Best Independent Living in Holbrook, NY

Why trust this guide? Our editorial team analyzed 9 independent living communities in Holbrook, NY using NY State Dept. of Health (NYSDOH) data, inspection records, complaints, amenities, and facility-level details. How we rank independent living in NY
Reviewed by
Last updated
We analyzed These are the facilities in Holbrook, NY our team has analyzed — not a count of every independent living provider in Holbrook, NY.
9 homes
Other senior care options in Holbrook:

Video Tour: Top-rated Independent Living facilities in Holbrook, New York State.

Watch this Video to see Holbrook's Top-rated Senior Communities

Compare Independent Living around Holbrook

Info below is compiled from the NY State Dept. of Health (NYSDOH), senior community websites & trusted data sources such as Walk Score & BBB.

Communities are listed from highest-ranked to lowest-ranked based on our methodology.

Care Types in This Table AL (Assisted Living): Housing with help for daily activities like bathing, dressing, and medication, without 24-hour skilled nursing. NH (Nursing Home): 24/7 skilled nursing care for residents with complex, ongoing medical needs. SNF (Skilled Nursing Facility): Round-the-clock nursing care, often for recovery after surgery, injury, or illness. MC (Memory Care): Secured, specialized care for people living with Alzheimer's or dementia. RC (Respite Care): Short-term temporary care that gives family caregivers a break. IL (Independent Living): Community living with dining, activities, and transportation for active seniors who need little personal care.
City and state of the facility. Used for mapping and state-average comparisons.
Licensed bed capacity (maximum allowed). Not the same as how many beds are currently filled.
A 0–100 score of a facility's regulatory inspection record, shown as a letter and compared with other facilities of the same kind in the same state. This is a proprietary Assisted Living Magazine grade. It is not a government rating. A dash means we have no inspection data for that facility.
Indicates whether residents are allowed to have pets in the facility.
Third-party neighborhood walkability score (0–100). Convenience/context metric, not a healthcare quality measure.
Name of the licensed owner, operator, or managing entity as filed with the state. Useful for grouping facilities under the same organization.
Count of regulatory inspections in the reporting window. Higher volume can reflect more oversight visits, complaint-driven surveys, or routine licensure cycles.
Share of inspections that resulted in violations, expressed as a percentage of total inspections in the window.
Regulatory visits tied to complaints or allegations in the state file—not the same as every routine survey.
Total count of violations (cited regulatory issues) recorded in the selected reporting period. Read alongside inspection counts for context.
The average number of violations this facility receives each time it's inspected, calculated as total violations ÷ total inspections. A lower number suggests more consistent compliance with safety and care standards.
Housing or bed configuration options (e.g. studio, shared), often from facility-reported amenities and licensing details.
The Bristal at Holtsville
IL
AL
MC
Holtsville (Express Drive North)
166
Facility 166
NY AVG 123
Rank #30 / 116
AYes
36
Facility 36
NY AVG 54
Rank #123 / 182
Eb Care At Farmingville LLC8
38%
Facility 38%
NY AVG 55%
Rank #47 / 105
3
Facility 3
NY AVG 14.5
Rank #31 / 105
0.4
Facility 0.4
NY AVG 2.3
Rank #27 / 105
Studio / 1 Bed / 2 Bed
The Bristal Assisted Living at Lake Grove
IL
AL
MC
Lake Grove
155
Facility 155
NY AVG 123
Rank #38 / 116
A-Yes
57
Facility 57
NY AVG 54
Rank #83 / 182
Lake Grove Senior Care LLC8
50%
Facility 50%
NY AVG 55%
Rank #58 / 105
6
Facility 6
NY AVG 14.5
Rank #45 / 105
0.8
Facility 0.8
NY AVG 2.3
Rank #42 / 105
Studio / 1 Bed / 2 Bed
The Village at South Setauket: A Willow Ridge Senior Living Community
IL
AL
South Setauket
200
Facility 200
NY AVG 123
Rank #9 / 116
A-Yes
51
Facility 51
NY AVG 54
Rank #92 / 182
Atr New York Lh, Inc11
36%
Facility 36%
NY AVG 55%
Rank #45 / 105
7
Facility 7
NY AVG 14.5
Rank #53 / 105
0.6
Facility 0.6
NY AVG 2.3
Rank #35 / 105
Studio / 1 Bed
Brightview Port Jefferson
IL
AL
MC
Port Jefferson Station
90
Facility 90
NY AVG 123
Rank #67 / 116
AYes
53
Facility 53
NY AVG 54
Rank #90 / 182
Bv Port Jefferson Operator, LLC6
33%
Facility 33%
NY AVG 55%
Rank #35 / 105
3
Facility 3
NY AVG 14.5
Rank #31 / 105
0.5
Facility 0.5
NY AVG 2.3
Rank #30 / 105
-
Village Walk at Patchogue
IL
AL
MC
RC
Patchogue (Village Of Patchogue)
146
Facility 146
NY AVG 123
Rank #42 / 116
C-Yes
89
Facility 89
NY AVG 54
Rank #29 / 182
Carlisle Patchogue Operator, Inc12
75%
Facility 75%
NY AVG 55%
Rank #88 / 105
20
Facility 20
NY AVG 14.5
Rank #89 / 105
1.7
Facility 1.7
NY AVG 2.3
Rank #76 / 105
Studio / 1 Bed / Suite
Brightview Sayville
IL
AL
MC
Sayville
92
Facility 92
NY AVG 123
Rank #65 / 116
C+Yes
37
Facility 37
NY AVG 54
Rank #119 / 182
Bv Sayville Operator, LLC9
78%
Facility 78%
NY AVG 55%
Rank #93 / 105
12
Facility 12
NY AVG 14.5
Rank #75 / 105
1.3
Facility 1.3
NY AVG 2.3
Rank #62 / 105
-
The Chelsea at Brookhaven
IL
AL
MC
Yaphank
81
Facility 81
NY AVG 123
Rank #77 / 116
C-Yes
5
Facility 5
NY AVG 54
Rank #177 / 182
Brookhaven Senior Living, LLC10
70%
Facility 70%
NY AVG 55%
Rank #84 / 105
21
Facility 21
NY AVG 14.5
Rank #92 / 105
2.1
Facility 2.1
NY AVG 2.3
Rank #86 / 105
Studio / 1 Bed
Jefferson’s Ferry
IL
AL
MC
NH
SNF
So Setauket
60
Facility 60
NY AVG 123
Rank #385 / 422
?Yes
21
Facility 21
NY AVG 54
Rank #400 / 450
Active Retirement Community Inc (Not For Profit)683%254.2-
Atria Hertlin Place
IL
Lake Ronkonkoma
--Yes
57
Facility 57
NY AVG 54
Rank #83 / 182
-----Studio / 1 Bed / 2 Bed

Rank badges are statewide and care-type specific: each independent living community is ranked against every other NY independent living community we track that reports that metric, not just the 9 analyzed for Holbrook. See how we rank facilities

Overview of The Bristal at Holtsville

Located within the neighborhood of Holtsville, NY, The Bristal at Holtsville provides families in Suffolk County with an assisted living experience like no other – in services, amenities, and care. The Bristal at Holtsville offers various living options, including independent living, assisted living, and memory care, where their professional and courteous team leads in providing top-of-the-line assistance and care fit to the varying needs of their residents.

Conveniently located near The Brookhaven Wildlife and Ecology Center, the amphitheater at Bald Hill, and the downtown area of Patchogue, residents at The Bristal can visit and enjoy fine restaurants, theaters, and cultural attractions. Dedicated to creating a dynamic and active atmosphere for its residents, the community offers amenities, including a heated outdoor pool, a putting green, a cinema, a fitness center, a full programming calendar, and a pet-friendly community

Contact The Bristal at Holtsville

Overview of The Bristal Assisted Living at Lake Grove

The Bristal at Lake Grove promises luxurious senior living by ensuring that residents are celebrated for their individuality and are encouraged to embrace their unique identity. Offering a comfortable assisted living home for seniors in Suffolk, its top-rated services aim to enhance the quality of life for every senior. The Bristal ensures residents maintain an active and enriched lifestyle that helps cultivate growth and a graceful aging experience.

The luxurious resort-style community in Lake Grove provides residents with all the necessary care by providing personal and 24-hour nurse care. Essential services include housekeeping, chef-prepared meals, medication management, transportation, recreational activities, and ADLs. Amenities include a library, a cinema, a fitness studio, an outdoor patio, an art studio, a bingo room, a putting green, and a swimming pool.

Contact The Bristal Assisted Living at Lake Grove

Overview of The Village at South Setauket: a Willow Ridge Senior Living Community

The Village at South Setauket is an assisted living community in South Setauket, NY, offering independent living and personal care. Here, older adults can feel at home, especially with the community’s nurturing and welcoming environment. Housekeeping, laundry, transportation, and restaurant-style dining are among the exceptional services provided to help residents maintain their independence. Along with personalized care plans, on-site physical and occupational therapy are also provided for residents’ holistic wellness.

Social events, light exercises, and activities are curated monthly to help residents stay active and encourage them to explore interests. Residents also have access to first-class amenities, like the salon, outdoor pool, and courtyard, for their relaxation and wellness. Located near fast-food chains, shops, recreation sites, and public transportation in South Setauket, the community guarantees accessibility and convenience. This assisted living community has high-quality services dedicated to older adults’ welfare, making it a great choice for senior living in New York.

Contact The Village at South Setauket: A Willow Ridge Senior Living Community

Brightview Port Jefferson

1175 Patchogue Road, 1175 Ny-112, Port Jefferson Station, NY 11776
Overview of Brightview Port Jefferson

Overlooking the quiet neighborhood of Port Jefferson Station, NY, Brightview Port Jefferson is a vibrant senior living community that offers independent living, assisted living, and memory care. Retire in the comfort of well-appointed accommodations with individually controlled heating and air conditioning and 24-hour emergency call system for added security and support. A compassionate care team is available 24/7 to provide round-the-clock support and assistance, providing utmost comfort and peace of mind.

A thrilling, worry-free lifestyle awaits at Brightview Port Jefferson with a wide range of interesting enriching activities and programs, daily chef-inspired meals, and resort-style amenities. There are plenty of inviting and stimulating common areas that foster engagement and enrichment of residents’ overall well-being. From multipurpose great room for entertainment, presentations, and gatherings to an arts, crafts and hobbies room with “Brain Fitness” learning stations, residents are guaranteed to find interesting things to do that brings both happiness and lifestyle enhancement.

Contact Brightview Port Jefferson

Overview of Village Walk at Patchogue

Village Walk at Patchogue is a charming and inviting community in Patchogue, NY, offering a peaceful environment for assisted living and memory care. Residents here receive tailored care and compassionate assistance with their daily living activities from a team of highly skilled care professionals. Those living with Alzheimer’s, Lewy body dementia, or other memory conditions thrive in the community’s safe and structured memory care unit where they are given personalized care and vibrant programs tailored to improve their independence, functioning, and cognitive abilities.

As a community dedicated to building trust and strong connections, Village Walk at Patchogue provides an array of enriching activities that bring residents together and nurture their overall well-being. With 24/7 security and emergency response systems available, residents can enjoy their peace of mind amidst a safe and secure environment. The community also provides access to various therapy services and convenient amenities like a salon, bistro, and internet lounge for an elevated living experience.

Contact Village Walk at Patchogue

Overview of Brightview Sayville

Overlooking the vibrant neighborhood of Sayville, NY, Brightview Sayville is a dynamic senior living community that offers resort-style independent living in a welcoming and secure setting. Residents enjoy the comfort and privacy of well-curated apartments that provide easy access to the community’s many amenities. The community offers interior and exterior maintenance, housekeeping, and linen laundry services to free residents from the burden of tedious chores and tasks.

Residents find plenty of opportunities for making new connections, exploring new hobbies, or reliving old ones, just right outside their door with convenient amenities and regularly conducted activities. The community provides chef-prepared meals to save residents from the hassle of preparing their own meals while making sure they get the nourishment and energy they need for a bright and active day. With transportation assistance, emergency assistance, and high-quality care options when needed, residents can comfortably retire, knowing that they have access to necessary services and amenities for a fulfilling way of life.

Contact Brightview Sayville

Overview of The Chelsea at Brookhaven

Set in the quiet community of Yaphank, NY, The Chelsea at Brookhaven is a peaceful senior living community that provides well-designed accommodations for Independent Living , Assisted Living, Memory Care, and Short Stays. Residents can choose from a variety of floor plans, including studios and one-bedroom apartments. With a 24/7 expert clinical team and emergency response system, residents can rest assured, knowing that their needs will be met immediately.

The community ensures residents maintain their holistic well-being with a variety of services like on-site physical, occupational and speech therapy, preventative health screenings and education, and pharmacy services. A vibrant calendar of activities, planned outings, and live entertainment helps residents live a vibrant and entertaining life. Housekeeping, laundry, and maintenance are handled to provide residents with more time to explore the community’s delightful amenities.

Contact The Chelsea at Brookhaven

Overview of Jefferson’s Ferry

Situated in So Setauket, NY, Jefferson’s Ferry offers nursing home, assisted living, independent living, memory care, and skilled nursing. The community provides continuous clinical support through nursing services. Specialized care is also provided for those living with memory-related conditions in a supervised environment.

The community has 60 beds, with a current occupancy of 88.3%. Rehabilitation services also provide recovery-focused care to help improve residents’ ability to function. Payment options include Medicare, Medicaid, and private pay.

Total nurse staffing is 4 hours and 59 minutes per resident per day, representing the daily nursing time allocated to each resident. The community also allows pets, so residents can bring a small animal companion.

Contact Jefferson’s Ferry

Overview of Atria Hertlin Place

Enjoy a lavish retirement experience with Atria Hertlin Place, a thriving senior living community in Lake Ronkonkoma, New York, offering independent living. The community guarantees residents plenty of privacy and comfort through their thoughtfully designed apartments, ranging from a studio to 1 and 2-bedroom floor plans, equipped with a kitchen or kitchenette and emergency alert system. Atria offers residents opportunities to stay active, eat well, engage, and live meaningful lives through its various Engage Life programs.

At Atria Hertlin Place, residents find comfort and convenience in knowing a compassionate and professional team is available 24/7. The community provides all the benefits of independent living and access to in-home care services, including companion care services, incontinence management, and medication assistance. Residents also enjoy plenty of amenities such as a private dining room for special occasions, a movie theater, a library and activities space for entertainment, and daily educational, social, cultural, and fitness opportunities to keep residents engaged and holistically healthy.

Contact Atria Hertlin Place

Weighting overview

  • 35%
    Resident Experience
  • 25%
    Regulatory
  • 15%
    Visual Media
  • 10%
    Website
  • 10%
    Stability
  • 5%
    Environment
01

Resident & Family Experience 35%

The single largest share of every ranking. Aggregated review sentiment and volume from major platforms — the closest signal to real resident experience.

  • Includes
  • Review Sentiment
  • Review Volume
02

Regulatory & Safety Record 25%

State inspection records, citations, and complaint visits. We weight per-inspection rates more heavily than raw counts.

  • Includes
  • State Inspections
  • Citations/Inspection
  • % Inspections w/ Citations
  • Complaint Visits
  • Accreditations
  • BBB Rating
03

Visual Media & Transparency 15%

Communities that publish high-quality visuals give families a real preview. No photos or tours = a negative transparency signal.

  • Includes
  • Video Tours
  • Virtual Walkthroughs
  • Photo Quantity
  • Photo Quality
04

Website & Operator Transparency 10%

Site quality and whether the operator publishes basic accountability information — staff names, contact details, ownership.

  • Includes
  • Website Content
  • Mobile Usability
  • Staff Info Available
  • Owner Info Available
05

Community Stability 10%

Operational signals indicating whether a community is well-run and meeting demand.

  • Includes
  • Occupancy Rate
  • Bed Options
06

Environment & Pricing 5%

Walkability and pricing transparency. Walk Score is weighted higher for Independent Living than for Memory Care, where most residents do not leave unaccompanied.

  • Includes
  • Walk Score
  • Pricing Transparency
No paid rankings Communities cannot pay to influence placement.
How we're paid: If we help you find a community and you move in, that community may pay us a referral fee. This never affects where they rank or what you pay. Learn more
Submit a correction

Independent Living in Holbrook at a glance

Avg Walk Score: 45/ 100The average Walk Score across facilities in Holbrook, NY. A third-party neighborhood walkability score (0–100) measuring convenience and context, not healthcare quality. Individual facilities can vary widely from this average.
National Average: 50/ 100
Avg No. of Beds: 124The average licensed bed capacity across facilities in Holbrook, NY. Individual facilities can vary widely from this average.
National Average: 90
Who we are

Your Senior Care Partner, Every Step of the Way

We help families find affordable senior communities and unlock same day discounts, Medicaid, and Medicare options tailored to your needs.

Contact us Today

Frequently Asked Questions about Independent Living in Holbrook, NY

What is independent living?

Independent living communities are residential settings for active older adults — typically with private apartments or cottages, shared amenities (dining, fitness, activities), and no built-in medical care.

How many independent living communities are listed on this page?

This page features 9 independent living communities in Holbrook, NY. Use the filters and comparison tools above to compare ratings, amenities, and pricing.

How do I choose the right independent living community in Holbrook, NY?

Start by matching the level of care offered to the resident's current and anticipated needs, then compare licensing status, staff-to-resident ratios, recent inspection results, and pricing. Tour at least two or three communities in Holbrook, NY, talk to current residents and families, and confirm what is included in the base rate versus billed as add-on services.

What should I look for when visiting independent living communities in Holbrook, NY?

Pay attention to staff interactions with residents, cleanliness and odor, food quality at meal times, the activity calendar, and how questions about pricing and care plans are answered. Ask to see the most recent state inspection report, the move-out / level-of-care-change policy, and a sample monthly bill that lists every fee.