Plum City Care Center
Nursing Home & Skilled Nursing · Plum City, WI
ALM Inspection Grade A+ Info ALM's inspection grade is 97 / 100, an A+ — 16 points above the Wisconsin average for CMS-certified facilities (81/100) · A proprietary Assisted Living Magazine grade.A 0–100 score of a facility's regulatory inspection record, shown as a letter and compared with other facilities of the same kind in the same state. It is not a government rating.
CMS overall rating Info CMS (the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services) is the federal agency that rates nursing home quality. Its Overall Rating runs from 1 to 5 stars, combining health inspections, staffing, and quality measures, with inspections weighted most heavily.

Plum City Care Center

Nursing Home & Skilled Nursing · Plum City, WI
ALM Inspection Grade A+ Info ALM's inspection grade is 97 / 100, an A+ — 16 points above the Wisconsin average for CMS-certified facilities (81/100) · A proprietary Assisted Living Magazine grade.A 0–100 score of a facility's regulatory inspection record, shown as a letter and compared with other facilities of the same kind in the same state. It is not a government rating.
CMS overall rating Info CMS (the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services) is the federal agency that rates nursing home quality. Its Overall Rating runs from 1 to 5 stars, combining health inspections, staffing, and quality measures, with inspections weighted most heavily.
Plum City Care Center accepts Medicare, Medicaid, and private pay.
Plum City Care Center accepts Medicare, Medicaid, and private pay.

Overview of Plum City Care Center

Fifty beds put Plum City Care Center at the small end, close enough that staff and residents learn each other’s names. The building is a nursing home and skilled nursing setting in Plum City, Wisconsin.

A visiting home nurse arrives, does the work, and leaves again; that’s not how coverage works here. Here, licensed nursing care stays on site every hour. The services list carries rehabilitation care as well. A broken hip leaves weight-bearing limits that no household can reasonably enforce, and that is the person this community is best suited for.

Meals come from a chef and a dietitian directed menus so a cook and a dietary professional both have a say in what goes on the menu. A patio and a library sit among the community’s listed amenities, and those are important for anyone who likes spending time outside or reading a good book.

The home bills Medicare, Medicaid, and private payers. Medicare covers short-term skilled care after a hospital stay and then stops, rather than paying for long-term residence. Daily nursing clocks in at 4 hours and 2 minutes for every resident. Carla Hutter is the facility’s administrator.

Quality ratings

Measured by Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS)

Overall rating Info The Overall CMS Rating combines results from health inspections, staffing levels and quality measures. Health inspections carry the most weight. Staffing and quality scores can increase or decrease the final rating based on performance compared to state and national standards.
▲ 61.7% Above WI avg. ▲ 61.7% Above WI avg.WI average: 3.1Click the badge to see the full State ranking.Click here to see the full State ranking.
Health Inspection Info Based on the results of the facility's three most recent standard inspections and any complaint investigations. CMS reviews the number, scope, and severity of deficiencies, with more recent findings weighted more heavily.
▲ 39.5% Above WI avg. ▲ 39.5% Above WI avg.WI average: 2.9Click the badge to see the full State ranking.Click here to see the full State ranking.
Staffing Info Measures average nursing staff hours per resident per day, including Registered Nurses (RNs) and total nursing staff. Ratings are adjusted based on the level of care residents require and are compared to state and national benchmarks.
▲ 8.0% Above WI avg. ▲ 8.0% Above WI avg.WI average: 3.7Click the badge to see the full State ranking.Click here to see the full State ranking.
Quality Measures Info Based on clinical and physical health indicators reported to CMS, such as hospital readmissions, falls, pressure ulcers, and improvements in mobility. These measures reflect how well residents' health needs are being managed.
▲ 56.7% Above WI avg. ▲ 56.7% Above WI avg.WI average: 3.2Click the badge to see the full State ranking.Click here to see the full State ranking.

Staffing Info Data period: Q2 2026 (April 1 – June 30, 2026).
Nursing care per resident per day and state rankings: CMS Provider Information.
Headcount, shifts and contractors: CMS Payroll-Based Journal (PBJ).
Resident count: CMS Long-Term Care Facility Characteristics (data as of Sep 2026).

Total nursing care per resident / day Info This nursing home is ranked 91st out of 164 nursing homes we track in Wisconsin for nurse hours. Total adjusted nursing hours per resident per day, combining RN, LPN, and aide time. CMS adjusts this for case-mix so facilities can be fairly compared.
↓ 8% · WI 4h 22mThis facility: 4h 2m per resident per day, 8% below the Wisconsin average of 4h 22m (among Wisconsin facilities reporting a recent figure).Green: 5% or more better than the state average. Yellow: within 5%. Red: 5% or more worse. Rank #91 / 164Nurse hours — State benchmarked This nursing home is ranked 91st out of 164 nursing homes we track in Wisconsin for nurse hours. Shows adjusted nurse hours per resident per day benchmarked to the Wisconsin average, with a ranking across 164 Wisconsin facilities. More hours mean more direct care. The national average is about 3.5 hrs; below 3.0 is a red flag. Communities with the same value for a metric share the same rank. Rankings compare like with like: every nursing home we track in Wisconsin that reports data for that category. Nursing homes without available data are excluded, so the pool size varies from metric to metric.
4h 2m

5 of 6 metrics below Wisconsin average

Staff by category

Q2 2026 · Apr 1 – Jun 30 More info This data comes from the CMS Payroll-Based Journal report covering April 1 – June 30, 2026.
Certified Nursing Assistant370378,25091100%7.1
Registered Nurse130131,97691100%6.7
Licensed Practical Nurse100101,67891100%6.6
Administrator1015266167%8.6
Other Dietary Services Staff2025257886%6.4
Dental Services Staff1015206470%8.1
Dietitian1014786167%7.8
Clinical Nurse Specialist2024426167%6
Nurse Practitioner1013645156%7.1
Respiratory Therapy Technician0221905965%3.1
Physical Therapy Aide0111826369%2.9
Physical Therapy Assistant022574347%1.3
Occupational Therapy Aide011391314%3
Occupational Therapy Assistant0111533%4.8
Feeding Assistant0111433%4.5
Qualified Social Worker033121011%1.2
Nurse Aide in Training101711%7.3
Medical Director011633%2
37 Certified Nursing Assistant
Coverage 100%
13 Registered Nurse
Coverage 100%
10 Licensed Practical Nurse
Coverage 100%
1 Administrator
Coverage 67%
By The Numbers

Community insights.

Bed count Info A smaller, more intimate setting that may offer a quieter environment and closer staff-resident interactions. 50 Rank #114 / 197Bed count — State benchmarked This nursing home is ranked 114th out of 197 nursing homes we track in Wisconsin for bed count. Shows this facility's certified or reported bed count compared to other Wisconsin facilities. Larger communities may offer more amenities, programs, and on-site services for residents and families. Communities with the same value for a metric share the same rank. Rankings compare like with like: every nursing home we track in Wisconsin that reports data for that category. Nursing homes without available data are excluded, so the pool size varies from metric to metric.

Smaller home · May offer a more intimate, personalized care environment.

Walk Score Info Car-dependent. A few nearby services may be reachable on foot, but most trips require transportation. Rank #109 / 191Walk Score — State benchmarked This nursing home is ranked 109th out of 191 nursing homes we track in Wisconsin for walk score. Shows how walkable this facility's neighborhood is compared to the average walk score across Wisconsin facilities. Higher scores benefit residents, families, and staff. Communities with the same value for a metric share the same rank. Rankings compare like with like: every nursing home we track in Wisconsin that reports data for that category. Nursing homes without available data are excluded, so the pool size varies from metric to metric.
44 / 100
Occupancy rate Info Occupancy lower than 85% suggests more openings may be available. Rank #74 / 167Occupancy rate — State benchmarked This nursing home is ranked 74th out of 167 nursing homes we track in Wisconsin for occupancy. Shows this facility's occupancy rate versus the Wisconsin average, with its Statewide rank out of 167. Higher occupancy signals strong local demand and financial stability. Communities with the same value for a metric share the same rank. Rankings compare like with like: every nursing home we track in Wisconsin that reports data for that category. Nursing homes without available data are excluded, so the pool size varies from metric to metric.
77% This home usually has availability

Based on 38.5 residents and 50 beds. Source: CMS Provider Information, average daily residents (data as of Oct 2026)

Higher than the Wisconsin average: 72.1%
Avg. Length of Stay Info Average number of days residents stay at this facility, based on CMS cost report data. Shorter stays often reflect post-acute or rehab care; longer stays reflect long-term care.
202 days

About This Community

License Details

Facility TypeSkilled Care
CountyPierce
CMS Certification Number525440
Certification TypeTitle 18 SNF Title 19 NF

Certifications & Programs

Music & Memory Program — Music & MemoryCertification from the nonprofit Music & Memory: staff are trained to build personalized playlists for residents with dementia, an evidence-supported way to reduce agitation and reconnect residents with memories.

Ownership & Operating Entity

Plum City Care Center is administered by Carla Hutter.

Owner NamePlum City Care Center Inc
Profit StatusFor-profit

Safety & Compliance

Resident Council

Staff Details

CNA Training Program

Therapy & Rehabilitation

1 service
Short-Term Rehabilitation

Staffing & Medical

1 service
Wound CareCare for wounds such as pressure sores, surgical wounds, or ulcers, including assessment, dressing changes, and monitoring for infection.

Additional Services

3 services
Guest Meals
Housekeeping
Laundry & Linen

Contact Information

Fax(715) 647-2054

Additional Policies & Features

Pets not allowed

Amenities & Lifestyle

Patio
Library
Cable Tv
Wi-Fi
Activities
Exercise Classes
Live Music
Cards, Bingo and Game Nights
Movie Night
Arts and Crafts
Puzzles
Wii Bowling
Holiday Celebrations
Wine and Dine
Scheduled Pub Nights
Baking
Card Clubs
Monthly Parties
Yoga Classes
Book Clubs
Quilting
Social Outings
Music Programs
Rug-Making Class
Tai Chi

Room Accommodations

Room Types
Private Room

Contact Plum City Care Center

Inspections

CMS Health Inspection History

Since 2023 · 3 years of data · Last health inspection Apr 2026

ALM Inspection Grade

97 / 100 Calculated from CMS inspection data for this community's nursing-home beds
How it compares

16 points above the Wisconsin average for CMS-certified facilities (81/100)

Category breakdown

Citations Strong

36 severity-weighted points (9 deficiencies) · 2× lower than the typical CMS-certified WI facility (median: 76)

Enforcement Strong

No fines on record · 0 enforcement actions

Persistence Typical

25 days to fix issues · faster than the typical CMS-certified WI facility (median: 27)

Inspection grade: 97 out of 100, letter grade A+.
Total health inspections
3 ↓ 52% · WI 6.2This facility: 3, 52% below the WI average of 6.2 (among WI facilities reporting a recent figure).Green: 5% or more better than the state average. Yellow: within 5%. Red: 5% or more worse.
Total health citations
13 Rank #36 / 168Health citations — State benchmarked This nursing home is ranked 36th out of 168 nursing homes we track in Wisconsin for health citations. Shows this facility's total health deficiency citations benchmarked to the Wisconsin State average, with a ranking across all 168 WI facilities. Lower citation counts earn a better rank. Communities with the same value for a metric share the same rank. Rankings compare like with like: every nursing home we track in Wisconsin that reports data for that category. Nursing homes without available data are excluded, so the pool size varies from metric to metric.↓ 54% · WI 28.3This facility: 13, 54% below the WI average of 28.3 (among WI facilities reporting a recent figure).Green: 5% or more better than the state average. Yellow: within 5%. Red: 5% or more worse.
Citations per inspection
4.33 Rank #85 / 168Citations per inspection — State benchmarked This nursing home is ranked 85th out of 168 nursing homes we track in Wisconsin for citations per inspection. Shows average deficiency citations per CMS inspection for this facility versus the Wisconsin mean across 168 facilities with citation data. Lower is better. Communities with the same value for a metric share the same rank. Rankings compare like with like: every nursing home we track in Wisconsin that reports data for that category. Nursing homes without available data are excluded, so the pool size varies from metric to metric.↑ 2% · WI 4.24This facility: 4.33, 2% above the WI average of 4.24 (among WI facilities reporting a recent figure).Green: 5% or more better than the state average. Yellow: within 5%. Red: 5% or more worse.
Citation severity
100% corrected 13 of 13 citations corrected
Bar = mix of this home's 13 citations, not a state comparison

Lighter shade = corrected

Critical J–L
0 ↓ 100% · WI 0.9This facility: 0, 100% below the WI average of 0.9 (among WI facilities reporting a recent figure).Green: 5% or more better than the state average. Yellow: within 5%. Red: 5% or more worse.
Immediate jeopardy
Serious G–I
0 ↓ 100% · WI 1.2This facility: 0, 100% below the WI average of 1.2 (among WI facilities reporting a recent figure).Green: 5% or more better than the state average. Yellow: within 5%. Red: 5% or more worse.
Actual harm
Moderate D–F
13 ↓ 50% · WI 25.8This facility: 13, 50% below the WI average of 25.8 (among WI facilities reporting a recent figure).Green: 5% or more better than the state average. Yellow: within 5%. Red: 5% or more worse.
No harm, more than minimal risk
Minor A–C
0 ↓ 100% · WI 0.5This facility: 0, 100% below the WI average of 0.5 (among WI facilities reporting a recent figure).Green: 5% or more better than the state average. Yellow: within 5%. Red: 5% or more worse.
No harm, minimal risk

Latest inspection: Apr 22, 2026 · 5 citations, all corrected

Most cited category: Quality of Life & Care, 5 of 13 citations · 5 categories in total

Citations history
Most recent first
Apr 22, 2026 5 citations
Resident Rights moderate citation Corrected
Resident Rights moderate citation Corrected
Quality of Care moderate citation Corrected
Quality of Care moderate citation Corrected
Quality of Care moderate citation Corrected
Jan 08, 2025 6 citations
Nutrition moderate citation Corrected
Quality of Care moderate citation Corrected
Quality of Care moderate citation Corrected
Pharmacy moderate citation Corrected
Pharmacy moderate citation Corrected
Infection Control moderate citation Corrected
Dec 07, 2023 2 citations
Pharmacy moderate citation Corrected
Infection Control moderate citation Corrected
Top deficiency categories
Share of 13 citations
Quality of Life & Care 5 deficiencies (38%)
Pharmacy Services 3 deficiencies (23%)
Infection Control 2 deficiencies (15%)
Resident Rights 2 deficiencies (15%)
Nutrition & Dietary 1 deficiency (8%)
How citations are counted

Health citations are formal notices following inspections when they fail to comply with safety and care standards.

All 13 citations resulted from standard inspections.

Includes all CMS health inspection records for this property, which could include management/ownership changes.

Source

Data sourced from CMS Health Deficiencies reports. Citation severity codes range from A (least serious) to L (most serious). Immediate Jeopardy (J-L) citations indicate situations where the facility's noncompliance has placed residents at risk of death or serious harm.

Enforcement

Penalties and fines About penalties and fines Federal penalties imposed by CMS for regulatory violations, including civil money penalties (fines) and denials of payment for new Medicare/Medicaid admissions.

Source: CMS Penalties Database · Data as of Oct 2026

1 penalty in the past 3 years

Latest: Apr 22, 2026 · 18-day payment denial

1 payment denial
Apr 22, 2026 · 18-day payment denial
Total fines
$0 WI avg $107KWisconsin average: $106,807. Average among the 146 Wisconsin facilities with a penalty on record.US avg $66KUS average: $66,281, among the 6,725 US facilities with a penalty on record.Rank #1 / 168Federal fines — State benchmarked This nursing home is ranked 1st out of 168 nursing homes we track in Wisconsin for federal fines. Shows this facility's cumulative CMS federal fine dollars versus the Wisconsin average among facilities with fines, and where it ranks among 168 facilities in the pool. Lower total dollars mean a better rank. Communities with the same value for a metric share the same rank. Rankings compare like with like: every nursing home we track in Wisconsin that reports data for that category. Nursing homes without available data are excluded, so the pool size varies from metric to metric.
Number of fines
0 WI avg 2.03Wisconsin average: 2.03. Average among the 146 Wisconsin facilities with a penalty on record.US avg 1.88US average: 1.88, among the 6,725 US facilities with a penalty on record.
Payment denials What is a payment denial? Serious action where Medicare and/or Medicaid temporarily stops payments for new residents until issues are fixed.
1 18 days ↑ 42% · WI 0.71This facility: 1, 42% above the Wisconsin average of 0.71. Average among the 146 Wisconsin facilities with a penalty on record.Green: 5% or more better than the state average. Yellow: within 5%. Red: 5% or more worse.US avg 0.35US average: 0.35, among the 6,725 US facilities with a penalty on record.
Health Outcomes

Quality of care over time

How residents at this home fare on health outcomes and preventive care, compared with the Wisconsin average.

Data as of Oct 2026 · CMS Care Compare

Long-stay quality rating Info CMS star rating for the care of long-stay residents, who live at the home for 100 days or more. It is built from the long-stay quality measures below. 5 stars is the best. 5 / 5 Significantly above average ↑ 64% · WI 3.0This facility: 5.0, 64% above the WI average of 3.0 (among WI facilities reporting a recent figure).Green: 5% or more better than the state average. Yellow: within 5%. Red: 5% or more worse.
Short-stay quality rating Info CMS star rating for the care of short-stay residents, mostly people recovering after a hospital stay for under 100 days. It is built from the short-stay quality measures below. 5 stars is the best. 3 / 5 Average ↑ 4% · WI 2.9This facility: 3.0, 4% above the WI average of 2.9 (among WI facilities reporting a recent figure).Green: 5% or more better than the state average. Yellow: within 5%. Red: 5% or more worse.
High-risk clinical events Info Average of five long-stay measures: pressure ulcers, falls with major injury, unplanned weight loss, worsening ability to walk, and needing more help with daily activities. Each is the % of residents affected, so lower is better. 7.4 Score · lower is better ↓ 18% · WI 9.0This facility: 7.4, 18% below the WI average of 9.0 (among WI facilities reporting a recent figure).Green: 5% or more better than the state average. Yellow: within 5%. Red: 5% or more worse.
Functional decline Info Average of three long-stay measures: needing more help with daily activities, worsening ability to walk, and loss of bowel or bladder control. Each is the % of residents affected, so lower is better. 15.1 Score · lower is better ↓ 20% · WI 18.9This facility: 15.1, 20% below the WI average of 18.9 (among WI facilities reporting a recent figure).Green: 5% or more better than the state average. Yellow: within 5%. Red: 5% or more worse.

13 long-stay measures: 11 better, 1 worse, 1 near WI average

7 short-stay measures: 3 better, 2 worse, 2 compared with US only

Financials

Money and staffing.

Plum City Care Center’s finances from its CMS cost report for the fiscal year ending December 2024, compared with 164 Wisconsin nursing homes that filed a recent report. Includes all financial data for this property, which could include management/ownership changes.

FY Dec 2024

Is it financially stable?

Profitable on care

6.5% operating margin

−5.9 pts vs prior year

Positive margin in 7 of the last 8 reported years. Net income $0.4M after other income.

Does it invest in staff?

Spends less on payroll than most Wisconsin homes

51.6% payroll share of revenue

WI average 58.7%Rank #110 / 164Payroll % of net patient revenue — State benchmarked This nursing home is ranked 110th out of 164 nursing homes we track in Wisconsin for payroll % of net patient revenue. Shows payroll as a percentage of net patient revenue versus the Wisconsin average, among facilities reporting a recent fiscal year. Below 25% may signal understaffing or heavy agency use — read with Staffing ratings. Communities with the same value for a metric share the same rank. Rankings compare like with like: every nursing home we track in Wisconsin that reports data for that category. Nursing homes without available data are excluded, so the pool size varies from metric to metric.

Payroll rose $0.1M while revenue rose $0.1M. A low share can mean leaner staffing; check hours per resident in the staffing section.

Who this home usually serves

Residents split by who pays for their care: Medicare, Medicaid, or private pay and other sources.
Over a year: CMS SNF Cost Report, FY2024 Snapshot: CMS Long-Term Care Facility Characteristics (quarterly), Sep 2026
Resident snapshot
39 residents · Sep 2026 Residents counted on the date of the latest CMS report, which updates quarterly.
Medicare 0 · 0%
Medicaid 20 · 51%
Private pay & other 19 · 49%
Shows care patterns over time; not used to rate this facility.

Mostly short-term rehab stays

Most residents typically stay for a few weeks or months before returning home or moving on.

Typical stay

Medicare 25 days Medicaid 1 - 2 years Private pay & other 5 - 6 months

Places of interest near Plum City Care Center

Address 0.0 miles from city center Info Estimated distance in miles from Plum City's city center to Plum City Care Center's address, calculated via Google Maps.

Calculate Travel Distance to Plum City Care Center

Add your location

Address

Compare Nursing Homes around the area

Info below is compiled from CMS reports & the WI Dept. of Health Services (DHS), senior community websites & trusted data sources such as Walk Score & BBB.

Communities are listed from highest-ranked to lowest-ranked based on our methodology.

Official facility name used in federal/state reporting (may differ slightly from the marketing name).
Care Types in This Table AL (Assisted Living): Housing with help for daily activities like bathing, dressing, and medication, without 24-hour skilled nursing. NH (Nursing Home): 24/7 skilled nursing care for residents with complex, ongoing medical needs. SNF (Skilled Nursing Facility): Round-the-clock nursing care, often for recovery after surgery, injury, or illness. MC (Memory Care): Secured, specialized care for people living with Alzheimer's or dementia. RC (Respite Care): Short-term temporary care that gives family caregivers a break. IL (Independent Living): Community living with dining, activities, and transportation for active seniors who need little personal care. HOS (Hospice Care): Comfort-focused care for those with a terminal illness, prioritizing quality of life over treatment. PC (Palliative Care): Comfort-focused care for serious illness at any stage, including alongside curative treatment.
City and state of the facility. Used for mapping and state-average comparisons.
Estimated monthly cost range for the facility.
Licensed bed capacity (maximum allowed). Not the same as how many beds are currently filled.
Better Business Bureau grade for the operating company. Reflects complaint handling and business practices, not clinical care quality.
Third-party neighborhood walkability score (0–100). Convenience/context metric, not a healthcare quality measure.
Housing or bed configuration options (e.g. studio, shared), often from facility-reported amenities and licensing details.
Woodside Lutheran Home
NH
AL
MC
RC
SNF
Green Bay -
118
Facility 118
WI AVG 78
Rank #29 / 197
-
67
Facility 67
WI AVG 48
Rank #47 / 191
-
Harbor Haven Health & Rehabilitation
NH
HOS
MC
PC
SNF
Fond Du Lac -
85
Facility 85
WI AVG 78
Rank #81 / 197
-
57
Facility 57
WI AVG 48
Rank #69 / 191
Private / Semi-Private Rooms
Badger Prairie Health Care Center
NH
SNF
Verona -
120
Facility 120
WI AVG 78
Rank #23 / 197
-
31
Facility 31
WI AVG 48
Rank #139 / 191
-
Morrow Memorial Home
NH
AL
IL
MC
SNF
Sparta -
80
Facility 80
WI AVG 78
Rank #91 / 197
A+
68
Facility 68
WI AVG 48
Rank #42 / 191
-
Plum City Care Center
NH
SNF
Plum City -
50
Facility 50
WI AVG 78
Rank #114 / 197
-
44
Facility 44
WI AVG 48
Rank #109 / 191
-

Rank badges are statewide and care-type specific: each nursing home is ranked against every other WI nursing home we track that reports that metric, not just the 5 on this page. See how we rank facilities

Know before you visit

Frequently Asked Questions about Plum City Care Center

Quick answers from public records and the community's own listing.
01 Is Plum City Care Center in a walkable area?
Plum City Care Center has a walk score of 44. Car-dependent. A few nearby services may be reachable on foot, but most trips require transportation.
02 What is the occupancy rate at Plum City Care Center?
Plum City Care Center's occupancy is 77%.
03 Are pets allowed at Plum City Care Center?
No, Plum City Care Center has a no-pet policy.
04 What is the best email address for Plum City Care Center?
The team at Plum City Care Center can be reached at plumcitycontact@rphfcorp.com.
05 Does Plum City Care Center operate as a for-profit or non-profit?
Plum City Care Center is registered as a for-profit in WI.
06 Who is the administrator of Plum City Care Center?
Carla Hutter is the administrator of Plum City Care Center.
07 What is the overall rating for Plum City Care Center?
Plum City Care Center received a 5-star overall rating from the CMS (Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services). This score combines results from staffing levels, quality measures, and health inspections.