Overview of Starkville Manor Health Care and Rehabilitation Starkville Manor Health Care and Rehabilitation is a 119-bed nursing home at 1001 Hospital Road, Starkville, Oktibbeha County, Mississippi, at city center. Everett Mckibben owns the facility. LLC Beverly G. Taylor administers.
CMS-certified, accepts Medicare and Medicaid. CMS CCN 255172. 1-star overall rating.
The 1-star CMS rating is the lowest possible and reflects critical deficiencies across all four rating domains. Health Inspection: 1 star, 64.7% below Mississippi average. Staffing: 1 star, 8.3% below state average. Quality Measures: 1 star, 53.9% below state average.
This lowest-tier rating directly reflects documented inspection failures, severely diminished staffing resources, and poor resident outcomes.
Inspection record is alarming. Five inspections in four years yielded 31 citations—85% above Mississippi average (16.9 citations). Citations per inspection average 6.2 versus state average of 3.83. Critical severity citations: 5 (400% worse than state average of 1).
Serious citations: 3 (173% worse than state average of 1.1). Deficiency patterns: Quality of Life & Care (8 deficiencies, 26%), Administration (5, 16%), Resident Rights (4, 13%), Pharmacy Services (3, 10%), Abuse/Neglect/Exploitation (1, 3%). Inspector findings describe wound care neglect with immediate jeopardy designation (February 2024); the highest severity level indicating residents were in imminent danger of death or serious harm. Additional complaint investigations found substantiated fund misappropriation (November 2023) and systemic staffing shortages (March 2023).
Most recent inspection (September 2025) identified deficiencies in resident dignity during meals, failure to implement care plans for splint use and hygiene, inadequate ADL assistance, and inaccurate staffing data reported to CMS.
Staffing is critically understaffed. Total nursing hours 3 hours 31 minutes per resident per day, 19% below state average and below the 3.5-hour national red-flag threshold. RN hours: 25 minutes (34% below state average, only 66% of state norm). LPN hours: 45 minutes (32% below state average).
Weekend RN hours: 15 minutes (32% below state average). The facility ranks 89th of 100 Mississippi nursing homes in nurse staffing. Payroll is 30.3% of revenu; well below the typical 55-65% for adequately staffed facilities, confirming systematic understaffing.
Financial strain is evident. Operating loss: -$449.9K (2023). Profit margin: -3.5%. Despite strong occupancy (93.7%, well above state average), the facility loses money, suggesting cost-cutting measures affecting care.
Revenue $13.0M against payroll of $3.9M indicates resources exist but are not allocated to adequate staffing.
Quality outcomes are mixed. Long-stay pressure ulcer rates, UTI rates, and weight loss rates are better than state average, but ED visits are 23% worse, falls with major injury are 12% worse, and antipsychotic use is 28% worse. Short-stay outcomes are substantially degraded: falls with major injury 1.9% (149% worse than state), discharge functional ability 17.1% (68% worse), successful return to home 42.9% (15% worse).
Families evaluating Starkville Manor should understand that the 1-star rating, immediate jeopardy wound care findings, substantiated fund misappropriation, critical staffing shortages, and deteriorating short-stay rehabilitation outcomes collectively present substantial risk. The facility’s pattern of recurring compliance failures despite corrective efforts demonstrates systemic dysfunction.
Families should ask about the February 2024 immediate jeopardy finding, corrections, verification of staffing adequacy, and protocols preventing fund misappropriation. Tour and verify directly.
