Best Nursing Homes in Suffolk County, NY

The Villa at Westhampton is an astounding assisted living community in Westhampton, NY, that offers personal care. Fully furnished private and semi-private apartments are provided in a home-like setting, ensuring residents’ comfort. A 24-hour emergency system, medication management, and housekeeping services are also offered, so residents have a hassle-free living. The community’s comprehensive services are dedicated to improving residents’ living experiences.

Residents can participate in various activities, encompassing educational, social, and cultural. A medical suite, outdoor seating, and a patio are among the community’s unique amenities dedicated for residents’ leisure and wellness. Surrounded by serene green spaces, residents are guaranteed a laid-back retirement. This senior living community is a good option in Westhampton, especially for those needing assistance in retirement.

Overview of Massapequa Center Rehabilitation & Nursing

Massapequa Center Rehabilitation & Nursing is a dedicated nursing home in Amityville, NY, that offers rehabilitation and skilled nursing. Featuring 40 short-term private rooms in a clean and welcoming setting, the community ensures residents are comfortable and safe. State-of-the-art therapy equipment, healthy cuisine, and in-house physicians are among the community’s top offerings dedicated for residents’ well-being.

Concierge services are also provided, so residents have a hassle-free living. With over four acres of beautifully maintained gardens and gym, residents have options on how to spend their free time. This nursing home is a good choice for those looking for comprehensive care to meet their complex healthcare needs.

Overview of Surge Rehabilitation and Nursing LLC

Surge Rehabilitation and Nursing LLC is a premier destination for rehabilitation therapy in Middle Island, NY. The facility offers physical, occupational, and speech therapy, as well as pulmonary rehabilitation services. Surge focuses on individualized care plans to meet the medical, social, and emotional needs of each patient.

Overview of Quantum Rehabilitation and Nursing LLC

Quantum Rehabilitation and Nursing LLC is a skilled nursing and rehabilitation facility in Middle Island, New York, operated by Mohammud Alam. The 120-bed facility accepts Medicare, Medicaid, and private pay, and it specializes in post-acute care, with a focus on physical, occupational, and speech therapy, as well as neurological rehabilitation.

Since 2022, the facility has recorded 4 total deficiencies across 3 inspections, averaging about 2 per year, which is about 61% below New York’s average of 5.1. All findings were isolated Level 2 citations involving resident records, care plan timing, and a building construction item; each was corrected within a reasonable timeframe. No fines, enforcement actions, or substantiated complaints appear in the record.

CMS rates the facility 5 stars overall, with a Health Inspection sub-rating 76% above the New York average. The staffing picture is the counterweight: nurse staffing averages 2 hours and 55 minutes per resident per day, about 26% below the state average.

An on-site gym supports therapy programming for residents working toward discharge.

With a 125-day average length of stay and a full complement of rehabilitation therapies, including neurological rehab, the facility is best suited for residents recovering from stroke, orthopedic procedures, or neurological events who need structured post-acute care in Suffolk County.

Overview of Oasis Rehabilitation and Nursing, LLC

Oasis Rehabilitation and Nursing, LLC is a skilled nursing facility located in Center Moriches, NY. It offers personalized rehabilitation services, including physical, occupational, and speech therapy, tailored to meet individual needs. The facility is dedicated to providing a comfortable and supportive environment for recovery.

Overview of Cold Spring Hills Center for Nursing & Rehabilitation

Cold Spring Hills Center for Nursing & Rehabilitation is a large residential community in Woodbury, NY, that offers nursing and rehabilitation. The community provides a wide range of care, including adult day care, memory care, cardiac rehabilitation, palliative care, long-term care, and hospice care. With round-the-clock care and assistance, residents enjoy the highest quality of life with their needs and preferences provided.

To keep residents from being lonely, fun recreational activities and engaging programs are also conducted, tailored to their leisure and wellness. Promoting a cozy and welcoming environment, residents can rest assured of spending their later years without worries. The community is ideal for those who need supplementary care to improve their living conditions in their golden years.

Overview of Westhampton Care Center

Westhampton Care Center is a 180-bed skilled nursing facility in Westhampton, New York, providing long-term nursing care, memory care, rehabilitation services, and respite care to residents across Suffolk County. The community is located 1.9 miles from the village center and and is privately owned and operated by Kelly Brady.

The facility holds a 5-star CMS overall rating. Its occupancy rate is 97%, well above New York’s statewide average of 88%, indicating sustained local demand. Nurse staffing averages 2 hours and 58 minutes per resident per day.

Across four inspections reported from 2022 through June 2025, the facility averaged 5.3 deficiencies per year — roughly in line with the New York average of 5.1. One January 2022 complaint investigation included a Level 3 actual harm citation, which was corrected by March of that year; subsequent inspections returned to Level 2 findings only. Complaint investigations did not result in substantiated findings, and no fines or enforcement actions appear in the record. All cited deficiencies were corrected within the required timelines.

The facility’s amenities include restaurant-style dining, private suites with individual climate controls, a salon, and outdoor gardens. Music therapy, pet therapy, and a Therapeutic Recreation program round out the activity calendar.

Westhampton Care Center serves residents seeking long-term nursing care or post-acute rehabilitation in a high-demand, low-turnover setting on the East End of Long Island.

Overview of Swan Lake Nursing & Rehabilitation

Swan Lake Nursing & Rehabilitation is a skilled nursing facility located in Patchogue, NY. It provides short-term rehabilitation therapies and long-term care in a comfortable environment. The facility is dedicated to delivering high-quality care and personalized service to its residents.

Overview of John T Mather Memorial Hospital of Port Jefferson New York INC

Located at 75 North Country Road in Port Jefferson, John T. Mather Memorial Hospital is a 249-bed facility operated as a voluntary non-profit community. It holds a perfect 5-star CMS rating and ranks highest in New York for nursing staffing intensity. The facility offers orthopedics, bariatric surgery, cardiac services, and neuroscience programs.

The facility’s distinguishing characteristic is unmatched staffing depth.

Nurses work 8 hours 53 minutes daily per resident; more than double New York’s typical 3-hour 29-minute average. All 163 staff members are direct employees with no contractor reliance. The roster includes 22 registered nurses, 37 certified nursing aides, 10 speech-language pathologists, 14 respiratory technicians, and specialized occupational and physical therapy personnel. Weekend coverage maintains 8 hours 13 minutes per resident.

Regulatory compliance is document-perfect. A September 2025 inspection yielded no deficiencies. Over four years, the facility accumulated 12 health citations, well below state average, with zero critical or serious violations. Three citations involved infection control; the remainder addressed resident rights, care quality, and administrative matters.

Zero federal penalties have been assessed in the past three years, and complaint investigations number zero.

Vaccination rates for short-stay residents exceed 98% for pneumococcal coverage and 99% for influenza. No short-stay residents newly initiated antipsychotic therapy; a 100% improvement over state patterns.

However, significant legal exposure must factor into decision-making. Since 2012, the facility has been named in 77 lawsuits. Thirty-two cases remain active as of May 2026, with court proceedings scheduled for April 27, 2026. This volume of concurrent litigation, independent of the facility’s strong inspection record, signals ongoing legal disputes that represent material risk.

John T. Mather delivers exceptional clinical staffing and regulatory compliance but carries substantial litigation exposure that requires thorough evaluation before placement.

Overview of Maria Regina Rehabilitation and Nursing

Maria Regina Rehabilitation and Nursing, at 1725 Brentwood Road in Brentwood, Suffolk County, is a 188-bed skilled nursing facility operated by Optima Care Brentwood, LLC, with a 4-star CMS rating. The community houses all residents in private rooms on a 212-acre campus and admits residents primarily for short-term rehabilitation under Medicare coverage.

Staffing levels show strength in bedside caregiving roles. Licensed practical nurses average 1 hour 19 minutes per resident daily, nearly 72% above the state standard; and nurse aides provide 2 hours 47 minutes per resident, 27% above state benchmarks. Weekend nursing hours reach 4 hours 8 minutes per resident, notably above the statewide 3-hour average. Registered nurse coverage runs at 33 minutes per resident daily, falling short of the state’s 42-minute benchmark.

Regulatory findings reveal a pattern of quality concerns. A complaint investigation in January 2025 identified 17 deficiencies related to care planning, medication management, nursing staffing sufficiency, and multiple life safety code violations in fire alarms, electrical systems, and sprinkler maintenance; all corrected by mid-March. Earlier inspections, dating to 2022, documented recurring themes in nursing staff competence, medication storage, and fire safety system upkeep. The facility recorded 19 citations over five years, compared with the state average of 13.

An enforcement action was issued in April 2024 following quality of care findings, accompanied by a $9,000 federal penalty.

An active lawsuit, initiated in 2024, has a scheduled court appearance in May 2026.

Complaint filings, 32 in total, remain well below the state average of 79.

Short-stay resident outcomes are notably strong: rehospitalization rates sit 32% better than the state norm, emergency department visits 44% better, and return-to-home rates 22% above state benchmarks. Amenities include a garden courtyard, chapel with religious services, and a resident dining room. Nursing assessment measures, vaccination rates, and rehabilitation outcomes rank favorably for post-acute placement.

Maria Regina fits residents completing acute hospitalization and transitioning to recovery through short-term rehabilitation, though recent regulatory findings merit inquiry about corrective measures.