Best Retirement Homes in Milwaukee, WI

Milwaukee Catholic Home is a skilled nursing facility located at 2462 N Prospect Ave, Milwaukee, WI, offering nursing home, independent living, assisted living, and memory care services. The facility is administrated by Kate Gerou. Milwaukee Catholic Home is certified by the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services as a voluntary non-profit community operated by a church.

The facility has continuously served residents since June 21, 1913.

The facility occupies an urban location with a Walk Score of 83, very walkable and ranked fourteenth out of 157 Wisconsin skilled nursing facilities. The facility is situated 2.3 miles from Milwaukee’s city center and 0.09 miles from Ascension Columbia St. Mary’s Hospital.

The facility houses 107 beds in one-bedroom and two-bedroom options with an occupancy rate of eighty-six percent, higher than the Wisconsin average of seventy percent. Monthly rates range from one thousand one hundred forty dollars to five thousand five hundred seventy dollars. The Better Business Bureau rating is A+ (Not Accredited).

The facility provides skilled nursing care with significant staffing strengths. Total nursing care per resident averages six hours and twenty-eight minutes daily, ranked third out of 161 Wisconsin skilled nursing facilities and fifty-three percent above the state average. Registered nurses provide one hour and seven minutes per resident daily, above state average. Licensed practical nurses provide forty-six minutes daily, above state average.

Certified nurse aides provide four hours and three minutes daily, representing substantial direct care support. The facility employs two hundred fifty-two staff members with a staff-to-resident ratio of two point five-five to one, better than the state average.

The facility serves primarily short-term rehabilitation residents, with eighty-eight percent Medicare admissions averaging twenty days and five percent Medicaid admissions. Services include transportation, fitness and recreation, and on-site specialists including dentists, podiatrists, and psychiatrists.

The facility’s Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services quality ratings are 36.1% above the Wisconsin average overall.

The facility has received three total health inspections compared to the Wisconsin average of six. The facility has fifteen total health citations compared to the Wisconsin average of twenty-seven point three citations. All citations are moderate level severity. The facility has zero critical citations and zero serious citations compared to Wisconsin averages of zero point nine and one point two respectively.

Recent citations from June 2025 and February 2024 addressed infection control, nutrition, and resident rights, all corrected. No penalties have been imposed in the past three years.

Families should verify specific corrective actions taken for all cited deficiencies and confirm protocols for ongoing quality monitoring and resident safety oversight.

Overview of Wilson Commons

Garnering local acclaim for excellent service, Wilson Commons offers a gold standard independent living facility experience for retirees that want to devote their time to pursuing personal leisure, growth, and newfound friendships. Situated on a scenic seven acres of land near Milwaukee’s Wilson park, spacious and cozy private quarters provide a serene view and natural lighting for that home-like feel as you settle in without ever having to worry about housekeeping, cleaning, or cooking, ever again thanks to a dedicated staff.

Your new independent living home boasts top notch security and safety, while fostering exciting days through amenities such as an on-site fitness room, extensive library and lush walking trails. Socialize and immerse yourself in the community with events prepared by their Lifestyle Enrichment staff that are geared towards resident interests, hangout in elegant common areas, and if you’re in need of a change of scenery, the campus is in close proximity to shopping and dining establishments.

Overview of Ascension Living Alexian Village – Milwaukee

Ascension Living Alexian Village – Milwaukee is a 108-bed skilled nursing facility at 9301 North 76th Street in Milwaukee, Wisconsin 53223 (Northridge). Legally operated by Alexian Village Of Milwaukee Inc and administered by Elsie Smith; CEO Mr. Gary Mohn.

Offers nursing home care, independent living, assisted living, and memory care on a 60-acre campus. Rooms from 650-2,513 sq ft (one-, two-, three-bed). Services include restaurant-style dining, on-site walking trails, social activities, housekeeping, and occupational, physical, and speech therapy with 24/7 nursing staff.

Non-profit, BBB A+. Walk Score 24; 15.8 miles from city center.

Accepts Medicare and private pay (primarily short-stay rehab and private pay).

Since 2022, Ascension Living Alexian Village – Milwaukee has received 9 inspections from the Wisconsin Department of Health Services documenting 46 deficiencies (11.5 per year; 283% above Wisconsin average of 3 per year). The most recent inspection on December 4, 2025 identified deficiencies in grievance resolution, mental health screening, fall investigations, and nutritional care. Repeated patterns include delayed abuse/neglect reporting (11 deficiencies total), inadequate incident investigations, quality-of-care failures (15 deficiencies), resident rights violations, and infection control lapses. Federal penalties: $91,000 in fines plus 2 Medicare/Medicaid payment denials (2024). CMS Overall Rating: 1 star (66.8% below Wisconsin average). Staffing ratios exceed state average overall (3.70:1), but direct nursing hours fall below state norms: RNs 36% below, LPNs 16% below, CNAs 34% below Wisconsin average. Occupancy: 72%.

Families should ask about corrections addressing abuse/neglect reporting delays, RN staffing ratios, infection controls, staff training, medication management, security procedures, and fall prevention.

St. Rita Square is a 22-bed retirement home at 728 East Pleasant Street in Milwaukee, Wisconsin 53202 (Lower East Side), licensed as a Class CNA facility by the Wisconsin Department of Health Services, Division of Quality Assurance. Legally operated by Glenwood Choban and administered by Chiara Housing And Services Inc; Samantha Jemison in leadership.

Offers independent living, assisted living, and memory care with month-to-month rent and no endowment fees. Mid-rise building with one- and two-bedroom units (744-1,487 sq ft) at $5,260-$12,785 monthly. Amenities include spa, salon, fitness studio, outdoor piazza, wood-fired pizza trattoria, restaurant-style dining, scheduled transportation, and clean air systems. Pet-friendly.

Serves advanced-aged, physically disabled, and dementia residents; HCBS compliant. Licensed April 14, 2025 (one year in operation).

Walk Score 94; 1.0 mile from city center.

The Wisconsin Department of Health Services inspection record reflects zero deficiencies on February 13, 2026 complaint investigation conducted by Wisconsin Department of Health Services, Division of Quality Assurance (census 10). As a new facility (one year in operation), early compliance is demonstrated, though limited inspection history.

Families should verify staffing credentials, dementia care training, HCBS service protocols, and month-to-month lease terms before enrollment.

Overview of Wilson Commons

Wilson Commons is a retirement home offering independent living and assisted living at 1500 West Sonata Drive in Milwaukee, Wisconsin 53221 (Wilson Park).

It is a mid-rise community on seven acres with 1-bed and 2-bed units. Pet-friendly. Amenities: on-site fitness room, extensive library, walking trails, elegant common areas, restaurant-style dining, housekeeping, and transportation. Lifestyle Enrichment staff coordinate resident activities and social events.

Not CMS-certified.

Walk Score 34; 6.9 miles from city center; 1.63 miles to Aurora St Luke’s Medical Center.

Wilson Commons is not licensed as a skilled nursing facility and is therefore not subject to Wisconsin Department of Health Services nursing home inspections or CMS quality rating and regulatory oversight applicable to nursing homes or assisted living facilities with skilled nursing components.

Critical facility data including administrator name, bed count, ownership, years in operation, occupancy rate, and accreditation or complaint history are not publicly disclosed.

Families should contact the facility directly to verify administrator credentials, staffing qualifications, liability history, and compliance with state and federal assisted living regulations before placement.