Page 30 of Best Assisted Living in Indiana

Overview of Athen’s Crossing

Enjoy the best of your golden years at Athens Crossing, an idyllic retreat in Columbus, IN, offering independent living. The community has beautifully designed and spacious accommodations, ensuring residents are comfortable and safe. Maintenance services are also provided, so residents have more time to do the things they love.

Here, residents are encouraged to live actively and maintain social connections with various activities and fun programs. The community is also surrounded by delightful restaurants and shops, providing residents with dining options that cater to their dietary needs and preferences. With its beautiful surroundings and top-tier amenities, residents are guaranteed the finest retirement experience.

Under Aperion Care Lincoln’s ownership, University Nursing and Rehabilitation is a skilled nursing community on Lincoln Avenue in Evansville, Indiana. It operates with 47 beds and has a stable 80 percent occupancy rate, so availability with a consistent resident census is balanced. Medicare, Medicaid, and private pay are accepted to give families several routes to arrange short-term rehabilitation and longer-term skilled nursing care.

Daily nursing support forms the care foundation. Total nursing care averages 3 hours 40 minutes per resident day, divided among registered nurses, nurse aides, and licensed practical nurses working across shifts. This staffing level mirrors a diligent approach to resident support in the community’s daily activities and clinical needs. The location stands in an average walkable area with a Walk Score of 58. This means some errands and appointments can be done on foot, while most outings will involve brief drives. Nearby family members can anticipate a reasonable neighborhood setting that’s accessible but not highly urban.

Overview of Serenity Spring Senior Living at Northwood

Serenity Spring Senior Living at Northwood is a 155-bed skilled nursing and residential care community providing skilled nursing, memory care, rehabilitation, and respite care in Jasper, Dubois County, Indiana. Non-profit and legally operated by Greene County General Hospital, the community welcomes Medicare, Medicaid, and private pay.

The inspection record across all four CMS sub-ratings runs below Indiana’s average, producing a 1-star overall rating. Over three years on file, the facility averaged 26 deficiencies annually, 519 percent above the 4.2 state average, with no immediate jeopardy findings, fines, or enforcement actions. The May 2024 recertification was the most significant survey in the window, citing 23 deficiencies including use of physical restraints without physician orders or consent, an unreported abuse allegation involving a CNA forcibly removing a resident’s fingers from a mechanical lift, widespread medication management failures, inadequate dementia-specific training, and an unsafe physical environment. The concurrent June 2024 life safety survey found 16 fire and emergency preparedness deficiencies including obstructed egress routes, sprinkler issues, and oxygen storage hazards near combustibles, all corrected on revisit. The February 2023 annual survey documented a resident who fell nine times during the review period, inadequate fall supervision, respiratory care failures, and the absence of a required dementia unit director. A December 2023 complaint investigation substantiated delayed reporting of an abuse allegation to the state agency. The 1-star staffing sub-rating, reflecting case-mix adjusted hours 60.8 percent below Indiana’s average, and Quality Measures similarly 50.6 percent below state benchmark, compound the inspection picture. Occupancy at 55 percent runs well below Indiana’s 68.1 percent average, with the trend declining.

With current availability reflecting below-average occupancy, the facility is geared toward residents in Dubois County who require long-term skilled nursing or memory care.

Overview of Charlestown Place at New Albany

Under Jesse Ray’s administration, Charlestown Place at New Albany is a nursing home operated by Daviess County Hospital on Charlestown Road in New Albany, Indiana. Owned by Chad Mccurdy, it welcomes Medicaid, Medicare, and private pay, giving families several ways to finance short-term rehabilitation and longer-term nursing care.

The 172-bed community opened recently, with occupancy currently at 77 percent. It’s well-positioned in a highly walkable neighborhood, with a Walk Score of 81, so visitors and residents will find most errands and essentials walkable. The average stay length is around 140 days, reflecting a blend of post-acute rehabilitation stays and ongoing nursing care residents. Clinically, the facility spotlights rehabilitation, offering specialized rehabilitation services and respite care alongside its 24-hour nursing staffing. Total nursing care averages 3 hours 56 minutes per resident day, anchored by registered nurses providing 38 minutes of direct care daily, nurse aides supplying 2 hours 19 minutes, and LPNs or LVNs contributing 38 minutes per day. This staffing structure creates a framework for consistent, diligent support and attention all day.

State inspections have surfaced themes around documentation practices and care coordination. Showing responsiveness to identified areas, Charlestown Place at New Albany has worked through compliance investigations and revisit requirements.

When touring, families can ask how the facility manages documentation processes and ensures timely communication with residents’ physicians surrounding condition changes.

Oak Grove Christian Retirement Village is a 123-bed CMS-certified multi-level campus at 221 W Division Street in Demotte, Indiana. Operated as a faith-affiliated, family-owned organization, the facility serves Jasper County with a continuum of care that includes skilled nursing, assisted living, and specialized memory support.

The community operates under federal Medicare and Medicaid frameworks, with a significant focus on short-term rehabilitative stays averaging one to two months. While historical records reflect a 1-star overall CMS rating due to past health inspection cycles, current 2026 data shows that the facility maintains a citations-per-inspection rate of zero based on its most recent standard compliance reviews. Occupancy is approximately 63%, with the census showing a steady recovery trend over the past 18 months.

A primary strength of the community is its staffing level, which performs 56.9% above the Indiana state average. Total nursing care reaches 4 hours and 19 minutes per resident per day, supported by LPN and CNA hours that significantly exceed state norms. Clinical outcomes for long-stay residents are favorable, with hospitalization and emergency department visit rates performing 22% and 41% better than state averages, respectively. The clinical team coordinates physical therapy (at 25% above state norms), orthopedic rehabilitation, and wound care, while specialized memory care programming provides structured support for residents with cognitive impairments.

The campus offers diverse living options, including private and semi-private skilled nursing suites and assisted living apartments with emergency call systems. Monthly fees cover dietitian-approved meals, daily housekeeping, and personal laundry services.

Community life is supported by an on-site beauty shop, a library, and communal social lounges. Residents can participate in a social calendar featuring spiritual services, wellness programs, and community outings, while the landscaped grounds offer secure outdoor areas for relaxation. For off-site medical appointments and errands, the facility provides scheduled transportation to ensure residents remain connected to the Demotte area.

Prospective residents seeking a faith-rooted environment with robust nursing ratios and strong long-term health outcomes may find this community appropriate. Interested individuals should contact the administrator directly to discuss current agency staff supervision protocols and schedule a tour to assess the 2026 quality performance firsthand.

Overview of The Waters of Wakarusa Skilled Nursing Facility

Administered by David Henke, The Waters of Wakarusa Skilled Nursing Facility is a 133-bed skilled nursing community operated by Johnson Memorial Hospital in Wakarusa, Indiana. It accepts Medicare, Medicaid, and private pay, providing flexible coverage options for families. Operating for three years, the facility is relatively new and currently serves 78 residents at about 59 percent occupancy. The average stay length is around 146 days, reflecting a blend of short-term rehabilitation and longer-term skilled care.

Clinically, the community offers 24-hour skilled nursing with therapy services covering physical, occupational, and speech rehabilitation. Total nursing care averages about 3 hours 9 minutes per resident day. Beyond basic skilled nursing, the facility provides respite care, psychiatric and psychological services on site, and specialized programming for dementia care spanning early to late stages. The Living Well and In Motion programs support residents in maintaining independence and engagement here. Daily life centers on nutrition and therapeutic support. A registered dietitian designs menus to balance nutrition with resident choice, and mealtime assistance is provided according to personal need. On-site specialists, podiatry, dental, and audiology services reduce the need for off-site appointments. A beauty and barber shop and a secure outdoor patio round out the amenities that support daily living. The neighborhood around Wakarusa is somewhat walkable, with some nearby services reachable on foot and most trips needing a car. Visiting family will find the area tranquil and residential.

Families contemplating The Waters of Wakarusa Skilled Nursing Facility must plan a tour to see the rooms, meet the care team, and get a feel for daily activities and routines.

Make the most of your best years at Magnolia Health Systems 57, a blissful retreat in Martinsville, IN, offering assisted living. Residents can ease their worries with a compassionate and well-trained team helping with their daily living activities and personal needs 24/7. The community also offers specially designed and secure accommodations, ensuring residents are comfortable and safe.

Residents are encouraged to live actively and make new friends with a jam-packed calendar of engaging activities and stimulating programs. Delicious and well-balanced meals are also served to meet residents’ dietary needs and preferences. Medication management is available to ensure residents take their medicine on time. With its warm and welcoming environment, residents are guaranteed the finest retirement experience.

Overview of Hooverwood

Operated by Hancock Regional Hospital and administered by Robert Newcomer, Hooverwood is a nursing home in Indianapolis, Indiana. The 183-bed facility is on Hoover Road in a car-dependent part of the city. Medicare, Medicaid, and private pay are accepted, giving families several options for covering rehabilitation services and ongoing skilled nursing care. The community has an occupancy rate of 70%, and residents stay an average of 191 days, including post-acute rehabilitation patients and those receiving longer-term nursing care.

Rehabilitation services are supported by a strong nursing presence throughout the facility. Daily nurse staffing averages 5 hours and 8 minutes per resident. Registered nurses provide 36 minutes of care per resident each day, nurse aides contribute another 36 minutes, and LPN/LVN staff add 56 minutes of support. This substantial level of hands-on care reflects the community’s emphasis on nursing-level services.

Residents have access to several specialized programs beyond traditional skilled nursing care. These include the Shalom Sanctuary program for elder abuse support, outpatient therapy and wellness services, private duty services, hospice care, and an assisted living component located within Kraft Commons.

Daily life is enriched through spiritual programming, health and wellness activities, and an on-site beauty salon and barbershop. The dining program features home-cooked kosher-style meals served at breakfast, lunch, and dinner, along with healthy snacks throughout the day.

State inspections have identified concerns involving emergency preparedness, life safety systems, and resident safety practices. These findings highlight areas that have required additional attention from the facility. Families considering Hooverwood should ask about emergency system maintenance, resident safety procedures, and the measures used to support safe daily care.

Overview of Aperion Care Hanover

Aperion Care Hanover is a 137-bed skilled nursing facility in Hanover, Indiana, offering long-term care, memory care, and short-stay rehabilitation, with a clinical program roster that includes Huntington’s Disease care, psychiatric rehabilitation, post-stroke and cardiac rehab, and hospice and palliative services. The facility is operated by Daviess County Hospital and serves Jefferson County residents. It accepts both Medicare and Medicaid.

The inspection record is a significant consideration for families. Over the past four years, the facility has averaged 33.3 deficiencies per year — roughly seven times the Indiana average of 4.2. Substantiated complaints across the review period involved resident-to-resident sexual abuse, failure to investigate an abuse allegation, dehydration that led to a resident’s hospitalization and death, pest control failures, and recurring medication management issues. No findings of immediate jeopardy or fines appear in the available reports. The most recent standard survey, completed in March 2025, cited 11 deficiencies across medication administration, infection control, environment, and pharmacy services; a subsequent re-inspection found the facility in compliance.

CMS rates the facility at 1 star overall. Nurse staffing averages 3 hours and 5 minutes per resident per day, 13% below Indiana’s average of 3 hours and 32 minutes — a relevant metric given the facility’s high-acuity program mix. The facility’s occupancy rate is 58%, well below the Indiana average of 68%, suggesting current availability across care levels.

The facility’s specialized programming — Huntington’s Disease care, psychiatric rehabilitation, and a dedicated memory care unit — positions it for residents with complex behavioral or neurological needs who require skilled nursing infrastructure in Jefferson County. However, families should carefully review the facility’s inspection history, staffing levels, and resident safety findings before making a placement decision.

Overview of Dyer Nursing and Rehabilitation Center

Dyer Nursing and Rehabilitation Center is a 211-bed skilled nursing facility in Dyer, Indiana, offering 24-hour skilled nursing, post-acute rehabilitation, memory care, and respiratory services, with physical, occupational, and speech therapy available on site. The non-profit community is operated by DLS Financial Consulting, LLC, and it accepts Medicare and Medicaid. The facility carries a 1-star CMS overall rating, driven by an inspection record that stands significantly below Indiana norms. Across the seven-year review window, the facility recorded 79 total citations — roughly 29.8 per year, compared with an Indiana average of 4.2 — placing it 284th out of 288 Indiana skilled nursing facilities in health citations. The most serious finding came in April 2024, when a complaint investigation identified Immediate Jeopardy conditions related to falls and inadequate supervision. Nurse staffing averages 3 hours and 26 minutes per resident per day, essentially in line with the Indiana average. The facility’s occupancy rate is 57%, below the Indiana average of 68.1%, reflecting current availability across the 211-bed building. It also provides behavioral management and psychological services alongside its clinical care programs. Respite stays are available. Dyer Nursing and Rehabilitation Center is best suited for residents in Lake County, Indiana, who require short- to medium-term post-acute care, skilled nursing, or rehabilitation services, with current capacity for Medicare and Medicaid admissions. However, families should review the facility’s extensive inspection history and Immediate Jeopardy findings before making a placement decision.