Best Nursing Homes in Suffolk County, NY

Brookhaven Health Care Facility is a leading community in East Patchogue, NY, providing short-term rehabilitation, skilled nursing care, and hospice care. Their outstanding team is available 24 hours a day, 7 days a week to assist residents with their most basic needs to complex care requirements. Residents recovering from an injury or hospitalization are provided with state-of-the-art rehab programs that utilize the latest research to guarantee excellent rehabilitation outcomes.

Dedicated to creating a home-like and vibrant living environment for its residents, the community offers an array of exciting activities to keep residents connected and active. Mealtimes are always nourishing with fresh and delicious meals served three times a day with accommodations for special diets. At Brookhaven Health Care Facility, residents are provided with all the amenities and services they need to maintain their maximum potential and live fully.

Overview of Smithtown Center for Rehabilitation & Nursing Care

Located at 391 North Country Road in Smithtown, New York, Smithtown Center for Rehabilitation & Nursing Care operates 162 licensed beds under private ownership by Smithtown Health Care Management. Current occupancy stands at 99 percent, substantially above the state average of 88.3 percent.

The facility provides respite care, rehabilitation services, and memory care. Therapeutic Recreation Services represent the documented program offering. Nursing care runs 2 hours 32 minutes per resident per day. The facility does not maintain 24-hour staffing and does not accept Medicare or Medicaid payment.

The regulatory record documents persistent compliance difficulties. Over a four-year span, 31 deficiencies were cited at an annual rate of 7.8, significantly above New York’s 5.1 average.

The most recent April 2025 complaint investigation produced ten citations affecting infection control, medication labeling and storage, PASARR screening adequacy, pharmacy service procedures, appropriate self-administration of medications, respiratory and tracheostomy care, professional care standards, pressure ulcer prevention approaches, egress illumination, and sprinkler system maintenance; all addressed by June 27, 2025. February 2024 brought ten violations: four health citations and six life safety code violations addressing antibiotic stewardship implementation, physician oversight of care, provider notification procedures, food subsistence provisions, electrical equipment testing, electrical systems adequacy, emergency lighting, and gas and vacuum piping inspection protocols; all were corrected by mid-April 2024. Two December 2022 COVID-19 surveys identified national health safety network reporting deficiencies marked as widespread in scope, neither of which had been resolved at the time of reporting.

No monetary sanctions, immediate jeopardy determinations, or license suspensions are listed.

Legal exposure includes four currently pending cases among 16 matters filed since 2013.

Families should review staffing schedules, infection control audits, medication safety procedures, and emergency response protocols given the facility’s regulatory pattern and operational limitations.

Overview of St. James Rehabilitation & Healthcare Center

St. James Rehabilitation & Healthcare Center provides high quality physical rehabilitation and senior care in St. James, NY. The facility offers a range of services including skilled nursing, rehabilitation, and memory care. It is designed to provide a luxurious and supportive environment for recovery.

Overview of Our Lady of Consolation Nursing and Rehabilitative Care Center

Our Lady of Consolation Nursing and Rehabilitative Care Center is a 345-bed skilled nursing and rehabilitation facility with 24-hour staffing at 111 Beach Drive in West Islip, New York, operated by a non-profit in Suffolk County. The facility provides skilled nursing, short- and long-term rehabilitation, memory care, and respite services. It accepts Medicare, Medicaid, and private pay.

CMS rates the facility 3 stars, with a staffing sub-rating 48.1 percent above New York average, the strongest of the four sub-ratings. Nurse hours run 3h 42m per resident daily, modestly above the 3h 29m state average. The health inspection sub-rating runs 29.6 percent below state average, driven in part by a July 2025 inspection that identified 16 deficiencies, a sharp increase from one deficiency in each of the two prior years, covering quality of care, nursing staff sufficiency, nutrition and hydration, and life safety systems. No fines, immediate jeopardy findings, or substantiated complaints are present. Occupancy stands at 83 percent, below New York’s 88.3 percent average.

Clinical programs include neurological care, orthopedic and amputee rehabilitation, a Pathway to Home discharge program, and therapeutic recreation, a broad post-acute offering for a community of this size.

Our Lady of Consolation Nursing and Rehabilitative Care Center is built for residents seeking large-scale non-profit skilled nursing or specialized rehabilitation in Suffolk County, with strengths in post-acute and complex care programming.

Overview of Milford Health & Rehabilitation Center

Make the most out of your best years with Milford Health & Rehabilitation Center, a distinguished community located in the serene residential area of Milford, CT, offering rehabilitation and skilled nursing. Featuring purposely designed accommodations, alongside comprehensive care options, the community provides the highest quality of care for residents to live without worries in their golden years. Here, residents receive top-notch care and assistance tailored to their special needs around the clock.

Aside from their healthcare needs, the community also strives to keep residents happy and active with fun recreational activities and engaging social events. Three delightful healthy meals are also served to meet residents’ dietary needs and preferences. Medication management, therapy services, and short-term care services are also provided to enhance residents’ living experiences. Find the care you need with the community’s wide range of care and state-of-the-art amenities that aim to promote comfort and safety.

Overview of St Johnland Nursing Center, INC

St. Johnland Nursing Center, Inc is a skilled nursing facility located in Kings Park, NY. It specializes in Alzheimer’s and dementia care, head injury rehabilitation, subacute care, and adult day health care. The center has been serving the community since 1866.

Overview of Brookside Multicare Nursing Center

Brookside Multicare Nursing Center is a skilled nursing facility in Smithtown, New York, with 353 beds. Operated by Emm Healthcare Group LLC in Suffolk County, the facility offers short-term rehabilitation, long-term care, memory care, ventilator care, adult day health services, and a pediatric extended-care program, an unusually broad clinical scope for a community-based nursing home.

CMS assigns Brookside a 3-star overall rating. Staffing is a clear strength: nurse staffing averages 3 hours and 55 minutes per resident per day, about 13% above New York’s average of 3 hours and 29 minutes, placing the facility 96th of 388 state SNFs. Health Inspection performance is slightly above state averages, while Quality measures are at the state average.

The inspection record warrants attention. Deficiencies average 7.8 per year, which is 53% above New York’s average of 5.1, driven in part by a cluster of Covid-era citations for health safety network reporting that remained uncorrected for several months in 2023.

A June 2024 complaint survey found 12 deficiencies across care planning, drug review, accident hazards, and building safety systems, all corrected by mid-2024. The facility also carries five enforcement actions, compared to a statewide average of 1.6, and received a $3,000 civil money penalty in July 2023. No Immediate Jeopardy findings or license actions appear in the record.

Amenities include therapeutic recreation, pet therapy, pastoral services, and beauty services. Brookside accepts Medicare, Medicaid, and private pay and maintains 24-hour staffing.

The facility suits residents who need a high level of clinical specialization, including ventilator-dependent patients, stroke and cardiac rehabilitation, or complex post-acute care, within a large, multi-program setting in Suffolk County.

Overview of Ross Center for Nursing and Rehabilitation

Ross Center for Nursing and Rehabilitation is a 120-bed skilled nursing facility in Brentwood, New York, operated by Ssny Holdco LLC under private ownership. The facility provides short- and long-term care, including rehabilitation services, memory care, subacute care, hemodialysis, and end-of-life comfort services, a relatively broad clinical range for a mid-size Suffolk County community.

CMS rates the facility at 2 stars overall, driven primarily by its Health Inspection score, which is 29.6% below the New York average. Across the available inspection record, the facility has averaged 6.8 deficiencies per year, about 33% above the New York mean of 5.1. Citations span care planning, dietary services, physical environment, and life safety systems.

Deficiencies have consistently been corrected within a few months of each survey, and complaint investigations in the record did not produce substantiated findings. No findings of Immediate Jeopardy or fines appear in the available reports.

Staffing is a relative strength. Total nurse staffing averages 3 hours and 7 minutes per resident per day, 11% below the New York average overall. However, the facility’s CMS staffing sub-rating is 11.1% above the state benchmark, a divergence likely attributable to case-mix adjustment. RN staffing averages 30 minutes per resident per day compared with New York’s average of 42 minutes, a gap worth noting for residents requiring clinical oversight.

The facility offers therapeutic recreation, bilingual staff, geriatric care management, an outdoor patio and garden, and on-site beauty and barber services. Religious services for all denominations and door-to-door transportation are also available.

Ross Center fits residents seeking a range of post-acute and long-term services in central Suffolk County, particularly those requiring subacute care, hemodialysis access, or rehabilitation within reach of Brentwood.

Overview of Waters Edge Rehab & Nursing Center at Port Jefferson

Located in Port Jefferson, New York, Waters Edge Rehab & Nursing Center at Port Jefferson is a 120-bed skilled nursing and short-term rehabilitation facility. It is operated by Port Jefferson Operating, LLC, owned by David Roll. The facility accepts Medicare, Medicaid, and private pay. About 53% of new admissions come through Medicare, and residents stay an average of 89 days, a profile oriented squarely toward post-acute and subacute care.

CMS rates the facility 2 stars overall. The 1-star Staffing rating reflects nurse staffing of 2 hours and 40 minutes per resident per day, about 24% below New York’s average of 3 hours and 29 minutes. Quality Measures earned a 4-star CMS rating, performing above the state average on several short-stay indicators.

The inspection record is concerning. Since 2021, the facility has accumulated 34 deficiencies across eight inspections, averaging about 6.8 per year, 33% above New York’s average of 5.1. The most recent inspection, in August 2025, resulted in 13 citations, including an Immediate Jeopardy level 4 finding tied to respiratory and tracheostomy care, along with a $243,000 federal civil monetary penalty.

A separate complaint investigation in February 2025 identified a second Immediate Jeopardy Level 4 citation for quality of care, which was corrected by April 2025. The facility has received four enforcement actions since 2018, compared to a statewide average of 1.6. Complaint volume is also elevated at 141 complaints since 2021, more than twice New York’s average of 79.

The facility offers rehabilitation services including orthopedic, amputee, and cardiopulmonary programs, along with an Urban Zen wellness track and a concierge patient experience program. Amenities include gourmet meals, a rehabilitation-focused environment, and diversified programming.

Waters Edge suits short-term Medicare and private-pay patients seeking post-acute rehabilitation in Port Jefferson. Families considering longer-term or clinically complex stays will find the inspection record and staffing figures the most relevant data points in this profile.

Overview of Medford Multicare Center for Living

Operated by Barry Cozier under private ownership, Medford Multicare Center for Living is a skilled nursing facility in Medford, New York. The 320-bed facility is on Horseblock Road in western Suffolk County, providing long-term nursing care, post-acute rehabilitation, memory care, respiratory therapy, and dialysis services, a broad clinical range uncommon at this size.

CMS rates Medford Multicare 1 star overall, largely because of a prolonged inspection record that included eight enforcement actions and $148,000 in cumulative fines between 2015 and 2024. The recent picture has shifted: the April 2024 inspection found zero deficiencies, and the facility reported no citations from inspections across the four-year window ending September 2025. That’s a meaningful reversal, though the 1-star designation reflects the full historical record.

Staffing remains the clearest ongoing concern. Nurse staffing averages 2 hours and 45 minutes per resident per day against New York’s average of 3 hours and 29 minutes, roughly 21% below average, ranking 336th out of 388 New York skilled nursing facilities. The gap may matter for residents with moderate-to-high acuity needs. By contrast, the facility’s occupancy is high, with 301 of 320 beds filled (94%), above New York’s 88% average, suggesting consistent community demand.

The facility’s program depth is notable for long-stay and complex-care residents. Named tracks include Post-Acute Rehab, a dedicated respiratory program, an in-house dialysis program, Dementia/Alzheimer’s care, and hospice and palliative care services. Mindful Wellness at Medford and The Medford Experience are facility-branded programming tracks.

Medford Multicare is a good fit for residents requiring specialized clinical services, dialysis, respiratory management, memory care, or post-stroke rehabilitation, who prioritize program availability and recent compliance improvements over staffing depth.