Best Assisted Living in Schererville, IN

Overview of Residences at Deer Creek

Founded by a group of local physicians, Residences at Deer Creek has served seniors in Schererville, Indiana, for 15 years. The community offers assisted living, memory care, and respite care along U. Highway 30, about 6 miles from Methodist Hospitals Southlake Campus. It is operated by Ail Operating LLC, with Karen Ayersman as Executive Director and Frances Guyton-Ward as Director of Nursing.

The 130-bed community is in a three-story building with studio, one-bedroom, and two-bedroom apartment options. The home’s occupancy is about 75%, giving families a well-established senior living community with a range of housing choices. Residents also have access to transportation services, fitness programs, and recreational activities. Pets are welcome, which can make the move easier for those with animal companions.

The surrounding neighborhood has a Walk Score of 34 out of 100. A few nearby destinations are within walking distance, but most errands require a car. The location near Methodist Hospitals Southlake Campus may also be helpful for residents who need ongoing medical care.

State inspections by the Indiana Department of Health have reviewed documentation and notification practices, including the timely reporting of falls and other incidents. Inspectors have also looked at staff training records and supervision procedures. Some inspection periods had no findings, which reflects continued regulatory oversight over time rather than a single inspection result.

Overview of Dyer Nursing and Rehabilitation Center

Dyer Nursing and Rehabilitation Center is a 211-bed skilled nursing facility in Dyer, Indiana, offering 24-hour skilled nursing, post-acute rehabilitation, memory care, and respiratory services, with physical, occupational, and speech therapy available on site. The non-profit community is operated by DLS Financial Consulting, LLC, and it accepts Medicare and Medicaid. The facility carries a 1-star CMS overall rating, driven by an inspection record that stands significantly below Indiana norms. Across the seven-year review window, the facility recorded 79 total citations — roughly 29.8 per year, compared with an Indiana average of 4.2 — placing it 284th out of 288 Indiana skilled nursing facilities in health citations. The most serious finding came in April 2024, when a complaint investigation identified Immediate Jeopardy conditions related to falls and inadequate supervision. Nurse staffing averages 3 hours and 26 minutes per resident per day, essentially in line with the Indiana average. The facility’s occupancy rate is 57%, below the Indiana average of 68.1%, reflecting current availability across the 211-bed building. It also provides behavioral management and psychological services alongside its clinical care programs. Respite stays are available. Dyer Nursing and Rehabilitation Center is best suited for residents in Lake County, Indiana, who require short- to medium-term post-acute care, skilled nursing, or rehabilitation services, with current capacity for Medicare and Medicaid admissions. However, families should review the facility’s extensive inspection history and Immediate Jeopardy findings before making a placement decision.