Page 2 of Best Nursing Homes in Evansville, IN

Administered by Stacy Burton, Park Terrace Village is a nursing home under owner David Hayes on Boehne Camp Road in Evansville, Indiana. Operated by the Health And Hospital Corporation of Marion County, it accepts Medicare, Medicaid, and private pay to give families several ways to fund care costs. The home serves a mix of residents and tends to operate at a moderate occupancy rate of around 63 percent across its 96 beds.

Operating for 27 years, the community’s average stay is about 121 days, which reflects a blend of shorter-term rehabilitation and longer-term care occupants. Daily nursing support totals roughly 3 hours 11 minutes per resident, with a breakdown of 43 minutes of registered nurse time, 3 hours 11 minutes of nurse aide support, and 39 minutes from licensed practical or vocational nurses each day. The Evansville location scores 30 on walkability, indicating an average walkable setting where some nearby services may be accessible on foot, but most trips require a vehicle. To reach the home and its surrounding area, visiting family members must plan for driving.

State inspections have raised repeating themes around medication management, infection control practices, respiratory care, food sanitation, and resident support during meals and daily routines. These are themes the Park Terrace Village continues to work on to fortify its operations.

Overview of Evansville Protestant Home

Evansville Protestant Home is a retirement community that offers rehabilitation services. The community offers an inviting atmosphere with fine hospitality. The senior living home community houses a team of dedicated staff who are compassionately ready to attend to any need one may have. Residents are encouraged and motivated to live their life to the fullest in a nurturing home-like setting. Evansville ensures that residents are relaxed and rejuvenated.
Evansville services include 24-hour nursing care, stimulating activities, engaging social activities and programs; with services that include speech, occupational, and physical therapy, rehabilitation, medication management, and ADLs. 

Braun Nursing Home, established in 1957 and operated by Envive Of River City LLC, has 71 beds for nursing home residents. Located at 909 North First Avenue in Evansville’s Jacobsville neighborhood, it accepts Medicare, Medicaid, and private-pay admissions. Current occupancy stands at 38.8% (27 residents), notably below the state average of 69.4%, with average resident stays of 116 days.

A walk score of 67 places it in a moderately walkable area, 1.2 miles from downtown.

The facility carries a 1-star overall CMS rating, 66.8% below Indiana’s benchmark; the state’s lowest tier. Health inspection ratings score 2 stars, 26.7% below state average. Staffing ratings earn 1 star, 60.8% below state average, with total nursing hours of 2 hours 50 minutes per resident daily.

However, the facility has avoided federal penalties and payment denials over three years; 28 deficiencies documented across four inspections with zero critical or serious citations.

Walking ability declines in 37.6% of residents; 162% worse than peers. Falls with major injury affect 12.4%—220% above the state rate. Depressive symptoms manifest in 60.9%; 153% worse than Indiana average. Functional decline scores 28.9 (69% worse than peers), and high-risk clinical events score 16.7 (109% above state norm).

October 2024 routine inspection identified elopement safety failures: two residents left independently without proper guardianship or physician notification; one resident with court-appointed guardianship due to schizophrenia left the facility on four documented occasions without communicating with her guardian. Fall prevention interventions were documented in care plans but not physically implemented; non-slip bathroom strips required by documented fall assessments were absent. December 2024 complaint investigation corroborated medication protocol failures: lisinopril administered without obtaining required blood pressure checks; fall interventions documented in plans but not executed; shift-by-shift care plan updates lacking for incident response.

The facility reported an $825,000 operating loss with -24.5% profit margin. Contractor staff comprise 74% of the workforce.

Braun Nursing Home serves primarily long-term Medicaid residents at critically low occupancy, with severe documented clinical outcome deficiencies and recent inspection findings indicating failures in medication safety, fall prevention execution, elopement supervision, and care plan implementation.

Overview of The Good Samaritan Home

Two hundred forty beds across Evansville. That’s the first fact: the size is spread across skilled nursing, assisted living, and three separate memory care buildings. It’s a governmental operation, located at 601 N Boeke Rd, where the Walk Score hits 38. You’re driving to get groceries.

Current census is 119 residents in a 51.8% full facility. The average stay is 164 days. Medicare covers most admissions, usually for short-term post-acute rehab. Medicaid picks up the longer stays. Private pay is also accepted.

The therapy menu is basic: physical, occupational, and speech-language services. For the memory care program, the stated philosophy centers on flexibility and individual autonomy, which matters if you’re placing someone in that unit. Activities run cooking classes, bingo, live entertainment, gardening groups, movie nights, and arts programming. Laundry and housekeeping are on-site. The facility promises 24/7 emergency nursing.

Nursing hours per resident per day total 2 hours and 52 minutes. Registered nurses handle 22 minutes of that. LPNs cover 40 minutes. Nurse aides account for 2 hours and 30 minutes.

The Good Samaritan Home is structured as a mixed-acuity facility. It accepts both short-term rehabilitation admissions and longer-term placements, with dedicated memory care units running alongside. For families in the Evansville area weighing post-acute rehab against longer-term placement options, this is a setting that theoretically accommodates both timelines under one roof.

Under Aperion Care Lincoln’s ownership, University Nursing and Rehabilitation is a skilled nursing community on Lincoln Avenue in Evansville, Indiana. It operates with 47 beds and has a stable 80 percent occupancy rate, so availability with a consistent resident census is balanced. Medicare, Medicaid, and private pay are accepted to give families several routes to arrange short-term rehabilitation and longer-term skilled nursing care.

Daily nursing support forms the care foundation. Total nursing care averages 3 hours 40 minutes per resident day, divided among registered nurses, nurse aides, and licensed practical nurses working across shifts. This staffing level mirrors a diligent approach to resident support in the community’s daily activities and clinical needs. The location stands in an average walkable area with a Walk Score of 58. This means some errands and appointments can be done on foot, while most outings will involve brief drives. Nearby family members can anticipate a reasonable neighborhood setting that’s accessible but not highly urban.

Overview of River Bend Nursing and Rehabilitation

River Bend Nursing and Rehabilitation is a 113-bed skilled nursing facility on Stocker Drive in Evansville, Indiana. Run by Adams County Memorial Hospital and managed by administrator Eric Ross, the building has a 58 percent occupancy rate. It accepts Medicare, Medicaid, and private pay options. Residents stay an average of 131 days, a timeframe that includes both short-term rehabilitation patients and long-term care residents.

The daily care model provides residents with an average of 3 hours and 19 minutes of direct nursing care. This time includes 41 minutes from registered nurses, 36 minutes from licensed practical nurses, and 2 hours and 9 minutes from nurse aides. The facility provides respite care and post-hospital rehab, and the building layout features private suites, family visit rooms, common sitting areas, and outdoor spaces.

The car-dependent Evansville neighborhood means visitors and residents will need a vehicle to handle errands or travel around the local area. Families can reach out to the administrative staff to ask about insurance coverage details, verify open beds, review the on-site respite care and post-hospital rehab programs, or schedule a tour of the facility’s private suites and outdoor spaces.

Overview of The Village at Hamilton Pointe

The Village at Hamilton Pointe in Newburgh, Indiana, offers a thorough set of senior living services. It’s operating as a multi-level community that serves occupants across the full continuum of aging care. The facility at 3800 Eli Pl provides nursing home, assisted living, independent living, memory care, and skilled nursing options, making it a one-stop destination for families needing diverse care levels in one place.

The facility’s staffing model reflects nursing-focused care, with registered nurses on duty and nursing aides providing direct care at 2 hours 33 minutes per resident day. This structure spotlights diligent resident support and monitoring. Pets are welcome, a feature that allows long-term occupants to maintain vital emotional connections with their animals during their stay. The Newburgh location offers a rural, car-dependent setting with limited walkability, an environment that charms residents preferring calmer surroundings and may depend on family or community transportation. The area’s character suits those wanting a more secluded campus-style living arrangement instead of urban proximity to services.

Important note: The Village at Hamilton Pointe isn’t currently listed as a Medicare or Medicaid provider, meaning occupants must verify what payment options and assistance programs it accepts. This distinction affects financing decisions and should be clarified early in talks with the home.

Nestling in the heart of Evansville. Solarborn offers independent living, assisted living, memory care, and rehabilitation services to its residents. The dynamic senior living community boasts their dignified and compassionate service that puts their residents in the highest regard; they have provided an exceptional senior living environment with a warm and welcoming atmosphere that makes residents feel at home. Solarborn strives in going above and beyond for its residents to thrive and succeed.
Solarborn lifestyle is centered on the comfort and stability of its residents, ensuring that all of them reach their full potential. Community features that help reach each residential goals involve a spectrum of adventure and activities; housekeeping, transportation, ADLs, and dining services are also included.