Manchester Commons of Presbyterian Senior Care is an 80-bed personal care home in Erie, Pennsylvania, operated by non-profit Presbyterian Homes in the Presbytery of Lake Erie. The facility offers assisted living, skilled nursing, dementia care, and respite services and accepts Medicare, Medicaid, and private pay. A 24-bed secured dementia care unit is in the building.
CMS grades the facility 5 stars, with a health inspection score 13.6 percent above Pennsylvania’s average. The compliance record warrants closer reading: across 13 inspections since 2021, the facility averaged 12.8 deficiencies annually, 172 percent above the 4.7 state average. A July 2022 inspection substantiated a fatal medication error wherein a resident received another resident’s medication; staff were suspended and terminated, and a provisional license was issued. The latest inspection in August 2025 substantiated a verbal abuse complaint, causing staff member suspension.
Nurse hours run 4h 57m per resident per day, above Pennsylvania’s 4h 35m average. Quality measures score 21.1 percent below the state average. Three meals daily are confirmed, with casual and formal dining options. The secured dementia unit served 19 of its 24 beds in the latest inspection.
The non-profit community is built for residents seeking personal care and dementia support in Erie County, with capacity for hospice and high-acuity populations.















