Primarily short stays
Residents typically stay for brief periods, with frequent admissions and discharges throughout the year.
Most new residents arrive under private pay (75% of admissions), and a typical private pay stay runs around 15 years.
Mcgivney Health Care Center, nestled in Carmel, Indiana, specializes in offering comprehensive long-term care services. With a capacity of 37 beds, this nonprofit facility stands as a dedicated participant in both Medicare and Medicaid programs, providing a vital support system for families in search of quality senior care for their cherished loved ones.
Reviews consistently highlight the center’s excellence, emphasizing its professional and compassionate approach to meeting the needs of seniors and their families.
McGivney Health Care Center is legally operated by Board Of Trustees Of The Flavius J Witham Memorial, and administered by Randall Shera.
Key information about the people who lead and staff this community.
In Indiana, the Department of Health, Division of Long Term Care is the primary regulatory body that performs onsite inspections and quality of care reviews for all licensed facilities.
Deficiencies
| This Facility | IN Average | vs. IN Avg |
|---|---|---|---|
|
Total deficiencies
| 114 | 36 | This facility has 217% more total deficiencies than a typical Indiana nursing home (114 vs. IN avg 36).↑ 217% worse Rank #359 / 386 Total deficiencies — State benchmarked This home is ranked 359th out of 386 homes in Indiana. Shows this facility's deficiencies compared to the Indiana average among 386 comparable communities in the ranking pool. Rankings are based only on facilities in Indiana that report data for that category. Facilities without available data are excluded from the ranking. |
|
Deficiencies per year
| 28.5 | 9 | This facility has 217% more deficiencies per year than a typical Indiana nursing home (28.5 vs. IN avg 9).↑ 217% worse |
|
Deficiencies per inspection
| 4.4 | 1.9 | This facility has 132% more deficiencies per inspection than a typical Indiana nursing home (4.4 vs. IN avg 1.9).↑ 132% worse Rank #289 / 386 Deficiencies per inspection — State benchmarked This home is ranked 289th out of 386 homes in Indiana. Shows this facility's deficiencies per inspection compared to the Indiana average among 386 comparable communities in the ranking pool. Rankings are based only on facilities in Indiana that report data for that category. Facilities without available data are excluded from the ranking. |
Inspections
| This Facility | IN Average | vs. IN Avg |
|---|---|---|---|
|
Total visits
| 26 | 19 | This facility has 37% more total visits than a typical Indiana nursing home (26 vs. IN avg 19).↑ 37% worse |
|
Inspections with deficiencies
| 11 | 7 | This facility has 57% more inspections with deficiencies than a typical Indiana nursing home (11 vs. IN avg 7).↑ 57% worse |
|
Inspection deficiency rate
| 42% | 37% | This facility has 5 percentage points higher inspection deficiency rate than a typical Indiana nursing home (42% vs. IN avg 37%).↑ 5% worse |
|
Inspections
| 12 | 13 | This facility has 8% fewer inspections than a typical Indiana nursing home (12 vs. IN avg 13).↓ 8% better |
Complaints & Investigations
| This Facility | IN Average | vs. IN Avg |
|---|---|---|---|
|
Total complaints
| 2 | 5 | This facility has 60% fewer total complaints than a typical Indiana nursing home (2 vs. IN avg 5).↓ 60% better Rank #50 / 352 Total complaints — State benchmarked This home is ranked 50th out of 352 homes in Indiana. Shows this facility's total complaints compared to the Indiana average among 352 comparable communities in the ranking pool. Rankings are based only on facilities in Indiana that report data for that category. Facilities without available data are excluded from the ranking. |
|
Complaints per year
| 0.5 | 1.3 | This facility has 62% fewer complaints per year than a typical Indiana nursing home (0.5 vs. IN avg 1.3).↓ 62% better |
|
Complaint visits
| 11 | 8 | This facility has 38% more complaint visits than a typical Indiana nursing home (11 vs. IN avg 8).↑ 38% worse |
Indiana average 6
Last Health inspection on Oct 2024
Indiana average 25
Indiana average 4.12
Health citations are formal notices following inspections when they fail to comply with safety and care standards.
All 42 citations resulted from standard inspections.
Indiana average: 0.2
Indiana average: 0.6
Reporting period: October 1 – December 31, 2025 (Q4 2025). Source: CMS Payroll-Based Journal report.
Manages medical care and health needs.
Assists with medical care and medications.
Helps with daily care and mobility.
Total hours from contractors
1,970 contractor hours this quarter
| Certified Nursing Assistant | 10 | 23 | 33 | 3,391 | 72 | 79% | 9.5 |
| Medication Aide/Technician | 4 | 10 | 14 | 2,138 | 74 | 81% | 10.5 |
| Licensed Practical Nurse | 3 | 26 | 29 | 1,796 | 87 | 96% | 9.4 |
| Registered Nurse | 2 | 2 | 4 | 261 | 26 | 29% | 7.9 |
| Administrator | 1 | 0 | 1 | 200 | 25 | 27% | 8 |
| Physical Therapy Aide | 0 | 1 | 1 | 101 | 42 | 46% | 2.4 |
| Speech Language Pathologist | 0 | 1 | 1 | 75 | 40 | 44% | 1.9 |
| Respiratory Therapy Technician | 0 | 2 | 2 | 73 | 20 | 22% | 3.6 |
| Physical Therapy Assistant | 0 | 2 | 2 | 72 | 18 | 20% | 4 |
| Qualified Social Worker | 0 | 1 | 1 | 46 | 39 | 43% | 1.2 |
| Occupational Therapy Aide | 0 | 2 | 2 | 33 | 8 | 9% | 4.2 |
| Feeding Assistant | 0 | 2 | 2 | 14 | 11 | 12% | 1.3 |
| Medical Director | 0 | 1 | 1 | 6 | 3 | 3% | 2 |
Includes penalties issued in 2023
Federal penalties imposed by CMS for regulatory violations, including civil money penalties (fines) and denials of payment for new Medicare/Medicaid admissions.
Source: CMS Penalties Database (Data as of Jan 2026)
Penalties are imposed by CMS for violations of federal nursing home regulations.
2 penalties in the past 3 years
Multiple penalties were reported in the last 3 years.
Last updated: Jan 2026
These measures show how residents usually do over time at this home, based on health outcomes and preventive care.
25% of new residents, usually for short-term rehab.
75% of new residents, often for short stays.
Source: CMS Long-Term Care Facility Characteristics (Data as of Jan 2026)
Residents meet regularly to discuss policies, care quality, and activities
Organized group of residents that meets regularly to discuss facility policies, quality of life, and activities.
Historical financial and operational data for McGivney Health Care Center from 2018–2023, based on CMS SNF Cost Reports.
Based on CMS SNF Cost Report for fiscal year ending in 12/2023.
Residents typically stay for brief periods, with frequent admissions and discharges throughout the year.
Most new residents arrive under private pay (75% of admissions), and a typical private pay stay runs around 15 years.
Coverage residents most often arrive under.
Coverage residents most often leave under.
158.0 miles from city center
Estimated distance in miles from Carmel's city center to McGivney Health Care Center's address, calculated via Google Maps.
Add your location
The information below is reported by the Indiana Department of Health, Division of Long Term Care.
| The Barrington of Carmel | NH AL IL MC | Carmel | 154
Facility
154
IN AVG
116
Rank
#82 / 437 |
71.4%
Facility
71.4%
IN AVG
69.4%
Rank
#174 / 434 | +3% | 9.22
Facility
9.22
IN AVG
3.44
Rank
#1 / 291 | -61% | +168% | $0
Facility
$0
IN AVG
$31.4k
Rank
#1 / 293 | 94
Facility
94
IN AVG
83
Rank
#47 / 384 | 5
Facility
5
IN AVG
25.0
Rank
#11 / 292 | 2.5
Facility
2.5
IN AVG
4.1
Rank
#52 / 292 | - | 110 | A+ |
39
Facility
39
IN AVG
37
Rank
#275 / 587 | Bhi Retirement Communities Inc | $17.0M
Facility
$17.0M
IN AVG
$10.7M
Rank
#43 / 294 | $6.9M
Facility
$6.9M
IN AVG
$4.2M
Rank
#67 / 294 | 40.6%
Facility
40.6%
IN AVG
42%
Rank
#217 / 294 | 155817 | ||||
| The Restoracy of Carmel | NH MC | Carmel (Carmel Arts & Design District) | 72
Facility
72
IN AVG
116
Rank
#344 / 437 |
94.4%
Facility
94.4%
IN AVG
69.4%
Rank
#12 / 434 | +36% | 4.61
Facility
4.61
IN AVG
3.44
Rank
#27 / 291 | -46% | +34% | $0
Facility
$0
IN AVG
$31.4k
Rank
#1 / 293 | 70
Facility
70
IN AVG
83
Rank
#326 / 384 | 44
Facility
44
IN AVG
25.0
Rank
#251 / 292 | 6.3
Facility
6.3
IN AVG
4.1
Rank
#244 / 292 | 2 | 69 | A+ |
77
Facility
77
IN AVG
37
Rank
#30 / 587 | Euson Lindsay Legacy, LLC | $10.1M
Facility
$10.1M
IN AVG
$10.7M
Rank
#164 / 294 | $4.4M
Facility
$4.4M
IN AVG
$4.2M
Rank
#147 / 294 | 43.7%
Facility
43.7%
IN AVG
42%
Rank
#133 / 294 | 155846 | ||||
| Bridgewater Healthcare Center | NH HC NC PC RC | Carmel (Carey Road) | 120
Facility
120
IN AVG
116
Rank
#167 / 437 |
85.0%
Facility
85.0%
IN AVG
69.4%
Rank
#63 / 434 | +22% | 3.52
Facility
3.52
IN AVG
3.44
Rank
#107 / 291 | +8% | +2% | $0
Facility
$0
IN AVG
$31.4k
Rank
#1 / 293 | 77
Facility
77
IN AVG
83
Rank
#228 / 384 | 23
Facility
23
IN AVG
25.0
Rank
#149 / 292 | 5.8
Facility
5.8
IN AVG
4.1
Rank
#224 / 292 | - | 111 | F |
49
Facility
49
IN AVG
37
Rank
#214 / 587 | Carey Mgt Co LLC | $14.9M
Facility
$14.9M
IN AVG
$10.7M
Rank
#68 / 294 | $6.5M
Facility
$6.5M
IN AVG
$4.2M
Rank
#66 / 294 | 43.7%
Facility
43.7%
IN AVG
42%
Rank
#182 / 294 | 155790 | ||||
| McGivney Health Care Center | NH HC RC | Carmel (East Smoky Row Road) | 37
Facility
37
IN AVG
116
Rank
#425 / 437 |
86.5%
Facility
86.5%
IN AVG
69.4%
Rank
#50 / 434 | +25% | 3.62
Facility
3.62
IN AVG
3.44
Rank
#88 / 291 | -56% | +5% | $8.2k
Facility
$8.2k
IN AVG
$31.4k
Rank
#248 / 293 | 76
Facility
76
IN AVG
83
Rank
#241 / 384 | 42
Facility
42
IN AVG
25.0
Rank
#241 / 292 | 14.0
Facility
14.0
IN AVG
4.1
Rank
#292 / 292 | 1 | 35 | - |
6
Facility
6
IN AVG
37
Rank
#509 / 587 | Gibault Care, Inc | $3.6M
Facility
$3.6M
IN AVG
$10.7M
Rank
#287 / 294 | $2.0M
Facility
$2.0M
IN AVG
$4.2M
Rank
#281 / 294 | 54.8%
Facility
54.8%
IN AVG
42%
Rank
#19 / 294 | 155855 | ||||
| Carmel Health & Living Community | NH HC MC RC | Carmel (Newark Village) | 188
Facility
188
IN AVG
116
Rank
#40 / 437 |
75.5%
Facility
75.5%
IN AVG
69.4%
Rank
#138 / 434 | +9% | 3.73
Facility
3.73
IN AVG
3.44
Rank
#72 / 291 | +22% | +8% | $0
Facility
$0
IN AVG
$31.4k
Rank
#1 / 293 | 69
Facility
69
IN AVG
83
Rank
#341 / 384 | 33
Facility
33
IN AVG
25.0
Rank
#205 / 292 | 4.1
Facility
4.1
IN AVG
4.1
Rank
#167 / 292 | 1 | 138 | A+ |
78
Facility
78
IN AVG
37
Rank
#25 / 587 | Cardon Management Company LLC | $18.5M
Facility
$18.5M
IN AVG
$10.7M
Rank
#11 / 294 | $7.5M
Facility
$7.5M
IN AVG
$4.2M
Rank
#17 / 294 | 40.6%
Facility
40.6%
IN AVG
42%
Rank
#215 / 294 | 155181 |
McGivney Health Care Center is located in Carmel, Indiana.
Here are the financial assistance programs available to residents in Indiana.
McGivney Health Care Center is in the East Smoky Row Road neighborhood of Carmel.
Jody Voelker is the Director of Nursing at McGivney Health Care Center.
The legal owner and operator of McGivney Health Care Center is Board Of Trustees Of The Flavius J Witham Memorial.
McGivney Health Care Center has a walk score of 6. Car-dependent. Most errands require a car, with limited nearby walkable options.
According to IN state health department records, McGivney Health Care Center's license number is 25-000545-1.
According to IN state health department records, McGivney Health Care Center's license expires on March 31, 2026.
McGivney Health Care Center's occupancy is 86%.
Care Cost Calculator: See Prices in Your Area
Nursing Home Data Explorer
Don’t Wait Too Long: 7 Red Flag Signs Your Parent Needs Assisted Living Now
The True Cost of Assisted Living in 2025 – And How Families Are Paying For It
Understanding Senior Living Costs: Pricing Models, Discounts & Financial Assistance