
601237/2014
Disposed
Comm-Other
PREMIER HOME HEALTH CARE
U.S. DISTRICT JUDGE U.S. COURTHOUSE SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF N.Y.
GIRLING HEALTH CARE
Garfunkel Wild, P.C.
11/16/2017
DeStefano, Hon. Vito M.
▼
Case Info
Court
Nassau Supreme Court
Index Number
601237/2014
Status
Disposed
Year Filed
2013
Case Name
PREMIER HOME HEALTH CARE vs. GIRLING HEALTH CARE
Case Type
Comm-Other
Track
Standard
RJI Filed
06/27/2013
NOI Due
06/27/2014
NOI Filed
Calendar Number
—
Jury Status
Justice
DeStefano, Hon. Vito M.
Next Appearance
11/16/2017
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
PREMIER HOME HEALTH CARE
Attorney / FirmU.S. DISTRICT JUDGE U.S. COURTHOUSE SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF N.Y.
Defendant / Respondent
GIRLING HEALTH CARE
Attorneys / FirmsGarfunkel Wild, P.C.
Motions (4)
#
Date Filed
Filed By
Relief Sought
Submit Date
Answer
Status
Decision
Order Signed
4
11/17/2016
Compel
02/21/2017
Yes
Decided: 05/11/2017 Decided Before Justice: DeStefano, Hon. Vito M.
Short Form Order
05/11/2017
3
11/07/2016
Compel
02/21/2017
Yes
Decided: 05/11/2017 Decided Before Justice: DeStefano, Hon. Vito M.
Short Form Order
05/11/2017
2
11/03/2014
Judgment - Summary
06/26/2015
Yes
Decided: 12/28/2015 Decided Before Justice: DeStefano, Hon. Vito M.
Short Form Order
12/28/2015
1
04/04/2014
Dismiss
05/29/2014
No
Decided: 10/03/2014 Decided Before Justice: DeStefano, Hon. Vito M.
Short Form Order
10/03/2014
Decisions (2)
Court
Index Number
Case Name
Motion #
Scanned On
Nassau Supreme Court
601237/2014
PREMIER HOME HEALTH CARE vs. GIRLING HEALTH CARE
101
Nassau Supreme Court
601237/2014
PREMIER HOME HEALTH CARE vs. GIRLING HEALTH CARE
100
Complaints (221)
Doc #
Date Filed
Document
Description
Motion #
Filing User
File
2
03/29/2013
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
Affidavit Of Service Of Summons And Verified Complaint Upon Defendant Girling Health Care Services, Inc.
Philip M Halpern
3
03/29/2013
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
Affidavit Of Service Of Summons And Verified Complaint Upon Defendant Girling Health Care Of New York, Inc.
Philip M Halpern
4
03/29/2013
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
Affidavit Of Service Of Summons And Verified Complaint Upon Defendant Harden Home Health, LLC
Philip M Halpern
5
03/29/2013
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
Affidavit Of Service Of Summons And Verified Complaint Upon Defendant Home Health Care Services Of New York, Inc.
Philip M Halpern
6
04/18/2013
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
Affidavit Of Service Of Summons And Verified Complaint Upon Defendant Harden Healthcare, LLC
Philip M Halpern
7
06/27/2013
RJI -RE: OTHER(SPECIFY IN DESCRIPTION AREA)
RJI re: OTSC
Kevin G Donoghue
8
06/27/2013
ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE ( PROPOSED )
NY001
Kevin G Donoghue
9
06/27/2013
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF PROPOSED OSC/EXPARTE APP
Donoghue Emergency Affirmation in Support
NY001
Kevin G Donoghue
10
06/27/2013
AFFIRMATION
Donoghue Affirmation Pursuant to Uniform Rule 202.07(f)
NY001
Kevin G Donoghue
11
06/27/2013
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT
Donoghue Affirmation in Support of Defendants' Motion to Extend Time to Respond to Plaintiff's Complaint
NY001
Kevin G Donoghue
12
06/27/2013
EXHIBIT(S)
NY001
Kevin G Donoghue
13
06/27/2013
EXHIBIT(S)
NY001
Kevin G Donoghue
14
06/27/2013
EXHIBIT(S)
NY001
Kevin G Donoghue
15
06/27/2013
EXHIBIT(S)
NY001
Kevin G Donoghue
16
06/27/2013
EXHIBIT(S)
NY001
Kevin G Donoghue
17
06/27/2013
EXHIBIT(S)
NY001
Kevin G Donoghue
18
06/28/2013
NOTICE OF MOTION
Notice of Motion to Dismiss
NY002
Kara Marie Cormier
19
06/28/2013
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION
Affidavit of Jeffrey Shemia
NY002
Kara Marie Cormier
20
06/28/2013
MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN SUPPORT
Memorandum of Law of Defendant Home Health Care Services of New York In Support of its Motion to Dismiss for Failure to State a Claim
NY002
Kara Marie Cormier
21
06/28/2013
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
NY002
Kara Marie Cormier
22
06/28/2013
NOTICE OF APPEARANCE (POST RJI)
NOTICE OF APPEARANCE BY ANDRE K. CIZMARIK FOR DEFENDANT HOME HEALTH CARE SERVICES OF NEW YORK INC.
Andre K Cizmarik
23
07/01/2013
ANSWER
Leonard M Rosenberg
24
07/01/2013
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
Leonard M Rosenberg
25
07/05/2013
STIPULATION - ADJOURNMENT OF MOTION
Adjournment Of Motion Return Date To August 14, 2013 (Plaintiff's Opposition Due On July 23, 2013; Defendant HCS's Reply Due On August 13, 2013)
NY002
Philip M Halpern
26
07/12/2013
NOTICE OF MOTION
Notice of Motion to Dismiss or Transfer Venue
NY003
Kevin G Donoghue
27
07/12/2013
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION
Hanson Affidavit in Support of Motion to Dismiss or Transfer Venue
NY003
Kevin G Donoghue
28
07/12/2013
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION
Donoghue Affirmation in Support of Defendants' Motion to Dismiss or Transfer Venue
NY003
Kevin G Donoghue
29
07/12/2013
EXHIBIT(S)
NY003
Kevin G Donoghue
30
07/12/2013
EXHIBIT(S)
NY003
Kevin G Donoghue
31
07/12/2013
EXHIBIT(S)
NY003
Kevin G Donoghue
32
07/12/2013
EXHIBIT(S)
NY003
Kevin G Donoghue
33
07/12/2013
EXHIBIT(S)
NY003
Kevin G Donoghue
34
07/12/2013
MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN SUPPORT
NY003
Kevin G Donoghue
35
07/12/2013
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
NY003
Kevin G Donoghue
36
07/16/2013
DECISION + ORDER ON MOTION
re: motion no. 001, DECISION + ORDER ON MOTION entered in the office of the County Clerk on July 16, 2013
NY001
Gregory Gonsieski
37
07/17/2013
ANSWER (AMENDED)
Amended Answer with Counterclaim
Leonard M Rosenberg
38
07/17/2013
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
Leonard M Rosenberg
39
07/22/2013
SUMMONS - SUPPLEMENTAL (PRE RJI)
(Supplemental Summons Naming HCS Certified Home Care NY, Inc. As An Additional Defendant)
Howard S Bonfield
40
07/22/2013
COMPLAINT (AMENDED)
(Amended Verified Complaint)
Howard S Bonfield
41
07/22/2013
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
(Affidavit Of Service In Connection With Supplemental Summons And Amended Verified Complaint)
Howard S Bonfield
42
07/22/2013
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION
(Affidavit Of Philip M. Halpern In Opposition To Motion To Dismiss)
NY002
Howard S Bonfield
43
07/22/2013
EXHIBIT(S)
Exhibit A (To Affidavit Of Philip M. Halpern In Opposition To Motion To Dismiss)
NY002
Howard S Bonfield
44
07/22/2013
MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN OPPOSITION
(Plaintiff's Memorandum Of Law In Opposition To Defendant Home Health Care Services Of New York Inc.'s Motion To Dismiss)
NY002
Howard S Bonfield
45
07/22/2013
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
(Affidavit Of Service In Connection With Affidavit In Opposition To Motion To Dismiss And Memorandum Of Law In Opposition To Motion To Dismiss)
NY002
Howard S Bonfield
46
08/02/2013
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
(Affidavit Of Service In Connection With Supplemental Summons And Amended Verified Complaint And Notice Of Electronic Filing Upon Defendant HCS Certified Home Care NY, Inc.)
Howard S Bonfield
47
08/09/2013
ANSWER WITH COUNTER-CLAIM(S)
Answer to Amended Verified Complaint with Counterclaim
Leonard M Rosenberg
48
08/09/2013
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
Donoghue Affirmation of Service
Leonard M Rosenberg
49
08/09/2013
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
Affidavit of Service
Leonard M Rosenberg
50
08/12/2013
ANSWER
ANSWER OF HOME HEALTH CARE SERVICES OF NEW YORK INC. TO AMENDED COMPLAINT
Andre K Cizmarik
51
08/13/2013
STIPULATION - OTHER
STIPULATION TO WITHDRAW MOTION TO DISMISS RETURNABLE AUG. 14, 2013
NY002
Andre K Cizmarik
52
08/14/2013
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION
Affidavit Of Cesar A. Perez In Opposition To Motion To Dismiss Or Transfer Venue
NY003
Philip M Halpern
53
08/14/2013
EXHIBIT(S)
Exhibit A (To Affidavit Of Cesar A. Perez In Opposition To Motion To Dismiss Or Transfer Venue)
NY003
Philip M Halpern
54
08/14/2013
EXHIBIT(S)
Exhibit B (To Affidavit Of Cesar A. Perez In Opposition To Motion To Dismiss Or Transfer Venue)
NY003
Philip M Halpern
55
08/14/2013
MEMORANDUM IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION AND IN SUPPORT OF CROSS-MOTION
Plaintiff's Memorandum Of Law In Opposition To Motion To Dismiss Or Transfer Venue
NY003
Philip M Halpern
56
08/14/2013
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
NY003
Philip M Halpern
57
08/20/2013
STIPULATION - ADJOURNMENT OF MOTION
NY003
Leonard M Rosenberg
58
08/21/2013
NOTICE OF MOTION
NOTICE OF MOTION BY DEFENDANT "HCS" TO DISMISS THE AMENDED COMPLAINT
004
Kara Marie Cormier
59
08/21/2013
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION
AFFIRMATION OF KARA M. CORMIER
004
Kara Marie Cormier
60
08/21/2013
EXHIBIT(S)
004
Kara Marie Cormier
61
08/21/2013
EXHIBIT(S)
004
Kara Marie Cormier
62
08/21/2013
EXHIBIT(S)
004
Kara Marie Cormier
63
08/21/2013
MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN SUPPORT
MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF DEFENDANT HCS CERTIFIED HOME CARE NY, INC. IN SUPPORT OF ITS MOTION TO DISMISS FOR FAILURE TO STATE A CAUSE OF ACTION
004
Kara Marie Cormier
64
08/23/2013
DECISION + ORDER ON MOTION
DECISION + ORDER ON MOTION entered in the office of the County Clerk on August 23, 2013
NY002
Clifford Reig
65
08/28/2013
STIPULATION - ADJOURNMENT OF MOTION
Stipulation Modifying Briefing Schedule And Return Date (Opposition Papers Due 9/20/13; Reply Papers Due 10/11/13; Return Date Is 10/15/13)
004
Philip M Halpern
66
08/29/2013
REPLY TO COUNTERCLAIM(S)
Plaintiff's Verified Reply To Counterclaim Asserted By The Harden/Girling Defendants
Philip M Halpern
67
09/03/2013
STIPULATION - ADJOURNMENT OF MOTION
NY003
Leonard M Rosenberg
68
09/13/2013
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN REPLY
Donoghue Affirmation in Further Support of Defendants' Motion to Dismiss or Transfer Venue
NY003
Kevin G Donoghue
69
09/13/2013
EXHIBIT(S)
NY003
Kevin G Donoghue
70
09/13/2013
EXHIBIT(S)
NY003
Kevin G Donoghue
71
09/13/2013
EXHIBIT(S)
NY003
Kevin G Donoghue
72
09/13/2013
EXHIBIT(S)
NY003
Kevin G Donoghue
73
09/13/2013
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
NY003
Kevin G Donoghue
74
09/13/2013
MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN REPLY
Reply Memorandum of Law in Further Support of Defendants' Motion to Dismiss or to Transfer Venue Based Upon a Contractual Forum Selection Clause
NY003
Kevin G Donoghue
75
09/13/2013
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
NY003
Kevin G Donoghue
76
09/16/2013
STIPULATION - ADJOURNMENT OF MOTION
Stipulation Modifying Briefing Schedule And Return Date (Opposition Papers Due 9/27/13; Reply Papers Due 10/18/13; Return Date Is 10/21/13)
004
Philip M Halpern
77
09/27/2013
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION
(Affidavit Of Cesar A. Perez In Opposition To Defendant HCS Certified Home Care NY, Inc.'s Motion To Dismiss)
004
Philip M Halpern
78
09/27/2013
EXHIBIT(S)
Exhibit A (To Affidavit Of Cesar A. Perez In Opposition To Defendant HCS Certified Home Care NY, Inc.'s Motion To Dismiss)
004
Philip M Halpern
79
09/27/2013
MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN OPPOSITION
(Plaintiff's Memorandum Of Law In Opposition To Defendant HCS Certified Home Care NY, Inc.'s Motion To Dismiss)
004
Philip M Halpern
80
10/10/2013
STIPULATION - ADJOURNMENT OF MOTION
STIPULATION TO ADJOURN DEFENDANT HCS'S 10/15/13 MOTION TO 11/5/13
004
Kara Marie Cormier
81
11/04/2013
MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN REPLY
REPLY MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF DEFENDANT HCS CERTIFIED HOME CARE NY INC. IN FURTHER SUPPORT OF ITS MOTION TO DISMISS FOR FAILURE TO STATE A CAUSE OF ACTION
004
Andre K Cizmarik
82
11/04/2013
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT
AFFIDAVIT OF JEFFREY SHEMIA
004
Andre K Cizmarik
83
11/04/2013
EXHIBIT(S)
004
Andre K Cizmarik
84
11/04/2013
EXHIBIT(S)
004
Andre K Cizmarik
85
11/20/2013
STIPULATION - OTHER
STIPULATION AND ORDER FOR THE PRODUCTION AND EXCHANGE OF CONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION
Andre K Cizmarik
86
12/03/2013
STIPULATION - SO ORDERED
SO ORDERED STIPULATION entered in the office of the County Clerk on December 3, 2013
Edward Liu
87
12/17/2013
DECISION ON MOTION -SETTLE ORD / JGMT
re: motion no. 003, DECISION + ORDER ON MOTION entered in the office of the County Clerk on December 17, 2013
NY003
Gregory Gonsieski
88
01/03/2014
DECISION + ORDER ON MOTION
re: motion no. 004, DECISION + ORDER ON MOTION entered in the office of the County Clerk on January 03, 2014
004
Gregory Gonsieski
89
01/31/2014
NOTICE OF SETTLEMENT W/PROPOSED ORDER/COUNTER ORDER
Kevin G Donoghue
90
01/31/2014
ORDER ( PROPOSED )
Kevin G Donoghue
91
01/31/2014
TRANSCRIPT OF PROCEEDINGS
Kevin G Donoghue
92
01/31/2014
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
Kevin G Donoghue
93
01/31/2014
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
Kevin G Donoghue
94
03/07/2014
DECISION + ORDER ON MOTION
re: motion no. 003, DECISION + ORDER ON MOTION entered in the office of the County Clerk on March 07, 2014
NY003
Clifford Reig
95
03/07/2014
NOTICE OF ENTRY
NY003
Kevin G Donoghue
96
03/07/2014
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
NY003
Kevin G Donoghue
97
03/14/2014
NOTICE TO COUNTY CLERK CPLR 8019(C)
Notice To County Clerk With Accompanying Order Transferring Venue (And The Entire Court File) From Supreme Court, New York County To Supreme Court, Nassau County
Philip M Halpern
98
04/01/2014
NOTICE OF MOTION
HCS'S NOTICE OF MOTION TO DISMISS THE AMENDED COMPLAINT
001
Kara Marie Cormier
99
04/01/2014
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION
AFFIRMATION OF KARA M. CORMIER, ESQ. IN SUPPORT
001
Kara Marie Cormier
100
04/01/2014
EXHIBIT(S)
PLAINTIFF'S AMENDED COMPLAINT
001
Kara Marie Cormier
101
04/01/2014
EXHIBIT(S)
ASSET PURCHASE AGREEMENT
001
Kara Marie Cormier
102
04/01/2014
EXHIBIT(S)
REDACTED EXCERPTS OF THE ASSET PURCHASE AGREEMENT
001
Kara Marie Cormier
103
04/01/2014
MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN SUPPORT
MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF DEFENDANT HCS'S CERTIFIED HOME CARE NY, INC. IN SUPPORT OF ITS MOTION TO DISMISS FOR FAILURE TO STATE A CAUSE OF ACTION
001
Kara Marie Cormier
104
04/01/2014
STIPULATION - OTHER
BRIEFING SCHEDULE FOR MOTION TO DISMISS AMENDED COMPLAINT
001
Kara Marie Cormier
105
04/02/2014
RJI (TRANSFERED- FROM/TO COUNTY)
Kara Marie Cormier
106
04/02/2014
ADDENDUM - COMMERCIAL DIVISION (840C)
Kara Marie Cormier
107
04/03/2014
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION
Affidavit Of Cesar A. Perez In Opposition To Defendant HCS Certified Home Care NY, Inc.'s Motion To Dismiss Plaintiff's Amended Complaint
001
Philip M Halpern
108
04/03/2014
EXHIBIT(S)
Exhibit A (To Affidavit Of Cesar A. Perez In Opposition To Defendant HCS Certified Home Care NY, Inc.'s Motion To Dismiss Plaintiff's Amended Complaint)
001
Philip M Halpern
109
04/03/2014
MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN OPPOSITION
Plaintiff's Memorandum Of Law In Opposition To Defendant HCS Certified Home Care NY, Inc.'s Motion To Dismiss Plaintiff's Amended Complaint
001
Philip M Halpern
110
04/04/2014
MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN REPLY
REPLY MEMORANDUM OF LAW
001
Kara Marie Cormier
111
04/04/2014
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN REPLY
REPLY AFFIDAVIT OF JEFFREY SHEMIA
001
Kara Marie Cormier
112
04/04/2014
EXHIBIT(S)
Girling LHCSA/Girling CHHA Agreement Dated November 16, 2011
001
Kara Marie Cormier
113
04/04/2014
EXHIBIT(S)
Certified/Girling NY Asset Purchase Agreement Dated July 11, 2012
001
Kara Marie Cormier
114
10/10/2014
DECISION + ORDER ON MOTION
Motion Seq.#01 Signed 10/03/2014
001
Carmine Ambroselli
115
10/17/2014
NOTICE OF ENTRY
(Notice Of Entry Of Decision And Order Filed And Entered On October 10, 2014)
Philip M Halpern
116
10/27/2014
ANSWER
ANSWER OF HCS CERTIFIED HOME CARE NY, INC. TO AMENDED COMPLAINT
Andre K Cizmarik
117
10/29/2014
NOTICE OF MOTION
NOTICE OF GIRLING AND HARDEN DEFENDANTS MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT DISMISSAL OF PLAINTIFF'S AMENDED COMPLAINT AND SUMMARY JUDGMENT ON DEFENDANTS' COUNTERCLAIM AGAINST PLAINTIFF
002
Leonard M Rosenberg
118
10/29/2014
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION
AFFIDAVIT OF BENJAMIN M. HANSON IN SUPPORT OF GIRLING AND HARDEN DEFENDANTS MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT
002
Leonard M Rosenberg
119
10/29/2014
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION
AFFIRMATION OF LEONARD M. ROSENBERG IN SUPPORT OF GIRLING AND HARDEN DEFENDANTS MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT DISMISSAL
002
Leonard M Rosenberg
120
10/29/2014
EXHIBIT(S)
EXHIBIT 1 - ASSET PURCHASE AGREEMENT BETWEEN DEFENDANT GIRLING SERVICES AND PLAINTIFF PREMIER
002
Leonard M Rosenberg
121
10/29/2014
EXHIBIT(S)
EXHIBIT 2 - MANAGEMENT AGREEMENT BETWEEN DEFENDANT GIRLING SERVICES AND PLAINTIFF PREMIER
002
Leonard M Rosenberg
122
10/29/2014
EXHIBIT(S)
EXHIBIT 3 - CONSULTING AGREEMENT BETWEEN DEFENDANT GIRLING SERVICES AND PLAINTIFF PREMIER
002
Leonard M Rosenberg
123
10/29/2014
EXHIBIT(S)
EXHIBIT 4 - APRIL 3, 2012 LETTER / APPLICATION BY PLAINTIFF PREMIER TO NYS DEPT OF HEALTH WITH CERTIFICATION AND LIST OF MULTIPLE REFERRAL SOURCES (CHHA'S AND OTHER PROGRAMS)
002
Leonard M Rosenberg
124
10/29/2014
EXHIBIT(S)
EXHIBIT 5 - JUNE 25, 2012 EMAIL EXCHANGE BETWEEN DEFENDANT AND PLAINTIFF REGARDING NOTICE OF SALE OF GIRLING CHHA TO CODEFENDANT HCS
002
Leonard M Rosenberg
125
10/29/2014
EXHIBIT(S)
EXHIBIT 6 - LHCSA / CHHA SERVICES AGREEMENT BETWEEN GIRLING SERVICES AND GIRLING NY
002
Leonard M Rosenberg
126
10/29/2014
EXHIBIT(S)
EXHIBIT 7 - ASSET PURCHASE AGREEMENT BETWEEN GIRLING NY AND HCS
002
Leonard M Rosenberg
127
10/29/2014
EXHIBIT(S)
EXHIBIT 8 - SUPPLEMENTAL SUMMONS AND AMENDED COMPLAINT
002
Leonard M Rosenberg
128
10/29/2014
EXHIBIT(S)
EXHIBIT 9 - GIRLING AND HARDEN DEFENDANTS ANSWER TO AMENDED COMPLAINT WITH COUNTERCLAIM AGAINST PLAINTIFF
002
Leonard M Rosenberg
129
10/29/2014
EXHIBIT(S)
EXHIBIT 10 - FEBRUARY 4, 2014 ORDER GRANTING DEFENDANT MOTION TO TRANSFER VENUE FROM NEW YORK COUNTY TO NASSAU COUNTY
002
Leonard M Rosenberg
130
10/29/2014
EXHIBIT(S)
EXHIBIT 11 - OCTOBER 3, 2014 DECISION AND ORDER OF HONORABLE VITO M. DESTEFANO ON CODEFENDANT HCS MOTION TO DISMISS
002
Leonard M Rosenberg
131
10/29/2014
MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN SUPPORT
GIRLING AND HARDEN DEFENDANTS' MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT DISMISSAL OF PLAINTIFF'S AMENDED COMPLAINT AND IN SUPPORT OF SUMMARY JUDGMENT ON DEFENDANTS' COUNTERCLAIM AGAINST PLAINTIFF
002
Leonard M Rosenberg
132
10/31/2014
LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE
(Letter To The Honorable Vito M. DeStefano)
Howard S Bonfield
133
11/04/2014
LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE
Letter Regarding Briefing Schedule on Defendants' Summary Judgment Motion and in Response to Plaintiff's October 31, 2014 Letter
002
Kevin G Donoghue
134
11/05/2014
LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE
LETTER TO JUDGE DESTEFANO FROM DEFENDANT "HCS" COUNSEL
Andre K Cizmarik
135
11/11/2014
LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE
Letter Application by Girling and Harden Defendants for an Enlargement in the Number of Pages for Memorandum of Law in Support of Summary Judgment Motion - Five Page Enlargement Requested
002
Kevin G Donoghue
136
11/20/2014
STIPULATION - OTHER - ( REQUEST TO SO ORDER )
(Letter To The Honorable Vito M. DeStefano Seeking Conference To Resolve Briefing Schedule Issues)
002
Howard S Bonfield
137
11/21/2014
STIPULATION - OTHER - ( REQUEST TO SO ORDER )
(Letter To Court Requesting That Accompanying Fully Executed Stipulation Be "So Ordered")
002
Howard S Bonfield
138
12/19/2014
STIPULATION - OTHER
(Stipulation Modifying Briefing Schedule In Connection With Harden/Girling Defendants Motion For Summary Judgment)
002
Howard S Bonfield
139
01/05/2015
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION
(Affidavit Of Cesar A. Perez In Opposition To Harden/Girling Defendants' Motion For Summary Judgment)
002
Philip M Halpern
140
01/05/2015
EXHIBIT(S)
(Exhibit A To Perez Affidavit)
002
Philip M Halpern
141
01/05/2015
EXHIBIT(S)
(Exhibit B To Perez Affidavit)
002
Philip M Halpern
142
01/05/2015
EXHIBIT(S)
(Exhibit C To Perez Affidavit)
002
Philip M Halpern
143
01/05/2015
EXHIBIT(S)
(Exhibit D To Perez Affidavit)
002
Philip M Halpern
144
01/05/2015
EXHIBIT(S)
(Exhibit E To Perez Affidavit)
002
Philip M Halpern
145
01/05/2015
EXHIBIT(S)
(Exhibit F To Perez Affidavit)
002
Philip M Halpern
146
01/05/2015
EXHIBIT(S)
(Exhibit G To Perez Affidavit)
002
Philip M Halpern
147
01/05/2015
EXHIBIT(S)
(Exhibit H To Perez Affidavit)
002
Philip M Halpern
148
01/05/2015
EXHIBIT(S)
(Exhibit I To Perez Affidavit)
002
Philip M Halpern
149
01/05/2015
EXHIBIT(S)
(Exhibit J To Perez Affidavit)
002
Philip M Halpern
150
01/05/2015
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION
(Affidavit Of Harry J. Nicolay, Jr. In Opposition To Harden/Girling Defendants' Motion For Summary Judgment)
002
Philip M Halpern
151
01/05/2015
EXHIBIT(S)
(Exhibit A To Nicolay Affidavit)
002
Philip M Halpern
152
01/05/2015
EXHIBIT(S)
(Exhibit B To Nicolay Affidavit)
002
Philip M Halpern
153
01/05/2015
EXHIBIT(S)
(Exhibit C To Nicolay Affidavit)
002
Philip M Halpern
154
01/05/2015
EXHIBIT(S)
(Exhibit D To Nicolay Affidavit)
002
Philip M Halpern
155
01/05/2015
MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN OPPOSITION
(Plaintiff's Memorandum Of Law In Opposition To Harden/Girling Defendants' Motion For Summary Judgment)
002
Philip M Halpern
156
01/12/2015
NOTICE OF CHANGE OF FIRM NAME OR ADDRESS (POST RJI)
EDWARDS WILDMAN LLP CHANGED NAME TO LOCKE LORD LLP FOR DEFENDANTS HCS AND HOME HEALTH CARE SERVICES OF NY INC.
Andre K Cizmarik
157
02/12/2015
NOTICE OF APPEARANCE (POST RJI)
Marc Andrew Sittenreich
158
03/04/2015
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN REPLY
Reply Affidavit of Benjamin M. Hanson in Support of Defendants' Motion for Summary Judgment
002
Kevin G Donoghue
159
03/04/2015
EXHIBIT(S)
Exhibit 1
002
Kevin G Donoghue
160
03/04/2015
EXHIBIT(S)
Exhibit 2
002
Kevin G Donoghue
161
03/04/2015
EXHIBIT(S)
Exhibit 3
002
Kevin G Donoghue
162
03/04/2015
MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN REPLY
REPLY MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN FURTHER SUPPORT OF GIRLING AND HARDEN DEFENDANTS' MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT
002
Kevin G Donoghue
163
03/06/2015
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
Affirmation of Service of Reply Affidavit in Support
002
Kevin G Donoghue
164
03/06/2015
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
Affirmation of Service for Reply Memorandum of Law in Support
002
Kevin G Donoghue
165
03/20/2015
SUBSTITUTION OF ATTORNEY (POST RJI)
Joseph L Clasen
166
06/18/2015
STATEMENT OF MATERIAL FACTS
002
Marc Andrew Sittenreich
167
07/09/2015
RESPONSE TO STATEMENT OF MATERIAL FACTS
(Plaintiff's Response To Harden/Girling Defendants' Statement Of Material Facts And Counterstatement Of Material Facts)
002
Philip M Halpern
168
07/15/2015
STIPULATION - OTHER - ( REQUEST TO SO ORDER )
Philip M Halpern
169
08/18/2015
STIPULATION - SO ORDERED
Nicholas Vitale
170
01/05/2016
DECISION + ORDER ON MOTION
002
Nicholas Vitale
171
01/29/2016
NOTICE OF ENTRY
Decision and Order with Notice of Entry
Marc Andrew Sittenreich
172
01/29/2016
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
Marc Andrew Sittenreich
173
06/03/2016
LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE
Ian Thomas Clarke-Fisher
174
06/06/2016
LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE
(June 6, 2016 Letter From Premier's Counsel To Justice DeStefano Responding To HCS's Counsel's June 3, 2016 Letter)
Howard S Bonfield
175
06/07/2016
LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE
Girling and Harden Defendants' position on HCS' request that the action be dismissed as against it
Kevin G Donoghue
176
10/04/2016
ORDER - OTHER
discovery
Nicholas Vitale
177
11/07/2016
NOTICE OF MOTION
003
Howard S Bonfield
178
11/07/2016
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION
(Motion To Compel Defendants To Produce Documents And For Issuance Of Conditional Order Striking Defendants' Answers In Event Of Noncompliance)
003
Howard S Bonfield
179
11/07/2016
EXHIBIT(S)
(Exhibit A To Affidavit Of Howard S. Bonfield In Support Of Motion To Compel Defendants To Produce Documents And For Issuance Of Conditional Order Striking Defendants' Answers In Event Of Noncompliance)
003
Howard S Bonfield
180
11/07/2016
EXHIBIT(S)
(Exhibit B To Affidavit Of Howard S. Bonfield In Support Of Motion To Compel Defendants To Produce Documents And For Issuance Of Conditional Order Striking Defendants' Answers In Event Of Noncompliance)
003
Howard S Bonfield
181
11/07/2016
EXHIBIT(S)
(Exhibit C To Affidavit Of Howard S. Bonfield In Support Of Motion To Compel Defendants To Produce Documents And For Issuance Of Conditional Order Striking Defendants' Answers In Event Of Noncompliance)
003
Howard S Bonfield
182
11/07/2016
EXHIBIT(S)
(Exhibit D To Affidavit Of Howard S. Bonfield In Support Of Motion To Compel Defendants To Produce Documents And For Issuance Of Conditional Order Striking Defendants' Answers In Event Of Noncompliance)
003
Howard S Bonfield
183
11/07/2016
EXHIBIT(S)
(Exhibit E To Affidavit Of Howard S. Bonfield In Support Of Motion To Compel Defendants To Produce Documents And For Issuance Of Conditional Order Striking Defendants' Answers In Event Of Noncompliance)
003
Howard S Bonfield
184
11/07/2016
EXHIBIT(S)
(Exhibit F To Affidavit Of Howard S. Bonfield In Support Of Motion To Compel Defendants To Produce Documents And For Issuance Of Conditional Order Striking Defendants' Answers In Event Of Noncompliance)
003
Howard S Bonfield
185
11/07/2016
EXHIBIT(S)
(Exhibit G To Affidavit Of Howard S. Bonfield In Support Of Motion To Compel Defendants To Produce Documents And For Issuance Of Conditional Order Striking Defendants' Answers In Event Of Noncompliance)
003
Howard S Bonfield
186
11/07/2016
EXHIBIT(S)
(Exhibit H To Affidavit Of Howard S. Bonfield In Support Of Motion To Compel Defendants To Produce Documents And For Issuance Of Conditional Order Striking Defendants' Answers In Event Of Noncompliance)
003
Howard S Bonfield
187
11/07/2016
EXHIBIT(S)
(Exhibit I To Affidavit Of Howard S. Bonfield In Support Of Motion To Compel Defendants To Produce Documents And For Issuance Of Conditional Order Striking Defendants' Answers In Event Of Noncompliance)
003
Howard S Bonfield
188
11/07/2016
EXHIBIT(S)
(Exhibit J To Affidavit Of Howard S. Bonfield In Support Of Motion To Compel Defendants To Produce Documents And For Issuance Of Conditional Order Striking Defendants' Answers In Event Of Noncompliance)
003
Howard S Bonfield
189
11/07/2016
EXHIBIT(S)
(Exhibit K To Affidavit Of Howard S. Bonfield In Support Of Motion To Compel Defendants To Produce Documents And For Issuance Of Conditional Order Striking Defendants' Answers In Event Of Noncompliance)
003
Howard S Bonfield
190
11/07/2016
AFFIRMATION OF GOOD FAITH
(Good Faith Affirmation Of Howard S. Bonfield In Support Of Plaintiff's Motion To Compel Defendants To Produce Documents And For Issuance Of Conditional Order Striking Defendants' Answers In Event Of Noncompliance)
003
Howard S Bonfield
191
11/07/2016
MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN SUPPORT
(Memorandum Of Law In Support Of Plaintiff's Motion To Compel Defendants To Produce Documents And For Issuance Of Conditional Order Striking Defendants' Answers In Event Of Noncompliance)
003
Howard S Bonfield
192
11/15/2016
NOTICE OF CROSS-MOTION
005
Kevin G Donoghue
193
11/15/2016
AFFIRMATION OF GOOD FAITH
Kevin G Donoghue
194
11/15/2016
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION AND IN SUPPORT OF CROSS-MOTION
Kevin G Donoghue
195
11/15/2016
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex A-Amended Complaint
Kevin G Donoghue
196
11/15/2016
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex B- First set of interrogatories
Kevin G Donoghue
197
11/15/2016
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex C - First request for documents
Kevin G Donoghue
198
11/15/2016
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex D- Plaintiff's Responses & Objections to First Set of Interrogatories
Kevin G Donoghue
199
11/15/2016
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex E- Plaintiff's Responses & Objections to Request for Documents
Kevin G Donoghue
200
11/15/2016
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex F- letter
Kevin G Donoghue
201
11/15/2016
EXHIBIT(S)
Ex G- e-mail chain
Kevin G Donoghue
202
11/15/2016
EXHIBIT(S)
Corrected Ex D
Kevin G Donoghue
203
11/16/2016
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION
003
Ian Thomas Clarke-Fisher
204
11/16/2016
EXHIBIT(S)
Copy of Defendants Home Health Care and HCS's Responses to Plaintiff's First Set of Document Requests Directed to the HCS Defendants
003
Ian Thomas Clarke-Fisher
205
11/16/2016
EXHIBIT(S)
Letter to Atty Bonfield dated November 16, 2016
003
Ian Thomas Clarke-Fisher
206
11/29/2016
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO CROSS-MOTION AND IN FURTHER SUPPORT OF MOTION
(Reply Affidavit Of Howard S. Bonfield In Further Support Of Plaintiff's Motion To Compel And In Opposition To The Harden/Girling Defendants' Cross-Motion To Compel)
003
Howard S Bonfield
207
11/29/2016
EXHIBIT(S)
(Exhibit A To Reply Affidavit Of Howard S. Bonfield)
003
Howard S Bonfield
208
11/29/2016
EXHIBIT(S)
(Exhibit B To Reply Affidavit Of Howard S. Bonfield))
003
Howard S Bonfield
209
11/29/2016
EXHIBIT(S)
(Exhibit C To Reply Affidavit Of Howard S. Bonfield))
003
Howard S Bonfield
210
11/29/2016
EXHIBIT(S)
(Exhibit D To Reply Affidavit Of Howard S. Bonfield)
003
Howard S Bonfield
211
11/29/2016
EXHIBIT(S)
(Exhibit E To Reply Affidavit Of Howard S. Bonfield)
003
Howard S Bonfield
212
11/29/2016
EXHIBIT(S)
(Exhibit F To Reply Affidavit Of Howard S. Bonfield)
003
Howard S Bonfield
213
11/29/2016
MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN OPPOSITION TO CROSS-MOTION AND IN FURTHER SUPPORT OF MOTION
(Reply Memorandum Of Law In Support Of Plaintiff's Motion To Compel And In Opposition To The Harden/Girling Defendants' Cross-Motion To Compel)
003
Howard S Bonfield
214
12/02/2016
LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE
Letter Motion Requesting Defendants to serve a Sur-Reply in Opposition to Plaintiff's Motion to Compel
003
Kevin G Donoghue
215
12/02/2016
EXHIBIT(S)
Email dated October 25, 2016
003
Kevin G Donoghue
216
12/02/2016
EXHIBIT(S)
Email dated November 4, 2016
003
Kevin G Donoghue
217
12/02/2016
EXHIBIT(S)
Email dated November 7, 2016
003
Kevin G Donoghue
218
05/16/2017
DECISION + ORDER ON MOTION
Seq # 003, 004
004
Andrew Boodhoo
219
05/23/2017
NOTICE OF ENTRY
(Notice Of Entry Of Order Filed And Entered On May 16, 2017)
Philip M Halpern
220
05/25/2017
NOTICE OF ENTRY
Marc Andrew Sittenreich
221
05/25/2017
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
Marc Andrew Sittenreich
222
11/01/2017
STIPULATION - DISCONTINUANCE (POST RJI)
Note to Clerk - Signatures on Multiple Pages
Philip M Halpern
47
New York Supreme Court
2013
651015/2013
Disposed
Comm-Contract
PREMIER HOME HEALTH CARE
PREMIER HOME HEALTH CARE SERVICES, INC.
GIRLING HEALTH CARE
GIRLING HEALTH CARE SERVICES, INC.
01/02/2014
Ramos, Hon. Charles E.
▼
Case Info
Court
New York Supreme Court
Index Number
651015/2013
Status
Disposed
Year Filed
2013
Case Name
PREMIER HOME HEALTH CARE vs. GIRLING HEALTH CARE
Case Type
Comm-Contract
Track
Extended Track
RJI Filed
06/27/2013
NOI Due
02/17/2015
NOI Filed
Calendar Number
—
Jury Status
Justice
Ramos, Hon. Charles E.
Next Appearance
01/02/2014
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
PREMIER HOME HEALTH CARE
Attorney / FirmPREMIER HOME HEALTH CARE SERVICES, INC.
Defendant / Respondent
GIRLING HEALTH CARE
Attorneys / FirmsGIRLING HEALTH CARE SERVICES, INC.
Motions (4)
#
Date Filed
Filed By
Relief Sought
Submit Date
Answer
Status
Decision
Order Signed
4
08/21/2013
DEFENDANT
Dismiss
01/02/2014
No
Decided: 01/02/2014 Decided Before Justice: Ramos, Hon. Charles E.
Short Form Order
01/02/2014
3
07/12/2013
DEFENDANT
Dismiss
11/19/2013
No
Decided: 12/16/2013 Decided Before Justice: Ramos, Hon. Charles E.
Long Form Order
02/04/2014
2
06/28/2013
DEFENDANT
Dismiss
08/14/2013
No
Decided: 08/14/2013 Decided Before Justice: Ramos, Hon. Charles E.
Short Form Order
08/14/2013
1
01/01/2013
Injunction/Restraining Order
07/08/2013
No
Decided: 07/08/2013 Decided Before Justice: Ramos, Hon. Charles E.
Short Form Order
07/08/2013
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (2)
Doc #
Date Filed
Document
Description
Motion #
Filing User
File
1
03/19/2014
COUNTY CLERK MINUTES FROM OTHER COUNTY
NY County Minutes Prior To Transfer to Nassau County Under Index # 601237/2014
Peter Garganese
2
03/25/2014
ORDER - OTHER
OTHER ORDER entered in the office of the County Clerk on March 25, 2014
Fernando Diaz
48
Nassau Supreme Court
2013
601118/2013
Disposed
Comm-Contract
PREMIER HOME HEALTH CARE
KENNETH A ELAN
EXTRAORDINARY HOME CARE, INC.
FARRELL FRITZ, P.C.
07/17/2014
Trial Judge, DCM
▼
Case Info
Court
Nassau Supreme Court
Index Number
601118/2013
Status
Disposed
Year Filed
2013
Case Name
PREMIER HOME HEALTH CARE vs. EXTRAORDINARY HOME CARE, INC.
Case Type
Comm-Contract
Track
Standard
RJI Filed
07/25/2013
NOI Due
07/25/2014
NOI Filed
03/27/2014
Calendar Number
2014N0855
Jury Status
Justice
Trial Judge, DCM
Next Appearance
07/17/2014
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
PREMIER HOME HEALTH CARE
Attorney / FirmKENNETH A ELAN
Defendant / Respondent
EXTRAORDINARY HOME CARE, INC.
Attorneys / FirmsFARRELL FRITZ, P.C.
Motions (3)
#
Date Filed
Filed By
Relief Sought
Submit Date
Answer
Status
Decision
Order Signed
3
03/25/2014
Strike Pleadings
04/09/2014
No
Decided: 04/09/2014 Withdrawn Before Justice: Parga, Hon. Anthony L.
Oral
04/09/2014
2
12/04/2013
Strike Pleadings
01/08/2014
No
Decided: 01/08/2014 Decided Before Justice: Reilly, Hon. Margaret C.
Short Form Order
01/08/2014
1
07/31/2013
Judgment - Summary
10/17/2013
Yes
Decided: 10/17/2013 Withdrawn Before Justice: Reilly, Hon. Margaret C.
Oral
10/17/2013
Decisions (1)
Court
Index Number
Case Name
Motion #
Scanned On
Nassau Supreme Court
601118/2013
PREMIER HOME HEALTH CARE vs. EXTRAORDINARY HOME CARE, INC.
100
Complaints (40)
Doc #
Date Filed
Document
Description
Motion #
Filing User
File
1
04/30/2013
SUMMONS + COMPLAINT
Kenneth Allen Elan
pdf
2
05/31/2013
ANSWER
VERIFIED ANSWER TO VERIFIED COMPLAINT
Franklin C Mcroberts
pdf
3
05/31/2013
ADMISSION OF SERVICE
AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
Franklin C Mcroberts
4
07/25/2013
RJI -RE: NOTICE OF MOTION
Kenneth Allen Elan
pdf
5
07/25/2013
NOTICE OF MOTION
001
Kenneth Allen Elan
6
07/25/2013
MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN SUPPORT
add't doc part of motion due to size
001
Kenneth Allen Elan
7
10/02/2013
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION
Affidavit of Caroline D. Greene in Opposition to Plaintiffs' Motion for Summary Judgment, to Strike and for Sanctions
001
Franklin C Mcroberts
8
10/02/2013
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION
Affirmation of Franklin C. McRoberts in Opposition to Plaintiffs' Motion for Summary Judgment, to Strike and for Sanctions
001
Franklin C Mcroberts
9
10/02/2013
EXHIBIT(S)
Exhibit A
001
Franklin C Mcroberts
10
10/02/2013
EXHIBIT(S)
Exhibit B
001
Franklin C Mcroberts
11
10/02/2013
EXHIBIT(S)
Exhibit C
001
Franklin C Mcroberts
12
10/02/2013
EXHIBIT(S)
Exhibit D
001
Franklin C Mcroberts
13
10/02/2013
EXHIBIT(S)
Exhibit E
001
Franklin C Mcroberts
14
10/02/2013
EXHIBIT(S)
001
Franklin C Mcroberts
15
10/02/2013
EXHIBIT(S)
Exhibit G
001
Franklin C Mcroberts
16
10/02/2013
EXHIBIT(S)
Exhibit H
001
Franklin C Mcroberts
17
10/02/2013
EXHIBIT(S)
Exhibit I
001
Franklin C Mcroberts
18
10/02/2013
MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN OPPOSITION
Defendants' Memorandum of Law in Opposition to Plaintiffs' Motion for Summary Judgment, to Strike and for Sanctions
001
Franklin C Mcroberts
19
10/02/2013
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
001
Franklin C Mcroberts
20
10/03/2013
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
DEFENDANTS' MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN OPPOSITION TO PLAINTIFFS' MOTION FOR FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT, TO STRIKE AND FOR SANCTIONS
001
Franklin C Mcroberts
21
10/15/2013
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN REPLY
001
Kenneth Allen Elan
22
11/07/2013
ORDER - PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE
Signed 09/19/2013
Carmine Ambroselli
23
12/03/2013
NOTICE OF MOTION
002
Kenneth Allen Elan
24
12/09/2013
STIPULATION - OTHER
Franklin C Mcroberts
25
12/09/2013
ANSWER
Verified Amended Answer to Verified Complaint
Franklin C Mcroberts
26
12/16/2013
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION
Affirmation of Franklin C. McRoberts in Opposition to Plaintiffs' Motion for Sanctions
002
Franklin C Mcroberts
27
12/16/2013
EXHIBIT(S)
Exhibit 1
002
Franklin C Mcroberts
28
12/16/2013
EXHIBIT(S)
Exhibit 2
002
Franklin C Mcroberts
29
12/16/2013
EXHIBIT(S)
Exhibit 3
002
Franklin C Mcroberts
30
12/16/2013
EXHIBIT(S)
Exhibit 4
002
Franklin C Mcroberts
31
12/16/2013
MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN OPPOSITION
Defendants' Memorandum of Law in Opposition to Plaintiffs' Motion for Sanctions
002
Franklin C Mcroberts
32
12/16/2013
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
002
Franklin C Mcroberts
33
12/24/2013
AFFIRMATION
002
Kenneth Allen Elan
34
01/17/2014
NOTICE OF ENTRY
Kenneth Allen Elan
35
02/10/2014
DECISION + ORDER ON MOTION
DECISION + ORDER ON MOTION entered in the Office of the County Clerk on February 10, 2014
002
Nicholas Vitale
36
02/18/2014
ORDER - OTHER
Certification Order Signed 02/11/2014
Carmine Ambroselli
37
03/21/2014
NOTICE OF MOTION
003
Kenneth Allen Elan
38
03/27/2014
NOTE OF ISSUE:WITHOUT JURY
Kenneth Allen Elan
39
04/08/2014
LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE
Kenneth Allen Elan
40
07/08/2014
STIPULATION - DISCONTINUANCE (POST RJI)
Franklin C Mcroberts
49
Kings Supreme Court
2013
503691/2013
Disposed
Comm-Contract
PREMIER HOME HEALTH CARE
KENNETH A ELAN
BETH EMETH HOME ATTENDANT
MINTZ & GOLD LLP
09/03/2014
Demarest, Hon. Carolyn E.
▼
Case Info
Court
Kings Supreme Court
Index Number
503691/2013
Status
Disposed
Year Filed
2013
Case Name
PREMIER HOME HEALTH CARE vs. BETH EMETH HOME ATTENDANT
Case Type
Comm-Contract
Track
Standard
RJI Filed
08/14/2013
NOI Due
08/14/2014
NOI Filed
Calendar Number
—
Jury Status
Justice
Demarest, Hon. Carolyn E.
Next Appearance
09/03/2014
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
PREMIER HOME HEALTH CARE
Attorney / FirmKENNETH A ELAN
Defendant / Respondent
BETH EMETH HOME ATTENDANT
Attorneys / FirmsMINTZ & GOLD LLP
Motions (1)
#
Date Filed
Filed By
Relief Sought
Submit Date
Answer
Status
Decision
Order Signed
1
10/21/2013
Judgment - Summary
11/20/2013
Yes
Decided: 11/20/2013 Withdrawn Before Justice: Demarest, Hon. Carolyn E.
Oral
11/20/2013
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (9)
Doc #
Date Filed
Document
Description
Motion #
Filing User
File
1
07/02/2013
SUMMONS + COMPLAINT
Kenneth Allen Elan
pdf
2
08/09/2013
ANSWER
Scott A Klein
pdf
3
08/14/2013
RJI -RE: REQUEST FOR PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE
Kenneth Allen Elan
4
10/08/2013
NOTICE OF MOTION
001
Kenneth Allen Elan
pdf
5
10/08/2013
MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN SUPPORT
001
Kenneth Allen Elan
6
10/21/2013
NOTICE OF WITHDRAWAL OF MOTION / ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE
001
Kenneth Allen Elan
pdf
7
01/22/2014
ANSWER (AMENDED)
Amended Verified Answer and Counterclaims
Richard Harris Topaz
pdf
8
05/28/2014
COMPLAINT (AMENDED)
Kenneth Allen Elan
pdf
9
08/04/2014
STIPULATION - DISCONTINUANCE (POST RJI)
Scott A Klein
pdf
50
New York Supreme Court
2013
155323/2013
Disposed
Negligence
DULBERGER, BERNARD
LAW OFFICES OF DEVON M. RADLIN
PREMIER HOME HEALTH CARE
Barry McTiernan & Moore LLC
07/15/2015
Bannon, Hon. Nancy M.
▼
Case Info
Court
New York Supreme Court
Index Number
155323/2013
Status
Disposed
Year Filed
2013
Case Name
DULBERGER, BERNARD vs. PREMIER HOME HEALTH CARE
Case Type
Tort-Other Negligence
Track
Standard
RJI Filed
11/11/2013
NOI Due
11/11/2014
NOI Filed
08/26/2014
Calendar Number
2014L-02669
Jury Status
Jury At Plaintiff's Request
Justice
Bannon, Hon. Nancy M.
Next Appearance
07/15/2015
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
DULBERGER, BERNARD
Attorney / FirmLAW OFFICES OF DEVON M. RADLIN
Defendant / Respondent
PREMIER HOME HEALTH CARE
Attorneys / FirmsBarry McTiernan & Moore LLC
Motions (2)
#
Date Filed
Filed By
Relief Sought
Submit Date
Answer
Status
Decision
Order Signed
2
03/31/2015
Preference
04/30/2015
No
Decided: 04/30/2015 Decided Before Justice: Bannon, Hon. Nancy M.
Short Form Order
04/30/2015
1
10/24/2014
Judgment - Summary
03/11/2015
No
Decided: 03/31/2015 Denied Before Justice: Bannon, Hon. Nancy M.
Short Form Order
03/31/2015
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (39)
Doc #
Date Filed
Document
Description
Motion #
Filing User
File
1
06/10/2013
SUMMONS + COMPLAINT
David Segal
pdf
2
11/11/2013
RJI -RE: REQUEST FOR PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE
David Segal
3
12/23/2013
ORDER - PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE
Re: Appearance #002, PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE ORDER entered in the office of the County Clerk on December 23, 2013
Sharon Hill
4
05/30/2014
ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE
Re: Appearance #003, COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE ORDER entered in the office of the County Clerk on May 30, 2014
Kevin J. Letts
5
08/26/2014
NOTE OF ISSUE:WITH JURY
David Segal
pdf
6
10/24/2014
NOTICE OF MOTION
Notice of Motion
001
Suzanne M Halbardier
pdf
7
10/24/2014
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION
Affirmation in Support of Miotion
001
Suzanne M Halbardier
8
10/24/2014
EXHIBIT(S)
Plaintiff's Summons and Complaint
001
Suzanne M Halbardier
9
10/24/2014
EXHIBIT(S)
Verified Answer of Defendant, Premier Home Health Care
001
Suzanne M Halbardier
10
10/24/2014
EXHIBIT(S)
Plaintiff's Bills of Particulars
001
Suzanne M Halbardier
11
10/24/2014
EXHIBIT(S)
EBT Transcript of Plaintiff, Bernard Dulberger
001
Suzanne M Halbardier
12
10/24/2014
EXHIBIT(S)
EBT Transcript of NPW Ellen Dulberger
001
Suzanne M Halbardier
13
10/24/2014
EXHIBIT(S)
Plaintiff's 8/22/14 Letter Waiving EBTs of Defendants
001
Suzanne M Halbardier
14
10/24/2014
EXHIBIT(S)
Affidavit of Celestina Cruz
001
Suzanne M Halbardier
15
10/24/2014
EXHIBIT(S)
3/23/05 Letter from the Department of State
001
Suzanne M Halbardier
16
10/24/2014
EXHIBIT(S)
Relevant Portions of Defendant, Grace Baah's Employment File
001
Suzanne M Halbardier
17
10/24/2014
EXHIBIT(S)
Criminal Court Minutes for Defendant, Grace Baah
001
Suzanne M Halbardier
18
10/24/2014
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
Affidavit of Service of Motion and Affirmation
001
Suzanne M Halbardier
19
11/13/2014
STIPULATION - ADJOURNMENT OF MOTION -IN SUBMISSIONS PART -RM 130
001
David Segal
20
11/14/2014
STIPULATION - ADJOURNMENT OF MOTION -IN SUBMISSIONS PART -RM 130
Plaintiff to respond on December 2, 2014 and Defendant to Reply by December 16, 2014
001
David Segal
21
12/15/2014
STIPULATION - ADJOURNMENT OF MOTION -IN SUBMISSIONS PART -RM 130
Stipulation Adjourning Defendant, Premier's Motion for Summary Judgment to 1/8/15
001
Suzanne M Halbardier
22
12/15/2014
STIPULATION - ADJOURNMENT OF MOTION -IN SUBMISSIONS PART -RM 130
001
David Segal
23
12/15/2014
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION
001
David Segal
24
01/07/2015
AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN REPLY
Reply Affirmation on behalf of defendant, Premier
001
Suzanne M Halbardier
25
01/07/2015
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
Aff of Serv of Reply Affirmation
001
Suzanne M Halbardier
26
03/10/2015
NOTICE OF CHANGE OF FIRM NAME OR ADDRESS (POST RJI)
Notice of Change of Address
Samantha Velez
27
03/10/2015
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
Affidavit of Service
Samantha Velez
28
03/31/2015
NOTICE OF MOTION
For Special Preference
002
Devon Marie Radlin
pdf
29
03/31/2015
EXHIBIT(S)
1) Birth Certificate 2) Note of Issue
002
Devon Marie Radlin
30
03/31/2015
DECISION + ORDER ON MOTION
re: motion no. 001, DECISION + ORDER ON MOTION entered in the office of the County Clerk on March 31, 2015
001
Robert Sobel
pdf
31
04/07/2015
NOTICE OF ENTRY
001
Devon Marie Radlin
32
04/24/2015
NOTICE OF APPEAL
Notice of Appeal
Suzanne M Halbardier
pdf
33
04/24/2015
PRE-ARGUMENT STATEMENT
Pre-Argumment Statement
Suzanne M Halbardier
34
04/24/2015
EXHIBIT(S)
Plaintiff's 4/6/15 Order with Notice of Entry
Suzanne M Halbardier
35
04/24/2015
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
Affidavit of Service of Notice of Appeal
Suzanne M Halbardier
36
05/05/2015
DECISION + ORDER ON MOTION
re: motion no. 002, DECISION + ORDER ON MOTION entered in the office of the County Clerk on May 05, 2015
002
Gregory Gonsieski
pdf
37
05/05/2015
NOTICE OF ENTRY
002
Devon Marie Radlin
38
09/17/2015
STIPULATION - DISCONTINUANCE (POST RJI)
David H Schultz
pdf
39
09/23/2015
ORDER - OTHER
Charmayne Moss
51
New York Supreme Court
2012
152710/2012
Disposed
Medical Malpractice
HART, NORMA
FEDERAL TRADE COMMISSION
PREMIER HOME HEALTH CARE
Barry McTiernan & Moore LLC
04/14/2014
Lobis, Hon. Joan
▼
Case Info
Court
New York Supreme Court
Index Number
152710/2012
Status
Disposed
Year Filed
2012
Case Name
HART, NORMA vs. PREMIER HOME HEALTH CARE
Case Type
Tort-Medical, Dental, or Podiatric Malpractice
Track
Complex
RJI Filed
08/23/2012
NOI Due
11/24/2013
NOI Filed
08/27/2013
Calendar Number
2013L-02936
Jury Status
Jury At Plaintiff's Request
Justice
Lobis, Hon. Joan
Next Appearance
04/14/2014
Parties
Plaintiff / Petitioner
HART, NORMA
Attorney / FirmFEDERAL TRADE COMMISSION
Defendant / Respondent
PREMIER HOME HEALTH CARE
Attorneys / FirmsBarry McTiernan & Moore LLC
Motions
No motions recorded for this case.
Decisions
No decisions available for this case.
Complaints (17)
Doc #
Date Filed
Document
Description
Motion #
Filing User
File
1
05/14/2012
SUMMONS + COMPLAINT
Edward James Hynes
pdf
2
08/23/2012
ANSWER
Verified Answer
Suzanne M Halbardier
pdf
3
08/23/2012
NOTICE OF MEDICAL MALPRACTICE
Edward James Hynes
4
08/23/2012
RJI -RE: NOTICE OF MEDICAL, DENTAL OR PODIATRIC MALPRACTICE
Edward James Hynes
5
11/07/2012
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
Edward James Hynes
6
11/07/2012
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
Edward James Hynes
7
11/07/2012
AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
Edward James Hynes
8
02/01/2013
ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE
Re: Appearance #002, COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE ORDER entered in the office of the County Clerk on February 1, 2013
Ann Spillane
9
03/20/2013
ORDER - STATUS CONFERENCE
Re: Appearance #003, STATUS CONFERENCE ORDER entered in the office of the County Clerk on March 20, 2013
Ann Spillane
10
04/26/2013
ORDER - STATUS CONFERENCE
Re: Appearance #004, STATUS CONFERENCE ORDER entered in the office of the County Clerk on April 26, 2013
Ann Spillane
11
05/15/2013
ORDER - STATUS CONFERENCE
Re: Appearance #005, STATUS CONFERENCE ORDER entered in the office of the County Clerk on May 15, 2013
Ann Spillane
12
06/28/2013
ORDER - STATUS CONFERENCE
Re: Appearance #006, STATUS CONFERENCE ORDER entered in the office of the County Clerk on June 28, 2013
Ann Spillane
13
07/31/2013
ORDER - STATUS CONFERENCE
Re: Appearance #007, STATUS CONFERENCE ORDER entered in the office of the County Clerk on July 31, 2013
Ann Spillane
14
08/27/2013
NOTE OF ISSUE:WITH JURY
Edward James Hynes
pdf
15
08/27/2013
ORDER - COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE
Re: Appearance #008, COMPLIANCE CONFERENCE ORDER entered in the office of the County Clerk on August 27, 2013
Karen I Berthiaume
16
10/30/2013
ORDER - PRE-TRIAL
Re: Appearance #009, PRE-TRIAL ORDER entered in the office of the County Clerk on October 30, 2013
Ann Spillane
17
04/21/2014
STIPULATION - DISCONTINUANCE (POST RJI)
Stipulation of Discontinuance with Prejudice
Katherine M Reilly
pdf
Need Help?
Let us help you or a loved one find the perfect senior home.
